Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAboutLT-SS-2020-003LT-SS-2020-003- E llensbu rg-Downtown pa rks 2O2O LODGING TAX SERVICES AGREEMENT BETWEEN KITTITAS COUNTY AND CITY OF ELLENSBURG (MUNICIPALITY} This Contract, effective October 6,2O2o is made and entered into by and between KITTITAScouNTY ("County"), a subdivision of the State of washington, and the clw oF ELLENSBURG ("Contractor"). WHEREAS, the purpose of this Agreement is to provide for Tourism-Related, Small-Scale Municipality-owned capital Projects relating to activities and expenditures designed to increase tourism, NoW THEREFORE, in consideration of the terms and conditions contained herein, or attached and incorporated and made a part hereof, the county and the Contractor mutually agree as follows: Section 1. Scope of Work. Contractor shall provide the services and staff described in its Application for lodging Tax Funds submitted to the Lodging Tax Advisory Committee, attached hereto as Exhibit ,,A,, (with limitations-see Section 2.a & b) which is attached hereto and incorporated herein by this reference. Except as otherwise specifically provided in this Agreement, Contractor shall furnish thefollowing as required to perform the services, described in paragraph (a) above, in accordance with this Agreement: Personnel, labor and supervision; technical, professional and other services- All such services, property and other items furnished or required to be furnished, together with all other obligations performed, or required to be performed, by Contractor under this Agreement are collectively referred to herein as ,,Services.,, Section 2. Pavment. As full compensation for satisfactory performance of the Contractor's Services, the county agrees to pay Contractor the sum of fifty thousand dollars {$SO,OOO.OO) to be used for capital project- only for the Downtown park lmprovements project. Additional payment terms: The county will make payment to the contractor only on a reimbursement basis, as receipts for any items are submitted to the County, not to exceedthe sum of fifty thousand dollars (550,000.00) to be used for capital project-only for Downtown Parks lmprovements project. Services/Expenses that are reimbursed must be dated duringthe 24 (twenty-four) months(or two years) of the date of the Agreement and final date to submit reimbursements requests is October 6,2022 after this date funds lapse. Requests for reimbursements must be submitted to: a b a b c d _County Lodging Tax Funding Agreement Page 7 LT-SS-2020-003-Ellensburg-Downtown Pa rks Kittitas County Aud itor Attn: Judy Pless 205 West 5th Ave - Suite 105 Ellensburg, WA 98926 a uditoraccounting@co.kittitas.wa. us e Reporting requirements of your events will be required on prescribed forms from the County Auditor. Section 3- Perfo nce bv Contractor a. Contractor shall not (by contract, operation of law or otherwise) delegate or subcontract .performance of any Services to any other person or entity without the prior written consent of the County. Any such delegation or subcontracting without the County's prior written consent shall be voidable at the County's option. b. Contractor shall at all times be an independent contractor and not an agent or representa- tive of the County with regard to performing the Services. Contractor shall not represent that it is, or hold itself out as, an agent or representative of the County. ln no event shall Contractor be authorized to enter into any Agreement or undertaking for or on behalf of the County. lt is understood that the Contractor and the Contractor's staff and employees are not employees of the County and are not, therefore, entitled to any benefits provided employees of the County. c. Contractor shall comply with all applicable laws, ordinances, rules, regulations, orders, licenses, permits, and other requirements, now or hereafter in effect, of any governmental authority (including, but not limited to, such requirements as may be imposed upon the County and applicable to Services). Contractor shall furnish such documents as may be required to effect or evidence such compliance. All laws, ordinances, rules, and orders required to be incorporated into agreements of this character are incorporated into this Agreement by this reference. Contractor agrees to obtain all required licenses and permits, and further agrees to keep them in fullforce and effect during the term of this Agreement. d. The County and the Contractor agree that in fulfilling the terms and conditions of this Agreement neither shall discriminate on the basis of race, creed, color, national origin, age, sex, marital status, or the presence of a physical, sensory, or mental handicap. e. The Services shall at all times be subject to inspection by and approval of the County, but the County's making (or failure or delay in making) such inspection or approval shall not relieve Contractor of its responsibility to perform the Services in accord with this Agreement, notwithstanding the County's knowledge of defective or non-complying performance, or the substantiality or ease of discovering the same. Contractor shall provide the County with sufficient, safe, and proper facilities and equipment for such inspection and free access to such facilities. f. This contract is subject to review by any Federal or State auditor. Contractor shall promptly furnish the County or its designee, or such Federal or State auditor with such information _County Lodging Tax Funding Agreement Page 2 LT-SS-2020-003-E I lensbu rg-Downtown Pa rks related to the Services as may be requested by the applicable governmental entity. Contractor shall preserve and maintain all financial records and records relating to performance of Services under this Agreement for six (6) years after contract termination. For such duration after the County makes final payment of compensation due hereunder, Contractor shall provide the County access to (and the County shall have the right to examine, audit and copy, with or without notice) all of Contractor's books, documents, papers and records related to the Services or this Agreement. g. Contractor understands and acknowledges that Contractor is solely responsible for its own reporting and accounting of all state, federal, social security, and local taxes, of every nature, arising from Contractor's performance of this Agreement. All compensation received by the Contractor will be reported to the lnternal Revenue Service at the end of the calendar year in accord with the applicable IRS regulations. Section 4. Release. lndemnitv, and Hold Harmless. The County assumes no liability for the Contractor's actions under this Agreement. Contractor releases and shall defend, indemnify, and hold harmless the County, its officers and employees, agents, representatives, attorneys and/or volunteers, from and against all claims, costs, liabilities, damages, and expenses, (including, but not limited to, reasonable attorney fees) which arise or may arise or be alleged to arise out of or by reason of this Agreement including: Any fault, negligence, strict liability or product liability of Contractor in connection with the Services for this Agreement; Any lien asserted upon any property of the County in connection with the Services for this Agreement; a Any failure of Contractor, or of the Services, to comply with any applicable law, ordinance, rule, regulation, order, license, permit and other requirement, now or hereafter in effect, of any governmental authority; or a Any breach of or default under this Agreement by Contractor Section 5. Compliance with Public Records Law. ln compliance with Washington's public records law, the County will retain copies of any documents associated with this Agreement, which may be required by law unless legally exempt from such retention, for any applicable legally required retention period. b. ln the event a public records request is made to the County for documents created in relation to this Agreement, should legal uncertainty arise regarding the disclosability of any documents under federal or state public records laws, the County shall provide notice to Contractor pursuant to Washington's public records act, chapter 42.56 RCW, to allow Contractor to seek a court injunction. c. The County specifically shall not be liable to Contractor for the County's release under public records laws of any documents not protected by trademark, copyright or other law. a a a _County Lodging Tax Funding Agreement Page 3 LT-SS-2020-003-Ellensburg-Downtown Parks Section 6. lndustrial lnsurance Waiver. With respect to performance of this Agreement and as to any claims against the County, its Additional lnsureds, officers, agents and employees, the Contractor expressly waives its immunity under Title 51 of the Revised Code of Washington, the lndustrial lnsurance Act, for injuries to Contractor's employees and agrees that the obligations to indemnifiT, defend and hold harmless provided in this Agreement extend to any claim brought by or on behalf of any employee of the Contractor. This waiver is mutually negotiated by the parties to this Agreement. Section 7. lnsura and Endorsements. a. The County may require through a request in writing that the Contractor provide the County with a certificate, binder, or policy of liability insurance, acceptable to the County in an amount specified by the County. b. Such liability insurance shall be such as will protect Contractor, its employees, agents and representatives, from all claims, losses, harm, costs, liabilities, damages and expenses arising out of personal injury (including death) or property damage that may result from performance of the Services or this Agreement, whether such performance is by Contractor or any of its employees, agents or representatives. c.Should the County require such liability insurance, the Contractoragreesto provide proof of insurance prior to commencing performance of this Agreement. d. Copies of the County's written request and the insurance documents provided by Contractor shall be attached to this Agreement and by this reference will be made part hereof. Where insurance is requested by the County, all liability insurance policies shall be endorsed to include the County as an Additional lnsured and shall stipulate that the insurance afforded by the policies shall be primary insurance, and that any insurance, self-insured retention, deductibles, or risk retention trusts maintained or participated in by the Parties shall be excess and not contributory to any other insurance maintained by the County. Contractor shall furnish the County a certificate of insurance with Endorsement as evidence that the required policies are in full force and effect. Section 8. Termination. The County may, by written notice thereof to Contractor, terminate this Agreement as to all or any portion of the Services not yet performed, whether or not Contractor is in breach or default. Upon receiving such notice of termination, Contractor shall, except as otherwise directed by the County, immediately stop performing the Services to the extent specified in the notice. ln the event the County terminates the Contractor's Services, the Contractor is obligated and hereby agrees to refund to the County all monies paid for Services not yet rendered by the Contractor, if any, as of the date of the notice of termination. _County Lodging Tax Funding Agreement Page 4 LT-SS-2020-003-El lensb u rg-Downtown Pa rks Section 9. Miscellaneous. a. Contractor shall not (by contract, operation of law or otherwise) assign this Agreement or any right or interest in this Agreement without the County's prior written consent. b. This Agreement embodies the entire Agreement between the County and Contractor, and supersedes any and all prior oral or written communications, proposals, conditions, promises, representations, or understandings regarding the Services. No change, amendment or modification of any provision of this Agreement shall be valid unless set forth in a written amendment to the Agreement signed by both parties. Notice for any purpose under this Agreement, except service of process, shall be given by the Contractor to the Kittitas County Commissioners and the Kittitas County Auditor, 205 West 5th Ave. Ellensburg, WA 98926. For all purposes under this Agreement, any notice by the County to the Contractor shall be given to the Contractor's address provided on the signature page. Notice may be given by delivery or by depositing in the U.S. Mail, first class, postage prepaid, certified mail, return receipt requested. d. The section and paragraph headings of this Agreement are for reference convenience only and are not intended to restrict, affect or be of any weight in interpreting or construing the provisions of such sections or paragraphs. e. This Agreement may be executed in one or more counterparts and by facsimile, each of which will be deemed an original, but all of which together will constitute one and the same instrument. f. Contractor warrants to the County that the individual signing on Contractor's behalf has the requisite power and authority to enter into and to perform Contractor's obligations under this Agreement. Contractor further warrants to the County that Contractor has made no misrepresentation or misleading statement in connection with this Agreement, and is not in violation of any applicable law, ordinance, or regulation the consequence of which will or may materially affect Contractor's ability to perform its obligations under this Agreement. g. lf any term or condition of this Agreement or the application thereof to any person(s) or circumstances is held invalid, such invalidity shall not affect the other terms, conditions or applications which can be given effect without the invalid term, condition or application. To this end, the terms and conditions of this Agreement are declared severable. h. The exclusive venue for any action brought to enforce this Agreement or any of its terms shall be in Kittitas County, State of Washington. c KITTITAS COUNTY BOARD OF COUNTY CO Chair RS _County Lodging Tox Funding Agreement rint Name R {l Page 5 LT lensburg-Parks Vice Chair Commissioner a,\ttllllllll/ltl7 /o /zo TnLf) w [Telephone] erk ofthe Board TO FORM Deputy Prosecuting Attorney _County Lodging Tax Funding Agreement Page 6 EXtnrUif ofrtt Applicant lnformation Name of Municipality: Mailing Address: Contact Person and Title Phone: Email: Project Title: Project Location: Funding Request: Operations (Circle One or Both) Citv of Ellensbure 501 N Andelson Ellensbure, WA 98926 Brad Case. 8ar"Ls & Recreation Director s09-925-8639 case b (CIcitvofe I I e n sburg. org Downtown Pa,rk lmprovemen$ Northwest corner of 4th & Pearl in Downtown Ellensburs ss0,000.00 Application Requirements _ 1.The project qualifies for lodging tax funds as a capital expenditure of a tourism related facility owned or operated by a municipality or is supporting the operations of tourism-related facilities owned or operated by a municipality. _z.The municipality has submitted no more than two applications for capital project funding in the current year. _ 3. The municipality's lodging tax advisory committee (or equivalent) has been informed of the project and endorsed it (not required for Kittitas County). A letter from the municipality is included. _4. Lodging tax capital project funds are not being substituted for other funds that are already secured or applied for (if applicable). _ 5. Municipality has secured matching funds of at least 50% of the total project costs. - 6. A completed project budget is included in the application (if applicable) _T.Adetailed 8%XtLvicinity map that clearlyshowsthe project is included (if applicable) Tourism-Related, Small-Scale Municipality-Owned Capital Project Narrative L. Project Description: Please describe the project in detail. lndicate the major work to be completed, any milestones that need to be overcome in order for the project to move forward and include a comparison of existing and proposed conditions. The scope of this project calls forthe removalof the drive thru structure of the existing bank building, located at the City owned Rotary Pavilion property. By removing the drive thru, an additional L,600 square feet can be used as programmable space for the multitude of recreational events that take place at the site throughout the course ofthe year. Program organizers currently use the parking area and pavilion area to run events, which is quite restrictive. The City has a long-standing stake in this property. From September 1, 1980 to September 25,2079,Lhe City subleased and was responsible for the maintenance and upkeep of the Rotary Pavilion. ln late September 2019, the City was able to purchase the property with the long-term vision of creating a public park. To that end, the City contracted with WalkerlMacy, a landscape architect firm, to perform concept design services for the entire property. Consulting services included a site inventory analysis, facilitating three distinctive stakeholder meetings and preparing concept site plans. Before starting work on this project, the City Parks & Recreation Departrnent will need to apply for a demolition permit through the City of Ellensburg Community Development Department, as well as take the project to the City Landmarks and Design Commission for their review. ln order to minimize impact on events taking place at the Rotary Pavilion, work could begin sometime in the late winter or early spring of 2021.. 2. Kittitas County Tourism lnfrastructure Plan: Please explain how the project meets the goals and priorities in the Kittitas County Tourism lnfrastructure Plan as adopted. Also, describe the specific county tourism infrastructure needs the project addresses and how the project directly increases tourism. Explain how the improvements will promote tourism in Kittitas County and indicate specifically how the improvements will directly increase economic activity resulting from tourists (see the definition of tourist on page 3 of this application). The development of this property will benefit tourism by creating a unique "destination" multi-purpose park in a centralized public space. The space will dramatically increase programming opportunaties that attract visitors to our community. A park of this type becomes a signature attraction and prime marketing tool for conventions, businesses, and tourism. Organized programming opportunities include but are not limited to, event and festivals for arts, food, music, movies, sports, and holidays, When a potential visitor comes to an event, they have made or will make additional I arrangements which can include hotels/motels, restaurants, fuel, retail, and recreational adventures. This addition economic activity positively impacts the community, as well as the communities traveled through to get to a destination. The Rotary Pavilion is uniquely situated in a location that makes it useful and usable year-round. There are many tourists that attended events in Ellensburg that last more than three days length. Of note are the Ellensburg Rodeo which boasts over 60,000 tourists each year. ln support of the Rodeo are several events that occur at the Rotary Pavilion such as the Rodeo Kick-Off breakfast, and the Hoedown in the Downtown. lt's not a reach to suggest that most of the Rodeo attendees have lodging in Ellensburg, which have an average overnight expenditure of $9S/pp (source: Dean Runyan Associates), and the RodeoisasignificantsupporterofCountytourismasadestination. Worthmentioning,too,isJazzin the Valley, also a multi-day event, which attracts an estimated 5,000 tourists who travel >50 miles from their residence/place of business to attend this very popular music event. For over 20 years, this annual, reoccurring event supports the County as a tourism destination, with attendees having multi-day lodging stays in Ellensburg and the County. ln total it is estimated that over 58,000 people annually stay overnight in Ellensburg for events that utilize the Rotary Pavilion property, of which, 65,000 people travel from an area greater than 50 miles away to attend these events. 3. Use of Grant Funds: Please explain exactly how the requested funds will be used. lnclude an itemized list. Grant funds from this program will be used to perform the following tasks: 1. Demolition and removalof the drive thru structure of the old Wells Fargo bank building, 2. Repair the bank building west wall that is disturbed as a result of the demolition work, 3. Removal of the drive thru customer service stations 4. Repaving where bank infrastructure was removed to provide added programmable area 4. Real Property: lf real property acquisition is a component of the project, please explain. lnclude any information of property already secured or evidence of the ability to secure the real property. 5. Capital Assets: lf capital asset acquisition is a component of the project, please explain. lnclude any bids solicited and received from potential vendors willing to supply the asset. All capital asset purchases req uire at least three bids. lf you have already selected one of the bids, please provide justifications in writing. 6. Coordination: Please explain how this project has been coordinated with other jurisdictions as well as affected stakeholders. Please include letters of support from stakeholders. As a part of the park master planning process, the City held stakeholder meetings with over 25 members of the community. These stakeholder meetings were attended by user groups such as Jazzin the Valley, Kittitas County Chamber of Commerce, Ellensburg Downtown Association, and the lron Horse Brewery. Also included in the stakeholder's meetings were downtown business owners and various members of City boards and commissions. Additionally, the City, along with Walker I Macy, the landscape architect firm assisting with the project, held a public forum at the Rotary Pavilion in October 20L9 which over 50 people attended, providing valuable feedback on the project. City staff has presented the project to local service clubs such as the Morning and Noon Rotary Clubs, and Kiwanis Club. 7. Studies: Please attach any feasibility or other studies that demonstrate linkages between the proposed project and the anticipated tourism impacts. Also please include your operations/maintenance funding strategy and business plan for long-term project sustainability (how the facility or facilities will be operated and maintained for at least three years following completion). Attached are two studies, the draft copy of the City of Ellensburg Strategic Plan 2O2O-2024 prepared by JayRay, and the Downtown Market Study and Economic Development Plan, prepared by Arnett Muldrow. The importance of the Rotary Pavilion property as a downtown public park, and the role it will serve as an event venue and economic generator is displayed throughout both plans, lnformation in the JayRay study, related to the projects impact on tourism can be found on: Page 10 & 62, Local events or festivals attract the most visitors to Ellensburg Page 27, Long-range Community Goals Benefitting Tourism, Downtown development ln the Arnett Muldrow study, information related to the downtown park can be found on: Page 26, Section 4.0 Recommendations, Reinforcing the Center Page 26, Section 4.1 Reinforcing the Town Center, 4.7.7 lmplement Ellensburg Town Sguore as d gdthering place. High Priority, Page 28, Figure 9, Ellensburg Core Area Plan PaEe 37, Section 4.4 Enhancing the Visitors Experience ,4.4.7 Relocate visitors' center to the core of downtown. The long-term management of the property will fall under the City Parks & Recreation Department. Two years ago, the City adopted a new special event permit process to better streamline and support event planners, this process is administered by the Parks & Recreation Director. The day to day maintenance of the property will be the responsibility of the City Parks Maintenance Division. 8. Project Readiness: Please provide a detailed project schedule, including milestones necessary for completion as mentioned in question 1 above. On the schedule, indicate items completed and exactly where in the schedule the project is at this time. Be sure to include expected completion date. As stated in question number 1, before starting work on this project, the City Parks & Recreation Department will need to apply for a demolition permit through the City of Ellensburg Community Development Department, as well as take the project to the City Landmarks and Design Commission for their review. ln order to minimize impacts on events taking place at the site, work could begin sometime in the late winter or early spring of 2021, lt is anticipated that the work will take less than 15 days to complete. Since the City acquired the property in September 2019, there has been no new development or alterations to the site. City staff is making application through a variety of grant programs for project development, including a $500,000.00 request through the Recreation and Conservation Office (RCO) for park development. lt is anticipated that the cost of the full park build-out will be approximately 51,500,000.00. lf is funding is available, full build out on the park could begin in September 2021. 9. Applicant Certification: Please sign below in agreement with statement of certification. Certification is hereby given that the information provided is accurate and the applicable attachments are complete and included as part of the application package. I further certifiT that the application thresholds are met at the time of application. Signature of Official Representative Title Date Tou rism-Related, Small-Sca le M u n ici pal ity-Owned Capital Project Budget All applicants for capital project funding must supply a detailed and complete project budget utilizing the following basic format: Funding Sources Lodging Tax Funds Request 550,000.00 *Other Grant Funds List By Source (indicate if secured or applied) *other Local Government Funds 550.000.00 List By Source Citv of Ellensburs Park lmpact Fees *Private Funds List By Source (may include in-kind) Total Available Funding Project Expenses ReaI Property or "Right-of-Way" Acquisition Cost Capital Asset Cost Construction Cost or "Hard" Cost lnclude an itemized list of general costs Sea attached proiect budget worksheet For example: asset type and cost, site prep, building foundation and structure, mechanicalwork, finish work, site restoration, electrical work, technology, etc. Soft Cost lnclude an itemized list of soft costs For example: design fees, construction management fees, survey costs, engineering fees, permitting costs, special inspections, cultural resource surveys, etc. Total PCIect costs $100,000.00 *Verifying documentation must be provided and attached to this budget. This documentation may include award letters, letters of commitment, or loan approval documentation. You must include this in order to meet the matching funds requirement, lf the funding source includes applicant funds, proof of available funding in the form of a letter of commitment from an authorized body or representative of the applicant is adequate. See attached City of Ellensburg Park Acquisition Fund Balance thru May 2020. Tourism-Related Facility Operational Funding Narrative {Municipality Applications Only} 1. Operational Spending: Please explain your request for operational funding and how it is directly related to supporting the operations of a tourism-related facility owned or operated by a municipality or public facilities district. 2. Sustainability Strategy: Please describe your strategy for long-term operational sustainability. lnclude any specific progress toward this goal. 3. Applicant Certification: Please sign below in agreement with statement of certification, Certification is hereby given that the information provided is accurate and the applicable attachments are complete and included as part of the application package. that lication thresholds are met at the time of application. 4n lA*rro.a-t8-zo re of presentative Title Date Date; To: From C;ry of MEMORANDUM June 1 8,2020 Kittitas County Lodging Tax Advisory Committee Brad Case, City of Ellensburg Parks & Recreation Director 4 City of Ellensburg Lodging Tax Advisory Committee ReviewSubject: The City of Ellensburg Lodging Tax Advisory Committee (or equivalent) has not been informed of the project due to the impacts of COVID 19 and regulations regarding public meetings. staff will be presenting the proposed project to the City Lodging Tax Advisory Committee at their next meeting, which is scheduled for Wednesday, July 1, 2020. CITY OF ELLENSBURG May 2020 Budget Updat€ Report For the Five Months Ending Sunday, May 31, 2020 41.67% of year complete 37.5% of payrolls complete BudgetYTD RemaininoBudoetMav Monthly % Rev/Evn YTD % Rev/Exo Dopt 160. Park Acquisiiion Fund Beg. Fund Balance: 10G160-282-00-00{00-000 Rsstric,ted Fund Balance 10G16G308-10-01-000-000 Reserved Beginning Balance 10G16G30&80-01-000-000 Unreserved Beginning Balance Total Beg. Fund Balance Revgnues: 100-160-308-10-01{00-000 Reseryed Beginning Batance 10S.160-308-80-01-000-000 Unrese.ved Beginning Balance 10G160-33640-8740G000 Gas Tax 1 00-1 60-345-85-00-000-000 lmpacl Fees 1 0G'1 60-361-1 1 {0-00S'000 Earned lnterest Total Revenues Expenditures Fund Balance Cash Balance: 100-160-1 1 1-10{0400-000 Cash 1 00-1 60-1 1 8-10{0-000-000 lnvestments Total Cash Balance 0.00% 0.00o/o 0.00% 0.00% 0.00% 0.00% $79,1 38 $734.723 $41,268 $79,138 -$734,723 -941,268 $79,136 u.uu% $//5,991 -S696,853 9E0,56% $1,7,11 $265,000 5^46% 1.450/" 0.00% s0 $0 $739 $59,074 $5,1 55 $972 $205,326 -$5,1s5 43j6% 22.52% 0.00% $93.48 93,850.00 $300.47 $zott, rrl 1 $4,243.95 $345,849 $4,243.95 $4,243.95 DOC,COU $2U1,143 $841,559 -$49s,710 1.59% 1.230h 24.5AYo 243.33% 0.00% 0.00% s841,559 $o -$841,559 $0 0.00% 0.00% $4,243.9b u.oo% $6/11,559 -$841,559 U.U070 62 ol 121 Tu\a{ F,nq- C6f rld Rdq Fd - E'.et. wa ROUGH COSTS SUMMARY - Concept Design an'&ro ffiffi P&!