Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAbout2024-12-23-minutes-public-works-and-cds-study-sessionKITTITAS COUNTY COMMISSIONERS Public Works and CDS Study Session Regular Meeting Monday December 23, 2024 - 1:30 PM BoCC Auditorium 205 West 5th Room 109 - Ellensburg 1. Call to Order 2. Citizen Comments (1 min. time limit) 3. Community Development Services -Critical Areas Update -Senate Bill 5290 4. Public Works -G4-29290 Water Right Permit Assignment -Broadband Planning Update 5. EXECUTIVE SESSION - RCW 42.30.110(1)(b) - To consider the selection of a site or the acquisition of real estate by lease or purchase when public knowledge regarding such consideration would cause a likelihood of increased price. 6. EXECUTIVE SESSION - RCW 42.30.110(1)(i)- To discuss with legal counsel representing the agency matters relating to agency enforcement actions, or to discuss with legal counsel representing the agency litigation or potential litigation to which the agency, the governing body, or a member acting in an official capacity is, or is likely to become, a party, when public knowledge regarding the discussion is likely to result in on adverse legal or financial consequence to the agency 7. Other Business - No Action to be taken 8. Concluded Created on 12/19/2024 11:15:14 AM KITTITAS COUNTY PUBLIC WORKS/COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT SERVICES STUDY SESSION MINUTES COMMISSIONERS' AUDITORIUM, 205 WEST 5TH ROOM 109 Regular Meeting MONDAY 1:30 PM December 23, 2024 Board members present: Chairman Brett Wachsmith, Vice Chairman Laura Osiadacz, and Commissioner Cory Wright. Others: Josh Fredrickson, Arden Thomas, Sally Kraft, Public Works; Chad Bala, Jeremy Johnston, Jessica Miller, Community Development Services; Chris Horner, Prosecuting Attorney's Office. At 1:30PM Chairman Brett Wachsmith opened the Public Works and Community Development Services Study Session. No Citizen Comments COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT SERVICES CRITICAL AREAS UPDATE Chad Bala briefed the Board of County Commissioners on the status of Resolution 2024-093. CDS will work with Facet NW Consultants to gather necessary data for a cost of $13.9K. SENATE BILL 5290 Jeremy Johnston briefed the Board of County Commissioners on Senate Bill 5290 that will go into effect January 1, 2025. This bill primarily focuses on changes to the development review timelines. Chad Bala and Jeremy Johnston will be reviewing the mandate and how it will affect current application fees. PUBLIC WORKS G4-29290 Water Right Permit Assignment Arden Thomas requested direction from Board of County Commissioners on the proposed partnership between Kittitas County and Joyce Palelek, a Vantage Area water right holder, and the subsequent request for Technical Assistance on Assignment of Application G4- 29290 to the Department of Ecology. The proposed partnership between Kittitas County and Ms. Palelek would enable the groundwater permit application to be processed and would maintain and provide water mitigation options with Vantage. Kittitas County would enter into a mitigation agreement with Ecology for an annual fee that would initially be absorbed in the 403 Fund. Water user fees would be developed to cover these costs. The Board provided direction to staff to send the technical assistance letter upon addressing Commissioner Cory Wright's direction to verify the use of the term, "Town", with Chad Bala, Community Development Services Director. Broadband Planning Update 12/23/24 MINUTES Josh Fredrickson briefed the Board of County Commissioners about the status of the Broadband expansion. Two of the three projects received grants and are underway. The third project is seeking funding through the NTIA BEAD project for seven identified project areas. The application process is robust and each of the seven projects requires a separate application, due at the end of January 2025. Marc Eyler is assisting in the identification of non -serviceable areas and Josh requested Marc receive a stipend for his work. County Commissioner concurred and suggested a contract amendment to cover this cost. EXECUTIVE SESSION 1 At 1:54PM the Board of County Commissioners announced they would recess into Executive Session for 10 minutes with Josh Fredrickson, Arden Thomas, and Chris Horner per RCW 42.30.110(1)(b) - To consider the selection of a site or acquisition of real estate by lease or purchase when public knowledge regarding such consideration would cause a likelihood of increased price. Action anticipated. At 2:04PM the Board of County Commissioners reconvened out of Executive Session. Vice Chairman, Laura Osiadacz, moved to approve Chair Signature on two Trust Water Right Purchase and Sale Agreements between Kittitas County and Suncadia and to direct staff to prepare enabling documents. Commissioner Wright seconded. Motion carried 3-0. EXECUTIVE SESSION 2 At 2:05PM the Board of County Commissioners announced they would recess into Executive Session for 10 minutes with Josh Fredrickson and Chris Horner per RCW 42.30.110(1)(i)- To discuss with legal counsel representing the agency matters relating to agency enforcement actions, or to discuss with legal counsel representing the agency litigation or potential litigation to which the agency, the governing body, or a member acting in an official capacity is, or is likely to become, a party, when public knowledge regarding the discussion is likely to result in an adverse legal or financial consequence to the agency. No Action Taken. At 2:10PM the Board of County Commissioners reconvened out of Executive Session. Meeting concluded at 2:10 PM KITTITAS COUNTY COMMISSIONERS KITTITAS COUNTY, WASHINGTON Sally Kraft, Administrative Chairman Assistant 12/23/24 MINUTES KITTITAS COUNTY COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT SERVICES COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT SERVICES — BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS 2024 STUDY SESSION STAFF REPORT STUDY SESSION DATE: December 23, 2024 TOPIC: Facet NW: Critical Areas ACTION REQUESTED: None LEAD STAFF: Chad Bala, CDS Director RECOMMENDATION: None BRIEFING SUMMARY: Resolution 2024-093 authorized the Community Development Services Director contract authority over task orders for immediate need in planning support services. As part of the ongoing negotiations with the Yakama Nation and additional Kittitas County Critical Area Code discussions with Facet NW (Critical Areas Consultant) CDS will be moving forward with this task order to gather real data regarding GIS & Stream Buffer information and conduct an analysis pursuant to Best Available Science (BAS). This will be supportive information that will be utilized as part of our periodic review of the Critical Areas Code. BACKGROUND: The Periodic Update requires an additional review of the Critical Areas Code, and this information will be a supportive analysis to the Critical Areas Code update. DISCUSSION: None FISCAL IMPACTS: None ATTACHMENTS: None KITTITAS COUNTY COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT SERVICES COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT SERVICES — BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS 2024 STUDY SESSION STAFF REPORT STUDY SESSION DATE: December 23, 2024 TOPIC: Senate Bill 5290 ACTION REQUESTED: None LEAD STAFF: Chad Bala, CDS Director Jeremy Johnston, Long Range Planner RECOMMENDATION: None BRIEFING SUMMARY: This bill is intended to modernize and streamline local project review. This bill primarily focuses on changes to the development review timelines. Note: If action isn't taken by January 1, 2025, then the new state timelines will automatically apply. Senate Bill 5290 requires all jurisdictions to implement new code language requiring the following: 1. 65 days: For Administrative project decisions that do not require public notice from the deemed complete date. 2. 100 days: For Administrative project decisions that require public notice to be from the deemed complete date. 3. 170 days: ForNon-Administrative project decisions that require public notice from the deemed complete date If timelines are not met: • A jurisdiction may be required to refund 10-20% of application review fees. • After January 1, 2026, if a jurisdiction adopted at least three of the recommended permit actions per RCW 36.70B.160(1) but is not meeting its permitting deadlines at least half the time since its most recent comp. plan update will be required to adopt additional measures. BACKGROUND: The Senate Bill was passed by legislature on May 81", 2023, with an effective date of July 23, 2023, and requires an implementation date of January 1, 2025 DISCUSSION: None FISCAL IMPACTS: To Be Determined: Potential application fee adjustment and training costs ATTACHMENTS: Senate Bill 5290, White Paper, & Draft Code: HB 5290 White Paper Beginning January 1, 2025: • All GMA planning jurisdictions are required to implement HB 5290 regardless of their ability to implement local regulations in time. There are a variety of minor changes that will need to be made, however, we've compiled a list below of the major issues for which we need to be made aware; A. Permitting Timelines: New permitting timelines are separated into 3 tiers. The "shot clock" is based on the deemed complete date and timelines established must utilize calendar days, not business days. 1. For administrative project decisions that do not require public noticing, a final decision must be issued within 65 days of the deemed complete date. This will impact land use applications like parcel combinations, BLA's, etc. 2. For administrative project decisions that require public noticing, but no public hearing, decisions must be issued within 100 days of the deemed complete date. This will include projects like zoning variances, reasonable use exceptions, etc. (note: this would not include short plats even though they would generally fall into this same category. RCW 58.17.140 provides specific timelines for all preliminary plats. 