HomeMy WebLinkAbout2026-03-30-cds-study-session-supporting-documents KITTITAS COUNTY
COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT SERVICES
2025 STUDY SESSION STAFF REPORT
STUDY SESSION DATE: March 30', 2026
TOPIC: Update: Periodic Comprehensive Plan Update
ACTION REQUESTED: Direction
BACKGROUND: The 2026 Periodic Comprehensive Plan Update process started
in 2025 with public outreach,numerous comment periods and
public meetings with the Planning Commission,taking testimony
and discussions regarding the Comprehensive Plan Periodic
Update.We have made significant progress throughout 2025 and
into 2026. In January of this year(2026)we issued the 30 day
comment period which ended March 2", 2026,taking additional
comments on the draft comprehensive plan,the new Climate
Element,and the Easton Subarea Plan. These documents were
presented to Planning Commission at their hearing on March
17',2026,to review and formalize a recommendation to the
BOCC. The Planning Commission voted 5-0 with a motion to
recommend approval including 6 amendments.
DISCUSSION: BOCC review of Comprehensive Plan.
Intent: Set hearing on May 5"for May 19',2026,Agenda
Hearing on the Comp plan document only.
Possible Options:
a. Move forward with Planning Commission's
Recommendation and amendments.
b. Move forward with Planning Commission's
Recommendation and amendments and allow staff to further
review comments and make the necessary
adjustments/amendments.
INTERACTION: CDS.
RECOMMENDATION: None.
HANDLING: None.
ATTACHMENTS: Memo.
LEAD STAFF: Chad Bala, CDS Director
kimley)))Horn
MEMORANDUM
To: Chad Bala,Community Development Services Director
Jeremy Jonston,Long Range Planner
From: Kimley-Horn and Associates,Inc.
Date: March 20,2026
Subject: March 17,2026 —2026 Periodic Comprehensive Plan Update Public Hearing
Public Hearing Procedures
The 2026 Kittitas County Draft Comprehensive Plan,new Climate Element and Easton Subarea Plan were
released for public comment on January 291h,2026.
Kittitas County received 12 written comments prior to March 2,2026,and one additional written comment
was submitted on March 17,2026.See the attached Appendix A with written comments submitted prior to
the public hearing.
The Kittitas County Planning Commission held a public hearing on the 2026 Kittitas County Comprehensive
Plan on March 17,2026.At the public hearing,in addition to public comment,5 additional written comments
were formally submitted,the Planning Commission held the comment period open with some continued
discussions with the public and then closed the comment period for final deliberations.See Appendix B
attached for comments that were received in writing at the public hearing.
Planning Commission Motion
The Planning Commission voted 5-0 for the following motion:
Motion to recommend approval of the 2026 Comprehensive Plan Periodic Update to the Kittitas County
Board of County Commissioners subject to the following amendments:
Amendment#1
Add a policy to the Utility Element to utilize a joint planning process with utility providers
to better prepare for the enhance communication during power outages.
Amendment#2
Add a policy to the Utility Element that the County should permit innovative sewer
systems through the formation of sewer districts in rural areas which do not constitute
urban governmental services and as allowed for in RCW 57.
Amendment#3
To incorporate drafted redlines proposed by Commissioner Deneen in the document
submitted to the Planning Commission on March 5th,2026 and presented at the Planning
Commission Public Hearing to the Board of County Commissioners for review.
Amendment#4
• • �f+ �: : 4•�{• - f0���s� or = .— �; odd — - - ■ - - _
Add a policy to the Recreation,Parks,and Open Space Element:"Kittitas County shall
establish a dedicated Recreation Division led by a full-time Recreation Division Manager,
to provide the professional coordination,planning,permitting,and promotion necessary
to responsibly manage the county's rapidly growing recreation and agri-tourism economy
across all four seasons and throughout both the upper and lower county.This position
should be established in either the Kittitas County Public Works Department or the
Kittitas County Community Development Services department."
Amendment#5
Add a policy to the Recreation, Parks,and Open Space Element:"Kittitas County shall
authorize agri-tourism,eco-tourism,and nature-based recreational enterprises on
Commercial Agriculture and Commercial Forest lands as compatible secondary uses,
including but not limited to:equestrian parks and trail riding operations;farm stays,rural
retreats,and outdoor educational programs;guided hunting,fishing,and wildlife
observation services;harvest festivals and agri-tourism events;and outdoor equipment
rental operations associated with primary resource land activities.Such uses shall be
authorized where they support the long-term economic viability of the resource
designation and do not impair the primary resource use."
Amendment#6
To address the changes provided by the Kittitas County Department of Public Works
submitted to the Planning Commission on March 17th,2026.
Next Steps for the Comprehensive Plan, Climate Element, and Easton
Subarea Plan
• The nonproject SEPA checklist will be issued on March 26`h
■ Kittitas County Community Development Services will coordinate with the Board of County
Commissioners to schedule briefings on the draft Comprehensive Plan and other documents and the
amendments proposed by the Planning Commission.
• Kittitas County Community Development Services will review amendments,comments,and
previously provided suggestions from the BOCC to provide options for consideration for adoption.
• A public hearing on the 2026 Kittitas County Draft Comprehensive Plan,new Climate Element and
Easton Subarea Plan will be scheduled.
• . • 00 Everett,WA 98201
Kimley)))Horn Appendix A Written Comments
Submitted Prior to Public Hearing
MEMORANDUM
To: Chad Bala,Community Development Services Director
Jeremy Jonston, Long Range Planner
From: Kimley-Horn and Associates,Inc.
Date: March 20,2026
Subject: March 17,2026 —2026 Periodic Comprehensive Plan Update Briefing
Starting on January 29`h,2026, Kittitas County initiated a comment period on the Draft Comprehensive Plan
Update,new Climate Element and Easton Subarea Plan.The draft development regulations and the draft
critical areas ordinance were not included as part of this 30-Day comment period.Comments were
submitted via the online form at KittitasCounty2026.com,email to romments(&kittitascounty2QZ6xom or by
mail or email to Kittitas County Development Services.The attached Exhibit A contains all PDFs,emails,and
online form comments submitted to the County.Verbal comments were also provided at the in-person public
hearing March 17,2026.
Table 1.Public Comments for Comment Period for Kittitas County Comprehensive Plan,Climate
Element,and Easton Subarea Plan.
I D Name Organization/Address Comment Method Date Received
001 Tim Trohimovich Futurewise Email 3/2/2026
Carryn Vande Puget Sound
002 Email 3/2/2026
Griend Energy
003 Gina Peckman Friends of Easton Email 3/2/2026
Kittitas
004 Sara Vickers Reclamation Email 3/2/2026
District
005 Gina Peckman Friends of Easton Email 3/1/2026
006 Debbie Bogart Resident Email 3/1/2026
007 Marge Easton Resident Email 3/1/2026
Brandsrud
(Duplicate of Dave Brandsrud Easton Resident Email 3/1/2026
007)
008 Jill Merwin Easton Resident Email 2/27/2026
009 Scott Downes WDFW Email 2/24/2026
010 Pat Kelleher Resident Email 2/19/2026
011 Tricia Sears Washington Email 2/13/2026
Geological Survey
012 Gina Peckman Easton Resident Email Unknown
Manastash
013 Skylar-Bisom Architecture Email 3/17/2026
Rapp Ellensburg
Resident
Colby2828 - •0 Everett, WA 98201
om:c m
3/2/26,4:00 PM KHA Mail-Comments on the Kittitas County 2026 Comprehensive Plan update
Comment #001
mai I Kittitas County 2026 Comments<comments@kittitascounty2026.com>
Comments on the Kittitas County 2026 Comprehensive Plan update
1 message
Tim Trohimovich <Tim@futurewise.org> Mon, Mar 2, 2026 at 1:30 PM
To: "comments@kittitascounty2026.com"<comments@kittitascounty2026.com>
Cc: Brooke Frickleton <brooke@futurewise.org>
Dear Staff:
Enclosed please find Futurewise's comments on the current version of Kittitas County 2026 Comprehensive Plan
update.Thank you for considering our comments.
Please let me know if you need anything else.
Tim Trohimovich, AICP (he/him)
Director of Planning & Law
r-
future
wise
Futurewise
1201 3rd Ave #2200,Seattle, WA 98101
(206) 343-0681
tim@futurewise.org
futurewise.org
connect: KI
2026-03-02 FW Comments on Kittitas Cnty Comp Plan Update.pdf
246K
https://mail.google.com/mail/u/0/?ik=fO8ae6a8l d&view=pt&search=all&permthid=thread-f:1858583575888328105&simpl=msg-f:1858583575888328105 1/1
[i
1201 3rd Ave#2200,Seattle,Washington 98101 Comment #001
future p• (206)343-0681
wiseice futurewise.org
March 2, 2026
Kittitas County Community Development Services
411 N Ruby St, Suite 2
Ellensburg, Washington 98926
Dear Staff:
Subject: Comments on the Kittitas County 2026 Comprehensive Plan update.
Sent via email: coliliiients c7ltittitascouili 2026.com
Thank you for the opportunity to comment on Kittitas County 2026
Comprehensive Plan update. We support the update. We also have
recommendations to improve the comprehensive plan and development
regulations update.
Futurewise works throughout Washington State to support land-use policies that
encourage healthy, equitable, and opportunity-rich communities, and that protect
our most valuable farmlands, forests, and water resources. Futurewise has
members and supporters across Washington State including Kittitas County.
Summary or ruturewlse t ommenu and Recommendations
• The Vision Statement should call more clearly for maintaining and enhancing
the County's agricultural industry. This industry is an important part of the
county economy. So maintaining and enhancing the industry is an important
economic development measure. Please see page 3 of this letter for more
information.
• Recognize that clustering will not protect working farms and farmers. This is
because clusters can convert agricultural lands to nonagricultural uses and
increase incompatible residential uses. Please see page 3 of this letter for more
information.
• Futurewise supports policies calling for predevelopment review of sites with
the potential for cultural resources and consultations with Indian tribes and
nations and the State of Washington Department of Archaeology and Historic
Preservation on their protection. This will help protect important cultural
resources. Please see page 4 of this letter for more information.
■ Please clarify the differences between Natural Resource Lands and Rural Areas.
This is necessary to conserve natural resource lands. Please see page 4 of this
letter for more information.
Re: Comments on the Kittitas County 2026 Comprehensive Plan upa ement#001
March 2, 2026
Page 2
• The policies and narrative on the Designation and De-designation of
Agricultural Lands of Long-Term Commercial Significance need to be updated
to comply with WAC 365-I90-050. This is necessary to protect important
farmland which is the basis of the agricultural industry. Please see page 5 of
this letter for more information.
• Table 4-2 on page 81, the comprehensive plan, and development regulation
updates must identify sufficient land for housing affordable to families earning
zero to 30 percent, 30 to 50 percent, 50 to 8o percent, 8o to too percent, and
100 to 120 percent of the Area Median Income (AMI). This is necessary to
provide adequate opportunities for housing for all. Please see page 6 of this
letter for more information.
■ Table 4-2 on page 81 should only including housing types documented to be
affordable for the various income categories as planned affordable housing.
This is necessary to provide adequate opportunities for housing for all. Please
see page 7 of this letter for more information.
• Affordable housing should be focused in cities and urban growth areas. It is not
possible to economically provide affordable housing in rural areas. Please see
page 8 of this letter for more information.
• Please address the other requirements of RCW 36.7oA.070(2) in the Housing
Chapter. This is necessary to provide housing for all. Please see page g of this
letter for more information.
• The climate and resiliency chapter requires more specificity and programs and
development regulations to comply with RCW 36.7oA.070(9)(e)(i). Please see
page 10 of this letter for more information.
• The climate and resiliency chapter must prioritize actions that benefit
overburdened communities to comply with RCW 36.7oA.070(i) and RCW
36.7oA.070(9)(e)(i). Please see page 11 of this letter for more information.
• The climate and resiliency chapter must address climate caused decreases in
water supplies and help address the increased demand for agricultural water
supplies. This is necessary to comply with RCW 36.7oA.070(g)(e)(i). Please see
page ii of this letter for more information.
Adopt policies, programs, and regulations to achieve environmental justice. We
have recommended principles to incorporate into the policies, programs, and
regulations. Please see page 12 of this letter for more information.
■ Adopt policies, programs, and regulations to address increased wildfire risk.
This is necessary to protect people and property from wildfire risk and comply
with RCW 36.7oA.070(g)(e)(i). Please see page 12 of this letter for more
information.
Re: Comments on the Kittitas County 2026 Comprehensive Plan upda ement #001
March 2, 2026
Page 3
Detailed Comments on Chapter 1 Introduction.
The Vision Statement should call more clearly for maintaining and enhancing
the County's important agricultural industry. See page 16.
Futurewise supports the vision statement on page 16. We do recommend that it be
strengthened by referencing "resource lands" which are an important part of the
county's economy and character. The vision statement includes "rural working
lands" and "working lands" which are rural land use designations and fail to
include agricultural, forest, and mineral resource lands.' We suggest that
references to rural working lands and working lands be changed to "resource
lands and rural working lands" "resource lands and working lands." This will
better encapsulate the intent to protect the county's important agricultural, forest,
and mineral resource industries as the county intends and as the Growth
Management Act requires.'
Clustering will not protect working farms and farmers.
Page 12 of the Introduction states that agricultural clustering preserves farmland.
This is not supported by peer-reviewed studies and other evidence. These papers
show that cluster subdivisions do not protect working farms, farmers, or
agricultural lands.3 The additional residential growth allowed on agricultural
lands of long-term commercial significance increases demands for limited water
and incompatibilities with agricultural uses.4 In several decisions the Western
1 Proposed Chapter 2 Land Use p. 22.
2 RCW 36.7oA.o6o(1).
3 Thomas L. Daniels, Where Does Cluster Zoning Fit in Farmland Protection?63 JOURNAL OF THE
AMERICAN PLANNING ASSOCIATION 129, 136 (1997) enclosed at the link on the last page of this letter
with the filename: "JAPA Where Does Cluster Zoning Fit into Farmland Protection.pdf." The Journal
of the American Planning Association is peer reviewed.Journal of the American Planning
Association Instructions for authors P. 3 &P. 4 of g enclosed in an additional email with the
filename: "JAPA Instructions for Authors.pdf."
