Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAbout2024-01-08-minutes-public-works-study-sessionKITTITAS COUNTY COMMISSIONERS Public Works Study Session Regular Meeting Monday January 8, 2024 - 1:30 PM BoCC Auditorium 205 West Sth Room 109 - Ellensburg 1. Call to Order 2. Citizen Comments (1 min. time limit) 3. Bowers Field Land Lease Discussion 4. Dunford Barn 5. Lick Creek Private Bridges 6. Executive Session: RCW 42.30.110 (1)(b) To consider the selection of a site or the acquisition of real estate by lease or purchase when public knowledge regarding such consideration would cause a likelihood of increased price. 7. Other Business - No Action to be taken 8. Concluded Created on 1/4/2024 11:24:43 AM KITTITAS COUNTY PUBLIC WORKS STUDY SESSION MINUTES COMMISSIONERS' AUDITORIUM, 205 WEST 5TH ROOM 109 Regular Meeting MONDAY 1:30 PM JANUARY 8, 2024 Board members present: Chairman Brett Wachsmith, Vice Chairman Laura Osiadacz, and Commissioner Cory Wright. Others: Mark Cook, Josh Fredrickson, Rebecca Cruse, Public Works; Jamey Ayling, Jessica Miller, Community Development Services; 1 member of the public. At 1:35 PM Chairman Brett Wachsmith opened the Public Works Study Session. No Citizen Comments. At 1:36PM the Board of County Commissioners announced they would recess into Executive Session for 10 minutes with Mark Cook, and Bill Clarke per RCW 42.30.110 (1)(b) To consider the selection of a site or the acquisition of real estate by lease or purchase when public knowledge regarding such consideration would cause a likelihood of increased price. At 1:46PM the Board of County Commissioners reconvened out of Executive Session with direction to staff to continue negotiations. BOWERS FIELD LAND LEASE DISCUSSION Josh Fredrickson briefed the Board of County Commissioners on Bowers Field binding site plan and the location of several lots at the airport that a party requested to lease. Josh Fredrickson stated the lots did not have established access to the taxiway, an estimated cost for design and construction of the access, and funding options were discussed for the project..The Board directed staff to inquire about ARPA funds or CARB Loan. Airport leases were discussed, and Josh Fredrickson stated a 30-year lease with two 10-year extensions was acceptable to the Federal Aviation Administration. Staff was directed to draft a reversion clause along with the lease. Discussion was had about a reversion clause and assessing the useful life of the buildings when conducting lease agreements. DUNFORD BARN Mark Cook briefed the Board of County Commissioners on the drafted deed received for Dunford Barn. Developers are preparing to begin construction and the residential community will need secondary access. Mark Cook requested the Boards approval for staff to continue design and construct the entrance. 2024-01-08 MINUTES LICK CREEK PRIVATE BRIDGES Mark Cook briefed the Board of County Commissioners on established plans for Lick Creek. Public Works was previously tasked with design of abutments, permitting, and construction of prefabricated private bridge for a joint -use driveway. The private property owners haven't purchased the bridge and continue discussion on cost associated. Staff was directed to pause on further permitting until the property owners are participating to move forward on this project and they purchase the bridge kit. Meeting concluded at 2:23 PM r a6 " Rebecca Cruse, Administrative Assistant 2024-01-08 MINUTES KITTITAS COUNTY COMMISSIONER KITTITAS COUNTY, WASHINGTON Brett Wachsmith, Chairman KITTITAS COUNTY DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC WORKS PUBLIC WORKS — BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS STUDY SESSION STAFF REPORT STUDY SESSION DATE: January 8, 2024 TOPIC: Bowers Field Land Lease ACTION REQUESTED: Direct staff. LEAD STAFF: Joshua Fredrickson RECOMMENDATION: Direct staff regarding lease of lots within the aeronautical area which do not have taxiway access, and the lease term template. BRIEFING SUMMARY: • Bowers Field Airport Binding Site Plan 2"d Amendment recorded January 19, 2023, identifies four lots available for future development which do not have current access to the taxiway. Land leases for development continues to be a source of revenue for Bowers Field Lease template has been developed to include 30-year term with two 10-year extension options BACKGROUND: Bowers Field Airport Biding Site Plan 2"d Amendment (BS-21 -0000 1) identifies lots within the aeronautical area of Bowers Field and the industrial park area that are available for lease. This includes four lots which do not have current access to the taxiway. Public Works met with representatives from the Federal Aviation Administration (FAA) regarding Bowers Field. FAA expressed concern over ground leases which extend beyond a 50-years term. Ground leases within the Aeronautical Area at Bowers Field are subject to FAA requirements, or grant assurances. Assurance 38 is specific to hangar construction. The FAA Order 5190.6B, Airport Compliance Manual states that leases exceeding 50 years raise issues with grant assurances and may be considered disposal of the property in that the term of the lease will likely exceed the useful life of the structures on the property. DISCUSSION: Lot establishment within the aeronautical area have been established by the recording of the binding site plan (BS-21-00001). This binding site plan identifies four lots, H-44, H- 45, H-46 and H-47 (Exhibit 1) which are to be accessed by a future extension of the existing taxiway. This access has not yet been constructed. Inquiries to Public Works have been made regarding leasing these parcels. The interest in these parcels is due to the fact that water and sewer utilities are more readily available than other lots. Without the extension of the existing taxiway, they are unable to access the runway. The current lease language does not include extension of the existing taxiway. To provide access to these lots, P W may seek to include the extension on the next capital plan to the FAA. It is anticipated that funding will not be available until after 2027. One option might be to allow the lessee to construct the extension and receive tenant improvement credit towards the land lease. Another would be to construct the improvements and add the cost to the lease. Lastly, Public Works could construct the improvements and seek cost recovery from the general fund. Previously PW met with the FAA which included a discussion of their concern about the lease term length. Follow up contact with the FAA has been completed. FAA supports a lease template using a 30-year term with two 10-year extension options. The FAA sees this as acceptable and would not create future concerns regarding the longer lease terms with the FAA. The Airport Advisory Committee considered limiting lease terms to 30 years with an option for two 10-year extensions. The AAC supported action to formalize lease duration within the aeronautical area at their November 8, 2023, meeting and recommended this for consideration by the Board of County Commissioners. Section 2 of the current lease template states the duration of the lease, the text indicating the 30-year term with two extensions is provided in Exhibit 2. FISCAL IMPACT: Undetermined at this time. ATTACHMENTS: Exhibit 1: Binding Site Plan Exhibit 2: Lease Template Exhibit l: Binding Site Plan m al/IB/N3] 08 J1.39 pl Y: Os Y: 9R 103 XI s90003 fw u, 1 F F XO , c mou x .mO,c _ a daa 9aa' - 'Im- �Mg$p}�¢B#$ g�Y'm OggZ _H ne So °m U v493III fll ;1�� £'@ z rcc„ c 11 ttcu !3 - x- yI§ f$ R $11% $ �v � m m a M.ocn wx � /� Oa'Oumts�ns mz ccma, Jcbc�mc5czv i . �' xR$ 9 p rr �an eew $.C3 Mnc.G+.,OX dg�$yggeRg"-9i cfm c4'a, IU my ° j W481 OJ'WL I pPp C {d ¢� YZ x';i � OGren gIW moGL Het M.n<.,4X � J ��ws •.