Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAbout2024-07-22-minutes-public-works-&-cds-study-sessionKITTITAS COUNTY COMMISSIONERS Public Works & CDS Study Session Regular Meeting Monday July 22, 2024 -1:30 PM BoCC Auditorium 205 West 5th Room 109 - Ellensburg 1. Call to Order 2. Citizen Comments (1 min. time limit) 3. Community Development Services a. Request to Approve a Resolution Supporting the Proposed Scope of Work and Budget Request Required for the Washington State Department of Commerce 2026 Periodic Update Grant Application b. Request to Approve a Resolution Supporting the Proposed Climate and Resiliency Scope of Work and Budget Request for the 2026 Periodic Review and Update to the Kittitas County Comprehensive Plan c. Comprehensive Plan Docket 4. Public Works a. Request to Approve a Resolution for a Permanent Single -Year Levy Lid Lift Supporting Roads b. Speed Study Request Criteria c. Charlton Road Speed Study Results d. 1-90 Feasibility Study 5.Other Business - No Action to be taken 6. Concluded Created on 7/18/2024 12:30:42 PM KITTITAS COUNTY PUBLIC WORKS/COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT SERVICES STUDY SESSION MINUTES COMMISSIONERS' AUDITORIUM, 205 WEST 5TH ROOM 109 Regular Meeting MONDAY 1:30 PM July 22, 2024 Board members present: Chairman Brett Wachsmith, Vice -Chairman Laura Osiadacz, and Commissioner Cory Wright. Others: Josh Fredrickson, Cameron Curtis, Reid Burbank, Rebecca Cruse, Public Works; Chad Bala, Jamey Ayling, Jessica Miller, Community Development Services; Stephanie Hartung, Prosecuting Attorney's Office; Dan Ireland, consultant with SCJ Alliance; 3 members of the public. At 1:31 PM Chairman Brett Wachsmith opened the Public Works and Community Development Services Study Session. Citizen Comments Mike Pearson, Kittitas County resident, commented on floodplain and wetland designation at his property and believed the maps to be bad science used for leverage to support fish habitat projects. REQUEST TO APPROVE A RESOLUTION SUPPORTING THE PROPOSED SCOPE OF WORK AND BUDGET REQUEST REQUIRED FOR WASHINGTON STATE DEPARTMENT OF COMMERCE 2026 PERODIC UPDATE GRANT APPLICATION Chad Bala requested the Board of County Commissioners consider Resolution 2024-131 and Resolution 2024-132 to support Community Development Services efforts to move forward with online applications. Chad Bala state he compiled the scope of work and review was conducted by the consultant. Vice -Chair Laura Osiadacz move to approve Resolution 2024-131 and 2024-132, Commissioner Cory Wright seconded the motion. Motion passed. REQUEST TO APPROVE A RESOLUTION SUPPORTING THE PROPOSED CLIMATE AND RESILIENCY SCOPE OF WORK AND BUDGET REQUEST FOR THE 2026 PERIODIC REVIEW AND UPDATE TO THE KITTITAS COUNTY COMPREHENSIVE PLAN Resolution 2024-131 and 2024-132 approved jointly at previous item of business. COMPREHENSIVE PLAN DOCKET Chad Bala briefed the Board of County Commissioners on the Annual Comprehensive Plan docket and detailed the itemized list of requests and recommendations. Chad Bala requested the Board of County Commissioners support the staff and committee recommendations. The 2024-7-22 MINUTES Board of County Commissioners support moving forward with recommendations as presented. REQUEST TO APPROVE A RESOLUTION FOR A PERMENANT SINGLE -YEAR LEVY LID LIFT SUPPORTING ROADS Josh Fredrickson briefed the Board of County Commissioners on the Road Levy Lid Lift and infrastructure funding sources for Kittitas County and stated the 10-year plan didn't anticipate rate increases or the cost Public Works has incurred due to inflation. Josh Fredrickson requested the Board of County Commissioners consider placing the proposed Road Fund Levy Lid Lift on the November 2024 general election and stated this approval would enable Public Works or the Auditors office to begin formation of pro -con committee. Vice - Chair Laura Osiadacz moved to approve presenting this decision to voters. Cory seconded the motion. Motion approved. I-90 FEASIBILITY STUDY Josh Fredrickson briefed the Board of County Commissioners on concerns that have been brought up for years about the impact of I-90 traffic on Upper Kittitas County roads and efforts that have been tried to alleviate weekend and holiday traffic. Josh Fredrickson introduced Dan Ireland with SCJ Alliance who made a presentation of the feasibility report that looked at alternatives to help address the current traffic issues. Dan Ireland shared the objectives for I- 90 study area from exit 70 to exit 85 and the topics studied along with the presentation. Josh Fredrickson expressed appreciation for those assisting with this study and WSDOT for their involvement. The Board of County Commissioners acknowledged all those involved and agreed that the traffic issue isn't going away anytime soon. SPEED STUDY REQUEST CRITERIA Cameron Curtis gave history on speed requests received by Public Works and stated in 10 years Public Works has had 62 requests, approximately 11 have resulted in a change and each is estimated to cost the maintenance crew alone $500 each, and that doesn't include extensive time to processing the request in office. Cameron Curtis presented the proposed changes to the process to meet criteria, a scoring sheet, and described each element of importance. CHARLTON ROAD SPEED STUDY RESULTS Cameron Curtis briefed the Board of County Commissioners on a request to reduce speed on Charlton Road from same resident as requested in 2022 and presented the findings of the most recent speed study performed in June 2024 with no recorded accidents. Based on the data collected and the findings presented, the Board of County Commissioners denied the request for a public hearing. Josh Frederickson stated Staff did utilize the request criteria as an exercise if it would align with the outcome. 2024-7-22 MINUTES Meeting concluded at 2:46 PM KITTITAS COUNTY COMMISSIONERS KITTITAS COUNTY, WASHINGTON f Rebe ca Cruse, Administrative Brett Wachsmith, Chairman Assistant 2024-7-22 MINUTES KITTITAS COUNTY COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT SERVICES 2024 STUDY STAFF REPORT STUDY SESSION DATE: July 22°d, 2024 ACTION REQUESTED: Request to Approve a Resolution supporting the proposed scope of work and budget request required for the Washington State Department of Commerce 2026 periodic update grant application. BACKGROUND: Kittitas County received a letter from WA ST Dept. of Commerce confirming that a 350,000.00 grant is available for Kittitas County to assist in the 2026 Comprehensive Plan Periodic Update. As part of the WA ST Dept. of Commerce's grant application, it is required that a supportive document be provided from the jurisdiction to complete the grant application. INTERACTION: CDS. RECOMMENDATION: Approve the Resolution supporting the proposed scope of work and budget request required by the WA. ST. Dept. of Commerce's Periodic Update Grant application. HANDLING: Return one original to Community Development Services. ATTACHMENTS: Resolution. LEAD STAFF: Chad Bala, Director. BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS COUNTY OF KITTITAS STATE OF WASHINGTON RESOLUTION NO. 2024-� AUTHORIZING THE SUPPORT OF KITTITAS COUNTY'S WASHINGTON STATE DEPARTMENT OF COMMERCE 2026 PERIODIC UPDATE GRANT APPLICATION WHEREAS: Kittitas County is required to update its Comprehensive Plan Periodic Update by 2026 per the Growth Management Act (GMA) RCW 36.70A.; and WHEREAS: Washington State Department of Commerce has informed Kittitas County that Three hundred and fifty thousand dollars ($350,000.00) has been reserved and appropriated by the Legislator for Kittitas County; and WHEREAS: Kittitas County will be issued a Periodic Update Grant (PUG) through the Washington State Department of Commerce; and WHEREAS: Three hundred and fifty thousand dollars ($350,000.00) grant funding are appropriated by the legislator following the biennial budget with one-half ($175,000.00) of the GMA update grant funding available beginning July 1, 2024, to June 30, 2025, and the second half ($175,000.00) of funding available beginning July 1, 2025 to June 30, 2026; and NOW THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED that the Board of County Commissioners of Kittitas County, Washington, in the best interest of the public, does hereby support Kittitas County's Washington State Department of Commerce periodic update grant application and scope of work to facilitate Kittitas County in the periodic review and update necessary to meet the requirements of the Growth Management Act. DATED this 7)- day of July 2024, at Ellensburg, Washington. � C.0 i1117jj' � Att�st;1L p1�C�l�rlc oard- Julie Kjorsvik M-Kep_`uty Clerk of the Board- Mandy Buchholz J4� BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS KITTITAS COUNTY, INGT Brett ach i airman STATE OF WASHINGTON DEPARTMENT OF COMMERCE 1011 Plum Street SE • PO Box 42525 •Olympia, Washington 98504-2525 • (360) 725-4000 www.commerce.wa.gov April 17, 2024 County of Kittitas County 411 N Ruby Street Suite 2 Ellensburg, WA 98926 RE: 2026 Growth Management Act Periodic Update Grant Greetings, We are pleased to inform you that $350,000 has been reserved for Kittitas County as a grant to assist in completing your work in reviewing and, as needed, revising your comprehensive plan and development regulations. Please register here to join us on April 22, 2024 at 1:00 PM for a drop -in session for questions about PUG applications. This funding is a non-competitive formula grant based on population size. Under RCW 36.70A. 13 0(5)(b) and the Growth Management Act, Kittitas County must complete review of its comprehensive plan by June 30, 2026. Funding is appropriated by the legislature following the biennial budget, one-half of your GMA Update Grant funding is currently available, or $175,000 is available to reimburse related review and update project costs from July 1, 2024 to June 30, 2025. The second half of this total award, or $175,000 will be available in your grant agreement for the period of July 1, 2025 to June 30, 2026. Commerce will sign a grant agreement with you in the upcoming month. This letter confirms that all related GMA update project costs incurred by your jurisdiction, beginning July 1, 2024, will be eligible for reimbursement. Therefore, you will not need to delay work on the update grant until the contract is signed. In addition to this financial assistance, Growth Management Services will continue to provide technical assistance for you during this periodic update process, until your scheduled update deadline and our regional planners are ready to assist you with any questions. In order to receive this funding, please complete and submit the GMA Update Grant Application materials. You can apply directly via an online form using this link. Please pay close attention to the instructions. You can also find application materials on the Growth Management Services grants wcbpage located here. Please submit your online application no later than September 30, 2024. We will begin creating your contract and finalizing your Scope of Work as soon as we receive it. If you have questions regarding this grant program or receiving technical assistance regarding your update, please contact Deanah Watson, at Deanah.Watson@Commerce.wa.gov. Sincerely, Dave Andersen, AICP Managing Director, Growth Management Services cc: Deanah Watson FISCAL YEAR 2025 PUG Scope of Work Task # Task Name and Description Task 1 Project kick-off and coordination Kick-off meeting to review the project schedule and deliverables, set times for ongoing coordination, and discuss roles and responsibilities of project team members. Bi-monthly 30-minute meetings and any meetings at critical project stages to coordinate on important project tasks. Deliverable 1: Kickoff meeting agenda and summary Task 2 1 Public Participation Plan Development of a Public Participation Plan, meeting the requirements of RCW 36.70A.140, which identifies procedures providing for early and continuous public participation throughout the Periodic Comprehensive Plan Update process. Deliverable 2: Final Public Participation Plan Task 3 Project website, outreach materials, public open houses, public meetings Preparation of project website and content, outreach materials for community engagement events, and summaries of input gathered from open houses for visioning and proposed policy work and housing work. Deliverable 3A: Short progress report on website delivery, outreach materials and input gathered from open houses for visioning ro osed policy work and housing work. _ Deliverable 313: Short progress report on website delivery, outreach materials and input gathered from open houses for visioning proposed policy work and housi ig work. Deliverable 3C: Report summarizing website delivery, outreach materials and summaries of Start Contract Start Date October 15, 2024 October 15, 2024 November 15, 2024 End October 1, 2024 October 15, 2024 October 15, 2024 November 15, 2024 November 15, 2024 October 15, 2024 June 13, 2025 December 15, 2024 February 15, 2025 June 13, 2025 input gathered from open houses for visioning proposed policy work and housing work. Task 4 Best Available Science (BAS) review and gap October 15, analysis Work program developed for critical areas review 2024 and analysis to determine any policy gaps to achieve consistency with BAS and GMA requirements. Deliverable 4: Final critical areas review overview and analysis of policy gaps Task 5 Plan audit, current conditions, data collection, October 15, analysis, and documentation _ Preparation of Comprehensive Plan policy audit 2024 and Department of Commerce checklist. Deliverable 5: Findings report from Comprehensive Plan audit and completed Department of Commerce checklist. Land Capacity Analysis Task 6 November 15, _ Land Capacity Report for UGAs Deliverable 6: Final Land Capacity Report for 2024 UGAs. Task 7 Housing Needs Assessment and an analysis November 15, of required HB 1220 equity and displacement 2024 analysis Development of Housing Needs Assessment (HNA) in alignment with HB 1220 (RCW 36.70A.070(2) and WAC 365-196-410. HNA will also include analysis of housing types that are affordable to people making different incomes in alignment with housing allocations from HAPT tool. Deliverable 7: Housing Needs Assessment and an analysis of required HB 1220 equity and dis lacement analysis. New Comprehensive Plan concepts presented Task 8 January 15, and draft plan policy edits - Includes existing 2024 conditions information for capital facilit Ian Development of policy concepts and initial comprehensive plan policy changes for initial review. In addition, this work will include gathering existing conditions information from county and non -county service providers for the Capital Facilities Plan. Deliverable 8A: Progress report detailing progress with Draft Plan Concepts and Policies and existing conditions information for capital facility plan. Deliverable 813: Progress report detailing progress with Draft Plan Concepts and Policies November 30, 2024 November 30, 2024 November 30, 2024 November 30, 2024 January 15, 2025 January 15, 2025 January 15, 2025 January 15, 2025 June 13, 2025 February 15, 2025 April 15, 2025 and existing conditions information for capital facilitv Oan. Deliverable 8Q Complete Draft Plan Concepts June 13, 2025 and Policy document and existing conditions information for capital facility Ian. Task 9 New Easton Sub -area plan policy concepts Nov. 1, 2024 February 28, resented and draft plan policy edits 12025 Development of policy concepts and initial sub- area plan policies for initial review. Deliverable 9A: Progress report detailing February 15, progress with Draft Plan Concepts and Policies. 2025 Deliverable 913: Progress report detailing April 15, 2025 progress with Draft Plan Concepts and Policies. Deliverable 9C: Complete Draft Plan Concepts June 13, 2025 and Policy document. FISCAL YEAR 2025 BU DG ET Deliverable # Task Number/Title and Deliverable Description Budget Year 1 1 Task 1: Project kick-off and coordination. $17,000 Task 2: Public Participation Plan. $14,500 Task 3: Short progress report on progress for website $20,000 2 3A delivery, outreach materials and input gathered from open houses for visioning proposed policy work and housing work. Task 3: Short progress report on progress for website $16,000 3B delivery, outreach materials and input gathered from open houses for visioning proposed policy work and housing work. Task 3: Report summarizing website delivery, outreach $9,000 3C materials and summaries of input gathered from open houses for visioning proposed policy work and housing work. Task 4: Best Available Science (BAS) review and gap $9,300 4 analysis. _ Task 5: Plan audit, current conditions data collection, $12,000 5 analysis, and documentation. Task 6: Land CapacityCapaci!y Analysis. $19,700 6 7 Task 7: Housing Needs Assessment and an analysis of $19,500 required HB 1220 equity and displacement analysis. 8A Task 8: Progress report detailing progress with Draft Plan $16,000 Concepts and Policies and existing conditions information for capital facility Ian. Task 8: Progress report detailing progress with Draft Plan 8B 4,000 Concepts and Policies and existing conditions information for capital facility Ian. 8C Task 8: Complete Draft Plan Concepts and Policy document $6,000 T and existing conditions information for capital facility Ian. - 9A Task 9: Progress report detailing progress with Draft Plan Concepts and Policies. 9B Task 8: Progress report detailing progress with Draft Plan Concepts and Policies. 9C Task 8: Complete Draft Plan Concepts and Policy document. Total FISCAL YEAR 2026 PUG Scope of Work Task # Description Task 10 Public involvement _ Public involvement to get feedback on draft comprehensive plan and development regulations includin meetings and public hearings. Deliverable 10A: Short progress report on progress for public involvement to get feedback on draft comprehensive plan and development regulations including meetings and public hearings. Deliverable 1013: Short progress report on progress for public involvement to get feedback on draft comprehensive plan and development regulations including meetings and public hearings. Deliverable 10C: Report summarizing public involvement to get feedback on draft comprehensive plan and development regulations including meetin s and public hearings. Task 11 Prepare second draft of the Comprehensive Plan Based upon review of the initial policy concepts and public engagement, this will include preparation of second draft of the Comprehensive Plan. This draft will include updates to policy text and introduction and other information contained _within each plan element. Deliverable 11A: Progress report on development of second draft of the Comprehensive Plan based on public involvement. Start Julv 1. 2025 $5, 000 $3,000 End June 12. 2026 August 15, 2025 December 15, 2025 June 12, 2026 July 1, 2025 October 15, 2025 August 1, 2025 Deliverable 11 B: Second draft of the October 15, Comprehensive Plan based on public 2025 involvement. Task 12 Prepare draft regulations August 1, 2025 November 15, 2025 Prepare draft regulations for consistency with Commerce checklist findings including draft Critical Area regulations. Draft regulations will also reflect consistency with the CPPs and other regulation changes needed to accommodate population and housing targets along with employment projections. Deliverable 12A: Progress report on preparation _ September 15, draft regulations for consistency with Commerce 2025 checklist findings including draft Critical Area regulations. Deliverable 126: Draft regulations for November 15, consistency with Commerce checklist findings 2025 including draft Critical Area regulations. SEPA expanded checklist January 1, 2026 February 1, Task 13 2026 Task 14 Task 15 Preparation of SEPA expanded checklist and issuance. This will also include responses to public comments. Deliverable 13: SEPA expanded checklist preparation and issuance. Final Comprehensive Plan preparation and adoption Based upon additional review and public engagement, this will include preparation of the Final Comprehensive Plan and steps necessary for adoption. Deliverable 14A: Progress report on preparation of Final Comprehensive Plan. Deliverable 1413: Final Comprehensive Plan preparation and adoption. Final Easton Sub -area plan February 1, 2026 February 1, _ 2026 February 1, June 12, 2026 2026 Based upon additional review and public engagement, this will include preparation of the Final Easton Sub -area plan and steps necessary for adoption. Deliverable 15A: Progress report on preparation of Final sub -area plan. Deliverable 1513: Final sub -area plan and aao icon. Task 16 Final development regulations preparation and adoption Based upon additional review and public engagement, this will include preparation of the February 1, 2026 March 1, 2026 June 12, 2026 June 12, 2026 March 1, 2026 June 12, 2026 June 12, 2026 Final development regulations and steps necessary for adoption. _ Deliverable 16A: Progress report on preparation March 1, 2026 of Final development regulations. _ Deliverable 1613: Final development regulations June 12, 2026 preparation and adoption. FISCAL YEAR 2026 BUDGET Deliverable # Task Number/Title and Deliverable Description Budget Year 1 10A Task 10: Short progress report on progress for public $22,000 involvement to get feedback on draft comprehensive plan and development regulations including meetings and public 10B hearings. Task 10: Short progress report on progress for public $10,000 involvement to get feedback on draft comprehensive plan and development regulations including meetings and public hearings. 10C Task 10: Report summarizing public involvement to get $9,000 feedback on draft comprehensive plan and development regulations including meetings and public hearings. 11A Task 11: Progress report on development of second draft of _ $26,000 the Comprehensive Plan based on public involvement. $14,000 11 B Task11: Second draft of the Comprehensive Plan based on public involvement. $28,000 12A Task 12: Progress report on preparation draft regulations for consistency with Commerce checklist findings including draft 12B Critical Area regulations. Task 12: Draft regulations for consistency with Commerce $13,000 checklist findings including draft Critical Area regulations. _ 13 Task 13: SEPA expanded checklist preparation and $10,000 issuance. Task 14: Progress report on preparation of Final 14A $10,000 Comprehensive Plan. Task 14: Final Comprehensive Plan preparation and $6,500 14B adoption. 15A Task 15: Progress report on preparation of Final sub -area $8,000 15B Task 15: Final sub -area plan and adoption. $4,000 16A Task 16: Progress report on preparation of Final $9,500 development regulations. _ 16B Task 16: Final development regulations preparation and $5,000 adoption. Total $175,000 KITTITAS COUNTY COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT SERVICES 2024 STUDY STAFF REPORT STUDY SESSION DATE: July 22nd, 2024 ACTION REQUESTED: Request to Approve a Resolution supporting the proposed Climate and Resiliency scope of work and budget request for the 2026 periodic review and update to the Kittitas County Comprehensive Plan. BACKGROUND: Kittitas County is required to plan for climate change and resiliency, which was added as the 14d' goal of the Growth Management Act (GMA) RCW 36.70A. As part of the WA ST Dept. of Commerce's grant application for Climate and Resiliency, it is required that a supportive document be provided from the jurisdiction to complete the Grant Application. INTERACTION: CDS. RECOMMENDATION: Approve the Resolution supporting the proposed Climate & Resiliency scope of work and budget as required by the WA. ST. Dept. of Commerce's Periodic Update Grant application. HANDLING: Return one original to Community Development Services. ATTACHMENTS: Resolution. LEAD STAFF: Chad Bala, Director. BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS COUNTY OF KITTITAS STATE OF WASHINGTON RESOLUTION NO.2024- � 3, AUTHORIZING THE SUPPORT OF KITTITAS COUNTY'S WASHINGTON STATE DEPARTMENT OF COMMERCE 2026 PERIODIC UPDATE GRANT APPLICATION WHEREAS: Kittitas County is required to update its Comprehensive Plan Periodic Update by 2026 per the Growth Management Act (GMA) RCW 36.70A.; and WHEREAS: Kittitas County is required to plan for climate change and resiliency, which was added as the 14"' goal of the Growth Management Act (GMA) RCW 36.70A.; and WHEREAS: Kittitas County is required to specifically update its Comprehensive Plan to include a Resiliency sub -element with goals and policies to improve climate preparedness, response and recovery efforts per the Growth Management Act (GMA) RCW 36.70A.; and WHEREAS: Monies have been appropriate by the Legislator to the Washington State Department of Commerce who has the responsibility to administer these monies to local jurisdictions, to meet their comprehensive plan periodic update deadline; and WHEREAS: Kittitas County will apply for a Climate Grant through the Washington State Department of Commerce; and NOW THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED that the Board of County Commissioners of Kittitas County, Washington, in the best interest of the public, does hereby support Kittitas County's Washington State Department of Commerce Climate & Resiliency grant application and scope of work to facilitate Kittitas County in the periodic review and update necessary to the meet the requirements of the Growth Management Act. ,day of July 2024, at Ellensburg, Washington. � �•,f dQ 2'Y,b_ F x r. �• SEAL ❑ Clerk of the Board- Julie Kjorsvik VDIe puty Clerk of the Board- Mandy Buchholz BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS KITTITAS COUN", AS ON t Brett W chsmith, Chairman 2026 Climate Grant Scope of Work Task 1 CLIMATE RESILIENCE SUB -ELEMENT Start Project kick-off and coordination Contract Start Date Task 1.1 Kick-off meeting to review the project schedule and deliverables, set times for ongoing coordination, and discuss roles and responsibilities of project team members. Task 2 Task 2.1 Task 3 Task 3.1 Bi-monthly 30-minute meetings and potentially additional meetings at critical project stages to coordinate on important project tasks. Deliverable 1: Kickoff meeting agenda October 15, and summary 2024 _ Public Engagement Plan October 15, 2024 Development of a Public Engagement Plan that meets the county's guidelines. Engagement plan will be linked to engagement as part of the periodic update but will also include engagement focused on people and communities who may be impacted by changes to the _climate. _ Deliverable 2: Final Public Participation Plan Project website, outreach materials, November public open houses, public meetings_ 15,2024 Preparation of project website and content, outreach materials for community engagement events, and summaries of input gathered from open houses for visioning and proposed policy work and housing work. Deliverable 3A: Short progress report on progress for website delivery, outreach materials and input gathered from open houses for proposed climate policy work. End October 1, 2024 October 15. 2024 5, 2024 November 15, 2024 November 15, 2024 November 15, 2024 June 13, 2025 December 15, 2024 Deliverable 313: Short progress report on February 15, 2025 progress for website delivery, outreach materials and input gathered from open houses for proposed climate policy work. Deliverable 3C: Report summarizing June 13, 2025 website delivery, outreach materials and summaries of input gathered from open houses for proposed climate policy work. Task 4 Explore Climate Impacts. November 1, February 1, 2025 2024 Identify c mmunity assets. _ Task 4.1 Task 4.2 Explore hazards and changes in the climate. Pair assets and hazards and describe Task 4.3 exposure and consequences. Identify priority climate hazards. _ _ Task 4.4 Deliverable 4A: Report summarizing January 1, 2025 website delivery, outreach materials and summaries of input gathered from open houses for visioning proposed policy work and housing work. Deliverable 4B. Submit a memo February 1, 2025 summarizing completion of this step or submit a copy of the completed Climate Element Workbook. Task 5 Audit Plans & Policies. January 1, March 1, 2025 Review existing plans for climate gaps 2025 Task 5.1 and opportunities. February 1, 2025 Deliverable 5A. Submit a summarizing progress in assessing existing plans for climate gaps and opportunities. March 1, 2025 Deliverable 5B. Submit a memo summarizing completion of this step or submit a copy of the completed Climate Element Workbook. Task 6 Assess Vulnerability & Risk. February 1, May 1, 2025 2025 Task 6.1 Assess sensitivity. Task 6.2 Assess adaptive capacity - Task 6.3 Characterize vulnerability. Task 6.4 Characterize risk. Task 6.5 Meet with partners, stakeholders and decision makers to decide course of action. Deliverable 6A Submit a summarizing March 1, 2025 progress in assessing vulnerability of submit a copy of the draft Climate Element Workbook. Deliverable 6B Submit a memo summarizing completion of this step or submit a copy of completed Climate Element Workbook. Task 7 Pursue Pathways. Task 7.1 Develop draft Goals & Policies. Task 7.2 Identify olic co -benefits. Deliverable 7A. Submit a memo summarizing progress of this step or submit a copy of completed Climate Element Workbook. Deliverable 7B. Submit a memo summarizing completion of this step or submit a copy of completed Climate Element Workbook. Integrate Goals & Policies. Task 8 Task 8.1 Review and finalize resilience goals and policies. Task 8.2 Consult with partners, stakeholders, and Final Deliverables decision makers. Deliverable 8A Submit a memo summarizing progress with drafting final climate policies, engagement, and public meetings and hearings. Deliverable 8B Submit a memo summarizing progress with drafting final climate policies, engagement, and public ril 1. 2025 June 30, 2025 meetings and hearings. J- Deliverable 8C Submit a memo summarizing progress with drafting final climate policies, engagement, and public meetings and hearings. Deliverable 8D Submit a memo summarizing progress with drafting final climate policies, engagement, and public meetings and hearings. _ Deliverable 8E. Adopt climate resilience goals and policies by ordinance or adopt update FEMA Hazard Mitigation Plan by Reference. Deliverable 8F. Submit a memo summarizing completion of this step or submit a copy of completed Climate Element Workbook. 1 April 1, 2025 June 30, 2025 May 1, 2025 June 12, 2025 June 13. 2026 August 30, 2025 October 30, 2025 December 30, 2025 March 30, 2026 June 15, 2026 June 15, 2026 Budget Deliverable # Task Number/Title and Deliverable Description Budget Task 1 Project kick-off and coordination Task 1.1 Kick-off meeting to review the project schedule and deliverables, set times for ongoing coordination, and discuss roles and responsibilities of project team members. Bi-monthly 30-minute meetings and potentially additional meetings at critical project stages to coordinate on important project tasks. _ Deliverable 1: Kickoff meeting agenda and summary $19,000 Task 2 Public Engagement Plan Task 2.1 Development of a Public Engagement Plan that meets the county's guidelines. Engagement plan will be linked to engagement as part of the periodic update but will also include engagement focused on people and communities who may be impacted by changes to the climate. $22,000 Deliverable 2: Final Public Participation Plan Task 3 Project website, outreach materials, public open houses, public meetin s _ Preparation of project website and content, outreach Task 3.1 materials for community engagement events, and summaries of input gathered from open houses for visioning and proposed policy work and housing work. Deliverable 3A: Short progress report on progress for $26,500 website delivery, outreach materials and input gathered from open houses for ro osed climate policy work. Deliverable 313: Short progress report on progress for I $23,000 website delivery, outreach materials and input gathered from open houses for proposed climate policy work. Deliverable 3C: Report summarizing website delivery, $23,000 outreach materials and summaries of input gathered from open houses for proposed climate policy work. Explore Climate Impacts. Task 4 Task 4.1 Identify community assets. Explore hazards and changes in the climate. Task 4.2 Task 4.3 Pair assets and hazards and describe exposure and consequences. Identify priority climate hazards. Deliverable 4A: Report summarizing website delivery, $14,000 Task 4.4 outreach materials and summaries of input gathered from open houses for visioning proposed policy work and housing work. Deliverable 413. Submit a memo summarizing completion of $14,000 this step or submit a copy of the completed Climate Element Workbook. Task 5 Task 5.1 Task 6 Task 6.1 Task 6.2 Task 6.3 Task 6.4 Task 6.5 Task 7 Task 7.1 Task 7.2 Task 8 Task 8.1 Task 8.2 Final Audit Plans & Policies. Review existing plans for climate gaps and opportunities. Deliverable 5A. Submit a progress report on assessing existing plans for climate gaps and opportunities. Deliverable 5B. Submit a memo summarizing completion of this step or submit a copy of the completed Climate Element Workbook. Assess Vulnerability & Risk. Assess Assess adaptive capacity. Characterize vulnerabili Characterize risk. Meet with partners, stakeholders and decision makers to decide course of action. Deliverable 6A. Submit a summarizing progress in assessing vulnerability of submit a copy of the draft Climate Element Workbook. Deliverable 6B. Submit a memo summarizing completion of this step or submit a copy of completed Climate Element Workbook. Pursue Pathways. Develop draft Goals & Policies. Identify policy co -benefits. Deliverable 7A. Submit a memo summarizing progress of this step or submit a copy of completed Climate Element Workbook. _ Deliverable 7B. Submit a memo summarizing completion of this step or submit a copy of completed Climate Element Workbook. Integrate Goals & Policies. Review and finalize resilience goals and policies. Consult with partners, stakeholders, and decision makers. Deliverable 8A Submit a memo summarizing progress with drafting final climate policies, engagement, and public meetings and hearings. _ Deliverable 8B Submit a memo summarizing progress with drafting final climate policies, engagement, and public meetings and hearings. Deliverable 8C Submit a memo summarizing progress with drafting final climate policies, engagement, and public meetings and hearings. Deliverable 8D Submit a memo summarizing progress with drafting final climate policies, engagement, and public meetings and hearings. Deliverable 8E. Adopt climate resilience goals and policies by ordinance or adopt update FEMA Hazard Mitigation Plan by Reference. $15, 500 $12, 500 $22,000 $13,000 $18,500 $13, 500 $16,500 11,500 $13,500 $6, 500 Deliverable 8F. Submit a memo summarizing completion of $6,500 this step or submit a copy of completed Climate Element Workbook. Total $300,000 KITTITAS COUNTY COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT SERVICES 2024 STUDY STAFF REPORT STUDY SESSION DATE: July 22°d, 2024 ACTION REQUESTED: Request to Review and Finalize the 2024 Annual Comprehensive Plan Docket list BACKGROUND: The Annual Comprehensive Plan Docket applications are required to be submitted every year by June 30d' with review, consideration, and decision by December of every year. INTERACTION: CDS. RECOMMENDATION: Recommend CDS staff to continue to move forward in processing the 2024 Annual Comprehensive Plan Docket list as is or with changes through the annual comprehensive plan process. HANDLING: None. ATTACHMENTS: None. LEAD STAFF: Chad Bala, Director. N N N N N N N N N N N N N O O O O CD O O O O O O O O N N N A N A N A N A N A N A N A N A N A N A N A O O O O O O O O O W N ,--• O CO W V O Ul A w N f+ Cn Cn D 1 N cn D D W n D D p a _� " p a o °� d ao a S CD C m : O 3 3 o CD rn o CD Q CD _0_0 CD CDL -3 nl C)"CO CD ' � O CD o C C7 v a z 0 N O Q O 0 3 a 0CD 3 C O CD CD O C 0 3 7 CD CD y v 3 sp CD w 7 CD O O. CDCCDD — � Q � 0 0 3 0 0 d O n CD � m 7C 2 r m T cn -o O n n n n C7 D c C� n C� a a En o r c n C O m v 0 C7 cn v cn C7 Cn v Cn O Cn 3 C7 cn 0 cn C7 cn Sp as CD _- Q n cn 0�� 3 0 m CD Q o- CD x A F+ N r n cn p o D N 7C m cn o m D 0 n C- D N CO V O N C CD Cr n 3 n a f = C n = Q n S O V Cl C. (D A CD C CD E,A CD O w (D O N awl V ^� Qcy UQ N O (D n n = A_ '� O 3 C O 3 a4 O Cap O a4 �% 00 N CD Cn O C O m 7 a] O 7 CD CIQ D 3 3 3 C7 O 3 3 CD _ N CILC �_ W CD S = CD Q D [D .