4 Tom Daniels, What to Do About Rural Sprawl?p. 1 of 4 (Paper Presented at The American
Planning Association Conference, Seattle, WA: April 28, lggg) enclosed at the link on the last page
of this letter with the filename: "Daniels What to Do About Rural Sprawl.pdf;" Hall, S.A., Adam,
J.C.,Yourek, M.A., Whittemore, A.M., Yorgey, G.G., Scarpare, F., Liu, M., McLarty, S.,Asante-Sasu,
C., McClure,S., Turk,J., Haller, D., Padowski,J., Deshar, R., Brady, M.P., Rajagopalan, K., Barber,
M.E., Weber, R., Stockle, C.O., Goodspeed, H.L., Gustine, R.N., Kondal, A., Yoder,J., Deaver, B.,
Downes, M., Tarbutton, S., Callahan, M., Price, P. Roberts, T., Stephens,J., and Valdez, W., 2021
Washington State Legislative Report: Columbia River Basin Long-Term Water Supply and Demand
Forecast P. 51 (Publication No. 21-12-Oo6, Washington Department of Ecology, Olympia, WA: 2022)
last accessed on Feb. 27, 2026, at:
tt .ecol lic tions uminar and at the link on the last
page of this letter with the filename: "2112Oo6.pdf."
L
01 Re: Comments on the Kittitas County 2026 Comprehensive Plan up�daafement #001
March 2, 2026
Page 4
Growth Management Hearings Board held that residential clusters in agricultural
lands of long-term commercial significance violated the Growth Management Act
where the density was greater than one dwelling unit per ten acres5 or where the
land in the cluster was prime farmland soils or where land where agriculture
could otherwise take place.6
uetaiied Comments and Recommendations on Chapter 2 Land
Use
Futurewise supports policies calling for predevelopment review of sites with
the potential for cultural resources and consultations with Indian tribes and
nations and the State of Washington Department of Archaeology and Historic
Preservation on their protection. See pages 31 and 32.
Cultural resources are important to maintain existing cultural traditions and our
appreciation of the past. We strongly support the policies calling for
predevelopment review of sites with the potential for cultural resources and
consultations with Indian tribes and nations and the State of Washington
Department of Archaeology and Historic Preservation over their protection.
Detailed Commentb and Regulations on Chapter 3 Rural and
Resource Lands
Clarify the differences between Natural Resource Lands and Rural Areas. See
pp. 47 - 51.
The Growth Management Act requires the designation and protection of natural
resource lands and a rural element.?We recommend that the Rural and Resources
Lands element better distinguish between these two different geographies.
5 Vince Panesko, et al., v. Lewis County, et al.,WWGMHB Case No. 00-2-0031c, Eugene Butler, et al.
v. Lewis County,WWGMHB Case No. 99-2-0027c, &Daniel Smith, et al. v. Lewis County, Western
Washington Growth Management Hearings Board (WWGMHB) No. 98-2-0011c, Final Decision and
Order (March 5, 2001), at p. *16, 2001 WL 246707 p.*10 last accessed on March 2, 2026, at:
lit CPs:(.Jelulto2a22.tiiy.sii4_ oin/ciseiiianilp-grZs./eluho
documentZaoT82QQQQ0Q1 2sri EACZ 900t❑ a 5-final- i sign-and-or
6 Vince Panesko, et al. v. Lewis County, WWGMHB Case No. 00-2-0031c&Eugene Butler, et al. v.
Lewis County,WWGMHB Case No. 99-2-0027c Order Finding Noncompliance and Imposing
Invalidity (Feb. 13, 2004), at pp. 21 - 27 of 49, 2004 WL 586071, P. *13 - 15 last accessed on March
2, 2026, at: c e t -
da uinen T 2 0o I2SAE 21 -order-oti- 0 1' e. See also RCW 36.7oA.177.
7 RCW 36.7oA.170; RCW 36.7oA.o6o; RCW 36.7oA.070(5).
L
Re: Comments on the Kittitas County 2026 Comprehensive Plan uplaa ement #001
March 2, 2026
Page 5
The policies and narrative on the Designation and De-designation of
Agricultural Lands of Long-Term Commercial Significance need to be updated
to comply with WAC 365-190-050. See pages 63 and 64.
One of the purposes of the periodic updates to comprehensive plans and
development regulations is to incorporate "provisions" adopted or amended since
the last periodic update.8 Since the last Kittitas County comprehensive plan
update, the Washington State Department of Commerce amended WAC 365-igo-
050 to expand the soil types that indicate an area has long-term commercial
significance for agriculture to include farmlands of statewide importance soils in
addition to prime and unique farmland soils.9 The soils in each of these
classifications can be found in Farmland Classification—Kittitas County Area,
Washington which can be found at the link on the last page of this letter with the
filename: "20260227_18o6o5o6402_43_Farmland_Classification Kitittas.pdf."
Both prime and unique farmland soils and farmlands of statewide importance soils
are high quality agricultural soils.10 U.S. Department of Agriculture regulations
generally define prime farmland soils as:
General. Prime farmland is land that has the best combination of
physical and chemical characteristics for producing food, feed, forage,
fiber, and oilseed crops, and is also available for these uses (the land
could be cropland, pastureland, rangeland, forest land, or other land,
but not urban built-up land or water). It has the soil quality, growing
season, and moisture supply needed to economically produce
sustained high yields of crops when treated and managed, including
water management, according to acceptable farming methods. In
general, prime farmlands have an adequate and dependable water
supply from precipitation or irrigation, a favorable temperature and
growing season, acceptable acidity or alkalinity, acceptable salt and
sodium content, and few or no rocks. They are permeable to water
and air. Prime farmlands are not excessively erodible or saturated
with water for a long period of time, and they either do not flood
frequently or are protected from flooding.11
8 Thurston Cnty. v. W. Washington Growth Mgmt. Hearings Bd., 164 Wn.2d 329, 344, 190 P•3d 38,
45 (20o8); RCW 36.7oA.130(1)(a).
9 Washington State Register (WSR) 23-o8-037 (Filed March 29, 2023) enclosed at the link on the
last page of this letter with the filename: "WSR 23-o8-037 pp 4 to ii.pdf" see WAC 365-190-
050(3)(c)(i) (2023) on page [io] of that file.
10
7 Code of Federal Regulations (CFR) § 657.5(a) & (c) last accessed on Feb. 27, 2026, at:
hltps•/Zwww ecfr govicurrent/tit -7/ u)title- /cliapter-Vl/stibcliap-ter—Ups1rt-6ri21s_gbparL-
A/section-6S7.S.
11 7 CFR§ 657.5(a)(1)•
Re: Comments on the Kittitas County 2026 Comprehensive Plan updaai�ement #001
March 2, 2026
Page 6
Similarly, the U.S. Department of Agriculture regulations define farmlands of
statewide importance soils as:
Additional farmland of statewide importance. This is land, in addition
to prime and unique farmlands, that is of statewide importance for
the production of food, feed, fiber, forage, and oil seed crops. Criteria
for defining and delineating this land are to be determined by the
appropriate State agency or agencies. Generally, additional farmlands
of statewide importance include those that are nearly prime farmland
and that economically produce high yields of crops when treated and
managed according to acceptable farming methods. Some may
produce as high a yield as prime farmlands if conditions are
favorable.12
As these U.S. Department of Agriculture regulations provide, prime farmland and
farmlands of statewide importance soils are high quality agriculture soils. That is
why WAC 365-I90-050(3)(c)(i) calls for these high-quality soils to be designated
and zoned as agricultural lands of long-term commercial significance. We
recommend that the criteria be based on prime and unique farmland soils and
farmland of statewide importance soils in designating agricultural lands of long-
term commercial significance.
Detailed Comments and Recommendations on Chapter 4.
Housing
Table 4-2 on page 81, the comprehensive plan, and development regulation
updates must identify sufficient land for housing affordable to families
earning zero to 30 percent, 30 to 50 percent, 50 to 80 percent, 80 to 100
percent, and 100 to 120 percent of the Area Median Income (AMI).
The Growth Management Act in RCW 36.7oA.070(2)(c) requires the county
comprehensive plan, and the county development regulations,13 to "[i]dentif[y]
sufficient capacity of land for housing including, but not limited to, government-
assisted housing, housing for moderate, low, very low, and extremely low-income
households, manufactured housing, multifamily housing, group homes, foster care
facilities, emergency housing, emergency shelters, permanent supportive housing,
and within an urban growth area boundary, consideration of duplexes, triplexes,
and townhomes[.]" RCW 36.7oA.070(2)(d) requires the county comprehensive
12 7 CFR § 657.5(c)•
13 RCW 36.7oA.130(i)(a), (e).
L
Re: Comments on the Kittitas County 2026 Comprehensive Plan up�°afement #L i
March 2, 2026
Page 7
plan, and the county development regulations,14 to: "(d) Make[] adequate
provisions for existing and projected needs of all economic segments of the
community, including: (i) Incorporating consideration for low, very low,
extremely low, and moderate-income households[.]" "`Extremely low-income
household' means a single person, family, or unrelated persons living together
whose adjusted income is at or below 30 percent of the median household income
adjusted for household size ..."15 "`Very low-income household' means a single
person, family, or unrelated persons living together whose adjusted income is at
or below 50 percent of the median household income adjusted for household size
»16 "`Low-income household' means a single person, family, or unrelated
persons living together whose adjusted income is at or below 8o percent of the
median household income adjusted for household size ...."17 "Moderate-income
household" means a single person, family, or unrelated persons living together
whose adjusted income is at or below 120 percent of the median household income
adjusted for household size ...."18
It is important to analyze housing needs and capacity by these categories because
different housing types and different levels of subsidies and incentives are needed
to fund housing affordable to families in the different income categories.19 So
Table 4-2 should be broken out by the income categories in RCW 36.7oA.07O(2)(c)
and (d).zO
Table 4-2 on page 81 should only including housing types documented to be
affordable for the various income categories as planned affordable housing.
RCW 36.7oA.07O(2)(c) requires the county comprehensive plan, and the county
development regulations,21 to "[i]dentif[y] sufficient capacity of land for housing
�4 RCW 36.7oA.130(i)(a), (e).
15 RCW 36.7oA.03o(18).
16 RCW 36.7oA.030(50).
17 RCW 36.7oA.030(26).
1s RCW 36.7oA.030(30).
�9 Washington States Department of Commerce, Local Government Division Growth Management
Services, Guidance for Updating Your Housing Element: Updating your housing element to address
new requirements P. 36 (Aug. 2023, updated Jan. 2026) last accessed on Feb. 26, 2026, at:
litt s ww a•ce.wa, v r -ma ement h - Tannin h si '- ace and
available at the link on the last page of this letter with the filename: "122o_Book2_Housing
Element Update_23o823 Final updated 26o112.pdf."
20 Futurewise, Kian Bradley, and Trevor Reed v. City of Mercer Island, Central Puget Sound Region
Growth Management Hearings Board (CPSRGMHB) Case No. 25-3-0003, Final Decision and Order
(Aug. 1, 2025) at 23 - 25 of 67 last accessed on Feb. 18, 2026, at:
i s e l c se a luho-
doci=meiit a T . ni6fRE z z -f' - eci ion- n - r
21 RCW 36.7oA.130(i)(a), (e).
01 Re: Comments on the Kittitas County 2026 Comprehensive Plan up�a�ment #001
March 2, 2026
Page 8
including, but not limited to, government-assisted housing, housing for moderate,
low, very low, and extremely low-income households, manufactured housing,
multifamily housing, group homes, foster care facilities, emergency housing,
emergency shelters, permanent supportive housing, and within an urban growth
area boundary, consideration of duplexes, triplexes, and townhomes[.]" The State
of Washington Department of Commerce has documented that in moderate-cost
communities to provide housing affordable to families and individuals earning 8o
percent or less of the area median income requires low-rise multifamily and mid-
rise multifamily housing and accessory dwelling units.22 In moderate cost
jurisdictions townhomes, duplexes, triplexes, and quadplexes can be affordable to
families earning 8o to 120 percent Area Median Income (AMI).�3 Middle housing is
not affordable to families earning 8o percent or less AMI.�4 Detached single family
homes are only affordable to families earning more than 120 percent AMI.�5
Table 4-2 relies in part on duplexes and triplexes to provide housing affordable to
families earning 8o percent or less AMI. This is not possible. Duplexes, triplexes,
and manufactured, mobile, and modular homes cannot be produced at rents
affordable to families earning zero to less than 30 percent AMI or 30 to less than
50 percent AMI. We recommend focusing on low-rise multifamily and mid-rise
multifamily housing and accessory dwelling units within urban growth areas.z6
Affordable housing should be focused in cities and urban growth areas.
Table 4-2 on page 81 allocates the unincorporated rural county 156 units of
housing affordable to families earning between 50 to 8o percent AMI to be
produced with duplexes and accessory dwelling units. The State of Washington
Department of Commerce has documented that to provide housing affordable to
families and individuals earning 8o percent or less of the area median income
requires low-rise multifamily and mid-rise multifamily housing and accessory
dwelling units.27 In moderate cost jurisdictions townhomes, duplexes, triplexes,
and quadplexes can be affordable to families earning 8o to 120 percent AMI.28
Middle housing is not affordable to families earning 8o percent or less AMI.�9 In
addition, there are significant water constraints and placing affordable housing in
22 Washington States Department of Commerce, Local Government Division Growth Management
Services, Guidance for Updating Your Housing Element: Updating your housing element to address
new requirements P. 36 (Aug. 2023, updated Jan. 2026).
�3 Id.
�4 Id.
25 Id.
26 Id.
27 Id.
2s Id.
29 Id.
L
Re: Comments on the Kittitas County 2026 Comprehensive Plan upSaa ement #001
March 2, 2026
Page g
rural areas increases transportation costs for families and transportation and
public service costs for the County. We recommend that these housing targets
should be reallocated to urban growth areas. Planning on affordable housing units
outside urban growth areas means that the county will not achieve its affordable
housing targets and there will not be opportunities for all income groups.
Similarly, the Washington Farmworker Housing Needs Assessment recommended
that to provide more affordable farm worker housing cities should be encouraged
"to increase zoning and infrastructure investments for multi-family housing
within urban growth areas.1130
Low-rise multifamily and mid-rise multifamily housing are urban densities and
are only allowed in urban growth areas. Planning on providing housing affordable
families earning 8o percent or less AMI in the rural area will fail. Instead these
housing targets should be reallocated to urban growth areas near jobs where the
affordable housing can be provided.
Address the other requirements for housing elements in RCW 36.70A.020(2).
RCW 36.7oA.020(2)(d)(ii) requires the comprehensive plan to "[d]ocument[]
programs and actions needed to achieve housing availability including gaps in
local funding, barriers such as development regulations, and other limitations ..."
We were unable to identify the programs, actions, and gaps in local funding in the
Housing Element or the Kittitas County - Housing Needs Assessment.
RCW 36.7oA.020(2)(e) requires the housing element to identify "local policies and
regulations that result in racially disparate impacts, displacement, and exclusion
in housing ...." We were unable to identify the programs, actions, and gaps in local
funding in the Housing Element or the Kittitas County - Housing Needs
Assessment.
