HomeMy WebLinkAboutLP 23-00001 Thorp Landing Final Decision 7 5 23KITTITAS COUNTY
LAND USE HEARING EXAMINER
IN THE MATTER OF ) FINDINGS OF FACT,
CONCLUSIONS OF LAW,
LP-23-0001 ) CONDITIONS OF APPROVAL
THORP LANDING LONG PLAT ) AND DECISION
THIS MATTER having come on for hearing in front of the Kittitas County Hearing Examiner on June
22, 2023, the Hearing Examiner having taken evidence hereby submits the following Findings of Fact,
Conclusions of Law and Decision:
I. FINDINGS OF FACT
Thorp Landing LLC submitted an application for a 104ot plat on 2 parcels totaling 54.39
acres of land. The proposal includes 10 residential lots ranging in size from 5.00 acres to
8.64 acres. The subject parcels are zoned Agriculture 5. It is part of a Rural Residential Land
Use designation. These parcels had a land use designation change from Rural Working to
Rural Residential and a zoning change from Agriculture 20 to Agriculture 5 under Ordinance
2022-017 (RZ/CP-22-00002 Thorp Landing) that was part of the County's 2022 annual
docket cycle for changes to the comprehensive plan, zoning map and development
regulations.
2. The project area contains two tax parcels (443233 and 493233), located approximately .5 miles
northwest of the intersection of N. Thorp Hwy and I-90 off of Thorp Landing Lane in Section
11, Township 18, Range 17, W.M.; Kittitas County. The properties bear Kittitas County Map
numbers 18-17-11040-0033 and 18-17-11040-0007.
3. Total Project Size: 54.39 acres
Number of Proposed Lots: 10 (2 currently existing)
Domestic Water: 2 Group B Wells (Existing one to serve 2 lots, New one to
serve 8 lots)
Sewage Disposal: Septic
Fire Protection: Thorp (Fire District 1)
Irrigation District: Westside Irrigating Company
Site Characteristics:
North: Residential/Town of Thorp
South: Residential/Some farmland
East: A Few Residential Lots/Vacant Land
West: Mostly Farming Uses
Access: Access to the site will be via Thorp Landing Lane (a private drive) from N. Thorp
Highway.
LP-23-00001
Thorp Landing Long Plat
Page 1 of 17
6. Deemed Complete: A Long Plat Application and SEPA Checklist were submitted to Kittitas
County Community Development Services on January 10, 2023. The application was deemed
complete on February 7, 2023. A petition for review of the County's redesignation of the
property from a land use designation from Rural Working to Rural Residential and zoning
change from Agriculture 20 to Agriculture 5 was submitted to the Growth Management
Hearings Board on February 12, 2023 after the application had been deemed complete on
February 7, 2023 and therefore vested.
Notice of Application: The site was posted pursuant to KCC 15A.03.110 on February 9, 2023
(Index #21). Two posting sites were established (One off of Thorp Landing Lane and the other
near Goodwin Road). A Notice of Application was mailed to all state and local
agencies/departments with potential interest in the project as required by KCC 15A.03.060, as
well as to adjacent landowners located within five hundred (500) feet of any portion of the
boundary of the proposal's contiguous tax parcels on February 21, 2023 and noticed in the local
county paper of record on February 21, 2023. The comment period for this notice ended on
March 9, 2023. Some comments were transmitted to the applicant on March 13, 2023 and full
comments were transmitted on March 15, 2023 to the applicant.
Zoning and Development Standards: The subject property is located approximately .65 miles
northwest of the I-90 Thorp Exit and has a zoning designation of Agriculture 5. The purpose
and intent of Agriculture 5 zone is to provide for an area where various agricultural activities
and low -density residential developments co -exist compatibly. The minimum lot size in
Agriculture 5 districts is 5 acres unless in a cluster plat as seen in KCC 17.28A.030. As this
property is not a cluster plat, the size of all lots must be at least 5 acres. As proposed, the plat
meets the 5-acre minimum lot size criteria. KCC 17.28A.030 also requires the minimum
average width to be at least 250 feet. All parcels except for one are greater than 250 feet in
width, however averaging out the lot widths of all 10 lots achieves an average of 394.56 feet
per lot which meets the width requirements. The created parcels with potential future dwellings
must be served by a legal 60 foot right of way or existing county road under KCC 17.28A.100.
North Thorp Highway is an existing county road and Thorp Landing Lane is a private drive
easement that is 60 feet wide which meets these criteria.
9. Preliminary Plats: The plat drawing submitted with the application was reviewed under KCC
16.12 Preliminary Plats and meets all requirements.
10. Comprehensive Plan: The 2006 Kittitas County Comprehensive Plan designated the proposal
site as "Rural Residential". Kittitas County has established the following goals and policies
to guide activities that are designated in these lands. These goals and policies were
developed in response to identified needs within the county, and support the County Wide
Planning Policies:
10.1 RR-G2: Opportunities should exist for traditional rural lifestyle and rural based
economies.
10.1.1 The proposed plat provides for people to live a traditional rural lifestyle and
support the rural based economy especially being near the small town of
Thorp.
10.2 RR-G10: The County should look for opportunities for a variety or rural density and
housing choices while maintaining rural character and protecting health and safety.