&Y wiowtfis $fioclCm i6lc- tr Mark Up (&dhead, Protn. IEuaM, Bords. B&O T6) fOfAL )3,2Q3 643,230 Esimrcd e!b&N(i! uSho SOURCENOTES I]TH Btuie il05.{0 Torll kieted UFEruNCEUSED Ef@-- !.s SF l0.s !5@,@ $5.5m UO 1]TH JO 13TH ]ONC PA\EN s a a@@ JO ISTH 3 --il---E- ?.m@ t66nd- i76@-rE6-- FVSre rad6 d tu6 Femob Ludhug ftn€dot iro r3TH ,s 3'CAl- ugnlln8 ]3TH tm.@ t12,@ lsmry4m t0m t.m lEuildrrt lEuq -rMM otrs lsbs.t5 EDMONDS CA1C FIEI,D 3Josf lguroT[u PM. Ir, ND.fr3 PilL TFiOWEnS lsfror[ P& t&GYffioErE[S lsuaror& qLY PMK t{FioEf, ExE JO I3TH l- PoftqrylqddswddFduF)Fl,m fo ltro JO I3TH TO I]TH l$alfr& u sm cMffcRNrc[wwEs l$moTA PMK &AIEYStrE CMffimt@hltrtEs lwEToT&oxLYPM IIFROVEffiS 13 50 lsuErora PMK sft ELEfrRTCI WSTES iE7,O0O f Eel UVlcmity. Pili - _-- _�--- le {:, - 'M � � • � •_' �. w � � '' iI a _st1 �.- ice_ _ N - I.. = r 1;' _ ��. J i newjr r TV M -777 OM �' *�N The project includes the removal ofeverything located inside the yellow box,with the exception of the building westfacing wall. rT Ellensburg Music Festival jazzinthevalley,com e I I e n s b u rg m u si cfe stiva l. co m PA Box2I4 Ellensburg, WA 98926 i nfo @ j o z z i nth eva I I ey. co m PRESTDENT / DTRECTOR Tony Swartz 425-239-278L tony@jazzintheval ley.com BOARD OF DIRECTORS Chris Bruya Micah Brunner Amy Burke Rob Fraser Greg Lyman Jorge Rodriguez Don Solberg Joy Solberg Laura Stanley Tony Swartz Norm Wallen Linda Warren Jazz in the Valley is a program of the Laughing Horse Arts Foundation, a nonprofit 501(c)(3) organization. June 18,2020 Kittitas County Lodging Tax Advisory Committee Kittitas County Courthouse Commissioner's Office 205 W.sth Ave. Suite l-08, Ellensburg, WA 98926 Dear Committee Members, For the last 20 years, the Rotary Pavilion has been home for Jazz in the Valley, our annual music event, where thousands of visitors arrive in Ellensburg to enjoy three days of jazz, sun, and our beautiful downtown. Hearing that the City of Ellensburg has applied for funding through the 'Tourism-Related, Small Scale Municipality-Owned' project program has the JIV Board of Directors very excited. Each year we run into challenges with event set-up; not surprisingly, a small bank parking lot and pavilion area is not very compatible with running a first-class musac festival. With this additional space we can potentially increase event attendance, provide more food & beverage vendors, expand seating, and overall create a much more appealing setting for our event. While the long-term vision of this rnuch needed downtown park site remains our focus as we work to develop the future for lazz in the Valley, the benefit of this project will reap immediate rewards. Sincerely, Tony Swartz President / Director Jazzin the Valley /sl *ffiE ELLENSBU RG DOWNTOWN ASSOCTATTON June 18,2020 Kittitas County Lodging1'ax Advisory Comminee Cornmissionetrs Office 205 Vf. 5th Ave. Suite 108, Ellensbutg,'$fl4 98926 Deat Cotntnittee Membets, On behalf of the Ellensbwg Downtown Association, I would like to strongly support the City of Ellensburg's application through the 'Tourism Related, Small Scale Municipality-Owned Capital Project'progtam for the proposed improvements at the future dorvntown park. As both a supporter and organizer of local evetrts, the EDA sees the benefits of this much needed ptoject. The future downtown park location serves as the hub of ow beautiful historic downtown, and the opportunity to enhance the park and create a more user-ftendly space will provide many economic benefits for our County. In its cunent configuation, the site is testrictive in not only how events can be set up but also limits the numbet of people that ate able to attend the event. As a tesult of this ptoject, event organizers will have mote flexibility to create the type of envjronmetrt event attendees are looking to cxperience. Thank you for yout considetation of this ptoject, out office would be happy to answ€t any additional quesrions you may have. Sincetely, TaylotVillwock Public Relarions Cootdinator Ellensburg Downtown Ass ociation Ellcnsburg Downtowe Association i 19 !( 5'r' Ave. Srute 102, Eller:sburg, V(A 93926 rwr.rv.ellensb urgdorvntorvn. org 509 -9 62 -6246 DRAFT FOR ,CO,MMITTEE REVIEW City of Ellensburg Tourism Strategic Plan 2A2A-2A24 Prepared by: JayRay 535 Dock Street, Suite 205 Tacoma, Washington 984A2 (:ity at Eileilsiiurg iiv.i /i'ar f:,ur'is r: Str'aieqrC Plr:r l0 19 Co nte nts P.3 P.4 P.6 lntroduction Executive SummarY Research & Discovery . Stakeholderlnterviews r Visitor Survey r Current Marketing Strategic Plan Framework r Situation r Goal, Vision, Strategy r Funding . Staffing r Positioning Leisure Tourism Sports Tourism Meetings Tourism Appendices r Executive lnterviews : Visitor Surveys r CWUCollaboration:College Town ExamPles P. 15 P.24 P,39 P.47 P.55 Ciry at Eltensburg Five-Year Tourism Strategic Plan 22019 lntrod uction The Ellensburg tourism strategic plan provides a five-yearguide to growing tourism as an important tool for economic development. The planning process was initiated by the Lodging Tax Advisory Committee (LTAC) and undertaken by Ellensburg's destination marketing organization, the Kittitas County Chamber of Commerce' The plan was developed with input from the Strategic Plan Committee. An independent marketing firm, JayRay Ads and pR, facilitated the planning process, research and final plan production. tnput on the plan was sought through interviews of tourism-engaged local leaders and a survey of recent visitors. The plan aligns with the goals, policies and objectives found in the following documents; , CRU gf.Eltergburp Car&prehqql8eglgE . Cify sf Ell€r$b{rts Pa{8s-,& ffegle-ation Comorehe . Eltre8sb$rs tlaw$tovrn lvtarket Studv and Econoclic Devgloprylent PlaE , Citv of Ellensbure Wqr{indjrng_glql ' Kittiras C$$ntY Tqqjqm lpfraitruetugllgn . Kittalas Valley Event Ce$ter . Kittltas CgLnty Csm-pgghgg$qg-gb!. Plan Elernents The tourism strategic plan builds on and refines current marketing efforts with a focus on: . Advertising r Website and other content platforms r Visitor information centers and kiosks r Visitor information services near freeway interchanges r Destination promotions r Support of destination marketing organizations through lodging tax funds Tourism Strategic Plan Conrrnittee Thank you to,the following individuals who participated in the advisory group and planning sessions: r Amy Mc6uffin, CEO, Kittitas County Chamber of Commerce . Brad Case. Director, City of Ellensburg Parks and Recreation . Carolyn Honeycittt, Economic Development Manager, City of Ellensburg r Madison Ford, Director of Tourism and Events, Kittitas County Chamber of Commerce . Matt Anderson, LTAC Member and General Manager, Holiday lnn Express r MollyJones-Kerchner, Executive Director, Ellensburg Downtown Association . Nicole Klauss, Ellensburg City Council Member, Chair of LTAC, and Content and Events Marketing Supervisor for Central Washington University Publicity Center . Teri Oliru Marketing Manager, Central Washington University City cf e ilansburg Fiira Year fourism Strateg.ic Pl3n J2019 Ellensburg's goal is to support a healthy economy through increased tourism. The cily will grow tourism by refiningand enhancing itsleisure tourism nrarketingand by reaching new audiences through sports and nreetings tourisrn. Ellensburg Tourism Plan Executive Summary Over the next five years, Ellensburg will: 1. Develop a stronger branding position that is true to the community's nature and attractive to visitors. Produce new advertising and marketing creative that supports this position. 2. Establish baselines and specific goals to measure its tourism effort. Expand reporting to include economic impact indicators and regular visitor surveys, as well as current analytics. 3. Grow the tourism program to include sports and meetings as well as leisure tourism. Engage in significant outreach to gain sports and meeting bookings. Set and track goals, 4. lmprove its online presence through a new website, Work to increase positive mentions on third- party online travel sites. 5. Create a robust social media program that reaches new audiences through travel influencer blogs, posts and social media takeovers. Make Ellensburg more socially "shareable," 6. lrnprove the experience at chamber and downtown visitor information centers, including a digital information board downtown. Deploy a mobile visitor center at freeway interchanges and off-site locatio,ns. 7. Focus advertising efforts on audience profiles and markets most likely to produce results- western Washington adults seeking reasonably-priced escapes. Test new digital advertising opportunities including those targeting sports and meeting event planners. 8. Support the tourism effort with funding that permits staffing sports and meetings tourism outreach and that allows marketing budget growth in keeping with Lodging and Sales Tax revenue growth. 9. Partner with other organizations to promote significant tourism opportunities. City of Ellensburg Five-Year Tourism Strategic Plaa 4 Research shows / Ellensburg is conflicted about its image as a rodeo town, college town or events town. Visitors aren't sure what to think. / The greatest number of visitors surveyed were 45 years old and older and come frorn King Qounty. They're "comfortable," but not wealthy. r' Most visitors surveyed come for events. They like the downtown and local beer, wine and sp'irits. lf under 45, they rank outdoor recreation as a strong attraction. They're likely to return 1-2 times a year. Opportunity knocks / Ellensburg offers a crowd-free, small-town escape close to a large urban area, / lts central, affordable location makes it attractive for meetings and events. r' lts historic downtown offers authentic, unique experiences. / lt has u nderutilized, quality sports facilities. / lts natural environrnent provides rich assets for leisure and sports tourism. 2019 I au rism Pla n Executive Su m m ary, p. 2 Position/rebrand & new creative Add outreach staff New website Downtown visitor kiosk & signs Mobile visitor information center Visitor survey Advertising Social nredia influencer campaigns Add content on 3rd party websites E-newsletter Leisure travel pa rtnerships i;'.:.::il"lir 1 j I I i'.?t ir'r ii.ii r..r;- J i)ilitir!(.ri,,';,r . I .ial '. :'lii 'r.'-' i.iJrftiy '14 1 !:;17r. !1i't ,ll i{q ttlir ir:r: ,ttr"$Jifil Establish sports advisory group Add sports web content Create sports tourism guide Begin sports tourism outreach Sports trade show exhibits Create sports Facebook account Review FTE needs for outreach Establish meeting tourism advisory group Begin meeting tourism outreach Add meetings web content Create meetings tourism guide Created Meetings Linkedln page Meetings trade show exhibits Host meeting planner dinners (.i:: l l,i ilierr;b,.r:fl ii ;.. \'e:r'lrl:iisilr Slr'.:ligiit l'ir_1n .)7t)\9 i l rl i t I I I I i Ellensburg Research and Discovery City of Ellensburg Fr.Je-Yea r T ourism Strat,.gic Plan 520L9 Research and Discovery: Executive lnterviews Executive lnterviews Stakeholders from the city, business, the chamber, the university, downtown association and local arts, events and historical organizations in Ellensburg were interviewed for input into this plan. lnterview candidates were identified by the strategic plan committee. JayRay reached out to more than 20 candidates and conducted 16 interviews. Questions focused on these key areas; goals, positioning, audiences, resources and success factors. Learnings Goals Ellensburg seeks to grow tourism into an increasingly important economic driver, while not sacrificing the relaxed, small-town atmosphere that makes it so attractive to residents and visitors alike. Ratherthan be a "tourist town" like Leavenworth, Poulsbo or other destinations, it seeks to offer an authentic small-town experience enlivened by the presence of a vibrant university culture and punctuated by regularfestivals and events that earn it a reputation for "always having something going on." ln additionalto leisure tourism, Ellensburg's location, affordability and facilities make it a good fit for small-to-medium sized group activities from conferences to youth and adult sports tournaments. Positioning (how visitors think of Ellensburg, distinct from other weekend getaways) Ellensburg is stillvery muclr what it has been-a relaxing, friendly small ranching and college town. lt's on its way to becoming more artsy (music, galleries, craft beer/cuisine), but it hasn't fully leaned into any one of the arts. lt also has tremendous recreational opportunities and natural beauty, not only for the avid outdoorsman, but for the Sunday nature walker, the once-a-year kayaker and the recreational cyclist. lt's a town that likes variety, with some event or festival happening most weekends. lt's centrally located and affordable. The rodeo is still its most well-known event. lf Ellensburg were to more clearly distinguish itself from its destlnation competition, the most common positions mentioned by stakeholders were: r "There's always something happening" events townr "Western heritage" town. "A place to escape" town r "Meet in the middle" town City of Ellensburg Five-YeaI Tourism Strategic Plan quoTEs oF NoTE "Unlike Ledvenworth or Winthrop, the activities change so there's a teasan to come back. We always have some fun activity going on," "You cqn't have lestivals all the time, but you can have u festive qtmosphere all the time, Ellensburg shauld hdve more street vendors and the city needs to help make that happen," "The rodeo is still very impottdnt, but the western theme for Ellensburg is wonlng, Our culture hos changed; we ore more and more influenced by the college and by the "wet" side," "l'd like to see us play up the Western way ol life. I see us appealing to the city dwellers who Jind the country lile appealing." 7z0r9 Research and Discovery: Executive lnterviews Learnings Audiences Ellensburg appeals more to the older visitor. Empty nesters and retirees were called out as frequently seen in the downtown museums, shops and restaurants. At the same time there's a desire to appeal to "young couples" who might corne for the outdoor recreation and stay in town for the beer and live music. This may not be as much age-based, as it is lifestyle-based. There did not seem to be as strong of an appeal to families who might find few activities for children once they have explored all the outdoor recreation options {however, those outdoor options maybe sufficient). There is a general sense that Ellensburg could do more to attract parents of current CWU students and CWU alumni in partnership with the university. Resources Ellensburg has a solid foundation of information for tourists-websites, visitor centers and campaigns to increase awareness of the destination. There is a general desire to take those resources to the next level. The website offers a lot of information, but it could be easier to navigate and provide more trip planning assistance. Consider adding more diverse images on the website and marketing materials to appeal to a diverse audience. Ultimately, a one-stop-shop website approach to area activities and events should be considered, using compelling storytelling rather than a directory-style site. The consensus is that Ellensburg still needs visitor centers to cater to older traveler. The centers need to be "dasily bumped into," either in downtown or near the freeway; they need excellent signage and they need to be open more (particularly during the weekend). While the basics of location and hours are importanf equally important is the visitor experience created at the centers. Success Factors ln order to get community support for the investments needed to take tourism marketing to the next level, leaders need to not only show interim measures of success, such as digital analytics, but also demonstrate a correlation of marketing efforts to business trends or sales data. Successful marketing also will continually strive to better reflect visitor motivations and target efforts to the most receptive audiences. For a complete review of the common themes, nuggets and learnings fron the stakehalder lntervlews, please ga to Appendix A, page 52. City of Eliensburg Flve-Year Tourism Strategic Plan 8 QUOTES OF NOTE "As far as visitors, we seem to see mostly empty nesters . #L o tt ro cti o ns for o ut- of - town guests are the rodeo and the university" Adventure seekers go to Roslyn." "We cater to the older crowd - empty nesters. l'd like to grow the you n ge r ca u p les. P eo ple looking for good beer, good food, outdoor recreation. Somewhere to hike, listen to live music, get a beer." "l'd like to see us do mare with CWU alumni." "ln general, Ellensburg is welcominq to adult alumni and parents. Sometimes there is friction with students and businesses downtown. But a student's bod experience with o downtown business will impact their interest in being a future tourist here." t019 Research and Discovery: Visitor Surveys Visitor Surveys An online visitor survey was emailed to approximately 6,800 people who had attended an Ellensburg event or received a tourism e-newsletter from the Kittitas County Chamber of Commerce. Of these, 521 people responded. lt is important to note that the email list was weighted toward event ticket holders (77%).lr also included Ellensburg residents. The answers of Ellensburg resident were suppressed in reporting results. The event-attendee responses were compared to non-event visitors and little distinction was found between the responses. Learnings The survey provides a window into who visits Ellensburg, for what reasons, and how they perceive the town and its surroundings. This provides guidance into target audience profiles and messaging for the tourism plan. Who visits Ellensburg? r 45-65+ years old. Based on the survey responses, the Age most likely visitor is well-settled in their career, families and life. I I Western Washington residents. More than 57 percent of respondents were frorn Western Washington - 29 percent came frorn King County alone, Upper Middle Class. More than 50 percent of respondents said their household incomes were $100,000 or more. Western Washington respondents reported more people in the 5150,000+ category than other groups. Based on Pew Research categories, the majority of respondent households are upper middle class. a5.3{ l$td rttl St6lr 6i. Visitors' Homes : western wa 3%3% r Central Wa r Other Eastern WA ' Tri-Cities 57% *Spokane r Oregon 15% King Corrnty makes up 29 percent of survey respondents. The county's demographic makeup is different from other Washington state counties in two key areas: ' Medium income 519K a year higher than Washington state. 2LYo of residents are foreign-born Source: DataUSA.io King County Difference City oi Ellensburg Five-Year Tourism Straiegic Plan I2019 Research and Discovery: Visitor Surveys What attracts uisitors? What do they believe Ellensburg offers? r Because of the makeup of the respondents, it wasn't surprising to see people said they came for events. Nearly 37 percent visited for an event with an additional 17 percent calling out the rodeo specifically. The top attractions beyond events were visiting friends and family, having a weekend getaway and visiting CWU. ' When asked how much they agreed or disagreed that Ellensburg had good offerings in these areas, respondents agreed the downtown, events and outdoor recreation were strong attractions. The strongest area of disagreement was family-friendly parks and activities. Dovrntown aEtbiefice, aYtard hlstory (s%l Vlsltlrrg Washlqgton lJnluersl'tv (5"/r) What best describes your reason for visiting? A w€ak€nd ge&away (tL%l Locol event or festiva[ (azz, beer, film or oth€rl) (37%') E[lensburgRodeo lt7%) Vlsftlngfrlen-ds and family: (L8o/o'l Rate how rnuch you agree or disagree tbat you visit Ellensburg for these features? Ernr*terd hrrlvdr ItoYiltdn Ortdogt r.arsrlhn Htar l,trElciem Foo4d.hftr nlitlik StauCr hobtJt p{*t ffi toll th N* 4vh 501t colt w* 80qt eolt fto$ l$ltoiSlyASoe llltr* HuJlsdro lDb|8loo lstronstyolrigrse City of tllensburg Five-Year Tourism Strategic Plan 2019 10 Research and Discovery: Visitor Surveys What do visitors do in Ellensburg? Future plans? r Most respondents stayed overnight in Ellensburg, but a significant number (28 percent) made it a day trip. r Most will return to Ellensburg one to two times in the next L2 months (57 percent). I ln ranking the vacation-worthy features of Ellensburg, respondents ranked visiting shops, museums and galleries in historic downtown at the top list of their, followed by the Ellensburg Rodeo, then Brewfest and beer/wine/cider/whiskey tastings, Ellensburg and Kittitas County offer a vacation-worthy trip. Please rank the following features or activities, starting with the one you are most likely to visit/attend/do {#L) and ending with the one you are least likely to visit/attend/do (#7i i 17.69% 5't 21.387o 3 20.69e 60 a 17.s9% 51 5 11.09% 92 6 8.2'loh 18 5.5204 16 TOTAL 290 SCORE 4-76 2 Vis,iting shops,.museurns a.d gallEries in'historic,{lownlown Eltensburg 62 Etbnsbu.g Rodeo, Spirfi of lhe West Cowboy Galhering and similar actiyities 28.28%13.457o 3S 4326a2 12.76c/o 1|-34o/o 37 30 8.87e/o 14.83%I 1-387o 33 2S0 4-52 Brcwfest,and beer/wino/cider/whiskey tastlngs 20.?4lc 15.527o 13.79% 12.07ya 't6.21% 9.66"/0 284735404559 12.41o/o 36 2S0 4.33 Jazz int'he Valley and otter music eveile 16.21y, 47 13ASYo 39 15.10% 18.620/o 14.83% 14.5t% 8.97% 30 il 43 43 26 2S0 4.17 Kiltitas Counly Fair and sixilar fffnily actlvities 5.17% 19_31% N.@To 16.55%15 56 58 48 20.6goh 13.10% 60 38 290 4-12 5.17% 15 ifking,;bikir€, rodk climbing, rafting and sinlilar mtisities 8,28o/o 12-76'Q1o 1138ah24 37 33 16.55% 18.28Vc 28.62:/0 48 53 83 4j4% 12 290 3:t4 Fhhhg,or huri$ng 4.140h 12 4.14o/o 12 8.28%12.76Yo 37 52.4104 15224 8.28o/o 10.00% 24 29 290 2-36 fiity of Ellensburg f r,re-Year Tourism Strategic Plan 2019 11. Research and Discovery: Visitor Surveys What do visiton thints of Ellensburg? . When asked to share three words that best describe Ellensburg, survey respondents most comrnonly listed off (in this order): 1) Friendly 2l Rodeo 3) Country 4l Relaxing n A word cloud built frorn the most ccrilmon descriptiue wordE used for Ellensburg- The larger the wor*-the more.often it was used- n r When asked how does Ellensburg make them feel, the two most common answers were "Relaxed" and "Welcomed." r Respondents were then asked to choose a statement that best described Ellensburg to them. The question tested how this particulargroup views Ellensburg. Nearly 50 percent chose the description: A quaint small town with a Western heritage. othsr{pt9lst rpeclfy) Ab*ocenpfor thstroatoutdoofs 6% Anlfivldrg wmmunltywhem tlnrdgdsralr f{me cvrator fstlve.. 3Lo/a Aqueintsmalt town wlth eWestern herlta3e 5oo/o Allvctyco{l4r mrnelfthrgpod qht$tc 5o/o Please see Appendlx 8, poge 58, ,or all suwey results, City of Ellensburg Five-Year Tourism Strat€gic Plar2019 12 Current Marl<eting Budget Kittitas County Chamber of Commerce is the destination marketing organization for Ellensburg. Under this contract, tourism marketing and its key components have a budget of $411,680 (2019). This does not include the support LTAC provides to events, signage, capital or strategic planning. This tourism marketing budget is currently allocated in the following way: r Visitor lnformation Center: S152,000 I Website Maintenance: $13,000 r CollateralMaterials:530,000 r Marketing and Advertising; $206,580 August Advertising Snapshot ln August 2019, more than 513,000 was spent in media buying for the following advertising efforts; ilulu VldEo 2EZ;O8s 4.3 M 746,9L5 170,633 400 Foosted po$!5 BoosteiJ posts e-Rer,$5 s7,499-98 s2,508.40 s1,969,g3 s1,149.5 unknown unknown 31,355 958 48 $gs cpnll So.os cpc $0.09 cPc Sr.zo cpc utiknown Google Display Facebook Email Twitter 2L,887 Google Search**** *Media costs only **CPM (Cost Per Mille - or cost per 1,000 ad impressions)*** CPC (Cost Per Click) **+*This was not included in the August analytics report, but is currently running City af Illensburg Five Ye3r Tourisrn Strategic Plan 58 65 MARKETING BUDGET AILOCATION IVisitor lnformation Center lWebsite Maintenance : Collateral Materials s Marketing and Advertising 37% 53% lmpressions/ e-newsletter 0Bens Clicks to website or landing page Channel Budget*E-news sign ups cPMl,*/ CpC*** 20r9 Current Marketing August Social Media SnaPshot MyEllensburg marketing includes posting and maintaining engagement on the following social sites raqebogk Twitter lnstagram Pinterest YouTube v.$l Yes NO No NO 449'46 3,215 1,45O 556 monthly viewers 56,subselibers August Website Sna Pshot Ellensburg tourism marketing efforts largely drive traffic to MyEllensburg.com, where people can learn more about the destination, book a hotel or sign up for the monthly e-newsletter. The following are analytics on the home page itself. 33,348 30,372 7.28 39 seconds 86% Up (positivel City of Ellensburg Five-Year Tourism Strategic Plalr Platform FollowersAdvertising? Trend {Up or down from previous month! New UsersUsers Pages per Visit Average Visit Duration Bounce Rate 2019 1.4 Ellensburg Strategic Tourism Plan 2024-2A24 City of Ellensburg Five-Year Tourism Strategic Plan 1520t9 Ellensburg Tou rism Situation An ideallocation Ellensburg is an ideal location for tourism. lt's central location in the state makes for a convenient meeting place for groups and events, Placed at the crossroads of the state's major east-west and north- south travel corridors, it is two hours or less frorn the major urban centers of Western Washington yet offers a dramatically different environment and pace. Ellensburg has long been an important stop on the l-90 route and serves a large number of travelers who are passing through to other end-points. ln recent years, City tourism efforts have led to a growing awareness of Ellensburg as a destination in and of itself. An authentic experience Ellensburg is not an over touristed destination. lt's historic downtown, city parks, walking trails, restaurants and brewpubs, galleries and museums clearly are community places, not just tourist places. The distinction gives it an authenticity craved by travelers and supports quality offerings to ensure visitors retu rn. Outdoor recreation Ellensburg's sunshine, natural beauty and wide-open spaces translate into a myriad of outdoor opportunities, from team sports to fly fishing, and mountain biking to taking a relaxing walk, These opportunities stand out as high-quality, under-utilized and easy to access. The university advantage The City's population of 20,000+ swells to over 32,000 each fall when students arrive at Central Washington University. CWU has a strong in-state reputation and is known as an affordable place to go to school. Nearly 95 percent of students are from Washington, with a solid third coming from King and Pierce Counties. Thirty-five percent are students of color, which brings diversity to an 84 percent white community. CWU contributes to tourism through family and friend visits to students, returning alumni and a rich calendar of activities and events that draw people to the campus and city. CWU's arts and culture programs benefit the community and visitors alike. A signature event The Ellensburg Rodeo has been bringing the Northwest to Ellensburg for nearly L00 years. The signature event drew 37,000 fans in 2019 (up from 36,000 in 201-8). For many fans, the event is an annualtradition. The prominence of the rodeo over so many years has created a "Western" image of the town that is supported by other activities and facilities, such as the Clymer Museum & Gallery and the Spirit of the West Cowboy Gathering. Festival scene The City of Ellensburg is home to more than 30 festivals and activities that appeal to residents and visitors alike. Some of them focus on music-Jazz in the Valley, Buskers in the Bu rg, etc.