RCW 36.7oA.020(2)(f) requires the housing element to "[i]dentif[] and
implements policies and regulations to address and begin to undo racially
disparate impacts, displacement, and exclusion in housing caused by local policies,
plans, and actions ...." RCW 36.7oA.020(2)(g) requires the housing element to
[i]dentif[y] areas that may be at higher risk of displacement from market forces
30 BERK Consulting, Washington Farmworker Housing Needs Assessment p. 184 (The Washington
State Department of Commerce:Jan. 2022) last accessed on Feb. 27, 2026, at:
ht i3s:Ifwww.Goinnierce.wa.goy/wn-
content ti laads/2o22/o4lCom merceReportso e ous' 6.22. )d and at
the link on the last page of this letter with the filename:
"CommerceReports_CSHD_FarmworkerHousing_Final_4.26.22.pdf."
L
01 Re: Comments on the Kittitas County 2026 Comprehensive Plan upc�aa ement #001
March 2, 2026
Page io
that occur with changes to zoning development regulations and capital
investments ...." ; RCW 36.7oA.020(2)(h) requires the housing element to
"[e]establish[] antidisplacement policies. We were unable to identify the
programs, actions, and gaps in local funding in the Housing Element or,the Kittitas
County - Housing Needs Assessment.
vetailed Comments and Recommendations on Chapter 10
Climate and Resiliency
The climate and resiliency element requires more specificity and programs
and development regulations to comply with RCW 36.70A.070(9)(e)(i).
RCW 36.7oA.070(9)(e)(i) provides in relevant part that:
The resiliency subelement must prioritize actions that benefit
overburdened communities that will disproportionately suffer from
compounding environmental impacts and will be most impacted by
natural hazards due to climate change. Specific goals, policies, and
programs of the resiliency subelement must include, but are not
limited to, those designed to:
(A) Identify, protect, and enhance natural areas to foster resiliency to
climate impacts, as well as areas of vital habitat for safe passage and
species migration;
(B) Identify, protect, and enhance community resiliency to climate
change impacts, including social, economic, and built environment
factors, that support adaptation to climate impacts consistent with
environmental justice; and
(C) Address natural hazards created or aggravated by climate change,
including sea level rise, landslides, flooding, drought, heat, smoke,
wildfire, and other effects of changes to temperature and
precipitation patterns.
Complying with these requirements will require new and amended regulations
especially to protect and enhance natural areas, to protect and enhance
community resiliency, and to address the natural hazards.31
Many of the policies are not specific as RCW 36.7oA.070(9)(e)(i) requires and
there are no programs. We identify several examples in the following sections.
31 RCW 36.7oA.130(i)(a).
Re: Comments on the Kittitas County 2026 Comprehensive Plan updaa ement #001
March 2, 2026
Page 11
The chapter must prioritize actions that benefit overburdened communities.
We appreciate that 10.2.2 identifies vulnerable populations, overburdened
communities, and environmental justice on pages 164 and 165. However, we did
not find any actions prioritized to benefit overburdened communities or any
policies or programs designed to benefit overburdened communities. Water
actions will be particularly important.
The chapter must address climate caused decreases in water supplies and
help address the increased demand for agricultural water supplies.
Much of Kittitas County is in Water Resource Inventory Area (WRIA) 39.31 The
2011 Columbia River Basin Long-Term Water Supply and Demand Forecast wrote:
The types of vulnerabilities that our region is expected to face due to
changes in water supply in the future are to some extent common
across all Washington's watersheds. These changes in supply are
driven by changes in timing of water availability within each year
and, in some watersheds, the greater variation expected between
years. However, the degree to which these changes are expected, and
the convergence of these changes in supply with expected changes in
the different demands for water are what vary across eastern
Washington's watersheds.
The WRIAs in the upper Yakima Basin (WRIAs 38 and 39) are
expected to see such convergence. These WRIAs are expected to
experience decreasing water supplies in low supply years (Figure 21),
while at the same time expecting increases in agricultural water
demand (Figure 23).33
32 State of Washington Department of Ecology, Water Resources Program, WRIA 39 Upper Yakima
Watershed Water Availability P. 7 (Publication 20-11-039: Aug. 2023) last accessed on Feb. 16,
2026, at: a a)s.t c . o ublic tioiis l P StimiiiarvPages/2oiio'4A.htniI and at
the link on the last page of this letter with the filename: "2011039.pdf."
33 Hall, S.A.,Adam,J.C., Yourek, M.A., Whittemore, A.M., Yorgey, G.G., Scarpare, F., Liu, M.,
McLarty, S.,Asante-Sasu, C., McClure,S., Turk,J., Haller, D., Padowski,J., Deshar, R., Brady, M.P.,
Rajagopalan, K., Barber, M.E.,Weber, R., Stockle, C.O., Goodspeed, H.L., Gustine, R.N., Kondal, A.,
Yoder,J., Deaver, B., Downes, M., Tarbutton, S., Callahan, M., Price, P. Roberts, T., Stephens,J., and
Valdez, W., 2o2i Washington State Legislative Report: Columbia River Basin Long-Term Water
Supply and Demand Forecast P. 51 (Publication No. 21-12-oo6,Washington Department of Ecology,
Olympia,WA: 2022) last accessed on Feb. 27, 2026, at:
lit tl2s:/Japps.ecoi_Qgy.wa.gov/publ i ti nmar Pa es 211 I)t nil and at the link on the last
page of this letter with the filename: "2112oo6.pdf."
L
Re: Comments on the Kittitas County 2026 Comprehensive Plan update #001
March 2, 2026
Page 12
Decreasing supplies are being driven by climate change.34
The climate and resiliency element needs to include specific goals, policies, and
programs to protect water supplies for agricultural industry and to provide water
for other uses to protect and enhance community resiliency to climate change
impacts including social, economic, and built environment factors as RCW
36.7oA.O70(9)(e)(i) requires. Unfortunately, 10.7.1 Drought on pages 169 to 170
does not comply with these requirements. It needs to be strengthened to comply
with RCW 36.7oA.070(9)(e)(i). We recognize that this is a significant problem
that will require help from the state and federal governments. But the chapter
needs to include policies and programs to address these problems and call on the
needed assistance.
These recommendations will help address the agricultural stakeholders concern
that that water availability and security are the most significant long-term
barriers for the agricultural industry, exacerbated by prolonged drought, reduced
snowpack, and uncertainty around water rights.35
Adopt policies and programs, and regulations to achieve Environmental
Justice. Please see pages 164 - 165 and 168.
We appreciate and support the environmental justice narrative on pages 164 - 165
and 168. However, RCW 36.7oA.070(i) requires that "[t]he land use element must
give special consideration to achieving environmental justice in its goals and
policies, including efforts to avoid creating or worsening environmental health
disparities." RCW 36.7oA.070(g)(e)(i) requires that the resiliency subelement
"must" "[i]dentify, protect, and enhance community resiliency to climate change
impacts, including social, economic, and built environment factors, that support
adaptation to climate impacts consistent with environmental justice[.]" However,
the narrative does not provide for how environmental justice will be achieved and
the elements do not include policies and programs to achieve environmental
justice. We suggest adding policies and programs to achieve the following
principles:
When planning for and siting uses with adverse environmental impacts direct
those uses away from areas with significant health disparities and adversely
impacting uses and equitably distribute the new uses.
34 Id. p. ES-3.
3s Chapter 1 Introduction p. 12.
L
01 Re: Comments on the Kittitas County 2026 Comprehensive Plan up a�ement #001
March 2, 2026
Page 13
• For uses that cannot be located in a different location, such as highway
expansions, mitigate adverse impacts including in those areas with significant
health disparities.
• Equitably site beneficial uses such as trails, parks, and schools and prioritize
new investments in underserved areas.
• Equitably plan for capital facilities and invest in underserved or overburdened
areas.
• Protect the resources needed by all communities including areas experiencing
environmental health disparities and by underserved areas such as surface and
ground water quality and quantity.
• Meaningful involve all affected people in these decisions and comprehensive
plan updates.
Adopt policies, programs, and regulations to address increased wildfire risk.
See 10.7.5 Wildfire on page 171.
Because of climate change and urban development in hazard-prone areas,
insurance is becoming increasingly difficult to get for housing and development in
these areas limiting the ability sell or use these developments.36 We need to direct
growth away from these areas. We recommend a new policy to address this need
and RCW 36.7oA.070(9)(e)(i)(C) to read as follows:
XX Direct grnwtl_, away from natural hazards created or aggravated by
climate p, including landslides, floQding, ikely to
effects of changes to teijiDgerature and precipitation 12a terns by not
_ y of uses in_tliese areas, aild no
Ata�ating �ese areas for residentialdevelopment_Qr
Cher types of u- ian �rawth.
In addition, the wildfire policies are not specific as RCW 36.7oA.070(9)(e)(i)
requires. For example, CR-P16 calls on the County to "[i]dentify and implement
strategies for reducing wildfire risk in the wildland-urban interface." But the time
36 Mona Hemmati, Ian P. Gray &Steven G.Bowen, The growing void in the U.S. homeowners
insurance market: who should bear the rising cost of climate change?4:35 NPJ CLIMATE ACTION P. 1
(2025) last accessed on March 2, 2026, at: tt . Iwww.natur��lartielesls4.g168-o2s-o0231-8
and available at the link on the last page of this letter with the filename: "s44168-025-00231-
8.pdf." This online journal is peer-reviewed. Nature portfolio peer review webpage last accessed
on Feb. g, 2026, at: littl2s:/IWww.iiature.com/iiature-t3ortfo-]tLole—clifc)i-ia1-palicieslneer-review and
at the link on the last page of this letter with the filename: "Peer Review—Nature Portfolio.pdf."
01 Re: Comments on the Kittitas County 2026 Comprehensive Plan ul�da�ment #001
March 2, 2026
Page 14
to identify the strategies is now and no specific strategies were identified.37 This
violates RCW 36.7oA.070(9)(e)(i) and RCW 36.7oA.130(1)(a) and (5)(c).
Further, RCW 36.7oA.070(i) provides in part that "[t]he land use element must
reduce and mitigate the risk to lives and property posed by wildfires by using land
use planning tools, which may include, but are not limited to, adoption of portions
or all of the wildland urban interface code developed by the international code
council or developing building and maintenance standards consistent with the
firewise USA program or similar program designed to reduce wildfire risk,
reducing wildfire risks to residential development in high risk areas and the
wildland urban interface area, separating human development from wildfire prone
landscapes, and protecting existing residential development and infrastructure
through community wildfire preparedness and fire adaptation measures." This list
could be developed into specific policies and programs based on that policy.
Thank you for considering our comments. If you require additional information,
please contact me at email: tim w futurewise.org or telephone (206) 343-o681.
Very Truly Yours,
(Sel- )
Tim Trohimovich, WSBA No. 22367
Director of Planning & Law
Enclosures at this link:
htt s: futu ewiseor .shar oint.com :f: I IcHr K1 ZWcc2 ct 6Aa 1
FS 2iGKGL4tl gwI?e=H7ege2
37 Futurewise, Kian Bradley, and Trevor Reed v. City of Mercer Island, CPSRGMHB Case No. 25-3-
0003, Final Decision and Order (Aug. 1, 2025) at 38 of 67.
3/2/26,3:59 PM KHA Mail-Kittitas Comp Plan comments from PSE
Comment#002
ma I Kittitas County 2026 Comments<comments@kittitascounty2026.com>
Kittitas Comp Plan comments from PSE
1 message
Vande Griend, Carryn<Carryn.VandeGriend@pse.com> Mon, Mar 2, 2026 at 12:59 PM
To: "comments@kittitascounty2026.com"<comments@kittitascounty2026.com>
Cc: Jeremy Johnston <jeremy.johnston@co.kittitas.wa.us>
Kittitas County planning staff,
Please see PSE's comments on Kittitas County's draft comprehensive plan. We would be happy to provide further
feedback or clarification during the drafting process.
Thank you for providing the opportunity to comment.
Carryn Vande Griend
Carryn Vande Griend
PSE Local Government Affairs
Central &Eastern Washington
Carryn.VandeGriend@pse.com
509.218.9012
Kittitas County comp plan_PSE comment letter_3.2.26.pdf
159K
hftps://mail.google.com/mail/u/0/?ik=fO8ae6a8l d&view=pt&search=all&permthid=thread-f.1858581655238426147&simpl=msg-f:1858581655238426147 1/1
Comment #002
PUGET SOUND ENERGY
Puget Sound Energy
P.O.Box 97034
Bellevue,WA 98009-9734
PSE.com
March 2,2026
Kittitas County Community Development Services
411 N Ruby St,Suite 2
Ellensburg,WA 98926
Dear Kittitas County Commissioners and Planning Staff,
Puget Sound Energy(PSE)appreciates the opportunity to provide comment on the Utilities Chapter of the Kittitas
County Draft Comprehensive Plan.As the local electric utility serving much of the county, PSE supports the County's
efforts to plan for reliable, resilient,and affordable utility infrastructure that meets the needs of existing and future
residents while respecting environmental and community values.
To that end,we respectfully submit the following comments on the Draft Comprehensive Plan policies
U-P4:Encourage joint electric utility construction standards for all electrical infrastructure constructed in the urban
growth area. In the interim, Puget Sound Energy and the Kittitas County Public Utility District will allow the City of
Ellensburg to review any new construction in the urban growth area.
PSE will continue to comply with applicable regulations governing electric infrastructure in urban growth areas.The
draft policy references a review process that is unclear as it applies to the Cle Elum and Kittitas UGAs.We respectfully
request clarification regarding the specific review expectations and processes for those areas to ensure predictability
and consistency in project planning and permitting.
U-P5:Coordinate with other utilities to create a County-wide utilities location map using GIS mapping.
PSE supports coordination with the County on utilities planning and recognizes the value of accurate mapping.
However,we are unable to comply with a blanket requirement to provide GIS utility data for County publication due
to privacy,security,and critical infrastructure protection requirements. PSE is willing to work collaboratively with the
County to respond to individual data requests in accordance with our established data-sharing protocols.
P7:Advocate for avoiding, where possible,routing major electric transmission lines above 55 kilovolts through urban
areas and critical areas.
PSE is subject to extensive state and local permitting requirements that prioritize avoiding critical areas unless no
reasonable alternative exists.While we support thoughtful siting practices, it is important that the Comprehensive
Plan maintain flexibility to allow for infrastructure decisions that ensure continued access to safe, reliable,and
affordable power as regional load and capacity demands increase.
U-P16:Any and all easement rights shall be acquired under normal lawful procedures. Process permits and approvals
for all utility facilities in a fair and timely manner, and in accordance with the development regulations that ensure
predictability and project concurrency. Trespass on utility easements shall be discouraged. Kittitas County reserves the
right to review all applications for utilities placed within or through the County for consistency with local policies,laws,
customs, and culture.
PSE appreciates the County's stated commitment to timely permit processing and enforcement of utility easements.
We comply with all applicable code and regulatory requirements. However,we seek clarification regarding the scope
Comment#002
of additional County review for"consistency with local policies, laws,customs,and culture,"as this language may
introduce uncertainty without further definition.