� �� $� ��K- 0 >so g' � ����§9�$k4s€fin ���� �yE 8 x 1 Er s s net i iqjgig § i•o S �'� $� Mn 3K4.'S_ $$m� a AR M M,«tr.wu__ ➢_ _ II _ _ G_ 4 & i°�S ��� a $ � �./ 9 a°a Pvs a a3N ml° BBZS J WSrc nlL'� I O'm 0s.fi/ M Vl gn m $^ g,$ $➢s Rtg -q tH gm xn , q n a �7m ci �g BBB$€ n O q @ p g ggl !A �'.pjY +Sy 9 $$,3�R$ .i` $ " A? DN°m '€�z r,. $ �. � $ , � t� ` NA 1 RR� :�fa� � $$& g�a�� 9C�gQ�$ K� m•-I ANSI $"- q x 01Rill ImIl' d Lv d q j A l d Caa RR s 'M PIP �F s' M.nf<r'' ��n� '� P`y � I• � �� R R$ g � � � ..� Z N HI g2 / •Y RA gg � � � O��j�� 2 `� � B �R Of � \ n� I � �5�//!�• '� \islet °°xSamai� '^ �� g$ � 5��� � R� �R� z � $n 4 :seen :I n All 11111111115111141191 $ affR $"gS3 4 g $ tf R"Bil $' 3 ad a41 8 pp P.x g$- � w 19 y 1i N : $ -65 is q Aa H ; 'uszos nOi A R w �O4yr ,e-in=iomozo "oo°z \ io s§rz `If. zq9• gi o Exhibit 2: Lease Template Text 2. TERM: Term. 2.1 Effective Date and Initial Term. The Lease shall be effective as of the Lease Date. The term of this Lease shall be for a period of thirty (30) years commencing on the Lease Date as provided in Exhibit C, if attached, and ending on (Date), such period being the "Initial Term" or "Term" and including any extensions as provided in Section 2.2. A "Lease Year" means the twelve calendar months commencing with the month of the Lease Date or Commencement Date, as the case maybe, each year of the Term. 2.2 Options to Extend. Prior to exercising Lessee option to extend this lease, the Lessee shall provide the Lessor with structural assessment of all improvements stipulating the expected useful life remaining in the asset. Providing sufficient useful life remains in the asset, the Lessee shall have the option to extend this Lease for Two (2) additional period(s) of Ten (10) years each if Lessee is not then in default of this Lease and delivers a written notice of the exercise of the then current option to extend to Lessor at least ninety (90) days prior to the expiration of the Initial Term or prior option period, as the case maybe. 2.3 Expiration Date. The date on which this Lease expires under the terms of Sections 2.1 or 2.2 shall be the "Expiration Date." KITTITAS COUNTY DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC WORKS PUBLIC WORKS — BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS 2024 STUDY SESSION STAFF REPORT STUDY SESSION DATE: January 8, 2024 TOPIC: Dunford Barn ACTION REQUESTED: Direct Staff LEAD STAFF: Mark R. Cook RECOMMENDATION: Direct staff prepare enabling documents BRIEFING SUMMARY: • The Board of County Commissioners agreed to have staff work with the Dunford Barn owner to prepare ownership transfer documents. • The owner's representative has delivered a draft deed that requires the county to construct access improvements. • The Engineering Division of Public Works has prepared preliminary improvement plans supporting the new access to the barn. BACKGROUND: Previously, discussions around ownership transfer have not included the mandatory requirement that the County construct access improvements. The proposed deed requires the county to construct access improvements to the Dunford Barn. The improvements are scheduled for construction in 2026 and appear in the recently adopted Kittitas County Capital Improvement Plan (CIP) — "Six -year parks and tourism capital plan" (EXHIBIT 1). DISCUSSION: The deed reservation does not have a timeline associated with it. Public Works designed the access to benefit the plat as a secondary access (EXHIBIT 2). Our thinking is that we would complement the developer's timeline constructing the access ahead of the full roadway and parking lot. This could be done with county forces in 2024. There is no problem with the deed as restricted so long as the county follows through with the full tourism improvements as designed and programmed in the CIP. FISCAL IMPACTS: $660,000 in design, permitting and construction is programmed in the 2024 — 2029 Six -year CIP — Recreation/Tourism. The final design is slated for 2024, permitting in 2025 with construction in 2026. ATTACHMENTS: EXHIBIT 1: RECREATION/TOURISM CIP (2024 — 2029) EXHIBIT 2: DEED Page 1 of 3 Public Works "Work Session Staff Report", 2024 EXHIBIT 1: RECREATION/TOURISM CIP (2024 — 2029) Page 2 of 3 Public Works "Work Session Staff Report", 2024 KITTITAS COUNTY 2020.2029 SIX YEAR PARKS AND TOURISM CAPITAL PLAN p g - 8 CAPITAL IMPROVEMENT PROJECT NAME 3 Dunfpa Interpretive Qnhr Design _ . ROMReplawmeM 50m Q Permittng fnnmu¢i.n LOp•Opp 2pp ppp 2 Ellensburg Field House (Formally RotaN lnaoar Sooner) Male One ]sppoD ]sO,aW ]sppoD ]sO,000 3 manaaman ttalnem verxme Deng" - _ - _ Bo,000 Wnelr..n 340 0 Glaamer Park Aueri Im ror_iN _ _ y5p — Pre, Oewlppment Plan _ 150,OW 100000 PNw Ow:Traib 250,OW 5 VanhBe RiverWalk drelopment an $OOW 2W ti Pumm g Phase One: Conurutlon 6 Unner COunN Reaeatlon Center q Band Serviw J50000 _ ]SOOpO ]SOpW 750. S 050,M J6p,OW 415000p 2CO,OOo 1,fi50,Wp 100,000 1,JSp,ODD lOp,OW 1,]SO0010 200,000 9,110,000 SUMMARY: 5 YEAR PROGRAM REVENUE COSTS AND ENDING FUND AMOUNTS BEGINNING FUND BALANCE -6,000 S.,.. 337,111l 562,951 ;M]jW 1,BW,MS LABOR 274,150 288,592 303,02E 318,1J3 33G,OR2 35p,]86 ANNUAL CAPITAL IMPROVEMENT TOTALS(-) OPFRATNG COSR ISO.pJO ]6pp00 _ _4350.OW _ 1.7SO.pCO _ 1•850p00 1195ppOp 1BA'sol 115,437 121,209 127,269 ]33,633 140,314 TOTAL ANNUAL COSTS 834,790 1,164,OM ]JA,231 3,195 ;317,7IA 2,441p0 EE TA%REVENUF IR1 III i,pppppp 2,OW,000 2,Wp,Opp ],000,000 2,000,O W )i TAX REVENUE( mx%m SOD,WO SOO WO Wolm OTNFR INCOMF(LOOGINGTA%I SOD,OW ASp,OpO 3pppJO 300,OW 3D0,000 3op,ppp GRAM/COSTSNAflE _ 2000W 1W,OW IOnlm 2W,000 TOTAL ANNUAL INCOME SWpW 1p50,W0 3000pW I 2,9m,OW 2,900.pW 3,OW,Wp ENDING FUND BALANCE 51,2101 337,281 1 S6 m 1 1.2.7.509 1 1.R49]95 1>anP ov[ EXHIBIT 2: DEED Page 3 of 3 Public Works "Work Session Staff Report", 2024 When recorded return to: Matthew A. Cohen Case Lombardi & Pettit 737 Bishop Street, Suite 2600 Honolulu, HI 96813 QUITCLAIM DEED WITH RESERVATIONS AND ACKNOWLEDGMENTS Abbreviated Legal: Ptn. NW'/<Sec. 3, T19N, R17E, and Ptn. SW'/<Sec. 27 and W'/ Sec. 34, T20N, R17E, all in W.M. Kittitas County Parcel Nos.: Ptn. 961865 and 961866 This QUITCLAIM DEED WITH RESERVATIONS AND ACKNOWLEDGMENTS is dated THE RANCH ON SWAUK CREEK LLC, a Washington limited liability company, GRANTOR, for and in consideration of Ten And No/100 Dollars ($10.00), and other valuable consideration in hand paid, conveys and quit claims to KITTITAS COUNTY, a Washington municipal corporation, GRANTEE, and said grantee does accept and assume, the following real estate described below (the 'Property"), situate in the County of Kittitas, State of Washington, together with all after -acquired title of the grantor herein: Parcel 2A per that certain Record of Survey filed in Book 45 of Surveys, Page 168- 169 under Auditors File No. 202306230005, Records of Kittitas County, Washington, being 15.70 acres, more or less. Kittitas County Tax Parcel No.: Map Number: SUBJECT, HOWEVER, to the following: Portions of 961865 and 961866 20-17-34050-0006, 20-17-34050-0007 EXCEPTING AND RESERVING UNTO GRANTOR all water rights and reservations of every type and description; GRANTEE DOES ACKNOWLEDGE AND CONFIRM that the Property has no access to a public road, and Grantee accepts and assumes full responsibility, obligation, and cost to create said access; FURTHER EXCEPTING AND RESERVING UNTO GRANTOR, the following: Page 1 of 5 24297/1813966599.3 (i) a right of access over and across any roadway that may exist or be constructed within the Property, such right of access being for the benefit of Parcel 1A per that certain Record of Survey filed in Book 45 of Surveys, Page 168-169 under Auditors File No. 202306230005, Records of Kittitas County, Washington ("Grantor's adjacent parcel"); and which such right of access may be assigned or