LP-23 -00001
Thorp Landing Long Plat
Page 2 of 17
10.2.1 This plat provides housing choices on 5 acres which is a variety of rural density
and does not require local government services to meet the housing needs of
the county. The county and state have found 5 acres to be consistent with rural
character
10.3 RR-G20: Protect residential activities from flooding areas and natural hazard areas.
10.3.1 The plat provides sufficient area outside the 100-year flood zone and outside
the Type F stream building setback for future housing.
10.4 RR-P25: New rural development shall provide adequate water for domestic use.
10.4.1 The plat will have 2 Group B well systems that are approved through Kittitas
County Public Health that will provide adequate water for domestic use.
10.4.2 The Hearing Examiner reviewed the project for consistency with the Kittitas
County Comprehensive Plan as described above. The Hearing Examiner finds
the proposed development consistent with the Goals and Policies ofthe Kittitas
County Comprehensive Plan.
11. A critical areas review of the parcel was conducted by CDS staff. There is a Type F Stream on
the northern side of the project that has a 100' buffer and what looks like an irrigation line
running through the SW portion of parcel 443233. Floodplain is located on the northeastern
corner of parcels 443233 and 493233. A Critical area report conducted by GG Environmental
was submitted to the County with the application materials. This report indicated no
jurisdictional wetlands and recognized the unnamed creek as a Type F stream with a 100-foot
setback. Kittitas County CDS issued a DNS for this project on June, 2023 after utilizing the
optional DNS process under WAC 197-11-355. The SEPA DNS decision was not appealed.
12. Applicable agencies, adjacent property owners, and interested parties have been given the
opportunity to review this proposal and have been notified of the Public Hearing. Timely
comments were received from the following agencies: Department of Health — Office of
Drinking Water, Snoqualmie Tribe, Westside Irrigating Company, Kittitas County Public
Health, Washington Department of Transportation — Aviation Division, Kittitas County Fire
Marshal, Colville Tribe, Washington State Parks, Department of Ecology and Kittitas County
Public Works. Below are summaries of the substantive agency and public comments submitted
as well as the response from the applicant regarding the comments:
12.1 Snoqualmie Tribe: Snoqualmie Tribe commented that they do not have substantive
comments at this time but if the project scope were to change, they reserve the right to
modify their position.
12.1.1 Applicant response: "At this time the plat will not be modified. Please also see
RLR's cultural resources report dated July 5, 2022."
12.1.2 Hearing Examiner Finding: CDS staff provided these comments to the
applicant and there is no change in plans considered at this time.
12.2 WSDOT Aviation: WSDOT Aviation found that there are no land use compatibility or
airspace issues in relation to local airports.
12.2.1 Applicant response: "Agreed. This plat has no airspace issues with local
airports."
12.2.2 Hearing Examiner Finding: CDS staff provided these comments to the
applicant.
12.3 Department of Health — Office of Drinking Water (DOH-ODW): DOH-ODW
commented that the project would be provided by a Group B water system that requires
approval from Kittitas County Public Health in their initial comments on February 22,
LP-23-00001
Thorp Landing Long Plat
Page 3 of 17
2023. Public Health commented that their JPR with DOH that they don't approve
above 9 connections at the county so that the applicant would need to work with DOH
for a system for 10 lots. DOH on February 23rd, 2023 then asked for clarification on
what the applicant is proposing for the water system on these lots and if they were
expanding the existing "Thorp Landing" water system. Staff then clarified on March
1, 2023 that the applicant was using an existing group B well to serve 2 of the new lots
and a new group B well to serve the other 8 lots. After this clarification, DOH said that
the two Group B water systems would be considered a "project" for ground water
withdrawal and water rights and could not withdraw more than 5,000 gallons a day.
They advised the applicant to confirm this with Ecology on the matter. They also said
that the proposal for expansion of a group B well and a new group B well would be
handled by Kittitas County Public Health. DOH sent new comments for the notice of
Public Hearing on June 5, 2023, stating that if 10 lots are served as a collective water
system, then it would require a Group A Water System that would have to be approved
by them.
12.3.1 Applicant response: "The plat will have 2 lots served by an existing and
approved Group B well and a new Group B well is proposed on Lot 7 that will
serve the rest of the proposed plat. The existing Group B Water system is not
being expanded and is approved for 6 connections (see Exhibit 10 of
application submittal). Also see e-mail chain from February 22 and March 1,
2023. All domestic water to serve the property which is the subject of this plat
application will be withdrawn from two wells. One well has already been
classified as a Group B system, and it serves lots not involved with the plat,
but which are described as Kittitas County Tax Parcel Nos. 19588, 19589,
19590, 19591, 19592, and 19593. Two of these lots are owned by third parties
and they had building permits issued after the current landowner bought a
Kittitas County Mitigation Package. The plat will add 10 lots to the above six
lots, for a total of 16 lots. Each lot may withdraw 275 gallons per day, so the
combined withdrawal of ground water from the property is under 5,000 gallons
per day. Because all of the property has irrigation water from the West Side
Irrigation Company, there is no need for any outdoor irrigation to occur using
ground water. The applicant, through covenants, conditions, and restrictions,
will restrict individuals acquiring lots within the plat to 275 gallons of water
per day with no outdoor use of water. Additionally, see responses related to
outdoor irrigation below in response to the West Side Irrigation Company's
comments."
12.3.2 Hearing Examiner Finding: CDS Staff transmitted these comments to the
applicant. The Hearing Examiner sets as a condition of approval to this
proposal that the Applicant obtain a Group B Well approval from Kittitas
County Public Health if they are adding 2 connections to an existing well and
adding a new group B well. The Hearing Examiner also sets as a condition of
approval that the Applicant get a group A well approval from the State
Department of Health if any system is to serve 10 or more lots.