U-P17:It is the position of Kittitas County that it is inappropriate for utilities to over or under build other utilities.A
specific example of such requirements may be found in RCW 35A.14.900 and other state laws.
PSE requests clarification of the terms"over build"and "under build" as used in this policy.The cited statutory
example(RCW 35A.14.900)relates specifically to annexation scenarios, in which county franchises are replaced by
city franchises.Additional context would help utilities better understand how this policy is intended to apply outside
of annexation circumstances.
U-G7.Plan for, coordinate, and allow the expansion of solar production,small nuclear and wind facilities to improve
the resilience of Kittitas County. Ensure codes encourage upfront mitigation for project impacts and are properly sited.
PSE appreciates the County's support for solar,wind,and small nuclear resources.We would also advocate for the
inclusion of battery energy storage systems to improve system reliability and community resilience. Energy storage
technologies play an increasingly important role in supporting grid stability, integrating renewable generation,
managing peak demand and improving outage response.
PSE supports the policies under this goal that direct the County to provide study requirements, mitigation measures,
preferred siting considerations,and a streamlined permitting process.As noted above for transmission, maintaining
momentum and flexibility in infrastructure siting will be critical to meeting the County's growing and evolving energy
needs.
CR-P8: Work with energy utilities to improve the safety and reliability of infrastructure replace with during extreme
heat events.
In 2025, PSE invested nearly$85 million in grid strengthening projects,with a large portion of this work concentrated
in Kittitas County.This included equipment upgrades, underground conversions and tree wire installations. We have
also installed 15 weather stations and seven Pano Al smoke-detecting cameras with viewsheds in the County,with an
additional two planned for 2026.We share camera access with more than 270 emergency response agencies
throughout our service territory, including fire districts, DNR and the Kittitas 911 center,which improve detection and
response times. PSE will continue to invest in wildfire mitigation and vegetation management to reduce risk, protect
our communities and maintain reliable electric service.
PSE has been a long-standing community partner, electric utility provider and renewable energy operator in Kittitas
County.We are committed to supporting Kittitas County's economic growth by investing in electric infrastructure that
serves existing customers, attracts new business and supports housing and employment growth. We will also
continue to work alongside Kittitas County to support renewable energy projects that contribute to the local tax base,
landowner income, long-term capacity,and the clean energy economy.
PSE looks forward to continued collaboration with Kittitas County as the Comprehensive Plan is refined.Thank you for
considering our comments and for your commitment to thoughtful,forward-looking utility planning.
Sincerely,
Carryn Vande Griend
Puget Sound Energy
Local Government Affairs
SUBMITTED VIA ONLINE COMMENT FORM 3/2/2026 Comment #003
AVAILABLE ON THE PROJECT WEBSITE
(KittitasCou nty2026.com)
"Dear Kittitas County Planning Department,
As concerned residents of Washington State with an interest in sustainable rural development, we are
submitting this public comment on the Easton Subarea Plan, particularly regarding the integration and
application of Type 3 Limited Areas of More Intensive Rural Development (LAMIRDs) under the Growth
Management Act (GMA). Our comments are informed by a detailed review of expert analysis on similar
proposals in the area, such as the Sparks Park-Easton Travel Center variance (File VA-23-00003), which
highlights critical inconsistencies with state and county planning standards. These issues underscore the
need for stricter adherence to rural character protection in any subarea planning updates.
1.Scale and Intensity of Development: The subarea plan should explicitly limit new commercial
developments to isolated small-scale businesses to preserve rural character. For instance, proposals
exceeding Kittitas County Code (KCC) 17.15.070 limits, such as those over 30,000 square feet in area,
33% impervious surfaces, or 4,000 square feet of retail, risk creating urban-like sprawl along highway
corridors. In the case of large-scale facilities like travel centers with extensive impervious surfaces (e.g.,
69% coverage over 15+ acres), this violates Comprehensive Plan standards and discourages low-density
rural sprawl as prohibited by the GMA. We urge the plan to incorporate binding size caps and intensity
thresholds to ensure new uses remain compatible with surrounding rural lands.
2.Utilization of Pre-Existing Sites: LAMIRDs are intended as a one-time recognition of areas in existence
prior to 1991, not for ongoing expansion onto vacant lands. The subarea plan must prohibit designations on
sites without evidence of prior commercial occupancy, such as tree-covered parcels shown in historical
aerial photos (e.g., 2009 Easton Study Area imagery). Allowing development on undeveloped sites
contradicts RCW 36.70A.070(5)(d) and could lead to inappropriate conversion of rural lands.
Recommendations include mandatory historical site reviews using GIS and aerial data to verify pre-1991
uses.
3.Conformance to Rural Character: The plan's definition of rural character, emphasizing open spaces,
natural landscapes, vegetation predominance, traditional rural lifestyles, wildlife compatibility, and protection
of groundwater, must be rigorously enforced. Developments that introduce 11-12 acres of impervious
surfaces within Critical Aquifer Recharge Areas (CARAs) or near Group A Wellhead Protection Areas pose
significant risks to groundwater resources, as seen in proposals covering 74% of sites with impervious
materials. This conflicts with KCC 17A.03.020 and Best Available Science requirements. Additionally,
incompatibility with adjacent resource lands (e.g., state-owned forests) and facilities like Easton State
Airport could undermine outdoor recreation and aviation safety, per Comprehensive Plan policies T-P44
and RR-P2. The subarea plan should mandate critical areas reviews, mitigation sequencing (KCC
17A.01.100), and buffers (up to 200 feet from CARAs) for all proposals, while discouraging strip commercial
developments.
In conclusion, updating the Easton Subarea Plan provides an opportunity to align with the GMA by
evaluating intense proposals such as Comprehensive Plan amendments or rezones, rather than variances.
Prioritizing small-scale, site-specific developments will protect Eastern Washington's rural economies, water
resources, and visual landscapes. We recommend incorporating these safeguards to prevent future
inconsistencies and support job opportunities for rural residents without compromising environmental
values.
Thank you for considering this comment.
Warm Regards,
Friends of Easton, on behalf of its members: (including but not limited to)
Gina Peckman, gina@peckmansearch.com
Marge Brandsrud
John Jensen
Cc. Terry Danysh, PRK Livengood
James Carmody, MFT Law
Comment#004
From: saraCla krdistrict.ora
To: Jeremy Johnston
Cc: kevin( krdistrict.oro
Subject: Kittitas County 2026 Comprehensive Plan Periodic Update-Comments
Date: Monday,March 2,2026 4:07:28 PM
CAUTION: This email originated from outside the Kittitas County network. Do not click
links, open attachments, fulfill requests,or follow guidance unless you recognize the sender
1 and have verified the content is safe.
Kittitas Reclamation District would like to submit the following comments regardingthe
Kittitas County Comprehensive Plan Periodic update:
10.1 Climate Resiliency
Yakima River Basin Integrated Water Resource Plan
• Add in "YBIP" or"Yakima Basin Integrated Plan" into parenthesis after the name.
■ This is a relatively vague description of the Yakima Basin Integrated Plan missing
collaboration between federal, state,tribal, environmental entities, and other
NGO partners.There is also a need to provide more details about the actions of
this plan. Please coordinate with Arden Thomas/KCPW for a more detailed
description.
10.4 Hazard Mitigation
Kittitas Reclamation District(KRD)should be identified as a planning partner within the
Hazard Mitigation Plan at the next available opportunity.
Please let us know if there are any questions.
Thanks,
Sara Vickers
KRD Assistant Manager- Operations
Lands Clerk/RRA Specialist
509-925-6158-Office
509-929-5014-Cell
www.kittitasreclamationdistrict.org
SUBMITTED VIA ONLINE COMMENT FORM 3/1/2026 Comment #005
AVAILABLE ON THE PROJECT WEBSITE
Part Two: (KittitasCounty2026.com)
7. USE THE RIGHT PROCESS FOR THE RIGHT PROPOSAL
The subarea plan should make clear that a variance is not the appropriate mechanism for approving development that exceeds Type
3 LAMIRD dimensional standards. A variance addresses minor deviations in cases of practical difficulty or unnecessary hardship. It
is not a tool for authorizing development at a fundamentally different scale or intensity than what the zoning allows.
Recommended subarea plan language: "Any proposed development that exceeds the dimensional standards established in KCC
17.15.070 for rural General Commercial zoning shall not be processed as a variance. Proposals that would fundamentally alter the
character, scale, or intensity of land use shall be evaluated as a Comprehensive Plan amendment and rezone, subject to full public
participation, environmental review, and policy analysis as required by the Growth Management Act."
8. SUMMARY OF REQUESTED SUBAREA PLAN ADDITIONS
I respectfully request that the Easton Subarea Plan be updated to include the following provisions:
4.Restate the binding dimensional limits from KCC 17.15.070 (30,000 sq ft total area,4,000 sq ft retail, 33% impervious surface) as
hard caps that cannot be exceeded through variance.
5.Require documented proof of prior commercial occupancy through historical aerial photography and county records before any
Type 3 LAMIRD development is approved.
6.Mandate verified critical areas review cross-referenced against County CARA maps and Group A Wellhead Protection Area maps
for every development application.
7.Require mitigation sequencing and Best Available Science for all proposals within or within 200 feet of a Critical Aquifer Recharge
Area.
8.Require compatibility review for proposals adjacent to DNR resource lands and the Easton State Airport, consistent with
Comprehensive Plan Policies T-P44 and RR-P2.
9.Prohibit strip commercial development patterns along highway corridors, consistent with GMA and Comprehensive Plan policy.
10.Direct over-scale proposals to the Comprehensive Plan amendment and rezone process, not variance,to ensure adequate public
participation and environmental review.
9. ADDITIONAL COMMENTS ON THE EASTON SUBAREA PLAN
In addition to the Type 3 LAMIRD development standards addressed above, I am submitting the following comments on other
sections of the Easton Subarea Plan. These comments address gaps in the plan's treatment of housing, economic development,
wastewater infrastructure, and wildfire mitigation, areas where the plan needs stronger, more actionable language to serve this
community.
9.1 Housing:The Plan Must Be Specific About Affordable and Workforce Housing
The Housing section of the Subarea Plan (Section 3) acknowledges that Easton's population is aging,that renter-occupied units
have declined by 55%, and that the community has expressed strong interest in affordable housing for young families and first-time
buyers. However,the plan's goals and policies remain too general to produce results. The plan references"affordable housing
options" and"property improvements"without defining what affordable means in the Easton context,without identifying specific
housing types, and without committing to measurable targets.
The community's own comments are specific:they want starter homes, affordable single-family homes for first-time buyers, ADUs on
R-5 lots, and protections against outside investment driving up prices. The plan should match that specificity. I recommend the
following additions:
a. Define"affordable housing" in the plan using a standard benchmark: housing that costs no more than 30%of the area median
household income.The plan should state this threshold explicitly so that future policy decisions can be measured against it.
b. Include workforce housing as a distinct category. Workforce housing serves the people who work in the community, teachers,fire
district staff, service workers, school employees but cannot afford to live here. The plan should explicitly commit to creating housing
options for households earning between 60%and 120% of area median income.
c. Set a measurable housing target. Based on the plan's own data showing 408 residents and an aging population, the community
should set a goal of 20-40 new affordable and workforce housing units within ten years within the Type 1 LAMIRD, tied to
wastewater infrastructure capacity (see Section 9.3 below).
d. Add short-term rental protections. Community members specifically raised concerns about outside investors driving up prices and
short-term rentals overtaking housing stock.The plan should include policy language directing the county to regulate or limit
short-term rentals within the LAMIRD to protect the community's housing supply for full-time residents.
e. Identify specific grant programs for affordable housing development in the recommended actions, including the Washington
Housing Trust Fund, USDA Multi-Family Housing Direct Loans (up to$50M for rural communities under 35,000 population), and
HUD Community Development Block Grants through Washington Commerce.
9.2 Economic Development:The Plan Needs a Market Analysis and Actionable Strategy
The Economic Development section (Section 4) identifies community desire for revitalization of Railroad Street and small local
businesses. It proposes walking tours,vision boards, and consulting with railroad operators as recommended actions. While
community engagement is valuable,these actions alone will not generate jobs, attract businesses, or close the service gaps
residents have identified. Walking tours and vision boards are process steps, not economic development outcomes.
The plan contains no market analysis. There is no assessment of what types of businesses are financially viable in a community of
408 residents with seasonal recreational traffic.There is no estimate of consumer demand,visitor spending capture, or revenue
potential for the types of businesses residents want (coffee shops, restaurants,gear rental, small retail). Without this analysis, the
plan is asking the community to pursue economic development without knowing what the market will support.
I recommend the following additions to the Economic Development section:
SUBMITTED VIA ONLINE COMMENT FORM
3/1/2026 AVAILABLE ON THE PROJECT WEBSITE
(KittitasCounty2026.com)
Comment #005
CONTINUED FROM PAGE 2
a. Commission or include a basic market analysis as a recommended action within the first year.This does not need to be
expensive, EDA Planning and Technical Assistance Grants (up to $300K) or USDA Rural Business Development Grants (up to
$500K) can fund feasibility studies for rural commercial development.The analysis should assess:what types of businesses are
viable given year-round and seasonal population,what the 1-90 traffic volume (30,000+vehicles per day) means in terms of
capture potential, and what infrastructure prerequisites must be met before businesses can operate.
b. Tie the economic development goals directly to the wastewater infrastructure constraint. The plan acknowledges that the lack of
a sewer or septic system is the primary barrier to development and school expansion (Section 5.3). No amount of vision-boarding
will produce a coffee shop or restaurant on Railroad Street if there is no wastewater system to support it.The economic
development section should state plainly that securing wastewater infrastructure funding is a prerequisite to Railroad Street
revitalization, not a parallel effort.
c. Include job creation targets. The plan should set a measurable goal, even a modest one such as 15-25 new permanent jobs
within five years from small businesses, cottage industries, and recreation-related services within the LAMIRDs.
d. Replace or supplement the walking tour and vision board actions with concrete steps:apply for an EDA Planning Grant for a
Railroad Street market feasibility study within the first year; identify three to five specific business types the market will support and
actively recruit them; and coordinate with the Kittitas County Economic Development Committee to integrate Easton into the
county-wide economic development strategy currently being developed.
9.3 Wastewater Infrastructure:The Single Most Critical Prerequisite
The Subarea Plan identifies the lack of a septic or sewer system as the primary barrier to development and school expansion.
Community members have raised this repeatedly in the March 2025 open house, in the April 2025 community meeting, and in
ongoing discussions. It was the very first comment at the open house: "Need a large scale septic system to move Easton forward."
And yet the plan does not include a single recommended action, timeline, or funding strategy for securing wastewater
infrastructure.