3. For non -administrative projects the bill requires a decision be issued within 170 days from the deemed complete date (again this would not apply to preliminary long plats). B. Modification Allowances: 1. Modifications are allowed for these timelines for more complicated projects with consolidated permit review such as: (i.e. PUDS, Master Planned Resorts, Etc.) 2. Modifications must be specific and implemented through a local ordinance. 3. Adoption of the prescribed provisions of this bill are not subject to appeal, however any ordinance which does create these kinds of modifications are subject to appeal. C. Implementation parameters: The bill provides 2 approaches for local jurisdictions to demonstrate consistency. Option 1— Up to 20% of permitting fees are subject to refund if timelines are not met. -10% of permitting fees must be refunded if the application decision exceeds the prescribed timelines by less than 20% of the maximum allowance. Example: If the fee for a non -administrative application is $2,000 and the decision isn't issued until the 203'd day from the deemed complete date (19% beyond the 170-day allowance) the applicant would be refunded $200. -20% of permitting fees must be refunded if the application decision exceeds the prescribed timelines by 20% or more. Option 2 — HB 5290 provides ten project review and code revisions (listed below a-j) that can be adopted to avoid Option 1. This option requires formal adoption of at least 3 of these provisions. (a) Expediting review for project permit applications for projects that are consistent with adopted development regulations; (b) Imposing reasonable fees, consistent with RCW 82.02.020, on applicants for permits or other governmental approvals to cover the cost to the city, town, county, or other municipal corporation of processing applications, inspecting and reviewing plans, or preparing detailed statements required by chapter RCW. The fees imposed may not include a fee for the cost of processing administrative appeals. Nothing in this subsection limits the ability of a county or city to impose a fee for the processing of administrative appeals as otherwise authorized by law; (c) Entering into an interlocal agreement with another jurisdiction to share permitting staff and resources; (d) Maintaining and budgeting for on -call permitting assistance for when permit volumes or staffing levels change rapidly; (e) Having new positions budgeted that are contingent on increased permit revenue; (f) Adopting development regulations which only require public hearings for permit applications that are required to have a public hearing by statute; (g) Adopting development regulations which make preapplication meetings optional rather than a requirement of permit application submittal; (h) Adopting development regulations which make housing types an outright permitted use in all zones where the housing type is permitted; (i) Adopting a program to allow for outside professionals with appropriate professional licenses to certify components of applications consistent with their license; or (j) Meeting with the applicant to attempt to resolve outstanding issues during the review process. The meeting must be scheduled within 14 days of a second request for corrections during permit review. If the meeting cannot resolve the issues and a local government proceeds with a third request for additional information or corrections, the local government must approve or deny the application upon receiving the additional information or corrections. Regardless of the option a jurisdiction chooses, every jurisdiction must provide annual reports, beginning in 2026, that demonstrate if the required permit allowances are being met at least 50% of the time. If they are not being met the bill requires adoption of the measures noted above (a-j) until permitting times are consistent with the statute. Recommendation: Utilizing option 1 appears to be the path of least resistance as follows: • The County could choose to only collect 80% of the permitting fees upon application submittal. • Then require the remaining 20% upon successful permit issuance when timelines are met. Option 1 could avoid complicating financial records with various refunds when timelines are not met. This may be especially true when application submittal and issuance timelines fall within different budget cycles. Maior Component to Comply: • Possible adjustments to applications fees for this additional work requirement • SmartGov assistance/cost: Additional training to run the appropriate stop and start scenarios, and more importantly annual reports. • This bill will require close monitoring and memorializing of all start and stop events in application processing. • The "shot clock" can be stopped anytime the applicant is informed of a need for additional information. Maintaining clear records of these events will be vital for reporting. • The code will need to be updated to relay these new timelines and there are various other more minor requirements that will need to be added as well. o These include items like specific timelines and criteria for requesting information and memorializing responses as well as some items that are exempt. Kittitas County Code Title 1 SA I PROJECT PERMIT APPLICATION PROCESS* Chapters 15A.01 Administration, Purpose and Objective 15A.02 Definitions —1-5A.03 Proiect Permit Application -Review 15A.04 Integration of SEPA 15A.05 Hearings 15A.06 Notice of Decision 15A.07 Administrative Decisions Appeals 15A.08 Judicial Appeal 15A.09 Planned Actions 15A.10 Amendments 15A.11 Development Agreements 15AA2 Coordination with State Permitting 15AA 3 (Repealed) Prior legislation: Ords. 96-19 and 97-05. Chapter 15A.01 ADMINISTRATION, PURPOSE AND OBJECTIVE Sections 15A.01.010 Purpose and authority. 15A.01.020 Administrative and enforcement officers. 15A.01.030 Applicability. 15A.01.040 Roles and responsibilities. 15A.01.050 Severability. 15A.01.010 Purpose and authority. It is the purpose of this title to effectively and efficiently administer applications for land use development activities by combining environmental review process, both procedural and substantive, with the procedure for review of project permits. 1. Each local government planning under __ __ shall establish a permit review process that provides for the integrated and consolidated review and decision on two or more project permits relating to a proposed project action, including a single application review and approval process covering part of or all project permits requested by an applicant for all or part of a project action, and a designated permit coordinator. When a project permit application is filed, the project review process should include land use, environmental, public, and governmental review so that documents prepared under different requirements can be reviewed together by the public and other agencies, in one project review process. In the event of inconsistencies within county code pertaining to such processing, this title shall control. (Ord. 2000-07; Ord. 98-10, 1998) 15A.01.020 Administrative and enforcement officers. 1. It shall be the duty of the Community Development Services director or such other persons designated by the county commissioners to administer the provisions of this title. 2. The prosecuting attorney may institute any necessary legal proceedings to enforce the provisions of this title. 3. The county sheriff and his authorized representatives shall have the authority to enforce the provisions of this title. (Ord. 2007-22, 2007; Ord. 2000-07; Ord. 98-10, 1998) 15A.01.030 Applicability. The provisions of this title shall apply to all land use permits under KCC Titles 15A, , , and , county shoreline master program, and to any related regulation or any other ordinance or law implementing these provisions. In the event of conflict with the current county code, this title shall control. (Ord. 2000-07; Ord. 98-10, 1998) 15A.01.040 Roles and responsibilities. The regulation of land development is a cooperative activity including many different elected and appointed bodies and county staff. The specific responsibilities of these bodies is set forth below and outlined in at the end of this title. 