12.4 Kittitas County Fire Marshal: Department of Ecology: The Department of Ecology
made comments on the withdrawal of groundwater and said anything beyond 5,000
LP-23-00001
Thorp Landing Long Plat
Page 4 of 17
gallons of water per day withdrawn requires authorization from the Department of
Ecology.
12.4.1 Applicant Response: See response to Department of Health Comments.
12.4.2 Hearing Examiner Finding: CDS Staff provided comments to the applicant.
The Hearing Examiner sets as a Condition of Approval that the Applicant
obtain approval from the Department of Ecology if planning on withdrawing
over 5,000 gallons of water a day.
12.5 Colville Tribe: Colville Tribe requested an inadvertent discovery plan be in place prior
to implementation. They also say if ground disturbing activities are to be conducted,
then a cultural resource survey and sub -surface testing should be done.
12.5.1 Applicant Response: RLR Arch. & Cultural Resources has already surveyed
the property and recommends the project to proceed as planned. Kittitas county
is the overseer for future development within the plat. Yakama Nation has
already reviewed the survey and agreed to its findings. There has been an
Inadvertent Discovery Plan already established.
12.5.2 Hearing Examiner Finding: CDS Staff is in receipt of the cultural resources
survey. This survey was done for the road building of Thorp Landing Lane for
Kittitas County SEPA Application 5E-22-00015 but did not incorporate the
entire plat area. The Hearing Examiner sets as a Condition of Approval that
the proposal have the inadvertent discovery plan in place during all ground
disturbing activities
12.6 Kittitas County Fire Marshal: The Kittitas County Fire Marshal's Office provided
comments related to fire apparatus access roads, fire flow, hydrant systems and wildfire
protection requirements on February 8, 2023. Staff received an e-mail from the Fire
Marshal's office on April 26, 2023 (See Index #44) that previous fire flow and fire
hydrant requirements for this plat are hereby waived and the lots are to be sprinkled
from the irrigation canal(s) and that the lots are low hazard WUIC scores and do not
have a high ability to expose to other structures in the event of a fire.
12.6.1 Applicant Response: At this time, there is no gate proposed and a key box will
not be needed. Per the Fire Marshal E-mail, fire flow and hydrant systems are
waived.
12.6.2 Hearing Examiner Finding_ The Hearing Examiner sets as a Condition of
Approval that a plat note that requires all structures to be sprinkled and all
roads constructed to meet International Fire Code (IFC) requirements.
12.7 Westside Irrigating Company ()LVSIC): WSIC commented that this plat lies wholly
within their service area and that there are two turnouts on the Main Canal. They
referenced KCC 16.18 which talks about provisions for the orderly system of providing
irrigation water to property to be subdivided and requires a water delivery system with
rights of way to each new lot to receive irrigation water. They talked about updated
bylaws regarding subdivisions and that they have no formal objection to the proposal.
12.7.1 Applicant Response: The applicant agrees to this regarding Westside Irrigating
Company comments and conditions for the plat. The applicant is aware of
Kittitas County Code 16.18 which sets forth the County requirements and the
applicant is aware of the West Side Irrigation Company's rules and regulations
regarding delivery ofwater. The applicant intends to provide two points for all
lots within the plat to access water from the West Side Canal. The water will
LP-23-00001
Thorp Landing Long Plat
Page 5 of 17
be delivered to each lot in a piped system, with each lot having an irrigation
riser which will be metered. Further, through the use of covenants, conditions
and restrictions, the applicant will require that the application of all West Side
Irrigation Company water to lots within the plat for purposes of irrigation will
be required to be through a sprinkler system. No flood irrigation of these lots
will be allowed
12.7.2 Hearing Examiner Finding; These comments have been provided to the
applicant. The Hearing Examiner sets as a condition of approval to have a
water delivery system (according to KCC 16.18) in place approved by WSIC
prior to final plat approval.
12.8 Washington State Parks & Recreation (State Parks): State Parks commented their
concerns about trespassing, noise and light glare, and potential stormwater discharge.
They said if the project proponent needs access to state park land, they need to apply
for and obtain legal access for easement.
12.8.1 Applicant Response: The preliminary plat map was submitted as part of the
application. If the plat is approved, it will eventually be recorded, and a record
will be provided to State Parks. There is no access for this proposal to State
Parks land and access is through Thorp Landing Lane. No trespassing and
dumping signs will be established on the property line with State Parks Land.
Typical county setbacks will apply to development on the property and CCR's
will cover noise, light and glare. The applicant has submitted an Ecology
stormwater erosivity waiver and stormwater will stay on site and it is highly
unlikely that that stormwater would ever discharge onto State Parks land.
12.8.2 Hearing Examiner Finding: The Hearing Examiner sets as a condition of
approval that signs for no trespassing and keeping all stormwater on site. The
county currently does not have regulations pertaining to light and glare.
12.9 Kittitas County Public Health (KCPH): KCPH commented on well and septic
requirements including the two proposed Group B water systems.
12.9.1 Applicant response: The applicant contacted Holly Erdman at the Kittitas
County Health Department regarding the public health comment. In
discussions with Ms. Erdman, it is clear that the heading of her comment
referencing the Conner Short Plat and the date of the comment are incorrect;
however, the applicant was able to confirm that the substance of Ms. Erdman's
comments on behalf of Kittitas County Public Health did in fact relate to this
plat application. The applicant understands and agrees to her comments.