-but many are one-of-a- kind like Dachshunds on Parade. These events are a major draw for Ellensburg and substantiate the claim that in Ellensburg, "There's always something going on." City {rf tll€nsburg Five-Yr-.a r Tourism Strale gic Pla n 20L9 i6 Situation, continued The many faces of Ellensburg r Walla Walla has wine, Leavenworth is little Bavaria, Gig Harbor promotes maritime and Mt. Vernon embraces tulips. ' ln stakeholder interviews, leaders frequently stated that Ellensburg didn't have just "one thing." Visitor surveys also showed Ellensburg was viewed differently by different groups. ls it a "Rodeo Town," a "Festival Town," or a "UniversityTown?" I The truth of what visitors experience-Ellensburg's brand-is likely somewhere in between. Right now, this experience is varied and relatively undefined, which can make marketing more difficuh. Challenges today and on the horizon r Ellensburg is often seen as a stop on the way to another destination. Many travelers don't get beyond the gas stations and fast food near l-90, ' CWU students from Western Washington often go home on the weekends ratherthan have friends and family come to visit them in Ellensburg. r Traffic in the Puget Sou nd region is bad and, as the popu lation grows, traffic congestion has extended over Snoqualmie Pass, potentially affecting visitor experiences, Currently travelers still flock overthe pass (notablyto Leavenwcirth and Chelan), buttraffic may be an issue in the future. ' Car ownership rates in Seattle are trending down (currently about L7 percent), especially for those under 35, Because Ellensburg is a road trip destination with no rail or commercial air, the bus or car rental is the only alternative for those without a car. City of Ellensburg Five-Year Tourism Strategic Plan I - 2019 17 Situation, continued SWOT The strategic plan committee helped analyze Ellensburg's strengths, weaknesses, opportunities and threats during a planning retreat. STRENGTHS (+) . Relaxing and welcoming "vibe": No over-tourism; not crowdedr Events and festivalsI Rodeo-western heritager Historic downtownI Authenticexperiences, operator-owned1 Central Washington University eventsr 0utdoor recreation: Affordable and often unique venues for small-to- mediurn size meetings/conferences: Significant ballfield resources for sports tournaments: New boutique hotel wEAKNESSES (-) r Lack of a convention center. No dedicated stafffor recruiting and acting as a liaison for group activities (business or sports)r Limited in-town child-oriented activitiesr Small downtown shopping districtr lnconsistent collaboration between the town and university. lnsufficient wayfinding signs for visitors. Undefined or transitioning brand INTERNAL FACTORS EXTERNAT FACTORS oPPORTUNtTTES (+) r Central, accessible locationr Excellent weather, four seasonst Beautiful natural environment-rivers, valley, nearby mountainsr Central Washington University and its students, family and alumnir Western Washington population growthr Puget 5ound area affluence THREATS (-) r Heavy traffic on Snoqualmie Passt Students commute home oftenr Car-dependentdestinationr Other weekend get-away destinations have stronger "bfands"r ChanBingdemographicsr Changing attitudes toward rodeor Snow on the pass during winter season City of Ellensburg Five-Year Tourism Strategic Plan 2019 18 Plan Framework Goal To support a healthy Ellensburg economy through increased tourism. Vision Centrally located, but otf the beaten path, Ellensburg offers leisure travelers a relaxing escape while providing group travelers (sports/meetings) a convenient, unique location for events.ln Ellensburg visitors experience a welcoming small town where there's always something going on. lts historic downtown provides a year-round attraciion and its scenic surroundings provide opportunities for all forms of outdoor recreation. Strategy Ellensburg willgrow tourism by refining and enhancing its leisure tourism marketing and reaching new audiences through sports and meetings tourism programs. 1. Leisure Tourism. Ellensburg will seek to: a) Better distinguish itself from competing destinations b) Reach a more targeted audience c) lmprove visitor experiences d) Measure success through economig as well as analytic indicators e) Collaborate more closely with Central Washington University and other community partners on targeted audiences or significant celebrations 2. Sports Tourism. Ellensburg will promote its location, the facilities at Rotary Parlg other parklpublic facilities and free- time activities to amateur youth and adult sports event planners in a systernatic and measurable way. Sports tourism will further enhance leisure tourism as people discover Ellensburg. 3. Meetings Tourism, Ellensburg will promote its location, meeting and the town's tourist appeal to meeting planners in a systematic and measurable way. Meetings tourism will enhance leisu re tou rism. Sports and meetings tourism efforts are dependent on additional staffing. While tactics are outlined for both strategies in each year of the five-year workplan, it may be beneficial to stagger the start of sports and meetings work by one year. City of €llensburg Five-Year Tourisrn Strategic Plan DEFINITIONS For the purposes ofthis plan, we will use the following definitions: . A goal is a broad primary outcome. ' A strategy is the approach you take to achieve a goal. r An objective is a measurable step you take to achieve a strategy. r A tactic is a tool you use in pursuing an objective associated with a strategy. 2019 t9 Plan Framework Proof Points {To be adapted tc each audience} r Ellensburg is a great place to meet-close by and centrally located. n lt's a place to relax, unwind and escape the crowds. . The historic downtown offers new discoveries in locally-owned shops, restaurants, pubs, galleries and museums. " There's always something to do in Ellensburg with a rich calendar of events for every interest. : Ellensburg gives you easy access to hundreds of miles of open space, trails and waterways. Funding Assurnptions The tourism plan uses a baseline budget of $461,680 for marketing/advertising, web, collateral and visitor centers in 2020 (2019 funding plus $SO,0O0) which is funded through the Lodging Tax Advisory Committee (LTAC) . Approximately $225,000 of that goes to marketing and advertising, A 5 percent per year growth in LTAC funding could reasonably be expected over the next five years based on earlier growth trends. Tactics that may exceed those funding levels are called out in the following workplan and may require additional funds or new funding sources. . 202O: $+0t,sgo (S225,000 for marketing and advertising) : 2a2L'.5484,764 ($236,250 for marketing and advertising) t 2022: 5500,002 ($248,063 for marketing and advertising) . 2A23: S525,452 {5260,466 for marketing and advertising} : 2A24: S551,725 ($273,489 for marketing and advertising) Other potential funding sources do exist, including the creation of a Tourism lrnprovement District {TlD), which is tourism-business led with participants self-assessing fees for a common goal, The challenge for TlDs and other strategies such as advertising sales in guides or co-promotions with business partners is the time it takes to develop and manage these strategies. Unless the strategy results in substantial funding increases, the time required may not be made up by the revenue increase. Staffing Assumptions Today's staffing levels are not sufficient to expand the tourism effort to sports and meetings. We anticipate that beginning in 2020 the sports tourism effort will require a .5 FTE for outreach and follow up. ln 2021, we expect that the addition of meetings tourism outreach will require another .5 FTE. These can be the same or different people. This is a sales-oriented position that requires someone who can cultivate relationships and be tenacious in follow up. We do assume that the marketing work which supports this outreach can be conducted by the current tourism marketing director position with the outside support of marketing agencies or freelancers. As in other communities where the chamber of commerce is also the destination marketing organization, it is important to dedicate this staff time specifically to tourism work. City of Eilensburg FF;e-Yeal" Tourisnr 5trategic Plan2019 2A Plan Framework lonSrange Cornmurrily Goals Sc*lefiting Tourism ln developing the tourism plan, the strategic plan committee and key stakeholders discussed several long- range goals that go beyond the scope of this plan. These recommendations are important for tourism in the long-term and benefit the community overall. Some of the following are addressed in other city plans or are within the scope of other departments, fl Downtown development. Ellensburg's downtown is a major visitor attraction as well as belng a community gathering place. Efforts should continue to encourage the development of businesses and amenities that serve both visitors and community. The new plaza will be a great improvement for downtown. Continue to strive to create a downtown that is festive every day, not just during events. 2l Transportation. Ellensburg is car-dependent and this has irnplications for attracting travelers who don't own cars or those traveling greater distances. Nearby destinations such as Yakima and Wenatchee have air and train access. Once in Ellensburg, travelers have access to Uber, Lyft and taxi service. However, the service is not always available or reliable. a) Continue work to make private and eventually commercial flights possible into Bowers Field Airport. b) Explore bike or scooter sharing opportunities. c) Expand Central Transit to visitor destinations. 3) lnterchange beautification and signage. Ellensburg's "front door" off l-90 reflects little of the charm and character to be found in the downtown. ln addition to wayfinding signage, it would be beneficial to look at the "curb appeal" of these entrances and implement a plan to make improvements, 4) Development of a conference center. This is a long-term goal that will require a feasibility study. Growth of the rneetings tourism program will help determine the timing of this study. 5l Development of a large-scale recreation center. This long-term goal will require a feasibility study, While it would largely benefit the community, there would be tourisrn benefits as well. 5) Development of a large-scale performance center. This may be done in conjunction with the rec center. The community and university need a larger venue for events that is not weather-dependent. Large events are a major attraction for visitors. City of Eliensburg Five-Year Tourism Strategic Plan 2019 11 Positioning Ellensbu rg to Visitors The research showed Ellensburg is perceived as a relaxing, friendly ruraltown. Visitors agreed with the "western heritage" description and also used the word "country" frequently when describing the town. Ellensburg will always be well-grounded in these roots, but community leaders shared their visions for an evolving community with a growing university influence and strong offering in the arts, craft beverages, outdoor opportunities, festivals and events. The "My Ellensburg" theme has allowed tourism marketing to be something for everyone. lt's time to distinguish Ellensburg from other destinations by adopting a theme that: U Honors the roots and values of the community without a traditional country theme 2l Resonates with visitors. lt olfers what they want ond whot they believe Ellensburg can provide. 3) Differentiates Ellensburg from other visitor destinations What does Ellensburg have that visitors crave? Perceived values, rather than specific offerings, offer a more consistent view of community personality lndependent Authentic Open-hearted FunJoving Slower-paced Strong 0utdoor-loving Free to relax and be yourself Uniquely local experiences to discover Friendly people, social opportunities There's always something to do No crowds, no lines, no pressure Be part of something vibrant, meaningful, memorable Enjoy natural beauty and open spaces City of Ellensburg Five-Year Tourism Strategic Plan Ellensburg Perceived Values Visitor Desires 20L9 77 Positioning Ellensbu rg to Visitors Theme Options 7. Ellensburg-Naturally independent Free to be yourself, free ta discover 2. EllensburgUnfiltered Few crowds, little pretense and more time to savor 3. Ellensburg-Wherelriendsmeet Where no one's o stranger Expanding on the Naturally lndependent Theme Leaning into one of these themes gives Ellensburg a chance to stand out. "Naturally lndependent" reveals a little of Ellensburg values and gives visitors a sense of freedom and escape. Naturally lndependent Ellensburg is a place where independent shops, pubs and restaurants thrive, where people follow their own path and visitors are free to relax and discover new things. What does independent look like? lmagery can be used to convey the values and personality of a destination, Below is a sample mood board that has images that help convey "independent." Ciiy 0f €llensburg Five-Year Tourism Strategic Plan 2019 23 Elle nsbu rg Leisu re Tou rism Work Plan Cily of Ellensburg Firie-Year Touriim ltrategic Plan 20 19 24 Leisu re Tou rism: Goa ls, Strategy Goats Ellensburg will seek to: 1) lncrease number of potential visitors exposed to Ellensburg's tourism message 2l lmprove visitor experiences with wayfinding and visitor center support 3) lncrease hotel bookings and other key indicators of destination marketing impact on tourism- related business Strategy Tourism marketing leads the visitor through the path of dreaming, planning, booking, experiencing and then sharing with others through social media and word-of-mouth, Ellensburg's current tourism marketing program uses most available tools. Taking it to the next level is a matter of strengthening and refining. Above all, Ellensburg needs stronger positioning that sets it apart from competing destinations, The current approach offers something for everyone which isn't memorable. A position - your best face forward - helps potential visitors form immediate impressions, makes advertising creative crisper and attracts targeted visitors. Through the strategic planning work, several possible positioning statements have been identified in this plan. A complete branding effort would be beneficial. Other key priorities for the program over the next five years are to: ' lmprove digital content and visitor experience on owned channels {web and social media) ' Make sure others share your story: social influencers, online travel sites, state travel site r Strengthen advertising by focusing on audiences most likely to visit and A/B test creative to continually improve the approach r Expand key community partnerships to reach specific audiences or celebrate major events. Work plan tactics follow and are more fully outlined in years L-3, with the understanding that market changes, visitor feedback and other factors will influence the evolution of the plan in years 4-5. City of Ellensburg Frve-Year Tourism Strategic Plan Social Media Publicity Visitor social media VisitorWebsite E-newsletter Partners vtc Onsite Advertising Online Tourism Sites VIC Offsite tnformation Partnerships -*!@ DREAM PLAN BOOK EXPERf ENCE/SHAR 2019 iE Leisu re Tou rism : Objectives Measurable Objectives The following olrjectives should be reviewed and revised yearly to adjr:st for marhet conditions, furtding, staffing and otlrer variables.g 2020 202r 2022 2023 2A24 15% over 2019 baseline in months of May, July and Sept. 15% increase over 201.9 baseline for -Reach -Engagement -Followers Track appropriate analytics for platform and establish baseline: -lmpressions -CIR/# Clicks -CPC or CPM -Completion rate (of video or audio) Goal based on budget growth. At least 10% increase over 2A20 5% increase over 2021 10% increase over 2022 5% increase over 2023 Conduct baseline survey. Set goals for t'recommend to a friend" No survey 2% increase over 2020 No survey 2% increase over 2022 Grow hotel bookings as measured by an increase in occupancy rates on the STR Report Goal:ZVo increase over 20t9 Goal:3% increase over 2020 Goal:3% increase Over 2021 Goal:3% increase Over2A22 Gaal:3% increase Over2A73 Establish baseline and goals for retail using Dean Runvan or equivalent report.+ fBD% increase over 2020. TBD% increase over 202L. TBD% increase over 2022. TBD% increase over, 2023. 10% increase over 2020. 5% increase over 2021 10% increase over 2422 57o increase over 2023 t0% increase over 2020 10% increase over 2021 10% increase over 2022 10% increase auer 2023 City of tllerrsburg Five-ye.ri Tourism Straiegic Plan Social Media Digital Advertising Visitor Survey Website 6ookings Sales 2019 76 Leisu re Tourism : Aud ience Primary Audiences 1) Slow Down and Savor ' 45-64 Vrs. . $1oo,ooo+ HH income r King, Pierce, Snohomish Counties Today's typical travelers to Ellensburg are in their mid-40s to mid-60s and come from King County. They like the small-town vibe-friendly, clean and fun. They appreciate freedom lrom traffic, freedom to walk in clean parks, freedom to leave responsibilities behind for a few days. With household incomes between $100,000 and $150,000, they're comfortable but carefulwith money. They seek out Ellensburg events and the downtown for fun and relaxation. Natural beauty and outdoor recreation are a bonus, but not the top draw. They appreciate good food, music and art, but aren't snobs about it. It's not about nostalgia as much as new experiences for travelers in their late-20s to early-40s. They want a crafted experience (and crafted beverages) away from crowded get-aways like Leavenworth and Port Townsend. The outdoors are more important to this group but they too like the festivals and they like to travel with friends. History can attract this group, but they want experiences, ratherthan lectures. Above all, make it shareable on social. This is a diverse and global group. (ln King County 28.7 percent of the population are people of color and 23.6 percent are foreign born. Source: King County webslte) 5econdary Audiences 2l Leave the Crowds Behind : 25-44Vrs. r S75,ooo+ HH income . King, Pierce, Snohomish Counties 3l Blend Business with Leisure (Bleisure) r 25-54yrs. r $loo,ooo HH income . King, Pierce, Snohomish Counties hjffi#ff Business trips blending with leisure are a fast-growing trend, as is the ability to work remotely. ln the Puget Sound area, it is increasingly common for employees to be able to work remotely one or more days a week. The morning commute could take them to Ellensburg for a day of remote work and then an extended weekend of play, City of Ellensbrrrg Fiye-Year Tourism ltrategic Plan L/t0l9 Leisure Tourism: Audience, Messages Seconda ry Audiences, continued 4l Central Washington University Reconnected. Three thousand students graduate from CWU each year, Ellensburg gives alumni a place to come home, reconnect with CWU, and more importantly, with each other. A joint program with the CWU AlumniAssociation would be mutually beneficial. 5) Friends from Afar. Ellensburg is centrally located in the state, but car dependent. The primary audience is just two hours away. Major events such as the rodeo can draw people from four or more hours away, opening up Vancouver BC, Portland and Spokane as drive markets, Travelers to Seattle (lnternational and otherwise) can make a two-hour hop over the pass to explore the distinct geology and culture of the Eastern side of the state, Ellensburg is most likely to reach these travelers through online travel sites and ExperienceWa.com. Leisure Traveler Key Messages r Ellensburg is close to home, but feels like a real escape r lt's a place to relax, unwind away from crowds : There's always something to do in Ellensburg {from the historic downtown to outdoor adventure) City of Fllensburg Five-Year Tourism strategic Plan2019 28 1. Le isu re Tou ris m : 2024 Tactics 2. Illensbrrrg Fasltion anql Creative a) Aelopt a newr more distinctive positioning staternent and strengthen messaging to focus consistently on experiences that underscore that position. l{ "Naturally lndependent" is chssen, for example, feature the things that show an independent spirit-craft breweries, local artisans, places that convey a sense of freedsm. b) Refresh creative. With a new, more distinctive position, Ellensburg will be able to present a more focused image with new creative. Sonre creative could be edited and repurposed. The word game would be retirecl. . A new video commercial will be needed. {May require additional investment.) . Specific campaigns can be developed to reach the audiences described earlier. ci Enlrance video and photo assets to support position. Review Ellensburg's video and photo assets in light of the new positioning statement^ Add to library as needed for new creative. Webshe and Ellensburg App al Refresh the look to match new positioning and creative. b) Adopt a new URL that's more easily searched, such as Ellensburg.com or VisitEllensburg.com. The URL should not be dependent on the advertising tagline or any positioning statement so that won't have to change through the years. A campaign landing page is more appropriate for unique URLs. c) Create content as needed to support the new position. {For exarnple, under dining options, do not list fast food first.) d) Add cantent in "Plan" that provides travel ideas for staying a day, a weekend or a week. e) Ensure there is content to support any partnership work {see below}. f) Oiscuss consolidation of Kittitas County and Ellensburg $avelwebsites with key slakeholders, We recognize this process would take time, but the advantage to travelers of having one site for information would be significaat, The savings of just one site tn update and support versus two also would be financially beneficial to the City and County in the long-run. C) Add Google events and Facebook pixel to the backend of the website for tracking and Facebook targeting h) Retire the existing Ellensburg App. MobilE websites are better information sites than apps unless there is a csncern for losing connectivity. Resurrect the site if there is a better way to "game-ify" the visit to Ellensburg. Visitor Centers and Signage {May require additional i*vestment.} al Continue current visitor information centers but make them more visible. Add significant sign to downtown visitor center. lmprove visitor center sign at Chamber of Commerce location, possibly by using a yard flaglbanner. b) Work to make brick and mortar visitor information centers more welcoming. lmprove ambiance, visitor comfort {consider space, chairs, restrgoms, candy jar, etc.}. c) Add digital information kiosk to downtown visitor infornration center to provide information when the site is not staffed. fi City ol Ellensburg Firre-Year Touri:m Strategic Plan20i9 29 6. Le isu re Tou rism : 2A2A Tactics 4. Visitsr Centers and Signag*, canlinued d) Make the downtown visitor center a festive anchor for downtown giveaways, street performers, seasonal window displays, food trucks and other visitor enrlchment. e) lmprove signage by replacing street banners with larger, more visible banners. () Proceed with the wayfinding sign plan adoption as soon as possible. 5. Visilor Researeh a) Survey 2,500 new visitors {emails captured within the past 2 years). lt's important to ask visitors over time what brought them to Ellensburg, what they liked about their experience and what could be improved. This visitor experience can be measured every other year and a trend established to help the DMO and community understand what's working and what needs to be improved. The first year's survey would establish a baseline. Socia! Ffedia a) Continue to build and implement editorial plan for all social platforms with renewed emphasis on lnstagram. lnstagram is a key source of travel inspiration and the preferred media for travel influencers, which have become some of the most important travel writers of today. To be a competitive destination, Ellensburg needs to strengthen this part sf its social media program while continuing to grow followers on its other social platforms. b) Continue to boost social media posts. Continue a strong cadence of posting and boosting posts on social media. The editorial calendar and posts should be crafted to support Ellensburg's new distinct position. c) Develop lnfluencer Campaign, ldentify top travel social media influencers and invite them to come to Ellensburg to cover one (or more) story angles that fit their profile, Cover their expenses (may include room comps) and have a contract in place as to what is expected of the influencer. lt can be a self-guided tour on their part, but we recommend kicking it off with a hosted meal with the town travel expert. Cross promote resulting posts on Ellensburg social media channels. 8. PublicRy a) Develop 2-3 story angles leveraged from the social media influencer campaign and share them with traditional travel writers, b) Create a media "poker hand" by identifying your top five media targets for the year. Adsertising a) Conduct programmatic digital campaign of at least L2 weeks with four, three-week ftights to run over the course of the late winter to early summer using new video creative. b) Google display and retargeting campaign using new/refreshed creative, Seek to stretch the budget to run late winter to early summer (6 months). c) Facebook advertising campaign to run late winter to early summer. d) Advertising will be expensive in this election year. Streaming video or cable W may not be a cost-effective choice until after the 2020 election. { ity dt l-llensb{rrg fi're-Year Tourism Strategi€ Plan 7 2019 30 Le isu re Tou rism : 2A20 Tactics 9. Advertising,continued a) Join the Washington Tourism Alliance and buy an advertising package that will allow tllensburg more control over its profile page content and enhance its ability to compete for the eyes of out-of-state and international travelers. b) lf budget allows, Google Search (AdWords) can be used for leisure tourism as well as sports tourism, which is mentioned later in the plan, 10. Other Tourism Websites a) Review and enhance Ellensburg's Trip Advisor and Expedia profiles. Add and manage profiles for the Ellensburg Visitor lnformation Center and add Ellensburg, WA as a contributor on the sites as well. Follow all site rules on contributions, b) Hold a Trip Advisor and Expedia tutorialfor local tourism businesses/organizations. c) Enhance presence on ExperienceWa.com, This is one of the main go-to sites for out-of-state, international and cruise travelers. While the state site needs to be updated, it still serves an important role, Cruise travelers embarking from Seattle, international and out-of-state travelers seek out information on this site. 11. E-newsletter ai Refresh the look of the e-newsletter in keeping with the new positioning. b) Consider the following: ' Lead with an image, keeping copy short. r Have a clear call to action and make individual stories sharable, c) Continue to build the email list through website, social and event registration opt-in. di Send newsletter out monthly. 12. Partnerships The Kittitas County Chamber of Commerce partners with many organizations in the region to promote Ellensburg tourism. The strategic planning committee emphasized the importance of collaboration and communications among partners. Significant opportunities also were discussed that offered unique partnering opportunities. Each year one opportunity has been identified that offers special promise for growing tourism. a) ln 2OZA, seek to partner with the Central Washington University Alumni Association to attract Alumni back to CWU and Ellensburg, The Association has existing programs to do this, but these could be enhanced and expanded to either encourage greater participation in a single event or identify alumni benefits that could be gained year-round. This might take the shape of a "DlY CWU Reunion," where smaller groups of friends can create a custom-crafted weekend for their friend groups. (May require additional investment.) b) Establish and lead a quarterly meeting of tourism stakeholders to enhance collaboration and communication. Strategic plan committee rnembers could form the nucleus of this group. City of Eliensburg Five-Y:ar Tnurism Strategic Plan 201S 31 Leisu re Tou rism : 2021 Tactics 1. W*bsite 2" a) lf stakeholders approve, consolidate into a new single EllenshurglKittitas County tourism website" This path benefits website users and offers efficiencies fot website maintenance. {Would requ ire additianal investrnent. } b) lf no new website, seek to: . lmprove navigatlon on existing site ' Enhance maps and guides to become more of a virtual visitor center with additional downloadable content . Create canrpaign-specific landing pages for tracking campaign results. c) Ensure there is content to support any partnership work (see below) Vlsitor Ceilters and Signage a) Deploy a mobile visitor center for Exit 109 and other locations inside and outside of Ellensburg, This vehicle, which would be fully wrapped with a strong promotionaldesign, maps and tnessages, would serve as a traveling visitsr center during busy l-90 weekends, such as Gorge concerts. lt can also be parked near the interstate exits as a mobile billboard and takerr to offsite locations to promote Ellensburg. {May require additieinal investmenl.) Social Media al Continue to build and implement editorial plan for allsocial media channels. b) Continue paid boosting of social posts. c) Host two influencer campaigns to cover Ellensburg in two seasons. d) Explore Augmented Reality (AR) Filters fsr social platforms. Create and Bromote in conjunction with rnajor campaign tpossibly the annual partnership project). e) Explore new social media platforms. Social rnedia is constantly changing, lt's important to continually review and refresh the social media plan. Publicity ai Leverage story angles developed for the influencer carnpaigns and pitch to tradiiionaltravel writers. 3. Advertising a) Conduct programmatic digitalvideo eampaign of at least 12 weeks with four, three-week flights run during late winter to early summer. b) Fxtend video campaign as budget allows to streaming video or cable TV. ci Google display and retargeting canrpaign. Seek to stretch the budget to run late winter to late summer (6 months). d) facebook advertising campaign to run late winter to early summer. e) Google Search ads for leisure tourism as well as sports tourism. f) Experiencewa.comadvertising. City of Ellensburg flie-Year Tourism Strattgic Plan 4. 5. 2019 JI Le isu re Tou rism : 2O2l_ Tactics 6. OnlineTourismsites a) Review and update Ellensburg's Trip Advisor and Expedia profiles. b) Explore other travel sites to assess value of enhancing listings there. 