1. Applicant. An applicant is expected to read and understand the county comprehensive plan and code and be prepared to fulfill the obligations placed on the applicant. Pre - application conferences are available to anyone who wishes to discuss such obligations prior to submittal. 2. Community Development Services Director. a. The Community Development Services Director (CDS Director) is responsible for the administration of portions of , Environmental Policy, Title 15A, Project Permit Application Process, Title 16, Subdivisions, Zoning, Title 17A, Critical Areas, and the shoreline master program. b. Upon request or as determined necessary, the CDS Director shall interpret the meaning or application of the provisions of said titles and issue a written administrative interpretation. Requests for interpretation shall be written and shall concisely identify the issue and desired interpretation. c. Administrative land use decisions on certain zoning conditional uses, and variances from the standards and dimensional regulations of the zoning code, _ such as setback and yard restrictions. d. The CDS Director or his/her designee shall have the authority to review and approve, deny, or approve with conditions, applications for the following: i. Letters of exemption from a shoreline substantial development permit; ii. Shoreline substantial development permits; iii. Revisions to shoreline substantial development permits; and iv. Requests for timing extensions for i through iii above. 3. Board of County Commissioners. In addition to its legislative responsibilities under K(_( i ifle I D , the board shall review and act on the following subjects pursuant to this title: a. Recommendations of the Planning Commission. Decision -making process by the board shall consist of a public meeting or meetings wherein the board reviews the written record transmitted from the Planning Commission for Legislative matters and issues a written decision in resolution or ordinance form. During such meeting(s), appropriate county staff will present the record to the board, providing information as necessary to ensure county code compliance. No new comment or information will be allowed by the board during the decision -making process. b. Appeals of site -specific rezones. c. Development Agreements. 4. Hearing Examiner - Decision. The Hearing Examiner shall review and make a final decision for the purposes of appeal under KCC section 15A.07 on the following applications and subjects pursuant to this title: a. Initial local County decision on Shoreline Conditional Use Permits subject to the Shoreline Master Program; b. Initial local County decision on Shoreline Variances pursuant to the Shoreline Master Program; c. Shoreline substantial development permits that are included in consolidated permit applications that are subject to Hearing Examiner review and action; d. Conditional use permits pursuant to the zoning code, KCC Title 17; e. Application for preliminary plats; f. Site -Specific Rezone applications; g. Appeals of administrative SEPA actions regarding an action without an underlying permit; h. Open record appeal of administrative SEPA actions; i. Appeal of administrative determinations such as short plats, variances, and code interpretations; j. Other actions requested or remanded by the Board of County Commissioners; and k. Appeal of administrative determinations regarding road standard variance decisions. S. Washington State Department of Ecology. The Washington State Department of Ecology shall be responsible for the final approval, denial, or approval with conditions for the following: a. Shoreline conditional use permits and revisions to same; and b. Shoreline variances and revisions to same. (Ord. 2022-00` , 2022; Ord,_ 2018-021, 2018; Ord. 2016-00! , 2016; Ord. 2014-008, 2014;) 15A.01.050 Severability. If any chapter, section, subsection, sentence, clause, phrase, part or portion of this title is for any reason held to be invalid or unconstitutional by any court of competent jurisdiction, such decision shall not affect the validity of the remaining portions of this title or the application of the provisions to other persons or circumstances. (Ord. 2000-07; Ord. 98-10, 1998) 0 Chapter 15A.02 DEFINITIONS Sections 15A.02.010 Generally. 15A.02.020 Administrator. 15A.02.030 Repealed. 15A.02.040 Consistency. 15A.02.045 Department 15A.02.050 Land use decision. 15A.02.06C Open record hearing. 15A.02.070 Person. 15A.02.08(l Project permit or project permit application. 15A.02.09n Public meeting. 15A.02.010 Generally. Certain terms and words used in this title are defined in the following sections. Words used in the present tense include the future; words in the singular number include the plural number; and words in the plural number include the singular number; the word "building" includes the word "structure," and the word "shall" is mandatory and not directory. (Ord. 2000-07; Ord. 98-10, 1998) 15A.02.020 Administrator. "Administrator" means the county planning director or his/her designee. (Ord. 2000-07; Ord. 98-10, 1998) 15A.02.030 Repealed. (Ord, 2012-0C , 2012; Ord. 2000-07; Ord. 98-10, 1998) 15A.02.040 Consistency. "Consistency" means, including but not limited to, compliance, conformity and consistency, and refers to performance in accordance with Kittitas County comprehensive plan and development regulations. (Ord. 2000-07; Ord. 98-10, 1998) 15A.02.045 Department. "Department" means the Community Development Services department 15A.02.050 Land use decision. "Land use decision" means a final determination by a local jurisdiction's body or officer with the highest level of authority to make the determination, including those with authority to hear appeals, on: An application for a project permit or other governmental approval required by law before real property may be improved, developed, modified, subdivided, or used, but excluding applications for permits or approvals to use, vacate, or transfer streets, parks, and similar types of public property, excluding applications for legislative approvals such as area -wide rezones and annexations, and excluding applications for business licenses; An interpretive or declaratory decision regarding the application to a specific property of zoning or other ordinance or rules regulating the improvement, development, modification, maintenance, or use of real property; and 3. The enforcement by a local jurisdiction of ordinances regulating the improvement, development, modification, maintenance, or use of real property. (Ord. 2000-07; Ord. 9810, 1998) 15A.02.060 Open record hearing. "Open record hearing" means a hearing by a single hearing body or officer, authorized by the local government to conduct such hearings, that creates the local government's record through testimony and submission of evidence and information under procedures prescribed by the local government by ordinance or resolution. (Ord. 2000-07; Ord. 98-10, 1998) 15A.02.070 Person. "Person" means an individual, partnership, corporation, association, public or private organization, or government entity or agency. (Ord. 2000-07; Ord. 98-10, 1998) 15A.02.080 Project permit or project permit application. "Project permit" or "project permit application" means any land use or environmental permit or license required from a local government for a project action, including but not limited to building permits, subdivisions, binding site plans, planned unit developments, conditional uses, shoreline substantial development permits, site plan review, permits or approvals required by critical areas ordinances, site -specific rezones authorized by a comprehensive plan or subarea plan, but excluding the adoption or amendment of a comprehensive plan, subarea plan, or development regulations. (Ord. 2000-07; Ord. 98-10, 1998) 15A.02.090 Public meeting. "Public meeting" means an informal meeting, hearing, workshop, or other public gathering of people to obtain comments from the public or other agencies on a proposed project permit prior to the local government's decision. A public meeting may include, but is not limited to, a design review or architectural control board meeting, a special review district or community council meeting, or a scoping meeting on a draft environmental impact statement. A public meeting does not include an open record hearing. The proceedings at a public meeting may be recorded and a report or recommendation may be included in the local government's project permit application file. (Ord. 2000-07; Ord. 98-10, 1998) 4 Chapter 15A.03 PROJECT PERMIT APPLICATION REVIEW Sections 15A.0�.0 i L; Complete application defined. 15A.03.020 Pre -application conference. 15A.03.030 Application and accompanying data. 15A.03.040 Determination of complete application. 15A.03.045 . Deadline extensions and supplemental information. 15A.03.050 Fee schedule. 15A.03.060 Notice of application. 15A.03.070 Specific procedures for permit review. 15A.03.080 Projects exempt from the provisions of notice of application. 15A.03.090 Review actions on project permit applications. 