Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAbout2026-08-04 6:00 PM - Planning Commission - Minutes KITTITAS COUNTY PLANNING COMMISSION MEETING MINUTES Courthouse RM 201 , ELLENSBURG Special Meeting TUESDAY 6 : 00 PM August 4 , 2026 Board members present: Joseph Pearson, Pat Deneen, Warren Taylor, Tyler Morris, Judith Jackson, and Bill Hinkle . Absent: None Board of County Commissioners present: Brett Wachsmith and Laura Osiadacz . Others : Chad Bala, CDS Director; Jeremy Johnston, Long Range Planner; Jamey Ayling, Planning Manager; Stephanie Hartung, Deputy Prosecutor; Jessica Miller, Office Administrator and two (2) members of the public. The meeting was called to order at 6: 00 P.M. CALL TO ORDER - Roll Call CHAIR TAYLOR mentioned that the Planning Commissioners received an email from Scott Carlson today resigning from the Planning Commission. He thanked him for his time and efforts . CITIZEN COMMENTS (1 min. time limit) There were no citizen comments . APPROVAL OF MINUTES COMMISSIONER HINKLE moved to approve the minutes from July 14, 2026 as presented. COMMISSIONER JACKSON seconded. Discussion - none . Motion passed, 6-0 . NEW BUSINESS INTRODUCTION TO PROPOSED 2026 DEVELOPMENT REGULATION UPDATES : SHORT TERM RENTALS LONG RANGE PLANNER JEREMY JOHNSTON presented this item and stated that this is an introduction with no action requested. He stated that staff received the final product today from legal . Staff is requesting feedback, identify any blind spots and to field any questions . The Annual Docket was suspended for 2025 and 2026 for the Comprehensive Plan update . Usually staff runs the development regulation cycle along the annual docket process but the CDS Director can initiate a cycle at their discretion. 2026-8-4 MINUTES 1 The Short Term Rental regulations are being considered for this upcoming cycle along with a few other issues . LONG RANGE PLANNER JOHNSTON provided the background on the Short Term Rental Committee and the draft regulations that were created out of the committee . The draft regulations were based on the results of a community survey and extensive discussion among the committee members . The survey was completed in 2025 and 60% of the respondents were in favor of regulations . The primary issues were noise, drain on local resources and parking. All short-term rentals operating within Kittitas County Unincorporated areas and UGA' s will require a permit to be renewed annually. The permits are administrative, and immediate neighbors will be notified of the application. Exceptions will apply to owner occupied rentals, PUD' s and MPR' s where short term rentals are expressly noted in the associated development agreement and the applicability may be subject to Interlocal Agreements . Short Term Rentals will be permitted in all zones that allow Single Family Residents . A short-term rental management plan is required which addresses issues like parking, fire life safety, noise and burn ban notification to renters . The short-term rental management plan also requires a site plan indicating the location of fire suppression/notification tools, structure ingress/egress and carbon monoxide detectors . The requirement of a decibel meter in primary exterior communal gathering spaces was included in the regulations . The current draft regulations include a 2 tier class system for the decibel meter requirements . The first-class system would be used as an evidentiary mechanism. Then if an operator receives three violations and those violations would include, if a neighbor called in and made a complaint about the noise, the county would request the readout from the decibel meter. The decimal meter limit would need to reach 80 decibels and if they exceeded that over a 30 minute period they would be sited with a violation. If they receive three of the confirmed violations, they would be required to upgrade to a level class 1 meter. This is a more legally defensible meter. After a total of 6 violations over the course of a year, the permit could potentially be revoked. COMMISSIONER HINKLE asked for staff to point out the changes that were made to the regulations by legal and staff after the committee members approved them. LONG RANGE PLANNER JOHNSTON stated that 90% of the changes were made to the decibel meter section, to make that section legally defensible . 2026-8-4 MINUTES 2 COMMISSIONER DENEEN asked for an explanation of the 30 minute timeframe . LONG RANGE PLANNER JOHNSTON stated that if they get spikes that go over the 80 meter decibels within a 30 minute window then it would potentially be a violation when the spikes go over the 30 minute period, and if someone made a complaint . COMMISSIONER PEARSON stated that we already have a noise violation ordinance . He asked what the cost would be for the annual renewal of this permit . LONG RANGE PLANNER JOHNSTON stated that the cost has not been established but there has been internal conversation about the permit process and fees . He stated Kittitas County does have a noise ordinance, the ability for the Sheriff' s Department to respond to and enforce each complaint throughout the county is difficult . COMMISSIONER OSIADACZ gave an explanation of why the Short- Term Rental committee was formed. She stated when the Commissioners started having meet and greets out in the community, the community was out in arms about short-term rentals . This was initiated by the people of Kittitas County. The biggest concern was the noise . They believe