granted by Grantor to others without the consent or joinder of Grantee or any other person or party; and (ii) provided that no gravel, paved, or otherwise improved roadway exists within the Property, a right to construct a gravel, paved, or otherwise improved roadway within the Property and generally in the area marked as "Proposed Roadway Layout" on the map attached hereto as Exhibit 1, as may be necessary or convenient to support the development and improvement of Grantor's adjacent parcel, subject to such regular and typical planning and permitting approvals as may be required by law by Grantee and which such approvals shall not be unreasonably withheld except as permitted by law, and further subject to reimbursement by Grantee to Grantor of Grantor's reasonable cost to construct portions of such roadway within the Property that benefit Grantee; and ALL ITEMS OF RECORD. This instrument may be executed in counterparts. [The remainder of this page is blank. Signatures are provided on the following page.] Page 2 of 5 24297/18/3966599.3 IN WITNESS WHEREOF, Grantor and Grantee have executed this instrument to be effective as of the date stated above. THE RANCH ON SWAUK CREEK, a Washington limited liability company By: Michael Jones Authorized Signatory KITTITAS COUNTY, a Washington Municipal Corporation Cory Wright, Chairman - Kittitas County Board of Commissioners GRANTEE Page 3 of 5 24297/18/3966599.3 State of Washington County of I certify that I know or have satisfactory evidence that MICHAEL JONES is the person who appeared before me, and said person acknowledged that he signed this instrument, on oath stated that he was authorized to execute the instrument and acknowledged it to be the free and voluntary act of such party for the uses and purposes mentioned in the instrument. Dated: Name: Notary Public in and for the State of Residing at: My appointment expires: Document Identification or description: Quitclaim Deed, covering portions of Kittitas County Tax Parcel No.961865 and 961866 Document dated or ❑ Undated at time of notarization. No. of pages at time of notarization: (Official Stamp or seal) Page 4 of 5 24297/18/3966599.3 State of Washington County of I certify that I know or have satisfactory evidence that CORY WRIGHT is the person who appeared before me, and said person acknowledged that he signed this instrument, on oath stated that he was authorized to execute the instrument and acknowledged it to be the free and voluntary act of such party for the uses and purposes mentioned in the instrument. Dated Name: Notary Public in and for the State Residing at: My appointment expires: Document Identification or description: Quitclaim Deed, covering portions of Kittitas County Tax Parcel No.961865 and 961866 Document dated or ❑ Undated at time of notarization. No. of pages at time of notarization: (Official Stamp or seal) Page 5 of 5 24297/18/3966599.3 KITTITAS COUNTY DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC WORKS PUBLIC WORKS — BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS 2024 STUDY SESSION STAFF REPORT STUDY SESSION DATE: January 8, 2024 TOPIC: Lick Creek Private Bridges ACTION REQUESTED: Direct Staff LEAD STAFF: Mark R. Cook RECOMMENDATION: Direct staff cease permitting efforts. BRIEFING SUMMARY: • Public Works (PW) continues to expend resources towards permitting two private bridges at Lick Creek. • One of the private private owners is refusing to fully fund acquisition of one of the private bridges. • Title research has verified replacement of one of the bridges requires authorization of both owners. • Public Works has insisted on a "Hold Harmless and Indemnification" release for using county provided abutment designs and permits. BACKGROUND: During construction of the Lick Creek Bridge project, two neighboring property owners threatened to sue the county for perceived increased flood risk. Proposing a resolution to the conflict, the Board of County Commissioners directed PW work with the property owners to develop a solution. The property owners agreed to pay for two private bridges and PW agreed to design bridge abutments and obtain project permits. The abutment designs are complete and permitting efforts are ongoing. DISCUSSION: PW continues paying for project permitting while one of the property owners has stated that he will not pay the full cost of the bridge acquisition. He has also stated that he will not sign any release of liability allowing the neighbor to use their shared driveway supporting one of the bridge locations. It appears that we are at a standstill. Our options appear to be to continue spending money on permits that we may not be able to use or suspend permitting efforts. There are no adverse impacts, thus far, resulting from the project. The risk associated with contentious land cover loss from fires (five years ago) is reducing with time as we get farther from the fire event. The forest is revegetating. Page 1 of 6 Public Works "Work Session Staff Report", 2024 The project was permitted using fish barrier removal legislation with full support from the Washington State Department of Fish and Wildlife. PW staff believes the legislation provides significant risk reduction associated with the project. Initially the Prosecuting Attorney's Office expressed disagreement with PW staff over protections in the statue but appear to now view the protections in a more favorable light. PW has continued to follow the direction of the Board of County Commissioners in good faith, believing the private property owners would meet their commitment in bridge acquisition. The pandemic had adverse impacts on the cost of domestic steel and prices are elevated from 2021. PW has spent $48,737.61 to date including county labor, design and permitting costs. We estimate another $10,000 is permitting expense to complete the effort. PW is requesting reconsideration on completing the permitting effort given the intransigence of the one property owner. Providing we complete the permitting effort; it is likely that the project will not see construction. Even if we complete project permitting, there is no guarantee that the property owners will not sue the county. The property owners have to overcome the legal protections afforded us in Revised Code of Washington 77.55.181. They must also show harm that the county created beyond the damage and property risk that existed before the barrier removal project. Given the snag of bridge procurement, the likelihood of not being able to use the permits once obtained for the project, PW is requesting to hold permitting efforts until and unless bridge procurement is affirmed by both property owners. FISCAL IMPACTS: The Road Fund has spent $48,737.61 to date on the project. ATTACHMENTS: EXHIBIT 1: ELECTRONIC MAIL FROM ROONEY DATED 4/21/23 EXHIBIT 2: TITLE INSURANCE LISTING THE SHARED EASEMENT EXHIBIT 3: RCW 77.55.181 EXHIBIT 4: COUNTY SPONSORSHIP LETTER Page 2 of 6 Public Works "Work Session Staff Report", 2024 EXHIBIT 1: ELECTRONIC MAIL FROM ROONEY DATED 4/21 /23 Page 3 of 6 Public Works "Work Session Staff Report", 2024 Candie Leader From: Tracy Rooney <tracyr@msn.com> Sent: Thursday, April 13, 2023 9:39 AM To: Laura Osiadacz, Cory Wright; Brett Wachsmith Cc: Mark Cook; Josh Fredrickson; Tracy Rooney; Julie Rooney; Eric Barlow Subject: Lick Creek (was Fw: Rooney Comments on PW Study Session draft (was Fw: June 28) Attachments: 2021_SS_Lick Creek private bridges_06172021.doc CAUTION: This email originated from outside the Kittitas County network. Do not click links, open attachments, fulfill requests, or follow guidance unless you recognize the sender and have verified the content is safe. Hello County Commissioners, I'm writing in regard to the Lick Creek project. I had a teleconference with Mr. Cook yesterday. This project got