Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAbout2026-09-22 6:00 PM - Planning Commission Public Hearing - Minutes KITTITAS COUNTY PLANNING COMMISSION PUBLIC HEARING MINUTES Courthouse RM 201 , ELLENSBURG Special Meeting TUESDAY 6: 00 PM September 22 , 2026 Board members present: Joseph Pearson, Pat Deneen, Warren Taylor, Tyler Morris, Judith Jackson, and Bill Hinkle . Absent: None Others : Chad Bala, CDS Director; Jeremy Johnston, Long Range Planner; Ellie Myers, Planner; Jessica Miller, Office Administrator and four (4) members of the public . The meeting was called to order at 6: 00 P.M. CALL TO ORDER - Roll Call CITIZEN COMMENTS (1 min. time limit) There were no citizen comments . APPROVAL OF MINUTES COMMISSIONER HINKLE moved to approve the minutes from August 4, 2026 as presented. COMMISSIONER MORRIS seconded. Discussion - none . Motion passed, 6-0 . COMMISSIONER MORRIS moved to approve the minutes from August 8, 2026 as presented. COMMISSIONER DENEEN seconded. Discussion - none . Motion passed, 6-0 . COMMISSIONER MORRIS moved to approve the minutes from September 8, 2026 as presented. COMMISSIONER DENEEN seconded. Discussion - none . Motion passed, 6-0 . CHAIR TAYLOR opened the public hearing. NEW BUSINESS 2026 PROPOSED DEVELOPMENT REGULATIONS (PUBLIC HEARING-ACTION REQUESTED) LONG RANGE PLANNER JEREMY JOHHNSTON stated there are three items on the agenda for the public hearing. He recommended going through each item separately and making a recommendation for each item individually. The Planning Commissioners agreed to the process . 2026-9-22 MINUTES 1 ITEM 26-01 - SEPA APPEAL REVISION - LONG RANGE PLANNER JOHNSTON presented the item. This item has been brought to the Planning Commissioners as it needs to be addressed immediately. It came to staff' s attention that our current process is ambiguous in a way that is described in the regulations and need more clarity. The proposed amendments involves revisions to Title' s 15, 15A, and 15B. Recent SEPA appeals have identified inconsistencies in the County SEPA procedures . The purpose of the proposed updates are to clarify the intended processes for SEPA appeals as they relate to administrative and legislative SEPA actions . There are two distinct appeal processes . The first one is administrative; this determination is made independently or in conjunction with general land use permits, for example : Plats and Conditional Use Permits . The second is legislative; this determination is associated with legislative items, for example : Comprehensive Plan and Development Regulation Amendments . The proposed changes would clarify the appeal procedures for each type of SEPA determination. There were no comments received. Staff is requesting a recommendation from the Planning Commission for this item. COMMISSIONER HINKLE requested that the Planning Commissioners receive bill reports, which is a report that includes recommendations, suggested amendments, or tracked changes . COMMISSIONER DENEEN asked if the provided SEPA Environmental Checklist is the current one used right now. LONG RANGE PLANNER JOHNSTON stated that yes, it is . CHAIR TAYLOR opened public comment . There was no public comment . CHAIR TAYLOR closed public comment . COMMISSIONER HINKLE moved to recommend approval to the Board of County Commissioners on item 26-01 . COMMISSIONER MORRIS seconded. Discussion - none . Motion passed, 6-0 . ITEM 26-02 - ADU APPLICATION REVISIONS - LONG RANGE PLANNER JOHNSTON presented this item. He stated this revision will simplify our accessory dwelling unit permit process . In 2025, the County adopted the ADU regulations as required under House Bill 1337 . Staff discovered that the application process (Permitted Administratively) retained discretionary criteria and a notice of application process . The Washington State Department of Commerce guidance describes the goal of HB 1337 as allowing for ADU development with processes and standards no more 2026-9-22 MINUTES 2 rigorous than Single Family Residents (SFR) development . The SFR development process does not include the Notice of Application process (NOA) or discretionary criteria. The proposed amendments would remove the NOA process and all discretionary criteria for ADU applications . The result should simplify ADU development and likely decrease permitting timelines . There was one comment received from Fish & Wildlife . Staff is requesting a recommendation from the Planning Commission for this item. COMMISSIONER MORRIS stated just to clarify, the changes just involve the updating the application process and not changing the regulations . LONG RANGE PLANNER JOHNSTON stated yes that this is correct . CDS DIRECTOR BALA stated this is part of the affordable housing goal that the state has been mandating. Staff will continue doing the critical areas review process, review for Fish & Wildlife stream buffers and wetland buffers . CHAIR TAYLOR opened public comment . There was no public comment . CHAIR TAYLOR closed public comment . COMMISSIONER HINKLE moved to recommend approval to the Board of County Commissioner for item 26-02 . COMMISSIONER JACKSON seconded. Discussion - none . Motion passed, 6-0 . ITEM 26-03 SHORT TERM RENTAL REGULATIONS - LONG RANGE PLANNER JOHNSTON presented this item. The Short Term Rental Committee was created in March 2024 to determine if there is a need for STR regulations . Following many monthly meetings and a community survey, the committee determined a need for regulations . In 2025, the Board of County Commissioners (BOCC) tasked the committee with the development of STR regulations via Resolution 2025-093 . The proposed regulations were approved by the STR Committee in December of 2025 . The current version