everyone should have property rights . They receive weekly emailed complaints regarding this . She stated the way the noise ordinance code is written, it is unable to be enforced through the Sheriff' s Department . Since a short-term rental is not a business, they do not have to abide by the same rules as a business . COMMISSIONER MORRIS stated the county has a strict site plan requirement for when someone is building a new structure, are they going to have the same requirements for short-term rentals? LONG RANGE PLANNER JOHNSTON stated no, for new structures the applicant is required to demonstrate the setbacks, etc. The short-term rental site plans we would require the applicant to demonstrate where the carbon monoxide detectors are, where the fire alarms and suppression tools are, where the burn ban postings will be located, etc. Discussion in the committee occurred around having fire life safety inspections but they decided against it due to cost and not enough staff. There would be a self-certification stating all the requirements have been met . The hope with these regulations is that we gain compliance with short term rental owners, there is a permit process, we have regulations in place, and the majority of people will follow them. COMMISSIONER MORRIS stated his concern is that we are putting in a regulation that is effectively doing nothing. 2026-8-4 MINUTES 3 COMMISSIONER HINKLE stated the way the regulations are written, it makes the homeowner responsible; he feels that the people who are concerned about the noise should be the ones documenting the sound from their house and reporting it . He also stated he has not seen any successful regulations in other counties or states . COMMISSIONER JACKSON stated that she doesn' t feel like having the decibel meter at the beginning of the permit period is right . She stated that if they have three offenses that have been reported and confirmed then they should start with the level 1 meter. LONG RANGE PLANNER JOHNSTON stated the tricky part would be how would we confirm the violation without having some objective meter. COMMISSIONER JACKSON clarified that it would be an annual permit . What is the timeframe for receiving the 6 confirmed complaints to potentially revoke the license? LONG RANGE PLANNER JOHNSTON stated that if the person had three violations within the 365 day period, they would be upgraded to the level 2 meter. If the person didn' t receive another violation in the next 6 months, they could go back to the level 1 meter. COMMISSIONER HINKLE stated he has frustration around regulations that are put into place that can' t be enforced or adjudicated, he believes this is the wrong direction and that it will create a ton of litigation. COMMISSIONER WACHSMITH asked if the Planning Commission was in favor of no short-term rental regulation. COMMISSIONER JACKSON stated that she is not in favor of the decibel meters, but if there were cheaper options or if they would be given out at the application time that would be better or if they became required after so many incidences . She stated she would be in favor of some parking regulations . COMMISSIONER OSIADACZ stated that the noise ordinance, as it' s written, cannot be enforced. CHAIR TAYLOR stated we are creating new regulations because the current noise ordinance cannot be enforced. He asked if there had been any discussion about changing the current noise ordinance . PROSECUTING ATTORNEY HARTUNG stated that the reason the regulations were written this way is because her office does infractions and that would be the legal consequences for enforcing the regulations . She stated there are limited resources in the Sheriff' s Department and she has been a part of the noise ordinance conversation. When the committee came up with the reporting decibel meter, they were ensuring that legal 2026-8-4 MINUTES 4 would have sufficient evidence to hold up in court . She stated that having regulations in place holds the homeowner responsible for what happens in their home, they have signed the agreement and application stating that they will follow the regulations . COMMISSIONER MORRIS asked if there is a penalty for operating a short-term rental without a permit . PROSECUTING ATTORNEY HARTUNG stated that would be a code enforcement violation and would follow the way those are handled. We always asked for voluntary compliance first, there are steps staff has to go through because we do have due process standards . For an officer to be able to enforce a noise violation, they have to hear it and that is not something we can change locally. CHAIR TAYLOR mentioned that he assumes there is way to check that the place being rented out is an actual residence in the application process . Public member Jessica Karraker shared that she was previously renting out a hickory shed and was informed by code enforcement that it was not allowed. CHAIR TAYLOR voiced his concern for staff time of figuring out if the structures were legal or not and the permitting process . Staff has the ability to look up structures to see if they were legally constructed. COMMISSIONER DENEEN stated he researched the decibel meters and there are different levels at varying prices . He said with the class 2 meters it doesn' t seem like you can take these into court . LONG RANGE PLANNER JOHNSTON stated the first three violations under the class 2 system, for confirmed violations based off of using the mechanism, this would be handled internally with staff. Discussion occurred regarding Suncadia short-term rentals . COMMISSIONER OSIADACZ stated that Suncadia has their own regulations and that they just go off of complaints . If they get more than one complaint, the owner gets fined. After so many complaints, the owner gets kicked out of the short-term rental program. COMMISSIONER PEARSON restated that he thinks if the noise ordinance doesn' t work that we should start there and fix it . He stated if the short-term rentals do need a permit, that the fee should be kept very low. DEPUTY PROSECUTOR HARTUNG stated that in 2011, a judge found our noise violation ordinance unconstitutional, and the county had to revise it in 2016, and it does have to be approved by the Department of Ecology. We don' t have as much local control as one would like . 