underway more than two years ago and understandably costs have increased considerably. I agreed with Mr. Cook that I would increase my spend to 57k from my original agreed upon 40k. As of last week, he informed me that I need to spend an additional 14K+ taxes to purchase an "optional" abutment package. Paying for the abutment was not part of the discussion two years ago. I addressed this in the e-mail below which he may or may not have shared with you. With good faith in the process, I'm looking for a way forward. Below is the e-mail I sent nearly two years ago. It clearly stated my willingness to spend 40K on the project and the rationale behind that spend. I've been under the impression for the last two years that you authorized this proposal as PW proceeded to dig test pits, engaged a design firm, etc. Unfortunately the county delayed the project and costs increased. I understand Mr. Cook's desire to use a "SuperSill" as part of the abutment design. Basically, it's a prefabricated steel form which is filled with cement and becomes part of the abutment itself but is not required as part of the bridge itself. I confirmed with the TruNorth bridge sales representative that while it speeds installation time, there are other common abutment designs used for these bridges. I've attached a link to the optional SuperSill abutment package brochure as well as the separate brochure that details bridge specifics. I cannot justify this additional 14k+ expense above and beyond the increased amount for the bridge itself just to save the county money on the agreed installation process. I'm hoping that you'll consider my concerns and authorize Mr. Cook to work within the parameters of the $57K I agreed to spend. I'm looking forward to hearing from you. Regards, Tracy Rooney 13610 Teanaway Rd, NFK Cie Elum, WA 98922 SuperSill: Abutments for Modular Vehicular & Pedestrian Bridges SuperSill Spread 8-2022.pdf (truenorthsteel.com) Modular Vehicular Bridges Modular -Vehicular -Bridge -Brochure 8-31-22 compressed pdf (true northsteel com) From: Tracy Rooney <tracyr@msn.com> Sent: Friday, April 7, 2023 9:11 AM To: Mark Cook <mark.cook@co.kittitas.wa.us> Cc: Josh Fredrickson <josh.fredrickson@co.kittitas.wa.us>; Candie Leader <candie.leader@ co. kittitas.wa.us>; Tracy Rooney <tracyr@msn.com> Subject: Fw: Rooney Comments on PW Study Session draft (was Fw: June 28) Hi Mark, I'm not sure if you are meeting the commissioners this afternoon or during Monday's study session. Here's the e-mail I sent about 2 years ago explaining Rooney's participation in regard to replacing the private crossings. It clearly states that I'm willing to spend a max of 40k on the project for the purchase of a bridge and my rationale for doing so. This e-mail was sent prior to your study session with the commissioners. It appears that my comments might not have been reflected in the final study session notes. Obviously, the project got delayed, prices changed, etc. but I'm still wanting to get things moved forward. I'm willing to bump my expenditure to the $51,950 that I was quoted last week for the bridge from TruNorth. This does not include the estimated $14k of a supersill package that goes with the bridge abutment. They still need specs to firm up the pricing for this component. I look forward to discussing the way forward next Wednesday. Regards, Tracy Rooney From: Tracy Rooney <tracyr@msn.com> Sent: Friday, June 25, 20218:43 AM To: Laura Osiadacz <laura.osiadacz@co.kittitas.wa.us>; cory.wright@co.kittitas.wa.us <cory.wright@co.kittitas.wa.us>; Brett Wachsmith <brett.wachsmith.co@co.kittitas.wa.us> Cc: Mark Cook <mark.cook@co.kittitas.wa.us>; Julie Rooney <julierooney@msn.com>; Eric Barlow <barlow.eric@gmail.com> Subject: Rooney Comments on PW Study Session draft (was Fw: June 28) Hello Commissioners, I received the attached Study Session draft that is being prepared for a meeting on Lick Creek from Eric Barlow. It seems timelier to 'comment on the draft than wait for a final copy to be posted. The Rooney's are seeking partial mitigation for the issues that county action is creating. Nothing more. The county project is putting in place grading that blocks today's high-water flow and a bridge structure to reroute existing floodwater conditions from the west side of the road to flow on the east side of the road. Evidence in the way of photos and county provided hydrology charts indicate clearly that county action to reroute these high flow events will overwhelm existing downstream infrastructure and limit access to and from the properties during high water events as well as create habitat degradation. The Barlow shop/barn will certainly take on water. WDFW's role in issuing the permit and the county's responsibility as project sponsor appear to be willfully misunderstood. Per WDFW correspondence with Mr. Rooney and which the commissioners were copied on 4-21-2020, "WDFW may only approve, deny, or provision Hydraulic Project Approvals with respect to no net loss offish life and fish habitat. We cannot take project impacts to residents, potential effects of flooding to infrastructure, or other non fish related concerns into consideration when issuing HPAs." It further states, "To answer your question on qualifications of hydraulic projects under Fish Habitat Enhancement Project criteria: the process requires that a project sponsor certify that a proposed project meets the FHEP criteria outlined under WAC— in other words, the onus is on the project sponsor and applicant to demonstrate that the project qualifies for FHEP and will not result in adverse impacts to public safety, infrastructure risk, etc." The Rooney's are concerned that their parcels will not be accessible on a recurring basis and not just during a hundred - year event. This is clearly a public safety risk that the county is creating and should be willing to mitigate. The Rooney's are not willing to participate in remedying this condition on their shared driveway with the Barlow property as they participated with WDFW (Specified size of culvert and assisted with permits), the KCCD (Cost share and engineering assistance) and others at great expense to combine two water crossings into one and eliminate any fish barriers that existed. This project was completed in 2012 and used as an example of private property owners not only willing to partner with agencies on habitat improvement but finding the opportunity to do so. Mr. Barlow is willing to fund replacement of this culvert with a bridge at his expense and the Rooney's will allow removal of his jointly owned culvert if driveway grading concerns are addressed as discussed with Mr. Cook and the County's engineering firm in January. The Rooney's are willing to participate to a maximum amount of forty thousand dollars with the county in replacing its northern most parcel's culvert with a bridge. (This pads the quote received when I priced out a bridge when this share arrangement was first undertaken by 18.75%.) The rationale behind this is fourfold. 1. It is desired to reduce project created backwater pressure and ice flow impacts on the neighbor's (Stuart Parcel 377635) adjoining parcel. 2. The county project will cause streamflow to "fire hose" through the existing culvert and create a fish blocking situation. Replacing this culvert with a bridge will prevent that and protect the millions of dollars in upstream habitat enhancements that have taken place in the last few years. 3. It is acknowledged that the existing culverts typical life span is 50 years and replacing this culvert basically moves this project forward by 20 years helps to justify the Rooney's monetary investment today. 