15A.03.100 Criteria for review of all project actions. 15A.03.110 Posting sites. 15A 03 120 Project permit categories review timelines and reporting. 15A.03.010 Complete application defined. The definition of a complete project permit application is defined in the relevant section of the zoning code, subdivision code, or, if applicable, development agreement adopted pursuant to this title. (Ord. 2000-07; Ord. 98-10, 1998) 15A.03.020 Pre -application conference. A pre -application conference is offered to all interested potential applicants. Applicants are encouraged but not required to request this conference except in the case of a Cluster Platting and Conservation Platting, Planned Unit Development, master planned resort, conditional use permit, shoreline substantial development permit, shoreline conditional use permit, shoreline variance, rezone and any preliminary plat over nine (9) lots where a pre -application conference is required. 1. Prior to formal submittal of a project permit application, one or more optional conferences with appropriate county department representatives and other public agency representatives may be requested by the applicant. The date, time and place of such conferences shall be at the mutual agreement of the participants. 2. Such conferences are intended as informal discussion and review of possible applications to assist the possible applicant in discovery of appropriate county regulations, standards, application formats and review processes that would be required of a project. 3. Such conferences are not publicized and the public is not permitted to attend in order that a potential applicant's interests be protected. 4. A pre -application conference may be waived if the CDS Director or Planning Official determines that the proposal is relatively simple (has few, if any, development -related issues), is substantially similar to a prior proposal affecting the same property, or is substantially similar to other projects developed by the same applicant. In order to request a pre -application waiver, the applicant shall submit a completed pre -application waiver request form, a written narrative justifying the request for a pre -application waiver, and the required fee. (Ord. 2016-00(., 2016; Ord. 2013-001, 2013; >jrd. 2011-0-1 , 2011; Ord. 2010-L. , 2010; Ord. 2007-22, 2007; Ord. 2007-22, 2007; Ord. 2000-07; Ord. 98-10, 1998) 15A.03.030 Application and accompanying data. 1. Written application for the approval of proposed project activities such as: zoning variance; zoning conditional use; short plat, long plat or subdivision; binding site plans; shorelines substantial development/conditional use/variance; master planned resort; and site -specific rezone shall be filed in complete form in the Community Development Services office upon forms prescribed for that purpose by the administrator. 2. The written application shall be accompanied by a site plan showing the dimensions and arrangement of the proposed development or changes including all proposed land uses and structures; points of access, roads and parking areas; septic tank and drainfield and replacement areas; areas to be cut or filled; and natural features such as contours, streams, wetlands, hazardous slopes, etc. The administrator may require other drawings, topographic surveys, photographs, or other material essential to an understanding of the proposed use and its relationship to the surrounding properties. 3. Applications for project permits shall be signed by the owner(s) of the property. 4. Appropriate fee(s) paid -in#ull. a Eighty percent of all application fees are due at the time of application submittal. The remaining twenty percent is due prior to permit issuance. In the event the Department does not issue a decision within the time limits established in KCC15A.03.120, the remainingtwenty wentypercent of the permit fees shall be reduced up to the following amounts: i Ten percent of the full permit fee if the decision was delayed no more than twenty percent of the overall processing timeline. ii Twenty percent of the full permit fee if the decision was delayed more than twenty percent of the overall processing timeline. Example A non -administrative process has a maximum processing timeline of 170 days from the date of notice of complete application If the Department processes this application and issues the decision between 171 and 203 days from the deemed complete date, the applicant's complete permit payment will be reduced by ten percent. If the Department issues a determination beyond 204 days, the applicant will receive a twenty percent reduction in the permitting fee. *This example excludes any timeline modifications established in KCC15A.03.120(4). (nr,] '�n','-r, 2014; 1-,-' `'nor 01•4, 2010; Ord. 2007-22, 2007; Ord. 2000-07; Ord. 98-10, 1998) 15A.03.040 Determination of complete application. 1. Within 28 days after receiving a project permit application, the local permitting agency shall mail or provide in person a written determination to the applicant, stating either: a. That the application is complete; or b. That the application is incomplete and what is necessary to make the application complete. An incomplete application shall expire after 180 calendar days unless the requested supplemental information is submitted in complete form. 2. To the extent known by the permitting agency, the permitting agency shall identify other agencies of local, state or federal governments that may have jurisdiction over some aspect of the application. 3. A project permit application is complete for the purposes of this title when it meets the procedural submission requirements of Kittitas County and is sufficient for continued processing even though additional information may be required or project modifications may be undertaken subsequently. The determination of completeness shall not preclude Kittitas County from requesting additional information or studies either at the time of the notice of completeness or subsequently if new information is required or substantial changes in the proposed action occur. 4. Within 14 days after an applicant has submitted to the permitting agency additional information identified by the permitting agency as being necessary for a complete application, the permitting agency shall notify the applicant whether the application is complete or what additional information is necessary. In determining the number of days that have elapsed after Kittitas County has notified the applicant that the application is complete, the following periods shall be excluded: a. Any period during which the applicant has been requested by Kittitas County to correct plans, perform required studies, or provide additional required information. The period shall be calculated from the date Kittitas County notifies the applicant of the need for the additional information until the earlier of the date Kittitas County determined whether the additional information satisfies the request for information or 14 days after the date the information has been provided to Kittitas County. i. If Kittitas County determines that the additional information submitted by the applicant is insufficient, it shall notify the applicant of the continued deficiencies and the procedures under subsection (4)(a) of this section shall apply as if a new request for studies has been made. b. Any period during which an environmental impact statement is being prepared following a determination of significance pursuant to Chapter __ ____ _, if Kittitas County and the applicant in writing agree to a time period for completion of an environmental impact statement. c. Any period of administrative appeals of project permits, if an open record hearing or a closed record appeal, or both, are allowed. The time period to consider and decide such appeals shall not exceed: i. Ninety days for an open record appeal hearing; ii. Sixty days for a closed record appeal; and iii. The parties to an appeal may agree to extend these time periods. d. Any extension of time mutually agreed upon by the applicant and Kittitas County. e. These time limits do not apply to a project permit application, if the project: i. Requires an amendment to the comprehensive plan or a development regulation; ii. Requires approval of a new fully contained community as provided in ',CW 36.70A.350, a master planned resort as provided in 'CW 36.70A.360, or the siting of an essential public facility as provided in ",CW 36.70A.200; iii. Is substantially revised by the applicant, in which case the time period shall start from the date at which the revised project application is determined to be complete. f. If Kittitas County is unable to issue its final decision within the time limits provided, it shall provide written notice of this fact to the applicant. The notice shall include a statement of reasons why the time limits have not been met and an estimated date of issuance of the notice of final decision. g. Applications shall be void if they remain incomplete for more than 180 days. h. This section shall apply to project permit applications filed on or after the date of adoption of this title. (Ord. 2014-015, 2014; Ord. 2000-07; Ord. 9810, 1998) 15A.03.045 Deadline extensions and supplemental information. . 