��' 3 O CD O O N N CDD CD O CD Q N C7 En Cm CD r0+ O N 00 N' CD 0 a_ o m O O W �° (Oil o m m c n m e a c m m A m m N o 3 CD o. N CD CD a�a n O O CD j CD O O O n C n CD 3 a N CD CO CCDD 3 -p O O fD 7 7 C Q ;:w H d O, 4> (D S. O a O O O NOL C D C C C C N. O — 7 CD a4 CD 0 vl 00 3 O 0 � (D C O � 3 cr O .< as ci Q 3 0 0 � m c c o 0° oa A v 0 O < C CD CL °, m f D ci cn d (D v a o CD W 0 '* o m 0 v D 0 CD n n 3 0 c o `° v 3 m n _ < Q. 0 C oa a7 aQ O Q CD * a, o < 0 * O cr O O CD 3 O 7 CA 3 _� �• C to C N CD C O fy CD O CD o:E O. Cn N O a 3 O_ Q ,0., W n Q a > w _ CD 7 O S j Op C) N CD NCO', v CL N 7 c n N X CD rN•r N CD Q. 3 a O O Cn 7 .Oi N a) NO 7 Q CD a 0a O N j n orcx C N Q CD m O v O F� N aCl ac O 0 O cn cn 7 CD O C S O "' �. O o. N Q 7 (7 W n CL N CD 3 O " O_ 'L 3 wO•r O CD p CD N K 0 Ol C O 'En C D^ N CD D c al 0 = N� O n as d .< Ao as — A 'd �. O fl. = a, 0 0 � 3 c m CD Q r o m n, M o _ o C r. a N 0 Cn o it CD 3 7 r CD OS N wn C] O d N a=4 O Ci Q <D N '� 4 (A- n CD CD M n d 0 Q. O a) (D 00 W W C CD D CDN 0 0 C = 3 C..l C'0 Q O C °7 N S• CD o CL D m --I 0 m aCA 0a cD < a Cra as S ,D Q N CD m n C < S G n N C * a as O CD a) CD (D C1 CDCD 0cr CD in al Cp D v c CD y a> > 0 cD O C d C O O = O N N FA, 3 C ca. Q Cl CL Cn (' O O * N Q O N Cn O D CD O Q O 7 O O O CD '3C C qLo.Q faD D C��D Q c �. a - 0 3 3 CD c c 3 y' 'MD3 CD > CD <D o, = o CrCD y C Q 0_ a = al Q. c cn CD o a a o _ m o c� y D is o al 3 CI a) CD 0 CDm aQ (D y „ Q � C G � KITTITAS COUNTY DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC WORKS PUBLIC WORKS — BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS STUDY SESSION STAFF REPORT STUDY SESSION DATE: TOPIC: ACTION REQUESTED: LEAD STAFF: Joshua Fredrickson July 22, 2024 Road Fund Levy Update Request to Approve a Resolution for a Permanent Single -Year Levy Lid Lift Supporting Roads RECOMMENDATION: Approve a Resolution for a permanent single -year levy lid lift for roads BRIEFING SUMMARY: • Results of three years of inflation have impacted infrastructure maintenance • Levy for roads can be increased by 1 % each year • Rate increase scenario was developed to maintain infrastructure • Consideration of Levy Rate Lid Lift and to establish a new baseline BACKGROUND: Maintenance and construction of Kittitas County roads are funded through three primary sources: property tax, gas tax, and grants. Property tax is collected from residents of the unincorporated areas of the County. Gas tax is collected state-wide and a portion is allocated to Kittitas County. Grants are awarded based on an application process and typically require matching funds to be available from the County. Kittitas County has been successful in the past in obtaining grant funding for road and bridge construction. The Ten -Year Transportation Asset Management Plan (TAMP) identified the need to address critical transportation asset investments. This plan utilized an annual inflation rate of two (2) percent. Inflationary impacts from 2021-2023 accumulated to 16.8 percent per the Western States Consumer Price Index (CPI). This has affected the ability to keep up with the anticipated road needs in the TAMP. From 2015-2019 levy shifts also impacted the road fund. While this allowed for the creation of the County's water bank system, which has benefited the county and residents, it came at an expense to public works infrastructure maintenance. DISCUSSION: Current levy rates are limited to a 1 % increase per year, plus new construction. Recent historic high inflation has eroded the purchasing power for maintenance and road construction projects on public infrastructure. A proposed levy lid lift is presented to provide stability of maintenance and construction of County roads and bridges. Rate scenarios have been developed by Public Works, with input from the consultant (Consor) levy survey and input efforts. The proposal for a levy lid lift is a single -year lift with the new dollar amount then being used for future assessments (Exhibit 1). The permanent single -year lid lift would increase the levy amount and then establish a new base for the one-(1) percent annual allowable increase. With a permanent sing -year lid lift, the levy lid bumps up more than 1 % in the first year, and then that amount is used to calculate all future 101 % levy limitations. The measure does not expire, and the levy lid does not revert. Future annual increases may not exceed 1 % without a vote to approve another lid lift. Current Levy Rate: $0.77 per $1,000 of assessed value Proposed Levy Rate: $1.01 per $1,000 of assessed value Single levy increase used for future assessments It is proposed that this levy lid lift be placed on the November 2024 General Election. Taxes levied in November are first due in April the following year. FISCAL IMPACT: Consideration of divesting from infrastructure assets must be considered without additional funds to the road fund. HANDLING: Return one original ATTACHMENTS: Resolution, Exhibit 1 Permanent Single -Year Levy Lid Lift BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS COUNTY OF KITTITAS STATE OF WASHINGTON RESOLUTION NO. 2024 -� A RESOLUTION TO SUBMIT A PROPOSITION TO THE VOTERS OF KITTITAS COUNTY: AUTHORIZING AN INCREASE OT THE KITTITAS COUNTY ROAD PROPERTY TAX WHEREAS: Kittitas County and its Public Works Department are responsible for maintenance, repairs and improvement for 500 miles of roads and more than 250 bridges and structures. WHEREAS: the Board of Commissioners has determined it is essential and necessary for the continued maintenance, repairs, and improvement of the Kittitas County roads and bridges that the County provide additional funds for the County Road Department; and, WHEREAS: surveys of Kittitas County voters have shown they are reliant on the County's Public Works Department to continuously provide critical services without interruption including access for emergency vehicles, snow plowing, keeping school bus routes open and safe, bridge safety, prevention of flooding on roads and timely repairs and paving; and WHEREAS: the Board of County Commissioners have determined the revenues that will be available to Public Works Department from its existing regular property tax levy will be insufficient to provide for the continued maintenance, repairs, and improvements of county roads, and therefore determined that it is in the interest of the County and its citizens to submit a levy lid lift proposition to the voters for their consideration. This proposition, if approved, would authorize the County to levy regular property taxes beginning in 2025 at the rate of $1.01027 per $1,000 of assessed value; and, WHEREAS: the proposed increase in the County's property tax levy of $0.24 per $1,000 of assessed value for 2025 would be the equivalent of $96 per year for a typical residence valued at $400,000; and, WHEREAS: the dollar amount of the maximum allowable levy under RCW 84.55 levied for collection in 2025 shall be used for the purpose of computing the limitations on subsequent levies, in subsequent years, under said Section; and, WHEREAS: the proposal set out in this resolution requires approval by a simple majority of the voters in Kittitas County. NOW, THEREFORE BE IT RESOLVED that the Kittitas County Board of Commissioners does hereby authorize the Clerk of the Board to certify a copy of this resolution to the Kittitas County Auditor no later than August 5, 2024, and to perform such other duties as may be necessary or required by law to place the proposition described herein on the ballot at the election to be held on November 5, 2024; and, NOW, THEREFORE BE IT FURTHER RESOLVED that the best interests of the citizens of Kittitas County require the submission to the qualified voters of the County a proposition to levy regular property taxes above the limitations established in RCW 84.55.010 for consideration at the general election. The proposition shall be to increase the County's regular property tax levy by $0.24 per $1,000 of assessed valuation for collection in 2025, for a total rate not to exceed $1.01027 per $1,000 of assessed valuation, and NOW, THEREFORE BE IT FURTHER RESOLVED the proposition also would approve the use of the dollar amount of the 2025 levy for computing the maximum levy that may be imposed in years after 2025, and NOW, THEREFORE BE IT FURTHER RESOLVED revenues from the property tax increases that would be authorized by the ballot proposition shall be used for the limited purposes of continued maintenance, repairs, and improvements of the Kittitas County roads and bridges, and NOW, THEREFORE BE IT FURTHER RESOLVED that the Kittitas County Board of Commissioners does hereby request that the Auditor, as supervisor of all elections, call and conduct an election in the unincorporated precincts in the County, in the manner provided by law, to be held on the date identified herein, for the purpose of submitting to the voters of the County a proposition in substantially the following form: Kittitas County Proposition No. 1 Kittitas County Road Maintenance Levy County Road Property Tax Levy Lid Lift The Kittitas County Board of Commissioners adopted Resolution Nd. _; proposing increasing the County Road regular property tax levy. If approved, this proposition would fund County Road and bridge maintenance, repairs, and improvements. It authorizes a 2025 maximum regular property tax levy rate of $1.01027 per $1,000 of assessed value and authorizes the use of the 2025 dollar amount to calculate the levy limit in subsequent years. Should this proposition be approved? [ ] Yes No NOW, THEREFORE BE IT RESOLVED that the Kittitas County Board of Commissioners does hereby direct the County Prosecuting Attorney to prepare a Ballot Title, as provided by law, in substantially the same format as set forth above. DATED on this 22nd day of July 2024, at Ellensburg, Washington. �!'OAttest: Julie Kjorsvik Deputy Clerk of the Board- Mandy Buchholz BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS KITTITAS COUNTY -,WAS ith, Chairman "Lama ONadaci, Vice -Chairman toryWriklft, Commissioner Exhibit 1: Permanent Single Year Levy Lid Lift Z9 o °QQD m c N tD aa}} W r O Ci V M O O N N Ey.................................. N o E N m in o n o m i . n Q ro m N' N o m n M Q ) OI m O1...................... O m m N M n N C M n 00 n n 0p 0 m N NQ Q y N O v' (tyy r Q No n o O N N M O O .Ni 0 a -I Q M M tO N N O f O..........................T _4 rl N O n O Q ap N 2! N O N rl Q O r O O Q a M i o a M m o � cd o � a • o � o 0 o a o y o a m Q v m 2 H } M m N Q O C O W 01 O U 0 0 _ v N ~ U KITTITAS COUNTY DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC WORKS PUBLIC WORKS — BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS STUDY SESSION STAFF REPORT STUDY SESSION DATE: July 22, 2024 TOPIC: Interstate 90 Corridor Easton to Cle Elum Feasibility Study ACTION REQUESTED: None Required LEAD STAFF: Joshua Fredrickson RECOMMENDATION: No action required. BRIEFING SUMMARY: • Interstate 90 traffic bypasses slowdowns by using County road network. • Feasibility study performed to identify alternatives. • Two primary alternatives have been identified: 1. Widening I-90 to the inside 2. Constructing a reversible lane • Next steps are to pursue environmental phases. BACKGROUND: For the past several years, Kittitas County has experienced an increase of Interstate 90 (I- 90) traffic bypassing onto local roads during 1-90 closures and slowdowns. This was confirmed through the efforts of the Upper County Traffic Committee (UCTC) and traffic engineering consultant Fehr & Peers. When developing a project for traffic calming devices, it was identified that I-90 traffic was working to bypass slowdowns and backups on I-90 by using the County road network. Public Works subsequently proposed a feasibility study and allocated funding on the State Transportation Improvement Plan (STIP) in 2022. Through a competitive Statement of Qualifications process consulting services of SCJ Alliance were secured in July 2022. DISCUSSION: Kittitas County sought to understand and identify the effective manner to address I-90 traffic bypassing onto local roadways between Easton (MP 70) to Cle Elum/SR 970 (MP 85). Current State efforts include widening I-90 west of Easton (MP 70). The County identified this location as a possible bottleneck, as there is not a location for traffic to disperse at Easton. The feasibility study considered seven alternatives. One alternative was a no -build scenario, where existing conditions remain the same. Three alternatives focused on use of existing I-90 corridor and three alternatives considered new or widened roadways outside of the I-90 corridor. Increasing the number of lanes will increase the ability of I-90 to carry traffic. This will also increase the safety on I-90. The project considered a variety of elements including safety, transportation demand, environment and public input to help identify and score the alternatives to come to a final selection. As part of the efforts to coordinate with a range of groups and stakeholders, the County and the Washington State Department of Transportation (WSDOT) partnered on the efforts of the feasibility study. WSDOT stood up their M3 (Multimodal, multidisciplinary, multi -agency) Team. They also sought input from their M2 (multimodal, multidisciplinary) Team. Community and stakeholder involvement occurred throughout the development of the feasibility study. Information was distributed through the STEER I-90 website and group. Stakeholder interviews were done focused on current travel conditions. Public surveys, virtual open house and an in -person open house were held to seek community feedback. It is anticipated the report will be made available on the STEER I-90 website: (httDs: //steeri90.com). Kittitas County has employed the assistance of a consultant to engage with federal legislators about the scope and importance of the project improvements along I-90. Federal funding is being requested through the Congressionally Directed Spending (CDS) process for the next phase of the project which includes the environmental analysis and preliminary design. SCJ Alliance, as consultant awarded to develop the feasibility study, will be available to present the feasibility study. FISCAL IMPACT: Full project costs are anticipated to be hundreds of millions of dollars. ATTACHMENTS: Exhibit 1: I-90 Corridor -Easton to Cle Elum Feasibility Study EXHIBIT 1: 1-90 CORRIDOR-EASTON TO CLE ELUM FEASIBILITY STUDY 4 .•ice --ikl. ft�7 1-90 CORRIDOR - EASTON TO CLE ELUM FEASIBILITY STUDY VOLUME 1.0 FEASIBILITY REPORT Draft Print July � _ p f -y KITTITAS [ OiY75. 2024 1-90 CORRIDOR - EASTON TO CLE ELUM FEASIBILITY STUDY VOLUME I0 : FEASIBILITY REPORT Prepared for: Kittitas County Prepared by: SCJ Alliance Subconsultants: Jacobs - Environmental Analysis, Equity and Inclusion Analysis Tierra Right of Way Services, Ltd. - Cultural Resources Review Fehr & Peers, Inc. -Traffic Analysis and Modeling J u ly 2024 APPROVALS AND SIGNATURE PAGE 1-90 Corridor - Easton to Cie Elum Feasibility Study VOLUME 1: FEASIBILITY REPORT Prepared for: Kittitas County Prepared by: SCJ Alliance Approved by: Joshua Fredrickson Public Works Director, Kittitas County Date Brian White Date Regional Administrator, South Central Region, WSDOT Karena Houser Date Director, Multimodal Planning and Data Division, WSDOT VOLUME 1: FEASIBILITY REPORT 1-90 Corridor - Easton to Cie Elum Feasibility Study I ii AMERICANS WITH DISABILITIES ACT (ADA) INFORMATION Kittitas County in accordance with Section 504 of the Rehabilitation Act (Section 504) and the Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA) commits to nondiscrimination on the basis of disability, in all of its programs and activities. This material can be made available in an alternate format by electronically mailing Candie Leader at die.lead er 4�co.kittitas.wa.us or by calling collect 509-962-7523. VOLUME 1: FEASIBILITY REPORT 1-90 Corridor - Easton to Cie Elunn Feasibility Study I iii TABLE OF CONTENTS Listof Appendices......................................................................................................................................................vi Listof Figures..............................................................................................................................................................vii List of Tables Acronyms....................................................................................................................................................................... ix Glossary.......................................................................................................................................................................... x ProjectBackground..................................................................................................................................................xiv 1 INTRODUCTION........................................................................................................1 1.1 Study Area.............................................................................................................................................................1 1.2 Purpose of This Feasibility Study....................................................................................................................1 1.3 Study Partners...................................................................................................................................................4 1.4 Study Process and Approach...........................................................................................................................6 2 RANGE OF ALTERNATIVES................................................................................. 8 2.1 No Build Alternative (Existing Conditions).................................................................................................10 2.2 Alternative 1: Widen 1-90 on the Outside....................................................................................................11 2.3 Alternative 2: Widen 1-90 in the Median.....................................................................................................14 2:4 Alternative 3: Widen 1-90 in the Median, Reversible Lanes...................................................................16 2.5 Alternative 4A: North - SR 903......................................................................................................................19 2.6 Alternative 413: North - Bullfrog Road......................................................................................................... 21 2.7 Alternative 5: South.........................................................................................................................................23 2.8 Other Potential Improvements.....................................................................................................................25 3 EXISTING CONDITIONS IN THE STUDY AREA..........................................28 3.1 Safety...................................................................................................................................................................29 3.2 Transportation Demand..................................................................................................................................34 3.3 Freight Mobility.................................................................................................................................................40 3.4 Environment.......................................................................................................................................................42 3.5 Resiliency............................................................................................................................................................48 3.6 Environmental justice and Equity................................................................................................................48 VOLUME I: FEASIBILITY REPORT 1-90 Corridor - Easton to Cle Elunn Feasibility Study I iv TABLE OF CONTENTS 4 ALTERNATIVES EVALUATION CRITERIA.....................................................52 4.1 Evaluation Criteria............................................................................................................................................52 4.2 Tier 1 Evaluation Approach and Results.....................................................................................................57 4.3 Tier 2: Targeted Evaluation.............................................................................................................................63 4.4 Alternatives Selected to Move Forward.....................................................................................................65 5 COMMUNITY AND STAKEHOLDER INVOLVEMENT................................71 5.1 Public Outreach Plan.......................................................................................................................................72 5.2 STEER 1-90 Coalition.........................................................................................................................................72 5.3 Tribal Coordination.......................................................................................................................................... 73 5.4 Public and Stakeholder Engagement..........................................................................................................73 6 NEXT STEPS............................................................................................................ 82 6.1 Legislative Outreach and Funding...............................................................................................................82 6.2 Preliminary Engineering.................................................................................................................................83 6.3 Environmental Analysis and Documentation............................................................................................84 6.4 Outreach and Engagement.............................................................................................................................84 6.5 NEPA Preferred Alternative, Final Design, and Implementation..........................................................85 6.6 Other Opportunities for 1-90 in the Study Area.......................................................................................85 6.7 Immediate Next Steps.....................................................................................................................................86 REFERENCES..................................................................................................................87 VOLUME I: FEASIBILITY REPORT 1-90 Corridor Easton to Cle Elum Feasibility Study I v LIST OF APPENDICES The appendices listed below can be found in the 1-90 Corridor - Easton to Cie Elum Feasibility Study, Volume II: Appendices. Appendix A Traffic Modeling Reports - 2019 and 2024 Appendix B Environmental Maps - 2024 Appendix C Cultural Resources Review-2024 Appendix D FHWA Screening Tool for Equity Analysis of Projects (STEAP) Data Appendix E EJ Screen Results Appendix F Detailed Evaluation Worksheets for Each Alternative Appendix G In-depth Environmental Evaluation by Alternative Appendix H Detailed Evaluation Worksheets for the 1-90 Alternatives Appendix I Public Survey Results - Summer 2023 Appendix J Public Survey Results - February 2024 Appendix K Webinar Polling Results - February 2024 VOLUME I: FEASIBILITY REPORT 1-90 Corridor - Easton to Cle Elunn Feasibility Study I vi LIST OF FIGURES Figure1-1 Project Study Area............................................................................................................................................2 Figure 1-2 Feasibility Study Process and Approach....................................................................................................6 Figure2-1 Range of Alternatives......................................................................................................................................9 Figure 2-2 No Build Conditions (Alternative 6)...........................................................................................................10 Figure 2-3 Alternatives 1, 2, and 3 - General Alignment............................................................................................12 Figure 2-4 Alternative 1 - Proposed Configuration....................................................................................................13 Figure 2-5 Alternative 2 - Proposed Configuration...................................................................................................15 Figure 2-6 Alternative 3 - Proposed Configuration...................................................................................................18 Figure 2-7 Alternative 4A - Conceptual Cross-Section.............................................................................................19 Figure 2-8 Alternative 4A - General Alignment...........................................................................................................20 Figure 2-9 Alternative 4B - Conceptual Cross-Section............................................................................................. 21 Figure 2-10 Alternative 4B - General Alignment...........................................................................................................22 Figure 2-11 Alternative 5 - Conceptual Cross-Section................................................................................................23 Figure 2-12 Alternative 5 - General Alignment.............................................................................................................24 Figure 3-1 Monday Summer Westbound Average Vehicle Volumes on 1-90 in the Study Area, 2018............35 Figure 3-2 Future Year 2040 No Build Modeled Travel Speeds by Time of Day and Location along 1-90 in the Study Area on Memorial Day Monday.......................................................................36 Figure 3-3 Cultural and Historic Sites, Parks, and Recreational Facilities in the Study Area ........................ 47 Figure 3-4 Environmental Health Disparities Map of 1-90 Corridor Study Area..................................................51 Figure 4-1 Tier 1 Evaluation Summary by Alternative - Weighted Score.............................................................62 Figure 4-2 Tier 2 Evaluation Summary by Alternative - Weighted Score.............................................................70 Figure 5-1 Public Survey 1 Results Summary - Biggest Public Concerns............................................................75 Figure 5-2 Public Survey 1 Results Summary - Prioritization of Improvements...............................................76 Figure 5-3 Public Survey 2 Results Summary - Preferred Alternative.................................................................76 Figure 5-4 Webinar 2, February 2024 - Sample Potting Question..........................................................................80 VOLUME 1: FEASIBILITY REPORT 1-90 Corridor — Easton to Cle Elum Feasibility Study I vii LIST OF TABLES Table1-1 WSDOT M2 and M3 Teams.................................................................................................................................5 Table 1-2 Feasibility Study Process and Approach.......................................................................................................7 Table 3-1 Collision Types along 1-90 in the Study Area, 2018 through 2023........................................................29 Table 3-2 Collisions by Injury Severity along 1-90 in the Study Area, 2018 through 2023................................29 Table 3-3 Injury Severity by Collision Type along 1-90 in the Study Area, 2018 through 2023........................30 Table 3-4 Injury Severity by Time of Year along 1-90 in the Study Area, 2018 through 2023 ............................30 Table 3-5 Injury Severity by Road Conditions along 1-90 in the Study Area, 2018 through 2023......................31 Table 3-7 ESA Listed Species Potential Presence and Designated Critical Habitat Adjacent to EachAlternative................................................................................................................................................44 Table 3-8 Select Socioeconomic Indicators.................................................................................................................49 Table 3-9 Environmental Health Disparities Summary for the 1-90 Corridor Study Area................................50 Table 4-1 Tier 1: Initial and Revised Evaluation - Project Goals, Criteria, Performance Measurements, and Weight...........................................................................................................................54 Table 4-2 Tier 1 Evaluation Results - Non-Weighted.................................................................................................58 Table 4-3 Tier 1 Evaluation - Weighted Scores............................................................................................................ 61 Table 4-4 Tier 2: Targeted Evaluation - Additional Criteria and Rating Descriptions.......................................64 Table 4-5 Tier 2 Evaluation Results - Non-Weighted.................................................................................................66 Table 4-6 Tier 2 Evaluation - 1-90 Alternatives Weighted Scores...........................................................................69 Table 5-1 Stakeholders Contacted and Interviewed.................................................................................................74 Table 5-2 Public Survey 1, Summer 2023 - Survey Questions................................................................................. 