4. The Rooney's want this dealt with prior to it becoming a hazard. A few additional discussion points brought up in the document: • The Flood Control Zone District Advisory Committee recently declined to provide the requested assistance. - As a member of the original Flood Control committee, I understand this decision. The need for driveway culvert replacements were identified early in the planning process and should have been budgeted as part of the project up front and not be dependent on the Flood Control budget for a PW created problem. It was not. Having reviewed meeting notes and discussion from the last few FC meetings, it is apparent that some members are looking for direction in how to rank "private property" projects in relationship to ranking public benefit. Allowing a county project to NOT create the only fish blocking barrier destroying the benefit of more than two million dollars in taxpayer funded habitat improvements seems to be of great public benefit. Obviously, an odd position to be in. • Staff and the property owners do not agree on the potential for probable adverse impacts resulting from the pending bridge improvement project on Lick Creek—Teanaway Road. - Photography from a previous high-water event clearly indicate that water from both sides of the road being moved to the East side only will not clear the existing culverts. The county provided hydrology reports with the qualification that culverts are free of obstruction. This seems unlikely given the much heralded "wood fiesta" upstream and the county's project specification that calls for more woody debris placement directly upstream from the existing culverts. It even appears that the hydrology reports excluded the 20% bottom coble fill that WDFW requires. Another new condition that the county project inflicts on the downstream owners is the increased risk of damage from ice flows. Currently, only ice that forms on the approximately 2,200 feet of Lick Creek's downward side of the North Fork Road effect downstream residents as the existing undersized county culverts do not pass what can be car sized blocks of ice. The forty -foot water crossing will pass ice flows from the entire length of the stream. They will certainly plug the Rooney's northern parcel culvert blocking access to their property as well as increasing the risk of severe water and ice damage to the Stuart's property. • No mitigation is required in the County's Hydraulic Permit Approval with the Washington State Department of Fish and Wildlife. This is a misleading statement. It is not a function of WDFW to do so as explained above by WDFW. The document states, "Recognizing that the canopy is rapidly re-establishing, PW used a canopy coverage of 52.7 percent in final design consistent with United States Geologic Survey Region 2 Regression Equations." This seems a stretch at best. While the upstream canopy is somewhat recovering from the 2005 Lick Creek fire, I see no on the ground validity in this statement on the Jolley fire. In fact, the canopy that is replacing the Lick Creek fire is quite different from its previously dense canopy and is made of more deciduous trees than what previously existed. It is my understanding that it takes years to recover canopy and to my knowledge there has been no effort to seed or otherwise replace this canopy. Additionally, the creek flow high water events pre -Jolley fire demonstrated that these culverts would not properly convey the water that currently flows on the West side of the road that is going to be re-routed to the East side going forward. So, the statement on canopy coverage re-establishing does not add to the discussion. • No mitigation is required from the Federal Highway Administration —the project funder.- Does the FHA even know that there are going to be adverse impacts? There were no correspondence items included in my prior public disclosure request that indicated these concerns were shared or part of any county discussion with the FHA. The document states: "PW anticipates that the Department's approval does not create absolute immunity from damages related to the bridge improvement project." Obviously, this is the crux of the issue. WDFW has made it abundantly clear that the county as the project sponsor is responsible for ensuring the project will not result in adverse impacts. The original project alternative grid made it known that from the first meeting with the agencies that downstream culvert replacements would be necessary if this creek alignment became the chosen alternative. It is well established that the county spent a lot of time and money to explore the idea of completely rerouting the creek eliminating the need for driveway culvert replacements yet this alternative exposed even greater risk and was abandoned. We are now almost three years into this and back to the original alternative that specified new driveway culverts. Between the Barlow's and the Rooney's, the county has the opportunity mitigate the county's culpability in causing the life -safety issues, infrastructure damage as well as destruction of habitat. I recommend the county take a forward - thinking and ultimately lower cost approach to the situation and fund what was originally specified by the county's engineering firm. Tracy & Julie Rooney 13610 Teanaway Rd, NFK Cie Elum, WA 98922 From: Eric Barlow <barlow.eric@gmail.com> Sent: Saturday, June 19, 20212:58 PM To: Tracy Rooney <tracyr@msn.com> Subject: Fwd: June 28 ---------- Forwarded message --------- From: Mark Cook <mark.cook@co.kittitas.wa.us> Date: Thu, Jun 17, 2021, 4:38 PM Subject: RE: June 28 To: Eric Barlow <barlow.eric@email.com> Cc: Candle Leader <candie.leader@co.kittitas.wa.us> Please track desired changes back for final. Regards, Cook. From: Eric Barlow <barlow.eric@email.com> Sent: Thursday, June 17, 2021 8:15 AM To: Mark Cook <mark.cook@co.kittitas.wa.us> Cc: Candle Leader <candie.leader@ co. kittitas.wa.us> Subject: Re: June 28 CAUTION: This email originated from outside the Kittitas County network. Do not click links, open attachments, fulfill requests, or follow guidance unless you recognize the sender and have verified the content is safe. Hi Mark Following up to see if you have a draft available. Thanks On Wed, Jun 2, 2021 at 1:18 PM Mark Cook <mark.cook@co.kittitas.wa.us> wrote: 1:30 PM Local time. It will likely be virtural. From: Eric Barlow <barlow.eric@gmail.com> Sent: Wednesday, June 2, 2021 11:51 AM To: Mark Cook <mark.cook@co.kittitas.wa.us> Cc: Candie Leader <candie.leader@ co. kittitas.wa.us> Subject: Re: June 28 CAUTION: This email originated from outside the Kittitas County network. Do not click links, open attachments, fulfill requests, or follow guidance unless you recognize the sender and have verified the content is safe. Sounds good. Will plan on that. Do you know what time the commissioners meeting is so I can book it on my calendar? Thanks On Wed, Jun 2, 2021 at 11:28 AM Mark Cook <mark.cook@co.kittitas.wa.us> wrote: It will have to be the 28th as I am gone on the 14th. I will still try and get a draft to you next week giving you additional time to prepare. Mark R. Cook, PE Public Works Director Direct line: 509-962-7692 Cellular: 509-859-6879 Electronic mail address: mark.cook@co.kittitas.wa.us The information transmitted by this email is intended oriy for the person or entity to which it is addre3ssed. This email may contain Confidential and/or privileged material. If you are not the wtonded reciple3t of this message, be aware that any nse, review, retransmission, distribution, or reproduction is strictly prohibited. If you received this in error. please contact the sender immediately and deiete. the material from all devices, message id: 38eb45918c6dcbdac24bb8779d044a94 EXHIBIT 2: TITLE INSURANCE LISTING THE SHARED EASEMENT Page 4 of 6 Public Works "Work Session Staff Report", 2024 EXHIBIT "A" LEGAL DESCRIPTION Order No.: 38254 Lot B of TEANAWAY MEADOWS NO. 2 SHORT PLAT 90-11 