HomeMy WebLinkAbout2025-07-01-minutes-200pm-public-hearing07/01/2025 MINUTES 1
COMMISSIONERS' MINUTES
KITTITAS COUNTY, WASHINGTON
AUDITORIUM
SPECIAL MEETING
TUESDAY 2:00 P.M. JULY 1, 2025
Board members present: Chairman Laura Osiadacz; Vice-Chairman Cory
Wright & Commissioner Brett Wachsmith.
Others: Mandy Buchholz, Office Administrator; Stephanie Hartung,
Chief Civil Deputy Prosecutor; Josh Fredrickson, Public Works
Director; Jamey Ayling, Planning Manager; Cameron Curtis, Engineer;
and three members of the public.
Chairman Osiadacz noted that the Hearings would be taken out of
order from what the Agenda published reflected.
PUBLIC HEARING LEASE HAY COVER STORAGE PUBLIC WORKS
At 2:00 p.m. CHAIRMAN OSIADACZ opened a Public Hearing to consider a
Lease with Paul Hutchinson for Hay Cover Storage Buildings located
on Goodwin Road.
ARDEN THOMAS, WATER RESOURCE MANAGER, reviewed a Staff Report and
stated that the County recently acquired property with hay cover
storage not utilized by the current agricultural tenant and has
received inquiries from parties interested in leasing the
facilities. These storage facilities are located at Parcel No.
505933. She noted that Public Works advertised a Notice of Call for
Sealed Bids on May 22 and May 29, 2025, in the newspaper of record,
with sealed bids due on June 6, 2025 at 9:00 a.m. and one bid was
received and deemed responsive. She stated that it was Public Works
recommendation to enter into a lease for the property with the
single bidder.
THERE BEING NO PUBLIC IN ATTENDANCE REQUESTING TO TESTIFY, THE
PUBLIC PORTION OF THE HEARING WAS CLOSED.
RESOLUTION 2025-130 LEASE - HUTCHINSON PUBLIC WORKS
VICE-CHAIRMAN WRIGHT moved to approve Resolution No. 2025-130,
Resolution Authorizing a Lease Agreement between Kittitas County and
Paul Hutchinson for Goodwin Road Hay Cover Storage. COMMISSIONER
WACHSMITH seconded. Motion carried 3-0.
PUBLIC HEARING CRITICAL AREAS ORDINANCE CDS
07/01/2025 MINUTES 2
At 2:03 p.m. CHAIRMAN OSIADACZ opened a Public Hearing to consider
amendments to the Kittitas County Code Title 17A, Critical Areas
Ordinance (CAO).
JAMEY AYLING, PLANNING MANAGER, reviewed a Staff Report and
explained that in December of 2021, Kittitas County adopted
Ordinance No. 2021-016, the Kittitas County Critical Areas Ordinance
(CAO). The Yakama Nation (Petitioner) filed a petition for review
with the Eastern Washington Growth Hearings Board (GMHB) on February
11, 2022, Case No. 22-1-0002 and on July 28th, 2022, a hearing on the
merits was held. On September 7th, 2022, the GMHB issued a final
decision and order in favor of Kittitas County on each issue and the
Petitioner filed an appeal of the GMHB’s decision to Superior Court
in Thurston County. On March 20, 2023, the Thurston County Superior
Court certified direct review to the Division II Court of Appeals,
where the Division II Court of Appeals transferred review to the
Division III Court under Case No. 396711. In July of 2024, Kittitas
County and the Petitioner entered into a settlement discussions over
the next eleven months, which included numerous meetings and
correspondence from July 2024 through May of 2025. On June 9, 2025
at a regularly scheduled Community Development Services (CDS) Study
Session Meeting, the Kittitas County Board of County Commissioners
(BoCC) approved Resolution No. 2025-118, concerning the settlement
with the Yakama Nation pertaining to the Kittitas County Code Title
17A, Critical Areas Ordinance.