1. Once an application has been deemed complete, the Director may request the applicant to submit additional corrections, studies or other information on the proposed project. The Director shall set a reasonable deadline for the submittal of corrections, studies or other information when requested, and shall provide written notification of such requests to the applicant. 2. Failure by the applicant to meet such deadline shall be cause for the application to be void. However, an extension of such deadline may be requested by an applicant if the request is made prior to the expiration of the deadline. Extension requests shall be submitted in writing, include a justification of why an extension is warranted. 3. When considering a request for a deadline extension, the Director shall give consideration to the code provisions to which the project is vested, if any. In order to assure equity in permit processing between past, current, and future applicants, deadline extensions shall be limited to one extension after code provisions affecting the project have changed. Once code provisions have changed as to make the vested code substantially different than current code, a requested deadline extension of up to six months may be granted, but it shall be the final extension granted. The Director shall determine whether code changes have created substantially different regulations. 4. The Director shall provide a written, mailed response to the applicant with its decision on each extension request. (Ord. 2018-021, 2018; :)rd. 2013-001, 2013; Ord. 2010-014 , 2010) 15A.03.050 Fee schedule. The fees for application related to this title shall be established by resolution and are referenced within of the Kittitas County Code. 2017; Ord. 2007-22, 2007; Ord. 2000-07; Ord. 98-10, 1998) 15A.03.060 Notice of application. Kittitas County shall provide a notice of application to the public and the departments and agencies with jurisdiction. If Kittitas County has made a SEPA determination of significance under Chapter 43.21 C RCW concurrently with the notice of application, the notice of application shall be combined with the determination of significance and scoping notice. Nothing in this subsection prevents a determination of significance and scoping notice from being issued prior to a notice of application. 1. The notice of application shall be provided within 14 days after the determination of completeness in the following method: a. Publishing notice, including at least the project location in other than a legal description, brief description of project, type of permit(s) required, comment period dates, and location where the complete application may be reviewed in the newspaper of general circulation in the general area where the proposal is located or in a local land use newsletter published by Kittitas County. Additional legal notice may be published for development applications located in the upper county in newspapers published at least weekly, in addition to the legal publishing requirement in the official county paper of record. b. Notifying public or private groups with known interest in a certain proposal or in the type of proposal being considered. c. Mailing to adjacent landowners. Adjacent landowners are the owners of real property, as shown by the records of the county assessor, located within 500 feet of any portion of the boundary of the proposal's tax parcel or lot of record (real property). If the owner of the real property which is proposed for activity owns another parcel or parcels of real property which lie adjacent to the real property proposed for activity, notice shall be given to owners of real property located within 500 feet of any portion of the boundaries of such adjacently located parcels of real property owned by the owner of the real property proposed for activity. Mailed notice for Solar Power Production Facilities shall be provided in accordance with KCC 1.61 C.080(21. d. Notifying the news media. e. Posting notice via the Kittitas County Website. f. Posting the site as outlined in m-L ii iu. 2. The notice of application shall include the following: a. The date of initial application, the date of the notice of completion for the application, and the date of the notice of application. b. A description of the proposed project action and a list of the project permits included in the application and, if applicable, a list of any additional studies requested to complete the application. c. The identification of other permits not included in the application to the extent known by Kittitas County. d. The identification of existing environmental documents that evaluate the proposed project. e. The location where the application and any studies can be reviewed. f. A statement of the public comment period, which shall be not less than 14 nor more than 30 days following the date of the notice of application. This comment period shall be pursuant to rable.A at the end of this title. g. Statement of the right of any person to comment on the application, receive notice of and participate in any hearings, request a copy of the decision once made, and any appeal rights. h. Kittitas County will accept public comments at any time prior to the closing of the public comment period of the specific application. i. The date, time, place and type of hearing, if applicable and scheduled at the date of notice of the application. j. A statement of the preliminary determination, if one has been made at the time of notice, of those development regulations that will be used for project mitigation and of consistency. k. Identify the designated permit coordinator. I. Any other information determined appropriate by Kittitas County. If the administrator has a reasonable basis for determining significant adverse environmental impacts are unlikely (pursuant to Chapter 15.04 KCC, SEPA Regulations) for a proposal, the notice of application comment period will suffice for purposes of compliance with Chapter 197-11 WAC, and a second comment period after issuance of the SEPA threshold determination will not be required; provided, the notice of application includes the following: a. A statement indicating that the county expects to issue a DNS for the proposal; and b. A statement indicating that the optional DNS process is being used, and that this may be the only opportunity to comment on the environmental impacts of the proposal; and c. A statement indicating that the proposal may include mitigation measures under applicable codes, and the project review process may incorporate or require mitigation measures regardless of whether an EIS is prepared; and d. A statement indicating that a copy of the subsequent threshold determination for the specific proposal may be obtained upon request. 4. A notice of application shall not be required for project permits that are categorically exempt under Chapter 43.21 C RCS%, (SEPA), unless a public comment period is required or for projects identified in <CC 15A.0. Projects exempt from the provisions of notice of application. (Ord. 2018-018, 2018; Ord. 2007-22, 2007; Ord. 2000-07, 2000; Ord. 98-10, 1998) 15A.03.070 Specific procedures for permit review. The specific procedures for individual permit applications and independent administrative actions, including public comment period, public hearing, decision -making body, and appeals, are established pursuant to I at the end of this title. (Ord. 2000-07; Ord. 98-10, 1998) 15A.03.080 Projects exempt from the provisions of notice of application. The following project proposals and land use actions shall be exempt from the provisions of notification when not associated with a larger, overall project. These projects allow an abbreviated application format and do not involve public review or hearing unless appeal to an administrative determination involving the underlying project is properly filed: 1. An act of subdivision not required to be accomplished by long plat, large lot subdivision short plat, or binding site plan; 2. Land use activity permitted without benefit of conditional use approval (administrative or quasi judicial), as listed in Zoning; 3. Minor amendments or modifications to approved developments or permits. Minor amendments are those which may affect the precise dimensions or locations of buildings, accessory structures and driveways, but do not affect the overall project character, increase the number of lots, dwelling units, or density, or decrease the quality or amount of open space; 4. Building and associated construction permits, including but not limited to mechanical, plumbing, tank and manufactured home placement, etc.; 5. Sign permit; 6. Flood development permit; 7. Critical areas binding determination; 8. Septic and associated health permits, including vault privy, pool and food handler, etc.; 9. Well and/or community water system permit; 10. Approval to access onto county road; 11. Acts of right-of-way vacation; 12. Miscellaneous county actions related to use of public areas or facilities; 13. Those actions categorically exempt from SEPA review, pursuant to Chapter 15.04 KCC, except as may be required by KCC 15A.03.060(D); 14. Those actions exempt from shoreline substantial development permitting process as set forth in WAC 173-27-040(2) and RCW 90.58.030. (Ord. 2016-006, 2016; Ord. 2014-01 S, 2014; Ord. 2007-22, 2007; Ord. 2000-07; Ord. 98-10, 1998) 15A.03.090 Review actions on project permit applications. Project review shall include the following steps: 1. A notice of determination of completeness to the applicant. 