Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAbout2026-11-23_CDS_SS_DOCS_ KITTITAS COUNTY COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT SERVICES 2026 STUDY SESSION STAFF REPORT STUDY SESSION DATE: November 23',2026 TOPIC: Update: TDR Workplan ACTION REQUESTED- None BACKGROUND: Kittitas County established an emergency moratorium regarding the Transfer of Development Rights(TDRs) on June 8',2026 (Res. 2026-101). On Augst 4th 2026 Kittitas County held the required hearing per RCW 36.70A.390 extending the moratorium on TDRs and incorporated a 1-year work plan(Res.2026-133). The workplan identified 5 tasks to be completed: ■ Task 1 (Research/Analysis)completed by October 2026. ■ Task 2(Options& Stakeholder Engagement)completed by January 13', 2026. ■ Task 3 (Drafting&Technical Review)completed by April 14', 2027. ■ Task 4(Public Review,Recommendation&Adoption)completed by July 141',2027. ■ Task 5 (Close out&Ongoing Monitoring)completed by August 41, 2027. Task 1 is completed and we are currently working on Task 2. We have completed the certificate stakeholders meeting portion of this task and our Public Open House will be held Tuesday November 24', 2026.We are in the process of re-scheduling our Joint Mtg with the Board and Planning Commission, at the request of the certificate stakeholders even though this not a requirement of the workplan. We have yet to hear back from all of our City Stakeholders regarding their interest in a TDR program. Clarity regarding their intentions will assist us in providing the BOCC with the context necessary to complete Task 2. INTERACTION: CDS. RECOMMENDATION: None. HANDLING: None. ATTACHMENTS: Work Plan. LEAD STAFF: Chad Bala, CDS Director& Jeremy Johnston,Long Range Planner EXHIBIT A WORK PLAN FOR THE REVIEW,ANALYSIS,AND POTENTIAL REVISION OR REPEAL OF THE TRANSFER OF DEVELOPMENT RIGHTS PROGRAM Kittitas County Community Development Services August 2026 Purpose To provide the Board of County Commissioners with a clear, structured, and time- bound process for evaluating the existing TDR program (KCC Chapter 17.13), directly addressing the deficiencies identified in the Washington State Department of Commerce comment letters dated March 27, 2026 and May 22, 2026, ensuring full consistency with the Growth Management Act (particularly RCW 36.70A.070(5), .110, and .030(38)), coordinating with the 2026 Comprehensive Plan and development regulations updates, and determining whether to comprehensively revise the TDR regulations or repeal the program with appropriate transition measures. Duration August 4, 2026—August 4, 2027 (one year). The work plan may be updated by Board direction. A subsequent public hearing and new findings would be required for any further six- month renewal. Primary Objectives 1. Analyze current TDR code, program history, usage, and outcomes against GMA requirements and Commerce comments. 2. Evaluate and compare the two main policy paths (revision vs. repeal). 3. Conduct stakeholder and public engagement. 4. Produce legally sound, GMA-compliant legislative proposals (amendments or repeal ordinance)ready for Planning Commission and BOCC adoption before moratorium expiration. 5. Maintain internal consistency with the adopted 2026 Comprehensive Plan and related updates (PUD, land use/zoning table, housing policies). Task 1: Research,Analysis & Legal Review Timeline: August 4—October 14, 2026 • Compile complete inventory of existing TDR activity(certificates issued, letters of intent outstanding, transfers completed, and sending/receiving sites involved. • Perform gap analysis of KCC 17.13 against: o Commerce May 22, 2026 comments (definitions in 17.13.015, receiving sites in 17.13.030(e)—(g), exchange rate clarity and application in 17.13.080, overall purpose and rural-to-rural risk). o GMA rural character and natural resource land protection standards. o Commerce March 27, 2026 comments on related land use/PUD/LAMIRD issues. • Research TDR best practices and model codes from comparable Washington counties. • Legal review of vested rights, takings exposure, and transition issues if repeal is selected. • Assess program effectiveness to date and interaction with the newly adopted 2026 Comprehensive Plan. Milestone/Deliverable: Staff technical memo to Board and Planning Commission summarizing analysis and preliminary options by October 14, 2026. Task 2: Option Development& Stakeholder Engagement Timeline: October 15 —Januaryl3, 2027 Option A—Comprehensive Revision • Specific fixes to purpose statement, receiving site definition and eligibility. Limit primarily to cities and UGAs with demonstrated urban infrastructure/services. • Strictly condition or remove broad rural/PUD/long plat options, exchange rate table and application language (clarify "additional units" on top of underlying zoning; remove or de-emphasize rural category), definitions, and cross-references. • Consider new or amended TDR policies in Rural Element. Option B—Repeal with Transition Provisions (Honor existing certificates for their full term; no new applications) • Prepare comparative white paper (pros/cons, legal/fiscal/implementation implications and GMA alignment). • Conduct stakeholder engagement: meetings with stakeholders (i.e. cities, developers, etc.), and consultation with Planning Commission. • Provide direct notice to holders of existing certificates and current applicants. Milestone/Deliverable: Options white paper+ engagement summary to Board by mid- December 