7. E-*ewslett*r a) Continue to build the email list through website, social and event registration opt-in. b) Consider adding a one-question survey to each story, ,,Was this helpful?,, 8. Partnerships a) Explore partnership with Ellensburg Parks and Recreation to encourage visitor use of parks and ballfields. Celebration of national "Walk in the Park" day provides a gtod hook to get visitors to explore Ellensburg's spacious, clean and SAFE parks. Beyond that,lt can expose uisitors to the ball fields and support the spo*s tourism effort. {May require additional investment.} City of Ellensburg Five-Year Tourism Strategic Plan 2019 33 Leisu re Iou rism : 2022Tactics 1. Refresh Creative a) Creative {acls of any kind} shoulcl be reviewed each year and major creative, such as videos, should generally be refreshecl every two to three years, {May require additional investment.} 2. Website Development a) Continue normal website maintenance. Ensure there is content to support any partnership work (see below). b) Update campaign landing pages to track results. 3. Visitor Centers and Signage a) Refresh street banners. b) Take mobile visitor center to at least three regional events outside of Ellensburg. c) Use visitor experience survey information to guide improvements to visitor centers. 4" Survey Visitors a) 5urvey 2,500 new visitors (emails captured withirr the past 2 years). Ask the same questions as in the 2020 survey and conrpare results. 5" Social Media a) Re-evaluate social media prograrn to find new opportunities and validate existing approaches, It's important to continually review and refresh the social media plan. b) Continue to build and implenent editorialand boosting plan for best performing platforms. c) Continue to host influencer eampaigns if results continue to be strong. d) Host up to five social media takeovers with industry partners to reach new audiences. 6. Publicity al Leverage the story angles developed for the influencer campaigns and share thern with traditionaltravelwriters. Continue pitching stories to your "poker hand" of media targets. 7. Advertising al Evaluate advertising program and adjust. Refresh creative. b) Likely continue programmatlc digital video, streaming video or cable TV, c) Likely continue Google display and retargeting campaign. d) Likely continue Facebook advertising. el Likely continue Google Search ads for leisure tourisrn as well as sporis tourism f) Experiencewa.comadvertising. B. Online Tourism Sites a) Revielv and enhance Ellensburg's online travel profiles, b) Hold a Trip Advisor and Expedia tutorialfor local businesseslexperiences. See if new online sites should be added to the tutorial,$/31/2a.d ,,".r-.t/?;tlll11ll&o r,-,. 34 Le isu re Tou ri sm : 2022 Tactics 9: E-newsletter a) Refresh look in keeping with advertising creative. b) Continue to build the email list through website, social and event registration opt-in. c) Continue one-question survey to each story, "Was this helpful?" 10. Partnerships a) Explore partnership with Ellensburg Downtown Association to promote comptetion of new plaza/new look for downtown. This could be promotion of a singular event or simply an emphasis on downtown messaging in this year's advertising and social. Explore the possibilities for showing off the new heart of the city. (May require additional ihvestment) City of Ellensburg tive-Year Tourisnt Strategic Plan fi/3t/2fri9 35 L 2, 4. 5 Leisu re Tou rism : 2423 Tactics Website Development a) lf a new, unified website was not created in 2027, by 2023 it will be time to create a new website for the tourism effort. New trends develop and the site wlll become dated. (Would require additional investment.) b) Ensure there is content to support any partnership work (see below) Visitor Centers and Signage a) Take mobile visitor center to at least three regional events outside of Ellensburg. b) Use visitor experience survey information to guide improvements to visitor centers. SocialMedia a) Continue with editorial and boosting plan for best performing platforms. b) Host two influencer campaigns if results continue to be good. Publicity a) Leverage the story angles developed for the influencer campaigns and share them with traditional travel writers. b) Continue adding to "poker hand" of media targets to pitch stories to c) Consider a biannual or quarterly e-newsletter of story ideas to list of travel writers. Advertising a) Evaluate advertising program and adjust. b) Likely continue: r Programmatic digital video, streaming video r Google display and retargeting r Facebook advertising . Google Search ads r Experiencewa.comadvertising, Online Tourism Sites a) Review and enhance Ellensburg's online travel profiles. F-newsletter a) Continue to build the email list through website, social and event registration opt-in. b) Continue or{e-question survey to each story, "Was this helpful?" c) Evaluatefrequencyof newsletter. Partnerships a) Explore partnership with Kittitas County Museum on the 140th celebration of Ellensburg's incorporation. iMay require additional investment.) City of Ellensburg Five-Year Tourism Strategic Plan 6. 8. 9. 2AL9 36 E J le nsb u rg Sports Tou rism Work Plan City of Ellensburg Five-Year Tourisrn Strategic Plan 7Q1_9 39 Le isu re Tou rism : 2024 Tactics 1. Refresh Creative a) Review and consider major refresh of creative based on changes in Ellensburg and the tourism rnarketplace. Because the website was redesigned in 2023, tlrere are likely dJsign and message changes that should be embraced. (May require additionalinvestment) 2. Website Development a) With a new website in 2A23, Year 5 will be spent refining the site and making improvements. 3. Visitor Centers and Signage a) Refresh street banners. b) Take mobile visitor center to at least three regional events outside of Ellensburg. c) Evaluate need for both brick and mortar VlCs based on past surveys and visitor trends. 3. Survey Visitors a) 2,500 new visitors (emails captured within the past 2 years). Ask the same questions as in the 2020 survey and compare results, 4. SocialMedia a) Re-evaluate social media program to find new opportunities and validate existing approaches. Are there new opportunities with new or changing platforms? b) Continue to build and implement editorialand boosting plan for best performing channels. c) Host influencer campaigns if results continue to be good. d) Host social media takeovers with industry partners. 5. Publicity a) Leverage the story angles developed for the influencer campaigns. b) Add to "poker hand" of media targets. c) Continue e-newsletter of story ideas to travel writers. 6, Advertising a) Evaluate advertising program and adjust. Refresh creative. b) Budget and buy media early because of the political campaign year. 7. Online Tourism Sites a) Review and enhance Ellensburg,s online travel profiles. b) Hold a Trip Advisor and Expedia tutorialfor local businesses/experiences, See if new sites should be added to the tutorial. City of Ellensburg Five-Year Tourisrn Strategic Plan 2019 37 8. Leisu re Tourism : z}z4lbctics 9. E-*ermsletter a) Evaluate e-newsletter and determine if it should be continued. Look at number of new subscribers, open rate and results of "one question" surveys. b) lf kept, refresh look in keeping with advertising creative; build lisU continue surveying readers. Consider sending newsletters tailored to specific interests. Partnerships al txplore partnership with Rodeo Association to promote the 100th annlversary of the Ellensburg Bodeo. {May require additisnal investment} City of ellensburg Five-Year Tourls* Strategic Plan20L9 38 Sports Tourism: Goals, Strategy, Objectives Goals Ellensburg will seek to: 1) Grow the number of events booked at Rotary Park, with an emphasis on multi-day events 2t Grow the number of events booked at other Ellensburg facilities/locations that can accommodate sporting events, from long-distance runs to equestrian events. Strategy The Ellensburg Sports Tourism effort requires more than advertising resources, lt requires a dedicated staff member to do sports outreach and follow up. Larger sports markets (Yakima, TriCities) offer additional planning services and this should be considered as Ellensburg's spotls tourism program grows. A number of marketing tools support sports outreach, including development of a sports section on the tourism website. Google Search ads and other promotions will attract leads for sports event bookings. We recommend sports tourisnr staff first attend and then later exhibit at sports conventions like the Pacific Northwest Youth Sports Expo. A sports tourism e-newsletter will provide information and build connections with sports event planners. Measurable Objectives The following measurable objectives should be revised and revised yearly to adjust for market conditions, funding, staffing and other variables. 2020 2027 2022 7023 2024 Add sports content to website and establish a baseline of vlsitors 10% increase in page users over 2020 10% increase over 2A2L 5% increase over 2022 5% increase over 2023 Develop a contact list of 250 targeted planners, coaches and officials. Grow contact list by 100 prospects. Meet with 8 event planners a quarter. Grow contact list by 100 prospects. Meet with 12 event planners a guarter Grow contact list by 75 prospects, Meet with 8-12 event planners a quarter. Grow contact list by 50 prospects, Meet with 6-8 event planners a quarter. Establish baseline of bookings & number of days in use by visltors. Oetermine 2020 gqal. r Grow bookings by to%r Grow days in use r Grow booklngs by 10%t Grow days in use Grow bookings by L0% Grow days in use Grow bookings by 10/o (ifstill capacity) Grow days in use Measure Analytics/ establlsh baseline Grow clicks by LO% Grow clicks by 70% Grow clicks by LO% Grow clicks by 70% I a tI : 'l,i'l sf Illeilsburg Fi.,ie-Year Tou ris;r Strategic Plan Yeat Website Sales teads Eookings Google Search 20 i9 I ,10 Sports Tourism: Target Audiences, Messages Primary Audiences r Leaders of sports leagues and organizations in Washington state ' Coaches, identified through WIAA and other certification programs " SchoolAthleticDirectors ' Sports tournament and sporting event organizers (runs, cycling events, etc.) r Sports camp organizers Secondary Audiences , Families of youth athletes r Adult amateur athletes " Event organizers for lesser-known sports or activities that can make use of the fields or other venues, including equestrian facilities " lndividuals who hunt and fish Which Sports tc Target? Ellensburg currently has underutilized fields in Rotary Park. The first priority will be to target sports that utilize those fields including baseball, softball and soccer. Sports like lacrosse could also be good opportunities for open soccer fields. Targeting must take into account the current capacity of fields and their competitiveness in attracting out-of-town sports visitors. A formal audit by the Parks & Recreation Department or an outside sports consultant can provide more detailed analysis to determine sport "market readiness," Ellensburg also has significant natural resources for running and cycling enthusiasts including trails, country roads and waterways-all of which are relatively free of traffic and offer beautiful surroundings. The disc golf course offers opportunities for play if not for full tournaments. The Kittitas County Event Center offers facilities for equestrian events {assuming the Bloom Pavilion opens late spring 20L9). The greater Ellensburg area offers up blue-ribbon fly fishing, as well as upland bird and large game hunting. While this is a smaller audience who tends to camp, Ellensburg offers a base camp for supplies and entertainment. Sports Tourism Key Messages . Ellensburg is close to home, in the center of Washington r lt's a relaxing place where we make it easy to hold your event ' There's always something to do in Ellensburg (from the historic downtown to outdoor adventure). lt's a fun and safe place for teams and their families outside of the competition. ' lt has easy access to exceptional open space, world-class fishing and upland bird and large game hunting. City of Ellensburg f i\,rerYear lourisnr Strategiij plan2019 {I 1,. Sports Tou rism : 2O2O Tactics 4. €stablish Advisory Group and Fund Sports Tourism Coordinator a) Determine leadership structure of sports promotionaleffort, Current resources suggest a partnership with the chamber leading promotion working in a close, formal partnership with Ellensburg Parks and Recreation. b) Develop advisory group including leaders of sports leagues, businesses and interested community members. c) Hire/dedicate staff to develop sports outreach program and to support tournament planners, coaches, officials and league leaders. (Would require additional investment.) d) Conduct analysis of current facility capacity and competitive position. (How do specific Ellensburg facilities compare to competing facilities?) Set goals for sports event booking. Website Development a) Add content to the tourism website that features sports facilities and support for sporting events, including a calendar of sports events and RFP process, (May require additional investment.) b) Add popup on facility web pages to gain sports event planner emails, c) Enhance content on city website to feature more inforrnation on ball fields and/or to link visitors to resources on the tourism site. Outreach {2020 will be a planning year for oulreach, with proactive outreach starting in 2021) a) Acqulre and use Salesforce for small business or similar CRM management tool. (May require adcJitional investment, althougli the basic CRM tool is relatively inexpensive.) b) Develop outreach lists, identify and prioritize targeted groups and officlals. c) Develop destination packet outlining facilities and benefits of Fllensburg as an event location, d) Become a member of the SportsETA {National Association for Sports Commissions) for sports tourism educalion and resources anel evaluate other mernberships. License use of SportsETA Event lmpact Calculator to get credible economic impact number$ for Ellensburg events" e) Attend the Pacific Northwest Youth Sports Expo to research market and make connections. SocialMedia 2 3. a) Elevate sports and tournaments in your generaltourism social media editorial plan. Ensure that it is part of the organic and boosting mix. Develop a sports hashtag. 5. Publicity a) lnclude unique sports angles into generaltourism story mix. RC Scale Hydro Racing would be one to include in this mix. b) Send out end-of-year news release on sports event economic impact to the community. City ci Eilensburg Fi're-Year Tourism Stlategic Plarr 2019 42 6. 7 8. Sports Tou rism : 2020 Tactics Advertising a) 9ogFl.lgtl.h campaign (Google AdWords)for key words/phrases such as "sports facilities," "ball fields," "practice fields" and "soccer fields,,, E-newsletter a) Create a twice-yearly e-newsletter for an opt-in list from website and from collected emails of sports event planners, league leaders, officials, coaches and school athletic directors. Partnerships a) Partner with Ellensburg Parks and Recreation, Kittitas County Events Center, Washington Horse Park and other local sports venues and businesses (possibly including CWU) to cross-lromote content on website, e-newsletter and social media. {May require an additlonalinvesiment in staff time for necessary collaboration.! City of Ellensburg Five-Vear Tourism Strateglc plan2gl9 43 Sports Tourism:2A21 Work Outline 1.. Aelvisory €roup and Sports Tonrisrn Coordinator a) Determine if support is needed beyond connecting planners to facilities to make Ellensburg more competitive as a sports event location. Consider expanded support to enhance or provide the following: {Would require adclilional investnrent.) r Guided site visits ancl tours ' Local volunteer recruitment . Grant programs to encourage hosting events in Ellensburg . Transportation assistance (arrange for shuttles to and from hotels, etc.) 2. Website Oevelopmenl a) Maintain and improve sports contents. b! Developing arrd post a Sports Evq$t Pbnfiins 6uide on the website. {Would require addilional investment.) 3. Outreach a) Begin proactive outreaclr. Make cannectiorts with and offer tours to officials from targeted groups, tracking contacts in Salesforce. Track leads, eontacts and field reservatiotts, b) Continue assoeiation memberships. c) Exhlbit at Pacific Northwest Youth Sports Expc ancl evaluate other trade show opportunities. Develop trade show booth/materials for exhibition. 4. SacialMedia a) Assess neerJ/ability to manage a separate Facebook aeco$nt for sports. b) lnclude organic and boosted posts as part of overallsociat media editorial plan. 5. Fublicity a) lnclude unique sports angles into generaltourism story mix, {RC Scale Hydro Racing for example.) b) Send out end-of-year news release on sports event economic impact to the comnunity. 5. Advertising a) Google Search campaign (Google AdWords) for key words/phrases such as "sports facilities," "ball fields," "practice fields" and "soccer fields." Review Year 1. key word performance. 7 " E-newsletter al Maintaintwice-yearlye-newsletter. 8. Partnerships a) Continue partnerships with all localsports venues. (.ity oi Hilenshurg Firre-Year Tourism Stralegic Plan20L9 44 1. Sports Tou ri sm: 2022 Tactics Adviscry Group and Sports Tourism Coorrjinator a) Review dedicated staff time and determine if it merits a 1.0 FTE. (would require additionalinvestment.) Website Development a) Maintain and improve sports content. Add video to show top sports venues, Outreach a) Continue outreach, lead tracking and management. b] Grow association. membe.rships, looking into running ancl eycling sports. Explore American TrailRunning Association and becoming a featured ,,TraiiTown.i c) Exhibit at Pacific Northwest Youth sports Expo and evaluate other trade show opportunities. Social Media a) create and manage separate Facebook account for sports. Develop annual social mediaeditorialplan. b) lnclude organic and boosted posts, c) Prornote sports facility video on Facebook. Publicity a) lnclude unique sports angles into generaltourism story mix. b) Send out end-of-year news release on sports event economic impact to the community. Advertising a) Assess performance of Google Search over time. lf still performing well, continue. b) Add digital banner ads to be placed in sports-related websites such as: r Washington youth Sports r Washington youth Soccer r Washington lnterscholasticActivities Association I Sports Events Magazine (onlinelweb) r Sports planning Guide (regionally targeted) E-newsletter a) Maintain twice-yearly e-newsletter. consider refreshing the look. b) lf there is enough content,. increase frequency or devote one or two of these e-newslefiers tosports other than those using the ball fields. c) Continue to build email list through website and contacts generated through outreach. Partnerships ai Continue partnerships with all local sports venues, City of €llensburg Five-Year Tourism strategic plan 45 2. 3. 5 6. 4. 7 8. r019 Sports To u ris m : 2A23 Tactics L. Website DeveloPment a) Maintain sports content. 3. Ouireach a) Continue outreach, lead tracking and management. b) Continue association memberships and tradeshow outreach' 4. Social Media a) Continue posting and boosting to Ellensburg Sports Facebook' 5. Publicity a) lnclude unique sports angles into generaltourism story mix' b) Send out end-of-year news release on sport event economic impact to the communlty' 6. Advertising a) Assess Google Search and digital display advertising. lf performing well, continue. 1. E-newsletter a) Maintaine-newsletter. 8. PartnershiPs a) Continue partnerships with local sports venues, Sports Tourism | 2024 Tactics l. WebsiteDeveloPrnent a) Maintain spo,ts content. 3. Outreach a) Continue outreach, lead tracking and management. 4. SocialMedia a) Continue posting and boosting on Ellensburg Sports Facebook' 5. Publicity a) lnclude unique sports angles into generaltourism story mix' b) Send out end-of-year news release on sport event economic impact to the community 6. Advertising a) Assess Google Search and Digital Display advertising. lf performing well, continue. E-newsleKer a) Maintain e-newsletter. Partnerships a) Continue partnerships with local sports venues. City of Ellensburg Five-Year Tourism Strat€gic Plan 7 8. !Lt1S 45 El lensbu rg Meetings Tou rism Work Plan '.i .: I .J;,, ' , rt1 City ol Ellensburg Five-Year Tourism Strategic Plan tnlo 47 Meetings Tourism : Goa ls, Strategy, Objectives Goals Ellensbu rg will seek to: 1) lncrease Ellensburg's reputation as a centrally-located, affordable and fun place for meetings. 2l Grow the number of small- and moderate-sized (200-person or less) professional, business and group meetings and conferences held in Ellensburg. Strategy Ellensburg meetings tourism requires dedicated staff time and close collaboration with locaI meeting venues. Because the work is similar, one person may be tasked with outreach for both meetings and sports tourism depending on the booking goals set in each area. lt will be essentialfor an advisory committee of local venues to develop the booking goals for the program and a universal approach for lead sharing and follow up. The meetings sales staff member will reach out to meeting planners, connect them to localfacilities and to provide follow up to ensure a positive experience. A number of marketing tools \)vill be deployed to support the outreach effort, including a significant enhancement of the website and adding listings to online venue search tools. An e-newsletter will be used to share more information and build connections with these prospects. Measurable Objectives The following measurable objectives should be reviewed and revised yearly to adjust for market conditions, funding, staffing and other variables, 2020 Planning year, Measure succe$ by X) fundlng staff 2) creating advlsory group and 3l determhini booking goals and a lead rharing and follow up approach. 2A2t Add content/ establish page visitor baseline za22 1095 increase over 2020 2023 tA% increase over 2021 2024 tSVc increase over 2022 r Create contact list of 250 prospectsr Meet with 1&12 new leads a guarter r Establish baseline of # of proposals r Determine 2O21, goal I Establish baseline of nonjocal meetlngsI Determine 2O21 goal r Growbookings bv5% . Grow bookings bv5% r Grow contact llst by 100 prospectsI Meet with 10-12 new leads a guarter r Grow contact list by 100 prospects. Meet with 10-12 new leads a quarter r Grow contact llst by 100 prospectsr Meet wlth 10-12 new leads a quarter r Grow number of proposals byLAY" . Grow numher of proposals submltted by s% r Grow number of proposals by5% r 6rowbooklngs by 10% I None r Establish basellne Grow clicks by LA% Grow cllck by City of Fllensburg Five-Year'fourism Strategic Plan Year Website Sales leads Proposals Bookings Advertising 2019 t ts9,, 48 Meeting Tourism : Iarget Audiences, Messages Primary Audiences . Professional meeting planners - lnternational Live Events Association - Meeting Professionals lnternational - 'National Association for Catering and Events - Professional Convention ManagementAssociation r Washington state agencies . Washington associations - Washington Society of Association Executives . Executive administrative assistants from larger organizations (public and private) - lnternational Association of Administrative Professionals Pacific NW Region r Church, scttool and special interest organizations Targef Markets Target markets for Ellensburg meetings tourism are dependent on drive times. For a one-day meeting, the target maiket would likely be no more than two hours away. For meetings with overnight stays, this could expand to about four hours. Ellensburg's competition as Washington's central location is Yakima and Wenatchee, both of which have convention centers and are served by airports. lts location advantage is its proximity to Snoqualmie Pass and l-90, Meeting Tourisrn Key Messages I Ellensburg is close to home, in the center of Washington r €llensburg offers affordable, interesting meeting spaces r Oul cornmunity is friendly--our venues are easy to work with . There'.s always something to do in Ellensburg (from the historic downtown to outdoor adventure). lt's a fun and safe place for meeting participants to relax and enjoy. City ol Ellensburg Five-Year Tourism Strategis Plan?0L9 49 M eeti ng Tou rism : 2020 Tactics 2020 is a Planning Year The Ellensburg meeting tourism program will take time to establish, especially given the additionalwork undertaken for sports and leisure tourism. We anticipate that 2020 will be a year of planning, with the actualwork effort not beginning until 202L. 1- Fund Meeting Tourism Coordinator and Establish Advisory Group a) Fund staff to develop meeting tourism outreach and promotional effort. The outreach work is a good match for the staff person doing sports tourism outreach. (Would require additional investment.) b) Develop advisory group of representatives of main event facilities and develop process for collaboration. This should include outlining the approach for responding to meeting RFPs and sharing leads that come in through the meetings tourism coordinator. 2. tusess, Establish 6oals a) Establish baseline for number of meetings of outside groups currently being hosted in Ellensburg in key meeting facilities. Establish goals for growth. b) Conduct an assessrnent of Ellensburg meeting facilities and a competitive analysis of similar meeting destinations. c) Finalize the RFP response process and communicate to the Ellensburg meeting venue stakeholders. City of tllerirburg Five-Year Tourism Strategic Plan 2019 50 2 Meeti ng Tou rism : 2021- Tactics Website Development a) Add content to the tourism website that features meeting venue assets and support availahle for meetings (from catering contacts to free-time excursions to potential shuttle buses). {May require additional investment.i b) Add a pop up on the meetings page to gain event planner emails. c) Add short meeting venue content on Chamber of Commerce website and link to meetings tourism page. Outreach a) Sign up for and monitor sources for governmental RFPs for meeting facilities. b) Develop rneeting planner guide (brochure of location and venue assets). lnclude facility descriptions and diagrams. {May require additional inveslment} c) Develop outreach plan, identify and prioritize targeted meeting planners, administrative assistants, association leaders, etc. Create list of prospects. d) Evaluate association memberships that offer most potential to connect with prospects. e) Connect with and offer information or tours to meeting planners. Use CRM management tool adopted already for sports tourism lead management. r Conduct a short "awareness survey" of your contact list as a meaningful way to interact with them and get valuable insight into what they need for meetings and what they know about Ellensburg, f) Attend NW Events Show to gain experience and exposure, Assess other conferences for future exhibiting. Social Media a) Develop an Ellensburg Meetings Linkedln page, Content should be similar to web page. Create and follow a meetings editorial calendar to ensure fresh content is posted regularly. b) lnclude welcome post to groups meeting in Ellensburg on general tourism social platforms as part of overall social media editorial plan. Online Venue Sites L 4. 3 5. a) ln collaboration with local event venues, add their information to online meeting venue sites such as: EventUp, UniqueVenues, Meetingo, NW Meeting & Events, etc. b) Develop a calendar for reviewing and updating site listings. E-newsletter a) Launch first issue of a twice-yearly events e-newsletter to prospects list. Feature different venues, caterers, free-time activities and more. t.ity of Ellensburg Five-Year Tourrsm Strategic Plan ?avJ 51 L. 2. Meeti ng Tou rism : 2022 Tactics Website Development a) Maintain and enhance meetings page. 0utreach a) Monitor sources for governmental RFPs for meeting facilities. Respond to or facilitate respond to appropriate meeting RFPs. b) Maintain and add to prospect list. c) Connect with and offer information or tours to meeting planners. d) Attend Pacific Northwest lnternational Administrative Assistants Conference and Washington Society of Association Executives Conference (or others as evaluatedi. e) Survey meeting planners who hold events in Ellensburg. Share the results with venues, Social Media a) Maintain Linkedln page. b) lnclude welcome post to groups meeting in Ellensburg on generaltourism social platforms, ci Explore custom Augmented Reality filters for Facebook and Snapchat with an Ellensburg geofence to allow participants to brand meeting photos in an Ellensburg-centric way, Publicity a) Seek a story in Northwest Meetings and Events Magazine or other trade publications highlighting Ellensburg's unique venues including boutique hotelor describe how the downtown was turned into a "conference cenler." b) Leverage story in in all owned channels - social, web, e-newsletter c) Send local press release on economic impact of meetings and on major events booked for the year. Online Venue Sites a) Continue to add content to online meeting venue sites. Advertising a) lf booking goals merit it, consider Google Search campaign (Google AdWords) and Linkedln advertising E-newsletter a) Produce twice-yearlye-newsletter, b) Reach out to advisory grou p for news - give them space to place their top stories. Citv of Ellensburg Five-Year lourism Strategjc Plan 4. 5. 6. 7 8. 20L9 52 1. 