Specifically, the applicant understands that prior to final plat approval, the
applicant will have to comply with KCC 13.35,027, by providing a certificate
of water budget neutrality or other adequate interest in water rights from a
water bank.
12.9.2 Hearing Examiner Finding CDS Staff has provided this comment to the
applicant and proposed conditions regarding Group B well approvals, soil logs
and water mitigation prior to final platting.
LP-23 -00001
Thorp Landing Long Plat
Page 6 of 17
12.10 Kittitas County Public Works (KCPW): KCPW provided comments on access
requirements, roads meeting fire codes, and that no access should be done from
Goodwin Road. They also commented about projected traffic trips and the possibility
of needing a traffic impact analysis. They had comments about required plat notes,
flood development and water mitigation. A follow up e-mail with updated comments
on March 14, 2023 mentioned that the owner information and the engineer of record
should be included on the face of the preliminary plat.
12.10.1 Applicant response: The applicant agrees with Public Works conditions. The
preliminary plat shows the location of the turnaround and that a portion of
Thorp Landing Lane has been reviewed and approved by Kittitas County and
was built. Thorp Landing Lane will be extended to serve this plat.
12.10.2 Hearing Examiner Finding,: CDS Staff has provided this comment to the
applicant and the Hearing Examiner sets as a condition of approval regarding
various road standards, floodplain standards as well as required plat notes. The
applicant provided a transportation concurrency application on 5-15-23 (TC-
23-00004) with estimated traffic trips. Kittitas County Public Works
determined that this plat does not require any mitigation measures for traffic
impacts on May 30, 2023.
13. Public Comments were received from the following people:
13.1 Fudacz Family: The Fudacz Family submitted comments and concerns regarding water
runoff and irrigation water rights on the parcels including 3 springs as well as concerns
about the applicant. They also said that the critical areas report submitted to the county
is inadequate.
13.1.1 Applicant response: The water rights issue was sorted out by the Ecology v.
Acquavella case that the Fudacz family were a part of There are limited claims
to the water and easements by the Fudacz family over the applicant's property.
The applicant has no obligation to highlight perennial springs throughout the
property and the report meets the county code and the Fudacz's and did not
produce their own report. No lots will have the ability to apply irrigation water
to the property except through the West Side Irrigation Company system that
complies with their rules and regulations as well as the County's.
13.1.2 Hearing Examiner Finding Critical Area Reports do not require springs to be
identified on them at this time under KCC 17A. Springs would need to be
included if the county had requested a hydrogeological assessment in a critical
aquifer recharge area. As this project is for residential lots, it does not fall
under the applicability sections of KCC 17A.03.030. All irrigation easements
and an irrigation delivery system will have to be shown on the final plat and
be approved by the Westside Irrigating Company prior to final plat approval.
13.2 Johnny & Erinn Boitano: Johnny & Erinn Boitano raised concerns about the aquifer
and septic system approvals. They mention that during the summer, everyone flood
LP-23-00001
Thorp Landing Long Plat
Page 7 of 17
irrigates their properties which brings the water table up and could contaminate the
aquifer and negatively affect the surface water and drainage patterns. They also
commented that the lots are in the floodplain.
13.2.1 Applicant Response: This proposed ten lot plat is not completely within the
floodplain. Only a small portion of the plat is in the 100 year and 500-year
floodplain and is in the back portion of the lots. Kittitas County does allow
people to build within the 100-year floodplain as long as flood development
requirements are met. The plat proposes a Group B water system that will be
approved by Kittitas County Public Health. Per the Kittitas County Health
Department's comment letter and county code, the proposed plat is allowed to
apply for individual septic systems.
13.2.2 Hearing Examiner Finding: There is sufficient space outside of the 100-year
floodplain to build on all of the proposed lots. Kittitas County Public Health
will have to approve all septic systems including soil logs prior to final plat
approval that looks at things like groundwater. The Hearing Examiner sets as
a condition of approval that the lots not be flood irrigated.
13.3 Paula Thompson: Paula Thompson commented on the 2022 comprehensive plan and
rezone update saying it was inadequate and that the current SEPA checklist does not
identify wetlands and perennial springs. She also commented on irrigation rights and
delivery systems as well as drainage patterns. She had concerns about lots without fire
hydrants and that a turn lane should be required on Thorp Hwy to turn onto Thorp
Landing Lane.
13.3.1 Applicant Response: Ms. Thompson did not file an appeal to the SEPA as part
of the 2022 comprehensive plan and zoning change. She has now filed a
petition to the Eastern Washington Growth Management Hearings Board but
that petition does not matter as this application was vested prior to the petition
as the county deemed it complete prior to that petition.
13.3.2 Hearing Examiner Finding: The applicant provided a critical areas report done
by a qualified professional that states there are no jurisdictional wetlands on
the property and one Type F stream on the north side of the property. An
irrigation system approved by Westside Irrigating Company will be required
prior to final plat approval. Kittitas County received a transportation
concurrency application from the applicant and found that no mitigation
measures are required for the creation of 10 lots in this plat.
14. The Hearing Examiner has reviewed all the comments submitted and has conditioned this
decision to address the concerns noted.