recorded October 24, 1990, in Book C of Short Plats at rage(s) 75 and 76, underAuditofs Fie No. 534442, Being a portion of the North half of Section 31, Township 21 North, Range 16 East, records of Kiltitas County, State of Washington. Abbreviated Legal: Lot B. Teanawway Meadows No. 2 Short Plat Purported Address: 13620 Teanaway Road North Fork, Cie Eum, WA 98922 Cade, "d 382 Pape 2 Commilmem KC1 KiNiffi Title and Eeama issui,g apenl for Westco Land Tik Insurance Condom COMMITMENT FOR TITLE INSURANCE SCHEDULE B PART Schedule B of the policy or policies to be issued will contain exceptions to the following matters unless the same are disposed of to the satisfaction of the Company: GENERAL EXCEPTIONS; A. Taxes or assessments which are not shown as existing New by the public rewrds. E. (1) Unpatented mining claims; (fl) reservations or exceptions in patents or in Acts authorizing the issuance thereof, (iii) water rights, claims a title to water; whether or not the matters described (i), (41 & (Ni) are shown in the public records; (iv) Indian tribal codes or regulations, Indian treaty or aboriginal rights, including easements or equitable servitudes- C. Extended coverage exceptions as follows: (1) Rights or claims of parties in possession not shown by the public records. (2) Easements, claims of easement or encumbrances which are not shown by the public records. (3) Encroachments, overlaps, boundary line disputes, or other matters which would be disclosed by an accurate survey and inspection of the premises and which are not shown by the public records. (4) Any lien, or right to a lien, for services, labor or material heretofore or hereafter furnished imposed by law and not shown by the public records. D. Any service, installation, connection, maintenance, tap, capacity, construction or reimbursement charges for sewer, water, electricity a other utilities, or for garbage collection and disposal. E. Defects, liens, encumbrances, adverse claims or other matters, if any, created, first appearing in the public records or attaching subsequent to the effective date hereof but prior to the date the proposed insured acquires of record for value the estate or interest or mortgage thereon covered by this commitment. F. Any tides or rights asserted by anyone, including but not limited to persons, corporations, governments, a other entities., to tidelands, or lands composing the shores or bottoms of navigable rivers, lakes, bays, ocean or gut, or lands beyond the line of the harbor or bulkhead lines as established or changed by the United States Government, or riparian rights, if any. SPECIAL EXCEPTIONS FOLLOW OMer No. 38254 Page 3 Cwnmilment KC1 Ieli tas Rfie and Escrow isshung agent for Wislcor Lard na, insurance comaarry COMMITMENT FOR TITLE INSURANCE SCHEDULE B PART SPECIAL EXCEPTIONS 1. LIEN OF THE REAL ESTATE EXCISE SALES TAX and surcharge upon any sale of said premises, if unpaid. As of the date herein, the excise tax rate is 1,53% and an additional County Real Estate Excise Tax Affidavit processing fee of $5,00. 2. GENERAL TAXES. The first half becomes definquent after April 301h. The second half becomes delinquent after October 31 at. Yew: Amount billed: Amount paid: Amount due: Levy code: Land uswDOR code: Map number, Parcel number: Assessed value of land: Assessed value of improvement: 2016 $4,223.97 $2,111.99 $2,111,98, plus interest and penalty, if delinquent 44 11 21-16-31051-0002 660536 $127.150.00 $406,620.00 3. DEED OF TRUST AND THE TERMS AND CONDITIONS THEREOF: Grantor: Richard L. Low and Jonica G. Low, husband and wife Trustee: First American Tale Beneficiary: MERS acting as nominee for Bank of America, N.A. Amount: $496,625.00 Dated: November 10, 2015 Recorded: November 16, 2015 Recording No.: 201511160009 ASSIGNMENT OF BENEFICIAL INTEREST Assignee: Bank of America, N.A. Dated: May 11, 2016 Recorded: May 12, 2016 Recording No.: 201605120002 4, RESERVATIONMECLARATION OF EASEMENTS, Including terms and provisions contained therain Recorded: November 19, 1990 Recording no.: 535156 In favor of Leavitt Brothers Corporation For: Irrigation ditch easement and easement for access thereto Affects: Refer to said instrument for the exact location. We note that instruments recorded May 6, 1991 and November 8, 1991, under Auditor's File Numbers 539104 and 544572 purport to partially terminate said ReservationiDeclaration of Easements. Refer to the record of said instrument for full particu[ars. Order No. M&I Pegea Cornoolnenl XCi penis Title and Escrow issuing agent for Weslcor land Ttlle Insurance Company EASEMENT, including terms and provisions contained therein: Recorded: November2l, 1995 Recording no.: 587Z74 In favor of: The owners and/or contract purchasers of Lots A. B and C Tearaway Meadows No. 2 Short Plat and Lots 1, 2, 3 and 4 Teanaway Meadows No. 1 Short Plat For Ingress and Egress Affects: Refer to said Instrument for the exact location. Said easement contains a provision for sharing in the cost of maintenance, repair or reconstruction by the common users. Refer to the record of said instrument for full particulars. 6. EASEMENT, including terms and provisions contained therein: Recorded: Novemberl4, 1991 Recording no.: 544715 In favor of Public Utility District No, 1 For: Electric transmission or distribution line or system and all other stated purposes Affects: The legal description contained in said easement is not sufficient to determine its exec location. Refer to the record of said instrument for full particulars. 7. DRIVEWAY EASEMENTAND MAINTENANCE AGREEMENT AND THE TERMS AND CONDITIONS THEREOF: Recorded September 16, 2009 Recording no: 2009091600D4 8. EASEMENT FOR RIGHT OF WAY for ditch running from the Teanaway River through the Northwest Quarter of the Northeast Quarter and the Southwest Quarter of the Northeast Quarter of said Section, as disclosed by judgment entered May 24. 1918, in Civil Cause No. 5818, Gieseppe Glustedd, at al, vs. Frank Amosso, at al. 9. COVENANTS, CONDITIONS, RESTRICTIONS ANDIOR EASEMENTS; but deleting any covenant, condition or restriction indicating a preference, limitation or discrimination based on race, color, religion, sex, handicap, family status, or national origin to the extent such covenants, conditions or restrictions violate 42 USC 3604(c): Recorded: November 16, 1990 Recording no(s): 535106 10, RESTRICTIONS, CONDITIONS, DEDICATIONS, NOTES, EASEMENTS AND PROVISIONS contained and/or delineated on the face of the short plat recorded October 24, 1990, in Book C of Short Plats, pages) 75-76 under Kitties County Auditors file no. 534442, 11, A RECORD OF SURVEY and any and all matters relating thereto: Recorded: August 10, 1990 Recording no.: 532009 Book. 16 Page: 165 12. ANY QUESTION THAT MAY ARISE due to the shifting and/or changing in the course of Lick Creek 13. RIGHT OF THE STATE OF WASHINGTON in and to that portion, if any, of the property herein described which lies below the line of ordinary high water of the Lick Creek, 14. ANY QUESTION THAT MAY ARISE due to the shifting andfor changing in the course of North Fork Teanaway River. 15, RIGHT OF THE STATE OF WASHINGTON in and to that portion, if any, of the property herein described which lies below the line of ordinary high water of the North Fork Teanaway River. Order No. 38254 Pages Commitment KC1 gsilas title and Escrow issuing agent far westoortand Title Insurance Company 16. RIGHTS OF THE GENERAL PUBLIC to the unrestricted use of all the waters of a navigable body of water not only for the primary purpose of navigation, but also for corollary purposes; including (but not limited to) fishing, boating. bathing, swimming, water skiing and other related recreational purposes, as those waters may affect the tidelands, shorelands or adjoining uplands and whether the level of the water has been raised naturally or artificially to a maintained or fluctuating level, all as further defined by the decisional law of this state. (affects all of the premises subject to such submergence.) 