includes the changes requested following County legal review. The community survey showed that 600 of the respondents were in favor of regulations . The primary issues included noise, drain on local resources and parking. LONG RANGE PLANNER JOHNSTON summarized the STR regulations, all short-term rentals operating within Kittitas County Unincorporated areas and UGA' s would require a permit that would be renewed annually. There would be exceptions to owner occupied rentals, PUD' s and MPR' s where short-term rentals are expressly noted in the associated development agreement or final development plan and regulations applicability may be subject to Interlocal Agreements . STR' s would be permitted in all zones 2026-9-22 MINUTES 3 that allow SFR' s . A short-term rental management plan would be required which would address issues like parking, fire life safety, noise, and burn ban notification to renters . The short- term rental management plan also requires a site plan indicating the location of fire suppression/notification tools, structure ingress/egress and carbon monoxide detectors . The requirement of decibel meters in primary exterior communal gathering spaces would also be required. Following legal review of the proposed regulations, they suggested we have a 2 tier class system. One is more inexpensive and would be the meter that would be required initially. If there were three confirmed violations as indicated by the meter, then the short-term rental owner would be required to update to a class one decibel meter system. In response to the feedback previously received by the Planning Commission, staff has prepared another version of the regulations which are identical to the ones provided but excludes all of the violation sections and decibel requirements . It would strictly rely on the current noise ordinance for enforcement . A copy was not provided to the Planning Commissioners for the hearing. There were no comments received on this item. CDS DIRECTOR BALA stated that there is an option to continue this hearing so that the Planning Commissioners could review the draft regulations without the violation section and decibel requirements . The Planning Commissioners agreed to hear public comment and then make the decision. CHAIR TAYLOR opened public comment . Jessica Karkaker - Resident, Short Term Rental Committee Member, Lodging Tax Advisory Committee Member - Ms . Karraker pointed out a few red flags which included on page 103 of the packet, violation 17 . 63 . 060 the noise violation does not reference the Kittitas County Code . On the next page, section (f) does reference the code . She would ask that staff look at that and ask legal if the Kittitas County Code, since it is outlined as quiet hours, be addressed in that spot . On page 104, section b, item 2, it states the second confirmed noise violation compliance letter and 60 day permit suspension, she thinks it should be noted that hypothetically you have a 60 day permit violation, you are not allowed to rent through the rental platform, you have every single weekend booked out for those days and you have to go in and cancel all those reservations . She states that after three cancellations in a row, Airbnb will suspend and remove your listing. The 3rd party entity controls the listing and way of doing business . She stated staff should 2026-9-22 MINUTES 4 be cautious about how they go about suspending permits . Once Airbnb removes a listing, you cannot go and have a different person list that address . It is now officially removed and no longer allowed to be on Airbnb; they track it by the address . Ms . Karraker stated that she feels it is important that when staff begins to enforce these types of noise ordinance violations, it should be the same across the board, including special use permits . Gina Peckman - Resident, Short Term Rental Committee Member - Ms . Peckman read her statement into the record. She spoke in support of the Short Term Rental Ordinance . Currently there are no rules around short-term rentals, not for safety, occupancy, or accountability. Neighbors like Chelan County, Leavenworth, Rosly, and Cle Elum all have regulations . She stated this is about guiding an industry that already exists . AirDNA counted just under 1100 active short-term rentals in this county since 2024 . These businesses are operating today using our roads, our water systems, and our emergency services, while contributing nothing structured back. She states the draft ordinance is written for everyone . It respects HOA rules, it requires a 24/7 local contact so a neighbor has someone to call . It protects a property owner' s right to earn income, while protecting the family next door' s right to sleep. She is in support of moving forward with the STR regulations . Amy McGuffin - CEO of Kittitas County Chamber of Commerce, Short Term Rental Committee Member, Liaison for the Lodging Tax Advisory Committee - Ms . McGuffin stated that the STR committee took a long time researching and questioning back and forth to put this product before the Planning Commissioners . She stated even though there is reservation regarding the noise ordinance section, she recommends that the Commissioners take the experts that were at the committee level and move forward with some of the restrictions because it does give staff the opportunity to regulate and follow through with this process . Chelan County, Leavenworth, Roslyn and Cle Elum have had issues with their regulations, but they have been able to work it out after finding out what was and was not working. Ms . McGuffin is in favor of moving forward with the regulations . CHAIR TAYLOR closed public comment . CHAIR TAYLOR asked about occupancy limits