2026; Board direction on preferred path by January 13, 2027. Task 3: Drafting & Technical Review Timeline: January 14—April 14, 2027 • Prepare full draft ordinance based on Board direction (either comprehensive amendments to KCC 17.13 plus any conforming changes, or repeal ordinance with transition language). • Initiate SEPA Review and associated public comment period • Prepare any necessary companion Comprehensive Plan amendments (e.g., consolidated TDR policies in Rural Element). • Full legal sufficiency review and internal consistency check with zoning code, PUD chapter, LAMIRD provisions, and other development regulations. • Complete SEPA documentation and staff report with findings. Milestone/Deliverable: Complete draft ordinance package and staff report ready for Planning Commission review by April 14, 2027. Task 4: Public Review, Recommendation & Adoption Timeline: April 15 —July 14, 2027 • Planning Commission public hearing, deliberation, and formal recommendation (April— May). • CDS Staff and legal review of Planning Commission's formal recommendation for consistency with the Growth Management Act. • Board of County Commissioners public hearing(s), deliberation, and adoption of ordinance(s) (May—July). • Post-adoption implementation tasks: update application forms and tracking systems, staff/permit reviewer training, public information materials, and notification to affected parties. Milestone/Deliverable: Final ordinance adopted by July 14, 2027, with clear effective date and transition rules. Task 5: Close-Out& Ongoing Monitoring Timeline: July 15 —August 4, 2027 (and beyond as needed) • Final written report to the Board summarizing work plan outcomes, ordinance changes (or repeal), and implementation status. • Preparation (if necessary) for any required six-month renewal hearing with updated findings and work plan. • Post-moratorium monitoring of TDR activity(if program continues) and compliance with new rules. Success Metrics • Clear Board direction on preferred path(revise or repeal)by end of 2026. • Draft ordinance(s)that directly and comprehensively address all Commerce-identified deficiencies. • Documented, meaningful stakeholder input incorporated into final product. • Zero new TDR applications accepted during the moratorium period. • Adopted regulations (or repeal)that are internally consistent with the 2026 Comprehensive Plan and demonstrably protective of rural character and natural resource lands while directing growth to appropriate urban locations, all being consistent with the Growth Management Act This Work Plan may be amended from time to time by Board direction to reflect new information, resource availability, or evolving circumstances. Workplan Table Purpose: Provide a structured process to evaluate the existing TDR program (KCC Ch. 17.13), address deficiencies identified by staff and the WA Dept. of Commerce (letters dated March 27 &May 22, 2026), ensure GMA compliance, and determine whether to comprehensively revise the regulations or repeal the program. The work plan satisfies RCW 36.70A.390 requirements for extending the moratorium beyond six months. Duration: August 4, 2026—August 4, 2027 (one year). Quarterly progress reports to the Board of County Commissioners. PHASE TINIELINE FOCUS; KEYACTIVITIES DELIVERABLES& MILESTONES •Inventory existing TDR activity(certificates, Task 1: LOIs,transfers,agreements)•Gap analysis of KCC 17.13 vs.Commerce comments&GMA Research, August 4—Oct 14, Staff technical memo to BOCC&Planning Commission Analysis&Legal 2026 •Research best practices from other WA summarizing findings and preliminary options(by Oct 14,2026) counties•Legal review(vested rights, Review takings,transition issues)•Assess program effectiveness&Comp Plan interaction •Develop two detailed options: A. Comprehensive revision of KCC 17.13(fix definitions,receiving sites,exchange rates, Task 2:Option add infrastructure requirements) B.Repeal 2026) Development& Oct 15—Jan 13, with transition provisions•Prepare 'Options white paper+engagement summary Board(Dec •Board direction on preferred path(revise vs.repeal)by Jan 13, Stakeholder 2027 comparative white paper(pros/cons, 2027 Engagement legal/fiscal implications,GMA alignment) Stakeholder workshops(cities,landowners, developers,ag/forest interests)•Public open house&direct notice to existing LOI holders E •Prepare full draft ordinance(s)based on Board direction•Initiate SEPA review•Draft Task 3•Drafting any companion Comp Plan amendments(e.g., &Technical Jan 14—April 14, consolidated TDR section in Rural Element)• Complete draft ordinance package and staff report ready for Review 2027 Legal sufficiency review by Prosecuting Planning Commission review(by April 14,2027) Attorney•Internal consistency check with zoning,PUD,LAMIRD,and other dev regs Complete SEPA documentation&staff report i •Planning Commission public hearing, Task 4:Public deliberation&recommendation(Apr—May) BOCC public hearing(s),deliberation& Review, Apr 15—July 14, Final ordinance adopted by July 14,2027(prior to moratorium adoption of ordinance(s)(May—June)•Post- expiration)with clear effective date and transition rules Recommendation 2027 adoption implementation:update forms, P ) &Adoption tracking systems,staff training,public info materials •Final written report to Board on work plan Task 5:Close- outcomes and implementation status Out&Ongoing July 15—August 4, Preparation for any required 6-month renewal Final close-out report to BOCC;smooth transition