This is the linchpin. Without wastewater infrastructure, Railroad Street revitalization cannot happen. New businesses cannot
operate. Housing expansion is constrained.The school cannot expand.The plan needs to state this clearly and include a concrete
path forward. I recommend the following:
a. Add a new goal:"EG 5.1: Secure funding for a community wastewater system to serve the Type 1 LAMIRD, enabling economic
development, housing expansion, and school facility improvements."
b. Include specific federal and state funding programs in the recommended actions: USDA Rural Utilities Water and Waste
Disposal Grants and Loans (up to $5M per project for rural communities); EPA Clean Water State Revolving Fund through
Washington Ecology; Washington Department of Commerce CERB infrastructure loans ($5M maximum at 1% interest); and USDA
Rural Economic Development Loans and Grants through local utilities.
c. Add a Year 2 implementation action:commission a wastewater feasibility study to assess system options (community septic,
small-scale treatment, or decentralized cluster systems), estimated costs, and the most competitive federal or state funding
programs.This study is a prerequisite to any grant application and should be prioritized alongside the communication networks
and inventory milestones already in the implementation timeline.
d. Add wastewater infrastructure as a milestone in the implementation timeline (Section 7.6), targeting feasibility study completion
by Year 2 and grant application submission by Year 3.
e. Change language where"restrooms"are mentioned to "tourism support services"
9.4 Wildfire Mitigation:The Plan Should Pursue Firewise Designation and Federal Funding
Section 6 of the Subarea Plan correctly identifies wildfire as a serious threat to the Easton community, noting that the USDA
classifies risk to homes in Kittitas County as greater than 97%of counties in Washington. The plan includes a policy to"Create a
Firewise Community Plan" (EP 6.1) and recommends seeking funding for fire mitigation. However,the recommended actions are
limited to quarterly consultations, hosting an awareness day, and seeking general funding opportunities. These are awareness
activities, not a funded mitigation strategy.
Kittitas County already has a strong foundation through KFACC (Kittitas Forest and Fire Adapted Communities Coalition), which
has secured $10 million in federal funding for forest thinning and has established 18 recognized Firewise Communities in the
county. Easton should build on this existing infrastructure rather than starting from scratch. I recommend the following additions:
3/1/2026 SUBMITTED VIA ONLINE COMMENT FORM
AVAILABLE ON THE PROJECT WEBSITE
(KittitasCounty2026.com)
Comment #005
CONTINUED FROM PAGE 3
a. Set an explicit goal of achieving Firewise USA community recognition for the Easton area within two years. This is a structured
national program administered by the National Fire Protection Association that provides a framework for community-level wildfire
preparedness, and recognized communities may qualify for insurance premium reductions of 10-20%, a direct financial benefit
to every homeowner in the area.
b. Include specific federal grant programs in the recommended actions: USDA Community Wildfire Defense Grants
($250K—$10M for fuels reduction planning and treatment, annual cycle typically in spring); FEMA Fire Prevention and Safety
Grants (up to$200K for Firewise community programs); FEMA Building Resilient Infrastructure and Communities (BRIC) grants
for hazard mitigation projects; and Washington DNR Forest Health Grants for fuels reduction and forest restoration.
c. Add a Year 1 implementation action:coordinate with KFACC and Fire District 3 to conduct a Wildland-Urban Interface
assessment specific to the Easton subarea, map defensible space needs for properties within and adjacent to the LAMIRDs, and
submit a USDA Community Wildfire Defense Grant application by the next annual cycle.
d. Add wildfire mitigation funding as a milestone in the implementation timeline (Section 7.6), targeting Firewise recognition by
Year 2 and a federal fuels-reduction grant application by Year 1.
The laws already exist. The limits are already on the books. The Easton Subarea Plan is our opportunity to make sure they are
applied clearly and consistently so that the rural character of this community is protected for the long term. But protection alone is
not enough.This plan must also give Easton's residents the tools they need to build a sustainable future, affordable housing they
can actually live in, businesses that can actually operate,wastewater infrastructure that unlocks both, and wildfire protections
funded by the federal and state programs that exist for exact.
Gina Peckman
Gina@peckmansearch.com
3/1/2026 SUBMITTED VIA ONLINE COMMENT FORM
PUBLIC COMMENT ON THE EASTON SUBAREA PLAN AVAILABLE ON THE PROJECT WEBSITE
What the Law Allows and Prohibits on Type 3 LAMIRD Land (KittitasCounty2026.com) Comment #005
To: Kittitas County Planning Department, Community Development Services and consultants,
As you update the Easton Subarea Plan, I am submitting this comment to request that the plan include clear,
enforceable language defining what can and cannot be built on Type 3 LAMIRD land. The Growth Management
Act, Kittitas County's Comprehensive Plan, and the County Code already set these standards. They just need to
be stated plainly in the subarea plan so there is no ambiguity going forward.
This comment draws on the legal framework established by RCW 36.70A.070(5), RCW 36.70A.030(35), Kittitas
County Code Chapter 17.15, the Critical Areas Ordinance (KCC Title 17A), the Kittitas County Comprehensive
Plan, and relevant Growth Management Hearings Board decisions.
1. WHAT STATE LAW SAYS ABOUT TYPE 3 LAMIRDs
The Growth Management Act created Type 3 LAMIRDs under RCW 36.70A.070(5) as a narrow exception to
general rural land use restrictions. The Legislature authorized counties to allow limited new commercial
development in rural areas, but only when all three of the following conditions are met:
1.Isolated small-scale business. The development must be an isolated, small-scale business. This is not
aspirational language—it is a ceiling on what can be built.
2.Site previously occupied by an existing business. Under RCW 36.70A.070(5)(d), the new development must
utilize a site that was previously occupied by a business. LAMIRD designations are tied to areas or uses in
existence prior to 1991. This is a threshold eligibility requirement, not a preference.
3.Conforms to rural character. The new business must conform to the rural character of the area as defined by
the county government.
A proposal that fails any one of them is ineligible for Type 3 LAMIRD development. The Growth Management
Hearings Board confirmed in People for a Liveable Community v. Jefferson County (No. 03-2-0009c, 2003) that
LAMIRDs are "intended to be a one-time recognition of existing areas and uses and are not intended to be used
continuously to meet needs (real or perceived) for additional commercial and industrial lands."
2. THE HARD LIMITS: WHAT KITTITAS COUNTY CODE ALLOWS
Kittitas County implemented the GMA's Type 3 LAMIRD standards through KCC 17.15.070, which governs the
rural General Commercial zoning district. These are the binding dimensional and intensity limits for any
development on Type 3 LAMIRD land:
These limits exist to implement the GMA's "isolated small-scale business" standard. They are not starting points
for negotiation. They are the maximum development intensity the Legislature intended for rural commercial land.
Any proposal that exceeds these thresholds is, by definition, not a small-scale business and cannot be approved
under Type 3 LAMIRD authority.
3. SITE ELIGIBILITY: THE PRE-EXISTING BUSINESS REQUIREMENT
Not every parcel within a Type 3 LAMIRD boundary is automatically eligible for new commercial development.
RCW 36.70A.070(5)(d) requires that the site be one "previously occupied by an existing business." This means:
Recommended subarea plan language: "No new commercial development shall be approved on Type 3 LAMIRD
land unless the applicant demonstrates, through documented evidence including historical aerial photography and
county records, that the specific parcel was previously occupied by a commercial business. Vacant or
undeveloped land within a LAMIRD boundary does not satisfy this requirement."
4. RURAL CHARACTER CONFORMANCE: WHAT THE STANDARD REQUIRES
Even when a proposal meets the size limits and site eligibility test, it must also conform to rural character. RCW
36.70A.030(35) defines rural character through seven criteria. Kittitas County has adopted its own local definition:
rural character is "the predominant visual landscape of open spaces, mountains, forests, and farms and the
activities which preserve such features."
Any new development on Type 3 LAMIRD land must satisfy all of the following:
-Open space and natural landscape predominate over the built environment (RCW 36.70A.030(35)(a))
-Traditional rural lifestyles and rural-based economies are fostered, not displaced (RCW 36.70A.030(35)(b))
-Visual landscapes traditionally found in rural areas are maintained (RCW 36.70A.030(35)(c))
-Compatibility with wildlife and fish habitat (RCW 36.70A.030(35)(d))
-No inappropriate conversion of undeveloped land into sprawling, low-density development (RCW
36.70A.030(35)(e))
-No requirement for extension of urban governmental services (RCW 36.70A.030(35)(f))
-Protection of natural surface water flows and groundwater recharge/discharge areas (RCW 36.70A.030(35)(g))
Additionally, Comprehensive Plan Policies T-P44 and RR-P2 discourage uses incompatible with resource lands
and airports. The Easton area includes working forest land managed by the Washington State Department of
NaturalThe subarea plan should explicitly require compatibility review for any proposal adjacent to resource lands
or airport operations.
The GMA and Comprehensive Plan also prohibit strip commercial development along highway corridors. The
subarea plan should include language preventing the clustering of commercial uses that would create a pattern of
highway-oriented commercial sprawl.
SUBMITTED VIA ONLINE COMMENT FORM
AVAILABLE ON THE PROJECT WEBSITE
(KittitasCounty2026.com)
CONTINUED FROM PAGE 5
Comment#005
5. CRITICAL AREAS PROTECTION: NON-NEGOTIABLE REQUIREMENTS
Much of the Easton LAMIRD area sits within or adjacent to designated Critical Aquifer Recharge Areas (CARAs). The
Easton Water District depends entirely on groundwater for its domestic and drinking water supply.The subarea plan must
incorporate the following existing legal requirements and make them explicit in the development review process:
Recommended subarea plan language: "No development application within a Type 3 LAMIRD shall be approved without a
verified critical areas review that cross-references the County's Critical Area CARA maps and Group A Wellhead
Protection Area maps. A finding of'no critical areas' is insufficient without documented evidence that the County's own
CARA maps, wellhead protection area designations, and Critical Areas Ordinance requirements have been reviewed and
addressed. All proposals within or within 200 feet of a CARA shall comply with mitigation sequencing under KCC
17A.01.100 and use Best Available Science to protect groundwater resources."
6. CLEAR STATEMENT:WHAT YOU CAN AND CANNOT BUILD
Based on the full legal framework above, here is a plain-language summary of what is and is not permissible on Type 3
LAMIRD land in the Easton area. I request that the subarea plan incorporate this distinction explicitly:
WHAT YOU CAN BUILD
•A small-scale commercial business that fits within 30,000 square feet of total use area
-Retail uses that do not exceed 4,000 square feet
-Development that keeps impervious surface at or below 33%of the lot
-New business on a site with documented prior commercial occupancy
-Uses that preserve the visual landscape of open spaces, forests, and farms
-Uses compatible with adjacent resource lands, airports, local resort business, and outdoor recreation
-Development that protects groundwater recharge areas and meets Best Available Science standards
-Businesses that provide job opportunities for rural residents without requiring urban services
WHAT YOU CANNOT BUILD
-Any development exceeding 30,000 square feet of total use area
-Any retail component exceeding 4,000 square feet
-Any project with impervious surface coverage exceeding 33%of the lot
-New commercial development on vacant or undeveloped land with no documented prior business use
-Large-scale highway-oriented commercial facilities (travel centers, large fuel stations, multi-use commercial complexes)
-Development that converts open space, forest, or natural landscape into predominantly built environment
-Uses that create strip commercial patterns along highway corridors, especially near other LAMIRD commercial uses
-Uses incompatible with adjacent working forest land, airport operations, or outdoor recreation values
-Any development within a Critical Aquifer Recharge Area that has not undergone a verified CARA review, mitigation
sequencing, and Best Available Science analysis
•24/7 commercial operations that generate noise, light pollution, and heavy vehicle traffic incompatible with rural character
Gina Peckman
gina@peckmansearch.com
SUBMITTED VIA ONLINE COMMENT FORM 3/1/2026 Comment#006
AVAILABLE ON THE PROJECT WEBSITE
(KittitasCounty2026.com)
Please see correction in spelling of platted and dedication date entered in this paragraph. (pg6)
Permanent Settlers and Fires created growth and eventually decline in businesses. The first post office
opened on June 23, 1890, and in 1902, the Johnson Brothers plated the town and on August 29, 1902,
Easton was dedicated. By 1904, about 150 people lived in Easton. On Thanksgiving Day, 1906, a fire
destroyed part of south Easton, including 11 saloons which were quickly rebuilt. Another fire hit south
Easton in 1913, destroying the rebuilt saloons. The third major fire occurred in the business district in
1934. In 1941, the Easton Volunteer Fire Department was established and still provides valuable services
to the community today.
Somewhere in this document it still has PUD for our power source, it should be PSE
Debbie Bogart
dabogart@outlook.com
3/2/26,3:59 PM KHA Mail-Easton Sub Area Comments Comment#007
Gmai
I Kittitas County 2026 Comments<comments@kittitascounty2026.com>
1
Easton Sub Area Comments
1 message
Marge Brandsrud <dmbrandsrud@comcast.net> Sun, Mar 1, 2026 at 3:08 PM
To: "comments@kittitascounty2026.com"<comments@kittitascounty2026.com>
Please see attached PDF document. This may be a duplicate as the initial email was sent from a different email address.
March 1 2026 comments.pdf
137K
https:Hmail.google.com/mail/u/0/?ik=fO8ae6a8l d&view=pt&search=all&permthid=thread-f:1858499160003769489&simpl=msg-f:1858499160003769489 1/1
3/2/26,3:59 PM KHA Mail-Easton Sub Area proposal Comments Duplicate of Comment#007
mai a Kittitas County 2026 Comments<comments@kittitascounty2026.com>
Easton Sub Area proposal Comments
1 message
DAVE BRANDSRUD<davebrandsrud@gmail.com> Sun, Mar 1,2026 at 2:59 PM
To: comments@kittitascounty2026.com
Please see attached PDF document
March 1 2026 comments.pdf
137K
https://mall.google.com/mail/u/0/?ik=fO8ae6a8l d&view=pt&search=all&permthid=thread-f:1858498589215701883&simpl=msg-f:1858498589215701883 1/1
Comment #007
March 1, 2026
Kitdtas County Community Development Services
411 N Ruby ST,Suite 2
Ellensburg WA 98926
Re: Public Comment on the proposed Easton Sub Area Plan
I would like to thank Community Development Services for their assistance in forming this
proposed addition to the County's Comprehensive Plan.
After reviewing the Draft version of the Easton Sub Area Plan I offer the following comments.
Page 16 of the Draft includes Easton Table 1 Zoning Descriptions and Uses. The information
presented on the table is blatantly misleading. Descriptions and allowed used presented do not
include Rural LAMIRD allowed use information provided in Kittitas County Code 17.15.070
Allowed Uses in Rural LAMIRD Lands and 17.15.071 Rural LAMIRD Table. The Descriptions and
Allowed uses appear to be taking from County Code Definitions and do not reflect actual
allowed uses and descriptions in the two LAMIRDS included in the Sub Area boundary. The
LAMIRDS are the areas where Light Industrial and General Commercial development would be
allowed. Kittitas County Code 17.15.070 and 17.15.071 include language which was put in place
to comply with the GMA's LAMIRD designation. If a Zoning Description Table is included in the
Sup Area Plan it must represent actual allowed uses and restrictions for the LAMIRDS.