2 Meeting Tou rism : 2023 Tactics Website Development a) Maintain and enhance meetings page. 0utreach a) Monitor sources for governmental RFPs for meeting facilities. Respond to or facilitate respond to appropriate meeting RFPs. b) Maintain and add to prospect list. c) Connect with and offer information or tours to meeting planners. d) Exhibit at either the Pacific Northwest lnternationalAdministrative Assistants Conference or the Washington Society of Association Executives Conference (or other evaluated conference) e) Host "Road Show" destination dinner. Go to a key meetings market and host a dinner and destination discussion for meeting planners. Make it fun and on-brand. f) Survey meeting planners who hold events in Ellensburg. Share the results with venues. Social Media a) Maintain Linkedln page, b) lnclude welcome post to groups meeting in Ellensburg on generaltourisrn social platforms. PubliciE a) Send local press release on economic impact of meetings and on major events booked for the year. Online Venue Sites a) Continue to add content to online meeting venue sites. Advertising a) lf booking goals merit it, consider Google Search campaign (Google AdWords) and linkedln advertising b) lf needed, consider adding regional advertising package in Northwest Meetings and Events E-newsletter a) Producetwice-yearlye-newsletter b) Reach out to advisory group for news - give them space to place their top stories. City of Ellensbrrrg Five-Year Tourism Strategic Plan 4. 5. 6. 7 8 2019 53 t. 2. Meeting Tourism:2024 Work Outline Website Development a) Maintain and enhance meetings page. Outreach a) Monitor sources for governmental RFPs for meeting facilities. Respond to or facilitate response to apprgpriate meeting RFPs. b) Maintain and add to prospect list. c) Connect with and offer information or tours to meeting planners. d) Consider exhibiting at either anothertargeted conference. e) Host "Road Show" destination dinner. Go to a key meetings market (different from 2023) and host a dinner and destination discussion for meeting planners. Make it fun and on-brand. f) Survey meeting planners who hold events in Ellensburg, Share the results with venues. Social Media a) Maintain Linkedln page. b) lnclude welcome post to groups meeting in Ellensburg on general tourisrn social platforms. Publicity a) Send local press release on economic impact of meetings and on major events booked for the year. Online Venue Sites a) Continue to add content to online meeting venue sites. Publicity a) Seek a story in Northwest Meetings and Events Magazine or other trade publications, b) Leverage story in in all owned channels - social, web, e-newsletter Advertising a) lf booking goals merit it, consider Google Search campaign {Google AdWords) and Linkedln advertising b) lf needed, consider adding regional advertising package in Northwest Meetings and Events E-newsletter a) Produce twice-yearlye-newsletter b) Reach out to advisory group for news - give them space to place their top stories. City of Ellensburg Five-Year Tourirm Strategic Plan 4. 5 6 7 8. 9. 2-0r.9 54 Appendices Research Resu lts l: Ciiy of Eliensburg Fiv.. Year l-or.:rjsm ifiatrgic irla:l 2019 55 Appendix A: Executive lnterviews Executive interviews JayRay staff spent a half hour or more talking about tourism with each of the following leaders in the Ellensburg community. Questions focused on these key areas; goals, positioning, audiences, resources and success factors, Amy McGuffin, CEO, Kittitas County Chamber Nicole Klauss, Ellensburg City Council Member and ITAC Chair Molly Jones, Director, Ellensburg Downtown Association Carolyn Honeycutt, Ellensbu rg Economic Development Manager Teri Olin, Marketing Manager, Central Washington University Matt Anderson, General Manager, Holiday lnn Express and LTAC Member Carla Jellum, PhD, Tourism and Hospitality, Central Washington University Kady Porterfield, Director, Kittitas County Events Center Laura Osiadacz, County Council Member, Kittitas County Monica Miller, Executive Director, Gallery One Brad Case, Director, Ellensburg Parks and Recreation Jeff Leichleiter, Marketing Manager, Ellensburg Rodeo Jared Vallejo, Director of Marketing, lron Horse Brewery Brad Fitterer, Owner, Fitterer's Furniture Sadie Thayer, Director, Kittitas County Museum Steve Townsend, Owner, Hotel Windrow Ciiy of tllenshurg Five-Year Tourism strategic Plan201-q 56 Append ix A: Executive lnterviews GOALS COMMON THEMES These are the most commonly expressed ideas relsted to these questions. HOW IMPORTANT IS TOURISM? WHAT WOULD YOU LIKE TO SEE HAPPEN IN THE NEXT FIVE YEARS?r Tourism is important and willbecome an increasingly important part of the economyr Grow tourism to help sustain local businesses. Become the destination, not a stop along the way to somewhere else. Align tourism goals with community goalsr Become the place where people from Western Washington go to relax and have fun: Become a destination for regional meetings and conferencesr Become a destination for sports tournamentsr Maintain and grow the rodeo to gain momentum going into the L00th anniversary rodeo in 2023 GOALS QUOTES OF NOTE These are quotes thot express commonly held idess or were especially important ta note. "We need tourists, Residents visit our businesses and make one to three purchases a month-this isn't enough to sustain our businesses." "l'd like to see tourism continue to grow ot a nice poce, as it has." "l don't think we should try to become another Leovenwarth (tourism-dependentt economy)." "WhQt benefits taurists should also benefit the community and makes for a more outhentic experience for the visitor." "l think the community will support more investments in tourism if they can be shown how meetings, sports eventst etc, can bring business to locol restourants and stores." 'l think the community is divided on bringing more people into town." "There's o large group (of residents) that says (CWU) students are ruining our town." POSITIONING COMMON THEMES These are the most commonly expressed ideas related to these questions WHAT IS ELTENSBURG KNOWN FOR?r W€'re in the center of everything {and a shorter trip from Western WA than Walla Walla)r "There's always something going on" (events and festivals)r Good weatherr We don't have a fixed imager Smalltown feel: Relaxed and welcoming: Outdoor recreation, the sceneryr Quiet little ranching and college townr The rodeo and Western heritage -"A touch of the West" City of Eilensburg Five-Year Tourism Strategic Plan 21119 tt Appendix A: Executive lnterviews FOSMOilING CCMMCN THEMES 'fhese srr the m*st conmonly expressed ideos reloted to these questians. HOW DOES IT STAND OUT FROM OTHER WEEKEND DESTINATIONS? ' Festivals and eventsr Music...maybe (between festivals, events, live music downtown and CWU's program) r Craft beer and other adult beverages...mayber Yakima River and trout fishing ' We have miles of walking and biking trails; you don't have to be an athlete to enjoy the outdoors. (The rodeo and Western heritage was not called out here, although it was mentioned in what is Ellensburg known for.) WHAT WOULD YOU LIKE ELLENSBURG TO BE KNOWN FOR?r Festivals and eventsI Westeril way of lifer Music. (Festivals, events, live music downtown and CWU's program)r Beer. "Maybe we're an upcoming beer,iazz, music town?". Art. Ellensburg is affordable and friendly to artists, so there's a growing presence.r Leisure. A place to get away from work.r Ecotravel: fly fishing, hiking, biking and other back-to-nature outdoor recreation ' : A step back to the past. "For me Ellensburg is about history, art and recreation. Being a historical place is not just about buildings and landmarks, it's about preserving the community, its culture and sharing that with others." POSITIONIRI€ QUOTTS OF NOTE The.se are quotes thol express camr*only hekl ideas ar we{e especially impartant to note. "l don't want Ellensburg to be known for onything different than who we ore/what we have todayi' "Ellensburg's strengths and distinctions are that it is in a sweet spot. lt isn't crowded, i(s not too expensive it's essy to park, has reosonohly good weother, and has greot outdoor activities." "Unlike Leovenworth or Winthrop, the activities chonge so there's a reason to come bock. That's o reoccurring theme I hear from people who come fram out of town; we always have some fun octivity going on," "You can't hove festivals all the time, but you can have a festive atmosphere oll the time. Ellensburg shoutd hove more street vendors ond the city needs to help make that hoppeni' "Cen?ralhss a welt-known music pragram. Euslnesses bring in music. We hsve Jazz in the V*lley and Euskers in the Burg. The Gorge is close." 'l'm not sure people here would ugree on one thing, unless eyents is our thing." "l'd like to see us play up the Western way of life. Leavenworth did Bavarian, we should do Western. I see us appeol,hg to the city dwellers who find the country life appealing." "The rodeo is still very importdnt, but the western theme for Ellensburg is waning. Our culture has changed; we ctre more and more intluenced by the College and by the "wet" side." "Aan't hong our hats on it (the rodeo)...someday soon the treatment of animdk in s rodeo may be recognized os not a good thing to do," City oi tllensburg Five-Year Tourism Strategir: Pian2C] g 58 Appendix A: Executive lnterviews POSITIONING QUOTES OF NOTE, CONTINUED These are quotes thot express commanly hekl iclaas ar were especially impartant to note. "A place to exptore/ploy; known lar leisure." "We have o mlle stretch of Yoklmo River within wolking distance of downtown." "The Yokimo River and trout fishing are certainly attractions that con grow." "Hundreds of miles of bike and hiking troils connectto Ellensburg. One of our main focuses is to improve wotking paths and trails.' "We're a universitv lq lot of young peaple and diversity adds to a feeling of vitality.' "Our ties to CWU offer a lot to the community, but we're not qcolleee town." AUDIENCE COMMON THEMES These $re the most camrnanly expressEtl ideos related to fhese questions. WHATTYPE OF TOURISM WOULD YOU TIKE TO SEE GROW? WHO DO YOU WANT TO ATTRACT TO ELLENSBURG?I The West side is our best source of touristsr Meetings and conferences, but we really need a conference center. We can host small groups of up to 200r Sports teams-youth and adult. May require facility improvement and staffingr We want to attract people with disposable income, highly-educated, recently retired and interested in the artsr Downtown audience is empty nestersi they have the freedom and money to travel, Adult leisure travelers ' Millennials who are looking for cool and sharable experiencesr Ellensburg lacks family-friendly amenities AUDIENCE QUOTES OF NOTE These ore quotes that express commanly held ideas or were especially importont to note. "As far as visitors, we seem to see mostly empty nesters . #L ottroctions for out-of-town guests ore the rodeo and the university, Adventure seekers go to Roslyn - Ellensburg isn't their destinution." 'oWe cater to the alder crowd - empty nesters. I'd like to grow the younger couples. Peopte looking for good beer, good food, autdoor recreation. Somewhere to hike, listen to live music, get a beer." "l'd like to see us da more with CWU olumni." "We con ottractJamilies through othletics, butthey alwoys osN 'What da you do here?' We don't hove a lot of family activlty options." "Explorers, odventure seekers...they have more disposable income thon families," "ln general, Ellensburg is welcoming to odult alumni and parents. Sometimes there is friction with students and businesses downtown. But a student's bad experience with a downtown business will impact their interest in being a future tourist here." City of Ellensburg Five-Ye"rr Tourissr Strategic Plan zA13 59 Appendix A: Executive lnterviews RESOURCEs COMMON THEMES These are the *ost cammonly expressed ideas related ta these rtruestions. WHAT ARE YOUR OVERALL IMPRESSIONS OF MYELLENSBURG,COM AND OTHER LOCAL TOURTSM SITE5? WHAT ARE YOUR THOUGHTS ON THE CURRENT MARKETING CAMPAIGN?. MyEllensburg does a good job of making Ellensburg appealing/very outdoorsyr Various websites contain a lot of inforrnation, but there's no one place for visitors to get all local information {And, no place for local event planners to consult for what's happening on specific dates.} . MyEllensburg website and campaign do not show diversityr Website doesn't offer any information for meeting plannersr ls there too much information on the website?r There's not a lot of curated trip planning on the website WHAT WORKS AND WHAT IS MISSING ATTHE PHY5ICAI- VISITOR CENTERS?. A downtown visitor center is beneficial, but only if it is open more hours, Shared/co-located Ellensburg and CWU visitor center presence. A visitor center/information kiosk at Exit 109r Current chamber location distant from downtown shops and needs "Visitor Center" specific signs Rrs0u8ces QLroTfS 0r NOTE These are quofes 2hat express commonly held itteas ar were espeeiolly impartant to nate. "Marketfng compaigns can come and go, but the website should be consistent. I seqrch on "visit" when Iooking for ploces to go, so l'm used to going to Visitseattle.org or TravelPortlond.cam. The IJRL is very simple and it just says what it is. When I Google 'Visit Ellensburg' I get a bunch of different sites." "Most people that come to the visitor center wsnt the poper form. Five years from now, it'd be greot to see a digitol visitor directory in high trafficked oreas in town." "Consider on olumni office in Downtown Ellensburg, Peaple come over on the weekend and the office at the college is closed. Freshmen students often don't like Ellensburg because there's nothing for them to do, but by the tirne they are seniors the love it here. They hove to leave for jobs, but they like coming bock," "How great would it be to encourage/invite residents to go to our visitor centers? (This would show the community thot we're here for you first, then visitors-and get their opinions on the experience, what there is to do, so they con better promote and invite friends and family taa)." "Hoving a visitor center in downtown is great, butthere needs to be better signage and hours." "Woyfinding around Ellensburg is still a problem. We were recently in Bend Oregon and they hove o fantastic visitor center with a lot of information and local flovor. (lt is on extension of the Place to Play theme ond offers o lounge.)" "There moy still be a generotion of tourists who use visitor centers, but I hove never personally gone into one. I think as times chonge, we have to change what we offer." "We are doing a much better job af telling stories. Good videos that are really popular inside and outside of Ellensburg," "Love the video on the web; don't love the word game theme." City of €llensburg Five-Year lcr"rrisrn Strategic Plan2019 60 Appendix A: Executive lnterviews L.ASTTHOUGHTS QUOTES OF NOTE These are quotes thot express commonly held ideas or were especially inportantto note. These flnal thoughts did nat fit any particulor mtegory. "Growing Ellensburg ds sn events destinotian will require coordination of schedules." "Using the Kittitas County Events Center for meetings is complicoted by the lock of hotels in walking distance and lock of tronsit to the site." (And potentially lack of ovailobility?) "We have 86 nonprofits in Ellensburg competing against ane another. l'd like to see all orgonizatlons warking together...we all have the some gools." '"The biggest thing is to be just weird enough to spork curiosity. For example, we'te o tight group of conse rv otiv es wlth I i b e ro I co I I eg e stu de nts." "The Upper and Lower Volley mentolity divides us." "Ellensburg needs to stop fighting with CWlJ." "We need a convention center!" "We're missing a connection to the Columbio River, whiclt is close snd offers mare recreational opportunities." "We need to use lodging tqx dollars to getthe biggest bang tor the buck. We have another hotel coming in two years that will grow the pot ol LTAC dallars. Haw daes the city best use that money?" City of Ellensburg Five-Year Tourism Strategic Plan2019 61 Appendix B: Visitor Surveys Ellensbutg Toruism Q1 Which of the following best describes your reason for visiting Ellensburg and Kittitas County? Visiting Washlngf,or Unlverslty A we€kend getaway Ettensb0rg Rodeo At'lstrER cH{xcEs Local e!€nt or festivel liear, beer, lilm ot oth€r!) Visiting'frlends and family Blensburg Rodeo Aweekend getaway Visiting Central Washi ngton University Downtown arnbiance, ad and history A base camp for oddoor ad\,enture Bitshess m€eting or confetence Sportirg eYent llive here Olher (please sp€cify) TOTAL Downtot\rn ambiance, art and history Answered:407 Skipped:O Vlsiting friends and family City oi Ellensburg Five-Year Tourism Strategic Plan Local event or festiva[ {jazz, bser, fiirn or otherl) nesp6xsrs 36.867c 17.69V" 16.9SYo 11.S0% 5-410/" 4.67% 3.6S% 3.18% 0.25Vo 0.00% 0,00% 150 12 69 46 19 15 13 1 0 0 4oit 2019 67 Appendix B: Visitor Surveys Ellensburg Tourism Q2 Before or during your trip, which of the following information sites to learn more about Ellensburg? (Select up to three) AGwered:2S Skippod: 111 MyEtlensbrrg,co centr*ul|shingt olColor.eom (}dlne review site... Chrmber of Commarce City of Ellensblgg centrrl lJ[ashlngton..; Ail$WEFCSOiCES MyElloosburgrcom Cff lt.allwashi ngtff Colo r.eom Online review site (TripAdvisor, Yelp) Gh6fiber ol'C\ommerce City of Ellensburg Cenhal Yvashington University Iotal Respo.rder{$296 I $'lit$*.9i1gP;1 m O% 19?A 20% 3Q9o 40Po 50!6 60% |Vh BOo/c gODh 1OO9/" RESFOIISES 46.S6% 4.3970 34.12% 25.34o/o 25.73% 22.97% City of Ellensburg Five-Year Tourism 5trategic Plan 139 'ts I01 75 88 58 :i:!:-' j.: ',' 2t19 63 Appendix B: Visitor Surveys Ellensburg lburism Q3 lf you came for the Rodeo - thank you! - and please share which is your favorite event? Ansurored;72 Skippod:355 Brit13 Ertl.rd€ Bt lls e""*ru"iof ffi steerwrastrinff; BrorE ddlhg Bshlnd {he Chtfes6ve-.. ATTISWERGHOICES Eulls Erlreme Bu0s Barrel racing Slearwrestling Bronc riding Behind the Chutos live music saloon TOTF.I. W 109o 20qs 30% 4046 50% 600,6 7U/o ffiVo 90% 100% RE$POiISES 20.8?Yo 27.780/o 8.s3% 6.54% 25.00% 11.111q City of Ellensburg Five-Year Tourisrn Strat€gic plan 15 20 6 5 18 o ?2 201S 64 Appendix B: Visitor Surveys Ellensburg Tourism Q4 lf you attended the rodeo, how often have you gone to this event? Angvrered:71 Skipp€d:336 ,nourrf ?-Stlmeb I or ll'orctirneg tr{ssa€Rcfrorc€s ,F3El liors &3 thttGs 464!roto umos rOTAt 015 10% 20% 30% adf, 507o &?o 70lA 80% 90P/c l0oolo RESFONSE8 19.720/, 21.1!/o 59.15olo City of Ellensburg Five-Year Tourism Strategic Plan 14 15 42 71 2019 65 Appendix B: Visitor Surveys Ellensburg Tourism Q5 What attracts you to the rodeo? (Check up to three) Ansv/er€d:7? Skipped:335 Family svenl tEditbd Excitingrctlon Ym rlde hoisE t6ur9,.. O% 1'0% 20!6 30oJi 40% 50% 800,6 70% 8o'A 9o7o 1oO% AllswERCHO|CES Family evont Weslarn tradilion & cdturo Exciling act'ton . Ybu rire hoBes yourself of neve fefitly rgha do Tolel Raspo&Jents:72 City of Ellensburg Five-Year Tourism Strategic Pian RESPOIISES s2,75% 66"67% 4028T" 27.78o/o 38 48 29 20 7019 66 Appendix B: Visitor Surveys Ellensbulg Tourism QG lf y'ou attended the rodeo this year, what days did you attend. (Check all that apply.) Ansvrered:68 SkiFped:399 Friday $raur&y Eid;w go to tlre pamde o-- A!,ls{lERCH$CS$ F ldat Srlsfilay Sund.y tloaday 0il yrru go to thogarade on $atuday? Ialat Resfrr4litol{s:68 *"*f{,ffiiffiffi.q{ *"r.rmffi {rh 10t6 20% 3096 ,101t 50% 60% 70ui 8096 00% 100i6 RESFONSES 29.41% 76.47% 99.71% 16.18i0/o 26.47o/o City of Ellensburg Five-Y€ar To\rrism Strai€gic Plan 20 52 27 11 IB ?019 67 Appendix B: Visitor Surveys Ellensburg Touiism Q7 lf you stayed for busine$s, please select the option that best describes your visit. Ansrvored: 15 Skipped: 392 contr."n"" I O rga nizatio n retreat Cornp[ny tralnk€ Aiirciitioililrro up r$€clll!! Bu:irgl mestlng Workhgin ElLBrburg Othrr (plea* spffilfy) ffi ANSWER CHOICES Cofferonce Organiration retreat Compmy training Associetionlgroup meotirg Eusiness meeting Working in Ellensbutg Othsr (please specify) TOTAL 0h 10q6 2A% 3O9o Aeh 50% ffin/o TAolo SOdk 9OpA 1O09o RESFOI{SES 6.67% 0.00% 6.67% 20.00% 26-67% 0.00% 40-00.16 City oi Ellensburg Fjve-Year Tourism Slrategic Ptan I I 3 4 0 6 {5 2019 68 Appendix B: Visitor Surveys Ellensburg Tourism Q8 Please ch'eck the reasons Ellensburg was selected as a location for this business event. Ansurored:20 Skipped:987 Central locotlon ir|.., Tie pr?sarce of€entral.., Affordobb cloreto tlestorL, Othcr (dea:a spec{fy} AI{SWSRGI{CfGES Central bcslion in siab Ihe presence sicsnt.sl Wffihingt)n tJnive6ity AJiord*le chss lo westefii wsshiftgtorL but cr,tange dweathor and "pac6'i 0th6r (pleass specify) Total Respondefiis:20 Wo 10ti' 20% 30% 40ji 50f' 6A% 70% 80% 90o6 1o0d/6 RESPOIISES 4A,000/o 15"0070 40.00% 30.00% 25.0V & 3 I 3 City of tllensburg Five-Year Tourism Strategic Plan 2019 59 Appendix B: Visitor Surveys Ellensbug Tourism Qg lf you stayed in Ellensburg for a sporting event, which best describes your visit? Anslirsmd:39 Skipped:368 Attsnddd o youthepon6.- Playod attc'ld€d I fr fi I tnu th... Atrendad a CIUU epofting cvert Attcndd the €lbl6burg.,, Othcr (pleasa rpecify) & loii 20ie 3Ai 4A9 50% tO%' 10'6 80% goti 1609" Altsl/vER 6HOrCEs Altended a yodh sports tournameilt Plsy€d in or altonded ar adull sgorls lournament Atiended a€\,VU sporllng eYent Att€nded lh6 ElhftEburg Rodeo Otfier (please specity) TOTAT City of Ellensburg Five-Year Tourism Strategic Plan RESPONSE$ 5- 13olo 0.00% 2.56% 89.74Vo 2.56% 2 0 1 35 e9 ?019 70 Appendix B: Visitor Surveys Ellensburg Tourism e10 Please check the reasons Ellensburg was selected as a location for this sporting event. Ansvrered:26 SkiPPed:3€ll csntral loBtion in.,. fhc pr:seme ofCentrC.., Affsdable I ffi_w Ctose to Westsr... Other (olcirsG rpecify) ANSWERGHOIC€$ Central bcalion in s{a?e Th6 pr€senes of Cott.alWshingion UniverEity Affordable Chsa ta W63l6tn Wa6hington. bul change ct'irealh. 8nd "pacs" Other (please sPecifY] Total R€sponCents:26 O% 10Yo 2O'lo 30% 40% SOoh @6h TOoh &0/6 90% 1O0% RE$POI{SES 46.19% 11.54T" n.oa% 42.31% 23.O8% 12 3 6 11 6 City o{ Ellensburg Five-Year Tourism 5t€tegic Plan2019 ?{ Appendix B: Visitor Surveys Ellensburg lburism Ql1 How long did you stay in Ellensburg? 8+ dals A,rcwEred: Agg Skipped: 1B Ov€migtrt (two drys) Just for the day (no ovarnight) +7 days 3 days At{gtt FR cHotcEs Jusl for the day {no ovemight) Oy€night gro days) 3 days 4-T days 8+ d8yn TOTAT City of Ellensburg Five-Year Tourism Strategic plan RESPOIISES 27.51e/o ee.qei/" 23.gloh 7.2A% 5.51% 1A7 108 03 ?8 23 3A9 2019 72 Appendix B: Visitor Surveys Ellensburg Tomisrr Q12 How often do you plan on visiting Ellensburg again over the next 12 months? Ansrrrared:389 Skippod: 18 1-2 tlrus 4-Etimes z-,erim*s BIHI{ T&BII l3orrrcr€ ffi Tlrrffia AIiISWERCHOIGES 'l-2lim€s &6 limes 7-12 tim€s 13 or rn0re aimea Unlikely to visit again TOTAL W 1Wo 20% 30?' lAVo 50% @lo 799/c 8O7o 90o 1000/6 RESPOTISES 56-81o/o 21.A8Yo 6.94% 10.540/o 4.63% City of Ellensburg five-Year Tourism Strategic Plan 221 g2 a1 41 18 38S 2019 73 Appendix B: Visitor Surveys Ellensburg Tourisrn Q13 When you think about Ellensburg and the surrounding area,what three words first come to mind? (e.9., When you think of San Franciscan you may think "artsy" whereas New York City you may think "fast.") Ansncrod:329 Skipped:78 On the left results included those attending events/rodeo in Ellensburg. On the right, event/rodeo attendees were excluded, Friendly and Country stay consistent; the only major change is the importance of Rodeo and CWU. F lyn # Times Used 51 34 30 29 25 20 20 18 1.6 16 t2 t2 10 8 5 5 5 Word Friendly Rodeo Country Relaxing Windy Fun SmallTown Western CWU Food Charming Quaint Music Beautiful Family Hiking Welcoming # Times Used 25 L2 tl 10 I 8 8 7 6 5 5 4 4 4 4 4 4 3 Word Friendly CWU Country Food Windy Beautiful Outdoors Charming Fun Quaint Relaxing Western SmallTown Music Good Family Art Sunshine Y n Criy of €llensbrrrg Frrre-Year ToLrism Sirategic Plan 241,9 74 Appendix B: Visitor Surveys Ellensbulg Tourism Q14 How do you feel when you are in Ellensburg? (Select up to two) Answered:329 SkipPfdrTS Ade€nturous f r-iuerat"a ffi a"U*rffi Btrhar'.d n Energized I RCurd Welconted AI'ISWERGHOICES Relaxed Aidvenlorous Liberated curi6us R6chaEed Energized Wolcomed f€tal Re6pondents:329 0% 10% N* 30% 40% 50% @o1o ?Ooia ABolo SVh l00oh RESPO}ISES 75.680/o 17.93o/o 3.04% 9.73% 13.07% s.12% 50.76% City of Ellensburg Fiue-Year Tourism strategic Plan 249 59 10 32 43 30 167 20L9 75 Appendix B: Visitor Surveys Ellensburg Tourism Q15 Which statement best describes Ellensburg to you? An$were&329 Skipped:78 Other {pleaoe speclfy) A base camp for the gyaat outdoors An inviting commultity f,herc tlmto's always sonre event or festlva... A qualnt smalt town Yrhh a Westem hetluge A livelycollage town wlth agood night Ufe Ail8{Gn$lol6Es A q{reirt slrlel loHn wlth a Ufsrlom hsrilrgp A lvdly ootl€go la'rdr tivif) a good night life &l invling mmnunily nrhete &ere's alvray,s sorne event of f€stival lo attend .A bese,carnF fo.15e groet Oddoors Olbor (ple*specify) TOTAI RESPONSES 49.85% 4-560/o 40.70% 6.38% 8,51% City of Ellensburg Five-Year Tourism Strategic Plan 154 15 101 21 28 329 2{}19 76 Appendix B: Visitor Surveys Dllensburg Tourisor Q16 Please rate how much you agree or disagree with the following statements. ANlrrqr: ?58 gkipped: 117 tutdo6 Fanittltiddy 0nit€ed trJieiliF DoM\lorn Eadd6 etrd i6slivals ffuldq), rgsodkln lA.Ba sc€rc Yaklmdcolilflbb Riffi Fed. &ial|r*!ta btu Enqgft h4reb? fiitTr'S:'tliffi'**'xEitt:fii,ffi EMEn hobl.?',"...";;llt.;,.ffii sL IoL 2oL 30* {0{6 30'; 60% 70% 80rt gopd to01s l5tFirlyA|fl |litil gureure STROIIGLY AGREE AGREE IJIiSURE sll3% 26 42.7'n6 19.7S% 6? g51mtrsly oisgrd STROI{GLY DISAGREE ?1.S0% 6S 20.s% 60 '11.03% 7,S6% 23 21.1Xoh 62 u .31'/o t0 ,8.28% 53 e9.4196 86 frltleirer O1SAGREE 25-00-qo 72 10.003t 29 208y' s 14,58% 42 62 fi.41% 4g 18.66% 57 14.63% 42 3.416h 1.72% 1^M% 'l ll4lo 3.47% 3.13?{ 6.21% 6.S+% TOTAL 2Ag 29n ?m 284 28& 2W 2S 289 47-S39t t30 43.6% 125 {0.28.* 116 3t.9.1% 4l-67 121) IflEICHTEO AVERAGE 2.71 ?.07 'l.r'O 2.U 2.54 2.54 2.59 2.66 10 29.31S 85 45.6-a% 132 1$ 40 17.24.4 f,l 8.34$6 rB.6?9( 112 al.1sJ6 119 t8 16 Actual Questions 1) You visit Ellensburg for its family-friendly parks, reslaurants and kid activities.2l You visit Ellensburg for its histsric downtown with interesting galleries and museums, quaint shops and authentic craft beverages and cuisine. 3l You visit Ellensburg for its fun, unique events and festivals" 4) You visit Ellensburg for its wide-open spaces for outdoor recreation {hiking, triking, fishing, birding, etc.} 5) You visit Ellensburg for its access to the Yakima River, the Yakirna River Canyon and the Columbia River. 6) You visit Ellensburg for its restaurants, bars and good night life.7l When you visit, Ellensburg has a good selection of hotels and places to stay. City of tllensburg Five-Year Tourism Strategic Plan 2C19 77 Appendix B: Visitor Surveys Ellensburg Tourism Q17 Ellen,sburg and Kittitas County offer a vacation-worthy trip. Please rank,the followi:ng features or activities, starting with the one you are more likely to visiUattend/do (#1) and ending with the one you are least likely to visiUattend/do (#7). Anslve(ed; 290 Skipped: 1 t7 10 I 6:II ffififfitjts3tt::? Jezzin the Vall€y and ot-. I Visiltng $hqp$ mu$€urrs arld {allefles tn t{gionc donrr{swn f.lonst urt 'Elbnsb.rrg Rodod, spirtt of f1e West Oori,boy Gatl8rl,tg.rfid s{fi iar *tivilkrg Kifrilss C6u.lty Fak an! sirnilar iamdy :xliv[*s Jezz in the Volloy ard,c*her rnusic evenls 8€$6esl aftC b€€rtrv&E/ciderwhi8koy taslhgs Hiking bikirg, rocr(climbing, .antr€ and similar activitres Fisning or hrn6n$8.2qoh 10.00% City of iilenslrurg Fi',le-Year Tourism Strategic Plan Visiting shops, mus€tltns and,.. Ellensbur g Bodeo, Splrltof tbl{e... kittitas County Fair qnd simil'i... Brf,wfz6t snd bear/wine lclder,,, Hiklng, blking, rock ctimbi,,. Fishing 0r hunting 7 5.52/o 16 11.38% 33 15 4.97% 26 12.41% 36 4.14o/o 12 5?.410/o 152 I a7 EOoL 51 28.29o/o a2 5.170h 15 16.21o/o 47 24.347t 5S 8-2804 24 4j4% 2 21.3s% 62 13.48e/" 39 19.3106 56 13.45% ao 15.52% 12.76% 37 4.14% 12 3 20.690/0 60 12.76% 20.0o% 5B 13.10e1a 38 13.790/" 40 11.38% 33 8.28% 24 4 17.59" 51 10.34olu 30 16.55% 4B 18.62olo 34 5 11.03% 32 9.970 26 20.69% 60 14.830 43 6 6.21% 18 14.830/" 43 13.10% 3B 14.83o/o 43 s.66% ?8 28.62% 83 12.760/o 37 TOlAL 290 290 290 290 2-q0 290 290 SCORE 4.76 4.52 4.12 4.17 4.33 3.74 2.36 12.n7% 16.2\% 35 47 16.55% ',t8.280/o 48 53 2924 20-L9 78 Appendix B: Visitor Surveys Ellensburg lburism Q18 What age group are you in? An8wered:2BS Skipped:121 .,r-nn I ,t-"n'|| .'"nffi n*rnm 55€4*"I AilettERcHorc€$ 18.2.,| '25-34 3544 ,t5-54 55S4 65+ TOIAL g% 1g% 2094 30% tl096 SOYo 6096 7Oo'/o 80% 90% 1O0% RESFOI{SES 0.35% 9.79% 13.SS% 22.7lth 29,x7a/o 23.780h City (}f Ellensburg Five-Year fourism Strategic Plan 28 40 65 84 68 286 20r.9 79 Appendix B: Visitor Surveys Q19 Which best describes where you live? Affiviefed:238 Skipp+xJ: 12.1 100% s0% 60% {0s zoYb o%l: l"x* Brn *,...i II-- SH * --" -*,S€ai Erst Sout hco Othr lhur Xits Saoh Oth. C.nt Spoh tri- (Xh. Or.g lddh Orh€ Otbfl. kinth .ma r ltonrp omlsr rel are Cltr'r on o . tor Cou[(ing Pi6r Couocourh WestWarharei cs tst U.S. cou t - ty C... c-. ty ty C,,. c-, i.., dre! !.,. r,.. L_ ANSWERCHOICES Seatile or the E#tside (ol Laka lArashinglon) East KingCodty Sornh KirU Cftrritf TacGma Olhtr Pl6rc6 C6(nbi Tholbiiro Cornty KahaD C([rity 3)arhomish comty Otlrcr W0shrn WaslinCon cettld Washhglo$ Spd(arc area Iri-Cllies a€a Oltcr Ea$erl W8shingion OcAr{! ldafb Olhec U-.S sl,tles olher s{nirps TOTAL When Western Washington locations are grouped together, they accounlfor 57Yo of where respondents live. King County alone is horne to 29% of survey respondents. Which best describes where you live? !We3te.n lva ,Tr;aiti€s Atea r ldrlo I Centtll WA r Spokane Area | {Jther Ealt€rr lija r Oregox rCltherstates .olherCoun(ries RESPOIISES '16.08% 5.59?4 7.44% 2.'to% 6.29% 4.55% 2.45% 629% 6_U% '15.03% 3.15% 42OV' 8.74% 2.80% l.4a,a 4.90% 2.45D/. 