75 Table 5-3 Public Survey 2, February 2024 - Survey Results......................................................................................77 Table 5-4 Webinar 1, August 2023 - Questions and Answers..................................................................................79 VOLUME 1: FEASIBILITY REPORT 1-90 Corridor - Easton to Cle Elum Feasibility Study I viii ACRONYMS BUILD: Better Utilizing Investments to Leverage Development (U.S. Department of Transportation Discretionary Grants Program) CCTV: Closed -Circuit Television DAHP: Washington State Department of Archaeology and Historic Preservation EPA: Environmental Protection Agency ESA: Environmental Species Act FISTS: Washington State Freight and Goods Transportation System FHWA: Federal Highway Administration FLAP: Federal Lands Access Program FMSIB: Washington State Freight Mobility Strategic Investment Board FRA: Federal Railroad Administration 1-90: Interstate 90 IBL: Information by Location INFRA: Infrastructure for Rebuilding America ITS: Intelligent Transportation System KCSR: Kittitas County Search and Rescue KVFR: Kittitas Valley Fire and Rescue KVH: Kittitas Valley Hospital LEP: Limited English Proficiency M2 Team: WSDOT Multimodal, Multidisciplinary Team M3 Team: WSDOT Multimodal, Multidisciplinary, Multi -agency Team MP: Milepost NEPA: National Environmental Policy Act NSFLTP: Nationally Significant Federal Lands and Tribal Projects NWI: National Wetlands Inventory O&M: Operations and Maintenance PEL: Planning and Environmental Linkages Study SEPA: Washington State Environmental Policy Act SR: State Route STEAP: Screening Tool for Equity Analysis of Projects STEER 1-90: Safety, Transportation, Environment, Equity, and Resiliency on 1-90 Coalition TIFIA: Transportation Infrastructure Finance and Innovation Act USFS: U.S. Forest Service WDFW: Washington Department of Fish and Wildlife WSDOT. Washington State Department of Transportation VOLUME I: FEASIBILITY REPORT 1-90 Corridor - Easton to Cle Elunn Feasibility Study I ix GLOSSARY 0 Active transportation network: Infrastructure and facilities that support human -powered modes of transportation, such as walking and bicycling. Alignment: The path or route followed by a transportation facility, such as a roadway. Alternative(s): Possible solutions to accomplish a defined purpose and need that are considered as part of a decision -making process. These can include local and state transportation system mode and design options, as well as travel demand management and transportation system management -type improvements such as ramp metering, mass transit, and high occupancy vehicle (HOV) facilities. C Closed-circuit television (CCTV) monitoring: A closed system of traffic surveillance cameras designed for highway and road monitoring, allowing for remote management and data gathering. Commercial truck parking facilities: Designated areas or facilities where commercial trucks can safely park or stop for rest periods, reducing the need for trucks to park on highway shoulders or in nearby communities. Commercial vehicle systems: Technologies and tools designed for use by commercial vehicles, including navigation systems, tracking devices, and safety features. Connectivity: The degree to which the various roadways and other transportation facilities within a network are linked and integrated, facilitating smooth and efficient travel. Corridor: A defined path or route for transportation, typically referring to a major road or highway like the 1-90 corridor. Crash assessment: Evaluation of the history and patterns of vehicle collisions within a specific area to identify trends and deficiencies. A Ecosystem resiliency: The ability of ecosystems to withstand and recover from disturbances, such as floods or climate change impacts. Evaluations focus on maintaining ecosystem functions and adapting to changing conditions. Environmental justice (E)): The fair treatment and meaningful involvement of all people regardless of race, color, national origin or income with respect to the development, implementation, and enforcement of environmental laws, regulations and policies. This includes using an intersectional lens to address disproportionate environmental and health impacts by prioritizing highly impacted populations, equitably distributing resources and benefits, and eliminating harm. Environmental review: The consideration of environmental factors as required by NEPA and SEPA. The environmental review process is the procedure used by agencies and others to give appropriate consideration to the environment in decision making. VOLUME I: FEASIBILITY REPORT 1-90 Corridor - Easton to Cle Elunn Feasibility Study I x Equity: Fairness and impartiality in the distribution of benefits, resources, and impacts of transportation projects among different groups within a community. Evaluation criteria: Standards or factors used to assess the performance of proposed alternatives in transportation planning. These criteria are developed based on project objectives and may include factors such as environmental impact, cost-effectiveness, and community benefits. F Feasibility study: A study conducted to assess the practicality, constructability, and potential impacts of a proposed project. Freight mobility: The ability of goods and cargo to move efficiently and effectively within a transportation network. Intelligent Transportation System (ITS): An integrated system of advanced sensor, computer, electronics, and communication technologies and management strategies, used to increase the safety and efficiency of the surface transportation system. Z Median: The portion of a divided highway separating vehicular traffic traveling in opposite directions. Mobility: The ability of people and goods to move freely and easily within a transportation network. Multimodal: Involving or accommodating multiple modes of transportation, such as cars, buses, bicycles, and pedestrians. GLOSSARY 1 National Environmental Policy Act (NEPA): A U.S. environmental law that requires assessment and publication of environmental impacts related to any federally funded project. No build (existing conditions) alternative: A scenario where no changes are made to the existing transportation infrastructure, maintaining current conditions. Potential impacts of the no build alternative are evaluated and used a baseline for evaluation of the proposed alternative(s). A Performance ratings: Scores or ratings assigned to alternatives based on their performance against evaluation criteria. These ratings may be qualitative or quantitative and help decision -makers assess the effectiveness and suitability of each alternative. Planning and Environmental Linkages (PEL): A collaborative and integrated approach to transportation decision -making, intended to minimize duplication of work and streamline project development, that (1) considers environmental, community, and economic goals early in the planning process, and (2) uses the information, analysis, and products developed during planning to inform the environmental review process. Preferred alternative: The highest -scoring alternative as identified through the tiered evaluation process, indicating that it best meets project objectives while minimizing impacts on the environment, communities, and stakeholders. VOLUME I: FEASIBILITY REPORT 1-90 Corridor - Easton to Cle Elunn Feasibility Study I xi Preliminary design: The initial phase of design development for transportation projects, where conceptual designs are refined and detailed to a level suitable for environmental review and analysis. Project need statement: A statement identifying the baseline performance need for the project. For each identified project need, there may be one or more performance metrics, targets, and gaps. Project purpose: The primary objective or goal of a transportation project, often established to address specific needs or challenges within a community or region. L Qualitative analysis: Evaluation method that focuses on assessing the quality or characteristics of alternatives based on subjective judgments rather than numerical data. Qualitative analysis may involve assessing factors such as feasibility, social impact, and environmental compatibility. Quantitative data: Numerical data used in the evaluation process to measure the performance of alternatives against predefined criteria. Quantitative data may include metrics such as cost estimates, traffic flow, and environmental impact assessments. I Resiliency: The ability of a transportation system to withstand and recover from disruptions or disasters, such as extreme weather events or accidents. Reversible lanes: Traffic lanes that can be switched in direction to accommodate peak traffic flow, typically operated during specific times or conditions. GLOSSARY Right of way: The land or property owned or controlled by a government agency (e.g. WSDOT, the County, or a municipality) for the construction and maintenance of transportation infrastructure. Roadway widening: Increasing the width or capacity of a roadway by adding additional lanes or shoulders. S Safety: Measures and conditions aimed at protecting travelers and reducing the risk of crashes or injuries within the transportation system. Shoulder: The portion of the roadway adjacent to the travel lanes, used primarily for accommodation of stopped vehicles, emergency use, lateral support of the travel lanes, and where allowed, use by pedestrians and bicycles. Stakeholders: Individuals, groups, or organizations with an interest or concern in the outcome of a project, including residents, businesses, advocacy groups, and government agencies. State Environmental Policy Act (SEPA): State - level environmental legislation modeled after NEPA, requiring assessment of environmental impacts for projects within state jurisdiction and codified in RCW 43.21C. IN Tiered evaluation: An evaluation process divided into tiers or phases, with each tier assessing alternatives based on different levels of detail or criteria. Tier 1 typically involves an initial assessment of all alternatives, while Tier 2 focuses on a more detailed evaluation of top - ranked alternatives. VOLUME 1: FEASIBILITY REPORT 1-90 Corridor - Easton to Cle Elum Feasibility Study I xii GLOSSARY Traffic conditions: The state of traffic flow and congestion on roadways, often assessed based on factors like volume, speed, and density of vehicles. Traffic congestion: The condition of excessive traffic volumes or slow speeds on roadways, often resulting in delays and reduced efficiency of transportation systems. Traffic monitoring devices: Equipment used to collect data on traffic volume, speed, and other parameters for transportation planning and management. Transit network: System of public transportation services, including buses, shuttles, and rail transit, designed to move people within a region or area. Transportation demand: The demand travelers will make on the transportation system based on the number and types of trips they will take and the mode and routes they will use. W Weighted score: A composite score assigned to each alternative based on the relative importance or weight of different evaluation criteria. Weighted scores help prioritize alternatives based on their overall performance against project objectives. Wildlife connectivity: Refers to the ability of wildlife to move across landscapes, often impeded by roads and other barriers. Assessments aim to determine how transportation projects can impact wildlife habitats and migration corridors. VOLUME 1: FEASIBILITY REPORT 1-90 Corridor - Easton to Cie Elum Feasibility Study I xiii PROJECT BACKGROUND In response to citizen -led task forces such as the Upper Kittitas County Traffic Committee, working groups, and public comment, Kittitas County Public Works initiated the 1-90 Corridor— Easton to Cie Elum Feasibility Study in partnership with corridor stakeholders including the Washington State Department of Transportation (WSDOT) and the Safety, Transportation, Environment, Equity, and Resiliency on 1-90 (STEER 1-90) Coalition. Study Area Interstate 90 (1-90) spans 300 miles in Washington State from the Port of Seattle to the Idaho state line, continuing east across the United States. 1-90 is the major east -west transportation corridor in Washington State and is vital to commerce, economy, and recreation statewide. Passing through Kittitas County it is a scenic highway identified as the Mountain to Sound Greenway (National Heritage Area). Residents, tourists, and businesses have long commented on transportation inefficiencies between Easton and Cie Elum impacting safety, freight, and mobility. The area of study is located along the 1-90 corridor from Easton to Cie Elum, a 15-mile portion in Upper Kittitas County beginning at the West Easton interchange at milepost (MP) 70.3 and ending at the 1-90/State Route 970/903 interchange at MP 85 within WSDOT's South Central Region, and the Upper Kittitas County surrounding communities. Upper Kittitas County generally includes the Town of South Cie Elum, City of Cie Elum, City of Roslyn, and the areas of Ronald and Easton. Study Objectives The feasibility study aims to investigate concerns from stakeholders by engaging agencies and the public to identify and describe issues related to transportation demand, safety, freight mobility, the environment, resiliency, and equity/inclusion issues within the study area to identify possible solutions. VOLUME I: FEASIBILITY REPORT 1-90 Corridor Easton to Cie Elum Feasibility Study I xiv 1 INTRODUCTION Working in partnership with the Washington State Department of Transportation (WSDOT), the Kittitas County Public Works Department (County) has undertaken this feasibility study as an initial step in a planning and design process for improvements within the 1-90 corridor in Upper Kittitas County. 1.1 Study Area Kittitas County is located at the geographic center of Washington State, midway between the heavily populated Puget Sound region and the eastern rural areas centered around Moses Lake. More than half of the County is covered by forests, while less than two percent (2%) of the County is in urban development. The study area is a 15-mile section of 1-90 located in Upper Kittitas County beginning in Easton at milepost (MP) 70.3 and ending at the 1-90/State Route 970/903 interchange at MP 85 in Cie Elum, as well as the surrounding local roads and populated areas located north and south of 1-90 in this area (Figure 1-1). Within the study area, directly along the 1-90 corridor are the communities of Easton, Cie Elum, and South Cie Elum. Other communities north of 1-90 include Ronald and Roslyn. Numerous recreational areas serve residents and tourists, including the Palouse to Cascades State Park, Washington State Horse Park, Memorial Park, and the Sun Country Golf Course. Both the Yakima and Cie Elum Rivers run through the study area. Besides 1-90, key transportation facilities in the study area include the BNSF Snoqualmie Pass main line, and SR 903 serving Roslyn and Cie Elum. 1-90 in the study area is a designated scenic highway and is also part of the Mountains to Sound Greenway (National Heritage Area). 1.2 Purpose of This Feasibility Study Feasibility studies are used to determine the practicability, constructability, and level of impact of a proposed project. Based on stakeholder and community feedback, the conceptual alternatives that could potentially reduce or alleviate the concerns or issues at VOLUME 1: FEASIBILITY REPORT 1-90 Corridor Easton to Cle Elum Feasibility Study I 1 L � Q AV W .O a v, I i a� - c �= e c 1 w hand are developed. Feasibility studies are then conducted to analyze these alternatives based on a variety of factors including transportation and mobility, environment, equity, resiliency, government and local agency coordination, and public input. Although such an analysis is not as detailed as a design or environmental study, it is intended to provide enough information to allow project sponsors to make decisions by reducing the quantity and scope of alternatives. The findings of the feasibility study will guide a shift towards a more focused allocation of resources, facilitating effective investment in the subsequent stages of design and environmental assessment. Project Purpose and Need This feasibility study is designed to identify potential solutions which can fulfill the project's purpose and goals, and why the project is needed. Project Purpose and Goals The purpose of the project is to: • Ensure continued and improved safety to 1-90 users, including travelers, maintenance crews, freight operators, and emergency responders. • Enhance mobility and connectivity on 1-90 for passenger vehicles, freight, transit, and active modes and provide support for increased person and freight throughput. • Respect the surrounding environment and provide measures to address the resiliency of the system, improve wildlife connectivity, and reduce impacts to environmental baseline conditions. • Support equity by ensuring communities and individuals are not disproportionately impacted. CHAPTER l: INTRODUCTION Need for the Project The project is needed to ensure continued safety and mobility throughout the study area. Kittitas County is home to many key freight - generating and time -sensitive industries, including agriculture and forestry, with 1-90 serving as a key thoroughfare for these industries. Providing a transportation system that accommodates these key economic generators and the timely movement of goods is important to Kittitas County. As such, WSDOT has identified this corridor as one of the state's major truck corridors, which is a major economic driver in the region, through both customers to the businesses along the routes and providers of goods movement for producers and growers in the County. In addition, growth within the County — industrial and residential — is contributing to increased congestion along 1-90. Such growth is putting a strain on the roadway network, both in terms of traffic congestion and wear and tear. Most of the congestion in Kittitas County occurs at certain times of the year — near ski resorts in winter or routes accessing the lakes in the summer. Heavy seasonal congestion on 1-90 and state routes within the study area can lead to traffic diverting onto local county roads. This poses both safety risks and delays to residents and also increases the maintenance burden on the County. This feasibility study addresses potential solutions to such traffic growth and congestion. A study initiated by the County in 2019 (see Appendix A) found congestion along 1-90 is heaviest during summer weekends and major holidays (Memorial Day, 4th of July, and Labor Day). In the westbound direction, this regularly occurs between MP 70 and MP 93 on Sundays in summer, with the most extreme congestion occurring on the Mondays of Memorial Day and Labor Day holiday weekends. Holiday traffic VOLUME I: FEASIBILITY REPORT 1-90 Corridor Easton to Cle Elunn Feasibility Study 1 3 volumes are approximately four times higher on 1-90 and three times higher on county roads than typical days. Speeds drop from an average of 70 miles per hour (mph) to 15 mph on 1-90, and increase by approximately 5 mph on county roads, reflecting that non -local travelers tend to speed along the local roads as they avoid 1-90 congestion. On those specific Mondays, congestion lasts for 12 hours on 1-90, while diversion and increased speed lasts approximately 6 hours on the county roads. The study also found the average travel speed along 1-90 within the study area, at 1:00 pm on Memorial Day 2018, was less than 20 mph. Based on the historical speed data, there is congestion along the corridor between 10:00 am and 9:00 pm. Travel speeds increased past MP 70 (traveling westbound) where the freeway widens from two to three lanes. Compared with typical volumes on 1-90 (mid- week during the fall and spring months), the volumes on summer and holiday weekends were significantly higher. On an average weekday, the hourly volume never exceeded CHAPTER l: INTRODUCTION 1,000 vehicles per hour. On Memorial Day, the hourly volumes exceeded 2,500 vehicles per hour for 12 hours and the total daily demand is almost three times higher. Although this 2019 study focused on traffic between MP 70 and MP 93, the modeling results indicated major congestion resulted from traffic entering at MP 80. Therefore, this feasibility study addresses these traffic challenges by developing and analyzing potential alternative solutions between MP 70 and MP 85. 1.3 Study Partners In conducting this study, the County's priority was to coordinate with a broad range of groups who utilize or operate the transportation network within the study area. A key element of this effort included partnering with WSDOT to confirm proposed alternatives align with the State's goals and plans. Since 1-90 is a federal (Federal Highway Administration, FHWA) facility operated by WSDOT, it is VOLUME 1: FEASIBILITY REPORT 1-90 Corridor Easton to Cle Elunn Feasibility Study 1 4 critical to follow established guidelines and requirements to ensure any proposed solution can be implemented, pending funding and various state and federal approvals. Throughout this process, the County and WSDOT maintained ongoing and substantive discussions, including the creation of a WSDOT M3 (multimodal, multidisciplinary, multi - agency) Team. Complementing the work of the M3 Team and the County, review and input was also sought from the WSDOT M2 (multimodal, multidisciplinary) Team. Table 1-1 provides more information about these teams and their roles. CHAPTER 1: INTRODUCTION In addition, it was important to the County and WSDOT to gather meaningful input from local agencies and legislators, the U.S. Forest Service (USFS), and business representatives. As part of this outreach, the County funded the creation of the STEER 1-90 Coalition, which provides local leaders and the general public with a voice in this process. A meaningful public outreach program was also an important element of this study. Chapter 5 provides an overview of the public and stakeholder outreach, as well as input provided during outreach efforts. Table 1-1 WSDOT M2 and M3 Teams Team WSDOT Participants Role and Responsibility M3 • WSDOT South Central Region • Regional Administrator • Assistant Regional Administration • Local Programs • Design and Traffic Engineering • Multimodal Planning and Data Division • Provided input and local perspective on the content of the study at specific decision points • Focused on consistency with local plans and policies • Reviewed alternatives and evaluation methodology ................................................................... M2 • Multimodal Planning and Data Division • Provided input and statewide • Active Transportation Division perspective on the content of the • Capital Program Development and study at specific study decision Management points • Development Division • Focused on consistency with • Environmental Services Office WSDOT modal plans and policies • Maintenance • Office of Equal Opportunity • Public Transportation Division • Rail, Freight and Ports Division • Traffic; Transportation Safety and Systems Analysis Note: Kittitas County staff and project consultant team members also participated in the M3 and M2 meetings. VOLUME I: FEASIBILITY REPORT 1-90 Corridor Easton to Cle Elum Feasibility Study 1 5 CHAPTER 1. INTRODUCTION 1.4 Study Process and Approach Based on meaningful discussions with stakeholders and insights into public concerns, the County and WSDOT developed a study process designed to ensure that alternatives effectively addressed the project's needs. The Public, Stakeholder, and Agency Input criteria used to evaluate each alternative were carefully selected to accurately measure how well each alternative aligned with the project's purpose. Figure 1-2 provides a general overview of the process employed during this study, and Table 1-2 briefly describes each step in the process. Figure 1-2 Feasibility Study Process and Approach liminary rrnatives fluation . riteria Public, Stakeholder, and Agency Input Evaluate and Compare Alternatives (Tier 1 and Revised Tier 1 Evaluations) Evaluate and Compare To Three Alternati (Tier 2 Evaluati N a VOLUME I: FEASIBILITY REPORT 1-90 Corridor Easton', to Cle Elum Feasibility Study 1 6 CHAPTER l: INTRODUCTION Table 1-2 Feasibility Study Process and Approach Step Activity 1 To kick off the project, the County and WSDOT met and interviewed key stakeholders and held a webinar to collect public comments and concerns. A public survey was also conducted to obtain community concerns regarding current travel conditions on 1-90 in the study area. ................................................................................................................................................................. 2 Based on the information provided from the outreach process, the purpose for evaluating and confirming the needs to the 1-90 corridor were confirmed. The study area and priority of needs were refined. ................................................................................................................................................................. 3 Based on the purpose and need stemming from public input, alternative solutions were identified. Measures to rate the effectiveness of the alternatives (how they met the purpose and need of the project) were also developed. ................................................................................................................................................................. 4 The alternatives were evaluated (Tier 1 Evaluation) based on the criteria. As part of this analysis, the current, existing conditions within the study area were documented in support of the evaluation. Traffic modeling was performed to assess current and future conditions on 1-90 during periods of issues. ................................................................................................................................................................. 5 Findings from the initial Tier 1 Evaluation were presented to the M2 and M3 Teams. Based on input from the M2 Team, the evaluation criteria were revised, and a Revised Tier 1 Evaluation was performed. ................................................................................................................................................................. 6 Following the Revised Tier 1 Evaluation, the three alternatives that scored the highest in their ability to solve the challenges along the 1-90 corridor in the study area were identified. ................................................................................................................................................................. 7 The top three alternatives were then evaluated against each other, with some criteria modified or updated to further differentiate the three alternatives. ................................................................................................................................................................. 8 Based on public and stakeholder input, as well as discussion between the County and WSDOT, an alternative was chosen to move forward for further design and environmental analysis, pending project funding. VOLUME I: FEASIBILITY REPORT 1-90 Corridor - Easton to Cle Elunn Feasibility Study 1 7 2 RANGE OF ALTERNATIVES This chapter presents the range of conceptual alternatives that were considered as part of this feasibility study. These alternatives were developed through a collaborative process, incorporating feedback from the community and stakeholders, as well as input and guidance from Kittitas County (the County) and the Washington State Department of Transportation (WSDOT). Alternatives development was focused on addressing the project's overarching purpose: to enhance mobility and connectivity in the study area while ensuring continued and improved safety. The seven alternatives considered include three situated within the existing 1-90 right of way, one representing the no -build scenario (reflecting existing conditions), and three alternatives involving the widening of existing roadways or the creation of new ones (see Figure 2-1). Once an alternatives) is selected to move forward into the next phase of analysis, the concepts presented in this. chapter will be further refined and designed. As part of the design, WSDOT's Complete Streets process will be incorporated into the process, as appropriate. Complete Streets is an approach to planning, designing, building, operating, and maintaining the transportation system that enables safe and convenient access to destinations for all people, including pedestrians, bicyclists, motorists, and transit riders. It uses a set of tools or treatments that create a more balanced and resilient transportation system. VOLUME I: FEASIBILITY REPORT 1-90 Corridor - Easton to Cle Elunn Feasibility Study 1 8 2.1 No Build Alternative (Existing Conditions) This alternative would leave 1-90 between MP 70 and MP 85 in its current configuration, with no changes to its posted speed, lane width, or access points. The No Build Alternative is referred to as Alternative 6 throughout this document. Description This section of 1-90 provides two 12-foot wide lanes in each direction, with inside shoulders of 5 feet and outside shoulders of 10 feet. The median is a 66-foot-wide grassy area, which currently serves as storage for snow during severe winter conditions. Current posted speeds along this section of 1-90 are 70 mph. Figure 2-2 shows a perspective rendering of the existing conditions. CHAPTER 2: RANGE OF ALTERNATIVES Considerations Based on a 2019 analysis performed along this corridor (Appendix A), key results indicated congestion along 1-90 is heaviest during summer weekends and major holidays (Memorial Day, 4th of July, and Labor Day). During these periods of congestion, speeds drop from an average of 70 mph to 10 mph on 1-90, and increase by approximately 5 mph on county roads, reflecting that non - local travelers tend to speed along the local roads as they avoid 1-90 congestion. On those specific holiday weekends, congestion lasts for 10 hours on 1-90, while diversion and increased speed lasts approximately 6 hours on the county roads. Figure 2-2 No Build Conditions (Alternative 6) VOLUME I: FEASIBILITY REPORT 1-90 Corridor - Easton to Cle Elunn Feasibility Study 1 10 2.2 Alternative 1: Widen 1-90 on the Outside Alternative 1 would widen 1-90 on the outside to add one new lane in each direction. Existing lane widths would not change, nor would the existing median and inside shoulder. The new lane would be 12 feet wide with a new outside shoulder of 10 feet (in both directions) and inside shoulders of 4 to 10 feet. The new roadway would result in three lanes in each direction. Most of the land required for expansion is located within existing WSDOT right-of-way, though some additional property will be required. Figure 2-3 presents the general alignment for Alternative 1 (as well as Alternatives 2 and 3, presented later in this chapter). Figure 2-4 shows a perspective cross-section of the proposed alternative. Considerations • Widening would occur primarily within existing WSDOT right-of-way. • Some private property impacts would occur at MP74. • Property impacts to Washington State Department of Fish and Wildlife at MP 79.1 due to realignment. CHAPTER 2: RANGE OF ALTERNATIVES • Median would stay intact, allowing for continued use for WSDOT maintenance. • Both Cie Elum River Bridges 90/134N and 90/134S would need to be replaced at MP 80.85. • Widening towards the median would still be required to locations to avoid larger impacts. • Most existing bridges spanning over the 1-90 corridor would need to be replaced. • This alternative assumes the replacement of all culverts and stream structures to the current requirements for fish or hydraulic demand. • Stormwater treatment facilities may require additional property needs due to reduction of width in the right of way. • This option provides the ability for WSDOT Maintenance and/or contractors to close a single lane on 1-90 during daytime hours and maintain two lanes of traffic. VOLUME 1: FEASIBILITY REPORT 1-90 Corridor - Easton to Cle Elum Feasibility Study 1 11 w � V J w �f z- ., `O � r J z C w 0 z w Q J O S' C 5 c o F 0 0 c , t c �•.z f� WE " I-j J : O CHAPTER 2: RANGE OF ALTERNATIVES 2.3 Alternative 2: Widen 1-90 in the Median Alternative 2 would widen 1-90 on the inside to add one new lane in each direction. Existing lane widths would not change, nor would the existing outside shoulder. The median would be used for the two new lanes and a new inside shoulder; the new lanes would be 12 feet wide with a new inside shoulders of 4 to 10 feet (in both directions). The new roadway would result in three lanes in each direction. Most of the land required for expansion is located within the existing WSDOT right-of-way. Figure 2-3 presents the general alignment for Alternative 2. Figure 2-5 shows a perspective cross-section of the proposed alternative. Considerations • Widening would occur within existing WSDOT right of way (median). • Additional median barriers/cable barriers would be required due to the reduction in the clear zone. • Interior existing lanes would need to be replaced to change the cross slope of the road to drain to the outside. • Median width would be decreased, possibly interfering with current WSDOT maintenance and emergency vehicle use. • Property impacts to Washington State Department of Fish and Wildlife at MP 79.1 due to realignment. • Both Cle Elum River Bridges 90/134N and 90/134S would need to be replaced at MP 80.85. • This alternative assumes the replacement of all culverts and stream structures to the current requirements for fish or hydraulic demand. • Widening towards the outside would still be required in select locations to avoid larger impacts. • This option presents the least risk of affecting or necessitating the replacement of the current bridges spanning the 1-90 corridor. The center barrier would be constructed around the existing center piers. However, it's important to acknowledge that many of the bridges in this corridor are approaching the end of their designed lifespans and might require replacement regardless of efforts to avoid impacts. • This option provides the ability for WSDOT Maintenance and/or contractors to close a single lane on 1-90 during daytime hours and maintain two lanes of traffic. VOLUME 1: FEASIBILITY REPORT 1-90 Corridor Easton to Cle Elum Feasibility Study 1 14 CHAPTER 2: RANGE OF ALTERNATIVES 2.4 Alternative 3: Widen 1-90 in the Median, Reversible Lanes Alternative 3 is based on an approach to add flexibility to the 1-90 corridor by adding more lanes in the