2.4 Goals and Policies
EG 1.0
EP 1.0 Work with Property owners and the community t develop a revitalization plan
infrastructural which will support economic and residential growth.
EP 1.1 " lelete "such as requiring conditional use nermits." Conditional Use review ensures that
a proposed use not usually permitted aligns with community standards and zoning. Impacts to
the community, neighbors and the environment must be evaluated and mitigations applied
when applicable.
EP1.5 ADD whole retaining Rural Character
Recommended Actions
EA1.1 Add language that will include property owners to this process.
Comment#007
Page 22 Easton Table 4 Housing Inventory
I am having difficulty understanding what this Table represents. It obviously does not represent
on the ground inventory and is not reasonable to assume these are projected additional units.
Page 29 Recommended Actions
EA 4.0 A Vision Board should include property and business owners working with the
community to create a cooperative and creative vision that can move forward to a reality.
Page 30 5.2 Existing Conditions
There are no public wastewater systems serving the proposed Easton Sub Area. All
wastewater is processed by private septic systems.
Electricity in the proposed Easton Sub Area is provided by Puget Sound Energy.
1-90 divides the area—there are safety concerns, emergency access issues and traffic
pressures. here issues are well documented and are an on--going issue with local citizens and
nusrnesses. There is a real threat to the Life Safety and Welfare on the community. The
proposed Easton Sub Area is Rural and is greatly impacted during travel interruption impacts
on 190 allowing what would be considered urban levels of traffic to leave the Interstate and
block Easton Area roadways. Those blocking incidents greatly impact the local emergency
services and their ability to assure the life safety and welfare of the community as well as the
traveling public.
Final thoughts
I am encouraged by the community input and participation in this process. I believe moving
forward the Sub Area Plan will bring the community closer together and revitalize the
community as a whole. I am encouraged that the community is deeply interested in and
committed to maintaining the Rural Caracter while future development and infill.
Thank you for reviewing my comments. I will be providing additional comments as this process
moves forward
Marge Brandsrud Comment#007
PO Box 638
Easton WA 98925
dmbrandsrud@comcast.net
Comment #008
From: All Merwin
To: Jeremy Johnston
Subject: Easton Subarea Plan Edits and Comments V3.0
Date: Friday,February 27,2026 2:21:31 PM
CAUTION: This email originated from outside the Kittitas County network. Do not click
links,open attachments, fulfill requests, or follow guidance unless you recognize the sender
and have verified the content is safe.
Hi Jeremy,
Below are my edits/comments for the Easton Subarea Plan. Please feel free to reach out if you
have any questions or concerns.
Thank you for taking the time to read these, and for all the assistance you have provided to the
Easton community. Your attention and knowledge are greatly appreciated!
Subarea Plan V3.0 Edits and Comments
Note:The footnotes indicate that Engagement was collected between March 2025 to June 2026.Is the 2026 date
correct,or should it be 2025?
Page 4; 1.2 Last paragraph;description of the area."—forested hills and steep slopes to the south and west as the
train rises into the Cascade foothills."Should this description include the rises to the north and east?(Easton Ridge)
Page 8.Easton Figure 8 description.Keechelus dam is misspelled as Keechlus.
Page 11; 1.4. Second line.Board of county commissioners is misspelled as BOAD.
Page 11; 1.5.First paragraph regarding the Easton community collaboration on revisions to the plan between March
2025 to June 2026.Is the June 2026 date valid?
Page 18;2.3.Community landmarks.Should Silver Ridge Ranch be included?It's been in existence for I believe
over 50 years and has been a prominent feature of the community.It sits right behind the LAMIRD 3 property off of
Sparks Rd.
Page 18;2.3.1.Community Design and Aesthetic. Should"Aesthetic"in the 2.3.1 title be plural,as in"Aesthetics"?
Page 19;2.4. EP 1-1 "...reduce barriers to permitting,such as requiring conditional use permits."Remove"...such
as requiring conditional use permits."This does not serve the community in a positive way.
Page 30; 5.2.Existing Conditions.Second paragraph states those not served by the Easton Water District are served
by private wells and septic tanks for their water and waste water.This is true,however,properties that are served by
the Easton Water District also utilize septic tanks for wastewater.There is no municipal sewer in Easton.
Page 30;5.3. Summary of Community Input-"Feedback from the community"lacks a footnote like the other
summaries include on previous pages.
Page 32;6.2.Existing Conditions,second paragraph,first sentence describes forested slopes,particularly to the
south and west.But there are also slopes to the north and east.Should those also be included?
Comment#008
Page 34;6.3. Summary of Community Input-"Feedback from the community"lacks a footnote like the other
summaries include on previous pages.
Page 37;7.4. Summary of Community Input-"Feedback from the community"lacks a footnote like the other
summaries include on previous pages.
Page 37;7.5.Implementation Actions,first paragraph,second sentence,"The community can also..."is unfinished.
Page 37;7.5,Implementation Actions,second paragraph,"As the community moves forward,as implementation
actions are executed the community..."Should this state"As the community moves forward,"and"(instead of"as")
implementation actions are executed..."?
Thank you.
Jill Merwin
Easton Resident
541-602-2652
jamerwin ni�com
Comment #009
L'
State of Washington
DEPARTMENT OF FISH AND WILDLIFE
South Central Region • Region 3 • 1701 South 24t" Avenue, Yakima, WA 98902-5720
Telephone: (509) 575-2740 • Fax: (509) 575-2474
February 24, 2026
Jeremy Johnston
Long Range Planner
Kittitas County Community Development Services
411 N. Ruby Street, Suite 1
Ellensburg,WA 98926
SUBJECT: WDFW comments on Kittitas County draft 2026 Comprehensive Plan
Dear Mr. Johnston,
Thank you for the opportunity to review the Kittitas County draft Comprehensive Plan. The
Washington Department of Fish and Wildlife (WDFW)has reviewed the plan, and we appreciate
that many positive aspects have been included in the plan, including elements and mentions to
include wildlife connectivity and the recognition that having connected fish and wildlife habitats
leads to a more resilient landscape. We provide these comments to improve the plan in
accordance with WDFW's mission to preserve,protect and perpetuate the state's fish, wildlife
and ecosystems.
Section 2. Land Use.
2.3.8. LU-G9. Master Planned Resort(MPR). Open space in the MPR should prioritize
protection of critical areas. Past MPRs have been permitted in wildlife connectivity corridors and
next to streams and wetlands. Please include a policy that recreation will be minimized in the
critical areas and limited to low-impact recreation such as trails. ,
Table 2-1 indicates that about 217,000 acres of land are within the Forest and Range zoning
designation(-15% of land in the county). The base density is ldu/20ac. Based on the spatial
distribution of the zone, this is where some level of development could occur that could fragment
high quality habitat areas and habitat connectivity. Recommend either modifying RR-P 10 to
include wildlife connectivity or add a separate policy that discourages rezones that increase rural
densities in these areas of conflict with wildlife connectivity.
Table 2-2, on page 25, about half of the 2046 population growth(7,280 people)is allocated to
Unincorporated Kittitas County. This will increase low-density sprawl within the county. This
also contradicts LU-P3: Reduce the conversion of land for development and concentrate future
growth in UGAs.
Table 4-1 (within the Housing section) shows that the population growth in unincorporated
Kittitas County grew by 4,798 people from 2000 to 2020. The population of unincorporated
Kittitas has surpassed the population(s) of all the incorporated areas within the county. Many
Page 2
Comment #009
Fish and Wildlife Habitat Conservation Areas (FWHCAs) including wildlife connectivity
corridors and shrubsteppe habitat are in these areas. We recommend directing growth towards
the Urban Growth Areas (UGAs) and reducing population growth in unincorporated areas of the
county. Continued sprawl is likely to undermine the value of these lands to various wildlife
species. The county should consider additional policies to limit population growth in
unincorporated and rural areas. The county should take additional measures to meet GMA
planning goal 2 that directs plans to reduce sprawl by reducing the inappropriate conversion of
undeveloped lands and encouraged growth in urban or incorporated areas.
2.3.10. Natural Environment
NE-G5, P26. WDFW Priority Habitat and Species (PHS) should be added to this list. Also
recommend changing the word"evaluate"to "promote".
Section 3. Rural and Resource Lands.
3.3.7 Rural Recreation. RR-G12. While WDFW understands and appreciates the need for
balanced recreation, high-impact recreational development should be discouraged in areas of
overlap with mapped corridors of wildlife connectivity. Please add this under RR-G12.
Commercial Agriculture Land Incentives. RR-G19-P103. These naturally occurring ponds and
springs have high wildlife use and are often critically important in areas of limited water such as
the dry areas zoned for commercial agriculture. Please clarify that these stock water uses will not
preclude or diminish access by wildlife at these naturally occurring sites.
Section 5. TranMoHation
T-G1, P9. WDFW has its climate resiliency guidance on culverts. Suggest integration into this
element: htt s://wdfw.wa. rovls ecies-liabitatslhabitat-recovg /fish- assa a/cliniate-clian a to
consider the impacts of climate hazards.
T-G6, P23. Wildlife. Consider tweaking the existing goal to add enhance wildlife connectivity
(right now only says minimize impacts). Under P23, add existing roadways (right now it just
says new roadways),but when we retrofit or rebuild roads, we should also look at connectivity
options.
Section 7. Utilities.
U-G7, P21. WDFW recently completed its guidance on solar and wind, including where we
recommend avoidance and mitigation strategies, BMPs and studies. We recommend that the
WDFW guidelines are required for environmental review of any new wind and solar.
https:l/wtlf%v.wa.gov/publicatioiis/02662
Section 9. Parks and Recreation
RPO-G1, P4. We appreciate the inclusion of these significant corridors. We would like to discuss
ways that we can incorporate wildlife connectivity corridors identified in WAHCAP and
designate those into open space plans. htlps://wdfw.wa.gov/species-habitats/habitat-
recov a ry/connectivity/act i on-plan
Comment #009
Page 3
I didn't see it in the existing or proposed Goals and Policies, but we should consider adding a
Policy that designates open space areas that are within critical areas as a higher protection
standard,potentially natural open space. There are only a few recreational elements that are
consistent with critical areas protection, yet there are quite a few elements allowed in open space
that are usually not compatible with critical areas. Designating these areas as a higher protection
open space would likely reduce some of that conflict.
Section 10. Climate.
While we appreciate the elements of the climate section, it is primarily geared towards human
uses. The County should include policies that"Identify, protect, and enhance natural areas to
foster resiliency to climate impacts, as well as areas of vital habitat for safe passage and species
migration". They should either include those policies within the climate element or show which
policies in the other elements meet this requirement.
10.7.1. Drought. Additions:
Encourage water conservation to protect instream flows for fish and aquatic ecosystems.
Preserve wildlife migration corridors so that wildlife can adapt to drought and resiliency.
10.7.5. Wildfire. Modify CR-G5, P 16 to address limiting new development in areas with high
wildfire risk.
10.1.2. Statewide and Regional Consistency
Washington Habitat Connectivity Action Plan(WAHCAP)
We appreciate that reference to the plan is included and we believe this demonstrates a
commitment to working to incorporate wildlife habitat connectivity into the county's document.
While corridors were correctly identified in the Cascade region and connecting the Cascades to
Hanford, there is a corridor of Statewide Significance that runs north to south in the eastern
section of the county referred to as the Columbia Plateau Backbone, see attached screenshot
below. Please amend the paragraph to include this corridor.
L.nd.r.pa I'rinrifla.(CLUBS.nd
CLOR51
I'
r
R T
i.
Comment #009
Page 4
Washington Shrubsteppe Restoration and Resiliency Initiative (WSRRI)
In 2024, WA developed WSSRI-the Washington Shrubsteppe Resiliency and Restoration
Initiative. One of the habitat protection goals states to work with local planning departments to
encourage the inclusion of habitat protection and restoration into land-use plans. While
shrubsteppe is already considered a critical area under PHS, WDFW would like to explore
additional conservation measures for areas that WSRRI has designated as high priority
conservation areas. We recommend that the plan be included in this section. Another habitat
protection goal under WSRRI is to protect high quality shrubsteppe areas from high intensity
fire. We recommend that WSRRI be mentioned in the hazard management plan under rangeland
fire protection. litt s://wdfw.wa. oy/ ublications/02489
Apj2end&B. Siio uahnie Pass Subarea Plan
This subarea contains a statewide wildlife connectivity core of significance as identified in
WAHCAP (named Cascade Crest) and the 1-90 Snoqualmie Pass East(the largest wildlife
crossing project to date in Washington)project runs through the plan area. Please update the
natural feature sections within the plan to acknowledge these wildlife connectivity areas of
significance.
The document refers to Plum Creek lands in several places. These lands were purchased by The
Nature Conservancy. Please update the text to reflect current ownership.
Section 6.1.3 Item 14 discusses future improvements to I-90. The Snoqualmie Pass East project
is completed for the first 7.5 miles and through the subarea plan area. Please update the
document to reflect this.
Appeizdil D. Easton Subarea Platt
Wildlife Connectivity:
1. WAHCAP maps both I-90 Easton segment and the surrounding natural resource lands as
having high wildlife habitat connectivity value. The sub-area plan should recognize that.
Recommend including this acknowledgment under the Land Use setting.
2. Recommend including under the Goals and Policies for Transportation a statement that
wildlife connectivity is a supported goal for highway projects.
3. Recommend including under the Goals and Policies for Land Use a statement that zoned
areas in the forest and range and Rural 5 zoned lands are valued for wildlife connectivity
and more intensive development in these lands should be discouraged.
While floodplain along the Yakima River is acknowledged as one of two primary natural
hazards, there are no goals and policies in Section 6.4 that address ways to lessen the flood risk
and preserve the natural floodplain of the Yakima River. Further development in the floodplain,
particularly the areas of frequent flooding near the Yakima River, prevents river restoration in
this reach. Development often requires loss of riparian habitat and hardening of the riverbanks to
prevent natural river processes. We recommend, including under the Goals and Policies, Section
6.4, that solutions to parcels in these frequently flooded areas should be explored, including
working with the Kittitas Flood Control Zone District. These solutions should be beneficial to
natural river processes and to make the Yakima River more resilient.
Comment#009
Page 5
Agpendix F. Land CavacLty Analysis.