On June 9, 2025, at a regularly scheduled CDS Study Session Meeting,
the Kittitas County BoCC adopted Resolution 2025-118, acknowledging
the settlement with the Yakama Nation pertaining to the Kittitas
County Code Title 17A, Critical Areas Ordinance (CAO) and directed
CDS to initiate the next steps for formal approval of the Ordinance.
On June 17, 2025, at a regularly scheduled BoCC Meeting, the
Kittitas County BoCC set a Public Hearing for July 1st at 2:00 p.m.
to consider approval of the Amendments to the Kittitas County
Critical Areas Ordinance.
VICE-CHAIRMAN WRIGHT reviewed questions he had for Legal. He
questioned how this process worked from a legal perspective and
asked Chief Deputy Hartung to explain the process. STEPHANIE
HARTUNG, CHIEF DEPUTY PROSECUTOR, explained the process of how they
got it to the correct Court and explained that originally it was in
the Court of Appeals Division #2 and it needed to be in the Court of
Appeals Division #3. She reviewed the negotiations process with
Yakama Nation and the review of the best available science. She
noted that our record on this in Court is over 6,000 pages. She
explained that before they went to Court, the Yakama Nation asked if
they could meet and the County agreed to, however, the County kept
their pre-arranged day in Court. She stated that what they found out
and realized after meeting with the Nation was that both parties
were not as far apart as they originally thought, which led them to
07/01/2025 MINUTES 3
11 months of meeting and negotiating and in the end only about a
quarter of the Ordinance was changed and had it went to Court that
most likely would have been a drastically different outcome. She
stated that she felt the County was able to keep what was important
while making it user-friendly, as well as complying with the Growth
Management Act (GMA). She stated it’s a really good product and will
be practically applicable by CDS. She noted that we did prevail at
the Growth Management Hearings Board. VICE-CHAIRMAN WRIGHT stated
he had additional questions of Planning Manager Ayling. He asked him
to clarify & define the use of degradation and how that will be
applied. He additionally asked Mr. Ayling to define Channel
Migration Zone. JAMEY AYLING, PLANNING MANAGER explained that the
maps are on Compass that show the channel migration zone and what
that will look like over time. They are able to see evidence of
channels that used to exist that they see over time no longer exist.
He shared that they have a team of experts that evaluate the
channels as well, additionally, he reviewed how they identify over
the course of a 100-year period and what those mechanisms look like
that are in place, noting that this is done at no cost to the
applicant.
CHAIRMAN OSIADACZ noted for the record that the office had received
written comment from Pat Kelleher that would be included in the
record.
THOSE PRESENT & TESTIFYING: PAT KELLEHER felt that the document is
ridiculous and does nothing to protect our environment. He stated
that it's written for the consumer and not the Nation. He stated
that the County needed to take a holistic approach on how to protect
the environment. THERE BEING NO OTHERS REQUESTING TO TESTIFY, THE
PUBLIC PORTION OF THE HEARING WAS CLOSED.
ORDINANCE 2025-006 CRITICAL AREAS ORDINANCE CDS
VICE-CHAIRMAN WRIGHT moved to approve Ordinance No. 2025-006, An
Ordinance Amending Kittitas County Code Title 17A, Critical Areas
Ordinance. COMMISSIONER WACHSMITH seconded. VICE-CHAIRMAN WRIGHT
stated that this is the 3rd time ever that we have done a change
under the Growth Management Act for Critical Areas. He expressed his
thanks to Legal and CDS for the work, as it was very in-depth, and
expressed his understanding with regard to what a difficult topic
this is to manage. He referenced California’s overhaul of their 1970
Environmental Act, which was just revised, and the outcome of that
could be felt in other areas. Motion carried 3-0.
The meeting was concluded at 2:31 p.m.
07/01/2025 MINUTES 4
KITTITAS COUNTY COMMISSIONERS
OFFICE ADMINISTRATOR KITTITAS COUNTY, WASHINGTON
Mandy Buchholz Laura Osiadacz, Chairman