46 16 21 6 18 13 7 l8 It 43 9 t2 26 g ,l l4 7 2& City of Ellensburg Firre-Year Tourisln Strat€gic Plan 2019 80 Appendix B: Visitor Surveys Ellensburg Tourism Q20 What group best describes your household income? AilSWERCrdOtCEs 549.999 or kss B€ tween$50,000 *nd $74,999 Between $75,0m snd S99,999 Eetwo€n $100,000 and $i50,000 $150;000 ormore TOTAL When Western Washington respondents are selected out, it shows they have.a slightly higher income with 59.50% reporting a household income of $L00,000 or more, compared to 51.10% of all respondents. I nterestingly, out- of-state and out-of-country visitors responded with lower incomes. Answered:272 Skipped: 135 City of Ellensburg Five-Year Tourism Strategic Plan $4gtg9ot getween 05O,OO0 end... gdt*en $75,000 and... Between $100,Q00 and.., $150,000 or llmre IIffi: less ffi Oyr 't0C6 UAo/o 3C4/o 4f/o 50'/o 80% lAo/o AOgo O0rlo'l0Oto flESPOt{SES 12.87Yo 14.71Vo 2l-32Ya 27.g4eh 23.16e/o 'E 40 58 76 53 ztz What group best describes your household income? Air{Fad: 153 Si:!t.d' 6 3,49,989 or lM 5160,000 ormE 8eilffiS50t0O0 [rdt7aBs loilsn fl5,000 ald tgSPSg 8aMSl0o.00o udsllopoo 2019 6I Appendix C: College Town Examples Ellensburg is often known for either the Ellensburg Rodeo or as the home of Central Washington University. The strategic plan committee discussed various ways that Ellensburg and Central Washington University might collaborate more closely. Conrmittee members and stakeholders interviewed had diverging views on Ellensburg leaning more into its college town image. The following are examples of how other towns of roughly similar size have collaborates with their colleges of roughly similar size. University of ldaho I Moscow, ldaho Population: 25,L46 College enrollment: 11,780 3'. Cross-referencing on website. Visitmoscowid.conlshows a collaboration with with Visit ldaho, the City of Moscow, University of ldaho and Moscow Chamber of Commerce a) Messaging is inclusive of university, Video tagline on homepage is "University. Diversity. Curiosity." b) Website promotes University of ldaho sporting events. c) Promotes University of ldaho facilities. For example, the university arboretum is included under Outdoor Recreations & Rentals d) They don't post on social anymore, but their old posts include images of the university a ) httos : l/qww. i nstaerarr|. corTtlyjsjtryol$ow ida lull 2. College banners on main street 3. Collaborative events: a) Annual trick:or--treatinF where community members go on-campus b) Annualdowntown block partv hosted by U of I and the City of Moscow c) Annual fair i: free which makes it very welcoming to students d) Annual Lionel l-lampton Jazz Festivalwhich partners with a lot of localbusinesses, a lot of locals are involved as well e) AnnualFaint the Palousq event where students paint the homes of people in need f) Welcoming signs at Farmers Markets for students {above) City of El{ensburg Five-Year Tourism Slrategic Plan 2019 82 Appendix C: College Town Examples Western Washington University I Bellingham, Washington Population: 89,045 College enrollment: 11,500 1. Cross referencing on websites. Bellingham's tourism website has a whole page dedicated to WWU a) Page talks about where the college is and why the town is great for students and parents b) Talks about what to see and do on campus, parking, how to get there, where to find the Visitor lnformation Center, things to see and do off-campus and key events c) WWU website has sgSlqnlgI_vi$tqdgthat's broken up into students and families, and community and alumni di lnformation for community include athletics, campus map, parking, transit, performing arts, Western gallery (art museum of WWU) and sculpture garden (WWU's contemporary sculptures) 2. Some college signs on main streets. 3. Collaborativeevents a) Op_ynlowF art walk hosted by WWU b) City promotes Wltp ala&ntweekqd c) A*fural P*i&.Bellinebgrvl llgggygt{ with a procession from Red Square to downtown to be welcomed by alumni and the greater Western community r Kicks off school year I Downtown festival for WWU community r WWU flag flies on top of Herald Building d) A*nual drawine/art evelt hosted by Viking Union gallery for students, involving local art community University of Wyoming I Laramie, Wyoming Population: 30,816 College enrollment: L2,627 Cross referencing on websites. Visit Laramie website features University of Wyoming Geology Museum and Art Museum on homepage. 2. No college signs or banners on main street {that we could find evidence of) 3. Collaborativeevents a) Visit Laramie features UW athletics, Department of Theater and Dance, graduation and homecoming on fea*.q{ed evelts page b) Laramie Jubilee Days, where students can join in on a carnival and rodeo celebrating Wyoming's statehood, but wghsitf doesn't speak to university at all City oi Ellensburg Firre-Year Tourism Strategic Plan 2019 i? Appendix C: College Town Examples Oregon State University I Corvallis, Oregon Population: 57,961 College enrollment: 28,886 1". Cross referencing on websites. a) Visit Corvallis has a website page dedicated to Oregon State University and about the contribution the university makes to the city. lt also mentioned that Oregon State hosts multiple events throughout the year, many of which are free and open to the public. Page invites community member to get involved with their events and to take a self-guided tour of the campus. b) Universitv website references Corvallis as ranked #2 friendliest college town in America 2. There are OSU banners all throughout downtown 3. Collaborativeevents a) Annual SeaYer Communitv Fair is made specifically to draw together OSU and Corvallis community b) Visit Corvallis and OSU co-sponsor the Corvallis Fqf FeSliViil c) Fall lnto Sorvice encourages students to volunteer for local organizations will volunteer projects City ol Ellensburg Five.Year Tourism Strategic Plan 2019 84 Thank you to the community members who provided insights and helped in the making of this plan. City of Ellensburg Five-Year Tourism ltrategic Plan 2019 B5 Downtcwn Nlarket Study snd Ecsnomic Developmerct Pl*n ELLENSBURG. WASHI NGTON Prepared by arnett muldrowG PLAI. FPEsETV€ PFOfiOTf. Freparod lor Cily of Ellensburg Lodging Tdx Commission Ellensburg Dovrntovrn Alsociation Ellensburg Business D€ve{opment Authority Kittitas County Chamber of Comrnerce :'il .,EgtL"f^rlrll 'ffi/l': iF, f rh \.- c!{ t +f,!h TABLE OF CONTENTS Backgroirnd Study Scope Expanding Success.. Connecting the Communlty ............... Enhancing the Visitor Experience 1.0 1.1 r.2 2.0 2.t 2.2 2.3 2.4 3.0 3.1 3.2 4.0 4.1 4.2 4.3 4.4 5.0 Introduction 3 3 Market Definition... Market Study 5 Trade Area Demographics and Market Segmentation 6 I Retail Market Analysis ......... 13 Overall Market Observations and Conclusions .......... ....."..,.............21 Physical Assessment ,.,..,,22 22 22Existing Conditions.. Recommendations 26 Reinforcing the Center..26 31 35 37 L A trnfi,oduction l.L tsackground With a population ofjust over 18,000 as of the 2010 Census, the City of Ellensburg is uniquely positioned in central Washington at the intersection of Interstates 90 and 82. It is the center of commerce and government for Kittitas County, which extends frorn the Cascades to the West and the Columbia River to the East. It is a popular destination for travelers because of its location, and a cluster of hotels and restaurants serve both exits to the commturity off of lnterstate 90. Ellensburg is also known as the home of Central Washington University and the annual Ellensburg Rodeo that attracts national attention. The downtown has maintained much of its historic charm including Victorian, Art Deco, and vemacular buildings of the 1920's. As is the case with many communities, downtown Ellensburg has changed from being the sole center of conunerce for the community as suburban-style commercial development has occurred in other parts of the city. However, Ellensburg has been very proactive in promoting and investing in the downtown as a vibrant location for independent retailers, specialty dining, a variety of business and financial services, government offices, cultural athactions, and special events. The community has not been content to rest on this success and has continued to invest in downtown. In20l3, community leaders acknowledged that a significant building in downtown - the Geddis Building - was at risk of becoming a serious blight on redeveloping downtown. The large building located at the pivotal southwest comer of 4th Avenue and Pearl Street was in decline. As a result, the City of Ellensburg, the Ellensburg Downtown Association, the Kittitas Counfy Charnber of Commerce, and the Ellensburg Business Development Authority forged an alliance formally called the Downtown Revitalization Committee, but more commonly known as "The Downtowners," to purchase the building, hold it in trust, and resell it to an owner that is actively renovating the property and plans to add new residential units and retail development to downtown. The Downtowrers realized that this success could be parlayed into an ongoing proactive approach to continued public/private partnership investrnent in downtown Ellensburg. 1.2 Study Scope This shrdy was commissioned to examine both the market opportunities for downtown as well as the physical environment and to recommend how the Downtowners should continue to utilize their knowledge and connections to create investment and development opportunities in the community, This study involved two key components that are closely intertwined. The first is an understanding of the Ellensburg market through a market analysis that looks at retail, residential, office, and accommodations possibilities. The second is connecting this market knowledge with key sites and buildings in downtown Ellensburg to prioritize potential for future investment. Of particular interest to the group was higher and better use of upper floor spaces in Ellensburg and over the course of the project examining a larger "fooq)rint" for downtown became apparent. 3 The study began in July with an immersive three-day visit to Ellensburg that involved back-to- back interviews and roundtable sessions with a variety of stakeholders, site visits to selected buildings and sites in downtown, as well as an overall community tour. The study included two customer zip code surveys conducted in both July and October that provided important data about the visitation patterns in Ellensburg. An intermediate meeting occurred over two days in September that provided the results of the first zip code sfrvey, physical analysis of downtown, and a detailed discussion of next steps. The study involved, several online presentations to the Downtowners partnership and concluded with a public presentation to Crty Council on November 2,2015. 4 2.0 Market Study This section of the report presents the findings of the market research for Ellensburg and sets the stage for firrther analysis that can be used to recruit business, enhance the housing market, help existing retailers target customers, and implement the accompanying marketing and recruitment strategy in a later section of this report. The goal of this market study is to show community stakeholders and potential investors how to capitalize on potential residential, retail, and office market opportunities and to leverage investments that will sustain the Ellensburg community while preserving the character that the community values. Chapter 2 is divided into four sections Section 2.1 describes the market definition based on zip code survey work completed by businesses in the community. It also provides insight into Ellensburg's trade area demographics and presents market data related to Ellensburg's primary and secondary trade areas. Section 2.2 provides demographic profiles of Ellensburg's primary and secondary trade areas, This section also presents a more detailed market segmentation using PRIZM@ Lifestage characteristics. (PRZM@ is a product of Nielsen Claritas.) Section 2.3 presents the retail market analysis that shows the amount of retail sales "leaking" from Ellensburg's primary and secondary trade areas. This information is based on the most recent data available and is a reliable source for understanding overall market pattems. This section concludes with some key opportunities for retail that could be used to both enhance existing businesses and recruit additional businesses to the Ellensburg community. This section also leverages Ellensburg's retail and demographic data to evaluate other market segments such as residential and office uses. Section 2.4 provides a concise conclusion to the overall market analysis -t 2.1 Market Definition Unlike radial and drive time studies that use arbitrarily chosen boundalies for customer hade zones, the market definition exercise for Ellensburg is based on zip code surveys completed by cooperating merchants. Zip code surveys have their own limitations, since zip code geographies can be fairly large and shetch beyond typical market boundaries. However, it is the only technique that conelates clearly with customer h'affic collected by metchants. Recorded zip codes are used to define a primary trade area, which is then analyzed in terms of demographics and economic activity. Two zip code surveys were conducted in Ellensburg in order to understand the market dynamics of the community while Cenhal Washington University was in and out of session. The first survey was held in July of 2015, and the second held in October of 2015. Sixteen local community retail businesses graciously participated in the zip code survey of their customers in July, and seventeen participated in October. Merchants were provided with a forrn to record customer zip codes and asked to keep the log for all customers during a ten-day period. 2.1.1 Zip Code Results The results of the zip code survey are presented in Figures l.l and 1.2 on the following page and are summarized as follows: . In July, lllensburg businesses recorded 1,086 individual customer visits from 156 unique zip codes representing 28 states and 12 foreign countries. In October, they recorded 1,808 individual visits from 178 unique zip codes representing 21 states and 3 foreign countries. c During both surveys, the 98926 zip code for Ellensburg had the most customer visits, controlling 56%o of the visits in July and 51% of the visits in October. r Customers were asked to identify whether they lived inside or outside the City of Ellensburg. The two results were similar wlth 42% of the customers living inside the city limits in the July survey and,39% in October; likewise, 14% lived outside the city limits in July compared with12% in October. r Central Washington University students were asked to identi$ themselves in the survey and represented the second highest percentage of visitors to shops and restaurants in the downtown. As would be expected, their results varied between the two surveys with 7yo of the visits in July and20Yo of the visits in October. r Visitors from the neighboring zip codes Kittitas and Cle Elum held 2o/o arrd 4% of their respective visits in July and 4o/a and 5% of their respective visits in October. r Customers from the rest of Washington accounted for 8% and 6Vo of theil respective visits in July and October. Many of these customers were regional in nafure, so only a portion of these might be considered "visitorso' in the traditional sense that they do not rely on Ellensburg as a regular destination for shopping. r Visitors from outside the state of Washington accounted for l2o/o and 4o/o of the overall respective visits from July and October. These numbers are quite significant when taken into the context of the visits from the rest of Washington. Visitors represent a key portion of the 6 market to the community, meaning that Ellensburg is serving not only a local and regional market, but a tourism market as well. 3o/o 42+6 rEllensburttNglDE tE[GnsburgOUTSlDE ;r C.ab.l Warhlryton Unill Xltdtas rTtorp ClcElwr tdsoutlt Cl€ Eliur tfgt$trsConrty ,?ahneCouty fitrycounty alestof Wa.lbiagbn EothffStat t lOth€rCoutrtriss 4o/o 149d Figare 1.1: Customer Visits to Participating Businesses by Zip Code in JaIy of 2015. 4%Wt LW tVo lEllenabugll{ :Ellenebug OUT rx Clm, Shdrnt "l(Itltes 39% Ttorp Clef,tun lSouth OeElum lGttitasCorurg "TtHac ilng rRart of'tllaal{ngton rOth.rSt.t!{ r0lhffCouqE{.! zAVr Figare 1.2: Customer Visits to Participating Businesses by Zip Code in Oclober of 2015. 4o/a li/o tolo 4r/o Loh Zola SVo 2Yo $ola IzrlD 7 Zl,2 Trade Ares Detinition Although the numbcr of visits provides an overall view of customer origin, a more accurate way to evaluate customer loyalty is to frame customer visits in the context of the poprilation of each zip code. This method corrects for zip codes that have exceedingly large or small populations that might skew the market penehation data. The primary hade area (PTA) is the geography wherc the most loyal and frequent customers to community businesses reside. Tables 1.1 and 1.2 reveal customer visits per thousand residents, showing an index that allows for an equal comparison of market penetration per zip code. It shows customer visits per thousand people for the highest representative visits to the Ellensburg community during both survey periods in 2015. Vlslts per Table 1.1: Castomer visits per L,000 populalion in Jaly of 2015, Zip Name Populallon VisltE Meits Per Thousand Table 1.2: Castoner visits per 1,000 popnlatlon ln Oaober of 2015. Determining the primary trade area can sometimes be more o'art" than science. At times, significant breaks in customer visits are not obvious. In Ellensburg's case, the division is clear; Ellensburg Kittitas, and Cle Elum emerge as the "most loyal" zip codes for area businesses and are thus identified as the primary trade area. Additionally, visits from Central Washington University students also fall into this range during the October suwey but not the survey conducted in July. This suggests that for the months that school is in session, CWU students contribute significantly to the Ellensburg market. I 2"2 Tt'ade Area Demographics ancl Market Segmentation 2.2.1 Ellensbarg Primary Trade Areu Demogrophics In 2015, the population for Ellensburg's primary trade area is estimated to be 33,591. The population grew by 23.3% between 2000 and 2010 and is expected to reach 35,037 by 2020, which is equal to adding about 136 new households per year. The median age for the primary trade area is 30, which is lower than both Washington at age 40 and the United States at 37 and is likely due to the age and number of CWU students. Househoid income for the primary trade area is $41,104. This income level falls below that of Washington at $56,835 and that of the United States at $51,939. (Source: Nielsen Claritas, Inc.). Additionally, it should be noted that this report was run by zip code of residents; while CWU does not have its own zip code, students are included in local census data and therefore should be included in this report from Ellensburg's zip code which will naturally decrease the Median Household lncorne for the community. 2020 Projertion ?015 EstiuNte 2010 Ceusus 2tlfllCemu G$owft2015-2020 Growfi20104015 Crov&200$'20t0 35,037 33,59r 32,442 26,297 43Ao/o 3.54Vo 23.370/s Table 2: Primary Trsde Areu Populution 212.2 Market Segmentation Market segmentation is a technique used to summarize demographic information into easy-to understand categories. The market segmentation illustrated for Ellensburg's primary trade area uses Claritas PRIZM@ data. PRIZM defines every U.S. household in terms of sixty-six demographic and behavioral types to help determine lifesfyles, purchasing behaviors, and preferences of the customer base. 2.2.3 PMZM Lifertage Segmentation The chart on the following page provides an easy to understand perspective on Ellensburg's market segmentation, Broadly speaking, Green Colors represent younger households generally without children in the home. Blue colors represent families with children. Red colors represent older families who may or may not have children in the home. ln the case of Ellensburg, the primary trade area's share of the PRIZM Lifestage categories is heavily skewed to "Striving Singles," categorizing 32Yo of the households (as shown in pale green in Figure 3). 'Yottng Achievers" (in green) comprises 18%, and "Midlife Success" (forest I green) and "Mainstream Families" (sky blue) each comprise 9Yo of households. Within each Lifestage category, darker shades represent highcr sociocconomic staflrs, while paler shades represent lower income levels. While Ellensburg has a large share of "Striving Singles" households with mediurn and low socioeconomic status, this can be explained by the proportion of college students that live in the community. Descriptions and predicted characteristics of the most common segments in Ellensburg are included in Table 4. Columns include Lifestage, segment category, a count of households in the primary trade area that fall into each category, as well as predicted household characteristics, which include income, age, corllposition, housing tenure, educational attainment, employment, and race. Figure 3: Primary Trade Area PRIZM Lifestage Segmentotion (Source: Nielsen Claritas,Inc.). s116 elt s96 1896 lMlrliltE succEs I'toufii AcHtEYEFS sTPlvlMi Sll.E IEE IA(T UM ULqTED ITVEATTH l$f,u1# {(tuMLtLqlo8s '.' MAIHSTFEAM t'r nllLIES ,. S IJSTA IN ITIG fA MILIEs IA F TIU ENT E fuIPTI IIE TS I@NsERvan/E cl'asstcs 'ic.qu'no tE (auP[E SIJSTAIIiJING Sf NIOE dG it6 r{6 99i tt 196 rtt IA The chart above depicts broad categories ofhouseholds. This section pofirays key sub categories of households along witli dcscriptions of lifestyle characteristics. tne descripiions below are provided by and paraphrased from Nielsen's descriptions of their PRIZM Lifestyle Segmentation data, The rounded percentage ofhouseholds in the prirnaly trade area and the rounded index to the United States is shown next to each description. An index of 100 would be a representation that matched that of the United States. These percentages were gathered from the airea within a ten-minute drive time from the intersection of 4th Avenue and Pearl Street in the heart of Ellensburg. City Startups 25.2% ctf Households in the Ellensburg primary trade area, Inclex to United States: 2,369 In City Starfups, young to middle-aged, multi-ethnic singles have settled in neighborfioods filled with cheap apaftments and a commercial base of cafbs, bars, laundromats, and clubs that cater to twenty-somethings - one of the youngest segments in America--with ten times as many college students as the national average. Greenbelt Sports 4'2% of Households in the Ellensburg primary trade area, Index to United States: 966 A segment of upscale exurban couples, Greenbelt Sports is known for its active lifestyle. Most of these older residents are married, college-educated, and own new homes. And few segments have higher rates for pursuing outdoor activities such as skiing, canoeing, backpacking, boating, and mountain biking. Boomtown Singles 10.0% of Households in the Ellensburg primary trade area, Index to tlnited States: 939 Affordable housing, abundant enhyJevel jobs, and a thriving singles scene--all have given rise to the Boomtown Singles segment in fast-growing satellite cities. Single and working-cLss, these residents pursue active lifestyles amid apartment complexes, bars, convenience- stores, and laundromats. 2.2.4 Market Definition Observations o a Ellensburg benefits from a robust mixture of visitors, and yet the local and regional population still dominates the market base. This presenti an important marfeting opportunity that mandates that the community retain a message that is appealing to both locals and those from out of town. Having completed over 200 market studies, patterns emerge over time. A community that benefits from over 15% of its visits from out of the local Jounty is rare to see. It indicates that the visitor market is important. Neariy 1 in every 20 visitors is from King County, Washington - a pattern also unusual as large mekopolitan areas frequently have lesJ than trvo percent market share in smaller communities over an hour's drive iway. This indicates that there is a strong market to the west of the Cascades that can be reacired through selective media. Kittitas County Tourism is already tapping this market and these numbers are bearing the fruit of this marketing initiative. We recommend continuing this push to market Ellensburg to the cities west of the Cascades. ]I o The influence of Central Washington University is very strong. Even during the summer' season students represented 7% of the customer base. When the University was back in session student traffic increased to 20o/o of the customer visits (one in every five visits). Of course, not all businesses will cater to the college student but the market is real and provides a charice for ongoing collaboration between downtown Ellensburg and Central Washington as a major institution and important downtown market base. From a tourism standpoint, the percentage of students is a key indicator that marketing downtown to parents and visitors to the University as well as students themselves would be a key strategic move. Befween 2000 and 2010, the population has enjoyed robust growth and is projected to continue to grow. This is a fundamental strength in any market analysis. Incorne levels in the primary trade area are lower than both tho United States and Washington State, but the college student presence can attribute to this since college students count in the Census at their school of residency. The psychographic analysis of Ellensburg indicates s{rong potential to retain talent cultivated at Central Washington and for others who seek to live in a vibrant community with an abundance of outdoor recreation opportunities along with reasonable proximity to a major metro area. Retaining students in a "college town" can always be a challenge and many students will naturally gravitate westward to the Seattle/Tacoma Metro area to work. However, there are recommendations later in this report designed to captufe some shrdents who wish to stay in the area (or recapture them later on). a o a 12 2.3 ftetail Market Analysis Ellensburg is a retail center serving the primary and secondary markets defined above. This section examines the Ellensburg Market to identify potential opportunities for new or expanded stores by examining "retail leakage." This will allow the comrnunity to assess what kind of additional stores would be attracted to Ellensburg and will help individnal existing businesses understand how they can diversifo product lines to capture this leakage. 