2. A notice of application to the public and agencies with jurisdiction. 3. No more than one consolidated open record hearing and no more than one closed record appeal. 4. Provisions may be allowed by the local jurisdiction for any public meeting or required open record hearing that may be held on the project by another local, state, regional, federal, or other agency, in accordance with provisions of Chapter 36.7013 RCW. 5. A single report by a representative of the administrator, stating all the decisions made as of the date of the report on all project permits included in the consolidated permit process. The report shall state any mitigation required or proposed under the development regulations or the agency's authority under The report may be the local permit. If a threshold determination other than a determination of significance has not been issued by Kittitas County, the report shall include or append this determination. 6. A notice of decision. 7. Except as otherwise provided for in this title, Kittitas County shall issue its notice of final decision on a project permit application in accordance with KCC 15A.03.120. within 20 days a4eF Kittitas CeLinty notifies the app"Eant that the applicatien ;5 EerAp! (Ord. 2000-07; Ord. 98-10, 1998) 15A.03.100 Criteria for review of all project actions. Project review should start from the fundamental land use planning choices made in local comprehensive plans and regulations, include review of consistency and land use impacts. 1. Applicable comprehensive plans and regulations that identify the type of land use for the site, specify density, and identify and provide for funding of public facilities needed to serve the proposed development and site should be the standard for project review. Consistency should be determined in the project review process by considering four factors found in applicable plans or regulations: a. The type of land use permitted at the site, including uses that may be allowed under certain circumstances, such as planned unit developments and conditional uses, if the criteria for their approval have been satisfied; b. The level of development allowed, such as units per acre or other measures of density; c. Infrastructure, such as the adequacy of public facilities and services identified in the comprehensive plan, to serve the proposed project; and d. The character of the proposed development, such as compliance with specific development standards. 2. In determining consistency, the determinations made pursuant to this title shall be controlling. 3. Project review should not require additional studies or mitigation under Chapter (SEPA) where existing regulations have adequately addressed a proposed project's probable specific adverse environmental impacts. 4. Supplemental authority as specified by Chapter 43.21 C RCW should be used to the extent that existing requirements do not adequately address a project's specific probable adverse environmental impacts. 5. Nothing in this title limits the authority of a permitting agency to approve, condition, or deny a project as provided in its development regulations adopted under Kittitas County comprehensive plan and development regulations and its policies adopted under Project review shall be used to identify specific project design and conditions relating to the character of the development, such as details of site plans, curb cuts, drainage swales, transportation demand management, or other measures to mitigate a proposal's probable adverse environmental impacts, if applicable. 6. Consistency between the proposed project and applicable regulations or plan should be determined through a project review process that integrates land use and environmental impact analysis, so that governmental and public review of the proposed project, involving development regulations under Chapter �6./OA RCVV and environmental process under Chapter _ __ run concurrently and not separately. 7. During project review, Kittitas County or any subsequent reviewing body shall not reexamine alternatives to or hear appeals on the items identified in such Kittitas County comprehensive plan and development regulation standards, except for issues of code interpretation. 8. When holding a hearing on a project permit application, the hearing body should utilize the following issues outlined as a review guide: earth, air, water (including irrigation water and its conveyances), plants, animals, energy and natural resources, environmental health, land and shoreline use, housing, aesthetics, light and glare, recreation, historic and cultural preservation, transportation, public services, and utilities. (Ord. 2000-07; Ord. 9810, 1998) 15A.03.110 Posting site. 1. These provisions shall apply to all development applications, except for development applications processed administratively. 2. The applicant shall post the subject property with signs as required by Community Development Services. 3. Signs shall be posted on each road frontage on the subject property and shall be clearly visible and accessible. 4. Signs shall be posted and on -site prior to issuance of a Notice of Application. 5. The sign shall be a minimum 2 feet by 3 feet and laminated and posted in a sturdy manner to remain on -site until after the expiration of the notice of decision appeal period. It shall be the responsibility of the applicant to properly dispose of the sign. 6. At the time of development application, Community Development Services will identify the number of signs needed and the general location of each sign on the subject property. 7. It shall be the responsibility of the applicant to place the structure in which the sign will be posted on -site. At such time the structure and sign is in place, the applicant shall return the signed affidavit of posting form to Community Development Services. (Ord. 2014-01 E, 2014; Ord. 2007-22, 2007) 15A 03 120 Project permit categories review timelines and reporting. 1. Administrative permits. a. Administrative permits include those land use applications that do not require public notice or a public hearing. b. Decisions on administrative application shall be made within 30 days of the deemed complete date For administrative applications that do not require a deem complete step, a decision shall be issued within 65 days of the submittal date. These timelines can be modified when any of the criteria of KCC15A.03.120(4) are met. 2. Administrative permits with public notice requirement. a. When an administrative permit requires public notice a decision shall be issued within 100 days from the deemed complete date. b. Preliminary short plat applications shall follow the determination schedule outlined in RCW 58.17. 3. Non -administrative permits. a. A non -administrative permit is a permit that requires public notice and an open record public hearing. b. Decisions on non -administrative permits shall be issued within 170 days from the deemed complete date. c. Preliminaryplat implications shall follow the determination schedule outlined in RCW 58.17. 4. Exceptions. a. The permit timelines established in KCC15A.03.120 do not include: i Circumstances in which an applicant and the Department agree in writing upon an extension to the processing timeline ii Any time in which the Department is waiting on the applicant to submit information necessary for application processing which has been requested by the Department in writing. iii Multiple application for the same project processed concurrently shall adhere to the longest decision schedule permit category involved. iv. The timelines established in 15A.03.120 shall not apply to Development Agreements Planned Unit Developments Master Planned Resorts, Land Development Code amendments and Comprehensive Plan amendment applications. S. Any written notice from the Department requesting additional information shall include a notice that non -responsiveness for 60 consecutive days may result in 30 days being added to the time for review. Non -responsiveness means that the applicant is not making demonstrable progress on providing additional requested information to the Department or that there is no ongoing communication from the applicant to the Department on the applicant's ability or willingness to provide the additional information. 