17. PENDENCY OF YAKIMA COUNTY SUPERIOR COURT CAUSE NUMBER 77-2-01484-5, State of Washington Department of Ecology, plaintiff vs. James J. Acquavells, at al, defendants; notice of which is given by Lis Pendens recorded on October 14, 1977 under Auditor's file number 417302 and by supplemental notice of Lis Panders recorded on June 4, 1980 under Auditor's file number 442263; being an action for the determination of the rights to divert, withdraw, or otherwise make use of the surface waters of the Yakima River Drainage Basin, in accordance with the provisions of Chapters 90.03 and 90,44, Revised Code of Washington. Attorney for plaintiff, Charles B. Roe, Jr., Swim Assistant Attorney General NOTE. The policy/policies to be issued include as one of the General Exceptions 'Water rights, dams or fide to water', the action referred to herein involves such water rights and so will not appear on said n fcv/policies as a Special Exception See next page for notes Order No. 3 54 Page 6 Comndmcrd KG1 Kilwas lade and Escrow ewing agent fa VJesicor Lam Title Insurance CoWany NOTES: NOTE 1: Upon the cancellation of this commitment, If no transaction is consummated in reliance thereon, the charge shall be reduced to an amount which, in the opinion of the Company, is reasonable compensation for work performed. NOTE 2: According to the public records, there have been no deeds conveying the properly described in this report recorded within 24 months prior to the date hereof except as follows: NONE NOTE 3: All matters regarding extended coverage have been cleared for mortgagee's policy. Address of property: 13620 Teanaway Road North Fork Cie Elm, WA 98922 NOTE 4: According to the application for title insurance, We is to vest in Edc P. Barlow and Shauna M. Barlow, husband and wire. Examination of the records discloses no matters pending against sald party0es). END OF SPECIAL EXCEPTIONS orkrNo. 3825,1 P., Cownm9ment KC1 WWII. The no EsrrowhSWrg agent far W.I., land Title Insurance Compe+ry EXHIBIT 3: RCW 77.55.181 Page 5 of 6 Public Works "Work Session Staff Report", 2024 RCW 77.55.181: Fish habitat enhancement project —Permit review and approval process Limitation of liability. RCWs > Title 77 > Chapter 77.55 > Print Section 77.55.181 77.55.171 << 77.55.181 >> 77.55.191 RCW 77.55.181 Fish habitat enhancement project —Permit review and approval process —Limitation of liability. (1)(a) In order to receive the permit review and approval process created in this section, a fish habitat enhancement project must meet the criteria under this section and must be a project to accomplish one or more of the following tasks: (i) Elimination of human -made or caused fish passage barriers, including: (A) Culvert repair and replacement; and (B) Fish passage barrier removal projects that comply with the forest practices rules, as the term "forest practices rules" is defined in RCW 76.09.020; (ii) Restoration of an eroded or unstable stream bank employing the principle of bioengineering, including limited use of rock as a stabilization only at the toe of the bank, and with primary emphasis on using native vegetation to control the erosive forces of flowing water; or (iii) Placement of woody debris or other instream structures that benefit naturally reproducing fish stocks. (b) The department shall develop size or scale threshold tests to determine if projects accomplishing any of these tasks should be evaluated under the process created in this section or under other project review and approval processes. A project proposal shall not be reviewed under the process created in this section if the department determines that the scale of the project raises concerns regarding public health and safety. (c) A fish habitat enhancement project must be approved in one of the following ways in order to receive the permit review and approval process created in this section: (i) By the department pursuant to chapter 77.95 or 77.100 RCW; (ii) By the sponsor of a watershed restoration plan as provided in chapter 89.08 RCW; (iii) By the department as a department -sponsored fish habitat enhancement or restoration project; (iv) Through the review and approval process for the jobs for the environment program; (v) Through the review and approval process for conservation district -sponsored projects, where the project complies with design standards established by the conservation commission through interagency agreement with the United States fish and wildlife service and the natural resource conservation service; (vi) Through a formal grant program established by the legislature or the department for fish habitat enhancement or restoration; (vii) Through the department of transportation's environmental retrofit program as a stand-alone fish passage barrier correction project; (viii) Through a local, state, or federally approved fish barrier removal grant program designed to assist local governments in implementing stand-alone fish passage barrier corrections; (ix) By a city or county for a stand-alone fish passage barrier correction project funded by the city or county; (x) Through the approval process established for forest practices hydraulic projects in chapter 76.09 RCW; or http://app.leg.wa.gov/RCW/default.aspx?cite=77.55.181[11/30/2018 8:48:44 AM] RCW 77.55.181: Fish habitat enhancement project —Permit review and approval process —Limitation of liability. (xi) Through other formal review and approval processes established by the legislature. (2) Fish habitat enhancement projects meeting the criteria of subsection (1) of this section are expected to result in beneficial impacts to the environment. Decisions pertaining to fish habitat enhancement projects meeting the criteria of subsection (1) of this section and being reviewed and approved according to the provisions of this section are not subject to the requirements of RCW 43.21 C.030(2)(c). (3)(a) A permit is required for projects that meet the criteria of subsection (1) of this section and are being reviewed and approved under this section. An applicant shall use a joint aquatic resource permit application form developed by the office of regulatory assistance to apply for approval under this chapter. On the same day, the applicant shall provide copies of the completed application form to the department and to each appropriate local government. Applicants for a forest practices hydraulic project that are not otherwise required to submit a joint aquatic resource permit application must submit a copy of their forest practices application to the appropriate local government on the same day that they submit the forest practices application to the department of natural resources. (b) Local governments shall accept the application identified in this section as notice of the proposed project. A local government shall be provided with a fifteen -day comment period during which it may transmit comments regarding environmental impacts to the department or, for forest practices hydraulic projects, to the department of natural resources. (c) Except for forest practices hydraulic projects, the department shall either issue a permit, with or without conditions, deny approval, or make a determination that the review and approval process created by this section is not appropriate for the proposed project within forty-five days. The department shall base this determination on identification during the comment period of adverse impacts that cannot be mitigated by the conditioning of a permit. Permitting decisions over forest practices hydraulic approvals must be made consistent with chapter 76.09 RCW. (d) If the department