HomeMy WebLinkAboutECONorthwest - Ellensburg Sleep Center Feasbility Analysis ReportEllensburg
Sleep Center
Feasibility Analysis Report
March 2024
Insert image/graphic
on top of this box.
Leave green border.
Background & Context
Existing Cold Weather Shelter
Operated by the KVMA
Boise v. Martin
Shelter beds required to enforce camping ordinances in both city and county
Regulatory Context for Emergency Shelters in Ellensburg
City Land Development Code updated February 5, 2024 to comply with HB 1220
Analysis Components
OPERATION
Desired framework for
Sleep Center
operation
Shelter
operations in WA
Year -round
overnight shelter
components
COST ANALYSIS
Detailed assumptions
and considerations for
cost analysis
Site prep costs
Building costs
Ongoing
operating costs
Expansion costs
SITE ANALYSIS
Identifying and
evaluating sites
Site Criteria
Site Search
Site Selection
Site Analysis
Pathways property –area behind the
former Nites Inn Motel
Recommended Site
CoStar & Vacant Lands Analysis
Methods for Site Search
Zoning, Site Size, Adjacent Uses,
Accessibility, Lease vs Own
Site Search Criteria
Image here
Add pic of new site
Source: Ellensburg Daily Record
Insert image/graphic
on top of this box.
Leave green border.
Operating Framework
•Year -round operation open 6PM
to 8AM
•Up to 25 individual use shelters
with heating and cooling
•Staff office, bathroom and
shower units, community areas
•Ideally would provide meals,
storage, onsite social services,
and other amenities
•Laundry, pet area, WiFi , landscaping Photo Credit: Pallet Shelter
Shelter Type Choices
Sheds, Moses Lake Sleep Center
Pallet Shelters, Seattle
Pallet Shelter Locations
Locations
Arkansas
California
Colorado
Delaware
Hawaii
Massachusetts
Montana
North Carolina
Oregon
South Carolina
Texas
Washington
Wisconsin
Pallet Shelters
Pallet Shelter, Burlington, VT
Source: Pallet Shelter
Interior of Pallet Shelter Unit
Source: Pallet Shelter
Insert image/graphic
on top of this box.
Leave green border.
Pallet Shelters in Washington
•Everett
•Tacoma
•Burlington
•Walla Walla
•Tulalip
•+ more!
Skagit First Step, Burlington, WA
Cost Analysis Overview
•Excavations
•Sewer, electric, and
water connections
•Landscaping,
lighting, and fencing
Site
Preparation
•Shelters
•Bathroom and
shower units
•Staff offices,
community room and
other amenities
Building
Infrastructure
•Staffing and security
•Program expenses,
including utilities and
leases
•Maintenance costs
Operating
Costs
•Adding two new
shelters per year for
a total of 43 shelters
after 10 years
Expansion
Costs
Site Preparation Costs
Considerations:
•Infrastructure and utility
improvement costs estimated
by City Public Works staff
•Improvements include adding
water, sewer, electrical, and
hardscaping to the sight
•Soft costs (sales tax, cost
contingency, and escalations)
come to ~$72,000
Total:
•~ $394,000
$31,000
$161,900
$99,100
$30,100
$24,500
$47,500
$0
$50,000
$100,000
$150,000
$200,000
$250,000
$300,000
$350,000
$400,000
$450,000
Contingency
Tax
Fencing and lighting
Water, sewer and
electric
Roads and paving
Site prep for work
$324,800
$145,000 $145,000
$20,000
$135,000
$99,500
$45,000
$43,000
$16,000
$43,000
$119,300
$142,300
$142,300
$13,500
$13,500
$13,500
$-
$100,000
$200,000
$300,000
$400,000
$500,000
$600,000
$700,000
Pallet Cost Non-Pallet Cost (Own)Non-Pallet Cost (Lease)
Shelters Bedding
Bathrooms and Showers Community Room
Staff Offices Storage Shed
Prep for Units Wishlist Items (excluding heat/ AC)
Building Costs
Considerations:
•Shelter costs make up the majority of the cost difference between scenarios
•City could potentially “mix and match” building components
•Pallet shelters advantages : set -up, warranty, safety, replacement options and mobility.
Totals:
•Pallet: $675,900
•Non-Pallet (own): $492,400
•Non-Pallet (lease): $306,900
Operating Costs per Year
Considerations:
•Tuff sheds likely to have much
greater maintenance and
upkeep costs
•While leasing infrastructure
requires no upfront cost, doing so
results in high annual costs
•Because the City is providing site
infrastructure improvements,
there are no leasing costs
Totals:
•Site A: $326,000
•Site B: $409,000
Totals:
•Pallet: $377,800
•Non-Pallet (own): $401,000
•Non-Pallet (lease): $452,300
$51,300
$260,000 $260,000
$260,000
$36,300 $36,300
$36,300$33,600 $33,600
$33,600
$23,200
$23,200
$47,900
$47,900
$47,900
$0
$50,000
$100,000
$150,000
$200,000
$250,000
$300,000
$350,000
$400,000
$450,000
$500,000
Pallet Non-Pallet (own)Non-Pallet (lease)
Trailer leases Staffing and security Program expenses
Utilities Maintenance Meals
$659,000
$285,000
$-
$100,000
$200,000
$300,000
$400,000
$500,000
$600,000
$700,000
Pallet Shelters Tuff Sheds
Ten Year Expansion Costs
Total costs for expanding
from 25 to 43 shelters over
ten years (two new shelters
per year).
•Does not consider maintenance
or upkeep costs
•Tuff sheds present major
maintenance and longevity
concerns
Q&A
Thank you!