and if it had been a topic of discussion. LONG RANGE PLANNER JOHNSTON stated it was discussed in the committee for at least a year. The issue is that it is a residential structure and there is no objective 2026-9-22 MINUTES 5 framework in which to limit occupancy. The potential occupancy requirements were abandoned after speaking to the building department . COMMISSIONER HINKLE stated he feels the owner should be responsible for how many people occupy the rental . COMMISSIONER MORRIS asked if there will be a probationary period with this item. LONG RANGE PLANNER JOHNSTON stated there would be a probationary period or a delay if it went before the Board of County Commissioners for approval . COMMISSIONER MORRIS clarified he meant if it gets enacted, would it be reviewed in two years to see if it is actually working. LONG RANGE PLANNER JOHNSTON stated that with a new set of regulations, there will always be adjustments and changes made to them in the years following to change what isn' t working. LONG RANGE PLANNER JOHNSTON clarified the violation section of the draft regulations . COMMISSIONER DENEEN stated he is 100% opposed to the decibel meters . He stated in the document he wrote up and was provided; we should take 18 months to collect some real data to see if the complaints are coming from the same location every time . COMMISSIONER MORRIS stated he recommend that the Planning Commissioners adopt the regulations all the way through Violation 1a and put something in the regulations stating it gets reviewed after four months . COMMISSIONER PEARSON agrees with Commissioner Morris and stated he doesn' t feel the homeowner should be required to put the noise decibel reader in the home until there are violations . LONG RANGE PLANNER JOHNSTON stated the problem is how do you confirm those are violations without the decibel reader. COMMISSIONER DENEEN stated he is opposed to putting decibel meters on anyone' s house or having business owners spending any more money to run the business . He would like the county to collect 18-24 months of data where someone calls, makes a complaint, staff tells them if you want to put a noise detector on your place then show me what the noise detector says to confirm the complaint . He is not opposed to having regulations and having everyone sign up so we know who they are and require fire life and safety. COMMISSIONER JACKSON stated that maybe we could all agree to strike anything having to do with the noise meter and move forward. CHAIR TAYLOR asked if there was a way to create a noise ordinance within the regulations . COMMISSIONER DENEEN requested the Planning Commissioner receive a copy of the draft short term 2026-9-22 MINUTES 6 rental regulations without the noise violation as soon as possible and continue this to the next meeting. COMMISSIONER DENEEN moved to continue this hearing item to the next meeting, for the Planning Commissioner to get the proposed new ordinances and to continue to take public comment at the next meeting. COMMISSIONER JACKSON seconded. Discussion - CDS DIRECTOR BALA stated that there are individuals in this room and not in this room that spent two years working on this product and it was a hard item to create, he wants to make sure that their work, time and effort is not minimized. Motion passed, 6- 0 . TDR WORK PLAN UPDATE LONG RANGE PLANNER JOHNSTON provided an update on the TDR program and plan. He stated the county is currently under a moratorium due to some issues pointed out by the Department of Commerce during a comprehensive plan update that the regulations as they currently exist, there was concern whether it was consistent with the Growth Management Act . Staff is currently working through the work plan that was approved by the Board of County Commissioners over the summer. The first task in the work plan was due by October 14th and has already been completed. Staff took a look at our current code, the letters that were submitted by Commerce, and based general requirements under the Growth Management Act trying to find where we had inconsistency. Staff completed an inventory of all of our existing TDR activity and compiled all of the TDR certificates that have been issued. This total came to 322, which included the ones that are about to be issued. Staff completed a comparative analysis of other jurisdictions TDR programs . There was one jurisdiction that has been successful and that is King County. COMMISSIONER HINKLE stated there is a lot of good information being provided. He stated he would like make a motion to approve Option B. LONG RANGE PLANNER JOHNSTON stated staff is not looking for a recommendation or formal direction. He stated staff is just updating the Planning Commissioners . COMMISSIONER HINKLE stated that he thinks the Board of County Commissioners should move forward with Option B. He stated that he would like to make a motion that the Planning Commission recommend the Board of County Commissioners do Option B. There was no second and the motion was withdrawn. CDS DIRECTOR BALA shared that staff sent the draft reviews to Commerce for their review, including Commissioner Deneen' s draft . Staff is waiting for their reply. LONG RANGE PLANNER 2026-9-22 MINUTES 7 JOHNSTON stated that if Commerce comes back saying that rural to rural transfers are acceptable, he will ask them for the code citation verification. As part of the task two stakeholder meetings, staff will be meeting with the cities and Commerce as well . OLD BUSINESS There was no old business . OTHER BUSINESS - No Action to be taken There was no other business . CHAIR TAYLOR concluded the Kittitas County Planning Commission public hearing. Public meeting ended at 7 : 12 pm. 2026-9-22 MINUTES 8