direction of traffic when at the times they are most needed. This alternative would add two new lanes within the existing 1-90 median. The direction of the two lanes would change direction based on peak demand (for example, Sunday westbound, Friday eastbound). This alternative would create four lanes in the direction during the days/hours when traffic is heaviest. Access into the reversible lanes would occur only at MP 70 and MP 85 with potential intermediate access points. Additionally, opportunities for emergency service vehicles to exit at various locations would be provided. Interlocat traffic would generally not use the reversible lanes while long-distance commercial freight and those looking to get through this section without stopping would use this bypass route during peak travel times. Existing lane widths on 1-90 would not change, nor would the existing outside shoulder. The median would be used for the two new lanes, barriers from existing 1-90 lanes, and new inside shoulders. Each new lane would be 12 feet wide with new inside shoulders of 4 to 10 feet. Most of the land required for expansion is located within the existing WSDOT right-of-way. Figure 2-3 presents the general alignment for Alternative 3. Figure 2-6 shows a perspective cross-section of the proposed alternative. Considerations • Widening would occur within existing WSDOT right of way (median). • Median width would be decreased, possibly interfering with current WSDOT maintenance strategies. • During non -peak travel times, reversible lanes could be ofFline or not operational. • Congestion in the non -peak direction would occur during the heaviest travel periods. • Access to the reversible lanes would be limited to MP 70 and MP 85. • Median barriers would delineate the new lanes. • The alignment of the new lanes within the existing median would vary to avoid impacts and also accommodate constructability. • This alternative assumes the replacement of all culverts and stream structures to the current requirements for fish or hydraulic demand. • Property impacts to Washington State Department of Fish and Wildlife at MP 79.1 due to realignment. • This option would not trigger the replacement of the Cle Elum River Bridges 90/134N and 90/134S at MP 80.85. An independent structure has been constructed previously in the median between the existing bridges (2022 Bridge Painting Project). • Widening towards the outside of the existing roadway would still be required in select locations where median width is not availabte. • Most existing bridges spanning over the 1-90 corridor would need to be replaced due to impacts to the center pier. VOLUME 1: FEASIBILITY REPORT 1-90 Corridor Easton to Cle Elum Feasibility Study 1 16 • Existing on and off ramps between MP 70 and MP 85 would not require alteration unless the new bridge overcrossing. • This alternative may be conducive to providing an emergency detour/bypass route when incidents require the closure of the existing eastbound or westbound 1-90 lanes within MP 70 and 85 (collisions, wildfires, roadway repairs). • This option allows WSDOT Maintenance or contractors to fully close two lanes CHAPTER 2: RANGE OF ALTERNATIVES of 1-90 in either direction and be able to perform construction, maintenance, and preservation duties in the safest work zone environment. • Commercial truck weigh station notifications, methods, or locations would need to be relocated before MP 70 and MP 85 before entering the bypass/reversible lanes. VOLUME I: FEASIBILITY REPORT 1-90 Corridor - Easton to Cle Elum Feasibility Study 1 17 2.5 Alternative 4A: North - SR 903 Alternative 4A was developed to explore whether improvements outside the interstate system could address the identified project needs. This alternative focuses on areas north of 1-90, starting at SR 903 near Cie Elum Lake and extending to 1-90 at MP 70. The primary objective of this alternative is to offer an alternative route for communities and businesses without relying solely on 1-90 between MP 70 and MP 85. It involves constructing approximately 12 miles of new roadway and widening existing roads to add capacity, featuring two 12-foot lanes in each direction with 6-foot shoulders adjacent to each lane. Upgrades will be made to existing roads such as Lake Cie Elum Dam Road, Tumble Creek Drive, various Forest Roads, and Sparks Road (East and West) to meet current roadway design standards. Some sections will require constructing new roads on undisturbed terrain or utilizing existing gravel maintenance roads, while other sections will involve using existing roads with one 12-foot wide lane in each direction. Figure 2-7 shows a conceptual cross-section of Alternative 4A. Figure 2-8 presents the general alignment for the proposed alternative. CHAPTER 2: RANGE OF ALTERNATIVES Considerations • Provides an alternative route for the Ronald and Roslyn community. • Provides a new emergency route for the communities if a major failure occurs on Interstate 90. • Creates a new fire break and access for wildland firefighters. • Could provide a connection from Lake Cie Elum to the Palouse to the Cascades State Park Trail. • Alternative length is long based upon steep terrain where existing roads do not exist. Grading for a roadway would result in major land transformation to the existing area along the corridor. • New bridge structures would be required across Cie Elum River and side channels. • This volume of new roadway in a river area is a very high risk to culturally sensitive areas (fatal flaw element). • This alternative could provide economic growth opportunities if land use zoning changes were modified. • Impacts to Endangered Species Act (ESA) listed fish and terrestrial species as well as to aquatic resources. • Potential impacts to historic and cultural sites, as well as parks and recreational facilities. • Could impact wildlife connectivity. Figure 2-7 Alternative 4A — Conceptual Cross -Section VOLUME 1: FEASIBILITY REPORT 1-90 Corridor - Easton to Cle Elum Feasibility Study 1 19 O 3 4 2.6 Alternative 4B: North - Bullfrog Road Alternative 4B was formulated to investigate whether enhancements outside the interstate system could meet the identified project requirements. This option concentrates on a route less impactful to undisturbed areas around the outlet of Lake Cie Elum and the riparian area of the Cie Elum River and establishing a more parallel collector - distributor route north of 1-90, commencing at Bullfrog Road just south of Suncadia and Roslyn and connecting to 1-90 at MP 70. Spanning approximately 10 miles, this alternative involves both new construction and upgrades to existing roadways. Parts of the route will run alongside existing power line right-of-ways and access roads. The new roadway will feature two 12-foot lanes in each direction with 6-foot shoulders adjacent to each lane. Additionally, certain existing roadways like Bullfrog Road, Jenkins Drive, Heron Drive, and Sparks Road (East and West) will be widened and straightened. Currently, these roads have one lane in each direction, with lanes approximately 12 feet wide. Figure 2-9 shows a conceptual cross-section for Alternative 4B. Figure 2-10 presents the general alignment for the proposed alternative. CHAPTER 2: RANGE OF ALTERNATIVES Considerations • Provides an alternative route for Roslyn and Suncadia. • Could provide a connection or paralleling non -motorized route to the Palouse to Cascades State Park Trail. • Provides a new emergency route for the communities if a major failure occurs on Interstate 90. • Creates a new fire break and access for wildland firefighters. • Grading for a roadway would result in major land transformation to the existing area along the corridor. • This volume of new roadway in a forested area near streams is a very high risk to culturally sensitive areas (fatal flaw element). • This alternative could provide economic growth opportunities if land use zoning changes were modified. • Impacts to ESA listed fish and terrestrial species as well as to aquatic resources. • Potential impacts to historic and cultural sites, as well as parks and recreational facilities. • Could impact wildlife connectivity. Figure 2-9 Alternative 4B — Conceptual Cross -Section VOLUME I: FEASIBILITY REPORT 1-90 Corridor - Easton to Cle Elum Feasibility Study 1 21 Ir gUg d� I' z O J f z CHAPTER 2: RANGE OF ALTERNATIVES 2.7 Alternative 5: South Alternative 5 was proposed as a means to assess non -interstate enhancements south of the 1-90 corridor, aiming to meet the needs of the community. This alternative explores the possibility of upgrading the current roadway serving as an 1-90 bypass route to accommodate increased traffic volumes and speeds during times of congestion on 1-90. The upgraded corridor would enhance capacity and connectivity between Easton and Cie Elum, bypassing the 1-90 roadway. The proposed realignment would start at Exit 70 and reconnect to 1-90 at Exit 85. To achieve this, a total of four lanes (adding one new lane in each direction) would be incorporated into Lake Easton Road, Railroad Street, Nelson Siding Road, Westside Drive, and Lower Peoh Point Road. Some segments of the alignment might require the construction of entirely new roads, each featuring two lanes in each direction. These roadways would consist of two 12-foot lanes in each direction with 6-foot shoulders adjacent to each lane. Currently, existing roadways primarily feature one lane in each direction, with lanes approximately 12 feet wide. Figure 2-11 shows a conceptual cross-section for Alternative 5. Figure 2-12 presents the general alignment for the proposed alternative. Considerations • Provides an alternative route for Nelson and South Cie Elum. • Route is currently often used by travelers when 1-90 traffic is congested. • This route would require multiple bridge structures over streams and creeks, including one over the Yakima River. • The new bridge structure over the Yakima River would impact proposed restoration work happening along the Yakima River at Hanson Ponds. • This would create a new southern connection to the existing interchange at MP 85 to better serve access to South Cie Elum. • Provides a more efficient emergency route for the communities if a major failure occurs on Interstate 90. • Grading for a roadway would result in major land transformation to the existing area along the corridor. • This route moves through areas of existing rural residential developments and communities. • This volume of new roadway expansion in undisturbed areas near streams is a very high risk to culturally sensitive areas (fatal flaw element). • This alternative could provide economic growth opportunities if land use zoning changes were modified. • Impacts to ESA listed fish and terrestrial species as well as to aquatic resources. • Potential impacts to historic and cultural sites, as well as parks and recreational facilities. • Could impact wildlife connectivity. Figure 2-11 Alternative 5 — Conceptual Cross -Section VOLUME I: FEASIBILITY REPORT 1-90 Corridor - Easton to Cle Elum Feasibility Study 1 23 N r V 2.8 Other Potential Improvements Apart from the alternatives outlined earlier, various other initial alternatives were identified and deliberated upon during stakeholder meetings, public input sessions, and M2 Team meetings. While these suggested improvements hold value in enhancing the corridor or as a short-term action item, they were not deemed comprehensive enough to proceed as part of the Tier 1 analysis. These improvements include the following: County Road Safety Improvements In recent years, a number of techniques and tools have been considered by the County to increase safety and decrease congestion along County roads. The County and local agencies can continue to work with the public and stakeholders to further consider and implement various safety features, such as new striping and signage. Local and County law enforcement can increase patrols along County roads to discourage speeding in residential areas. Intelligent Transportation System (ITS) Infrastructure The alternative of incorporating additional Intelligent Transportation System (ITS infrastructure was considered, which involves integrating more advanced messaging signs, speed reduction signs, closed-circuit television (CCTV) monitoring, and traffic monitoring devices. These enhancements aim to alert drivers about a change in conditions, congestion, collisions blocking the roadway, and slow speeds ahead of the study area, enabling them to avoid potential issues. CHAPTER 2: RANGE OF ALTERNATIVES However, this option was not advanced as an independent Tier 1 alternative. • ITS infrastructure is already in place along the 1-90 corridor and is continually being upgraded. • WSDOT has diversified their public outreach methods such as text messaging, website notices, commercial vehicle systems, and cell phone applications, which effectively provide early notifications to drivers. • The implementation of ITS is an existing WSDOT policy for any new project, especially concerning interstate improvements. It's understood that with any proposed alternatives on 1-90, additional and upgraded ITS components would already be included in the project scope of work. Commercial Truck Parking Facilities Based on input from stakeholders and local business leaders, parking facilities either in or outside the existing 1-90 right of way were suggested. These independent facilities could be implemented independently from this project and funded privately or with public funds. This initiative aims to alleviate issues such as trucks parking on the side of the interstate, occupying on and off -ramp shoulders, and parking in adjacent communities while awaiting deliveries to regional ports or for closed roadways to reopen. This proposal emerged consistently during interviews with stakeholders and local communities. However, while such facilities could assist trucks during delivery wait times and closures, they do not fully address the majority of the purposes and needs identified in this study. VOLUME I: FEASIBILITY REPORT 1-90 Corridor Easton to Cle Elum Feasibility Study 1 25 CHAPTER 2: RANGE OF ALTERNATIVES There is a clear demand and necessity for additional truck parking. Integrating such facilities into any of the identified 1-90 alternatives or developing them as standalone projects in collaboration with local public agencies or private entities would be highly beneficial. Currently, ongoing efforts are being made to address this specific concern by various public agencies: • WSDOT is currently evaluating potential opportunities to expand truck parking at safety rest areas and commercial vehicle inspection sites along Interstate 5 and Interstate 90. analysis of sites adjacent to Interstate 90 near North Bend. • The Washington State Freight Mobility Strategic Investment Board (FMSIB), in consultation with WSDOT, is developing an implementation plan for truck parking solutions' FMSIB designated strategic freight corridors in 2023 and will soon begin prioritizing these corridors and addressing related issues, which may include the development of truck parking facilities. Passenger Rail • WSDOT is coordinating with local The Federal Railroad Administration (FRA) governments, ports, and private entities is currently conducting a rail study which in developing recommendations for state is reevaluated discontinued long distance assistance in the development of private passenger rail service in the United States. truck parking sites, including a feasibility As part of this study, a stakeholder group 1 https://wsdot.wa.gov/construction-VIannm,+/statewide-i.,..—,,i.;g... I vans VOLUME I: FEASIBILITY REPORT 1-90 Corridor Easton to Cle Elunn Feasibility Study 1 26 from Washington State has been stressing the importance of evaluating train service from Seattle to central Washington, including stops in Kittitas County and through Yakama. The current train service, although it does travel to Spokane from Western Washington (and Portland, OR) travels along a northern route and does not provide service to residents and travelers in Kittitas. The rail study, FRA Long Distance Rail Study, is in the early stages of working with stakeholders and collecting information.' CHAPTER 2: RANGE OF ALTERNATIVES in addition, in June 2020, the Washington Legislature directed the Joint Transportation Committee to study the potential for passenger rail service that would serve Auburn, Ellensburg, Yakima and the Tri-Cities. The study, Feasibility of an East-West Intercity Passenger Rail System for Washington State, concluded that ridership "is not expected to be high due to long journey times and relatively low number of long-distance car trips today." The study is expected to be completed by year end 2024.3 2 htt-s://fratorgdistancerailstud .ors/ 3 https://Ie .wa.pov/JTC/Documents/Studies/East%20West%2ORail/EastWestRail_flnatRe+ortJune2020.:df VOLUME I: FEASIBILITY REPORT 1-90 Corridor Easton to Cle Elum Feasibility Study 1 27 3 EXISTING CONDITIONS IN THE STUDY AREA The study area is located along the 1-90 corridor from Easton to Cle Elum in Upper Kittitas County and includes 1-90 and surrounding county and local roads. Communities in the study area include Easton, Cle Elum, South Cle Elum, Roslyn, Nelson, and Ronald. The following sections provide an overview of the current transportation and traffic conditions along the roadways, as well as existing environmental and community conditions within the study area. Each section is organized based on the project goals and evaluation criteria discussed in Chapter Four. VOLUME I: FEASIBILITY REPORT 1-90 Corridor - Easton to Cle Elum Feasibility Study 1 28 CHAPTER 3: EXISTING CONDITIONS IN THE STUDYAREA 3.1 Safety Table 3-1 Collision Types along 1-90 in the Study Area, 2018 through 2023 The safety discussion includes information regarding collisions along 1-90, as well as %of Collision Type Crashes surrounding County roads. In addition, common Total emergency and evacuation routes are also Barrier/Median 131 17% discussed, including typical responders. ........................................••••..••.•..........•..............•• Struck Animal 119 16% 3.1.1 Existing Crash ............................................................................. Object/Road Debris 57 8% Assessment............................................................................. Overturned 40 5% An assessment of existing crash history ..Vehicle ............................... was performed to determine overall trends/ Rear End 180 24% deficiencies on the 1-90 corridor in the study ...........................""""""o ................................... Side-swi a 86 11/° area. The existing safety assessment of the 1-90 corridor is focused on both eastbound Snow/Earth Bank 44 6% and westbound travel lanes between Easton """"""""""""'...""."""".........."'............ Over Embankment/ and Cie Elum. The Washington Department 30 4/a Ditch of Transportation (WSDOT) provided existing crash history data on this portion of 1-90 and Other* 69 9% local roads in the study area for the most Total 756 100% recent complete six years (2018 through 2023). The existing crash data is summarized in the Source: WSDOT, January 30, 2024 following sections. *Note: "Other" collision types include, but are not limited to: fire started in vehicle; jackknife trailer; vehicle struck pedestrian; one parked - one moving; and from same direction - all others 1-90 Crash History Existing data includes 756 crashes that Table 3-2 Collisions byInjury Severity along occurred on the I-90 mainline between I-90 in the Study Area, 2018 through 2023 mileposts (MP) 70 and 85 during the six -year period. This averages a total of 126 crashes per Injury Severity Crashes % of year or roughly one every three days. Total As shown in Table 3-1, the most common Fatal 8 1% collision types on this section of 1-90 include Serious Injury 12 2% rear -ends (24%), a vehicle hitting a barrier or ..........................................................................••. median (17%), and a vehicle hitting an animal Minor Injury 73 10% (predominantly deer and elk; 16%). ............................................................................. possible Injury 97 13% ............................................................................. As illustrated in Table 3-2, 74 percent of all crashes that occurred on this portion of 1-90 during the six -year period were property - damage -only crashes. There were eight fatalities and twelve serious injury crashes over the six -year period. Property Damage 558 74% Only (PDO) ........................................................................... Unknown 8 1% Total 756 100% Source: WSDOT, January 30, 2024 VOLUME I: FEASIBILITY REPORT 1-90 Corridor — Easton to Cle Elunn Feasibility Study 1 29 CHAPTER 3: EXISTING CONDITIONS IN THE STUDY AREA Table 3-3 Injury Severity by Collision Type along 1-90 in the Study Area, 2018 through 2023 Injury Severity 2 TO m 9 V W a X U -� o Wo +�+ 1.1 L > 0 LN L GJ to In W 3 iA m •_ Y G f0 0 W E L o Fatal 3 0 1 1 0 0 0 1 2 .................................................................................................................................................................... Serious Injury 1 1 2 2 3 0 1 2 0 .................................................................................................................................................................... Minor Injury 9 7 7 8 22 3 8 6 3 .................................................................................................................................................................... Possible Injury .................................................................................................................................................................... 16 8 6 9 37 4 4 6 7 Property Damage 101 102 41 17 118 79 29 14 57 Only (PDO) ................................................................................................................................................... ............. Unknown 1 1 0 3 0 0 2 1 0 Total 131 119 57 40 180 86 44 30 69 Source: WSDOT, January30, 2024 *Note: `Other" fatal collision types included: vehicle struck pedestrian; and one parked - one moving Table 3-4 Injury Severity by Time of Year along 1-90 in the Study Area, 2018 through 2023 >a toa c� -- Ea > C z 2 a UL Injury Severity in � cn � LL In� � Fatal 4 2 1 1 ....................................................................... Serious Injury 2 3 6 1 ....................................................................... Minor Injury 12 27 17 17 ....................................................................... Possible Injury 18 36 13 30 ....................................................................... Property Damage 84 159 126 189 Only (PDO) ......................................................... ........ Unknown 0 2 1 5 Total 120 229 164 243 Source: WSDOT, January30, 2024 As shown in Table 3-3, the collision type involving a vehicle hitting a barrier or median resulted in the highest percentage of severe injury collisions. Rear end crashes were recorded at the most common collision type, predominantly resulting in less severe injuries or no injury at all. As presented in Table 3-4, the spring season experienced the fewest overall collisions on this section of 1-90, but had the highest percentage of fatal and serious injury crashes (5%). The winter season experienced the highest number of collisions overall, and also the highest percentage of property damage only collisions (78%). VOLUME I: FEASIBILITY REPORT 1-90 Corridor Easton to Cie Elunn Feasibility Study 130 Table 3-5 Injury Severity by Road Conditions along I-90 in the StudyArea, 2018 through 2023 Injury Severity c " s L N +� di Fatal 7 0 1 0 ............................................................................ Serious Injury 8 0 2 2 ............................................................................ Minor Injury 48 6 13 6 ............................................................................ Possible Injury 66 10 12 9 ............................................................................ Property Damage 340 40 134 44 Only (PDO) Unknown 5 1 2 0 Total 474 57 164 61 Source: INSDOT, January30, 2024 CHAPTER 3: EXISTING CONDITIONS IN THE STUDY AREA As shown in Table 3-5, approximately 65% of all collisions and 75% of all fatal and serious injury collisions on 1-90 in the study area occurred during dry road conditions. Local Roadway Crash History An assessment of existing crash history was also performed for portions of local roads within Kittitas County where potential roadway improvements may be implemented as part of this project. Based on County data, there were several roadways that experienced zero crashes during the six -year period, including W Sparks Road, E Sparks Road, Lake Cie Elum Dam Road, S Cie Elum Way, Heron Drive, Tumble Creek Road, Jenkins Drive, Tall Timber Trail, Lake Easton Road, Cie Etum Way, Madison Street, Rossetti Way, and Reservoir Canyon Road. 1 - ' r � � is • y VOLUME I: FEASIBILITY REPORT 1-90 Corridor - Easton to Cle Elunn Feasibility Study 1 31 CHAPTER 3: EXISTING CONDITIONS IN THE STUDY AREA 3.1.2 Emergency Response Services A number of emergency response agencies operate in the study area, including ambulance, fire, and police services. Depending on where these services are located and where they are dispatched, many use 1-90 within the study area and therefore experience current traffic conditions and are impacted by congestion, potentially delaying response times. These services are summarized in the following sections. Medical Kittitas County Public Hospital District #2 Kittitas County Public Hospital District #2 provides ambulance services through Upper Kittitas County Medic One and is the only licensed, advanced life support service in Upper Kittitas County. The hospital district also supports a small amount of the care provided at Kittitas Valley Hospital (KVH) Urgent Care — Cle Elum and the Open Door Medical Clinic. The district serves Kittitas County from the King/ Kittitas County border at Snoqualmie Pass to the Elk Heights area (about 7 miles southeast of Cie Elum)? Fire Fire District 3 — Easton Kittitas County Fire District 3 provides fire protection and emergency response services to the residents of Easton and the surrounding areas. 1 https://www.ukcrnedicone.org/ 2 htt s:/1� kc�fdZor-',I 3 https://www.cleelumfire.com/ Fire District 6 — Ronald The Kittitas County Fire District 6 service area covers 17.2 square miles, serving all of Ronald, Lake Cie Elum, Salmon La Sac north to Hex Mountain, and parts of Suncadia. The district operates three stations and shares automatic mutual aid with Cie Elum Fire Department, Roslyn Fire Department, and Hospital District 2. It also provides mutual aid to Districts 1, 3, and 7 as requested. Fire District 7 — Cie Elum Kittitas County Fire District 7 is the largest fire district in the Upper Kittitas County area, covering 126 square miles around the communities of Cie Elum, South Cle Elum, Roslyn, and Ronald. The district provides services from eight stations with 16 full-time firefighters and 52 volunteer firefighters, averaging over 800 calls annually. The district is the primary backup transporting agency for Kittitas County Public Hospital District42. In addition to 19 miles of 1-90, Kittitas County Fire District 7 covers approximately 20 miles along SR 970, extending to SR 97 up to the top of Blewett Pass. This accounts for many collisions, extrications, and accident responses during the busy summer weekends and snow- covered winter months.2 City of Cie Elum Fire Department The Cie Elum Volunteer Fire Department has two stations and 42 volunteers. The department is responsible for approximately five square miles of area in Kittitas County and receives a current call volume of over 500 calls a year .3 VOLUME I: FEASIBILITY REPORT 1-90 Corridor Easton to Cie Elum Feasibility Study 1 32 City of Roslyn Fire Department The Roslyn Fire Department is a volunteer department serving the residents of Roslyn and the surrounding areas with one station. Town of South Cie Elum Fire Department The South Cie Elum Fire Department is a volunteer department serving South Cie Elum with one station. Kittitas Valley Fire and Rescue Kittitas Valley Fire and Rescue (KVFR) provides mutual aid throughout all of Kittitas County. Law Enforcement Kittitas County Sheriff's Office / Search and Rescue The Kittitas County Sheriff's Office, located in Ellensburg, serves the entire county. The Sheriff's Office is comprised of around 40 officers and is headed by the County Sheriff.' Additionally, Kittitas County Search and Rescue (KCSR) is an all -volunteer, non-profit organization whose mission is to provide personnel for the Sheriff's Office to conduct search, rescue, recovery, and evacuation operations, primarily within Kittitas County. KCSR does not act in any capacity except at the direction of the Sheriff's Office.' Cle Elum-Roslyn Police Department The Cie Elum-Roslyn Police Department has the unique responsibility of providing law 4 https://www.co.kittitas.wa.us/sheriff 5 https://kittitassar.or_F,,/ CHAPTER 3: EXISTING CONDITIONS IN THE STUDYAREA enforcement services to the citizens of Cie Elum and Roslyn. These services include traffic safety, community policing, vehicular crash investigation, crime prevention and investigation, and public education. The department consists of a Chief, Corporal, seven patrol officers, and one part-time animal control officer, with at least one patrol officer on -duty at all times. Depending upon the location of the emergency, and the office/service being dispatched, 1-90, as well as surrounding County roads, are used to respond. 3.1.3 Evacuation Routes 1-90 is a major thoroughfare through the study area, and therefore also serves as an evacuation route in case of natural disasters or other emergencies. Because it is generally well -maintained and less susceptible to closures due to weather conditions compared to alternative routes through mountain passes, its reliability makes it a preferred evacuation route over local county or city corridors. Additionally, the communities of Roslyn, Ronald, South Cie Elum, Cie Elum, Easton, and Kittitas County have various mutual service agreements for fire and medical services, making 1-90 a critical link between these communities. VOLUME 1: FEASIBILITY REPORT 1-90 Corridor - Easton to Cle Elum Feasibility Study 1 33 3.2 Transportation Demand The transportation demand discussion includes information regarding traffic conditions on 1-90 and surrounding roadways. Also included below is a discussion of other existing transportation facilities in the study area. 3.2.1 Traffic Conditions 1-90 traffic conditions in the study area were reviewed and modeled to determine peak congestion times. These analyses took place in 2019 and 2023 and are discussed below. Modeling and analysis focused on westbound traffic since data indicate traffic is more dispersed in the eastbound direction over various weekend days. 2019 Analysis An analysis of 1-90 and county roads within the Upper Kittitas County area was completed in 2019 (Appendix A), specifically evaluating how holiday traffic congestion on 1-90 impacts the local road network. As part of this effort, CHAPTER 3: EXISTING CONDITIONS IN THE STUDY AREA several potential capital improvements that might address traffic congestion issues stemming from holiday traffic were modeled. Holiday Congestion Congestion along 1-90 is heaviest during summer weekends and major holidays (Memorial Day, 4th of July, and Labor Day). In the westbound direction, this regularly occurs between MP 70 and MP 93 on Sundays in summer, with the most extreme congestion occurring on the Mondays of Memorial Day and Labor Day holiday weekends. Holiday traffic volumes are approximately four times higher on 1-90 and three times higher on county roads than typical days. Speeds drop from an average of 70 mph to 15 mph on 1-90, and increase by approximately 5 mph on county roads, reflecting that non -local travelers tend to speed along the local roads as they avoid 1-90 congestion. On those specific Mondays, congestion lasts for 12 hours on 1-90, while diversion and increased speed lasts approximately 6 hours on the county roads. VOLUME 1: FEASIBILITY REPORT 1-90 Corridor - Easton to Cle Elum Feasibility Study 134 CHAPTER 3: EXISTING CONDITIONS IN THE STUDY AREA 3000 w 2500 W E 0 > 2000 a� v tv a>i 1500 on a� a 1000 500 0 Figure 3-1 Monday Summer Westbound Average Vehicle Volumes on 1-90 in the Study Area, 2018 ,-igo 0 '9 O09 O 9 o q O�9 O 90 9 O 9 y �0,�0,20 0 00 00 00 00 00 0A 00'o 0 'oO��A�0 9iyJ 9'L! iLj 2! 'l! �! 'L! 2l �1 �! �! �! + ?I All Summer —May - No Holiday Memorial Day July Average --September - No Labor Day Holiday 2024 Analysis Based on the existing conditions information collected and analyzed in 2019, an updated model was developed to project how future traffic conditions could potentially change if no improvements were made (see Appendix A). 