15. In review of this proposal, it is important to consider the goals and policies of the
comprehensive plan, applicable county code, public and agency comments, any identified
environmental concerns and state and federal requirements. Identified below is the Hearing
Examiner's analysis and consistency review for the subject application.
LP-23-00001
Thorp Landing Long Plat
Page 8 of 17
16. Comprehensive Plan Consistency: The proposal is consistent with the goals and policies of the
Kittitas County Comprehensive Plan. The subdivision can help promote a rural lifestyle, only
requires rural government services and provides options for housing and development that can
take place outside of the floodplain.
17. Consistency with the provision of KCC. 17 Zoning: The proposal is consistent with the
provisions of KCC 17.28A. The lots are all over 5 acres and there is adequate size to put houses
or other uses on the properties. All lots are served off Thorp Landing Lane from Thorp Highway
which is an existing county road meeting the requirements of KCC 17.28A.100.
18. Consistency with the provisions of KCC 17A Critical Areas: This proposal is consistent with
the Kittitas County Critical Areas Code. The applicant submitted a critical areas report which
indicated no wetlands on the property and one Type F stream. The stream has a 100' buffer
(plus 15' additional building setback) which is shown in the plat map. The plat map also
contains the 100-year floodplain. There are sufficient areas outside of required setbacks to
build. The Hearing Examiner finds the project with conditions consistent with KCC 17A
Critical Areas.
19. Consistency with the provisions of KCC 16.12 Preliminary Plat Subdivision Code: This
proposal is consistent with the Kittitas County Subdivision Code (Title 16) for Preliminary
Plats with conditions.
20. Consistency with the provisions of KCC Title 12: Roads and Bridges: This proposal is
consistent with the Kittitas County Title 12 Roads and Bridges with conditions.
21. Consistency with the provisions of KCC Title 20: Fire & Life Safety: This proposal is
consistent with the Kittitas County Title 20 Fire & Life Safety with conditions
22. An open record public hearing after due legal notice was held on June 22, 2023 via video
conferencing.
23. At the open record public hearing the following exhibits were entered into the record:
23.1
23.2
23.3
23.4
23.5
23.6
23.7
23.8
23.9
Ex. 1
Ex. 2
Ex. 3
Ex. 4
Ex. 5
Ex. 6
Ex. 7
Ex. 8
Ex. 9
23.10 Ex. 10
23.11 Ex. 11
23.12 Ex. 12
23.13 Ex. 13
23.14 Ex. 14
23.15 Ex. 15
Plat Application
Receipt
Applicant Exhibit List
Preliminary Plat Map & Legal Descriptions
Parcel Numbers and Acreages
Floodplain, Shoreline & Vicinity Maps
Old Zoning and Land Use Maps
Project Narrative
Subdivision Guarantee
Recorded Access Easement
Comprehensive Plan/Zoning Docket Amendment Ordinance 2022-017
Zoning Code and Permitted Uses Table for Ag-5
Group B Water System Approval
Satellite Management Agreement
Critical Areas Report
LP-23-00001
Thorp Landing Long Plat
Page 9 of 18
23.16
Ex. lb
SEPA Checklist
23.17
Ex. 17
Grading Permit GP-22-00008
23.18
Ex. 18
Road Certification
23.19
Ex. 19
Ecology Erosivity Waiver
23.20
Ex. 20
Deemed Complete
23.21
Ex. 21
CDS Staff Maps
23.22
Ex. 22
Affidavit of Posting
23.23
Ex. 23
Notice of Application
23.24
Ex. 24
Affidavit of Mailing & Publication - Notice of Application
23.25
Ex. 25
Snoqualmie Tribe Comments 2-21-23
23.26
Ex. 26
WSDOT Aviation Comments 2-21-23
23.27
Ex. 27
State Department of Health - Office of Drinking Water Comments 2-22-23
23.28
Ex. 28
Colville Tribe Comments 2-23-23
23.29
Ex. 29
Kittitas County Fire Marshal Comments 2-24-23
23.30
Ex. 30
Westside Irrigating Company Comments 2-28-23
23.31
Ex. 31
State Department of Health - Office of Drinking Water Comments Updated
Comments 3-1-23
23.32
Ex. 32
Dept. of Ecology Comments 3-7-23
23.33
Ex. 33
Washington State Parks and Rec Comments 3-8-23
23.34
Ex. 34
Public Health Comments 3-9-23
23.35
Ex. 35
Fudacz Family Comments 3-9-23
23.36
Ex. 36
Johnny & Erinn Boitano Comments 3-9-23
23.37
Ex. 37
Paula Thompson Comments 3-9-23
23.38
Ex. 38
Kittitas County Public Works Comments 3-10-23
23.39
Ex. 39
Transmittal of Comments 3-13-23
23.40
Ex. 40
Kittitas County Public Works Comments Updated with Survey Comments 3-
14-23
23.41
Ex. 41
Transmittal of Comments 3-15-23
23.42
Ex. 42
Extension for Response timeline to comments granted to April 7, 2023
23.43
Ex. 43
Extension for Response timeline to comments granted to April 17, 2023
23.44
Ex. 44
Extension for Response timeline to comments granted to May 1, 2023
23.45
Ex. 45
Fire Marshal e-mail regarding fire flow, hydrant, and sprinkler requirements
23.46
Ex. 46
Applicant Response Comments 5-1-2023
23.47
Ex. 47
Transportation Concurrency Required Letter 5-5-23
23.48
Ex. 48
Transportation Concurrency Application
23.49
Ex. 49
Transportation Concurrency Receipt 5-15-23
23.50
Ex. 50
Transportation Concurrency Determination 5-30-23
23.51
Ex. 51
SEPA DNS
23.52
Ex. 52
Notice of Public Hearing & SEPA Action
23.53
Ex. 53
Affidavit of Mailing & Publication - Notice of Public Hearing and SEPA
Action
23.54
Ex. 54
WSDOH Comments from Hearing Notice 6-3-23 & 6-5-23
23.55
Ex. 55
Returned Mail Notice of Public Hearing & SEPA Action
23.56
Ex. 56
Staff Report
23.57
Ex. 57
PowerPoint Presentation
23.58
Ex. 58
Paula Thompson public comments with exhibits.