While we appreciate that critical areas were mapped and the resulting area was removed from the
analysis, it is uncertain if all Fish and Wildlife Habitat Conservation Areas (FWHCA)were
included. In addition to streams and their associated Riparian Management Zones (RMZ) that are
shown on the maps, additional FWHCA should be mapped including all WDFW Priority Habitat
and Species mapping including shrubsteppe and Biodiversity Areas and Corridors. These are not
currently included in Kittitas County Compas mapping, and we would like to clarify if they were
included in this analysis. Further, the two maps included in the appendix only show areas around
the existing jurisdictions of Roslyn, Cle Elum South Cle Elum, Ellensburg and Kittitas. We
recommend including a map that shows the analysis at the county scale to be able to review and
comment on unincorporated county areas.
Thank you again for the opportunity to comment. Please contact me at 509-607-3578 or
Scott.Downes@dfw.wa.gov to set up a time to discuss these comments.
Sincerely,
Scott Downes
Regional Land Use Lead
Comment #010
From: Chad Bala
To: Jeremy Johnston
Subject: FW:Public comment on comprehensive plan
Date: Thursday,February 19,2026 11:39:24 AM
From Pat Kelleher
Chad Bala
Director
Kittitas County Community Development Services
411 NRuby Street, Suite 2
Ellensburg, WA 98926
(P) 509-962-7506
chtiJhrtict( kr,.killiters_iVer.its
From: pat kelleher<psk98926@yahoo.com>
Sent:Thursday, February 19, 2026 10:19 AM
To: Chad Bala <chad.bala@co.kittitas.wa.us>
Subject: Public comment on comprehensive plan
CAUTION:This email originated from outside the Kittitas County network. Do not click
Links, open attachments,fulfill requests, or follow guidance unless you recognize the
sender and have verified the content is safe.
Chad
Please include my comments for the record on comprehensive plan
n
o a a i o a ❑ a a -
013.pdf
Regards
Pat Kelleher
Comment#010
KItlt.as Comity
Comittywide Plartnin.g.,
Policies
Last ainmded oji .1uI.Y 5, 201-6
s
Comment#010
PREAMBLE 10 THE r
These Planning Policies are to be used solely to establish a framework from which the
comprehensive plans of the County and cities within the county are developed and adopted,
pursuant to RCW 36.70A, The Growth Management Act.
These policies are adopted to ensure consistency and coordination among the comprehensive
plans of the County and the cities.
Nothing in these policies shall be construed to alter the land use powers of the cities or County.
VISION STATEMENT
This statement is a general vision of the future of our county,toward which this framework and
these policies aim.
Kittitas County and the cities will value and protect and enhance the quality of life by protecting
the visual and physical environment; fostering economic opportunity, diversity, and security;
supporting a wide range of natural resource-based industries; ensuring access to recreational
opportunities; promoting educational excellence; and providing for affordable housing and
accessible transportation.
Discussion and Explanation
Planning for growth and change must be based on maintaining and enhancing the existing
quality of life, the character of the County, and meeting the needs of the community as a whole.
Actualizing this vision requires a collaborative effort among public officials from all
jurisdictions and active citizen participation. Public officials have decision making
responsibility; however active citizen involvement through a variety of venues must be
encouraged and valued.
The entire community must be willing to share the burden and the responsibility of achieving
mutually identified planning goals.
The implementation of County-wide Planning Policies will promote more efficient growth
patterns which may result in reduced cost of public services and facilities in the long term due to
more logical distribution of governmental services.
July 5, 2016 2
Comment #010
RO LE OF T 1F Kl T
i. The Kittitas County Conference of Governments (KCCOG) may serve as mediator in
matters of conflict resolution regarding interpretations and issues of clarification related to
this document.
ii. All jurisdictions of Kittitas County will jointly work to identify and address service
areas and their impacts through the KCCOG.
iii. The process for engaging in conflict resolution mediation with regard to development
impact fees shall be agreed upon by all parties involved, KCCOG shall serve as the first
level of conflict resolution according to the agreed upon process.
1. INTERLOCAL AGREEMENTS
Objective: To encourage cooperation between Kittitas County and the cities and towns within the
County on a basis of mutual advantage and to provide services and facilities in a manner that will
be best suited to geographic, economic,population, and other factors that influence the needs and
development of local communities.
Policy 1.1: Measures intended to implement countywide planning policies may include
interlocal agreements, contracts, memorandums of understanding, and joint
ordinances, or a combination thereof.
Policy 1.2: Cities and the County shall execute interlocal agreements to coordinate and
manage growth in UGAs and should consult special districts as appropriate.
Interlocal agreements shall acknowledge and implement the Countywide Planning
Policies and shall incorporate uniform criteria for orderly annexation.
Policy 1.3: Joint funding arrangements through mechanisms such as interlocal agreements
should be adopted for a period after annexations of developed properties to
consider compensation for the County's loss of revenues and its capital facility
expenditures prior to annexation, and any city obligations to provide capital
facilities to the area annexed.
2. URBAN GROWTH AREAS
Objective: To cooperatively determine future Urban Growth Areas and provide opportunities for
a broad range of needs and uses within such areas for the following twenty(20)years for each
jurisdiction.
General Policies
Policy 2.1: The County, in cooperation with the cities, will designate Urban Growth
Areas (UGAs) for each jurisdiction that is expected for the next twenty(20)
July 5, 2016 3
Comment #010
years as required by the Growth Management Act. Policies may consider
potential growth anticipated for the subsequent fifty(50)years.
Policy2.2: The designation of UGAs beyond the existing limits of incorporation will be
based on demonstration of necessity to meet population projections and a
demonstration by the cities that municipal utilities and public services either
already exist, or are planned for and can be effectively and economically
provided by either public or private sources.
Policy 2.3: UGAs will be determined by projections of population growth in both rural and
urban areas of the County. These projections shall be reached through
negotiation at the KCCOG, taking into account current growth rates and the
Office of Financial Management(OFM) anticipated population projections.
Policy 2.4: The subdivision, rezone, capital improvements, and governmental service
decisions of all County governmental jurisdictions should be directed by their
projected share of growth and should be in proportion to that projected share of
growth. These projections will be reviewed on an annual basis as needed at a
regularly scheduled KCCOG meeting.
Policy 2.5: Proposals for development, subdivisions, and public projects within the
unincorporated UGAs shall be subject to joint review by the County and the
affected incorporated jurisdictions according to the development standards and
comprehensive plans. The County shall enforce these standards as agreed upon
in the joint permit review process or interlocal agreements.
Policy 2.6: Subdivisions and development within the UGAs shall be orderly and
coordinated between County and city governments and utility service
purveyors.
Policy 2.7: Within UGAs, the forming of unincorporated areas of suburban density shall be
planned and coordinated.
Policy 2.8: The County should consider the use of joint SEPA lead agency status with any
incorporated area for projects within a UGA to ensure coordination of
mitigation for potential environmental impacts.
Policy 2.9: Final development approval will continue to reside with the County for
areas outside of City limits.
Policy 2.10: Consistent development regulations and development standards including but
not limited to: street alignment and grade,public road access, right-of-way,
street improvements, sanitary sewer, storm water improvements, power,
communications, utilities,park and recreation facilities, and school facilities
should be adopted for areas within the identified twenty(20)year UGA
boundaries for each jurisdiction within Kittitas County.
July 5, 2016 4
Comment#010
Policy 2.11: To encourage logical expansions of municipal boundaries into UGAs and to
enable the most cost-efficient expenditure of public funds for the provision of
municipal services into newly annexed areas,the County and the respective
cities shall jointly develop and implement development, subdivision and
building standards, coordinated permit procedures, and innovative financing
techniques including the possibility of development impact or other fees for the
review and permitting of any new development within UGAs.
Policy 2.12: City services should not be extended outside 20-year UGAs;however
municipal services may be extended to serve a Master Planned Resort approved
pursuant to the Kittitas County Comprehensive Plan Master Planned Resort
Policies and RCW 36.70A.360. Such services include,but are not limited to:
central sewage collection and treatment, public water systems, urban street
infrastructure, and storm water collection facilities.
Policy 2.13: County adoption of city standards for development within corresponding UGAs
shall be negotiated. These may include the following:
1. Street locations, both major and secondary
2. Street right-of-way
3. Street widths
4. Curbs and gutters
5. Sidewalks
6. Road construction standards
7. Cul-de-sacs, location and dimensions
8. Storm drainage facilities, quantity, quality, and discharge locations
9. Street lights, conduit, fixtures, locations
10. Sewer, septic regulations, private sewer, dry sewer facilities
11. Water,pipe sizes, locations, construction standards
12. Electrical and natural gas distribution systems
13. Communication utilities, telephone, cable TV, etc.
14. Fire protection, station locations, fire flows, uniform codes
15. School facilities
16. All building requirements
17. Subdivision and platting requirements
18. Mobile homes and manufactured home regulations
19. Zoning ordinances: permitted uses in UGAs, setbacks,building heights, lot
coverage, etc.
20. Libraries
21. Any other like services.
Policy 2.14: The availability of the full range of government services will be subject to the
annexation policy of the adjacent municipality. Utility extensions into the
UGA shall be consistent with the adopted comprehensive plan and capital
facilities plan of the utility purveyor.
July 5, 2016 5
Comment#010
Policy 2.15: In rural unincorporated areas outside UGAs, the County may designate limited
areas of more intensive rural development (LAMIRD), consistent with the
provisions of RCW 36.70A.070(5).
Policy 2.16: All planning efforts within UGAs associated with an incorporated city shall
be accomplished on a joint basis between the city and the County and include
participation from residents of unincorporated areas to the satisfaction of the
County.
Policy 2.17: Amendments or changes to the UGA designation may only be proposed once a
year and must be reviewed by the KCCOG. Amendments may only be
proposed by a city or the County.
Policy 2.18: Amendments to the UGA shall be mutually agreed upon between a city and the
County. The KCCOG shall review and make recommendations regarding UGA
amendments that have the potential to affect population allocations.
Policy 2.19: An amendment to a UGA shall only be approved once the city or the County
has demonstrated that the UGA designation criteria listed in policies 2.1
through 2.4 have been met.
3. REDUCE SPRAWL
Objective: To reduce the inappropriate conversion of undeveloped land including farmland into
sprawling, low-density development.
Policy 3.1: Commercial developments including retail, wholesale or service related
activities having a gross floor area more than 4,000 square feet, with
associated parking facilities, shall be located only within UGAs and Limited
Areas of More Intense Rural Development(LAMIRDs). When commercial
facilities are developed in conjunction with an approved Master Planned
Resort, those portions of hotel/motel, short-term visitor accommodations,
residential uses, conference and meeting rooms, and eating and drinking, and
active recreation service facilities which are not devoted to retail sales shall
not be subject to the 4,000 square foot limitation. All other retail,
wholesale, or service related facilities included in the Master Planned
Resort shall be subject to the 4,000 maximum square foot size.
Policy 3.2: New industrial development which is not resource-based and requires urban
services and zoning permits shall be located only within UGAs or industrial
zoned land. Temporary industrial uses may be allowed within Master Planned
Resorts approved by the County pursuant to RCW 36.70A.360 and the County
Comprehensive Plan Master Planned Resort policies; provided, however, that
any such use shall be limited to master planned resort construction,
development,maintenance, and operational purposes and shall be subject to
annual review and approval by the County. Nothing in this section shall
prohibit Master Planned Resorts approved by the County from continuous
July 5, 2016 6
Comment#010
maintenance and operational needs of such resorts.
Policy 3.3: Planned Unit Developments (PUDs)which include commercial and/or
industrial uses in addition to residential uses shall be located in UGAs or
Master Planned Resorts pursuant to RCW 36.70A.360 and .362, and the
County's Comprehensive Plan Master Planned Resort Policies.
Policy 3.4: The location of all PUDs shall be established to foster the efficient expansion
and management of infrastructure and utilities and demonstrate compatibility
with resource land uses; impact fees may be assessed to compensate the cost of
increased demands upon infrastructure, services, and utilities.
Policy 3.5: Only residential PUDs will be allowed outside of UGAs and LAMIRDs and are
subject to the policies contained herein; densities of PUDs allowed outside
UGAs and LAMIRDs shall be determined by the underlying zone
classification.
Policy 3.6: The County may authorize master planned resorts in Kittitas County pursuant to
RCW 36.70A.360 and .362, and the County's Comprehensive Plan Master
Planned Resort Policies.
4. TRANSPORTATION
Objective: To provide for adequate and appropriate transportation systems within the County
that are coordinated with county and city comprehensive plans.
Policy 4.1: Transportation plans (i.e., transportation elements of comprehensive plans) shall
promote the development and implementation of a safe, efficient, and
environmentally sound transportation system in accordance with federal and state
requirements, including the State's Growth Management Act that is responsive to
the community.
Policy 4.2: Transportation plans will support the planning goals for comprehensive plans set
forth in RCW 36.70A.020 and 36.70A.070(6), including promotion of economic
development consistent with available resources and public services and facilities.
Policy 4.3: Transportation plans will be consistent with their respective comprehensive plans
and will be compatible with the applicable components of other local and regional
transportation plans (e.g., QUADCO Regional Transportation Planning
Organization, bordering counties, WSDOT and local agencies).
Policy 4.4: The County and cities shall cooperate in the analysis of, and response to, any
proposed major regional industrial, retail/commercial, recreation, or residential
development proposals that may impact the transportation system in Kittitas
County.
Policy 4.5: Transportation plans and project prioritization shall be developed in active
consultation with the public.
July 5, 2016 7
Comment#010
Policy 4.6: Inter-jurisdictional transportation plans shall promote a coordinated and efficient
multi-modal transportation system, including alternative forms of transportation
for the movement of goods and people.
Policy 4.7: The transportation plans will,to the maximum extent practical,provide a safe and
environmentally sound system that meets community, elderly, disabled and low-
income population needs.
Policy 4.8: Transportation improvements which are necessary to maintain the identified level
of service standards shall be implemented concurrent with new development so
that improvements are in place at the time of development, or that a financial
commitment is provided to ensure completion of the improvements within six
years.
5. HOUSING
Objective: To encourage the availability of affordable housing to all economic segments of the
population,promote a variety of residential densities and housing types typical of the character
of Kittitas County, and preserve existing,useful housing stock.
Policy 5.1: Consistent with RCW 36.70A.070(2)(c) a wide range of housing development
types and densities within the county will be encouraged and promoted;
including multiple-family and special needs housing, to provide affordable
housing choices for all.
Policy 5.2: All types of housing for individuals with special needs should be allowed by all
jurisdictions.
Policy 5.3: Multi-family housing meeting the needs of all income levels should be
encouraged by all jurisdictions within Urban Growth Areas.
Policy 5.4: Jurisdictions shall consider innovative economic techniques and strategies for
providing affordable housing as part of their economic development strategy.
6. E!LONQMIC DEVELOPMENT
Objective: To provide an environment encouraging economic growth within the County and its
jurisdictions that is compatible with County character.
Policy 6.1: The jurisdictions in Kittitas County will work with local and regional
economic development interest groups in preparing and implementing
economic development plans.