2026-8-4 MINUTES 5 COMMISSIONER HINKLE asked if we could take more time to refine the regulations . He suggested we issue a license, do a fire life safety inspection, and then have an agreement that staff encourages people to use with some basic requirements and see how it works . COMMISSIONER OSIADACZ stated that the committee did a lot of work on the regulations and asked if there was a matrix that would be easier to provide to the Planning Commissioners that goes through all of the different scenarios throughout the process of the committee and those outcomes . CHAIR TAYLOR shared his concern with moving forward with these regulations and many people not approving of them if they passed. Discussion occurred regarding the decibel reader requirement and possibly removing that section from the regulations . COMMISSIONER JACKSON asked for clarification on what changes need to be reported when management changes . LONG RANGE PLANNER JOHNSTON stated that the idea is to let the immediate adjacent neighbors know that there is an STR operating and to provide them with a contact . If the property manager changes, we would want to provide them with an update . COMMISSIONER MORRIS stated that we should have a $10 permit so that we can register and know how many short-term rentals there are in this jurisdiction that we could actually enforce the regulations . He believes staff is opening themselves up to a lot of code enforcement complaints . COMMISSIONER OSIADACZ shared that most of the people she receives complaints from are at Hyak, by Lake Cle Elum, Pineloch Sun, and the new houses at Waterville . She stated the one thing that people complain to her about is the noise and their quality of life . COMMISSIONER DENEEN stated he is concerned about fire, life and safety being completed in the short-term rentals and should be a low end cost . CHAIR TAYLOR stated that he feels that there was good discussion at today' s meeting, there is no decision to make tonight and we will continue this conversation at the next meeting. CITIZEN COMMENTS RELATED TO STR DISCUSSION 2026-8-4 MINUTES 6 AMY MCGUFFIN - CEO of Chamber of Commerce and STR Committee Member - Ms . McGuffin stated that the committee asked all sorts of questions during their meetings and consulted with legal throughout the entire process . She stated that the average level of a house party with bass, music and lots of noise is about 80 decibels . The committee took this opportunity to compare this to the record noise level at Lumen field, which is 138 . The committee came to an agreement that 80 was a good level to start the process so that if there is problems with the decibels than we can learn from it . She stated that from a consumer' s standpoint in VRBO and Airbnb, you can have house rules but they will not enforce the house rules based off the platform. The house rules do help from an insurance component for any injuries, etc. The STR committee members were looking at it from the county' s liability standpoint, if we said these are our regulations for short-term rentals would the people who followed the rules have liability coverage too? The committee wanted to look at both sides, the homeowner and the consumer. She stated that the Chamber of Commerce does have a subscription to AirDNA, which is a short-term rental data platform. She stated the Lodging Committee actually provided the funding for the subscription. This subscription allows for us to follow the data and see what it really looks like from an impact perspective . The Lodging Committee also uses the subscription to look at the tax revenue base . JESSICA KARRAKER - STR Committee member - Ms . Karraker stated she would not be opposed to reopening the short-term rental committee . She is shocked that other committee members did not show up to tonight' s meeting. DEPUTY PROSECUTOR HARTUNG stated these regulations will be enforceable as presented; there are always going to be challenges and the possibility of legal argument . COMMISSIONER HINKLE asks if these regulations are enforceable and does it accomplish what we want to accomplish. DEPUTY PROSECUTOR HARTUNG stated that if we have to strengthen it in the future, then we strengthen it . OLD BUSINESS There was no old business . OTHER BUSINESS - No Action to be taken CDS DIRECTOR CHAD BALA shared that an appreciation letter was written for Bruce Coe and has been provided for signature to the Planning Commission Chair and Board of County Commissioner' s Chair. The letter will be mailed directly to Bruce Coe . 2026-8-4 MINUTES 7 CHAIR TAYLOR concluded the Kittitas County Planning Commission public meeting. Public meeting ended at 7 : 24 pm. 2026-8-4 MINUTES 8