2.3.1 Retail Leakage in the Trade Areas Retaii leakage refers to the difference between the retail expenditures by residents living in a particular area and the retail sales produced by the stores located in the same area. If desired products are not available within that area, consumers will travel to other places or use different methods to obtain those products. Consequently, the dollars spent outside of the area are said to be "leaking." If a community is a major retail center with a variefy of stores it will be "attracting" rather than "Ieaking" retiail sales, Even large commtrnities may see leakage in certain retail categories while some small communities may be attractors in categories. Ellensburg is a strong "attracting" community in many retail categories and is "leaking" sales in other categories. Such an analysis is not an exact science. In some cases large outflow may indicate that money is being spent elsewhere (drug store purchases at a Target or apparel purchases through the internet). It is important to note that this analysis accounts best for retail categories where households (rather than businesses) are essentially the only consumer groups. For example, lumberyards may have business-to-business sales that are unaccounted for in consumer expenditures. The best example for Ellensburg is gasoline. Ellensburg can capture some of the inflow of dollars from gasoline stations, but it is unlikely that truckers are going to be the potential customers who would go downtown to eat and shop. Stores such as jewelry shops and clothing stores are more accurately analyzed using retail leakage. The leakage sfudy for Ellensburg is a "snapshot" in time. Consequently, there are factors that point to this being a more conservative look at retail potential depending on what factors are examined, For example, population growth means that there will be more customers in the future resulting in greater demand for retail. A second factor making this study more conservative is that the leakage study only examines the market demand of the geographies defined as the primarytrade area identified for Ellensburg. A successful store model can capture from well beyond the defined primary trade geography and foster a strong visitor market, which is evidenced in the figures 1.1 and 1.2 which show over 10% of the customers are coming fi'om outside of the state of washington. With these conservative factors in mind (meaning our numbers represent "minimum" potential and not "maximum" potential) the primary trade area selected store sales equaled $520.i million in 2015. Consumers in the same area spent $541.9 million. Therefore, the primary trade area is leaking $21.5 million in sales annually. Ellensburg is unique, however, in its location along Interstate 90. The city serves as a stop before and after crossing the Snoqualmie pass over the Cascade Mountain Range, and it sits at the intersection of a major East/Vfest Interstate and a North/South Interstate. The result is that l3 nearly one fifth of all sales in Ellensbr.rrg occurs at gasoline stations. When taken out of the cquation, Ellensburg's leakage increases dramatically from $21.5 nrillion to a substantial $129.4 million. If the community werc to capture just a por-tion of this leakage, it would supporl additional and expanded retail opporhrnities both in downtown Ellensbrug and throughout thc City. 2,3.2 Detailed Retait Market Opportunity Tables Section 2.3.1 explores the retail trade patterns iri aggregate, the tables on the following pages explore the individual retail categories where Ellensburg is lealcing and gaining sales in the primary trade area. This data should be used as an overall guide to retail market potential and should not substitute for detailed mar-ket resear-ch on the part of auy business wishing to open in the area, Please note that some catcgories are subsets of larger categories. The numbers next to each store type represent the North American Industrial Classification System code (NAICS). The green columns lepresent the consurner demand in the Ellensburg trade areas. The light blue columns represent the store sales for all retailers in the trade areas. The dark blue columns indicate the retail opportunity gaps and retail surpluses in each category. Numbers in parentheses indicate an inflow of dollars and numbers outside of parentheses indicate market leakage, Retail Stores Total Retail Sales & Eating, Drinking Places EXCLUDING Gas Saations Motor Vehicle & Parts Dealers-44| Automotive Dealers-44 I I -Other Motor Vehicle Dealeis-4412 Automotive Parts/Access/Tires-44 1 3 Fumiture & Home Furnishings Storcs-44? Furniture Stores-442I Home Furnishing Stores-4422 Electronics & Appliances Stores-443 Appliance, TV, Electronics Stores-4431 I' Household Appliances Stores-4431 I I Radio, TV, Electronics Stores-4431 12 Conrputer & Sofiware Stores-441 12 Camera & Photographic Equip.-443 I 3 Building Material, Garden Equip. Stores -444 Building Matsdal & Sr4iply444t Home €enters-4441I Paint & Wallpgp.eJ Stores-44412 Haidware Stsres.44413 Other Buildilg Mat. Dealers-444 I 9 Building Mal Lum$eryards- 4 4 419 I Lawn/Garden Equip/Supply Stores-4442 Outdoor Porver'Equip: Stores-44421 Nrrrsery & Garden Cenrets44422 2015 Demand (Consumer DxP.) 541,862,569 482,337,089 119,944,737 97,956,748 13,651,653 8,332,336 10,215,2a3 5,187,588 5,027,615 10,994,445 8,591,642 1,468,794 7,122,949 2,174,486 228,317 56,4563'r3 47,348,958 19,297,564 758,241 - 5,132,541 22,760,652 8,5 89,1 6 1 9,107,4 I 5 3,239,493 5,867,9?2 l4 2015 Supply (Retail . Sales) 52A338,429 352,942,944 88;907,793 +1,069,070 19,984,273 27,855,450 tLa28p24 9,169,029 I,859,195 3,532,741 1,914,125 429,339 1,484;787 1,6 1 8,6 16 0 64,19r,935 36,461,64V 9,929,954 9r l;187 10,970,53-8 l'4;650,963 5,479,5q5 ?7,73A,293 u,420,327 6,7A9,9t66 Retail Stores Food & Beverage Stores-445 Grocery Storcs-4451 Supemrarkets, Grocery Stores-44-l I I Converience Stores-445 12 Specialty Food Stores-4452 Beer, Wine & Liquor Stores-4453 Henlth & Perspnal Care Stores-446 Phamracies & Drug Stores-4461 I Cosmetics, Beauty Supp, Perflirne -44612 Optical Goods Stores-446l3 Other Health & Personal Care-44619 Gasoline Stations-447 Gasoline Stations vry'Conv Stores-4471 I Other Gasoline Stations-447 I 9 Clothing & Clothing Aecessories Stores-448 Clothing Stores-4481 Men's Clothing Stores-448 1 I Wonren's Clothing Stores-448 I 2 Cltildren's, Infants' Clothing-448 I 3 Farnily Clothing Stores-448 14 Clothing Accessories Stores-448 I 5 Other Clothing Stores-448 I 9 Shoe Stores-4482 Jewelry, Luggage, tea*rer Goods-4483 Jewehy Stores'4483 I Luggage & Leather Goods-44832 Sporting,Goods, Hobby, Book, Music-45 I Sporting Goods, Hobby, Music Inst-451I Sporting Goods Stores-451 I I Hobby, Toy& Game Stores-45l12 Sewing Piece Goods-45 I l3 Mrsical Instrument & Supplies-451 14 Book, Periodical & Music Stores-4512 Book Stores & News Dealers45l2l Book Stores-45 l2l I News Dealers & Newsstands-451212 Prerccorded Tape, CD, Record-45122 GeneralMerchandise".Stores4 52 Department Stores, Excl Leased Departments-4521 Other General Merch. Stores-4529 Miscelldneous Store Retailers-453 Florists.453l Offlce'sgpplies, St'alio[egy, Glfrs:4532 Ofr ce $uppliqs & Stati orrery-4532 1 Gift Novelty & Souvenir Stores-45322 tlsed Merchandise Stores-4533 2015 Dernancl (Consumer D*P') 49,553,508 46,274,799 3,279,320 6,213,838 22,177,72s 26,217,695 20,884,343 1,779,041 I , 189,43 I 2,365,97A 59,525,480 43,358,849 16,166,631 24,812,345 13,477,E64 704,143 3,041,275 695,942 7,263,350 602,151 1,171,003 2,163,2A5 9,771,276 8,1 I 7,459 1,053,917 11,583,696 9,353,161 4,981,463 2,519,969 899,83 I 952,999 2,230,535 1,999,914 l,glg,627 179,187 23t,721 65,527,155 26,629,260 38,897,995 I 6,055,1 I I 54r,812 7,405,451 3,479,92A 3,925,63t 1,341,052 2015 Supply (Itetail Sales) 44,529,57i 38,s72,300 5,957,773 15,369,495 838,174 10,5'13,777 7,159"6A5 958,04? 730,128 1,726,0a? 167"395,485 84,53t,532 82,863,953 3,540,00? 2,7\5,714 204,624 45E,203 237,519 1,461,197 0 354,167 44t,644 382,653 382,6s3 0 15,688,524 12,959,694 I I,185260 l,a76,6ga 0 697,754 2,728,830 2,728,83A 2,729,930 0 0 20,967,991 4,739,923 ,6,227,959 5,204,681 256,160 484,666 0 484t666 t.300,841 15 Relalt Sfiorcs Othel- hdi$c. Sloro Reuiters4539 Ftodservfc. e & Erinking $laaqs.72? 2015 Demantl (Conrumer Exp.) 6;166,866 1015 Supply {&slell Se-lo$ 2t969;01,4 62,589,198 68f570,149 28p93,276 24,115,628 6,821,028 2,65r,266 3t.,95q,}63 27it4?*53$ '8,a37i018 !.23SJ3+ Special Dita!<irtg -AltoLqlicBey-7.*14 Figara 3: Retail Leakaga in the Frlwary Trade Area" Source: Nellsen 16 2.3.3 Overall Retail Market Opportunities The retail market potential for Ellensburg combines many different facets of the data gathered above. Retail matkets depend on both quantitative and qualitative information. Moreover, just because there is retail market potential for a potential retail store tJpe in no way ensures success of that store t1pe in the community, There are many reasons why a business might succeed or fail, and the retail marlcet is but one of those factors. The days of the downtown compcting with suburban locations for primary retail have long since vanished, The major "pro" of keeping all retail in the community is that once a shopper has left, they have left for the day and their money will follow. This section explores retail development likely to develop in suburban locations in Ellensburg. " Family clothing - This category includes stores such as TJ Maxx, Ross, and similar type stores that cater to all family members. They typically locate in suburban market developments. With over $5 million in leakage from thc primary hade area, this could be a suburban opportunity for Ellensburg. A store of similar type (though unlikely a chain) could also work in a downtown setting. o Auto Dealers - Ellensburg is home to a number of highly successful auto dealerships, though not all auto brands are currently represented in the market. There is an opportunity for new car dealerships that would likely develop in a suburban location. There is also a growing trend of downtown auto dealerships decamping to suburban locations for better exposure. t Electronics - While Ellensburg is leaking sales in the electronics category, this store type has proven to be problematic as of late with the demise of Circuit City and the bankruptcy of Radio Shack, A regional electronics store may be successful based on the market leakage. : Pharmacies * Surprisingly, Ellensburg leaks sales in Pharmacies. This could be a trade of the retail dollar for in-store pharmacies at stores like Fred Meyer or, more likely, a signal for additional demand. The location is likely to be suburban and will have littte to no impact on the downtown pharmacy in Ellensburg. o Home Improvement Stores - This is an intriguing category for Ellensburg in so far as independent garden dealers, hardware stores, and similar store types have proven to be great for the cornmunity. A home center such as Home Depot might be plausible based on these numbers but would likely have a negative impact on existing independent merchants, t General Retail - This category includes stores like Fred Meyer, Target, and Walmart. Ellensburg currently has a high quality Fred Meyer in very close proximity to the core of downtown, although separated by storage and warehousing uses that would not encourage walking between the two. Retail leakage indicates potential for some degree of additional general retail. The impact of such a store on downtown would be minimal and would likely benefit downtown Ellensburg and the community as a whole as it would retain customers that are currently leaving the community to shop in Yakima, metro Seattle, or Wenatchee. t7 2.3.4 Downtown Retail Murket Opportunities The opporhrnities below are more ideally suited for a downtown location. That is not to say that both suburban growth and downtown growth cannot co-exist - as already mentioned, strengthening the overall retail market for Ellensburg should bc a "rising tide lifts all ships" proposition. The are presented here because they have the opportunity to be particularly successftil downtown. o Restaurarzls - This category is very strong aud is likely to continue to thrive in the community. There are opportunities for growth both within downtown Ellensburg and throughor* the city. Restaurants are a "clustering" business type where more begets more. This is particularly true when a community attracts visitors as Ellensburg does. This does not mean that every restaurant will be successful and will require deft market research with any new restaurateur. The market data shows leakage overall for Ellensburg of $21 million but an overall gain for restaurants of just under $6 million. The greater region is grossly underserved by restaurants. A quick look at Yakima shows that at a twenty minute drive from the intersection of Front Street and Yakima Avenue shows the market has a gain of $167 million in overall retail sales yet maintains a restaurant leakage of $69.6 million. Comments that residents of Yakima come to Ellensburg to dine are verified by this number. The opportunity is amplified when you look at spending pattems for students, Ellensburg's highway location, and the conservative definition of the trade area. . Office Supply Stores - This would have been an obvious powerhouse opporhrnity fbr a suburban store in Ellensburg. This retail store fype has bcen in a state of national flux as big box office retailers have scaled back stores as a result of online shopping. Howevet, the data indicates that possibilities exist in this category both with what would now be a "small box" store in outlying areas of Ellensburg or working with existing specialized office stores in the downtown to expand services and product lines. o Clothing Stores - This store type, which include family clothing noted above, severely leaks sales in Ellensburg. This type of leakage is to be expected in a market the size of Ellensburg but does present opporlunities both for specialty retail in downtown and also in suburban locations. Clothing opportunities in downtown Ellensburg are going to cluster around young women, and the communify should take a dual strategy of working with existing clothiers and recruiting new specialty clothing stores. However, the Family Clothing category represents an opportunity for a small box store such as TJ Maxx to possibly be supported in suburban Ellensburg. As already mentioned, this would not eliminate the chance to grow specialty clothing in the core of downtown. (Shoes - a subcategory of clothes also represents a niarket opportunity for downtown or to expand the product line of an existing store). t Miscellaneous Retail * This broad and inclusive category is geared toward the highly niche- oriented retail that tends to cluster in a downtown setting. Specialty retail will continue to be an opportunity in downtown Ellensburg and is highly suited for the district specifically. Some specialty retail seen in other communities are oil and vinegar stores, running stores, rock and mineral stores (already present), niche gifts, fraternity/sorority stores in college towns, and many more. 18 Over-all, this study looks at a very conservative capture scenario for leaking retail sales in several ways: . Only counting existing leakage in both ttade areas and presurning no population growth in the primary ttade area (which will continue to grow); . Only counting local and regional population - not visitors (who comprise over l5o/o of the customer base); . Using a20Yo capture rate used, leaving 80% of market leakage to continue to leak elsewhere; . Using a very conservative $200 per square foot estimated sales across all retail categories. The supportable square footage under this scenario is 95,000 square feet of total retail in the overall ttade arca. Suburban developers are likely to use more aggressive numbers, leaving anyone looking at downtown to focus on roughly a third of this number. Even still, this could support significant expansion of the downtown's retail footprint by simply "freezing the demand" in current time. 2.3.5 Key Housing Market Opportanities Unlike retail markct analysis, housing markets are much less precise to understand. Using the projections for the primary trade area for population and household growth it can be assumed that the Ellensburg market will add 120 additional housing units per year in Ellensburg or 600 by 2020. Building permit data repofted through the City of Ellensburg corroborates this number with the average of 55 new units (consewative estimate) coming online each year. National trends in housing indicate increaSing interest in downtown living both with millennials and empty nesters. With Ellensburg's young average age of 30 and large proportion of college students, there is a potential market for altemative kinds of housing such as lofts, condos and apartments. A simply allocation model that captures only 50% of the demand for future housing in the market would yield 150 new units that do not conform to the traditional single-family house. This estimate for additional downtown housing is a bit more aggressive than the retail assessment but the national trends point toward growth in this area and new product coming on line conoborates these national trends. More detail as to the location of this housing is shown in the plans below but they will generally cluster in upper floor units in the core of downtown and in new mixed-use development between downtown and Central Washington University. 2.3.6 Hotel Murket Opportunities Ellensburg is home to ten hotel properties with a total of 682 hotel rooms. The occupancy rate across all of these properties is 58%, which is slightly lower than the national standard of 62%. It is important to note, however, that this occupancy rate accounts for some ageing properties within the city limits of Ellensburg and that new properties experience higher occupancy. The same is tnte for the averuge daily room rate in Ellensburg, which stands at $87 per night and is lower than the national average daily room rate at $104 per night. Again, ageing properties can account for this figure. More importantly, Ellensburg has experienced an increase in average daily rates, revenue per available room, and occupancy rates. The Kittitas County Tourism 19 Director along with the Lodging Tax Advisory Committee tracks Lodging Tax revenues. Revenues have increased every yeal but one since the recession, which adversely affected rates in 2009. So far in 2015, monthly Lodging Tax revenues have incrcased every month but one and, barring any unforeseen circumstances, 2015 will represent a record year in Lodging Tax collection. This is a positive trend that is likely to continue and points to iucreasing demand placing positive upward pressure on the local hotel market. National h'ends in hotel and visitor stays point to continued interest in alternative forms of lodging, including smaller boutique inns, self-catering inns, and specialty lodging that are close to tourist attractions and are within walking distance of the area's key restaurant and dining options. National hotel chains are pafng attention to this trend and have responded with creative brands such as Hotel Indigo by IHG, Canopy and Curio by Hilton, and Aloft by Westin to address this demand. Furthermore, this trend is migrating from bigger city markets to smaller comnunities where both independent hotels and chain affiliated hotels are being developed in downtowns even while other hotel products in the markets continue to thrive. 2.3.7 Office Market Opportunities Perhaps the most difficult market to evaluate in a community like Ellensburg is the office market. There is little speculative office space in the market and as a consoquence there is no historic absorption tates, consistent tent rates, and vacancy rates. The issue is exacerbated in downtown where upper floors that might be conducive to office space are in various states of repair. During the interview process, the price of $ l0 per square foot a year was cited as reasonable for space that was already suitable for a tenant. This rate hovers just at a level where buildings owners have difficulty maintaining old buildings for the rent they are commanding. Ideally, the market should work to slowly get the rental rates from $10 per square foot to $12 per square foot. An effective way to do this is to develop "right-sized" ground floor spaces that work for smaller specialty shops, The recommendations portion of this report will explore some creative solutions to jump start office space use in downtown Ellensburg and work toward slowly escalating rent rehrms to allow for addiJional investment in downtown buildings. 20 a t a a 2.4 Ovevall l\{arket Observations ancl Conclusions The following conclusions are based on the market evaluation above. These conclusions also undeqpin the recommendations that will follow in Chapter Three. : " Ellensburg has made significant investments in both downtown and tourism reach and the sllccess of downtown is reflected in the breadth and depth of the customer base. Central Washington University and downtown Ellensburg are inextricably linked, and the community should explore ways possible to continue to reinforce and grow those connections. Growth will continue in Ellensburg. This is inevitable. The market data indicates potential for both suburban and downtown growth to coincide. The days of downtowns and suburban locations "competing" fol the customer dollar are over. If Bllensburg can retain a customer in town who might travel to another market, it will be a much easier task to get that shopper loyal to downtown. Smart suburban retail development generally will not negatively impact downtown. Housing is going to play a major role in the future of downtown Ellensburg. The trends all point to ongoing success with downtown housing that not only caters to students, but also to ernpty nesters and young professionals. The empirical data points to increasing room rates, occupancy, and revenues that indicate strong potential for a hotel/inn that would serve as a complement (not competition) with existing hotels in the community. To avoid being competitive with existing properties this hotel should be located in downtown Ellensburg. Concepts for this are shown in a later section of this report. Ellensburg has a distinct opporhurity to "curate" the growth of the community and to expand the footprint of its downtown to better connect the dots between attractions, This will be explored later in the report. 21 3.0 PhysicalAssessment 3.1 Background In addition to the market assessment, this project engaged in a physical assessment of downtown Ellensburg to evaluate how it is performing, ways in which it can improve, and how it can continuej to serve both locals and visitors as evidenced in the market study. The following maps provide insight into the composition of downtown currently and set the stage for tecommendations that will follow. 3.2 Existing Conditions Downtown Ellensburg is a Certified Main Street Commumty by the Washington and National Main Street Progtams. The boundary of downtown's official designation is 6th Avenue to the north, Ruby Street to the east, 2nd Avenue to the south, and Water Street to the west. Figure 5 on the following page shows this boundary. The "heart" of downtown could be the subject of debate but is generally accepted to be the Intersection of Fourth Avenue and Pearl Sheet. It is the home to the Rotary Pavilion which is the center point for many downtown events and is bounded by some of the most distinctive architecture in downtown. A core of strong shopping arid dining options extend one to three blocks in every direction from this point. Figure 6 shows downtown Ellensburg with amenities, attractions, and educational institutions. These would include Morgan Middle School just outside of the core boundary to the south and Ceuhal Washington University and its associated open spaces to the north of the downtown boundary. Within the boundary are four city-owned parking lots, Rotary Pavilion, Rotary Plaza, the Library, Friendship Park, a skate park, and a community garden, The core area is also the home to the Ellensburg Farmers Market, which occurs on the East Fourth Avenue. Figure 7 goes further to show recent investment in downtown Ellensburg and its immediate surroundings. This is a critical exhibit in that it reflects on the dynamic nature of downtown and is not designed to be comprehensive in nature. Investrnent in downtown is occurring in nearly every part of the district and adjacent areas. Central Washington University is also actively pursuing projects that will reinforce its presence on the south side ofUniversity Way. In the center of town, the Geddis Building, mentioned in the introduction of this report, is actively becoming full of storefront tenants. The Elks Building is under renovation into a mixed- use development, Patricia Place apartments (36 units) were completed and arc l00Yo occupied, showing market demand for additional housing. New restaurants have opened, upper floor residential development has been completed, and other renovations are underway. This is a clear sigu that downtown Ellensburg is enjoying significant investment, that Central Washington University is growing in a direction that places key locations like a potential visitor center for the campus closer to downtown, and that interest continues in the future success of the community. The goal of the recommendations that follow is to illushate the kinds of investments that are possible, explore ways to make the visitor experience more vibrant, and continue to invest in downtown. 22 UGB{D -E* Doqbunborulory t, ' Oawii$$ Crnhi-4tlt Aie. qrd ?eorl 5t, gtl€N5guP,G COWNISWN n1asTtt tr.aN Downlqwn Core Sepnnbor?0lF t t, i j I 4 ? '-\{+ Figure 5: Downtown Core 23 E€F{A i I* I II ilull I ;f*,'.it 0ornte,r Bovxiory f*rrnros Csntar , {* Avo. cnd Fso,l 5t tols o^d O!.h spac! I@6 Md*ol Gtv.O"rrcd lo&irg tor Acedmic ln:lituricn: : { 1, I rit -!It ...: ._'.f;i!rJ ' [: f]r I nllNssuRc oortvNlowN va$lx PBN '{ iPsrkr snd Open Spoter Public Porking R€tsurcsr Arodomit lnclihrlionr * !'d Sapnrbr lloil c.:"s i a .'X-' r'' t:' $'t.:1*.t'-lr"i::: Figure 6: Parles and Open Spaces, Public Parking Resaltrces, and Academic Institutions tn and arcund Downtown 24 liir::!rn & !r,,r r €. iaj ) . t:': rl f11'.'!' i-.'1 ,.r: :'1, ri r- Irt 1.. i r,rv- .; :. n , t ":fl tiI :' r' .l'' j I ; II lililt , 1...' l; " 'r.' i. . t ':;*ttAli):':{:itl'a'..: - .1 i,... : 't ,' f , i, ,"i ir-:reri lrr' i..]'l'*' -1 e.1.,'.'i,.r'.r '.i. -.....',J, rr,r.J-,,1;."r,j ,r-.,r,:F , " r!.1.t.--j, i., tIIl t'tr:h:,._ l,t -.!,:r'( 't,1i.r$rtfjij r!.-:i ReentSuccs*og Froieclo irr Progrcr* tl i: Figure 7: Recent Successes and Projects in Progress 25 4.0 Recommendations The recommendations in this chapter are divided into four key strategies important for the future success of downtown Ellensburg: t Reinfurcing the Center: This skategy is designed to focus on the core of downtown Ellensburg by providing enhanced gathering places and gateways to the community in the public realm and additional development opportunities in vacant ground floor and, more importantly, upper floor spaces. e Expanding Success: This strategy recognizes that the core of Ellensburg is highly developed, and there is great potential to expand the footprint of downtown to include blocks that would connect downtown to major development opportunity sites. a Connecting the Community: This strategy focuses on multiple modes of hansportation that allow locals and visitors to use downtown Ellensburg by car, bike, on foot, or by public transit. It also continues to reinforce the importance of connections between downtown and existing hotels and between Central Washington University and downtown. o Enhancing the Visitor Experience: This shategy recognizes that tourism and visitor traffic are critical to the success of Ellensburg. Recommendations here focus on having a curated visitor experience and on the potential for a new hotel and meeting space in downtown Ellensburg. 4.1 Reinforcing the Center 4.lJ Implement Ellensharg Town Sqaare as a gathering place. I{ig& Priorily. Perhaps the most significant public improvement shown on the plan is to create a true Ellensburg town square adjacent to the Rotary Pavilion. Figure 8 below shows some examples of similar spaces in other places and the plan in Figure 9 shows that the Ellensburg Town Square would retain parking on some of the space, make better use of parking on adjacent blocks, and replace existing parking with a green lawn panel and a small splash pad that can be used as the central gatheling placJfor the iommunity. This space could include restrooms relocated from 3'd and Main as well as the downtown visitor's center, Figure 8: Green gatheringspaces. 26 4.1,2 Continue to pursae emdpromote upperfloor mixed-use developntent. High Priorily. The private sector opportunities are shown in tlnee categories in Figure 9 on the following page: complete, in progress, and opportunity sites/buildings. There are nine opportunity buildingi Jnd one opporfunity site and each is furtlier explored either explicitly or more geoerally depending on the nahtre of the building or site. Ellensburg should consider an open house "live downtown" event to promote downtown residential development opporfunities. The event should be an open house of existing residential units in downtown to show both potential residents and developers the potential for additional living in the community. Many people simply haven't experienced what downtown living can be like. Some communities have even done "mock" upper floor housing with furnishings from local decorators to showcase what downtown living could be like in a particular building. 4.1.3 lYork to build Ellensbarg Gateway dt corner of Main and Third. Medium Priority. Currently the corner of 3'd Avenue and Main Street is an existing parking lot paved with concrete pavers. Figure 9 shows that the same number of parking spaces can be moved to be on sh.eet parking, opening up the area for outdoor dining and an attractive downtown gateway sign at the northeast corner of the intersection. The restrooms at the southwest corner of the intersection should be relocated to the center of town as outlined in recommendation 4.1.1 above. 27 5O3 N. PEARL ST.. UPPER FLOOR R,ESIDENI'AI. (coMPr.ErEl EIKs BUILDING RENOVAIION AND outDooR DtNaNo ADDtnoN llN PRoCREssl 42O 8UII,DINC. REUSE OPPOR'UNIIY CTYMER MUSEUM - BOUTIOUE HorEt {rN PT,ANNTNG) BLuE ROCK SATOON REUSE {COMPLETE) THE EIMIRA - UPPER FTOOR REU5E OPPOIIUNIIY EII.EN5BURG TOWN SAUARE - OPPORIUNITY cAsltE surr.DrNc RtusE lcoilPl,ErE) TARMIRS MARKET. NEW ATICNMENI OPPORIUNI'Y OEDDIS EUI1DING - UPPER FIOOR TESIDENTIAI OPPORTUNIIY EI.I.ENsBI.JRG T[ORAI. - UPPER FIOO[,IEUSf OPPORIIJNITY COWORKING sPACC. OPIORTUNITY O(I5IING PARKINC LOT. REDIVITOPMINT OPPORIUNITY KIEINEERG EUII.DING REUsC {IN PROGTESS} CRg EUITDING N.EU5E (COMPIEIE) EIIENSBUTG OA'IWAY PIAZA - OPPORIUNI'Y OTD II.I.INSOURG HOIEI. OPPOITUNIIY oPponluNtrl SlrE 1il6 w.3'oAvt.] opPoRruNtrY SlrE (ExrslrNc PUruc lEsltoollsl ELI,ENSBURG, WA DOWNTOWN MASIE& PIAN Downtown Core lllustrotive Plon -J. Figure 9: Ellensburg Core Area Plan @r-L_.r-------l fEa October 2Ol5 l0 !