to new or Monitoring 2027 hearing(updated findings&work plan)• repealed regulations g Post-moratorium monitoring of TDR activity (if program continues)and compliance KITTITAS COUNTY COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT SERVICES 2026 STUDY SESSION STAFF REPORT STUDY SESSION DATE: November 23rd, 2026 TOPIC: Productivity,Workload Management, and Employee Morale Initiative ACTION REQUESTED: Direction/Approval BACKGROUND: KCCDS has been operating under reduced staffing levels since September 1,2026. KCCDS has implemented a staffing coverage program that utilizes current staffing on a rotational schedule covering the recently vacated positions and due to staff reductions has continued to experience sustained workload demands while covering vacancy areas. INTERACTION: CDS. RECOMMENDATION: None. HANDLING: None. ATTACHMENTS: Productivity,Workload Management,and Employee Morale Initiative LEAD STAFF: Chad Bala, CDS Director Productivity,Workload Management, Employee Morale Initiative To: Kittitas Board of County Commissioners From: Kittitas County Community Development Services Department Subject: Proposed 90-Day Operational Pilot Program Purpose Kittitas County Community Development Services(KCCDS)is experiencing sustained workload demands while operating with limited staffing resources.The Department is proposing a temporary,90-day operational pilot to create dedicated staff time for application processing,building-plan review,permit issuance,backlog management,and workflow improvements. The pilot is intended to improve the Department's use of existing resources,reduce interruption-driven inefficiencies,support employee morale, and maintain timely,consistent service to County residents,contractors,and businesses. Proposed Operational Changes For an initial 90-day period,KCCDS proposes to: • Temporarily suspend general walk-in counter service. • Continue all required building inspections and essential departmental functions. • Temporarily suspend customer access through telephone,email,scheduled appointments,and other appropriate communication methods. • Provide in-person assistance,when necessary,at the discretion of the Community Development Services Director. • Establish protected work time for staff to process applications,complete plan reviews,issue permits,address outstanding work,and improve internal workflows. This proposal does not eliminate public access to the Department.Rather,it shifts routine counter interactions to scheduled and remote service channels so staff can dedicate uninterrupted time to time- sensitive technical and administrative work. Performance Measures and Accountability The Department will evaluate the pilot using measurable workload and service-delivery indicators, including: 1. Plan-review production:Number and type of completed plan reviews,including full,quick, foundation-only,and correction reviews. 2. Application and permit processing: Applications processed,permits issued,and changes in turnaround time. 3. Outstanding workload: Open inventory,aged applications,and backlog reduction. 4. Service access: Customer contacts and appointments managed through telephone,email,and scheduled in-person meetings. 5. Operational improvements: Workflow changes implemented and their effect on consistency, efficiency,and staff capacity. 6. Employee feedback: Staff observations regarding interruptions,workload manageability, productivity,and morale. The Department will provide the Board with a progress update after 30 days and a final evaluation at the conclusion of the 90-day pilot. The Department's target is an approximate 10-15 percent improvement in productivity,recognizing that outcomes will be influenced by application volume,project complexity, correction cycles,and staffing availability. Anticipated Benefits The proposed pilot is expected to: • Improve staff productivity through focused,uninterrupted work time. • Increase the Department's ability to complete plan reviews and issue permits efficiently. • Reduce outstanding workload and improve management of aging applications. • Improve consistency and accountability in application and permit processing. • Allow the Department to evaluate and refine internal workflows. • Reduce workplace stress associated with constant counter interruptions. Support a more sustainable working environment and stronger employee morale. Requested Board Action Kittitas County Community Development Services respectfully requests that the Board of County Commissioners authorize the Productivity,Workload Management,and Employee Morale Initiative as a temporary 90-day operational pilot program. Authorization would allow the Department to temporarily modify public counter operations while continuing building inspections,essential departmental functions,scheduled appointments,and reasonable customer access through alternative service methods. Conclusion This temporary pilot is a proactive management response to current workload and staffing challenges.It is not intended to permanently reduce public access or departmental services.Instead,it is designed to provide staff with the dedicated time and working conditions needed to process applications,complete technical reviews,address accumulated work,improve service delivery,and support employee morale. At the conclusion of the 90-day period,KCCDS will return to the Board with measured results,operational findings,and recommendations regarding future counter-service and workflow practices.