LP-23-00001
Thorp Landing Long Plat
Page 10 of 18
24. Darren Higashiyama representing the Kittitas County Fire Marshall's office, provided testimony.
He testified that it was agreed that the fire hydrant requirement would be waived by the County
and stated that there was no agreement that sprinklers would be waived for habitable structures.
It was Mr. Higashiyama's opinion that the requirement for sprinklers within habitable structures
has always been required and should remain required for this project. He did indicate that there
are ongoing discussions regarding what type of projects sprinklers should be required, but did
not change his opinion regarding this project.
25. The Applicant did not submit any testimony from any experts regarding the lack of need for a
residential sprinkler system in each of the residences.
26. The Kittitas County Fire Marshal's office are the experts regarding fire safety within Kittitas
County. The Hearing Examiner was not provided with any evidence as to why sprinkler systems
in the habitable structures should not be required in this project.
27. The Hearing Examiner would note that it was staff's recommendation that sprinkler systems
within habitable structures be waived and that instead, a 30' defensible space around habitable
structures be required.
28. The Hearing Examiner is going to require the interior sprinkler systems within residential
structures in the conditions of approval, but will give the Fire Marshal's office the option, upon
further consideration of this issue, to waive that condition and instead provide the 30' defensible
space as the only additional fire defense mitigation.
29. Appearing and testified on behalf of the Applicant was Chad Bala. Mr. Bala testified that he was
an agent authorized to appear and speak on behalf of the property owner and Applicant. Mr. Bala
believed that the requirement for interior sprinkler systems for habitable structures was a new
condition imposed by the Fire Marshal. As indicated above, Mr. Higashiyama indicated that this
requirement had always been proposed by the Fire Marshal. Mr. Bala testified that there are low
fire fuels present due to the area pastures.
30 Also speaking on the Applicant's behalf, was Jeff Slothower. Mr. Slothower is the attorney for
the Applicant and property owner. He testified that other homes in the area had not been required
to have interior sprinklers in residential structures. He also indicated that there is simply no
additional water to purchase for this fire flow requirement.
31 _ The following members of the public testified at the hearing:
31.1 Pat Deneen. Mr. Deneen testified regarding fire flow water requirements and that there
simply is not enough water to be purchased for fire flow requirements.
31.2 Paul Dempsey. Mr. Dempsey was not able to be heard on this video conference call,
however, upon questioning from the Hearing Examiner, he simply indicated that he
wished the Hearing Examiner to rely upon their written submission.
32. The Kittitas County Hearing Examiner considered all evidence within the record in rendering
this decision.
33. Any Conclusion of Law that is more correctly a Finding of Fact is hereby incorporated as such
by this reference.
II. CONCLUSIONS OF LAW
The Hearing Examiner has been granted authority to render this decision.
LP-23-00001
Thorp Landing Long Plat
Page 11 of 18
2. As conditioned, the development meets the goals, policies and implementation
recommendations as set forth in the Kittitas County Comprehensive Plan.
As conditioned, this proposal is consistent with applicable federal and state laws and
regulations.
4. Public use and interest will be served by approval of this proposal.
As conditioned, the proposal is consistent with Kittitas County Code Title 16 Subdivision, Title
17 Zoning, Title 17A Critical Areas, Title 15 Environmental, Title 12 Roads and Bridges and
Title 20 Fire & Life Safetv.
6. Any Finding of Fact that is more correctly a Conclusion of Law is hereby incorporated as such
by this reference.
III. DECISION
Based on the above Findings of Fact and Conclusions of Law, LP-23-0001 — Thorp Landing Long
Plat is hereby APPROVED subject to the following Conditions of Approval.
IV. CONDITIONS OF APPROVAL
All Conditions of Approval shall apply to the Applicant, and the Applicant's heirs, successors in
interest and assigns.
The project shall proceed in substantial conformance with the plans and application materials
on file submitted on January 10, 2023 and transportation concurrency submitted May 15,
2023 except as amended by the conditions herein.
Building
2. The applicant is responsible for compliance with all applicable local, state and federal rules
and regulations, and must obtain all appropriate permits and approvals.
Environmental and statutory review may be required for all current and future development,
construction, and improvements. The applicant and/or all future owners of any lot or lots
within this subdivision are responsible for compliance with all applicable local, state, and
federal rules, requirements, codes, and regulations. It is incumbent upon said applicants and
future owners to investigate for, and obtain from the appropriate agency or their
representative, all required permits, licenses, and approvals for any development,
construction, and/or improvements that occur within the boundaries of this subdivision.
All structures will need to be permitted and built to the current Kittitas County adopted
building codes at the time of construction.