6. Permit processing timeline reporting The county shall prepare an annual performance report consistent with the requirements of RCW 36 70B 080 These reports shall be provided to the Washington State Department of Commerce and published on the County website no later than March 1 of each year to reflect the previous year's reporting data.Disclaimer: This web site is provided for informational purposes only. Although every effort has been made to provide accuracy, all information and resources shown are not official. Neither Kittitas County nor any of its agencies, officials or employees guarantees the accuracy of any information on this web site. Reliance upon the information contained on or accessed through this web site is entirely at your own risk. Kittitas County reserves the right to make changes without notice. KITTITAS COUNTY DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC WORKS PUBLIC WORKS — BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS STUDY SESSION STAFF REPORT STUDY SESSION DATE: December 23, 2024 TOPIC: G4-29290 Water Right Permit Assignment ACTION REQUESTED: Direction to Staff LEAD STAFF: Arden Thomas RECOMMENDATION: Direct staff to sign and submit letter to the Department of Ecology. BRIEFING SUMMARY: • A Vantage Area water right holder is interested in assigning their water right permit application G4-29290 to Kittitas County. • The proposed assignment would expand the County's mitigation program to Vantage. • Assigning application G4-29290 to Kittitas County would maintain and provide water mitigation options in Vantage. • Costs associated with the proposed assignment would be covered by the 403 Fund (Water Resources) until they could be covered by fees charged to water users. • The next step to advance this request for assignment is to submit a formal request for Technical Assistance to the Department of Ecology BACKGROUND: Joyce Palelek has a groundwater right, certificate 4042-A, for domestic supply in the town of Vantage. In 1987 Ms. Palelek submitted application G4-29290 requesting a change to domestic supply, future high density development supply, irrigation, and stock water use. Kittitas County staff and representatives for Ms. Palelek have met with the Department of Ecology to discuss potentially assigning application G4-29290 from Ms. Palelek to Kittitas County, amending the place of use of the application, amending the location of proposed wells, and retaining the multiple purposes previously applied for. The next step to advance this request is for Kittitas County and Ms. Palelek to submit a formal request for Technical Assistance on Assignment of Application G4-29290 to the Department of Ecology. The proposed partnership between Kittitas County and Ms. Palelek would enable the groundwater permit application to be processed and would maintain and provide water mitigation options within Vantage. Page 1 of 3 Public Works "Work Session Staff Report", 2024 DISCUSSION: The proposed assignment would expand the County's mitigation program to the Vantage Area. There is only one municipal water provider in this area. The County's existing water bank has demonstrated the broader community benefits associated with the County's entry into the water mitigation arena. FISCAL IMPACTS: Kittitas County would enter into a mitigation agreement with Ecology to utilize the Lake Roosevelt Incremental Release Program and there is an associated annual fee. This annual fee (estimated in the $17,000 - $30,000 range) would initially be absorbed in the 403 Fund (Water Resources) and water user fees would be developed to cover these costs. We will budget for these costs in 2026. A budget amendment may be needed for 2025. ATTACHMENTS: Exhibit 1: Draft Technical Assistance on Assignment of Application G4-29290 Letter Page 2 of 3 Public Works "Work Session Staff Report", 2024 EXHIBIT 1: Draft Technical Assistance on Assignment of Application G4-29290 Letter Page 3 of 3 Public Works "Work Session Staff Report", 2024 December 23, 2024 Tom Tebb, Director Office of Columbia River (OCR) 1250 West Alder Street Union Gap, WA 98903 Re: Technical Assistance on Assignment of Application G4-29290 Dear Tom: We are following up on our technical assistance meeting with additional detail on Kittitas County's proposal to submit an assignment of the subject application from Applicant Joyce Palelek to Kittitas County. Prior to our formal submittal, we wanted to send this letter and ensure you have all the relevant information you need to process this assignment request to an approval. Concurrent with the assignment, we will be requesting an amended place of use of the proposed application to ensure Kittitas County can provide reliable service in this area of the County where we do not currently have mitigation assets. ' As you are aware, Kittitas County has a county -wide goal to ensure that the public has reliable access to minimum quantities of water for public health and safety needs. Additionally, there have been times and locations where the County has believed the private sector has monopolized access to mitigation supplies necessary to mitigate for both Total Water Supply Availability (TWSA) and local senior water right holders. In those instances, the entry of the County into the mitigation market has served the public interest by ensuring that the public has access to multiple options to meet their development needs. This letter outlines our request, the procedural lens we understanding Ecology will evaluate our request through, and the substantive public interest merits of our request. Joint County and Applicant Request Our specific requests are: 1. Assign Application G4-29290 from Joyce Palelek to Kittitas County 2. Amend the place of use of Application G4-29290 as shown on Figure 1 below: a. from the SE % NE % and the E%2 SE'/ of Section 30 b. to contiguous land inclusive of the E %2 of Section 30, Section 19, and the SE of Section 18 3. Amend the location of two wells proposed for Section 30 to match the place of use as the obstacle of I90 will necessitate having sources on each side of the freeway 4. Retain the existing multiple purposes applied for, inclusive of domestic supply, future high density development supply, irrigation, and stockwater purposes Office of Columbia River December 7, 2024 Figure 1: Existing Place of Use (red outline in Section 30) and Proposed Place of Use (yellow) Procedural Framework for Request Our first request involves an assignment of the application from Joyce Palelek to Kittitas County and we are in the process of preparing that on Ecology's required form. Based on our review of the form, the statutory reference to RCW 90.03.310 (below), and Ecology's policy guidance in PRO 1000 (also below), this appears to be largely an exercise in ensuring that Ecology's contact information on the application remains current. Absent additional technical assistance, we will simply submit the form as required. RCW 90.03.310 Appropriation procedure —Assignability of permit or application. Any permit to appropriate water may be assigned subject to the conditions of the permit, but no such assignment shall be binding or valid unless filed for record with the department. Any application for permits to appropriate water prior to permit issuing, may be assigned by the applicant, but no such assignment shall be valid or binding unless the written consent of the department is first obtained thereto, and unless such assignment is filed for record with the department. Page 2 Office of Columbia River December 7, 2024 PRO 1000 (Page 8) IV. ASSIGNMENT OF APPLICATIONS An application may be assigned to another person or persons by the applicant, upon written consent of the department, using Ecology's Assignment of Application or Permit to Appropriate or Store Water form. No such assignment(s) shall be binding unless properly filed with Ecology along with the appropriate fee (RCW 90.03,310). Assignments are noted on either the application or permit. Assignment is not required when an applicant or permit holder changes his/her name (e.g, due to marriage, divorce, or corporate name change). In these cases, a memorandum to the file is made and a ministerial amendment is made to the document. Our second request is the place of use and point of withdrawal amendment. Ecology adopted WAC 508-12 governing the Administration of Surface and Groundwater Codes, which outlines the process for such amendments. Our goal in this section is to demonstrate that our amendment can be successfully processed by Ecology concurrent with our assignment request. WAC 508-12-190(1) describes the process for amending place of use and point of diversion for surface applications, and WAC 508-12-220 extends this same process to groundwater applications (see below, including relevant underlined section). WAC 508-12-190(1) Surface water appropriation procedure —Amendments as to source, quantity, etc. (1) In the event an applicant or permittee should desire to amend the terms of his application or permit regarding source, quantity, point of diversion, purpose, or place of use, the procedure shall be as outlined in RCW 90.03.380 excepting that no certificate of change will issue but the amendments shall be incorporated in the terms of the permit. WAC 508-12-220 Groundwater appropriation