Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAboutKittitas County CEMP_Completed_Review_Letter (Final)April 10, 2025 Sheriff Clay Myers Kittitas County Sheriff’s Office 307 W. Umptanum Road Ellensburg, WA 98926 Re: Kittitas County Comprehensive Emergency Management Plan Dear Sheriff Myers: Thank you for submitting the Kittitas County Comprehensive Emergency Management Plan (CEMP) for our review, as required under RCW 38.52.070. Congratulations on completing this significant accomplishment. The enclosed documents provide a compilation of recommendations for your next planning and review cycle to meet the requirements of chapter 38.52 RCW and chapter 118-30 WAC. Addressing the lawful requirements category will ensure your CEMP’s continued consistency with the State CEMP and the incorporation of industry best practices. The Washington Emergency Management Division (EMD) looks forward to receiving the next iteration of Kittitas County’s CEMP in five years. To better incorporate the use of core capabilities and make the CEMP a more operational document, CEMP development in Washington has undergone significant changes. If you would like additional information or assistance, please contact EMD’s Planning Section at emdcempreview@mil.wa.gov. Sincerely, Director Enclosures (2) EMD CEMP Evaluated Checklist – Kittitas County 2025 CEMP Review and Recommendations – Kittitas County 2025 EMD CEMP Evaluated Checklist - Kittitas County 2024.xlsx Section Title Tier III - Required Tier II - Suggestions Tier I - Optional Introductory Documentation 88%91%0% Purpose, Situation, & Assumptions 100%100%100% Concept of Operations 100%76%59% Direction, Control, & Coordination 100%65%72% Organization 100%100%100% Responsibilities 100%72%75% Communications 100%67% Administration 100%100% Finance 100%100%100% Logistics 100%100%100% Development & Maintenance 100%100%24% Population Protection 100%75% ESF 4 100%100% ESF 5 65%79% ESF 6 73%86% ESF 8 82%92% ESF 9 75%89% ESF 10 83%90% ESF 13 60%87% ESF 15 67%90% Resource Management 72%88% ESF 7 78%85% ESF 11 100%100% Critical Infrastructure 100%79% ESF 1 60%79% ESF 2 100%96% ESF 3 75%84% ESF 12 71%93% TIER TOTALS*96%73%77% Rating: 4 4 4 4 4 4 5 5 4 4 3 4 4 4 5 5 3 4 4 4 4 4 5 4 5 5 Basic Plan Annexes COMPREHENSIVE EMERGENCY MANAGEMENT PLAN (CEMP) Five Fundamental Plan Review Criteria: Rating System: 1 = Missing All of the specified characteristics 2 = Minimally addresses the specified characteristics 3 = Addresses Some of the specified characteristics 4 = Addresses Most of the specified characteristics 5 = Addresses All of the specified characteristics *Each Tier Total is the sum of all elements that have been addressed across all sections in the column and displayed in a percentage Cells that are grayed out do not contain elements that are reviewed for that tier. ADEQUACY A plan is adequate if: The scope and concept of planned operations identify and address critical tasks effectively; The plan can accomplish the assigned mission while complying with guidance; The plan's assumptions are valid, reasonable, and comply with guidance. FEASIBILITY A plan is feasible if: The organization can accomplish the assigned mission and critical tasks by using available resources whithin the time contemplated by the plan; The organization allocates available resources to tasks and tracks the resources by status; Available resources include internal assets and those available through mutual aid or through existing state, regional, or Federal assistance agreements. Specifically, the jurisdiction should complete a capability estimate that: Identifies the current status of resources arrayed to support the plan; Analyzes the required resources based on the courses of action in the plan; Identifies the most supportable courses of action and ways to reduce the impact of resource deficiencies. ACCEPTABILITY A plan is acceptable if: It meets the requirements driven by a threat or incident; It meets decision maker and public cost and time limitations; It is consistent with the law; It can be justified in terms of the cost of resources; Its scale is proportional to mission requirements. COMPLIANCE The Plan should align with guidance and doctrine to the maximum extent possible because these provide a baseline that facilitates both planning and execution. COMPLETENESS A plan is complete if it: Incorporates all tasks to be accomplished; Includes all required capabilities; Integrates the needs of the general population, children of all ages, individuals with disabilities and others with access and functional needs, immigrants, individuals with limited English proficiency, and diverse racial and ethnic populations; Provides a complete picture of the sequence and scope of the planned response operation; Makes time estimates for achieving objectives; Identifies success criteria and a desired end-state. COMPLETE OVERVIEW Washington Emergency 3/19/2025 Management Division Page 1 Comprehensive Emergency Management Plan (CEMP) Review & Recommendations Jurisdiction: Kittitas County (2024) The plan provides well written, easy to understand and necessary information for the administration of an emergency management program. The recommendations provided below are separated into three tiers: Tier III – Lawful Requirements; Tier II – State Suggestions; and