Roads and Transportation
4. Road Standards: This application is subject to the latest revision of the Kittitas County Road
Standards, dated 12/15/2015. A performance guarantee may be used, in lieu of the required
improvements, per the conditions outlined in KCC 12.01.150.
LP-23 -00001
Thorp Landing Long Plat
Page 12 of 18
4.1 Roads & Driveways:
4.1.1 An approved access permit shall be required from the Department of Public
Works prior to creating any new driveway access or performing work in the
county road right-of-way.
4.1.2 Private roads serving any of the lots within the development shall be
inspected and certified by a licensed professional engineer for conformance
with the 2015 Kittitas County Road Standards. This certification shall be
completed prior to final plat approval or if a performance guarantee is used in
lieu of the required improvements, the private road must be certified to
comply with the minimum requirements of the International Fire Code prior
to building permit issuance.
4.1.3 Roads and Driveways longer than 150' in length are required to provide a
Fire Apparatus Road Turnaround meeting the requirements of Appendix D in
the International Fire Code.
4.1.4 Maintenance of driveway approaches shall be the responsibility of the owner
whose property they serve. The county will not maintain access.
4.1.5 Future access onto proposed lots may not be accessed off a county road if
there is an alternative road to access from.
4.1.6 Kittitas County will not accept private roads for maintenance as public streets
or roads until such streets or roads are brought into conformance with current
County Road Standards and formally adopted by the Kittitas County Board
of County Commissioners.
4.1.7 Access is not guaranteed to any existing or created parcel on this application.
4.1.8 Newly created lots shall access onto an internal road system and not directly
onto a County Road.
4.1.9 All road construction within the public or private right-of-way shall be
designed by or under the direct supervision of a civil engineer, licensed to
practice in the State of Washington. Please submit a road plan and profile
drawings along with any associated drainage reports for a formal Civil
Review to Kittitas County Public Works (KCC 12.04.020)
5. Other
5.1 If over 100 cubic yards of material are displaced during construction, a grading
permit shall be required. If over 500 cubic yards, an engineered grading permit shall
be required. If the applicant plans on applying for final plat prior to building, a bond
for construction shall be required
LP-23-00001
Thorp Landing Long Plat
Page 13 of 18
5.2 Prior to the final platting process, a Civil Review of the plans will be required by
Public Works. If the applicant is getting an engineered grading permit, the Civil
Review will be included in the permit
5.3 All plats must show the acceptance signature of the County Engineer. The acceptance
block shall be as follows (per KCC 16.24.170):
EXAMINED AND APPROVED
This day of , A.D., 20
Kittitas County Engineer
5.4 Contact the Kittitas County Rural Addressing Coordinator at 509-962-7523 to obtain
addresses prior to obtaining a building permit. A parcel cannot receive a building
permit or utilities until such parcel is identified with a 911 address.
5.5 Mailboxes must be approved the U.S. Postal Service. Mailbox locations are site
specific. Contact your local Post Office for location and design standards before
beginning construction.
5.6 All accesses and roads need to be compliant with the 2018 IFC including Appendix
D.
6 Survey
6.1 Owner, Engineer of Record, and Surveyor of Record shall be on final plat.
6.2 A Title Report shall be submitted and the legal description on the Title Report shall
match the legal description on the final plat.
6.3 Controlling corners shall be noted, and property corners set.
6.4 The boundaries along the Type F stream shall be delineated
6.5 A right-of-way or easement shall be shown for an approved irrigation water delivery
system as approved by the Westside Irrigation Company.
6.6 The plat must show the acceptance signature of the Westside Irrigation Company.
The acceptance block shall be as follows (per KCC 16.18.035):
I hereby certify that the irrigation for the Thorp Landing Plat confonns to the
requirements of Westside Irrigating Company.
This day of A.D., 20_
Westside Irrigating Company Representative
6.7 Lot Closures shall be submitted. Computer sheets shall be submitted with the final plat
LP-23 -00001
Thorp Landing Long Plat
Page 14 of 18
showing the closure of plat boundaries, blocks, lots or any tract. It is the responsibility of the
Professional Licensed Surveyor (PLS) to ensure the lot closures are correct and accurate.
7 Water/Sewer
7.1 In accordance with KCC 13.35.027, the applicant shall provide one of the following
documents before final plat approval:
7.1.1 A letter from a water purveyor stating that the purveyor has adequate water
rights and will provide the necessary water for the new use
7.1.2 An adequate water right for the proposed new use
7.1.3 A certificate of water budget neutrality from the Department of Ecology or
other adequate interest in water rights from a water bank.
7.2 All applicants for land divisions shall also submit information on "proximate parcels"
held in "common ownership" as those terms are defined in WAC 173-539A-030 and
otherwise demonstrate how the proposed new use will not violate RCW 90.44.050 as
currently existing or hereafter amended.
7.3 Failure to obtain mitigation before commencement of an activity requiring mitigation
shall be a code violation subject to enforcement under Title 18 KCC.
7.4 In accordance with KCC 13.04.090, a minimum of one soil log for each proposed lot
where individual sewage disposal systems are contemplated must be completed and
approved prior to final plat approval.
7.5 The existing Group B water system must be approved and/or expanded to serve 2 lots
of this plat prior to final plat approval.
7.6 The new proposed Group B water system must have a well drilled and a Group B
water system approved to be able to serve 8 connections with a public water system
ID # issued prior to obtaining final plat signature.