@ 28 4.1.4 Intplement co-working space arud potential makers space. Co-working spaces have moved from what some might consider a fad into a fuIl-blown national trend with over 80% growth in available spaces during the past two years. According to the Commercial Real Estate Development Association report: Between 2005 and 2014 the number of co-working spaces has gone from I to 781. Deslnnag monitors co-worlcing spaces nationally and cites that 6AYo of existing co-working spaces will expand in 2015, 4.5 new co-working spaces are created each clay, and245 people become members globally each day, Ellensburg has multiple opportunities to capitalize on this growth while building on paftnerships within the Chamber of Commerce, with Central Washington University, and even with the creative comnnnity that thrives in Ellensburg and Kittitas Counfy. Before delving into the specific recommendations, it is important to begin to define how eacir of these spaces work, as semantics can sometimes get in the way of truly understanding the purpose of these new models for the workplace environment. It is alio important to know that, although their definitions are provided below, the fluidity within which they can function in a space is as creative as the very ideas themselves. Co-working spaces provide a place for individuals or small companies to work in a shared environment. Companies can interact with one another in informal ways, form collaboratious, or simply share in the creative atmosphere of the space. Co-working spaces may host events and activities, but rarely provide formal bnsiness coaching. Such spaces provide conferencing capabilities, shared printers, a kitchen, restrooms, and most importantty high speed internet access. Incubator spaces are also places where businesses co-habitate as well, A key difference between co-working and incubator spaces is the level of support provided to grow businesses. These spaces frequently have a higher education partner that is helping to cultivate and coach businesses toward success. Many incubators have the desire to "graduate" businesses from the space. There is already an incubator space in Ellensburg, so this approach may not be the most appropriate for downtown, although the trend is continuing to evolve into other kinds of incubators. Accelerator spaces provide a shuctured way to "graduate" companies, often within a specified period of time. Usually, accelerator spaces receive significant support from venture capital that is directly investing in the start-ups, The goals of an accelerator is to "spin out" successful ventures, These spaces tend to gravitate around like businesses that have collaborative capabilities. Makerspaces are physical locations where people gather to share resources and knowledge. Unlike the spaces described above, makerspaces focus on projects and fabrication. Consequenily, makerspaces provide tools and facilities for the makers. While experts or higher education- affiliated advisors might be available, makers frequently get help from other users, These spaces began to be associated with fields such as engineering, fabrication, computer science, and graphic design. Many makerspaces have higher education partnerships who desire to create an 29 informal combination of lab, shop, and conference room. Frequently, 3-D printers, manual tools, and classroom spaces are associated with makerspaces. Such spaces take very little upfit to make them function, but the key would be flexible space for many office type configurations and excellent intemet access. The Kittitas County Chamber of Commerce is currently working on one co-working space on N. Pearl Sheet in the old Red Cross office building. Ultimately, multiple spaces could be developed that could take on multiple partnerships and even focus on particular professional collaborations (such as artists studios or architectural and engineering offices) so the community should be prepared to engage in a discussion with others on the endeavor. The goal is to have flexible spaces to cultivate entrepreneurial growth in the heart of downtown Ellensbug. 4.1.5 Continue ongoing recruitment and _retention of retail. The retail analysis clearly indicates that there is sufficient demand for additional specialty retail and the expansion of existing retail in Ellensburg. The commurity should consider subdividing spaces for a "small store" concept. Pascagoula, Mississippi used seventeen prefabricated "Kahina Cottages" as a retail accelerator. Over 30 applicants applied for the spaces, and, after five years of operation, four original tenants have moved on to larger spaces in the downtown. From a recruitment standpoint, the best prospects are 1. Expansion of existing stores; 2. Specialty stores in neighboring communities looking for expansion opportunities in Ellensburg; 3. People who may have relocated to Ellensburg with retail experience. The Kittitas County Chamber of Commerce sponsors a business plan competition in conjunction with Yakima, which could be expanded and targeted to retaiVrestaurant use in downtown Ellensburg. Cenhal Washington University may consider parhrering with the Ellensburg Downtown Association and the Chamber of Commerce for such an expanded business plan program. 4.1.6 Explore realignment offarrners' market. Ellensburg should explore the prospect of realigning the farmer's market to the market vendors face out toward the street. By doing this, emergency equipment can get by and also allows the market to reinforce existing retailers. This could be launched on an experimental basis to see which configuration works best. 3A 4.2 Expanding Success 4.2.1 Begin to look at downtown as a broqder City Center Figure 9 on the following page illustrates opportunity sites in a much bloader context than the downtown core plan shown in Figure 8. The sites are divided into sixteen sites labeled as Level 1 opportunity sites and ten sites labeled as Level 2 opportunity sites. The levels are to provide some idea as to which sites are more likely to develop in the shorter versus longer term. It in no way implies that a Level 2 opportunity might not rise up to be avery early devel,opment project. The sites are also markod as to whether they are vacant land or lots, are underutilized properties whete the existing use may not be consistent with a denser and developed downtown, or ar€ properties where the ground floor may be occupied and the upper floor is vacant. When examined as a whole, downtown Ellensburg can be viewed to extend to University Way to the north and across Water Street to the west. The City should acljust the zoning for portions of Water Street to expand the downtown core. 4.2.2 Partner with existing and. new investors on underutilized sites idenffied by prioriry in the plan. The single best way to explore redevelopment of undenrtilized sites and buildings is to communicate with property owners, Many owners simply do not know that their properties have a higher or bettel use or may not know where to begin on considering renovation, while others may have no interest whatsoever in pursuing investment at this time. The Downtowners can continue to meet and work with property owners on a case-by-case basisby answering questions, contemplating partnerships, and offering incentives io advance redevelopment. Some communities have contemplated creating incentives that treat downtown buildings as a community would any other inftastructure opporhrnity. In so doing, communities have implemented ADA grant programs to bring buildings up to code, created shared sprinkler systems that allow for a number of buildings to enjoy the benefit of this fire suppression code compliance or installed shared elevator space for upper floors funded through puUtic or quasi- public entities. Some uses may be ideally suited for property trades so that higher and better uses can come iuto downtown Ellensburg. Many of these opportunities are refening to property trades along Water Street where there are uses that should be off the street and in industrial areas of Ellensburg. The Kittitas Reclamation District, the food bank, and storage lots would probably benefit from locations that are more efficient. 3t (€satls t#uryroddg :97 a*8gg:!': lIrpctoit't r$t.L',raqg tquq.roddl3'rP S.li" iii ,'i!:,;i'r.*i!\t| 1 I,i:il?r;Lr k.,i '11{..irjrl'. 11 ;:\Y.1{ tl l1 i}irr?..!,-! :4r. t,6J-. i !. .r- rr'!!ri F 1l f 1; t<.,!; :'\'..4 <!',r..* -n _iqa) ar'.:-.^ti,i.r--:l'i,r-'rrr -< 3."J ;..L.,.,fi :.'.r'. t i;i .,-,ra,-*h1r: jo!e- ;t, - -' lr\,n, th ,, -Lr'.. t., ,\'j r,q' a*.. :{ 1,,,1 |n..n""r' t t:,+ii:,t,.+IIf:!*'a_,iy;t ,' r..,J' l-;ti'r1 ir* i, ! , -..1.,a I I ,i: :..1{. n{:{. -riP:.? ";r}r,i.:i. ,rr t.i rr' ;.^!,:,r):i r."-;ri{i lirl!rdrt^ri,iq,.r,wy/s."1 H:H*IfiffirI,tIt.:f.r.].{_?i.ilt 4.2.3 Host un investmentforunr in the comnmnity. The Downtowners should collaborate to conduct an investment fonrm in the community for potential investors. This forum can provide potential business owners with a profile of the market in Ellensburg, available prope$ies in the community, guidance on support services available to potential businesses through a variety ofpartners. The event should last no longer than two hours, offer refreshments, and give a brief overview of the following: r Represeutatives of the Downtowners should present findings of this market study and recommendations. ' CitY staff can share the support services that the City of Ellensburg can provide. " Ellensburg Downtown Association can discuss its program of work and assistance. o Private Sector Property Owners/Commercial Real Estate Representatives should provide an overview of the space available in Ellensburg, a brief synopsis of leasing basics, and if possible, any incentives they have to promote local business. o The Kittitas County Chamber of Commerce and the Eltensburg Business Development Authority can provide information on the overall economy of the iounty, services provided by each group, and resources for business start ups. o The Small Business Development Center andlor a SCORE Association chapter should provide information on business plan support, start-up assistance, and additional services they provide. Ideally, the otganizations should promote a follow-up consultation day in Ellensburg so attendees can sign up for appointments. o Existing businesses should provide an overview oftheir personal experiences doing business in downtown Ellensburg (with a focus on the positives and helpful hints). The Downtowners should leverage these partners to help promote the event. The goal is to reach out to anyone interested in investing or starting a business in Ellensburg. 4.2.4 Create an investment 'blub" for Ellensburg Ellensburg should also explore a funding program that could incorporate a modest return on investment for participating in an investment club for buildings and sites in the community. The JOBS Act, signed into law by President Obama, requires that the SEC create some parameters for this fipe of investing. The SEC has just released those parameters. There is also nothing to preclude local investors to create a more traditional investment program or a property renovaiion company with the expectation that there witl be a retum on investment to the partners. In some cases these operate independently of the city an in others there is a partnership skucture to implement a plan such as this. It is important to understand that this funding recommendation is designed to augment existing funding options that vary from traditional bank financing to state and federal tax credits. Any investment fund is best used to leverage other financial tools available for a project. 33 4.2.5 Cultivate ongoing purtnership for "Signatuye Street" along University Way to emp hasize Central lY'ashington University. Significant redevelopment is expected over the next five years along University Way between Main Street and Chestnut Street. Central Washington University has already constructed very attractive signs along the conidor. Over time, the Cify of Ellensburg should contemplate an ongoing parhership with Central Washington University to create a strong streetscape along the road and reinforce the intersection of Main and University Way as a galeway to downtown. 4.2.6 Consicler community center in the city center. The YMCA was once a major attractor in downtown Ellensburg for recreation and activities, which have now moved elsewhere in the city. Ellensburg should explore the long term possibility of a multi-use community center in the core of the comrnunity. Downtowns are always the best location for community centers fol several reasons. These centers create economic spin off of having activities in an area where people can 1. walk to the location,2. spend money in the area afterward, 3. share parking resources, and 4. serve as an atffactor for additional investment. Several of the vacant or underutilized sites identified in Figure 10 would be ideally suited for a community center that could host meetings, events, the arts, and other uses. This type of project will require a cooperative effort and should be flexible enough to handle a variety ofuses. 4.2.7 Consider an employer-assisted housing fund Employer-assisted housing programs provide incentives for employees to live within designated places near their place of employment. There are many benefits to such a program including reducing commute times, pollution, and stress; increasing employees' loyalty to the locale where they work; and providing a sustainable program to ensure that housing stays stable in a local market. Typically,large employers such as universities, hospitals, and govemments create these funds to foster investment in the community they call home. Often times these incentives are as simple as a small down paym.ent assistance program in a targeted area, reduced fees in a highly targeted area, or a suite of benefits through a public- private partnership. This program could continue to keep neighborhoods between downtown and Central Washington University stable, as well as encourage investment in more housing downtown and more upper floor conversion. 34 4.3 Connecting the Community 4.3.1 fmplement creative place-making Creative place-making works with comrnunity members to bring together arts and cultur.e in ways that connect physical space to needs in the community. The goal of this effort would be to foster broader exploration of downtown by visitors while showcasing the talent of a local aftist. Ellensburg should explore working with an organization like the nonprofit Pomegranate Center based in Seattle that explores creative place-malcing in communities aJa partnership effort, Creative place-rnaking projects could be incorporated into the town center as well as create physical connections between CWU and downtown Ellensburg. Today, key stakeholders are working on an excitiug program to corurect tluough a public art program to create "markers" that will be located in a variety of locations to explore between downtown and campus. The concept, dubbed "Project Brilliance," will implement reflector art pieces from the tate nict Elliott, a renowned local artist to be placed in strategic locations throughout downtown Ellensburg to ultimately connect the Old Heat Plant, slated to become a visitor's center for Central Washington Universify, with the core of downtown. Figure 1l on the following page illustrates the potential locations for these installations on key comers throughout the larger downtown area. 4.3.2 Continue pafinership with Central Washington Ilniversitlt to bring investment into the core of downtown over tinle whether through progrants oy capital projects, Central Washington University is a strong partner with the Ellensburg community, and its students represent a significant portion of the customer base in downtown. Over time, the University and the Downtowners should seek partnership efforts that may bring programs or even capital projects into the downtown. Sorne of the ideas expressed in other recommendations of this report could be potential parlnership projects. 4.3.3 fmplement bicycle friendly streets as identifted in prior plans. Ellensburg has worked on bicycle friendly streets and the downtown is very navigable by bicycle. The community should continue to implement these imporlant recommendations and will implement new bicycle racks that have been designed in similar sfyle to existing quality downtown sheet furnifure. 4-3.4 Implement circalator transportationfrom CllU throagh downtown to hotels. Cenhal Transit already operates a fxed route system in Ellensburg. Over time, the possibility of a circulator that connects the local hotels through downtown and onto Central Washington's campus would be an excellent way of creating a regular service for visitors to the cornrn-unity. The potential route is shown in Figure 1l below. 35 lE6!N0 0lrnrtrret t*&y t5r'sldqr* f P,dacndfuospcer weHAv€ wnHAv€ wlltH AVF !rSrHlvr lilill I rfn I I t\U'r1 fornco f.to*ct Cdy-gteed Pdldrg lrb td{.rlc fnlEud.e Edtidg SisA 3E,ibof,d il4s lnut'Jurw Por{trtul F&rc !rlonrbr ol Sh^S Si.d Novori [rrrrgh lvblic hrlml &<€d 3!@r,er snd fu.las h Pro<eri btosl I {lqtumty SJ.. k*cl ? CpFonldt Jiht lrlarlsird i' f,t(d*'fi 0g$ Erfir+nqa l'&nftl P{Uh tn/Gqtlw:ng l.lodr!o r-rr)Paloor,El CwU Do*ilovn'C:e!la,or' 9u Aoc r{ trl AvE \d, trNoAvt wr'll Avg vJ ril Avt EIENSBUtg DOwNl{]Wf r n{AglE{ ttAt\ lmoge Enhon(oncntl Sirengthenad Conneclions Stptmb* l0l5 : ', ;',t t- rr.$'lt6{Avg tgAqtlot lt6 l.' i .,t.'"., ,- Figure 1I: Image Enhancements and Strengthened Connectionsfor Dawntown 36 4"4 Enhancing the Visitor Experience 4.4.1 R.elocate visitors' center to the core of downtown. Ellensburg should explore the possibility of a visitors' center in downtown. The Wells Fargo Drive Tluu could be an ideal location for snch a faclltly as it is in the heart of the community, offets "storefront" convenience, and could also provide public restrooms in the center of downtown. 4.4,2 Implement thoroagh wayJinding signs. In the most general sense, wayfinding is the process by which we navigate the world. Whether it is our daily commute or a joumey to an unexplored locale, we rely on cues, habits, patterns, landmarks, and verbal and visual directions to establish and confirm a working knowledge of our environment, A comrnunity wayfinding system takes these cues and creates a seamless system of signs, kiosks, and markers designed to guide visitors to destinations, remind residents of local offerings, facilitate community engagement, and achieve community-specific goals. A wayfinding system typically features various sign types including gateway signage, directional signage, parking signage, pedestrian signage, as well as maps and information guides. A typical wayfinding system utilizes a community's marketing brand graphics and includes gateways, vehicular and pedestrian directional signage, street banners, district and parking signs, building markers, and informational kiosks. Ellensburg has some dated wayfinding signs that are difficult for the motorist to read and reflect older graphics for the community. Furtherrnore, these signs only begin to appear once a visitor is already in downtown, It is imperative that Ellensburg implement a complete wayfinding plan along with a phased implementation plan to curate the visitor experience through downtown. Examples of wayfinding from another are shown below in 12. Figure 12: Example of Wayfinding Planfrom Greenwood, SC Uptovn rIIi I I r::fj:': ;,_11;,.i :r{'),? lypical Signi Fluted Post ffimffimqlll qltF quF qLhtt *u$t +r s?*tsr qdr bS. dhr!.*hr b*Lr.o hb|H Sh+g*. F*-.. fl=itiii F--.lttr* alblb h Ethrh -rirh rqi.u id.FdVg.a *gd **drcn .--1.'.--.. - .;--,-..,(,'', : . l:;::...: /): rqri arlt ftT-l @ Srlb,T ltTj rryr{ -t [* 37 4,4.3 Implement and continue to modify parking resources and procedures. Mentioned in the physical analysis, the study area boundary contains four city-owned parking lots generally well placed throughout the clowntown core, Additionally, on-street parking has, been mostly converted to angle parking with a variety of times to accommodate the variety of uses (loading zones, more lengthyparking options on the outlying areas, etc.) Some best practices on public parking should explored. Ellensburg should conduct a "light" parking study to examine existing public and private inventory as well as on and off street parking. The study should also explore peak times for parking. T5lpically, the outcome of such a sfudy presents tactics such as better signage, ongoing management of spaces, ensuring that close in spaces come at a time premium, and directing long-term visitors and employees to outlying lots, One option for Ellensburg to consider would be to implement back in angled parking on a block in downtown as a pilot project. This type of parking provides several advantages over traditional parallel or angled parking. First, cars have much more visibility moving out of a space when they have backed in (and the movement into the space is easier than parallel parking), second the doors to the car open to the sidewalk rather than the street making it safer for parents with children, and the rear of the car is to the sidewalk allowing for easier loading for any shopping. Two potential opporlunities for expanded parking exist on both the Skate Park lot (should it move) and on the Old Creamery lot as discussed in section 4.4.4 below. Many communities have found than an annual parking summit allows policies to be tweaked and issues resolved as parking is an ever changing dynamic in downtowns. 4.4.4 Pursue a downtown boutique hotel witlt meeting spuce and parking. As mentioned in the market analysis portion of this study, there is a potential market for a unique hotel product in downtown Ellensburg. After evaluating several properties, the old Ellensburg Hotel in the Shoudy-Cadwell Building at the corner of 3'd Avenue and Main Street appears to be the strongest opportunity for several reasons. First, the location is highly visible which will be important for any downtown hotel. Second, while the hotel will need to be modernized and upgraded significantly, it has traditionally been a hotel. Third, its location provides visitors easy access to all of downtown Ellensburg. Last, the hotel has the potential for adjacent meeting space and parking. Figure 13 illustrates the potential for the projeot. The hotel could be located in the existing building with ground floor retail remaining in place. A potential joint use elevator tower could be constructed to the rear of the property for ADA compliance. Parking for the hotel should be located on the 'old creamery' site preservirrg the Art Deco fagade of the burned out building. Plan estimates show potential for 70 parking spots on this site which is less than a block from the hotel itself. The City of Ellensburg will need to be the partner to complete this parking resource reserving room for expanded parking through an "over/under" ramp in the future. Rough estimates show that the hotel could probably accommodate 40-50 rooms depending on how it is configured. It is likely that the hotel's operation would be independent of a chain affrliation, though many national chains are exploring specialty branded boutique hotels. Many 38 travelers arc finding that hotels with character located near restaurants and shops are more appealing than standard hotels. The community should also explore some creative meeting space that would accompany the hotel. This could be part of the community centei mentioned in a prior recommenduiioo or a stand alone creatively adapted facility. Idpally, the meeting facility would be able to accommodate more guests than the hptel itself to drive haffic to other accomrnodations in the community. Figure 13 shows several options for such a facility in the vicinity. 39 U Pf, IYAIE RIDIVEIO9MENI OPPO[IUNITI $lES CIIY.OWH€D PARKING I,O' OPPOTIUNIIY. PRESERVF fACADES OI'ORMER CRTAMERY EUII.DiNC AIONG SbAV!. AND WA'TTR SI. 70 suRfAcE PARilNG SpACgS SITOWN. 19 ON"SrRfEr PARI(ING SP^CIS SHOWr.l ol9 lH,tNSSURS l.lortt RCD€Vt!OpM:Nt OFpOnlUNlly FRIVAIE REOTVELOPMEilT OP'ORIONITY SIIE3 fl.LtNSBURG, $/A DOWNlO'ivN trlAStaR PIAN Potentiol City Porking lor lllustrotive Plon Qctab:' i015 F-]_r---10 J0 rio s Figure I3: Potential Hotel Site With Parking Potential ,.tHAVStr 5t -.'il F 40 5.0 Conclasion In order for this plan to be successful, it must have specific lesponsibilities and a consensus as to how those responsibilities will be implemented. Several points should be considered: e The Downtowners will ultimately play a critical role in the implementation of the plan. Its primary role will be as a facilitator between the representative partners involved in this plan that comprisl the group. c This plan is very forward thinking and no ono agency can camy the workload by itself. This should include very specific actions strategies and realistic timeframes. An opportunity must be made to pair attainable goals with responsible parlies while also identifiiing funding strategies for each task. ' A Downtowners "summit" should be held every year to evaluate the progress of this effort and share it with partner stakeholders and the public. The attached "Strategy Board" summarizes all of the projects and recommendations included in the Market Study and Strategic Plan for Downtown Ellensburg. The board is designed as a working document for benchmarking and ongoing evaluation of the implementation process. Each recommendation that is presented in brief on the strategy board is supported in recommendations above. 5.IJ Strategies und Visions Each of the plan strategies and visions are outlined in the strategy board. It is important to remember the ultimate marketing and development strategies that each project supports. Of iourse, each of these strategies is linked with one another, but failure to achieve any one goal does not negate the ability to achieve others. 5.1.2 Time Frsmes The projects are divided into three periods. The first series of projects are demonstration projects that should begin immediately. For the most part, these are simple projects that will be highly visible, hurr" significant impact and should be completed within the first year after the plan is adopted. The second set of projects is labeled "next steps." Some of these are more advanced projects while others are continuations of projects that began during the demonstration period. The next step projects should be completed within the second and third year of the plan. The final steps are long term and forward thinking. They may evolve into shorter tenn projects as opportunities present themselves. The strategy board and its recommendations represent a 'living document." As time goes by and implementation proceeds, some priorities will shift while other ones will arise. The implementation strategy board should be evaluated periodically and no less than annually. This evaluation process will allow for finished tasks to be indicated on the board, for responsibitities to be shifted berwien parties, and for time frames to be adjusted for individual projects. Ellensburg has a tremendous track record of innovation and success. The ongoing commercial success will depend on continued partnerships among many different groups. It is only through this continued spirit of partnership and commitment to a vision that the recommendations in this study can be successful. Fortunately, Ellensburg is poised to succeed in these efforts as it has in so many others. 4T Strategy Board for Downtown Ellensburg r Continue toprcgr"m fl'6b on Lllashurglown Squre, . hnDlffit SWc@rcrstflar co;tin6tirrn\vilhprrkingor drixed use. . \!mkrvith CWtl on ffirlrlcmrk6 space lied wilhUnivmitj 1mgraro Tlpare ofElleuhrgwll @i,ims to be ( whlsl for inrurutlt'c ry6an idvftalEilloD ofoh,gcillffi ili tEllfrsa wtiotl6f illngs to extErique, 16liEuwt ofFntruclt owflffi on up[*r r Conrlruct Ellerob(g Torvn Sqoue. . (}nds!et, work eitll proJx,ty otnm on upper lloor space rmwation. Irnplmmt Ellmsbwg Gatetvay rr N"E Comcr. Auluiropmpaty fr SW cornur 6lmVlTqt15. l4t'oand qir linc corvorliin r snrce ur1 crpluo nulcn spae.' Strategies First Steps 2016 Next Steps '17-tI8 Long Term Steps '18-'22 Goal . DocMqt rU ntrunl Eucslcs ifl pdvatc itr\rshuqt dNntost as scparatc hrilding pcmit rcport. As nerr const[ction oJ'\,isitos cenlergtLhe oldI{et Plant ones lo fruition, paa{ner lor improvmenh d Unir'dity Way,. PlNuc downto$n emtrurrity Cstd. . Host hr\,*lnenl l'ffi e\rrt tlto to lhrw _yEnrr. r lrDplqtrcot $tsck$pa inplolcNctrt to lvdts StreeL . Discusr cmplolcr rssistcd hoging ftild *iti C\VIJ and oilrer nrajor employcs. DN iltov n E I I e il t bt t g w il I efl)an.l kt iilchkls ll;ulcr hMtand I;aivil$ln' W.!l'os nqlat coryiJba Itirfutuni tm'umLtnt. rvsi ed LhivdJily dov,tlsrn CC Zsr ' Explore cftilivs Plssnuking . Conl.ilucto idillilylostiorr forn bicvclc iicxlly mnntnity sith ncw nckr, identiliod'!rfe rorios", and ouier tactiB. . Begin iftplenrenlrtion of ron- f, oturizc{ tran$Iorlal.i0o phn . Implmmt crcitiw Pliemaking . Conlinu€ implonmtatim of ooF rnolorizod tmroporhlim plur . brplmort cirubtor tluougl dormtorvn to Univcnih otrd Hotcls- . (lonlinte lo e{rand CrcaLivE Placmliug . !/ork nith L'l!'U on omplete pkcry spacctiul wifr llnirosity prugnn$ nB Inwkilttlhkt fuit'@il ('tl'ti, [t^rilkMn, I nlvtlqle 90, ercl rha r$t offtllrnrhtrydlllit ahncedand bryran'd, . Implqtrcnt phrsc II of rvafindiug p.hr. . t)pm meetilg l'acility and do$ntolrn holcl. . I)o'elop ray6nding lrlm. . (:oatdnllalcrddilional pa*ing dolvrto$il should the ekntc pail. mo\rc- . Bcgin discussionrrvilh lrofrcrtrl ormqon downionn holel. . f)psn visitoF qteron Ellcrburg ToRr Squre, r Implmmtphase one ofnaylinding Pls. . Co$tuelptrkilgrcsouFou Old(imeryBuilding. . H6l inruualldrki!8 su{unit to disussisgc. l'lsltars vill alg,cilqtryr vrit,!, of dccmrnyJutbr oilnN hth ttl ilN hu;tof !!llentht* ntl' th4$:houl lhe Ctty o lotg.s tila a t e I I c urutc |isiktc\xilanct,