Tier I – Optional State consistency reviews will follow the recommendations identified in Tier III. Tier II identifies the next logical step in the planning process and should be considered guidance to assist with state-wide planning coordination; Tier II does not include any legal requirements, but highly suggested recommendations to better prepare your jurisdiction. Tier I identifies entirely optional, accreditation-related elements and remains dependent on individual jurisdictions’ preparedness goals, capabilities and resources. TIER III – Lawful Requirements CEMP Location Recommendation to Meet Legal Obligations Reference Basic Plan – Approval Document Ensure the approval document is signed by either the Emergency Management Director or the senior elected official. This is expected and is a reminder to sign the official document when it is ready to be promulgated/approved. Chapter 118-30, WA CEMP, CPG 101 ESF 7 – Mutual Aid Discuss the procedures to provide projected or anticipated costs, as well as the reimbursement process when mutual aid agreements are activated. Also, consider including as attachments any checklists and forms for requesting and providing assistance. Title 38.56 RCW, WA CEMP, CPG 101 ESF 7 – Mutual Aid Discuss the procedures to provide projected or anticipated costs, as well as the reimbursement process when mutual aid agreements are activated. Describe or briefly highlight the process and procedures that are followed to reimburse incident related expenses. The next step is to describe how those expenses are paid for. Do departments pay Title 38.56 RCW, WA CEMP, CPG 101 Washington State Emergency 3/19/2025 Management Division Page 2 TIER III – Lawful Requirements CEMP Location Recommendation to Meet Legal Obligations Reference out of their own budgets? Who might pay for a contractor who covers work done by multiple departments? What if a department does not have the money to pay for the resources they need? ESF 7 – Unsolicited Donations Consider addressing or developing a plan which covers the management of unsolicited donations and spontaneous volunteers. Chapter 118-30 WAC, WA CEMP, CPG 101 TIER II – State Suggestions CEMP Location Recommendation to Meet Legal Obligations Reference CEMP Word Choice – The use of the term “special populations” or “vulnerable populations” is not advised. A more appropriate term that fits your needs is Access and Functional Needs, which includes the populations you are intending to address. Consult the National Preparedness Goal 3nd Edition, Appendix A: Terms and Definition, Access and Functional Needs. Consider reviewing documents to update this word choice. NIMS 2017 Basic Plan – Approval Document Consider discussing authorities and decision- making policies in either your approval document or the delegation of authority if the senior or appointed officials were absent. WA CEMP, CPG 101 Basic Plan – Concept of Operations There are many elements that can be addressed in the Concept of Operations section of the Basic Plan relating to three elements, or Core Capabilities, which impact all Mission Areas. The first is Planning, the second is Public Information & Warning, and the third is Operation Coordination. Your plan did a good job of addressing these, there were just a few missing. The National Planning Frameworks, WA CEMP Basic Plan – Direction, Control, & Coordination Part of the Comprehensive Emergency Management Plan should include a description of the activities taking place in the other mission areas (i.e. Prevention, Protection, Mitigation, Recovery). While your Annexes show some of this planning consideration, the Basic Plan is meant to The National Planning Frameworks, WA CEMP Washington State Emergency 3/19/2025 Management Division Page 3 TIER II – State Suggestions CEMP Location Recommendation to Meet Legal Obligations Reference describe the relationships between these mission areas/planning efforts/etc. The State CEMP is currently moving in this direction with its own Plan which is the reasoning behind offering this recommendation and the previous one as a suggestion for future updates to your CEMP. Basic Plan – Direction Control & Coordination – Staging Areas When discussing multi-jurisdictional coordination, there is an opportunity to discuss how your jurisdiction would coordinate to establish logistical staging areas and community points of Distribution (CPODs). National Response Framework, National Disaster Recovery Framework, WA CEMP, CPG 101 Basic Plan – COOP/COG Consider adding a section to the Basic Pian to address Continuity of Operations and Continuity of Government (COG). There are multiple elements within the Tiered Checklist to guide you on the information that is recommended to add to the Basic Plan. Also, consider reaching out to the Continuity Planner at WA EMD for more information. National Planning Frameworks, Continuity Guidance Circular, CPG 101 Basic Plan – Responsibilities There are many tasks and abilities that Departments/Agencies (at all levels of government), the private sector, community organizations, and individuals should be participating in and accomplishing based on the guidance offered by the National Planning Frameworks. The Responsibilities section is an opportunity to not only address what capabilities are, but what they should be. This