1-90 in Upper Kittitas County experiences recurring seasonal congestion, particularly at the end of summer weekends and holiday weekends in the westbound direction. This congestion typically causes slower speeds and congestion as far as east of the Elk Heights Road interchange and dissipates when 1-90 widens to three lanes in each direction. There is a current WSDOT construction project to widen Source: WSDOT PTR B04, 2018 data analyzed by Fehr & Peers 1-90 from two lanes in each direction to three lanes in each direction from the Cabin Creek Interchange to the West Easton Interchange (scheduled for completion fall 2028).6 Average 2018 volumes were collected by a WSDOT permanent traffic recorder and are shown for different Mondays throughout the year in Figure 3-1. Memorial Day and Labor Day volumes peak and then decrease considerably in the late morning hours. This sudden decrease reflects the limited capacity of 1-90 under congested conditions. Speeds decrease and corridor travel times increase considerably during this recurring congestion. According to industry data for 6 https://wsdot.wa..ov/construction (anning/search-iro ects/i-90-snot ualmie-pass-east-cabin-creek-interchan e-west-easton-interchance-Gihase-3 VOLUME 1: FEASIBILITY REPORT 1-90 Corridor — Easton to Cle Elum Feasibility Study 1 35 Memorial Day 2018, average speeds along the corridor decrease from free flow (close to 70 mph) to under 10 mph for long periods of the day and large swaths of the corridor. Travel times from Elk Heights Road to Lake Easton Road increase from about 30 minutes to as much as 150 minutes at the most congested time of the day. CHAPTER 3: EXISTING CONDITIONS IN THE STUDY AREA congestion along the corridor with slow speeds through much of the day, as shown in Figure 3-2. The figure shows travel speeds in increments of 10 mph between Elk Heights Road (rightmost column) and Lake Easton Road (leftmost column) by time of day, with 9:00 a.m. to 9:15 a.m. at the top of the figure and 8:45 p.m. to 9:00 p.m. at the bottom. The 2018 model was updated and validated As shown in Figure 3-2, the congestion begins the model against current industry data. early in the day near Lake Easton Road, and The model projected traffic for year 2040, quickly builds back past Elk Heights Road. Slow which again reflected the heavy westbound speeds in the corridor span from about 10:00 Figure 3-2 Future Year 2040 No Build Modeled Travel Speeds by Time of Day and Location along 1-90 in the Study Area on Memorial Day Monday No Build: Existing Configuration, Speeds Westbound -* Tree Farm Rd Golf Course Rd W 1st St ake Easton Road Cie Elum Elk Heights Road 9:00 AM _ ... _ 9:15 AM 9:30 AM 9:45 AM 0:00 AM 10.15 AM 10:30 AM 10.45 AM 11:00 AM — — 11:15 AM 11:30 AM 11.45 AM 12:00 PM 12:15 PM 12:30 PM 12.45 PM 1:00 PM 1:15 PM 1:30 PM 1:45 PM 2:00 PM 2:15 PM 2:30 PM 2:45 PM 3:00 PM 3:15 PM 3:30 PM 3:45 PM 4.00 PM 4.15 PM 4:30 PM 4.45 PM 5:00 PM 5:15 PM 5:30 PM 5.45 PM 6:00 PM 6:15 PM 6:30 PM 6:45 PM 7:00 PM 7:15 PM 7:30 PM 7:45 PM 8:00 PM 8:15 PM 8:30 PM 8.45 PM 0-20 MPH 21-30 MPH 31-40 MPH 41_50 MPH 51-60 MPH 61-70 MPH Source: Fehr & Peers VOLUME 1: FEASIBILITY REPORT 1-90 Corridor — Easton to Cle Elunn Feasibility Study 1 36 a.m. to 8:00 p.m., with the peak congestion from about 2:00 p.m. to 4:00 p.m. 3.2.2 Active Transportation Network As defined by WSDOT, active transportation entails "a human -scale and often human - powered means of travel to get from one place to another"; this includes "walking, bicycling, using a mobility assistive or adaptive device such as a wheelchair or walker, using micromobility devices, and using electric -assist devices such as a -bikes and e-foot scooters."' Active transportation facilities in the study area include the Palouse to Cascades State Park Trail and numerous local and regional trails (see Section 3.4.5 and Figure 3-3 for additional detail). 1-90 is not open to active travel modes with the exception of bicyclists who are permitted to operate in the right shoulder of the highway per RCW 46.61.160.11 CHAPTER 3: EXISTING CONDITIONS IN THE STUDYAREA Bicyclists regularly use many of the roads in Kittitas County; however, there are few routes that provide specialized facilities to improve conditions for bicyclists in the study area. County roads are generally narrow with deep ditches and small shoulders. Bicyclists appear to more often choose Kittitas County roads that offer wide shoulders and smoother pavement, including Bullfrog Road, Upper Peoh Point Road, and Westside Road in the study area. 1-90 is not a designated U.S. Bicycle Route. 3.2.3 Transit Network Kittitas County Connector The Kittitas County Connector is a free bus service between Ellensburg and Upper Kittitas County operated by HopeSource and Central Transit. It operates seven days a week, with several departures per day. 7 https://wsdot.wa.gov/business-wsdotlsupport-tocal p rorams/technical-assistance/active-trans ortation-services 8 htt s://a .lef,.wa. •ov/rcw/defauttasDx?cite=46.61.160 VOLUME 1: FEASIBILITY REPORT 1-90 Corridor — Easton to Cle Elum Feasibility Study 1 37 CHAPTER 3: EXISTING CONDITIONS IN THE STUDY AREA HopeSource HopeSource is a private, non-profit organization providing a wide range of human services, including low-cost transportation service, to all citizens of Kittitas County. It operates its door-to-door service Monday through Friday from 7:00 a.m. to 6:00 p.m.; rides must be scheduled 24 hours in advance. Service to Yakima is provided twice a month. Hope Source services are funded by a WSDOT grant; the organization provides 3,500 annual rides for Cie Elum, Roslyn, and Ronald seniors Wenatchee Valley Shuttle The Wenatchee Valley Shuttle operates between Wenatchee and SeaTac several times a day, with scheduled departure times. Reservations are required for the shuttle. The shuttle runs seven days a week regardless of weather or pass conditions.' Regional Transportation Providers Greyhound and Flixbus provide limited access interstate and interregional transportation service along 1-90 in the study area, with several routes per day traveling through the area. Both of these bus lines have only one stop in Kittitas County, at the intersection of US 97 and University Way in Ellensburg. 3.2.4 Local, Tribal, and State Planning The following discusses state, tribal, and county plans for the study area, emphasizing transportation facilities. WSDOT Plans and Studies 2040 and Beyond WSDOT's State Transportation Policy Plan, 2040 and Beyond (2020), outlines several key goals 9 https://www.weiiatcheevalleyshuitle.com/ aimed at shaping the future of transportation in the state. These goals include: • Economic Vitality: Promote and develop transportation systems that stimulate, support, and enhance the movement of people and goods to ensure a prosperous economy. • Preservation: Maintain, preserve, and extend the life and utility of prior investments in transportation systems and services. • Safety: Provide for and improve the safety and security of transportation customers and the transportation system. • Mobility: Improve the predictable movement of goods and people throughout Washington state, including congestion relief and improved freight mobility. • Environment and Health: Enhance Washington's quality of life through transportation investments that promote energy conservation, enhance healthy communities, and protect the environment. • Stewardship: Continuously improve the quality, effectiveness, and efficiency of the transportation system. These goals collectively aim to guide transportation planning, investment, and decision -making in Washington state towards a more sustainable, resilient, and equitable transportation system for the future. Highway System Plan WSDOT's Highway System Plan (2024) outlines the goals and priorities for the state's highway network. It recommends program funding levels for 20 years in preservation, maintenance, and the capacity and operational improvement of the highway system, including safety considerations. VOLUME 1: FEASIBILITY REPORT 1-90 Corridor - Easton to Cle Elum Feasibility Study 1 38 Primary emphases for the Highway System Plan include: • Congestion relief • Preservation of existing investments • Improvement of traveler safety • Efficient movement of freight and goods • Improvement and integration of all transportation modes to create a seamless intermodal transportation system for people and goods Washington State Freight System Plan The Washington State Freight System Plan (WSDOT 2022) outlines strategies and priorities for managing and enhancing the state's freight transportation network. It aims to support the efficient movement of goods to and from Washington's ports, airports, railroads, and highways while addressing challenges such as congestion, safety, and environmental sustainability. CHAPTER 3: EXISTING CONDITIONS IN THE STUDY AREA Washington State Rail Plan The Washington State Rail Plan 2019-2040 (WSDOT 2020) outlines strategies and priorities for managing and enhancing the state's passenger and freight rail transportation network. The purpose of the Plan is to identify future needs and strategies to: • Meet the increasing demand for passenger and freight rail services in Washington in partnership with private rail carriers that own much of the network over which passenger and freight trains operate. • Develop more efficient and effective connections between rail and other modes of transportation. • Ensure the sustainability of Washington's public and private short line railroads that face infrastructure investment needs in order to preserve these important services to communities. VOLUME 1: FEASIBILITY REPORT 1-90 Corridor Easton to Cle Elunn Feasibility Study 1 39 CHAPTER 3: EXISTING CONDITIONS IN THE STUDY AREA Kittitas County Plans Kittitas County Long Range Transportation Plan The County's Long Range Transportation Plan (Kittitas County 2008) identifies 1-90 as the primary east -west freight facility in Washington State. The Plan acknowledges that regional container traffic relies on 1-90 and the transportation system approaching 1-90 to transport hay and other agricultural products to Puget Sound seaports. It also includes goals to preserve the corridor's carrying capacity and improve its performance. Tribal Plans Outreach to the Colville Tribes, Muckleshoot Indian Tribe, Snoqualmie Indian Tribe, and Confederated Tribes and Bands of the Yakama Nation took place during the study. The Yakama and Snoqualmie Tribes, per their request, have been kept updated on this study's progress and proposed alternatives. The project team will continue to request collaboration, provide updates, and solicit feedback from the tribes to ensure transparency on project recommendations that are consistent with their future plans. 10 htt s:/lwsdot.wa.pov/sites/default/files/2024-01/fvts-appendices-2024pdf 3.3 Freight Mobility Freight mobility refers to the ability to efficiently and effectively move goods from producers to consumers, businesses, and other destinations via various modes of transportation including trucks, trains, ships, and airplanes. It encompasses the entire supply chain process, from the point of production to distribution and delivery. Washington's Freight and Goods Transportation System (FGTS) classifies freight corridors based on annual freight tonnage moved, with T-1 corridors moving the most tonnage and T-5 corridors moving the least. 1-90 is classified as a T-1 corridor, meaning it moves more than 10 million tons per year. According to FGTS, this section of 1-90 handles an annual truck tonnage of 42,780,000. The annual daily truck volume on this section of 1-90 is 7,100, and trucks make up 21.6% of overall traffic 10 The segment of 1-90 between Easton and Cie Elum plays a critical role in facilitating freight mobility for several reasons. It serves as a vital east -west corridor connecting major population centers, industrial hubs, and transportation gateways in Washington state. It links the metropolitan areas of Seattle and Spokane, as well as key ports, airports, and distribution centers in the region. 1-90 in Washington state plays a crucial role in facilitating freight mobility for several reasons. The segment of 1-90 between Easton and Cie Elum traverses through central Washington and serves as a vital east -west corridor, linking the Puget Sound region with the eastern parts of the state and beyond. The 1-90 corridor provides access to key ports along the Puget Sound, including the Port of Seattle and the Port of Tacoma, two of the busiest container VOLUME I: FEASIBILITY REPORT 1-90 Corridor — Easton to Cie Elunn Feasibility Study 140 ports on the West Coast. Freight moving through these ports relies heavily on efficient transportation corridors like 1-90 to reach distribution centers, warehouses, and markets across the state and beyond. The efficient movement of freight along the 1-90 corridor is essential for supporting regional and statewide economic activities. Industries such as manufacturing, agriculture, retail, and distribution rely on the timely delivery of goods to sustain operations and meet consumer demand — so any disruptions or congestion along this corridor can have significant implications for businesses and supply chains. CHAPTER 3: EXISTING CONDITIONS IN THE STUDY AREA The existing traffic conditions as presented in Section 3.2.1 also affect the movement of freight along the 1-90 corridor within the study area. Truck parking is often described as an issue by the community members during public comment. Chapter 2 describes how this study acknowledges truck parking in the alternative review and other overlapping efforts in addressing truck parking concerns. VOLUME 1: FEASIBILITY REPORT 1-90 Corridor - Easton to Cle Elum Feasibility Study 1 41 3.4 Environment Environmental resources and existing conditions were identified within 500 feet of the alternative alignments to provide a high- level preliminary desktop environmental review for which potential opportunities, benefits and challenges for the proposed alternatives may occur. The 500-foot buffer comprises the environmental study area for each alternative. The preliminary desktop review was developed by qualitatively evaluating aquatic resources, wildlife connectivity, ecosystem resiliency, and Endangered Species Act (ESA) critical habitats in the vicinity of the proposed alignment of each alternative. Further studies and assessments will need to occur for each resource once the preferred alternative is selected to move forward for further evaluation. Existing conditions for environmental resources in the study areas are described in the following sections and illustrated in Appendix B. 3.4.1 Aquatic Resources Streams and Rivers Streams and rivers identified within the study area of Alternatives 1 through 3 include the Yakima River, Cie Elum River, Big Creek, Little Creek, Tucker Creek, Crystal Creek, Nelson Creek, and Silver Creek, as well as three additional unnamed perennial and two unnamed intermittent streams (Appendix B, Map 1A). Streams mapped within the study area of Alternative 4A include Silver Creek, Domerie Creek, the Cie Elum River, and several unnamed perennial and intermittent streams (Appendix B, Map 113). The study area of Alternative 4B includes Silver Creek, the Cie Elum River, and several unnamed perennial and intermittent CHAPTER 3: EXISTING CONDITIONS IN THE SIUDYAREA streams (Appendix B, Map 1C). The Cie Elum River is adjacent to Alternative 4B. The study area for Alternative 5 includes the Yakima River, Big Creek, Little Creek, Nelson Creek, Peterson Creek, Silver Creek, Spex Arth Creek, Tillman Creek, Tucker Creek, the Kittitas Reclamation District Main Canal, and several unnamed intermittent and perennial streams (Appendix B, Map 1D). Lakes and Ponds Lake Easton is within the study areas for all alternatives. Lavendar Lake as well as several unnamed bodies of water are within the study area for Alternatives 1 through 3. No additional bodies of water are located within the study areas of Alternatives 4A or 4B. Hanson Ponds to the south of Cie Elum are within the study area for Alternatives 1 through 3 and Alternative 5. Wetlands The proposed alignment for Alternatives 1 through 3 is within or adjacent to wetland complexes associated with the Yakima and Cie Elum Rivers. The National Wetlands Inventory (NWI) maps several wetland complexes along these alternatives given the proximity to these rivers along the extent of the alignment. The proposed alignment for Alternative 4A appears to bypass NWI mapped wetland areas but crosses the Cie Elum River, which may include wetlands. The proposed alignment for Alternative 4B is within or adjacent to the Cie Elum River, which may include associated or adjacent wetlands. The proposed alignment for Alternative 5 is within or adjacent to the Yakima River, which may include adjacent and associated wetlands. NWI is a broadscale mapping tool for desktop review prior to fieldwork. There are likely wetlands along each alignment that are not mapped within NWI and wetlands that are mapped within NWI may not meet all three indicators (vegetation, VOLUME I: FEASIBILITY REPORT 1-90 Corridor Easton to Cle Elum Feasibility Study 1 42 soils, hydrology) required to be classified as a wetland or may differ in size. Given the coarse scale of NWI it is important to note that it provides a general location of potential wetlands but cannot accurately predict how many wetlands or total acres of wetlands could be impacted by any of the alternatives. Also, as presented in Appendix B, Map 2A, WSDOT environmental mitigation sites are located along and within the 1-90 right of way, and will be impacted. Fish Passage The Washington Department of Fish and Wildlife (WDFW) Fish Passage Barrier dataset identifies one mapped partial fish passage barrier within the study area of each alternative. 3.4.2 Wildlife Connectivity The study areas encompass a variety of habitats that support fish and wildlife species. Wildlife connectivity is currently fragmented by roadways within the study areas for each of the CHAPTER 3: EXISTING CONDITIONS IN THE STUDY AREA alternatives. The wildlife connectivity criteria assesses if the alternative has the potential to improve the availability of wildlife habitat and connectivity. No existing wildlife fencing occurs within the study areas of Alternatives 1 through 5. WSDOT's Wildlife Crossing Structures dataset includes one wildlife crossing structure that occurs within the study area of Alternatives 1 through 3 near milepost 81 on 1-90 at the Cle Rum River bridge. WSDOT's Habitat Connectivity Investment Priorities dataset maps a 2-mile segment of 1-90 within the study area of Alternatives 1 through 3 as low priority for habitat connectivity investment. The remaining 14 miles of Alternatives 1 through 3 are ranked as high priority. Roadways included in Alternatives 4A, 413, and 5 are not ranked. The graphic in Appendix B, Map 4E, illustrates the severity of carcass removal in the study area. The study area for Alternatives 1 through 3 borders or bisects WDFW Priority Habitat and Species areas including the Upper Yakima VOLUME I: FEASIBILITY REPORT 1-90 Corridor— Easton to Cie Elunn Feasibility Study 1 43 CHAPTER 3: EXISTING CONDITIONS IN THE STUDY AREA Common Name Table 3-7 ESA Listed Species Potential Presence and Designated Critical Habitat Adjacent to Each Alternative Potential Presence Listing Status Alternatives Alternative Alternative Alternative 1-3 4a 4b 5 Canada lynx ........................................................................... Threatened Gray wolf ........................................................................... Endangered North American Proposed wolverine Threatened Yes Yes Yes No ........................................................................... Yes ........................................................................... Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes .................................................................................... Marbled murrelet Threatened Yes .................................................................................... Northern spotted owl Threatened Yes Northern spotted owl — Threatened No Critical Habitat .................................................................................... Yellow -billed cuckoo Threatened Yes .................................................................................... Bull trout — Columbia Threatened Yes River DPS .................................................................................... Bull trout — DPS Critical Threatened Yes Habitat .................................................................................... Steelhead — MCR DPS Threatened Yes ......................................................................................................_..................... Steelhead — MCR DPS Threatened Yes Critical Habitat ........................................................................... Yes Yes Yes ........................................................................... Yes ........................................................................... Yes Yes Yes Yes No ........................................................................... Yes ........................................................................... Yes Yes Yes Yes ......................... Yes .................................................. Yes Yes Yes .......................................... Yes .............................................................................................................. ................................. Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Species and critical habitat are from the U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service and National Marine Fisheries Service species lists based on a 500-foot buffer along each alignment. Riparian Area, Domerie Flats Elk Winter Concentration Area, Bullfrog Mill Winter Elk Concentration Area, Bullfrog Mill/Cle Elurri Wood Duck Nesting Area, and the Cie Elum River Riparian Area as well as several other wildlife migration corridors and winter use areas. Alternatives 4A and 4B both bisect the Domerie Flats Elk Winter Concentration Area. Alternative 5 borders the south side of the Domerie Flats Elk Winter Concentration Area. 3.4.3 Ecosystem Resiliency The ecosystem resiliency criteria assesses whether the alternative has the potential to increase resiliency against the impacts of climate change, such as reducing risks associated with extreme flood events. Channel Migration Zones (CMZ) are areas within the floodplain where a stream or river can be expected to move naturally over time due to hydrology and topography. Alternatives 1 through 3 are mostly in Tier 1 CMZ with one area of Tier 2 CMZ near milepost 75. Alternative VOLUME I: FEASIBILITY REPORT 1-90 Corridor Easton to Cie Elum Feasibility Study 144 4A crosses the CMZ and 100-year floodplain of the Cie Elum River near the south end of Cie Elum Lake. Alternative 4A crosses the Cie Elum River 100-year floodplain near its eastern terminus. Alternative 5 is within the Yakima River floodplain and CMZ near Cie Elum. 3.4.4 Environmental Species Act (ESA) Listed Species and Critical Habitat The endangered and threatened species and critical habitats criteria assess the alternatives for impacts to ESA listed species and critical habitats that may be impacted by the proposed alternatives. The potential presence of ESA listed species and designated critical habitat adjacent to each alternative is shown in Table 3-7. All alternatives, with the exception of Alternative 6 (no build alternative), may affect bull trout and steelhead because there would likely be in -water work associated with construction in rivers and streams that support these species. Alternatives 4a and 5 would likely have the greatest potential for long term impacts to butt trout and steelhead because these alternatives require new bridge crossings over the Cie Elum River and Yakima River, respectively. Alternatives 1 through 3 provide the greatest potential for improving water crossings which could have longterm beneficial effects for these species. Construction noise may affect terrestrial species associated with these Alternatives; however, this cannot be analyzed until an action area is defined and field surveys occur to assess potential habitat for ESA listed species during future assessments. Species Species that are potentially present within or adjacent to the proposed alignment of each CHAPTER 3: EXISTING CONDITIONS IN THE STUDY AREA alternative are listed in Table 3-7. Additionally, sensitive areas such as breeding buffers occur for northern spotted owl within the study areas for Alternatives 1 through 4a. Critical Habitat Alternatives 1 through 3 cross the Yakima River, which is critical habitat for steelhead and bull trout (Appendix B, Map 4A). Alternative 4A passes through northern spotted owl critical habitat and terminates near the Cie Elum River (Appendix B, Map 4C). Alternative 4B also passes through northern spotted owl critical habitat and terminates near the Cie Elum River (Appendix B, Map 4C). Alternative 5 adds new crossings over the Yakima River but does not pass through northern spotted owl critical habitat. 3.4.5 Historical Sites, Parks, and Recreational Facilities Figure 3-3 provides the general location for historical sites, as well as parks and recreational facilities. These resources are listed below. In addition to the following resources, a more in-depth analysis was performed which explores the geologic, historic, cultural, and ethnographic setting in the study area. This report is included in Appendix C. Cultural Sites A preliminary review of the Department of Archaeology and Historic Preservation's (DAHP) resources database revealed at least 60 previously recorded archaeological resources within 0.5 miles of the 15.5-mile segment of 1-90. In addition, the DAHP's statewide predictive model indicates that the majority of the highway segment under study lies within an area with a very high risk of containing archaeological features and/or materials. VOLUME I: FEASIBILITY REPORT 1-90 Corridor - Easton to Cle Elunn Feasibility Study 1 45 CHAPTER 3: EXISTING CONDITIONS IN THE STUDY AREA Historical Sites Historical resources in the study area include: Cie Elum • Douglas Munro Burial Site at Laurel Hill Memorial Cemetery, listed on the Washington Heritage Register (resource ID 675496), Forest Ranger Road • Vogue Theater, listed on the Washington Heritage Register (resource ID 675497), 210 Pennsylvania Avenue • Kinney Building, listed on the Washington Heritage Register (resource ID 675498), 108- 1101/2 East 1st Street • Cie Elum-Roslyn Beneficial Association Hospital, listed on the National Register and Washington Heritage Register (resource ID 675481), 505 Power Street South Cie Elum • South Cie Elum Yard District, listed on the National Register and Washington Heritage Register, which historically served the Chicago, Milwaukee, St. Paul, and Pacific Railroad • Milwaukee Road Bunkhouse, listed on the National Register and Washington Heritage Register (listing number 89000210), 526 Marie Avenue Roslyn • Roslyn Historic District, listed on the National Register and Washington Heritage Register (resource ID 674584) • Northwestern Improvement Company Barn • Northwestern Improvement Company Store • Roslyn Riders Club House, Track, and Arena Parks and Recreational Facilities Parks and recreational resources in the study area include: National and Regional Facilities • Okanogan -Wenatchee National Forest • Lake Easton State Park • Palouse to Cascades State Park • Washington State Horse Park Local Facilities • Cie Elum: Cie Elum City Park, Flag Pole Park, Centennial Park, Hanson Ponds Park, Cie Elum Fireman's Park, Cie Elum Memorial Park • South Cie Elum: South Cie Elum Fireman's Park • Roslyn: Roslyn Urban Forest, Roslyn Pioneer Park, Centennial Park • Nelson: Sun Country Golf Course • Suncadia: Prospector and Rope Rider Golf Courses • Ronald: Tumble Creek Golf Course VOLUME I: FEASIBILITY REPORT 1-90 Corridor Easton to Cle Elum Feasibility Study 146 - !! - / 9 � ■ , fn \ /2[ § /t�\E \ § $ / T u. -_ ,..� 2 ( � \J&ƒk}\\,ff U6 \®\\�\\{\)]/\ 23LT 30 2�&■ ® b : f�2,/,2f#!!; 7 0\z!/t{!{!4E!®!« Lu �g lEfE� u ) ) ` z'u, xu —se §f2\°�`\`�. B�® .� CHAPTER 3: EXISTING CONDITIONS IN THE STUDY AREA 3.5 Resiliency A resilient transportation system is one that can withstand and recover from disruptions, whether they are caused by natural disasters, technological failures, or human -caused incidents. Resiliency involves the ability of the system to maintain functionality and adapt to changing conditions while minimizing disruptions to people, goods, and services. This section of 1-90 can be susceptible to natural hazards such as wildfires and snowstorms. The highway's resiliency depends on its ability to withstand these hazards and recover quickly from any damage. Resiliency is also influenced by the maintenance and condition of the highway's infrastructure, including bridges and road surfaces. Regular maintenance and investments in infrastructure upgrades can enhance 1-90's ability to withstand and recover from disruptions. 1-90's resiliency is also affected by the availability of alternative routes for evacuations and detours in case of closures or disruptions. In the study area, 1-90 currently only has two lanes in each direction, so crashes or other causes for lane closures can cause a major disruption in the flow of traffic. Identifying and maintaining alternative routes can mitigate the impact of disruptions on the highway and ensure the continued flow of traffic during emergencies. 3.6 Environmental Justice and Equity The environmental justice (EJ) and equity evaluation identifies whether there are communities with EJ concerns and evaluates whether the alternatives would equitably distribute project benefits and prevent disproportionate and adverse effects to human health. The EJ study area is defined as the census tracts and block groups within 0.5 mile of the 1-90 study corridor from South Cie Elum to Easton because it is the area most likely to experience socioeconomic effects from changes to the corridor. Federal guidance on EJ is transitioning from an analysis of impacts to minority and low-income populations (per the 1994 Executive Order 12898) to a broader analysis of environmental and health effects on "populations of concern" (per the 2023 Executive Order 14096)". At the state level, WSDOT is responsible for incorporating environmental justice in its plans and programs because it is a covered agency under the Washington's Healthy Environment for All (HEAL) Act (RCW 70A.02). However, guidance on HEAL Act Environmental justice Assessments is still underway (WSDOT 2024). 3.6.1 Demographic and Socioeconomic Indicators The study area does not meet the definition of an EJ population or a Justice40 disadvantaged community12 because the minority population is only 15% of the overall population and not meaningfully greater than the minority population of the comparison geographies of Kittitas County, Cie Elum, and Roslyn, which 11 The broader definition of "communities with environmental justice concerns" better integrates the discrimination protections under Title VI of the Civi l Rights Act of 1964. 12 An "environmental justice population" described in Executive Order 12898 and EPA 2016; a "disadvantaged community" described in the CEIST Screening Tool methodology: https./IscreeninStool."o •tatform, ov/en/methodolo=.y VOLUME I: FEASIBILITY REPORT 1-90 Corridor Easton to Cle Elum Feasibility Study 148 CHAPTER 3: EXISTING CONDITIONS IN THE STUDY AREA Table 3-8 Select Socioeconomic Indicators Indicators 1-90 Study Area Comparison Geographies Roslyn Cie Elum Kittitas County WA Demographics° .................................................................................................................................................................. Total Population 12,598 703 2,147 44,147 7,617,364 .................................................................................................................................................................. Minority Population 15% 15% 19% 19% 34% .................................................................................................................................................................. White Alone, Not Hispanic or Latino 85% 85% 81% 81% 66% Income .................................................................................................................................................................. People Below Poverty 10.5% 6.0% 16.8% 14.8% 10.0% Limited English Proficiency .................................................................................................._...........................-...........................-..........................._...........................