procedure —Applicability of foregoing rules. The general application of rules numbered WAC 508-12-080 through 508-12-210 inclusive on surface water applications, shall also apply to the groundwater appropriation procedure. The rule requires the same analysis as that completed in RCW 90.03.380. The standard of review is a finding of no impairment (see underlined sections below). RCW 90.03.380 (1) The right to the use of water which has been applied to a beneficial use in the state shall be and remain appurtenant to the land or place upon which the same is used: PROVIDED, HOWEVER, That the right may be transferred to another or to others and become appurtenant to any other land or place of use without loss of priority of right theretofore established if such change can be made without detriment or injury to existingrights. ights. The Page 3 Office of Columbia River December 7, 2024 point of diversion of water for beneficial use or the purpose of use may be changed, if such change can be made without detriment or injury to existing rights. When considering impaired parties, only existing water rights are appropriate to consider because applicants are not entitled to such protection under RCW 90.03.580(5)(a). RCW 90.03.380(5)(a) Pending applications for new water rights are not entitled to protection from impairment, injury, or detriment when an application relating to an existing surface or ground water right is considered. In this case, the application will be fully mitigated under the Lake Roosevelt Incremental Release Program, the County is prepared to accept the mitigation agreement with OCR to maintain this mitigation in perpetuity, and no existing water right can be impaired by the modification of the place of use. Additionally, the County will ensure that any well drilled to supply water under the application will be located at sufficient distances to avoid well interference. This can be documented in the findings of the Report of Examination. We believe our amendment request can be successfully processed and welcome Ecology's final technical assistance before we submit a letter request with our assignment form requesting concurrent amendment of the application. Public Interest is Served We note that an important difference between the surface and groundwater change statutes is the lack of any public interest evaluation. This finding was confirmed by the Supreme Court in the PUD District No. I of Pend Oreille v. Ecology (aka Sullivan Creek, 2002) decision. Because WAC 508-12-190(1) directs Ecology to make findings as required in RCW 90.03.380 only, there should be no public interest evaluation of the County's request. Nonetheless, we believe our application is in the public interest and offer the following additional points in support of our application. • The County is better suited to plan and facilitate service to developments in this area. The County has planning responsibilities under the Growth Management Act, and has a water code it implements to ensure reliable service. • Having access to mitigation from the County's mitigation program ensures that other service providers are acting in consistent manner with regard to public service. • The proposed place of use is subsumed within and contiguous with original requested place of use and it is not being transferred to a different project removed from the original place of use. • We note that the applicant believed that the 2002 Settlement Agreement with Ecology that references the unincorporated Town of Vantage as the service area for related Certificate 4042-A was also intended to apply to this pending application. In retrospect, an application amendment should have been sought at that time, but this request ensures the applicant's original intent is satisfied. • The County's stewardship of this application ensures that it will be used in a non - speculative manner. • During the Report of Examination process, the County will submit growth density and population projection information sufficient to support beneficial use under this permit. We Page 4 Office of Columbia River December 7, 2024 note that the application references irrigation of up to 85 acres as well as future high density development supply. This speaks to the phased nature of the development where initial use by irrigation would be phased out as "future" development occurs. Because irrigation is typically the most water intensive use of water on the land, starting with the irrigation quantities on which to base the 600 gpm instantaneous request was reasonable, and any future development could be subsumed within those quantities. The place of use in our amendment was selected after considering: o The place of use noted in the original application materials. o The complexity associated with serving unincorporated areas of the Town of Vantage that straddles both sides of I90. o County GIS maps showing the local water district boundary. We note that a portion of this application could serve this same area, or could provide complementary service in the vicinity. o The local County boundary for areas designed for Limited Ares of More Intense Rural Development. o Local terrain and developable lots. o Local zoning and public/private land use designations. Based on all these criteria, the County's proposal reasonably includes the developable areas in and around the unincorporated Town of Vantage, including the original place of use. With an acknowledgement from Ecology that you have sufficient information to render a decision on our request, the County and the Applicant are prepared to immediately file the required forms and assist Ecology in processing the application and associated water service contract. Please feel free to contact us at your earliest convenience if you need any additional information. Sincerely, Arden Thomas Water Resource Manager Kittitas County Public Works Joyce Palelek Applicant G4-29290 Page 5 KITTITAS COUNTY DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC WORKS PUBLIC WORKS — BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS STUDY SESSION STAFF REPORT STUDY SESSION DATE: December 23, 2024 TOPIC: Broadband Planning Update ACTION REQUESTED: None Required LEAD STAFF: Joshua Fredrickson RECOMMENDATION: No action required. BRIEFING SUMMARY: • Two grants have been awarded to Kittitas County for broadband expansion • Plan development for the Thorp and Edgemont areas is underway • Contract is being developed for the second project award • A third grant source is available to the County through the National Telecommunications and Information Administration Broadband Equity Access and Deployment Program (BEAD) • Applications due January 31, 2025 BACKGROUND: Kittitas County has been awarded two grants to help expand broadband (high speed internet) in the County. Funding includes a grant through the Public Works Board (PWB) and another through the Washington State Broadband Office (WSBO). Additional funding for broadband expansion is available through the National Telecommunications and Information Administration (NTIA) Broadband Equity Access and Deployment (BEAD) Program. Public Works has been working with the County's broadband consultant for development of broadband expansion phases. DISCUSSION: Project funding to expand broadband service to rural portions of the county is available through the Public Works Board, Washington State Broadband Office and the NTIA. Funding has been secured through two sources and being sought through the third. The project funded through PWB will expand broadband service to areas of Thorp and Edgemont. Design and permitting is underway for this project area. Expansion of broadband in the Thorp and Edgemont area is anticipated to provide broadband service to over 550 locations. The project funded through WSBO is currently going through contract development. An RFQ was circulated and received one submittal from a qualified provider, Lightcurve. This is the same company working on the PWB project. This project continues to expand broadband service in rural areas of the county, anticipating serving over 700 locations. In November a Notice of Funding Opportunity (NOFO) was posted by the NTIA for the BEAD project. Seven project areas have been identified and set up by the State Broadband Office. Each project area requires a separate BEAD application. Originally it appeared only four project areas might be viable. Currently we anticipate an application for each of the seven project areas. BEAD application submittals are robust, including the requirement for a full network design and financial bonds supporting the design and construction. These items are being developed by the providers with Public Works input. Funding match amount is anticipated through the State of Washington. Applications are due January 31, 2025. Working with our broadband consultant and providers it is anticipated that an application will be submitted for each of the project areas. FISCAL IMPACT: Grant funding has been awarded through PWB and WSBO, additional funding will be requested through BEAD applications. ATTACHMENTS: None