section should also be considered a place to set expectations. For more information on stakeholder responsibilities, consult the CEMP Evaluation Checklist – Tier II Suggestions tab. Overall, this section was well-written, there were just a few missing. The National Planning Frameworks, WA CEMP, CPG 101 Basic Plan – Terms and Definitions / Abbreviations Consider moving those terms and definitions which only apply to a specific function to a Support Annex. The definitions section within WA CEMP, CPG 101 Washington State Emergency 3/19/2025 Management Division Page 4 TIER II – State Suggestions CEMP Location Recommendation to Meet Legal Obligations Reference a support annex serves to house unique terms or jargon. This will leave the Basic Plan’s terms and definitions section free to discuss more general concepts that are appropriate to its intended audience. Also, consider removing any terms, definitions, or anacronyms that is not used in the Plan to help reduce its length and sharpen its focus. ALL ESFs – Responsibilities Support Agencies that do not fall within the jurisdiction of the county should not be given responsibilities. Rather, you should list how you coordinate with them when they are executing their responsibilities that are detailed in their own plans. For example, State Patrol should not have responsibilities listed, rather what should be listed is how you coordinate together to help accomplish the mission. WA CEMP, CPG 101 ESF 1 – Alternative Transportation Describe the alternative methods of transportation that can be used during an incident (e.g. using ferries, local school buses, city/county buses, etc.). The National Planning Frameworks, WA CEMP, CPG 101 ESF 1 – Coordination with ESF 11 Consider describing how ESF 11 may work with ESF 1 to manage the transportation of food supplies, livestock, or emergency resources to affected areas. This collaboration ensures that critical resources reach their destinations efficiently and safely during a disaster or emergency The National Planning Frameworks, WA CEMP, CPG 101 ESF 1 – Incident Management Building off the incident management measures described for Roadways, Pipeline, and Rail; consider describing what incident management practices will be implemented for those involving Aviation and Maritime. Even if your jurisdiction has no capabilities to perform either of these a discussion should still occur concerning who manages those specific incident types and how your jurisdiction assists or coordinates (e.g. provides traffic control in affected areas, WA CEMP Washington State Emergency 3/19/2025 Management Division Page 5 TIER II – State Suggestions CEMP Location Recommendation to Meet Legal Obligations Reference provides specific transportation resources, etc.). ESF 3 – Utility Coordination Discuss the coordination involved with ESF 12 in the identification, prioritization, and repair work for utilities. The National Planning Frameworks, WA CEMP, CPG 101 ESF 5 – Senior Officials Describe the process involved in providing routine briefings to Senior Officials during an incident. WA CEMP, CPG 101 ESF 5 – Public Information Management (Unplanned Assistance) Consider discussing the consideration for the unplanned arrival of individuals and volunteer groups as well as integration of unplanned assistance from community members or neighboring jurisdictions. WA CEMP, CPG 101 ESF 5 – Staff/Equipment Requirement and EOC Layout Consider identifying the staff and equipment requirements necessary for the EOC. This can include training requirements for staff and equipment (laptops, monitors, communication devices, whiteboard, etc.) that would be needed. Provide a diagram of the primary and alternate EOCs (e.g., locations, floor plans, displays) and identify and describe the critical communications equipment available/needed (e.g., phone numbers, radio frequencies, faxes). WA CEMP, CPG 101 ESF 6 – Shelters There were a few additional elements that should be addressed when describing this ESF. The first is the establishment of reception centers at shelter locations (not to be confused with disaster recovery centers) and alternative accommodation for those who are unable to attend congregate shelters (ex. Pet friendly or Domestic Violence victims.) Also, consider discussing the process for family reunification, registered offenders with lawful restrictions, and other hazards that may be posed by the incident. National Response Framework, National Disaster Recovery Framework, WA CEMP, CPG 101 Washington State Emergency 3/19/2025 Management Division Page 6 TIER II – State Suggestions CEMP Location Recommendation to Meet Legal Obligations Reference ESF 7 - Credentialing Consider discussing how personnel who fulfill an ICS position are credentialed to be considered capable or qualified to meet the roles and responsibilities. Prevention Framework, Protection Framework, WA CEMP, CPG 101 ESF 8 – Managing Disaster-related Conditions Discuss how ESF 8 provides distribution systems for their services (i.e. Point of Dispensing (POD)). Also discuss how human waste disposal services are provided. National Disaster Recovery Framework, WA CEMP, CPG 101 ESF 9 – Concept of Operations Excellent work creating a concise and well thought out SAR ESF. Consider discussing the following topics to completely round