-.......................... Speak a Language Other than English 4% 3% 6% 7% 20% Source: U.S. Census 2021 a) U.S. Census American Community Survey 5-Year Estimates, 2018-2022 was not available until 2024, after the criteria for this evaluation were established. b) People who reported to `speak a language other than English" at home is a greater percentage of the population than people who report to speak English "less than well' or "limited English proficiency". each have a minority population between 15 and 19 percent (Table 3-8). The study area low-income population is smaller than the comparison geographies of Cie Elum and Kittitas Counties and similar to that of the state of Washington. The study area has a similar low limited -English speaking population compared to Roslyn. Cie Elum Roslyn Elementary School demographics on race, limited English proficiency, and low-income status also reflect the demographics of the study area provided in Table 3-8. The WSDOT Limited English Proficiency (LEP) Accessibility Plan recommends that for a service area where LEP exceeds 5 percent of the population or >1,000 people, translation and other reasonable steps should be taken for successful outreach. The study area is smaller than the overall 1-90 service area, but for context, it does not meet this threshold (WSDOT 2022). Additional data about the study area from FHWA Screening Tool for Equity Analysis of Projects (STEAP) highlights the percentage of households without computers or internet access, the percentage of residents with disabilities, and the percent of people not in the labor force is higher than found within the County (see Appendix D). Health Disparities The Washington Tracking Network "Information by Location" (IBL) tool is a source for geospatial environmental and health data from the State of Washington Department of Health. Figure 3-4 is a screenshot of the study area using the Environmental Health Disparities IBL mapping tool and Table 3-9 summarizes some key data about the two census tracts composing the 1-90 corridor study area. The U.S. Environmental Protection Agency E)Screen Tool provides a similar display of environmental exposure risk and socioeconomic indicators (see Appendix E). Environmental Health Disparity ranking is a way to compare health and social factors (e.g., collections of environmental and VOLUME I: FEASIBILITY REPORT 1-90 Corridor Easton to Cle Elum Feasibility Study 1 49 CHAPTER 3: EXISTING CONDITIONS IN THE STUDYAREA Table 3-9 Environmental Health Disparities Summary for the 1-90 Corridor Study Area Environmental Risk Factors Census Tract 53037975200 Census Tract 53037975100 Environmental Health Disparities Overall Rank 5 2 Environmental Exposures Rank 5 2 ................................................................................................................................................................... Diesel exhaust PM2.5 emissions 4 3 ................................................................................................................................................................... Ozone concentration 8 9 ................................................................................................................................................................... PM2.5 concentration 10 2 ................................................................................................................................................................... Proximity to heavy traffic roadways 4 4 ................................................................................................................................................................... Toxic releases from facilities 1 1 Environmental Effects Rank 1 1 ................................................................................................................................................................... Lead risk from housing 5 7 ................................................................................................................................................................... Proximity to hazardous waste treatment storage and disposal facilities 2 1 ................................................................................................................................................................... Proximity to Superfund sites ................................................................................................................................................................... 1 1 Proximity to risk management plan facilities 4 1 Socioeconomic Factors Rank 3 6 ................................................................................................................................................................... Limited English Proficiency 1 1 ................................................................................................................................................................... No High School Diploma 5 7 ................................................................................................................................................................... People of color (race/ ethnicity) 1 1 ................................................................................................................................................................... Population Living in Poverty 3 8 ................................................................................................................................................................... Transportation Expense 10 10 ................................................................................................................................................................... Unaffordable Housing 2 6 ................................................................................................................................................................... Unemployed 8 6 Sensitive Populations Rank 8 4 .................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................._ Death from Cardiovascular Disease 6 2 .................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................._ Low birth weights 8 8 Source: Washington Department of Health 2023. Note: Values are presented as deciles or ranhs. They illustrate a difference in rish, but not how much risk VOLUME I: FEASIBILITY REPORT 1-90 Corridor — Easton to Cie Elunn Feasibility Study 1 50 CHAPTER 3: EXISTING CONDITIONS IN THE STUDY AREA i ? r © ae s.a e. rew� setee.fen �. h. A — [nvdmnnym; H—Ah Mi En..mwnena EaMrmm.nW H t � . `� i• � a EH.. sa- w a' f-t— i I� SM V .M1p.Mbt al . 53037975100 I6y #15,3037975200 Figure3-4 Environmental Health Disparities Map of 1-90 Corridor Study Area socioeconomic data) that may contribute to disparities in a community (i.e., census tract). Health and social factors that can contribute to disparities in environmental health include environmental exposures, environmental effects, socioeconomic factors, and sensitive populations. The tool organizes a collection of indicators into these four categories. The two census tracts in the study area have an overall ranking of 2 and 5. Each number from 1 to 10 represents 10 percent of communities (or census tracts). For example, Census tract 5100 has a rank of 2 for Environmental Exposures. That means only 10% of communities in Washington State have a lower health disparity (or are less affected by environmental exposures) and 70% have a greater level of disparity (or are more affected by environmental exposures). The indicators are averaged within each theme or Environmental Health Risk Factor. Although the overall rankings for the study area are low to moderate (indicating the area is not disproportionately burdened by environmental health risks), Table 3-9 highlights a few severe disparities within each risk factor that are present in the study area. For example, both census tracts have the highest rank (10) for transportation expense, and they share high ranks in ozone concentration (9, 8). VOLUME I: FEASIBILITY REPORT 1-90 Corridor Easton to Cle Elum Feasibility Study I Sl 4 ALTERNATIVES EVALUATION CRITERIA The evaluation criteria selected to evaluate the proposed alternatives were developed based on the project purpose and goal statements presented in Chapter One for this study. The alternatives evaluation was completed in two phases (tiers): Tier 1, an Initial Evaluation and a Revised Evaluation of all alternatives; and Tier 2, a Targeted Evaluation of the top ranked alternatives. For each goal statement, a number of evaluation criteria and measurements were developed. The Tier 1 Evaluation consisted of the seven preliminary alternatives identified in Chapter 2. The Tier 1 Evaluation included two rounds of evaluation: • An initial evaluation which was presented to the public for input; and • A revised evaluation which incorporated public input. Alternatives with better performance (represented by higher scores) were then advanced to the Tier 2 Targeted Evaluation, which provided a more comparative assessment of the remaining alternatives. Additional criteria were added to the Tier 2 evaluation to further distinguish the remaining alternatives. The evaluation process drew upon insights from both Kittitas County (County) and Washington State Department of Transportation (WSDOT) staff, as well as input from the public and stakeholders. Feedback gathered on the alternatives and evaluation criteria through public webinars and an open house was incorporated into the evaluation process. Public surveys provided an additional opportunity for the public to provide input on the alternatives and evaluation process. For additional information about the public engagement process and comments received, please refer to Chapter 5. 4.1 Evaluation Criteria The evaluation methodology was developed to measure how well each alternative meets the project purpose and goals. The analysis was primarily qualitative with some quantitative data used to develop performance ratings. VOLUME 1: FEASIBILITY REPORT 1-90 Corridor Easton to Cle Elunn Feasibility Study 152 CHAPTER 4: ALTERNATIVES EVALUATION CRITERIA The evaluation methodology included the development of: • Project Goats (from Purpose and Need presented in Chapter 1) and total assigned points for each Goal; • Evaluation Criteria for each Goal; and • Performance Measurements (points) for each criterion ranging from 1 (alternative does not meet or improve the criterion) to 3 (alternative meets or exceeds goal of criterion). Each Performance Measurement was assigned a Weight based on the Goal's assigned points and its number of criteria. For each Alternative, a total weighted score was determined by summing the total weighted scores for each Project Goal. Performance Rating Methodology The Performance Rating for each criterion is based on the total Assigned Points for each Project Goal divided by the number of Evaluation Criteria for that Goal. For example, Freight Mobility was assigned 10 points, and has 3 criteria. Therefore, each criterion's maximum weight would be 3.3 points (10 divided by 3). The Weighted Score for each Alternative's ability to meet the overall Goal was calculated as follows: Criterion's Performance Measurement Weight (1, 2, 3) times the Weight (based on the Goal's Assigned Points and number of Criteria). Alternative Criteria Scoring Example: 1. If an Alternative was being scored on the Project Goal Freight Mobility - Freight Mobility = Max 10 points out of 100 Total Goal points 2. There are 3 Evaluation Criteria for Freight Mobility: Freight Mobility 10 pts maximum divided by 3 categories = Max 3.3 pts per Performance Measurement 3. Performance Measurement'3' = Max Value, 7 = Moderate Value, '1' = Minimum/No Value So if the Performance Measurement for this Alternative is "3 - Increases freight throughput", it would receive 3.3 pts (Max value). If it is rated as a "2 Moderately increase freight throughput", it would receive 1.7 pts (Moderate Value). If it is rated as a "1 - Did not increase freight throughput", it would receive 0 pts (Minimum/No Value). VOLUME 1: FEASIBILITY REPORT 1-90 Corridor - Easton to Cle Elum Feasibility Study 1 53 v a F £Lnn o 0 0 0 o s a a a s a a C O: o cn i N d - N c d VI L 111 •C R G i c0 N i6 c d ate+ u w •a+ : Y- c^ N O O R N .a IN d V U o o : E N °1 c •' ,� w° : u o` : L, a`a w i E ,>, : n: y c c ..�, v '� a:o Hadd eV oo RRa a rsNeuRyRul c°=w0>o O O bcl_ O O E >o V°2B c av E c: Jc'U E 'c [ M : w w : a : L Y 'd^ °.: R v aci - •� ° c a udi d a udi : iddn a ndn E :. dO v`+ O >E >a °c oud v y u Ebl N 'd_X^ : vURC R�c Rv Uc> ad : Np� wVr aE : E E oE-- •aUc- ::-d- U X •- C . LmU NVI qOcq : 0 E: a >, c O O V R _uoT d V vl d E !E: O C d O O c d OI] N d O d % O E T O vi d O of C vl iO O Vdl i6 O N i0 O: IYl ; WcdE . N o d 2a�`_W Vdl d •aCo0 @po Ca+Nud Nd udC:NodCc,:CdtzE d o o 0 cEO" 0 0 0 odpN:': o: 0 o wo y c I I I I I I I I I -y: I I I c -dp✓p� l I I I i l i 0 0 uIn z: l I I u'n z I I I I I I I I I VEa I I 1 cNu p I I I d O d Y Y T -30 c o O 0 N o 0 a- Y u 16 0 a c 47 u G R o 10 E OE N EO d o ` C V `o a `. vi v y w o i d ` L w c ° T t dN= Y y o V C O N V - a G N T N N> 6 c a yl d N 3 yl d vl i O a+ O d 0 V a � 9 C O •V io L Lti lGn• LO� Hrs 0 ud o °=Vom� wo;° m> c m> => 3>o L.nda °Ea: �`^ d aE n d aQ: o o' my oE E C R C R o x J OO VN N Q •N iO N %� ' > d d 0 E O w O N C u° C °" R N C d C « d V C u C V G N O W O N/ O C" >GO �p '�' O '�" O C" R Q Y C 1 y C R ad+ O d d d d d C d d d Y O d £ Y ✓i d d : d T y: Y y :£ N IF 7 y y o V N 0 d N _ o E N E o cm N 0 0 y N o 0 o C 0 0 ; W Ik o u N _ o £ c o o o W p W p O W p 6 p Q p S p a V C,: 91 T ? O U V R a C C �_ N O C a O •V t d d R G u > > }- ° a y N I"I m E C N V a M r 3 R on V C O Z G N L R y Z o m e a O « 0 R > N a d v d c 'o ° c , E> o c l7 z a vl m a H w 0 V ° P a F c W 0 n c C O-• 3 a1 O c y E o: c: R nc_ny: E n_nE: � w O N y: C ' y � R- Y a.EaRyJELon0 E tR/I i0 o ` N o o. o o n � o: s:E Eat M M M M N a C L R o a v o a a a d O L EV R u E .Y � � V, -yip O R axi on c E to: m a _0 10 R T. In aui E O 'u N u hp u R Y N N C = - V n V -00 U: N E Q I a a > o Q c'a•: c T� o.Ea E y u R � U N C u C C N y R T R VI yl n E ¢ in R T R: o U Q N U a N N E R N : C V1 • : 9 R UI N IV N M 1 0 0 0 u0 > 3 .E a a: c o 0 o O: O v Y y o.' o.o: Ems° Rom: - o o v E n: J O > Q 6 E i T E R C ,> L : OV .E VI N N QI N n n« VI L iC�• N D o c o@ c: io'�'E E c E o m a« i VI VI d C N i N v h U _ nna na m: R E a : nv',: .o: E Eo Ezo.0 .ocpn ax,o aX,� Eo �=t: I I 1 i I I l i I I I i I I I a a a V C bRn 0 o N o .c U Ip •y bq a w ao N R El > n o o a R 9 0 r R �F y R •� J .0 a oci c E '> c O Q a V1 R m c O R O R L uuj R y y1 � ID •) tn « > T L 3 a E Y Y n R E O T ao v p E C O 0 C IS. 0 }+ ,« R u C E Y ._ R c w N d J u O C N p N C L p d� �tm > > > 3 a a o. •y nr > u > O L .- - m 1O y L •E iO •« L lD C > R O u> d> M C C a C N 9 C i O• y O R y V W OE r a C b N nJ W O d p L V � Y Y •O N U to N o ao A N v G O oQuu' E u o C oe C 'N D R rit Ul c, a u A u o O C R VI C C Un O � O ' O R O A c V a O. � C > O n Ln N E m R E � H R E >, C R W ou d Z C a u°, w o ° w a d a F "EE y E m OR W M M M M M M •X •d M M M M M M M M i3 a N o ro v a 'S E' nn_: N > ro c °1 E d.E .- ro�C CVO>vEi L L C ro E J ro .- .-. C_ V O V a d� ro ro o c a E :° Q:.� u E N N 0 o d o o a, �' a uO1i : o E YYa: i.� a as u: YYa >. E �p 0 ro N O: d 0 > u C: > C C: D V C E E a d: as m E a v a a po CWrn M N - : M N c O 0 C � Y 3 c ii ac � m= N •d a L bll N O 'VI V) N C > ✓ d ; O o i•r V d ro ll y d C. •rp O •16 c v 9 '� •O C LL y LL N E ow C UO Y Vw�� U` N N R E E: u " �+ O c a C c N ro y is O ro a: IYiI y sF ;r, J" o 6 N ro c' U - N O O V 0-o d 0 � o `d: d co d : a� E: 7 0 In o 3' O L � o ro d c ro � b c u w c •c VI N p^ E N ro N O � d c N � o N .� o E o In EO 0 N d E: y : E w 8 d� "'0 ' vNi E °' C a> y n d ro N> d N 0 C a a N ro J o: > o v �yo c d d :EE � E ti' u c O .O-• � 2.2 d"6 10 ro d ]'>'> ' N ro' E' N N O ro n E O a n I : n._ n d E A d N E O n 16 EEvo > .� J 0, 0 Ea 0 N N N d d O. V 1 : • -Cj a a ro o > • d n a- o a 'O O N ` d E c R E j : on o C N N N ro 0 c ra E c a r• c o c o u a N d •O N C CL r6 rV0 ro ro n: W �, E•u c a c E m +� • Q u rc `. d a +�•' c d d 2 •O d m _ > w : C O ro C m W = •C d a CO dcc i m L O � v L 0 0 o YO a a N n E � � a d N n E $ ro C d C •� E d +N-• � u N O N C O 2 > d c O ro a O<1 c > v C ro E ra n n i d L C N L O W V L ro d C O d O 0 O C > u > t d > d a v m O > ; ro C ro L to u c rsE 0 y N IdJ O �. rp d •Y N d: C ro ra. ro: d ro m oy; y ':•lo o 0 a o ro� a ooro; i o u 4.2 Tier 1 Evaluation Approach and Results As presented in Chapter 3, existing conditions in the study area were identified based on each Evaluation Criterion topic (as appropriate). Alternatives were then evaluated, using baseline conditions, and were given a Performance Measurement rating. This initial evaluation was presented to the public at an open house in February 2024. CHAPTER 4: ALTERNATIVES EVALUATION CRITERIA Based on public comments, scores were adjusted, and new criteria were added to two separate Project Goals — Safety and Transportation Demand. Table 4-2 presents each alternative's revised Performance Measurement (rating) for the identified evaluation criteria. VOLUME 1: FEASIBILITY REPORT 1-90 Corridor - Easton to Cle Elum Feasibility Study I S7 N Q a 12 pn c w a 3 � J M N -- M N -: M N -: M- -: M N to on V c d Dn = d d O d N R N E E m o � w d d� O H d c c a, y C u R Ta �1 a T� C> _> R a V1 O W O VI •y d m .� d : C p/ Cl d Wit,,, •O Y : A 0 uEi : Y u e a f C a t6 O Cl pi d 'in : O `o � c O R C d d: V O o O 1 E 0 w O wx d: >. N N d R> o o o •y •y « o: m n E d a C n ce au+ n: y C w G p C .w .w •� V O R: C ip r. •> U •� O d' U O ry O i7 pJ � Cyl N jk O p ao no,5`' akco, u, o M N � d c A a i L u 0 5 0 a L d a 0 E c N u e E a F N Q a Q R Yr•• � fK Q M Q N Q r Q r 0 d C : C 0-: N O ; C Lbll 3 : O Nl E T ro E o t E f6 ra m n" Lnn ma's o°ind L -L.� y E N y n n .: >. c : �. c '— O ;a d �_ o C C > C o N O C O un — O L E o O ti c: L •p R ar : .y i+ p a •' L E E d Li N L a .°» d R cn- un R ✓r p C •y C R C yW C O y N R y N m N R •O � R o 50 avoo0 : 5 T � aJ a E > _ C O O E a E E ✓ O R M O �i rn m ra a 41 N r y X° n 0 b!1 }+ E U N u N N R R ra � C y y _ u R r6 bn R t3 y O N d T O Y y C y „d,, y V y j C Y y i a+ V1 N E L V _ J n u .E ' •E Y E R E y ; a, •- '- c o E = E 0 0 ° y QO c EL RL 4 R > > � �QE y y 3 �.E: y N v °' °-o c-° N O � E �•-v: aw a, yo- •iyCOO J"O > > i m� 'C° O o y E ,nNyb v rn u E E Ed -'�E> > _o s<LO< oac C a `o y c N N y Y O m Q n R u a L y u > o. .w u w �- vi 'O - c c N O fi= n r. �« n o c a Y o 11 W S> y •a+ W y` V u o: •y,• ° d y � O y R •U O R 1 O N al R CL R a1 C O V u> y C V O N N •R W A y A M •N �6 is O @ n y C Y C � d : H C Ol N C d) d C � 6 C 0.V tLif LP C Q� O� _ y� anT+• V C ayj N C C -O : d ate+ a) d d y al N U d R y d y U L p y C: i R y •U y bn Y O C U C1 u cn L R - c c c Ti cc o R d c c R ui o hn a O t! • c > > n W N R L W n O F Q w M N - . M N- : M N -: M N y Gi C d 'nn u O L CO i0 O u w c '- N 3 -C E u r 6 o o. o 0: a Y 3: a Y•N d y � �'ay w v�"o' L/1 0 M N `o "6 rt L +R+ E O > C N 1I1 3 i d 3 C 0 N O X W �y � � O u c R A n E N N O d � n E o N O u N c •R E C O n d c "� c O > N N C @ R n U1 d N 10 L R o N y CL E d d R N@ R p L N: U L n. !� v V N L d u c c io 0 c E i u v °': es v d a y •� d: d E C_ E c t y aoy:ao�:�oo r N Table 4-3 presents a summary of weighted scores for each alternative by Project Goal, and the diagram in Figure 4-1 illustrates how the alternatives compared to each other. Detailed evaluation worksheets, along with CHAPTER 4: ALTERNATIVES EVALUATION CRITERIA explanations for the scoring, are included in Appendix F. A comprehensive environmental evaluation was also performed, and findings are presented in Appendix G. Table 4-3 Tier 1 Evaluation - Weighted Scores Alt 1 Alt 2 Alt 3 Alt 4A Alt 4B Alt 5 Alt 6 1-90 Outside I-90 Median I-90 Reversible North RouteNorth Route South No SR 903 Widening Widening Lanes Bullfrog Road Route Build Extension Safety 15.0 15.0 18.0 15.0 15.0 12.0 0.0 ..................................................................................................................................................................... Transportation 8.6 8.6 8.6 4.3 4.3 2.9 0.0 Demand ..................................................................................................................................................................... Freight Mobility 6.7 6.7 6.7 1.7 1.7 5.0 0.0 ..................................................................................................................................................................... Environmental 6.0 9.0 9.0 1.5 1.5 0.0 1.5 ..................................................................................................................................................................... Resiliency 9.4 9.4 9.4 1.9 •--......................................................................... 1.9 1.9 0.0 ......................................................................................... Equity/Inclusion 6.7 8.3 8.3 5.0 6.7 5.0 6.7 _ ................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................... Relative Cost of 3.3 3.3 3.3 0.0 0.0 1.7 6.7 Alternatives Total Score 55.6 60.3 63.3 29.3 31.0 28.4 14.8 VOLUME I: FEASIBILITY REPORT 1-90 Corridor - Easton to Cie Elum Feasibility Study 1 61 CHAPTER 4: ALTERNATIVES EVALUATION CRITERIA Figure 4-1 Tier 1 Evaluation Summary by Alternative -Weighted Score 80.0 70.0 60.0 50.0 40.0 30.0 20.0 10.0 0.0 ■ Relative Cost of Alternatives • Equity/Inclusion s Resiliency E Environmental ■ Freight Mobility r Safety ■Transportation Demand ■ Transportation Demand Alt 1 Alt 2 3.3 3.3 6.7 8.3 9A 9.4 &0 9.0 6.7 6.7 21.0 2L0 8.6 8.6 •Safety 8 Freight Mobility Aft 3 3.3 $.3 9.4 9.0 6.7 24.0 8.6 f Environmental AIt4A Alt48 0A 0.0 5.0 6.7 1.9 1.9 1.5 1.5 1.7 1.7 18.0 18.0 4.3 4.3 Resiliency ■fquity/Inclusion Alt 5 AR 6 1.7 6.7 5.0 5.0 1.9 0.0 0.0 1.5 5.0 0.0 12.0 0.0 2.9 0.0 ■ Relative Cost of Alternatives VOLUME 1: FEASIBILITY REPORT 1-90 Corridor - Easton to Cle Elum Feasibility Study 1 62 4.3 Tier 2: Targeted Evaluation The highest performing alternatives from the Tier 1: Initial and Revised Evaluation phase were advanced into the Tier 2 evaluation. The purpose of this second evaluation was to further explore the differences among the alternatives that had relatively close scores. Based on the evaluation as presented in Table 4-3 and Figure 4-1, three alternatives scored higher than the other alternatives, but were very close in their scoring: • Alternative 1: 1-90 Outside Widening • Alternative 2: 1-90 Median Widening • Alternative 3: 1-90 Median Widening, Reversible Lanes CHAPTER 4: ALTERNATIVES EVALUATION CRITERIA To further differentiate between these alternatives, additional Evaluation Criteria were used to help distinguish potential differences. Since all three alternatives were modifications to 1-90, WSDOT provided input into the additional criteria. The additional criteria used in the Tier 2 Targeted Evaluation are presented in Table 4-4. VOLUME I: FEASIBILITY REPORT 1-90 Corridor - Easton to Cle Elum Feasibility Study 1 63 9 R W C .y 7 W M N � N to a R nn c M N 0 a R O W1 L O z CHAPTER 4: ALTERNATIVES EVALUATION CRITERIA Using the same process used in the Tier 1 Evaluation, Table 4-5 presents the Tier 2 Targeted Evaluation for 1-90 Alternatives' Performance Measurements (rating) for the identified criteria. Additional traffic modeling was also undertaken which compared the three alternatives. The results of this modeling exercise are presented at the end of Appendix A The public input via a survey and Open House was conducted in February 2024 (see Chapter 5). The public voted on one or more preferred alternatives. Alternative 2 received the most votes with Alternatives 3 and 1 almost tied (see Figure 5-3). The public heavily favored improvements that encroached upon the median over outside widening or outside of the 1-90 corridor. Table 4-6 below presents a summary of weighted scores for each alternative by Project Goal, as well as a diagram (Figure 4-2) showing how each alternative compared to each other. Detailed evaluation worksheets, along with explanations for the scoring, are included in Appendix H. A comprehensive environmental evaluation was also performed, and findings are presented in Appendix G. 4.4 Alternatives Selected to Move Forward The Tier 1 Evaluation identified all three 1-90 alternatives as the best -performing alternatives aligning with the Project Goals compared to alternatives outside of the 1-90 right-of-way corridor. However, given the comparable scores for all three 1-90 alternatives, the County and WSDOT conducted a Tier 2 Evaluation to further compare the top three alternatives to each other still based on the Project Goals. Although all three 1-90 alternatives scores were again very close, the County and WSDOT concluded expansion in the median of 1-90 would likely cause less disruption to traffic flow, and less physical impacts to the natural environment and surrounding communities. Therefore, Alternatives 2 and 3 will move forward and be further evaluated in the next phases of this study. More information about next steps is presented in Chapter 6. VOLUME I: FEASIBILITY REPORT 1-90 Corridor Easton to Cle Elum Feasibility Study 1 65 a+ Q a E u E a Fa O N toic " c0- N oacmwac c w u i> E W: " 'x .E i o •= N i a" No c o d N �: p N'X E: 0 0'x: +' o.o: G N vOi . q� v vOi : C 4RL1 VOi : r0+ pn "6 : E N > N N N E u o oo u o °o u o o a o u; u o a a: o: o: a z: o z c: o 0 MN �;MN �'MN �;MNrMNr E v v c c UIl v E v c V = 3 U o O x G, is c E o c - p m T C O a R N O oc f6 c� O c a. lua c E > L. y� T .> T . C In n a n a m Cf V R o: " w o o: � o E: N E W K 14 C: d O: _ N o M: t6 N O: N _ c 0 SD: H E a, > c o:r � N.` O.o E- ° E:>O :cER�.Lic'��uO�V wi coy o:t E n: E E: o ai ou nn •-' = u°1n' > o E: n>. c: o ou: u rya Et:Oca:.4=a:N a' u 'N m N N W N O N O p�: d N o: N !0 O: N a o: N O N b4 C9 O1 N: N N N . c E u: c E u: E= °1: u o v: E 'o a, u u uu.000: 000: o. o:omo: oa C E c: u VI z: u V7 z: E n cn: C c: u d c) C O I I I I I I[ I I I J I I I t l I I t I I I[ I I I R =o U : c o M R c O 3 u N y V v pq o J C = � C Y C C c R = o R R E O � .a H •R M Y � O = V .� C. L v R E E o E m d L 41 J p Y: u N > N : A R d io d R y y n: 4 a' m c o uo b0 c O U, Y a S ■ O 12 s en .i N i, n E m n ro a 'n o O d u: n is a a u p t d to y > 0 ` N ro v •v bA : yl J O y Y d N d n yl E s ui `i n d X ` n E c: :E o O Q h t � u� ` a d ylY E a 0 n: Y E_ i a O m o d > w o f "NO tV6 E u o U 3 ro y C= R L H C Y E =mod •�wd dung a�roo .Eo o ro E N C 3 J T O C d p 10 y O = O 0 0° d ° d C d N O .o d u d d i n E >> E 3�E L'OO°'c.� OuEa'Y d m d E o o d ? c L o � >> C > C Ip n' C E: ro C C C 0 o N o v a E °' v o N u n. o o a a d n a v; E a d n d', m N a: o" o E E o E o o. •c o> o X: E O '- m: d a a o zoo: o- no m: o I I I I I I I I I I I I I i I a a °1 In N nn bn : d — .o o ro o a y '� - y n 00 d 0 a 9 O r E E «u0 o tG d N U J .V a C bn bn d C a `• O ^Q a C ro Y to ro C O p ro v a SEs E a y •V bn j c- E L '3 .� Y N w y c O. Y ad+ n ro o c rn ° n bn u m E M - _ toE d ro c W u d w O N N °: R L i C « 0 s m u A s 'o >0 3 YI L bn a e n c E d u C c a E m >o •q C V N �� C T C « 4 am` t- Q Y O A 9 ad+ Y •y u ad+ C O C y W d V d In d !6 N '� C C d d L N •N U In n.: GO 6 u V to E 0 0: d N O G d 'a� O C O •� Y d adN+ O 'In 0 ro ro N C V m d u ix C1 kF a a (0 O bn o M N E i d C N Y c +d+ O i N O T C T A E V 00 c d d m N Q T N L !0 +O-• V c c y V d C > O y In N 0 O V d 2 d c d T C ro d 7 H� d L 9 N p E T N_ • •LL 0 LL Y : d LL C N ..« M1 i 'N : �� 't N d aT+ 7 aLd+ �yo:� u A N E VOO` 7 N V v i V A C d �: O v V N c E E: r .E OV C O> C EE9.9cc T CL:C CN:C ct d y m 6 3 o ;3 d N: O d d: N d +0 d 0 °: d O d d: O._: O. O C: d O L E: of o 3: 0 o m: m o m O c O d a d N c E d N N d N J i d u c - � N E -°d o -o 0 E c > bn .n 3 0 L9 >� N N� O E L N> nn A H yr o_ o w N N E o > o N c c c v R o: d o 0 0 d a E a d d a v ° L : .y u r- o o f L; 3 0 on: m[2 u� nc: >.O c E CO N N N EL• d d d o 0 n 0 0 O+ u u O: vl o1 v: V.. N b+29 E' E : j O N V: 0 0 0; ° d Y W a E O N °- c >>> Y E o'E_ a E E o.E oo of o z E: p au aaa aaa Y d d �+ O L d n rti� 7 c O •' VI O d O o E f m d Ou O � o d.N E «o E 0 o NA u :'70p Y ua+i N N N@ D L vl o n O 'in O o> d a c d Y= 0 �✓ a c d o a c o d o� •� c v E = a> oe u =a d c v v A d d d?� cu •N ra p rt a:"n L m c d> d -° W •n d d O U itl C 'c d: 1 d Ed m £> >` v c 9 En:d W'O uC� OL L y u.d+ ul >w:E �.> > :o >� o C m y w e °- O: C V C O C C C L 'y O N d 3:'� w V m 0 coip> V O o v: E Y '� c vyd N c: C N a C O C OO d u: C o IO o Y' d o10 0 0 d c a r o m 0 O d e v V � d d 'Y T O EO G n V •� d W V O = Q 11 11 CHAPTER 4: ALTERNATIVES EVALUATION CRITERIA Table 4-6 Tier 2 Evaluation —1-90 Alternatives Weighted Scores Alt 1 1-90 Outside Widening Alt 2 1-90 Median Widening Alt 3 1-90 Reversible Lanes Safety ..................................................................................................................... 20.0 20.0 22.5 Transportation Demand 8.6 8.6 7.9 ..................................................................................................................... Freight Mobility 6.7 6.7 6.7 .......................................................................................................•............. Environmental 6.0 6.0 6.0 ..................................................................................................................... Resiliency ..................................................................................................................... 9.0 7.5 7.5 Equity/Inclusion 6.7 8.3 8.3 ............................................................................................................................................................................... Relative Cost of 3.3 3.3 0.0 Alternatives Total Score 60.2 60.4 58.9 VOLUME is FEASIBILITY REPORT 1-90 Corridor - Easton to Cle Elum Feasibility Study 1 69 CHAPTER 4: ALTERNATIVES EVALUATION CRITERIA Figure 4-2 Tier 2 Evaluation Summary by Alternative -Weighted Score 70.0 60.0 50.0 40.0 30.0 20.0 10.0 ■ Relative Cost of Alternatives s Equity/Inclusion ■ Resiliency ■ Environmental ■ Freight Mobility III Safety m Transportation Demand Alt 1 3.3 6.7 9.0 6.0 6.7 20.0 8.6 Alt 2 3.3 8.3 7.5 6.0 6.7 20.0 8.6 [" 22.5 1 Alt 3 0.0 8.3 75 6.0 6.7 22.5 7.9 VOLUME I: FEASIBILITY REPORT 1-90 Corridor Easton to Cle Elum Feasibility Study 1 70 5 COMMUNITY AND STAKEHOLDER INVOLVEMENT Public outreach is a critical part of any planning study. It harnesses the insights of roadway users and other members of the public who supply the local knowledge, context, and information necessary to make informed project decisions. Engagement of the residents, travelers, and other drivers who regularly use 1-90 in Kittitas County is a key factor in this project's success. Consistent with Kittitas County (County) and the Washington State Department of Transportation (WSDOT) community engagement practices, this feasibility study process included opportunities for the public and stakeholders to share their concerns, issues, and preferred solutions. Various forms of outreach were used to ensure the widest range of engagement within the study area and the County as a whole. The general approach for public outreach included: • Development of a Public Outreach Plan • Creation of the STEER 1-90 Coalition (discussed below) to share and disseminate information about the study • Interviews with organizations, agencies, and businesses that use corridor roadways as part of their routine business, with a focus on freight mobility • Collection of broad public input on 1-90 issues and potential improvements through virtual workshops, an open house, and surveys The County and WSDOT reviewed public, stakeholder, and affected agencies' comments and concerns that were received during the public outreach activities. This feedback was used to help: • Guide the development of project alternatives to address the ongoing traffic concerns along 1-90 in the study area • Develop evaluation criteria to accurately measure the ability of the proposed alternatives to address concerns • Select the preferred alternative to move forward for further analysis, pending funding. VOLUME 1: FEASIBILITY REPORT 1-90 Corridor Easton to Cle Elum Feasibility Study 1 71 CHAPTER 5: COMMUNITY AND STAKEHOLDER INVOLVEMENT 5.1 Public Outreach Plan The Public Outreach Plan outlines a framework for stakeholder engagement and public involvement activities. The Plan was prepared to guide the approach for outreach to the public and stakeholders to learn about the project and the study, ask questions, and submit comments on their concerns and their favored alternatives. The following goals and objectives helped guide the public involvement and communications strategy. • Goal 1: Promote an understanding of the purpose and need for the project and the study and the process leading to final decisions. • Objective: Ensure comprehensive information about the study and the decision process is available to the public and the media. • Goal2: Involve the stakeholders and public early on and throughout the process. • Objective: Involve new and existing stakeholders by providing a range of public input opportunities. • Objective: Provide continued communication and feedback to the public throughout the process. • Objective: Publicize meetings and activities through multiple and diverse communications vehicles. • Objective: Seek participation of all potentially affected and/or interested individuals, communities and organizations. 1 https://steeri90.com/ • Goal3: Ensure that public input is incorporated into the decision -making process. • Objective: Involve the community and other stakeholders at key milestones and decision -making points throughout the environmental review and design process. • Objective: Solicit meaningful input from affected communities on the range of alternatives and potential impacts. • Objective: Respond to public comments in a timely and thorough manner. • Objective: Report back to the community on how their feedback has been considered and incorporated into the decision -making process. These goals and strategies were implemented through various forms of communication, as presented in the following sections. 5.2 STEER 1-90 Coalition The County oversaw the funding and development of the STEER 1-90 Coalition, comprised of stakeholders from a range of organizations engaged in improving this portion of the 1-90 corridor. STEER 1-90's websitel serves as an online forum to disseminate information about the project and bring together community and regional stakeholders, including business owners, legislators, and industry leaders. STEER 1-90 focuses on bringing attention to the need for 1-90 improvements in the study area via lobbying, public outreach, and technical study. Utilizing STEER 1-90's website, the County facilitated seamless communication with the public, enabling the dissemination of information through various channels including VOLUME I: FEASIBILITY REPORT 1-90 Corridor Easton to Cle Elum Feasibility Study 1 72 CHAPTER S: COMMUNITY AND STAKEHOLDER INVOLVEMENT webinars, the establishment of a mailing list, and the facilitation of online public surveys. 