determines that the review and approval process created by this section is not appropriate for the proposed project, the department shall notify the applicant and the appropriate local governments of its determination. The applicant may reapply for approval of the project under other review and approval processes. (e) Any person aggrieved by the approval, denial, conditioning, or modification of a permit other than a forest practices hydraulic project under this section may appeal the decision as provided in RCW 77.55.021(8). Appeals of a forest practices hydraulic project may be made as provided in chapter 76.09 RCW. (4) No local government may require permits or charge fees for fish habitat enhancement projects that meet the criteria of subsection (1) of this section and that are reviewed and approved according to the provisions of this section. (5) No civil liability may be imposed by any court on the state or its officers and employees for any adverse impacts resulting from a fish enhancement project permitted by the department or the department of natural resources under the criteria of this section except upon proof of gross negligence or willful or wanton misconduct. [ 2017 c 241 § 1; 2014 c 120 § 1; 2010 c 210 § 29; 2005 c 146 § 505; 2001 c 253 § 55; 1998 c 249 § 3. Formerly RCW 77.55.290, 75.20.350.1 NOTES: Intent —Effective dates —Application —Pending cases and rules-2010 c 210: See notes following RCW 43.21 B.001. http://app.leg.wa.gov/RCW/default.aspx?cite=77.55.18] [11/30/2018 8:48:44 AM] RCW 77.55.181: Fish habitat enhancement project —Permit review and approval process —Limitation of liability. Part headings not law-2005 c 146: See note following RCW 77.55.011. Findings—Purpose-1998 c 249: "The legislature finds that fish habitat enhancement projects play a key role in the state's salmon and steelhead recovery efforts. The legislature finds that there are over two thousand barriers to fish passage at road crossings throughout the state, blocking fish access to as much as three thousand miles of freshwater spawning and rearing habitat. The legislature further finds that removal of these barriers and completion of other fish habitat enhancement projects should be done in a cost-effective manner, which includes providing technical assistance and training to people who will undertake projects such as removal of barriers to salmon passage and minimizing the expense and delays of various permitting processes. The purpose of this act is to take immediate action to facilitate the review and approval of fish habitat enhancement projects, to encourage efforts that will continue to improve the process in the future, to address known fish passage barriers immediately, and to develop over time a comprehensive system to inventory and prioritize barriers on a statewide basis." [ 1998 c 249 § 1.] Joint aquatic resource permit application form—Modification-1998 c 249: "The department of ecology permit assistant [assistance] center shall immediately modify the joint aquatic resource permit application form to incorporate the permit process established in section 3 of this act." [ 1998c249§2.] Finding—Report-1998 c 249: "The legislature finds that, while the process created in this act can improve the speed with which fish habitat enhancement projects are put into place, additional efforts can improve the review and approval process for the future. The legislature directs the department of fish and wildlife, the conservation commission, local governments, fish habitat enhancement project applicants, and other interested parties to work together to continue to improve the permitting review and approval process. Specific efforts shall include the following: (1) Development of common acceptable design standards, best management practices, and standardized hydraulic project approval conditions for each type of fish habitat enhancement project; (2) An evaluation of the potential for using technical evaluation teams in evaluating specific project proposals or stream reaches; (3) An evaluation of techniques appropriate for restoration and enhancement of pasture and crop land adjacent to riparian areas; (4) A review of local government shoreline master plans to identify and correct instances where the local plan does not acknowledge potentially beneficial instream work; (5) An evaluation of the potential for local governments to incorporate fish habitat enhancement projects into their comprehensive planning process; and (6) Continued work with the federal government agencies on federal permitting for fish habitat enhancement projects. The department of fish and wildlife shall coordinate this joint effort and shall report back to the legislature on the group's progress by December 1, 1998." [ 1998 c 249 § 15.] Effective date-1998 c 249: "This act is necessary for the immediate preservation of the public peace, health, or safety, or support of the state government and its existing public institutions, and takes effect immediately [April 1, 1998]." [ 1998 c 249 § 18.] Site Contents Selected content listed in alphabetical order under each group http://app:.leg.wa.gov/RCW/default.aspx?cite=77.55.181[11/30/2018 8:48:44 AM] RC 'A' 77.55.181: Fish habitat enhancement project— Penn it review and approval process —Limitation of liability. Let Your Voice Be Heard Come to the Legislature Comment on a Bill Contact Your Legislators Find Bills Committee Meeting Schedules & Agendas District & Legislators Laws & Rules Member Information / Rosters Video & Audio on TVW Additional Information Accessibility Information Civic Education Comments about this site Contact Us Disclaimer Employment Opportunities Gift Center Glossary of Terms Help History of the State Legislature Privacy Notice Reports to the Legislature Search About the Legislature Committees House of Representatives Legislative Agencies Legislative Information Center Legislature Home Senate Track Legislation Bills Email Updates (GovDelivery) RSS Feeds Web Services Outside the Legislature Congress - the Other Washington Governor's Website OFM Fiscal Note Website Washington Courts Translate Select Language Powered by G:. gi.: Translate http://app.leg.wa.gov/RCW /defaull.aspx?cite=77.55.181 [ l 1 /30/2018 8:48:44 AM] EXHIBIT 4: COUNTY SPONSORSHIP LETTER Page 6 of 6 Public Works "Work Session Staff Report", 2024 n.Cnnea...m ant(. y>T alp �+ qry �Y�T�gv a ��,Y` pt�'2 1'>1TTJ11�0 Vo V 1� 1 Z DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC WORKS January 21, 2020 Washington Department of Fish and Wildlife, HPA Office PO Box 43234 Olympia, WA 98504-3234 RE: Fish Habitat Enhancement Project (FHEP) Consistently Verification for Teanaway Hydraulic Improvement Project — Phase 2 Lick Creek Culvert Replacement Dear WDFW Reviewer: Kittitas County Public Works has reviewed the Lick Creek Culvert Replacement Project and has determined that it is consistent with criteria described in RCW 77.55.181(1)(a)(c)(ix), which allows the approval of a Fish Habitat Enhancement Project "by a city or county as a stand-alone fish passage barrier correction project funded by the city or county". The Lick Creek Culvert Replacement Project is a fish passage improvement project that the Washington Department of Fish and Wildlife identified as a partial barrier (site ID 660008) in an assessment performed in April 2015. Kittitas County, as a sponsor of this project, approves of its submittal as a Fish Habitat Enhancement Project. For Kittitas County planning questions, please contact Lindsey Ozbolt, Kittitas County Planning Official at (509) 962-7046 or lndsey.ozbolt@co.kittitas.wa.us. For project specific questions contact me as the project manager at 509-962-7692 or mark.cook@co.kittitas.wa.us. Sincerely, Mark Cook Kittitas County Public Works Director Attachment: JARPA including FHEP documentation