it out: • Methods for monitoring distress levels; • Tracking locations of distressed individuals. WA CEMP, CPG 101 ESF 10 – Concept of Operations While a separate review is conducted for ESF 10/LEPC Plans by EMD’s LEPC Planning Team, there are a few elements that are addressed in FEMA guidance. Consider discussing the implementation of treatment options. Even if your jurisdiction does not participate in the process (i.e. the Department of Ecology takes care of the waste), ESF 10 should briefly describe/highlight who is participating in these activities and if any coordination is involved. National Mitigation Framework, National Response Framework, National Disaster Recovery Framework, WA CEMP, CPG 101 ESF 12 -Disruption, Extended Outage, Neighbors Consider discussing what impacts a significant disruption in energy supplies (gas, electricity, natural gas, etc.) would cause. A secondary consideration would then be to discuss a plan to manage and endure those extended energy outages. Lastly, consider discussing how disruptions to energy supplies or suppliers in neighboring geographical areas affect your jurisdiction and others. The National Planning Framework, WA CEMP, CPG 101 ESF 13 – Public Safety and Security Discuss the process for determining public safety and security resource support. Also, discuss how a common operating picture will be developed. National Response Framework, National Disaster Recovery Washington State Emergency 3/19/2025 Management Division Page 7 TIER II – State Suggestions CEMP Location Recommendation to Meet Legal Obligations Reference Framework, WA CEMP, CPG 101 ESF 14 ESF 14 has been superseded by the development of the National Disaster Recovery Framework and is being replaced in the National Response Framework to coordinate lifelines. While a Long-Term Recovery annex is no longer necessary, you may opt to keep it (consider renaming to ESF 21, or 22, etc. to maintain consistency with guidance) or use it to begin building a Recovery Plan to compliment your response efforts (for more information talk to the EMD Recovery Coordinator about the implementation of the Washington Restoration Framework). NRF, NDRF, WA CEMP ESF 15 – Notices The topics covered within ESF 15 encompass aspects of nearly all of the activities of other ESFs and is a difficult Support Annex to develop. Considering this, your ESF 15 Annex demonstrates a high-level of development and forward thinking. There are only a few considerations which can be addressed. Discuss how information pertaining to the potential impacts of secondary hazards is relayed to the public. Discuss mechanisms which will be in place for the family reunification process. Discuss the notifications provided for emergency transportation information. Lastly, discuss the possibility of providing announcements for upcoming community meetings (i.e. involving state officials, local authorities, damage assessments, etc.). National Response Framework, National Disaster Recovery Framework, WA CEMP TIER I – Optional CEMP Location Recommendation to Meet Legal Obligations Reference General The biggest concern with accreditation entities and requirements is detailed explanations of process and procedures. It is often not enough to simply address that you EMAP Washington State Emergency 3/19/2025 Management Division Page 8 TIER I – Optional CEMP Location Recommendation to Meet Legal Obligations Reference perform an activity, but rather explain each step of the process involved to accomplish such activities. Basic Plan Develop and/or reference a multi-year strategic plan complete with goals, objectives, milestones, and implementation methods. EMAP 3.1.1 Basic Plan – Concept of Operations Discuss some basic NIMS concepts (i.e. modular, unified command process, span of control, etc.) EMAP 4.5.1 Basic Plan - Communications There are a lot of elements to try and provide methods and processes regarding crisis communication, public information, and education. EMAP 4.11.1 - 4.11.4 Basic Plan - Development and Maintenance A training and exercise program contains numerous components. Accreditation is primarily concerned with the methods used to train, exercise, and track all this data. EMAP 4.9 - 4.10 Additional Considerations CEMP Location Recommendation ESF 6: Mass Care - ARC While it is fairly common to rely on the support and capabilities of the American Red Cross, your own capabilities should not be discounted. Consider investing in planning efforts focused on what the capabilities of the County and its Cities are capable of in comparison of those of the ARC. If a significant or widespread disaster were to occur, then the capabilities and resources of the ARC would be severely diminished and prove to be insufficient. Therefore, it is advised that you work closely with them to develop your own plans based on your capabilities which can be instituted in a worst-case scenario. At the very least (as the former is no small task), consider reviewing the ARC’s procedural manuals so that you can describe how the ARC accomplishes certain capabilities. For example, examine what methodology the ARC uses in shelter site selection, qualification, and operations. This can be incorporated into your ESF 6 annex in the case that the ARC is not able to assist you immediately following a disaster or emergency.