5.3 Tribal Coordination In late 2022, the County and WSDOT reached out to Tribes deemed to have potential interest in the project and study process. Tribes contacted via email in December 2022 were: • Colville Tribes • Muckleshoot Indian Tribe • Snoqualmie Indian Tribe • Confederated Tribes and Bands of the Yakama Nation An overview of the project and the study process, along with a map of the study area, was provided to each Tribe. In May 2023, the Snoqualmie Tribe requested a meeting with the project team. This online meeting was held on June 21, 2023. Also in May 2023, the Yakama Tribe contacted the project team and requested updates as the project moved forward. The Colville Tribe and the Muckleshoot Tribe did not wish to be involved at that time. In January 2024, both the Snoqualmie and Yakama Tribes were provided graphics and descriptions of proposed alternatives, an evaluation summary, and were informed of upcoming opportunities for engagement, including a webinar and open house. 5.4 Public and Stakeholder Engagement The following sections summarize public and stakeholder engagement efforts, beginning in June 2023. Activities listed below were primarily initiated at two key milestones: • At the initial kick-off of the project to gather the public's thoughts and concerns about travel in the study area, and • Prior to the release of this draft report, to gain insight into the public's thoughts on alternatives and their preference for a preferred alternative. 5.4.1 Information Distribution and Notices The STEER 1-90 website is the primary host for the project using links to other project platforms. The website provides information about the study, upcoming project milestones, and public involvement opportunities. It also serves as a point of access to collect public input and as a location where questions about the project can be addressed. The website includes opportunities for the public and stakeholders to sign up to receive email communication and updates regarding the project. 5.4.2 Stakeholder Interviews Stakeholder interviews were held in June and July 2023. The goal of the interviews was to obtain information and concerns regarding current travel conditions along the 1-90 corridor in the study area. Most interviews took place via telephone, with some stakeholders opting to complete a questionnaire. A mix of industry, agency, and port representatives were included in the interview pool based on discussions with the STEER 1-90 Coalition. A list of stakeholders contacted during the engagement process is presented in Table 5-1. Questions focused on: • Gathering feedback regarding the purpose and need of the study • Understanding how traffic and mobility affect the stakeholders' respective organizations • Identifying current traffic mobility concerns in the study area VOLUME I: FEASIBILITY REPORT 1-90 Corridor - Easton to Cle Elunn Feasibility Study 1 73 CHAPTER 5: COMMUNITY AND STAKEHOLDER INVOLVEMENT Table 5-1 Stakeholders Contacted and Interviewed Stakeholders Contacted Interviewed Inland Port Authorities Washington State Port X Authorities ............................................................................. Port of Quincy X ............................................................................. Port of Warden X ............................................................................. Port of Pasco ............................................................................. X Port of Mattawa X Industry Private Farm Organizations (Quincy, Washington): BAM Farms, Allred Farms, Stahl Farms, Davis Farms ............................................... I............................. Lamb Weston (Washington Plants) ............................................................................. PNW Veg Co. (Washington Plants) ............................................................................. Amazon ............................................................................. Microsoft X Agencies WSDOT Maintenance ............................................................................. X Cle Elum Police Department X ............................................................................. Cle Elum Fire Department X. ........................................................... Cle Elum — Roslyn School X District Recreation Suncadia Resort X ............................................................................. Sleeping Lady Mountain Resort ............................................................................. Icicle Creek Center for the Arts ................................................................... . Washington State Parks - Palouse to Cascade Trail ..... ............. US Forest Service District Ranger Key takeaways from these interviews included: • Congestion is impeding freight mobility and emergency response • Commuting to/from the general area is on the rise, thus increasing travel time • Traffic congestion is contributing to an inability to attract new employees • Environmental impacts and climate change should be considered as part of the study Information gathered from these interviews contributed to the development of the project's alternatives, as well as criteria for the evaluation process. 5.4.3 Public Surveys Two public surveys were conducted to received input from the public and stakeholders to identify: • Community concerns, to assist with development of the Project Purpose. • The community's preferred alternative(s). In addition, voluntary demographic information was collected to provide the project team with an overview of the population profile of respondents. Public Survey 1: Summer 2023 During the initial stages of the project, from July 13 through August 18, 2023, public opinion was sought via an online survey linked through the STEER 1-90 Coalition's website and promoted through various stakeholders' social media accounts. The purpose of the public survey was to better understand how the public uses this portion of 1-90. Survey questions are presented in Table 5-2 below. Over 900 survey responses were submitted to the County. Figures 5-1 and 5-2 provide a summary of concerns and priorities. Appendix I contains the Public Survey Summary. VOLUME I: FEASIBILITY REPORT 1-90 Corridor - Easton to Cle Elum Feasibility Study 1 74 CHAPTER S: COMMUNITY AND STAKEHOLDER INVOLVEMENT Table 5-2 Public Survey 1, Summer 2023 — Survey Questions Travel on 1-90 in the Study Area 1. How do you travel on 1-90 from Easton to Cle .Elum?.......................................................................... ........................................................................................ 2. How frequently do you use any portion of 1-90 between Exit 70 (Easton) and Exit 85 (Cie Elum)? ................................................................................................................................................................... 3. What are the main reasons you travel on 1-90 between Exit 70 (Easton) and Exit 85 (Cie Elum)? Areas of Concern 4. What is your biggest concern related to this section of 1-90? Please rank from 1 (biggest concern) to 5 (least concern). ................................................................................................................................................................... 5. In the vicinity of 1-90 between Exit 70 (Easton) and Exit 85 (Cie Elum), which of the following roadways do you think is the biggest concern? Potential Improvements 6. When considering alternative improvements on 1-90 or the surrounding roads, what do you think should be the priority? Please rank the following in order of importance, from 1 (most important) to 4 (least important). ................................................................................................................................................................... 7. Which of the following do you consider to be the best solution to improve traffic on 1-90? Additional Comments — Open -Ended 8. Is there anything else you would like us to know about the section of 1-90 between Exit 70 (Easton) and Exit 85 (Cie Elum)? Respondent Information/Demographics 9. What is your annual household income? ................................................................................................................................................................... 10.What is your age? ................................................................................................................................................................... 11. How do you identify your race/ethnicity? ................................................................................................................................................................... 12. Do you identify as Hispanic and/or Latino? Figure 5-1 Public Survey 1 Results Summary — Biggest Public Concerns Safety Increased commute/ travel time Condition of the road Economic impacts of delay Environmental impacts Percent of respondents who ranked each option: ■ 1st 2nd 3rd 4th 5th VOLUME I: FEASIBILITY REPORT 1-90 Corridor - Easton to Cle Elunn Feasibility Study 17S CHAPTERS: COMMUNITYAND STAKEHOLDER INVOLVEMENT Figure 5 2 Public Survey 1 Results Summary — Prioritization of Improvements safety (improve/maintain safe move- ment of people and vehicles) Mobility (improve flow of traffic) Economic vitality (economic well-being for surrounding communities) Environment and Health (protect human health and the environment) 20 40 60 80 Percent of respondents who ranked each option: ■ 1st 2nd 3rd 4th Information gathered provided a foundation for development of the project's alternatives, as well as criteria for the evaluation process. Public Survey 2: February 2024 A public survey was available both at the in -person Open House and online. The survey invited community members to identify their preferred alternatives) and to share any additional insights with the County and WSDOT. As presented in Chapter 4, the majority of respondents indicated Alternative 2 as their preferred alternative Figure 5-3 Public Survey 2 Results Summary — Preferred Alternative (see Figure 5-3). Please 1.) what alternative would you like to see as part of the 1-90 improvements refer to Table 5-3 for between Easton and Cie Elum? Select all that apply. an overview of the 100% survey results. A total 90% of 74 respondents t provided information about their preference i0 and their reasoning. W 00. Appendix i provides v 50% more information about 1.2 40% the survey methodology cy and results. 20%CA 0 10% 1 . I . ri 0% a ,01INoaze `C`a� ��Q scams C Je �.��� �L`42 has& C� Preferred Alternative of Responding Individuals VOLUME I: FEASIBILITY REPORT 1-90 Corridor - Easton to Cle Elum Feasibility Study 1 76 CHAPTERS: COMMUNITYAND STAKEHOLDER INVOLVEMENT Table 5-3 Public Survey 2, February 2024 — Survey Results Alternative # Votes Reasons Alternative 1: 25 • Prioritize options that keep traffic on the freeway (1-90) Widen 1-90 to • Reasons include reducing congestion and improving emergency the Outside response times • Avoid diverting traffic onto county roads to minimize hazards for residents Emphasize safety, environmental impact, and long-term solutions Preserve neighborhood integrity and minimize disruption to residents • Considerations include minimizing costs, preserving private property, and reducing environmental impact ................................................................................................................................................................... Alternative 2: 46 • Advocacy for economical options to minimize congestion and Widen 1-90 in hazards the Median • Prioritize keeping traffic on 1-90 to aid emergency response and safety • Utilization of existing freeway right of way for cost-effectiveness • Support for widening 1-90 to improve traffic flow and safety • Preference for options minimizing impact on local roads and residents • Consideration of snow removal efficiency and access management • Proposal for inward expansion to minimize environmental impact • Emphasis on maintaining safety, environmental impact, and property rights Support for expanding 1-90 lanes to accommodate traffic and improve safety • Recognition of cost-effectiveness and reduced habitat destruction • Proposal for cost -saving measures such as utilizing existing median space • Advocacy for additional lanes on 1-90 in both directions for efficiency VOLUME I: FEASIBILITY REPORT 1-90 Corridor Easton to Cle Elunn Feasibility Study 1 77 CHAPTERS: COMMUNITY AND STAKEHOLDER INVOLVEMENT Table 5-3 (continued) Public Survey 2, February 2024 - Survey Results Alternative 3: Widen 1-90 in the Median, Reversible Lanes Alternative 4a: SR 903 Extension Alternative 4b: Bullfrog Road Extension Alternative 5: South Route Alternative 6: No Build 27 • Emphasize economical options for efficiency and effectiveness • Advocate for keeping traffic on 1-90 to avoid congestion and hazards • Prioritize safety for residents, especially during emergencies • Support for alternatives preserving neighborhood integrity • Preference for options allowing traffic to remain on 1-90 • Consideration for construction impact on traffic and property • Importance of durability and traffic management, especially during holidays • Concerns about emergency access and traffic flow in case of incidents • Advocacy for expanding lanes on 1-90 to handle heavy traffic • Emphasize cost-effectiveness and minimal disruption to resources • Support for reversible lanes in the median to maximize flexibility • Consideration of safety and adaptability in proposed solutions • Proposal for separation of trucks from other vehicles for safety .................................................................................................................................... 1 Alternate 4A need second way out and not the dead end in case of a fire or high winds (downed trees) .................................................................................................................................. - 3 • Emergency evacuation. • Easy snow plowing. Move access from Bullfrog Rd to 1-90. • This choice, 4B may be the least impactful to surrounding area, i.e. short distance, no residential homes. ....................................................................................................................................- 1 • Easton to exit 74 first then widen to Nelson Siding westside Upper Peoh, don't go through south Cle Elum. Local traffic only. ...................................................................................................................................... 2 • All of these 1-90 improvements wont happen for years. • Highway expansions historically only offer temporary reductions in congestion (after temporarily impacting traffic during the -10 year construction period). They are also extremely costly, particularly when current highway maintenance needs are severely underfunded, and have adverse environmental impacts. Likewise, scenarios 4A, 4B, and 5 would significantly impact the rural character of the immediate area without any clear benefit (other than apparently diverting traffic off 1-90) and run counter to the County's own plan of "preservation of the existing and future transportation system should be a funding priority ahead of expanding the system." Alternative 6 should be further expanded to look at actual expansion alternatives such as permanent variable speeds, lower county road speeds, traffic speed cameras, increased State Patrol emphasis, etc. VOLUME I: FEASIBILITY REPORT 1-90 Corridor Easton to Cle Elum Feasibility Study 1 78 CHAPTER S: COMMUNITY AND STAKEHOLDER INVOLVEMENT 5.4.4 Virtual Open Houses (Webinars) Two virtual open houses were held as part of the outreach process — one at the onset of the study, and another prior to the release of the draft report. Both webinars were widely advertised two weeks prior to the events and recorded so they could be played for those not able to attend the live webinar. Advertisements were displayed between the communities of Easton and Cle Elum in the form of informational handouts and signs. Advertising methods included: • Kittitas County and STEER 1-90 website, interested party email list • Announcements on agency websites • Community bulletin boards and newsletters • Press releases • Social media announcements • Mailings to neighborhood associations in adjacent communities Webinar 1: August 10, 2023 Public Review of Study's Purpose and Need: An online open house was held to solicit feedback on the purpose and need of the study, including soliciting feedback regarding traffic and mobility concerns. Concurrent with the webinar, an online survey was posted on the Steer 1-90 website soliciting public comments. During the webinar, participants were asked to submit questions to the County for discussion during the webinar. Questions (and their answers) are presented in Table 5-4. Information gathered during this webinar provided a foundation for development of the project's alternatives, as well as criteria for the evaluation process. Webinar 2: February 20, 2024 Public Review of Alternatives and Evaluation: An online open house was held to solicit feedback on alternatives and their evaluation. Approximately 40 people attended the webinar. Seven alternatives were presented, as well as Table 5-4 Webinar 1, August 2023 — Questions and Answers Question What changes will be made to the 1-90 corridor or onloff exits? ................................................................. When would construction season for this project begin? Answer Not quite there yet. Currently right now we are identifying the issues. .................................................................................................. We need to make sure our solution is identified and funding is available. No set construction timeline at this time. Pushing to shorten this timeline with federal funding. It took 16-years to get a project started in this area The Upper County Traffic Committee studied and proposed some traffic calming measures. ... ....................................................................................................................................................... I ...... Will the County Public Works revisit We are back revisiting what measures we could employ. those to relieve some safety issues on the county roads being used to bypass congestion on the interstate? VOLUME 1: FEASIBILITY REPORT 1-90 Corridor Easton to Cie Elum Feasibility Study 1 79 an overview of the evaluation process and scoring. A survey was posted on the STEER 1-90 website for participants to complete, focused on ranking their three preferred alternatives. Figure 5-4 presents the participants' choices for a preferred alternative. Detailed polling results can be found in Appendix K. 5.4.5 Open House An in -person open house was held at the Cie Elum Senior Center on February 28, 2024 to solicit feedback on alternatives and their evaluation. Approximately 100 residents attended the open house. Information boards were displayed and staff from the County, WSDOT, and the project team were available to answer questions. Following initial viewing, a question and answer period took place. CHAPTER 5: COMMUNITY AND STAKEHOLDER INVOLVEMENT Figure 5-4 Webinar 2, February 2024 — Sample Polling Question The seven alternatives were presented, as well as an overview of the evaluation process and scoring. A survey was available for attendees to complete, focused on ranking their three preferred alternatives. The public voted on one or more preferred alternatives. Alternative 2 received the most votes with Alternative 3 and 1 almost tied (see Figure 5-3 under the public survey summary in Section 5.4.3). The public heavily favored improvements that encroached upon the median over outside widening or outside of the 1-90 corridor. Community Feedback During discussions with open house attendees, considerable attention was drawn not only to the public's preferred alternative(s), but also to existing alignment concerns that participants hope will be addressed within the scope of this project. A few attendees raised concerns regarding potential snow storage locations in Alternative 3. However, notable support was voiced for Alternative 3 due to its potential to mitigate disruption caused by lane closures in either the westbound or eastbound direction. VOLUME I: FEASIBILITY REPORT 1-90 Corridor - Easton to Cie Elunn Feasibility Study 180 A recurring theme of discussion centered on safety concerns associated with the curve in the vicinity of the weigh station (near MP 80), with attendees expressing hopes that the project would address this issue. Additionally, there was a consensus within the community to prioritize keeping 1-90 traffic on the interstate and discouraging the use of county roads as detours, rendering Alternatives 4A, 4B, and 5 as highly unfavorable. The majority of the attendees were very concerned about the inclusion of an alternative south of 1-90 (Alternative 5) which, from their perspective, would only exacerbate the existing problems of unsafe conditions in front of their homes (speeding), and hindered access to their driveways due to drivers exiting 1-90 and detouring through their neighborhoods. Discussions also touched upon the realization that this project may take several years to complete and the potential for interim safety CHAPTERS: COMMUNITYAND STAKEHOLDER INVOLVEMENT enhancements to county roads to deter traffic diversion. Suggestions included the implementation of traffic calming measures on county roads to improve safety in the meantime. While participants acknowledged the need for improvements on the county roads, they also recognized that these initiatives might constitute a separate project rather than being integrated into the 1-90 solution. Based on the public feedback from the activities held during February 2024, new criteria - focused on safety and mobility - were added to the evaluation criteria. The Tier 1 and Tier 2 evaluations were revisited and updated, based on what the County and WSDOT heard from the community. The County and WSDOT will continue to work closely with the community to ensure their voices are heard and included in the future analyses as the project progresses. VOLUME I: FEASIBILITY REPORT 1-90 Corridor - Easton to Cle Elum Feasibility Study 1 81 6 NEXT STEPS This chapter outlines the steps necessary to move the 1-90 Easton to Cie Elum project forward from a feasibility study to implementation. 6.1 Legislative Outreach and Funding Kittitas County (County) and consultants have engaged with federal legislators to inform them of the scope of the project, its importance, and the region's need to improve capacity issues along 1-90 in the study area. In March 2024, a delegation met with Washington State legislators in Washington, D.C. to begin this process. Additionally, a list of prospective federal grants has been compiled to target facilitating further design, environmental analysis, and eventual implementation. The following U.S. Department of Transportation grant and funding opportunities are potentially available for this project: • Better Utilizing Investments to Leverage Development (BUILD) Grant, Office of the Secretary for Transportation Policy • Federal Lands Access Program (FLAP), Western Federal Lands Highway Division • Infrastructure for Rebuilding America (INFRA) Grants, Office of the Secretary for Transportation Policy • Nationally Significant Federal Lands and Tribal Projects (NSFLTP) Program, Federal Highway Administration • Surface Transportation System Funding Alternatives, Federal Highway Administration • Transportation Infrastructure Finance and Innovation Act (TIFIA) Program, Build America Bureau • Transportation Infrastructure Finance and Innovation Act (TIFIA): Rural Project Initiative (RPI), Build America Bureau The County will continue working closely with the Washington State Department of Transportation (WSDOT) to identify potential state and/or federal funding opportunities to help advance project planning and design. Once funding is obtained, preliminary design and environmental analyses will be initiated. Current public engagement efforts will continue and be expanded through the STEER 1-90 Coalition. VOLUME I: FEASIBILITY REPORT 1-90 Corridor Easton to Cle Elum Feasibility Study 1 82 6.2 Preliminary Engineering The selected alternatives (Alternatives 2 and 3) discussed in Chapter 4 of this document will need to be further developed at a preliminary design level to more accurately understand the project footprint and potential environmental impacts. As part of the preliminary design phase, a best -fit alignment and method of widening the corridor will be further evaluated. There are multiple areas along the 1-90 corridor that will require interim alternative assessments to determine the best methods for reducing environmental impacts and minimizing interruptions to the traveling public. The overall goal is to identify an initial design footprint for the project to better analyze environmental and traffic outcomes. The design footprint will show the locations of improvements in the corridor, including stormwater facilities, earthwork, and CHAPTER 6: NEXT STEPS connection methods to the interstate. While no new access points to 1-90 have been proposed during the feasibility study, modifying existing access to accommodate additional lanes will be required. Future design work will include plan and cross-section views of the improvements and construction staging schemes to identify staging areas within or adjacent to the WSDOT right-of-way. Preliminary engineering, typically at the 5% to 10% level will be developed to determine potential environmental impacts, which is necessary in determining the level of environmental analysis and documentation that will be required for the project. Once the level of environmental analysis and documentation is identified, engineering design (typically developed to the 15% to 30% level) will move forward concurrently with the environmental analysis. VOLUME I: FEASIBILITY REPORT 1-90 Corridor - Easton to Cle Elum Feasibility Study 1 83 CHAPTER 6: NEXT STEPS 6.3 Environmental Analysis and Documentation 1-90 is a federal facility and is maintained and operated by WSDOT. Because of this federal nexus (and potential federal funding) federal environmental regulations must be followed. As funding becomes available the County, in partnership with WSDOT and in consultation with the Federal Highway Administration (FHWA), will prepare environmental documentation pursuant to the National Environmental Policy Act (NEPA). In addition, because of state and county involvement, the Washington State Environmental Policy Act (SEPA) and Healthy Environment for All (HEAL) Act would also be part of the environmental and approval process. Historically, FHWA has encouraged agencies to prepare a Planning and Environmental Linkages (PEL) study prior to moving forward with NEPA. However, WSDOT has determined a PEL is not necessary for this project since the purpose of such a study is to reduce the range of alternatives by identifying those that are not feasible (i.e., those that have fatal flaws) or do not meet the purpose and need for the project. Because this feasibility study narrowed down the alternatives and identified those that are not feasible and do not meet the purpose and need, preparation of a PEL would be a costly and unnecessary step. Therefore, the next step in environmental review is to identify the NEPA documentation (class of action) required for this project. Preliminary engineering will be developed to help identify potential impacts for key environmental areas including, but not limited to: noise, wildlife connectivity, fish passage, and cultural resources. Once preliminary design and environmental screening has occurred, the County will work with WSDOT to prepare information for FHWA regarding how to move forward with NEPA. Consultation with FHWA will be critical to determine the appropriate NEPA documentation. The necessary NEPA documentation can range from a Categorical Exclusion (CE) (a checklist which is often accompanied by technical studies) to an Environmental Assessment (EA) (more robust than a CE and requires a formal public comment period) to an Environmental Impact Statement (EIS). An EIS requires lengthy, in-depth analysis and formal public comment periods and hearings. The County will work with WSDOT and FHWA to determine which class of action is appropriate for this project. The County will determine the level of documentation to comply with SEPA. If it is determined a SEPA Checklist will be completed (with technical studies), the County may choose to adopt the NEPA documentation as part of their SEPA process. 6.4 Outreach and Engagement This feasibility study will be widely available via the STEER 1-90 website to the general public and stakeholders to review and provide comments. Comments received on this document will be compiled and reviewed and will be a key consideration when designing the scope of work and analysis approach for the NEPA/SEPA process. It is the County's and WSDOT's intent to re -initiate and expand upon the community and stakeholder outreach that was completed as part of this feasibility study as the project moves into the NEPA/SEPA process. VOLUME I: FEASIBILITY REPORT 1-90 Corridor - Easton to Cle Elum Feasibility Study 184 WSDOT will continue to work closely with the County and form an interdisciplinary team of WSDOT engineers, planners, and environmental specialists to review findings and help guide the NEPA process. Outreach activities during the environmental process may include: • Compilation, review, and consideration of public comments received on this feasibility study. • Continued coordination with the Yakama and Snoqualmie Tribes, as well as other interested Tribes. • Outreach to disadvantaged and overburdened communities. • Maintenance of the STEER 1-90 Coalition website with up-to-date information and project materials. • Online open houses to provide project progress updates to the surrounding communities and solicit input. • Regular briefings with non -governmental, community organizations and other groups that have requested them. 6.5 NEPA Preferred Alternative, Final Design, and Implementation Following completion of the NEPA and SEPA documents, and the identification of a Preferred Alternative, permit applications will be prepared and submitted to agencies with jurisdiction, and the final design will be completed. Once funding, design, and approvals are in place, construction of the project can begin, CHAPTER 6: NEXT STEPS pending local, state and federal funding. Construction phasing and timelines will be provided in the NEPA/SEPA documents and revised as needed once funding is secured. It is anticipated public engagement will continue through the construction phase. 6.6 Other Opportunities for 1-90 in the Study Area In addition to the proposed project, other short-term solutions can be investigated for implementation while environmental and design activities progress. These solutions are discussed in Chapter 2, and include: • Intelligent Transportation System Infrastructure (ITS) updates to the corridor. • Commercial Truck Parking Facilities (public or private) within or outside of the existing right of way. • Road safety improvements on County roads outside of the 1-90 Corridor study area. • Continue collaborating with residents to identify short-term methods of managing/ communicating surges of traffic on County roads. • Work with online mapping services/sources to discourage traffic re-routing of interstate traffic onto County roads not sized or designed for large increases in traffic volumes. • Passenger rail service to the area, although a longer -term solution, can also alleviate some traffic congestion along 1-90 corridor in the study area. VOLUME I: FEASIBILITY REPORT 1-90 Corridor- Easton to Cle Elum Feasibility Study 18S CHAPTER 6: NEXT STEPS 6.7 Immediate Next Steps In the coming months, following the release of this final document, the County will: • Make this document available for public review and input. Comments received on this document will be reviewed and considered as part of the environmental scoping process. • Continue to pursue funding opportunities to move this project forward into preliminary design and environmental analysis. • Keep the public and stakeholders updated via the STEER 1-90 website and periodic presentations to the STEER 1-90 Coalition. • Confer with WSDOT (and FHWA if necessary) to determine the level of NEPA documentation that will be required and whether a HEAL Act Environmental Justice Assessment will be required. VOLUME 1: FEASIBILITY REPORT 1-90 Corridor - Easton to Cle Elum Feasibility Study 1 86 REFERENCES BML Investments, LLC. 2024. Wenatchee Valley Shuttle. Accessed March 15, 2024. https://www. wenatcheevalleyshuttle.com/. Cle Elum Fire Department. 2023. Cie Elum's Volunteer Fire Department. Accessed February 19, 2024. https://www.cleelumfire.com/. Department of Archaeology and Historic Preservation. 2024. Washington Information System for Architectural and Archeological Records Data (WISAARD). Geospatial Dataset. Accessed March 28, 2024. htt s://wisaard.dah .wa. ov/Ma . Federal Emergency Management Agency. 2021. National Flood Hazard Layer. Geospatial Dataset. Accessed January 19, 2024. https:/Idata-kitco_qis.opendata.arcgis.com/ datasets/ldcafb998a71462caf6ea2fc4cd2cd5a o/explore. Federal Railroad Administration. 2024. Amtrak Daily Long -Distance Service Study. Accessed April 16, 2024. htU)s://fralon distancerailstud .or •/. Kittitas County Search and Rescue. 2021. Kittitas County Search and Rescue. Accessed February 19, 2024. https:/Ikittitassar.or/. Kittitas County. 2021. Kittitas County Shoreline Master Program. Update September 14, 2021. https:// www.co.kittitas.wa.us/uploads/documents/cds/smp/2020/2021%20SMP%20Document%20 FINAL.I7df. Kittitas County. 