7.7. If the proposed 10 lots are to be served a single water system, it shall be a Group A
water system that is approved by the State Department of Health prior to final plat
approval.
7.8 Any Ground Water withdrawals over 5,000 gallons per day shall require
authorization from the Department of Ecology.
8 Other
8.1 Applicant must meet all state and federal regulations.
8.2 An Irrigation Water Delivery System as described in in KCC 16.18.030 shall be
provided by the developer and approved by Westside Irrigating Company prior to
final plat approval.
LP-23-00001
Thorp Landing Long Plat
Page 15 of 18
8.3 All stonnwater shall be kept on site or require a Construction Stormwater permit
from the Department of Ecology
8.4 No trespassing signs shall be put up on the boundary line of each lot that abuts with
Washington State Parks land. A legal easement shall be required if wanting access to
State Parks Land from this plat.
8.5 Taxes must be paid in full on all tax parcels involved in this land use action as
required by Washington State Law (RCW 84.40.042 & 84.56.345) prior to final plat
recording
8.6 All sheets of the final mylars shall reflect plat number LP-23-00001 and an accurate
legal description shall be shown on the face of the final plat. Engineers and Surveyors
need to be cognizant of the requirements related to Final Plats (KCC 16.20) and
Survey Data and Dedications (KCC 16.24). The final plat must be submitted in full
conformance with these chapters of Kittitas County Code; non -compliant molars
will be reiected and returned to the applicant A final plat number will be assigned
when CDS receives your final plat application. This file number will also be required
on the face of the final plat.
8.7 There shall be no flood irrigating of the properties.
8.8 Critical Areas
8.8.1 All final surveys shall include denotation of the Type F Stream and its 100'
buffer.
8.8.2 All final surveys shall include denotation of boundary of the 100-year
floodplain.
9. Cultural Resources
9.1 Should ground disturbing or other activities related to the proposed subdivision result
in the inadvertent discovery of cultural or archaeological materials, work shall be
stopped in the immediate area and contact be made with the Washington State
Department of Archaeology and Historic Preservation (DAB?), Yakama Nation, and
Colville Tribe. Work shall remain suspended until the find is assessed and appropriate
consultation is conducted. Should human remains be inadvertently discovered. as
dictated by Washington State RCW 27.44.055, work shall be immediately halted in the
area and contact made with the coroner and local law enforcement in the most
expeditious manner possible.
10. Plat Notes
10.1 The following plat notes shall be recorded on the final mylar drawings:
10.1.1 Environmental and statutory review maybe required for all current and
future development, construction, and improvements. The applicant and/or
LP-23-00001
Thorp Landing Long Plat
Page 16 of 18
all future owners of any lot or lots within this subdivision are responsible for
compliance with all applicable local, state, and federal rules, requirements,
codes, and regulations. It is incumbent upon said applicants and future
owners to investigate for, and obtain from the appropriate agency or their
representative, all required permits, licenses, and approvals for any
development, construction, and/or improvements that occur within the
boundaries of this subdivision.
10.2 All development must comply with International Fire Code.
10.3 An approved access permit will be required from the Department of Public Works
prior to creating any new driveway access or performing work within the county road
right-of-way.
10.4 Lots 5 & 6 shall not have access from Goodwin Road unless approved by Kittitas
County Public Works.
10.5 The approval of this division of land provides no guarantee that use of water under
the ground water exemption (RCW 90.44.050) for this plat or any portion thereof will
not be subject to curtailment by the Department of Ecology or a court of law.
10.6 Metering is required for all new uses of domestic water for residential well
connections and usage must be recorded in a manner consistent with Kittitas County
Code Chapter 13.35.027 and Ecology regulations.
10.7 Any further subdivision or lots to be served by proposed access may result in further
access requirements. See Kittitas County Road Standards.
10.8 Kittitas County will not accept private roads for maintenance as public streets or
roads until such streets or roads are brought into conformance with current County
Road Standards and formally adopted by the Kittitas County Board of County
Commissioners.
10.9 Maintenance of the access is the responsibility of the property owners who benefit
from its use.
10.10 A public utility easement 10 feet in width is reserved along all lot lines. The 10-foot
easement shall abut the exterior plat boundary and shall be divided by 5 feet on each
side of interior lot lines. Said easement may also be used for irrigation.
10.11 All structures on these lots shall be sprinkled unless otherwise waived by the Kittitas
County Fire Marshal,
10.12 In the event the requirement sprinklers in Condition 10.11 are waived by the Kittitas
County County Fire Marshal, all habitable structures shall have a 30' defensible
space around them in accordance with 2018 IWVIC 603.2
10.13 The subject property is within or near land used for agriculture on which a variety of
LP-23-00001
Thorp Landing Long Plat
Page 17 of 18
commercial activities may occur that are not compatible with residential development
for periods of varying duration. (RCW 36.70A.060(1)) Commercial natural resource
activities performed in accordance with county, state and federal laws are not subject
to legal action as public nuisances." (RCW 7.48.305)
10.14 All activities within the floodplain must be permitted through the floodplain
development permit process and follow regulations within KCC 14.08.220.
10.15 All lots shall not allow flood irrigation.
Dated this t day of July, 2023.
KITTITASCOUNTY HEARING EXAMINER
L.
This Decision is subject to appeal pursuant to the Kittitas County Code and the Revised Code of
Washington.
LP-23-00001
Thorp Landing Long Plat
Page 18 of 18