2022a. Channel Migration Zones. Geospatial Dataset. Accessed January 19, 2024. htt s://data-kitco ,,is.o pendata.arc is.com/datasets/cc2564dd6edf4f2e8fe7ae7d73aboeb9 0/ explore. Kittitas County. 2022b. Floodway. Geospatial Dataset. Accessed January 19, 2024. https://data- kitcoQis.opendata.arceis.com/datasets/baeal788c37645018a46888110fde8f5 0/explore. Kittitas County. 2024. Kittitas County Sheriff's Department. Accessed February 19, 2024. https://www. co.kittitas.wa.us/sheriff. NMFS. 2021. Steelhead_MiddleColumbiaRiverDPS_20050902. Steelhead Middle Columbia River Distinct Population Segment Critical Habitat Geospatial Dataset. Accessed January 30, 2024. https://noaa.maps.arc.gis.com/home/item.htmI?id=7ebd09a5f9c743eebb2368b83542fife7. VOLUME I: FEASIBILITY REPORT 1-90 Corridor - Easton to Cie Elum Feasibility Study 1 87 REFERENCES Northwest Indian Fisheries Commission. n.d. Statewide Washington Integrated Fish Distribution Online Map. Accessed February 1, 2024. htt s:// eo.nwifc.ori /swifd/. U.S. Geological Society. 2023. USGS National Hydrography Dataset Best Resolution (NHD) for Hydrological Unit (HU) 4 - 1703. Geospatial Dataset. Accessed January 19, 2024. https://apps. nationalmap.r ov/downloader/. Upper Kittitas County Medic One. 2024. Medic One - Ambulance Service for Upper Kittitas County. Accessed February 20, 2024. https://www.ukcmealcone.or . USFWS. 2010. FCH_ Solvelinus_confluentus-20101018. Revised Designation of Critical Habitat for Bull Trout in the Coterminous United States Geospatial Dataset. Accessed January 19, 2024. https:// ecos.fws.gov/ecp/species/E065?#crithab. USFWS. 2021. FCH_Strix-occidentalis_caurina-20211110. Revised Designation of Critical Habitat for the Northern Spotted Owl Geospatial Dataset. Accessed January 19, 2024. htt s://ecos.fws. ov/ ec /s ecies/B08B?#crithz'- USFWS. n.d. HUC 17030002. National Wetland Inventory. Geospatial Dataset. Accessed January 19, 2024. https://fw:-,p. ........--,--.;...d/wetlands/apps/wetlands-mapper. Washington State Joint Transportation Committee. 2020. Feasibility of an East-West Intercity Passenger Rail System for Washington State. htt s://Ie .wa. ov/ITC/Documents/Studies/ East%20West%20Rail/EastWestRail_FinalReportrune2020.pdf. WDFW. n.d. FP Sites. Fish Passage Geospatial Dataset. January 19, 2024. htt s:// eodataservices. wdfw.wa.eov/arc is/rest/services/A licationServices/FP Sites/Ma Server. WDFW. n.d. Priority Habitats and Species. Geospatial Dataset. Accessed February 1, 2024. https:// geodataservices.wdfw.wa.igov/hp/phs/. WSDOT. 2022. WSDOT - Habitat Connectivity Investment Priorities. Geospatial Dataset. Accessed January 19, 2024. https://i?,isdata-wsdot.opendata.arcgis.com/ data sets/ 176270dc6d4e4430a59684872602f157 2/explore. WSDOT. 2023. Washington State Freight and Goods Transportation System (FGTS) 2023 Update -Appendices. Accessed March 22, 2024. https://wsdot.wa.gov/sites/default/files/2024-01/fats- appendices-2024.pdf. WSDOT. 2024a. Freight Plans. Accessed March 22, 2024. https://wsdot.wa.gov/construction-planning! statewide-plans/freight-plans. WSDOT. 2024b. 1-90 - Snoqualmie Pass East - Cabin Creek Interchange to West Easton Interchange (Phase 3). htt s://wsdot.wa. ov/construction- tannin /search- ro ects/i-90-sno ualmie- iass- east-cabin-creek-interchan e-west-easton-interchan e- hase-3. WSDOT. n.d. Wildlife Crossing Structures. Geospatial Dataset. Accessed Jan 19, 2024. https://data. wsdot.wa.gov/arc£is/rest/services/Shared/HabitatConnectivitVData/FeatureServer/O. VOLUME 1: FEASIBILITY REPORT 1-90 Corridor Easton to Cle Elunn Feasibility Study 188 KITTITAS COUNTY DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC WORKS PUBLIC WORKS — BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS STUDY SESSION STAFF REPORT STUDY SESSION DATE: July 22, 2024 TOPIC: Speed Study Process Change ACTION REQUESTED: Direct staff regarding finalizing the process change to Speed Study requests. LEAD STAFF: Cameron Curtis RECOMMENDATION: Direct staff to alter the process in which Speed Study requests are processed. BRIEFING SUMMARY: • Public Works has received approximately 62 Speed Study requests over the last ten years. Only 11 of these studies resulted in a change to the Speed Limit. • Currently, all Speed Study requests require physical data collection which is condensed into a report. The results of every report are presented to the Board of County Commissioners and potentially a Public Hearing. • PW reviewed alternatives for evaluating speed revision requests including Grant County utilizes screening criteria to minimize County resources spent on Speed Studies. • Public Works has identified criteria by which Speed Studies requests could be screened for advancement. BACKGROUND: Public Works receives speed revision requests which require a Speed Study every year, and very few requests are supported by engineering evidence. Posted speed limit revisions are requested by residents, county officials and staff. Typically speed revision requests come from a property owner along the road segment. In 2023 alone, 7 speed studies were requested and only 1 was deemed valid enough to set a adjust the speed limit (14%). This pattern is consistent with the last ten years when a total of 62 speed studies were requested and only 11 resulted in a change to the Speed Limit (18%). To perform a Speed Study, the following are typical steps taken by Public Works staff: 1. Interact with the requester to explain the process, verify the scope of the request, and set initial expectations. 2. Install traffic tubes on the roadway in an appropriate location to ensure accurate data is collected. Typically, data is collected for 7 full days and equipment is then picked up sometime on day 8. 3. Data is transferred to staff to be processed and condensed into a reasonable format. 4. Accident data from the previous 5 years is pulled to identify a safety concern, if it exists. 5. Roadway geometry is evaluated to determine if the design speed for the roadway matches the posted speed limit. 6. Data is presented to the Board of County Commissioners to determine if an engineer's report should be prepared, and a Public Hearing should be set. This process can take anywhere from 4 to 6 weeks from start to finish depending on staff and equipment availability, and preliminary estimates indicate the study may cost approximately $500 including labor and equipment rental. Currently, Public Works does not charge a fee to make a request, nor is the number of requests limited by applicant or road. DISCUSSION: Public Works is interested in streamlining the process to provide an improved response time to County residents. In an effort to be responsive, PW has investigated various methods used around the State to determine the need for Speed Studies. An example is Grant County which utilizes a scoring sheet with 10 categories (Exhibit 1) to help identify whether a road is likely to receive support from the BOCC. PW also considered alternatives such as speed limits based on road classification and developed areas. These alternatives were not pursued as they did not provide consistency for drivers. Public Works has prepared a draft scoring sheet (Exhibit 2) which could be utilized to help communicate the speed data criteria and filter out unlikely Speed Studies, limiting time and resources spent on Speed Studies. Criteria includes: o Road Geometry o Existing speed data o Change in land -use within the immediate vicinity o Public Works Safety Concern o Sherrif s Office Safety Concern o Community Support These topics are found to be most effective when setting speed on rural roadways. FISCAL IMPACT: Public Works estimates that by utilizing scoring criteria, the number of speed studies brought before the BOCC may be reduced by as much as 75%. This would result in a cost savings of approximately $2,600 per year. ATTACHMENTS: Exhibit 1: Grant County Example Scoring Criteria Exhibit 2: Proposed Kittitas County Scoring Criteria Exhibit 1: Grant County Example Scoring Criteria ►r' - PUBLIC WORKS DEPARTMENT ..:=� 124 ENTERPRISE STREET SE EPHRATA, WA 98823 SPEED LIMIT PETITION ENGINEERING SCORING & RECOMMENDATION FORM LOCATION ROAD U-SE from 9-SE to City Limits SCORE 58 Evaluation Item Points Comments Points Roadway Geometry There is a vertical curve with associated no passing zone markings 5 (Horizontal and Vertical) 1-10 along the centerline for this section of road. There are no trees, fences, or close power poles along the sight lines, Driveway Site Distances 1-10 until you get to the City Limits. There are no driveways, until you 2 get to the City Limits. The section of road has (0) driveway approaches per mile. The Driveway Density Driveway De) 1-10 section is rural and has very low density for a rural area, until you 2 get to the City Limits. The 32' section of road is in very good condition and has paved Pavement Conditions & 1-10 shoulders. This makes it easy to go fast with this comfortable 9 Paved Shoulders section. The 25-MPH speed limit sign, just North of 9-SE, was not placed Crash History & 1-10 by the County and is currently not enforceable under County Code. 9 Regulated Speed Comments The County Code regulated speed is 55-MPH to the City Limits. FCC 07 Major Collector with T3 Heavy Truck Classification. Road Classification Slowing truck traffic along this route may cause trucks to take 3 (Arterial/Collector/Truck 1-10 local access roads instead of this designated T3 Truck Route. Route) This route is essential to AG Commerce. The 85% speed is 58-MPH, which is exactly what should be on a 55- Traffic Volumes MPH road. We do not have a speeding problem for this section Characteristics (85% speeds 1-10 of County Road. It should be noted that these speeds were taken 7 & Truck/Car Ratios) South of the non -enforceable 25-MPH sign, where the regulated speed is 55-MPH. The applicant will need to provide an updated list of petitioners Community Support 1-10 showing the level of Community Support to lower the speed along 3 this section of road. County Staff has conducted a field review of the petitioned section of road. The 25-MPH speed limit sign, just North of 9-SE, was not 18 Onsite Staff Evaluation 1-20 placed by the County and is not enforceable by Code. Consider an ordinance to add this section as a 35-MPH zone. Reduce the regulated speed from 55-MPH to 35-MPH, along Road U-SE, from 9-SE to the Engineer Recommendation City Limits, to support the designated T3 Truck Route. Request that the City of Warden place a 25-MPH speed limit sign at the City Limits and set a radar speed sign there too. Date and Signature 7.12.2023 Note: A high score supports the petition. 60 points is typically needed for recommendation. 100 point maximum. Office: (509) 754-6082 Fax: (509) 754-6087 Email: publicworksAgrantcoupMwa.gov Website: www.grantcouno wa. oy Exhibit 2: Proposed Kittitas County Scoring Criteria p�tiF n�C xnFS .. TO 11tFcoLL F ' 1U 11ITAS COUNTY K I'TTITgB COUW _X1'1V DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC WORKS SPEED LIMIT PETITION: ENGINEERING AND RECOMMENDATION FORM LOCATION Click or tap here to enter text. SCORE Evaluation Item Points Comments Points Road Geometry Click or tap (Horizontal and 1-10 Click or tap here to enter text. here to Vertical) enter text. Click or tap Existing Speed Data 1-10 Click or tap here to enter text. here to enter text. Change in Land -Use Click or tap within the Immediate 1-10 Click or tap here to enter text. here to Vicinity enter text. Click or tap Public Works Safety 1-10 Click or tap here to enter text. here to Concern enter text. Click or tap Sherrif's Office 1-10 Click or tap here to enter text. here to Safe Concern Safety enter text. Click or tap Community Support 1-10 Click or tap here to enter text. here to enter text. Engineer Click or tap here to enter text. Recommendation Date and Signature t Click or tap to enter a date. Click or tap here to enter text. Note: A high score supports the petition. 35 points is typically needed for recommendation. 60 point maximum. 411 N. Ruby St, Suite #1 TEL (509) 962-7523 Ellensburg, WA 98926 FAX (509) 962-7663 KITTITAS COUNTY DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC WORKS PUBLIC WORKS — BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS STUDY SESSION STAFF REPORT STUDY SESSION DATE: July 22, 2024 TOPIC: Charlton Road Speed Study Results ACTION REQUESTED: Direct staff regarding setting a Public Hearing to receive the Engineer's Report on the Request for Speed Reduction on Charlton Road LEAD STAFF: Cameron Curtis RECOMMENDATION: Direct staff regarding setting a Public Hearing for the Speed Reduction Request on Charlton Road. BRIEFING SUMMARY: • A resident on Charlton Road requested a speed reduction on Charlton Road from Wilson Creek Road to Naneum Road (MP 0.00 to MP 1.10). • The speed study was conducted from June 20, 2024 to June 28, 2024. • Speed study data collected at MP 0.65. • Average daily traffic (ADT) of 105 vehicles, with a 37% truck traffic percentage. • ADT distribution is 48% eastbound and 52% westbound at MP 0.65 • 85% speed is 48 Miles Per Hour (MPH) at MP 0.65. • [0] accidents in the past five years within the project study location. BACKGROUND: Responding to a request received on April 15, 2024, to reduce the posted speed on Charlton Road from 50 MPH to 35 MPH, Public Works deployed traffic data collectors June 20, 2024, and collected through June 28, 2024. The request indicated safety was the main concern, noting traffic from the Event Venue as particularly problematic. As event venue traffic was the main concern, traffic counting was delayed from the initial request in order to collect traffic which may be reflective of events. Additionally, the request notes six other residents in agreement with the reduction request. Data collected at mile post 0.65 has and ADT of 105 vehicles, and 37 percent truck traffic within the average daily traffic distribution of vehicle size. Traffic at this location is split 48.4 percent eastbound and 51.6 percent westbound. Overall 85th percentile speed at this location is 47.85 MPH with directional speeds of 48.5 MPH eastbound and 47.2 MPH westbound. A speed reduction on this segment of roadway was previously requested August of 2022. The speed study data at the time represented an 85% speed of 53 MPH. DISCUSSION: 85th percentile speeds show traffic is operating at the speed of the current speed limit of 50 MPH. The request asks the County to consider factors which are not considered by Federal Guidelines for posting speed limits on rural county roads including pedestrian usage, clear zone concerns, and school bus stop frequency. The County is currently meeting the Federal Guidelines for establishing speed limits by setting the speed limit within 5 MPH of the 85th percentile speed of free -flowing traffic. There are ten approaches along Charlton Road, primarily serving residential uses. There were no recorded crashes along this roadway in the previous five years. FISCAL IMPACT: None ATTACHMENTS: Exhibit 1: Speed Reduction Request Exhibit 2: Speed Study Results Exhibit 1: Speed Reduction Request Rebecca Cruse (PW) From: Sent: To: Cc: Subject: Importance: Follow Up Flag: Flag Status: Please see request below. Thank you, Contracts Specialist Kittitas County Public Works 411 North Ruby Street, Suite 1 Ellensburg, WA 98926 Direct Line: 509-962-7699 Cell: 509-201-2854 Candie Leader Tuesday, May 14, 2024 8:59 AM Josh Fredrickson; Cameron Curtis Tate Mahre; Kelee Hodges FW: Speed reduction request for Charlton Rd High Follow up Flagged From: Hana Kriebel <hanakr@hotmail.com> Sent: Tuesday, May 14, 2024 8:56 AM To: Candie Leader <candie.leader@co.kittitas.wa.us> Subject: Speed reduction request for Charlton Rd Importance: High CAUTION: This email originated from outside the Kittitas County network. Do not click links, open attachments, fulfill requests, or follow guidance unless you recognize the sender and have verified the content is safe. Good afternoon, my name is Hana Kriebel and I live at 1161 Charlton Road with my husband, 3 young children and many ranch animals. Two years ago my family and other families that live on Charlton Road, for safety reasons, requested to have the maximum speed limit on Charlton Road be LOWERED to 35mph or less between Wilson Creek Road and Naneum Road. Since our last denied request two years ago, Sweetwater Ranch, an 'Event Venue', particularly for weddings are happening every single weekend for the months of May to October. The amount of traffic has increased significantly even more! These events bring in many'Out of Town" guests and they are NOT aware of the cautions that come with our'Open Range' roads. Since our last denial and speaking to the owners of the venue it was recommended we place our own signage to help traffic. We purchased out of our own pockets reflective cones for along the side of the road. This addition has not helped the speed of the vehicles that fly by our place. Even when I am standing out at the mailbox holding hands with my five year old, they don't have the courtesy to slow down. Our farms are comprised of livestock, horses, additional farm animals and also include many wildlife crossings. Charlton Road may not have many homes on it, however, the existing homes consist of 80% families with young children under the age of 10. 1 pray that it does not take a wreckage or fatility for the change. In addition, there are two bus stops on the road for elementary school students. There still has yet to be any signage posted for "bus stop ahead." For these reasons, we request the speed limit on our road, Charlton Road, be lowered to the maximum speed limit of 35mph or less with proper signage. We plead for lowering the speed limit on our the road for safety. Thank you for your time and consideration. Sincerely, Residents of Charlton Road, Hana & John Kriebel 253-230-6714 & 509-312-5170 (The names below are in agreement and have asked to be added to this request) Victoria & Jesse McCormic, 1241 Charlton Rd. Paul & Shelly Arnold, 1571 Charlton Rd. Leanne & Dave Adams, Bill & Connie Criag 1371 Charlton Rd. Burton Gray & Roxanne Williams 570 Charlton Rd. Rosie Hale 401 Charlton Rd. Greg Ogden 835 Charlton Rd. The information transmitted by this email is intended only for the person or entity to which it is addressed. This email may contain confidential and/or privileged material. If you are not the intended recipient of this message, be aware that any use, review, retransmission, distribution, or reproduction is strictly prohibited. If you received this in error, please contact the sender immediately and delete the material from all devices. message id: 38eb45916c6dcbdac24bb8719d004a14 Exhibit 2: Speed Study Results d Q N LA Z D w ZZ w � LD C � LU VV\ w V i ;ijeum Rd O 1 ra N ' 1 ra u W 1 C 1 � E 1 cn 4- 1 ra AJ L / , 1 J � 1 C f6 /� � W a i—L 1 m ^it V 1 1 Y 1 0 c O w � v ce (�jr Z , o d O "� �_ � 1It L , (0 ro 'v 1 1 U 1 147 1 le 1 d' = 1 � 1 1 1 O 1 N a 1 0 .NI )Re J0 ,��,WV 0 x E E i a � � q E £ E � t y° n ` � E � a e a� $ o � yQfi Y C g $L$ 3 ! f y LL i 'CY y �� �E `s B� 2 pp H O m CEE C E�� � All � 3 i E doygiwi�ka G W uz u V a e Y i r2u �Z Road Number _ Road Name MP !43512 _ i E� 5%Speeds _ _ . _ - - iWB - Thurs ay i Beg in Time 6:44AM Thursday 'End Time _ 10:03 AM ;Total Hours I 171.32 ITotal Days _ 7.1 I _ Bikes _ ^ 'Kars & Trailer ! —12 Axle Long 48.5C Charlton Rd 0.660 _ _ 6/20/2024 6/27/2024 47.2C 47.85 _ 0.002 Begin Count Date End Count Date -�� - COMBINED TOTAL - J 814 114 TOTAL / TOTAL DAYS 0.36E FACTOR 0.92 0.26C - - - "- - COMBINED TOTALS _ - !Buses 0.001 - 12 Axis 6 Tire 0.322 !Single 3 Axle 0.00E i j Single 4 Axle 0.00c 0.035 Average Total _ _ Ad'usted ADT 114 Double < 5 Axle 105 Double 5 Axis _ Double > 6 Axle 0.001 0.001 % PERCENTAGE Multi <6 Axle Mutti 6 Axle 0.00c 0.00c Multi >6 _ 0.000 Cars, Pickups Trailers .72 _ 0.631 _ 0 33 1.0C Singles - - 37 - - _ Doubles Trains — 5 0.041 - - 0 0.00; _ 4"e 0.37 TOTAL TRUCKS_ TOTAL 114 1.00 TRUCK % GROSS ANNUAL TONS: CiV 5-00 TRUCK ROUTE CLASS: do•l Kittitas County Public Works ROAD NAME Via- IL;CtI f r1,� Begin Count Date 12:olc e. tou Time End Count Date3le, o2Y Time 10 (i3 Counter Number G Z . bS rti1 �'. cam' e.�-;,LSoY+ C,tzK t2D North Arrow Sketch counter location, identify tubes, distance tubes apart, and distance to nearest cross road or other identifying point. I 5 rev; 2 2 j.�✓,e 2o2y Posted Traffic Tech Date ROAD NAME CHARLTON RD MILEPOST .65 CROSS STREET .65 mi E of Wilson Creek Rd 12:00 AM 1:00 AM 2:00 AM 3:00 AM 4:00 AM 5:00 AM 6:00 AM 7:00 AM 8:00 AM 9:00 AM 10:00 AM 11:00 AM 12:00 PM 1:00 PM 2:00 PM 3:00 PM 4:00 PM 5:06 PM 6:00 PM 7:00_PM 8:00 PM 9:00 PM 10:00 PM 11:00 PM Average Daily Traffic (ADT) Volume Grand Totals Average Hourly Volumes EASTBOUND WESTBOUND 0.3 0.3 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0:3 0.1 0.1 0.9 0.6 0.7 2.9 1.5 3.4 2.0 3.5 2.8 3.9 2.4 4.4 4.9 4.0 3.1 2.7 4.3 4.0 3.9 2.7 8.9 2.9 3.6 4.9 3.1 3.0 4.7 2.7 3.1 3.7 3.1 3.4 1.0 2.4 0.6 1.9 0.4 0.9 55.4 58.5 Volume Totals EASTBOUND WESTBOUND 394 420 48.4% 51.6% Site: 43512 Thursday, 6/20/2024 6:45 AM - Thursday, 6/27/2024 10:00 AM Combined - 0.6 0.0 0.0 0.3 0.3 1.4 3.6 4.9 5.5 6.6 6.9 8.9 5.9 8.3 6.6 11.7 8.4 6.1 7.4 6.9 6.6 3.4 2.4 1.3 113.9 Combined 814 1 N ' Ln m a O 00 co W,.o�000vOr00000'o'000000oo00 aj� aoQ0o0oo0000'0000000000000 ( N N t0 N N A O N N c m 23 coo 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 o g o 0 o a o c o 0 0 0 o a 75 o 0 0 c o 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 d o'o to W. o a o 0 o a o 0 o g o O O O O O O O'O 0,0 O O O O O O 0 0 GIo t0 v N W O C O O O O 0 0 0 0 0 0 0,0 O O O O O g 0 0 0 0 a 0 0 0 0 0 0 o 0 0 0 0',0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0',0 10 n� W W o 0 00000 7 0000000*io'o 0000go O O O O O O O d O 0 o 0 O O O O O O 0 0. 0 Clo p O O 0 0 'i�0 �� 0000000r o,00,'°0000001000000'0 Ln 0 v 0 4).T o0 o'oo o'oovo'v o0 o 0 o 0 0 0 0;0 0`0 0 0 0.0 0.o 0 d00. t6 Y ~ N W W O o 0.0 O M O'.;q o'O vi.:M O D W r �? a CA o 0 0 0 0 0 0'0 0'0 0,0 0:0 0 0 0'0 0,0 0'0 0'0 �- y M V) r a' m 0 7 Q tW L O O O O O t0 M'M .-I'.O h 91 h:n 01 A O E M 0. . h M M:.i u = u� W F coon 0.0010 �� O' � OO'-.-1 O O O O LA f0 N u Iq OIO o g 0 0 0'a o q qo Orp O q q.0 O,O O.O 0 0 to O o o 0 o O o 0 G. 0 o 0 o o o 0 0 0 0.0 0 0 0 0 m _WX M O o O O O M V' M 0+ Pt n O h *i O t0 h N" t0 t0 ei .i m Q O N J 04 tj C!i ! O Ot � Iq tO tD M AD tO tD Of -+ .i O Ot tD O O 12W OO O.O 000.4,4 .i m 4-+N.�.iOOo U '0 cc t- in OO 0 0 0 0 OO O O O U �m C C 0 0 0 C O O 0 0 O O G�o O O OHO O p o 0 0 0 c 0 O W O F M O O O rl T h In O OD Q' 01 .-1 . M Ot 6t . t0 r1 h rl .-I O tp a O 0 06 00 0 .N N N N M m 4 -4 vi M m v M M'ri O O J I ce E U Ln W Ln F S g S S f E f g S f f S S f 8 f f f m Q a a a a Q a 4 a a a d a a a kL a a a a o. a a a UI 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 00 %� N .-I N M V IA tG � GO Ot O �j C" -1 NM a' Ln tp h 6 at p � W Y W WN C f z 0 in 0. 1 LU Q M K oC f U 0 0 O 0 W= o c a' o � o t0 ' A It Ln M LnF W M rn z O a 10 Z O W t� E U W 0 0 0 0 0 n o C�o C�o o C�o o D O O C� a o O (�0 C� 0 0 06 a 0 0 a 0 a 0 0 0 0 0 0 00 0 0 0 0 o 0 0 �D A on 0 Ono coo 0 0 0 o 0 0 o O b O:O o O O o o v,., O b 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 -O 0 0 0 0 0 j 3 Q £ III. lD ,0 0 0 o o o a 0 0 0 O O O o'O 0 C! (R,O 0 00 00 a) m o 0 O q O 0 0 p 0 0 OO O,O OO 0 0 O.O Ord O O O O.O Q O ;0O V a/ O O O O. O O O ri al al .••� D O O O O O O O O O O ., O O O O O O O O O 0 ,: 0. 0 O I O N 0 0 0 A o O O O O O O O :D 0 0 0 0 O "0 O O O O O 2.2 O o O -O.O 0 O10 000,00 d a 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 Ono 0 X.0 O O O O O O O O O (I -y O V' -! -� O P st O *+ ; O 0 0 in ^i ! O b 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0,0 O O O O O O (R,O O;O O'O O O O'O O O O O O'"'O O.O O.O O O O .'O O'O O O O.O O O O 6 O o 0"0 c n O O O'O O n 1p y ax) a) 0 0 D O D O O O, O n -I O 0 .-4 1 0 O .O 0 0 0,0 O `O C1 Q c 00 c 0 0 0 0 y O en En a'm T y O1 a .i n C� G� M .•� O� .+ n �� Ga) F 00 0 .O O O- 4 -4 N rl - i n +ti w O O -i r-I O =--I O -O O O = X a N O'O C� O O O o 'IO -� O'',,O O O O.O O"O O O O'O 1�)1 0 0 0 010 O O O :O O b 0 0 m a) 0 0 0 O O O M r .+ M N M r• r+ a it C� O! n 0 0! It O- I x C COCOOQ -4 . O. -i . O Q 0,0000 0 0 --4O Q 9 N dS L O O M-! O rD to O p 7- I n 7 ri ri O O Ib cr- r- � O' )�1 W 0 0 0 .O O d 0 0 -y O I" �'; .4 N 'r I O O N ra U F 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 ed O .O O O O O O O O C�O C�005,0 O O.O O O O O O O O-O O,O OHO O.O OO O.O O C m Ln 0 0 Q O M V Q O 0) (1) O O c O O H Q C Ln 9 M N O C A Of y, 10 �l o O C a) F M r-0 X y a M N -{ Ln rI O V) N m O rn v m n XX c o L N N rn o'd � an c to N ra Ln U F`- M rl L f)f -q a O 490 Y N £ m O N M O O M N �, m 7 IA T V b n O n Of G1 O n n It'. �t O Gn + v1 p 1.0 O O O LD N M M M V V N� a N N V M N M M ro --I p N H ynj Q a a'Q a Q Q Q Q Q a a a a a a a a a a a n V1 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 Oi0 0 0 0 0 0 0 OO 0 0 u 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 j Z r r7 N M d- in W n c0 0% O H N ',4N Cq It Ln %0 t. 00 0% O I Q � T o-Ci 10 H a 2 D m LU W 3 N O O O O O O O O (I -y O V' -! -� O P st O *+ ; O 0 0 in ^i ! O b 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0,0 O O O O O O (R,O O;O O'O O O O'O O O O O O'"'O O.O O.O O O O .'O O'O O O O.O O O O 6 O o 0"0 c n O O O'O O n 1p y ax) a) 0 0 D O D O O O, O n -I O 0 .-4 1 0 O .O 0 0 0,0 O `O C1 Q c 00 c 0 0 0 0 y O en En a'm T y O1 a .i n C� G� M .•� O� .+ n �� Ga) F 00 0 .O O O- 4 -4 N rl - i n +ti w O O -i r-I O =--I O -O O O = X a N O'O C� O O O o 'IO -� O'',,O O O O.O O"O O O O'O 1�)1 0 0 0 010 O O O :O O b 0 0 m a) 0 0 0 O O O M r .+ M N M r• r+ a it C� O! n 0 0! It O- I x C COCOOQ -4 . O. -i . O Q 0,0000 0 0 --4O Q 9 N dS L O O M-! O rD to O p 7- I n 7 ri ri O O Ib cr- r- � O' )�1 W 0 0 0 .O O d 0 0 -y O I" �'; .4 N 'r I O O N ra U F 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 ed O .O O O O O O O O C�O C�005,0 O O.O O O O O O O O-O O,O OHO O.O OO O.O O C m Ln 0 0 Q O M V Q O 0) (1) O O c O O H Q C Ln 9 M N O C A Of y, 10 �l o O C a) F M r-0 X y a M N -{ Ln rI O V) N m O rn v m n XX c o L N N rn o'd � an c to N ra Ln U F`- M rl L f)f -q a O 490 Y N £ m O N M O O M N �, m 7 IA T V b n O n Of G1 O n n It'. �t O Gn + v1 p 1.0 O O O LD N M M M V V N� a N N V M N M M ro --I p N H ynj Q a a'Q a Q Q Q Q Q a a a a a a a a a a a n V1 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 Oi0 0 0 0 0 0 0 OO 0 0 u 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 j Z r r7 N M d- in W n c0 0% O H N ',4N Cq It Ln %0 t. 00 0% O I Q � T o-Ci 10 H a 2 D m LU W 3 N Uf N Y v u c 0 � 3 z o o u, J E Ut0 to t _xNT Q � t0 V 1 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 O C 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0O O O O O O O O c 0 0 0 0'0 0 0 0'0 o a o.o 0 0 0 0 0 0 - o 0 o c 0 0 0 0 O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O 0 O C 0 0 0 0 O'O O O O O o 0 0,0 0 0 0 O O:O O O O c 0 0 O O O d 0 0 0 0 o v C? rr O 0 C! C! c CI O O 6 C;,6 6 Cr Ci CI o 0 0 0 0.0 0 o 0 C O 0 0 C 0 0 0 O 0,0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0.0 O N 0 0 0 0 0 0 O c 1 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 O. O O O O O O O O C 0 0 0 0 0 0 O O N It M h 1+1 t} M M t0 0 .-1 0 0 0 'It O O 0 0 0 c O 0 o 0 O'Ci O O O O O O O O O O O c 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 '0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 C P o ei o 0 0 0 0 0 0 0. oo 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 o c 00 000a00oo.+etoo r00000000c 0 0 0 O CI O. 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 O O O o 0 0 000 0 C r1 O O o O o 1� o .•a .i t0 -! T •t r� n M Nt n n tt O It K 0 0 O O 0 0 .-r N M N CM N. i r 1 .-1 N N N .y N .4 _ +-i O C O O O O O O O d O- 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 P O 0 0 0 0 C 100 o0 o to to(n In v rntq rt tod a t.%gato.i V r4 c a' P O M M O t0 tLf O (, O O Ot 'I O ei r-1 t0 h C� It V N, N N M N to a N M N M 14 O C 0 0 o a o 0 0 0 0 0 o M o 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 o a o c o G O Ci C O C o Ci o CI C) C Cf C O O CI o C G o C c c0 O O M M V t0 dt 1r1 tD O1 .: r"1 t� r -! 't al t0 1 't K t0 1, O t0 M N fS�F'ff�Sfg <f z gCL M Sf �¢QQ¢ad¢d¢B < a 2 a o_(L n.&n.mo.mmo.a 1 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0.0 o 0 00 O 0 0 0 o 0 00 c 0 0 0 0 99 0 0 0 o a 0 •- o 0 0 0 0 0 0 0.0 o c N 11 N of V' m t0 h co O o .. ,-[ N inn It I!1 tD (z m Ot O } n O C rn X N a J N Q1 cd fN U O 49. Y f m 0 O 0 N �-1 tD Gli N LA LA N N N N N O 0 Of a Im a? m M N A ei r a? N 1`'1 N O O Ci 0! A w V• N M a w O O+ z Z � mcoo m 14 .0 0 0 0 0 0 N O O O O O o 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 m O O O O O O O O O C O O V bn O O C O o 0 0 0 C o C G O 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 C V 'rn 0 0 0 0 0 0 0.0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 o a o 0 0 0 o c V V 0 0 o C CD o 0 o c o c o d o c o o c o 0 6 o d c o o a o c In V M g O T 'D M Q n m V a C! O 0 0 0 O O '� 0 0 0 0 .r O O, H .-r' N .i O H O O O O C V O O Z 0 ao+ O o O O O O C?.± M M N P Pti 'D �++`* o ooc000d000-=.,aoN oocc.+oo< F my V IO L n r0 n m 'O Y O v in Q i S o o o0000ea...+.-r.saa.,�vo+Mav-'.+00c _ 14 M o 0 o d o 0 0 0 0 0 o 0 0 0 0 0 O o 0 0 0 0 0 S N V o N o o o c c d o v o 0 0 0 0 0 o c o 0 o a o 0 0< N V N 0 0 0 0 0 -' O 0 0 '-I C!O O O N 0 0 m PtO m o C!C 0 0 0 o 0 0 0 P o 0 0 0 0 0 0 O O O O O o 0 0- C -' v u+0000o0000o00.+pr .+oa00o0 oe O 6 O O o 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 [i C 0 0 0 0 C V ri .i O O e m w O C a f S S f f f f i F F F f F F S F S E f f F£ S E Q p a Q p Q Q a Q p Qp Q QpO Q Q a a m a m a a p ap m e. m e 00 0 6 0 0 0 0 0 0i 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 p O 0 o C In b^ GO P O •N1 •! N M 7 N b n W P 0' W W ce Q � N z O to O w N O d L f U 'o N p O n N � V O O H n of m t0 V G a 0 y pV 0 V L � v C7 > M O .-I � O O ' iOp 'O L n vNj v E M a m ri Ln p N m N M M '�' v o I m O 0 n 6 V o N N g` cc m N V 1V N H ' O Go O M v 9 O N E m N n E N 9 0 m 1n v M O rn m n a N Cn Li m N v o G h 0 Npp d .M .i co n p N n .-1 E Nv � E c � O M S M ~ V rl L a � N � a E m 019 fn v o 403, r a �. d IL s d m m CA y 0 O M d z Z 0 O to W � 1 3 7 O G S ut n N \ ,r ut r Y u ,v O V \ C m z O W F J cc E Ln u \to. 'w E w Wa' z0�' 0 oW� a J 0 Dot f U O O O C! O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O G O O O C O O O b O 0 0 C 0 C) 0 0 6 0 0 6 0 6 O O O O O C 0000,00r1Pob0000.io..00000 OC O O O G O G O O O 0 0 0 0 0 G O 0 0 0 0 0 0 G C 000a000rim.+.�oo.+00000000 oc ' O O O C7 0Q C n 0 0 0 0 0 O O O C O O O O b O C 000000'oin ar+.+a.+m.+a,,PMooO oc oa000a•o.+�na�c'oM�o�cri�uo.,00wi oG ocooc❑i od Oo.-id000coo.-ioodce 0 0 O❑ tl b V V7 O N h V7 V) rl a 0 0+ fn M C cram r?mamkownaM-.,.!n Uo c O O O .... O O- m. 0 O w a " 0 a - - O 0 b O O O O O O O O O O ci O.4 C O 6 6 6 0 6 0 6 0 0 C I.+d tl0O-+rn o r,.. r, o o M r, C! n O-. r,4 tic O O 00 00 On O o 00 00 00 co 00 Oct 0 C 0 O c o d o o d o o a d o 0 o c o o c c o o d o c o c 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 4 0 n O 0 0 0 0 0 0 Q G❑ r1 O O- .-, q O' v ut b' p O n O r` C+ O b r. n 't p m 7 O O O O O O N m m m It v N @' N N v m N ""' m" . 4 aaQaQQ QQQ QQao.aa:naaan.aao o o 0 o g o,o 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 r1 N M V N w r• m m O rl N s9 N M Q w w N m m O r O 'C O OC r• ; O 'C G 'D r o\ a �o ut u c w ov V �\ L i O m � a � o c O L ut v d N \ E m Go M o m u o M N u O \ C1 c cm w u V) m ILV \ rn v u fn v\ 0 N {n C rl \ ~ L f E �! 9 E a N IN mu f O r m � N \ C �.-1 ltln r• .N.. m o m H Ln O n E N\ 7 O E C N E M ~ \ 10 C!C N ~ E N O " O � \ N L y a d n a°1i 0 N LUGo A Ln q F C 9 V V m a a a H v rn mcu Q A ❑ N M A r V c m w d a Y N U 0 0 vi oC � Z 00 0 W J E Uto ' 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 •+ 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 +-I 0 0� M � NI 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 OI O V 'o 00000n00000Mo.+000000000o v v I 'O oo66oc6o6.d6o6c66d66co666oc o v L v rn M m 0 0000000vmM.+oo COI C O O O C O o 0 o o o a C-o o 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0� .1 C v E Li 3 ' m n O O ut h O M' .I-� V- M O 0 0 0 0 .y of O� '^ v m qO K v N E mi U 1 .0 N e N a O N N h O V O O O w,� M a M� o 0 0 vI o 0 0 ' u O � W EY \ �O1 O G . u d' a I m 0 0 0 0 0 A b .-I K sr a O h .+ ^ 10' .!. n ^' M a r' .'I N ' u O; 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 .-I .+ eV N .-I .-' 'i �'I .-� O N o 0. 0 0 0 NC11 a ^ N N R ^' A 0 O� ,+1 n Q a M O M Lq N c \ C F EQ 1r1 e m � o m I.goo....dinUoonn a n n c� a• u d; � M E - N H R f ' 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 '+ O O '+ O O + O d 0 0 0❑ 0 0 .-I .i o M C m N \ m � H cn Q 0 d' .+ M a O rl 4 .y ti Ln ' u o� ' 000c000a ocococod ooc0000 ui 10 N\ E o �g ao e E ' N0 0 0 0 0 'i Q .O O M 0 0 0 6 r1' O O V^-• M 0 O O Lm O ' M r 0 0 0 0 O. 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 7 O O 0 d N L a N e N o n j o0000a000000.. .+moo-000000 Io E L9 rn u o" o 0 o a c o o d o c o o c ei o c o ri o 0 0 0 o c•l o M o; v t n Vl v It O% 10 'a O M T O d W n 0 0 0 0 0 rl tl1 r N 6 i0 h O �O ^ m �O ^ %6 �O �'1 N- ti M M c m C Y a o d 6 6 N n Q Q Q a d a a g q Q Q a off. a a a a n�. a a a 1 E O O O C O O O O O b 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 D 0 es 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 `'• > 99 N rl N m V' H �D n W l91 6 N N ra N M ul tD ^ N A O ei �y ei •i f" '� Q T c a� o o e o M Z� 0 o h a ' IR L n mzp NM NN O t0 lD ZF N m N .-I O� u1 O ei N '1 rl .Od N O W b N N N N N N n m M Ni ?0. ~ N ~ O t0 N M + If in m N 0 0 0 m m v en N � � Ln L Q r� a 00 �o Y t0 ~ v% N N 00 N N N N T M f0 -010 7 � L � H v m v u c Z o O w � E ULn Ln tD ko w � z`nin 0 Ln o a w a O c E u Ln Ln N rl M 00 00 -4 N M tp d' M V' go NM Y t0 Ln n 1 C) �0 V M to O 00 O^ OV to N �C nC4