Policy 6.2: Economic vitality and job development will be encouraged in all the
jurisdictions consistent with all comprehensive plans developed in accordance
July 5, 2016 8
Comment #010
with the Growth Management Act.
Policy 6.3: Economic development activities will be implemented in a manner which
supports our quality of life and is consistent with comprehensive plans. This
can be achieved by:
1. Recognizing that education and training which produce a skilled work
force are essential to the county's economic vitality.
2. Basing the level of economic development activity on our ability to manage
the resulting growth.
3. Requiring urban non-resource based economic development activities to
locate within designated UGAs or incorporated cities.
4. Requiring economic development proposals to show how increased
services and infrastructure support will be provided.
5. Undertaking countywide and regional efforts to coordinate economic
development activities.
6. Ensuring that the economic development element of local comprehensive
plans and countywide and regional growth management plans are compatible.
7. PROPERTY RIGHTS
Objective: To ensure that private property shall not be taken for public use without just
compensation having been made. The property rights of landowners shall be protected from
arbitrary and discriminatory actions.
Policy 7.1: The rights of property owners operating under current land use regulations shall
be preserved unless a clear public health, safety, or welfare purpose is served by
more restrictive regulation.
Policy 7.2: Surface water runoff and drainage facilities shall be designed and utilized in a
manner which protects against the destruction of property and the degradation
of water quality.
8. PERMITS
Objective: To ensure predictability by processing applications for both state and local government
permits in a timely and fair manner.
Policy 8.1: Upon receipt of a complete application, land use proposals and permits shall be
expeditiously reviewed and decisions made in a timely manner.
9. r ]
Objective: To maintain and enhance natural resource-based industries, including but not limited
to: productive timber, agricultural, and fisheries industries. Encourage the conservation of
July 5, 2016 9
Comment #010
productive forest lands and productive agricultural lands, and discourage incompatible uses.
Policy 9.1: Industrial developments which are solely resource based may be permitted
beyond UGAs.
Policy 9.2: Industries and commercial developments which provide for and/or compliment
sales of agricultural production and agricultural tourism, or enhance
recreational tourism within the County shall be encouraged within rural areas.
Policy 9.3: All economic development and population growth in the County shall be
accommodated in a manner that minimizes impacts on agricultural land,
forestry, mineral resources, shorelines, and critical areas.
10. OPEN SPACE AND RECREATION
Objective: To encourage the retention of open space and development of recreational
opportunities, conserve fish and wildlife habitat, increase access to natural resource lands and
water, and develop parks.
Policy 10.1: Preserve open space and create recreational opportunities through the use of
innovative regulatory techniques and incentives such as but not limited to:
purchase of development rights, transfer of development rights, conservation
easements, Public Benefit Rating System, and level of service standards.
Policy 10.2: New park and recreational facility plans shall include natural features,
topography, floodplains,relationship to population characteristics,types of
facilities, various user group needs, and standards of access including travel
time.
Policy 10.3: Indoor and outdoor recreation facilities shall be designed to provide a wide
range of opportunities allowing for individual needs of those using these
facilities.
Policy 10.4: Expansion and enhancement of parks, recreation, scenic areas, and viewing
points shall be identified, planned for, and improved in shorelands and urban
and rural designated areas.
11. ENVIRONMENT
Objective: To protect and enhance the County's quality of life and rural environment by
safeguarding its environmental resources.
Policy 11.1: All jurisdictions shall protect critical areas through comprehensive plans and
policies and develop regulations that are consistent with the adopted
environmental ordinances.
July S, 2016 10
Comment#010
Policy 11.2: Groundwater should be identified and protected, including appropriate
protection of aquifer recharge areas. Supplies of potable domestic water,
irrigation water, and firefighting water should be ensured in the rural, suburban,
and urban areas.
Policy 11.3: Water rights are those rights defined in state law, including RCW 90.03.010
and 90.44.035, as well as those rights as defined by agreements between the
State and the County.
12. CITIZEN PARTICIPATION
Objective: To encourage the involvement of citizens in the planning process and ensure
coordination between communities and jurisdictions to reconcile conflicts.
Policy 12.1: The County and cities shall provide regular and ongoing opportunities for
public review and comment throughout the Comprehensive Plan development
process.
Policy 12.2: The County and cities shall continue to encourage public awareness of the
Comprehensive Plan by providing public participation opportunities and public
education programs designed to promote a widespread understanding of the
Plan's purpose and intent.
Policy 12.3: The County and cities shall encourage citizen participation throughout the
planning process as mandated by state statute and codes for environmental, land
use, and development permits.
Policy 12.4: The County and cities shall utilize broad based Citizen Advisory Committees to
participate and assist in the development of Comprehensive Plan Elements, sub-
area plans, and functional plans as necessary.
13. PUBLIC FACILITIES AND SERVICES
Objective: To ensure that public facilities and services necessary to support development shall
be adequate to serve the development at the time of occupancy and service levels are not
decreased below minimum standards.
General Public Facilities and Services
Policy 13.1: Planning and financing for public facilities to serve potential business and
industries except natural resource based should be limited to urban growth
areas.
Policy 13.2: Siting requirements for County public facilities within UGAs shall be jointly
and cooperatively established with the municipalities. Municipal services
July S, 2016 11
Comment#010
should be extended by cities within unincorporated areas of UGAs.
Policy 13.3: The cities and the County shall develop a cooperative communication process
through KCCOG, which includes public involvement at an early stage, to consider
siting of city, countywide, and statewide public facilities, including but not
limited to, solid waste disposal, correctional, transportation, education and human
service facilities.
Policy 13.4: The siting of any public facility requires that the facility location be compatible
with area land uses. Local comprehensive plans and regulations will establish
standards to ensure such compatibility.
Policy 13.5: In determining a local government's fair share of siting of public facilities, the
decision maker shall consider at least the following:
1. The location and effect of existing public facilities on the community.
2. The potential for re-shaping the economy, the environment, and the
community character resulting from the siting of the facility.
Policy 13.6: The County and cities should jointly sponsor the formation of Local Improvement
Districts for the construction or reconstruction of infrastructure to a common
standard which are located in the city and the Urban Growth Areas
Policy 13.7: The levels of service for capital facilities shall be cooperatively defined,planned,
and financed by all segments of the public and private sector involved in
providing a particular service.
Policy 13.8: Financing methods for infrastructure serving residential needs should be mitigated
for resource lands as designated by the County in keeping with anticipated levels
of service impact.
Policy 13.9: All development should be evaluated so that it is assigned a fair and proportionate
share of future infrastructure costs within UGAs and other designated service
areas.
Policy 13.10: All jurisdictions shall participate in identifying needed regional services. All
jurisdictions shall cooperate to identify adequate revenue sources and in creating
financing mechanisms for regional services and infrastructure. Financing
mechanisms may include increment financing or tax base sharing.
Policy 13.11: All jurisdictions shall coordinate bond elections for capital facility planning and
financing.
Policy 13.12: Public facilities will not be located in Resource Lands or Critical Areas unless no
feasible alternative site location exists, such as in the case of utility transmission
facilities.
July 5, 2016 12
Comment #010
Essential Public Facilities
Policy 13.13: The comprehensive planning process in each jurisdiction shall identify land for all
essential public facilities of city, countywide, or statewide significance, such as
human service facilities, educational or solid waste handling facilities,
transportation facilities, correctional facilities and in-patient care facilities.
Policy 13.14: Essential public facilities requiring siting outside cities or UGAs must be self-
supporting and must not require the extension, construction, or maintenance of
municipal services and facilities. Criteria shall be established that address the
provision of services when siting an essential public facility. Essential public
facilities should not be located outside cities or designated twenty-year urban
growth areas unless the nature of their operations needs or dictates that they be
sited in the rural area of the County.
Policy 13.15: Essential public facilities shall be sited in places that enhance the region's
development strategy and that encourage their efficient use by the public.
Policy 13.16: All jurisdictions shall identify existing essential public facilities including but not
limited to:
1. Utility corridors, sewer,water,power and communication facilities
2. All transportation facilities
3. Landfills, solid waste handling, and disposal facilities
4. Sewage treatment facilities
5. Recreational facilities
6. Schools
7. Municipal facilities (city halls, fire stations,police stations, libraries, and post
offices)
8. Parks
9. State and local correctional facilities
10. In-patient facilities, including substance abuse facilities
11. Mental health facilities
12. Group homes
13. Secure community transition facilities
14. Any facility on the state ten-year capital plan maintained by the Office of
Financial Management
Policy 13.17: All jurisdictions shall establish a countywide process for siting essential public
facilities of region-wide significance. This process will include:
1. An inventory of needed facilities;
2. A method of fair share allocation of facilities;
3. Economic and other incentives to jurisdictions receiving such facilities;
4. A method of determining which jurisdiction is responsible for each facility;
5. A public involvement strategy; and
6. Assurance that the environment and public health and safety are protected.
July 5, 2016 13
Comment#010
Policy 13.18: Essential public facilities which are identified by the County, by regional
agreement, or by State or Federal government shall require public involvement
through meetings and hearings, and involve review and comment from citizens
and local jurisdictions.
Policy 13.19: All jurisdictions shall strive to locate regional and essential public facilities so as
to distribute them equitably countywide.No single community shall be required
to absorb an undue share of the impacts of regional and essential facilities.
14. Historic Preserva#ion
Objective: To identify and encourage the preservation of lands, sites, and structures that have
historical or archaeological significance.
Policy 14.1: The County and cities shall consult with local historic preservation groups to
ensure coordination of plans and policies by the Department of Archaeology and
Historic Preservation.
Policy 14.2: The County and cities shall consult with local historic preservation groups and/or
advisory groups as appropriate.
July 5, 2016 14
Comment #010
GLOSSARY OF TERMS
Capital Facilities: Capital Facilities are those physical features or assets which
provide a public service such as, but not limited to: fire
stations, water towers,police stations, libraries,highways,
sewage treatments plants, communication, and recreation
facilities.
Development Impact Fees: Development impact fees mean a payment of money
imposed upon development as a condition of development
approval to pay for public facilities needed to serve new
growth and development, and that is reasonably related to
the new development that creates additional demand and
need for public facilities,that is a proportionate share of the
cost of the public facilities, and that is used for facilities
that reasonably benefit the new development. Impact fee
does not include a reasonable permit or application fee.
Development Regulations: Development regulations means any controls placed on
development or land use activities by a county or a city,
including but not limited to: zoning ordinances, official
controls, planned unit development ordinances, subdivision
ordinances, and binding site plans ordinances.
Development Standards: Development standards mean any required minimal
functional standard which describes or defines how
development is to occur. Development standards are
intended to serve as an established level of expectation by
which development is required to perform.
Essential Public Facilities: Essential public facilities include those facilities that are
typically difficult to site, such as: airports; state education
facilities; state or regional transportation facilities; state and
local correctional facilities; solid waste handling and
disposal facilities; and in-patient facilities including
substance abuse facilities, mental health facilities, group
homes and other health facilities.
Interlocal Agreements: Interlocal agreements mean any binding agreements,
contracts, or other stipulations between two or more
governing entities which implement the provisions of the
County-wide Planning Policies.
LAMIRD: Limited Areas of More Intense Rural Development
(LAMIRDs) are an optional designation available through
the Growth Management Act to recognize areas of rural
July 5, 2016 15
Comment#010
development that are more intensive than the balance of the
rural area. The LAMIRD designation allows for
redevelopment and infill in historical rural towns and
communities, as well as intensification and new
development of isolated small businesses and small-scale
recreational uses. Specific guidance for designation and
development in LAMIRDs is provided in RCW
36.70A.070(5).
Level of Service: A level of service is an indicator of the extent or degree of
service provided by, or proposed to be provided by a public
facility, such as,but not limited to, fire protection, water
supply, sewage treatment, library services, highways, and
communication and recreational services.
Local historic preservation group: Local historic preservation group means a committee,
advisory board or other group that is designated by a local
jurisdiction or recognized by the Washington State
Department of Archaeology and Historic Preservation.
Local Improvement District: Local improvement district means the legislative
establishment of a special taxing district to pay for specific
capital improvements.
Municipal Services: Municipal services are those services in keeping with
and/or required in incorporated cities such as,but not
limited to, centralized sewage collection and treatment,
public water systems, urban street infrastructure,power and
storm water systems, emergency services, libraries, and
government.
Planned Unit Development: A planned unit development is the result of a site specific
zone change, based on a binding site plan. The planned unit
development zoning district is intended to encourage
flexibility in design and development that will result in a
more efficient and desirable use of land.
Policy: A broad based statement of intent that gives management
direction or guidance in the decision making process. The
policy statement is used to select a primary course of
action.
Resource Lands: Resource lands mean those lands designated by the County
which are to be protected from urban growth
encroachments and incompatible land uses. Resource lands
include all lands designated as Commercial Forest, Forest
July 5, 2016 16
Comment#010
and Range,Agricultural Lands of Long-Term Commercial
Significance, and Mineral Resource Lands.
Transfer of Development Rights: Transfer of development rights are the conveyance of
development rights to another parcel of land where
restrictions places on development of the original parcel
prevent its previously allowed development. Transfer of
development rights are usually associated in a program
which involves sending and receiving zones.
Urban Growth Areas: Urban growth areas are those areas designated by the
County or an incorporated city and approved by the
County, in which urban growth is encourages. Urban
growth areas are suitable and desirable for urban densities
as determined by the sponsoring jurisdiction's ability to
provide urban services.
Utilities: Utilities mean the supply, treatment, and distribution, as
appropriate, of domestic water, sewage, stormwater,natural
gas, electricity, telephone, cable television,microwave
transmissions, and streets. Such utilities consist of both the
service activity along with the physical facilities necessary
for the utilities to be supplied. Utilities are supplied by a
combination of general purpose local governments as well
as private and community based organizations.
July 5, 2016 17
Comment #011
From: Sears.Tricia(DNR)
To: Jeremy Johnston
Cc: ;Watson.Deanah(COM)
Subject: Kittitas County's Comprehensive Plan and Critical Areas Ordinance Amendments(2026-S-11466):WGS comments
Date: Friday,February 13,2026 5:54:32 PM
CAUTION: This email originated from outside the Kittitas County network. Do not click
links, open attachments,fulfill requests, or follow guidance unless you recognize the sender
and have verified the content is safe.
Hello Jeremy,
In keeping with the interagency correspondence principles, I am providing you with comments on
For this proposal submitted via Planview, I looked at the proposal and focused on areas related to
WGS work. Of note, but not limited to, I look for language around the geologically hazardous areas,
mineral resource lands, mining, climate change, and natural hazards mitigation plans.
Specifically in this proposal, I reviewed the Critical Areas Checklist Kittitas_06052025, KCC
17A_Critical Areas Ordinance_25.12.31, and Kittitas Comp Plan V3.0 RedlinesPDF.
Kudos to you for making changes to the critical areas ordinance and comp plan!
Crft'cal Areas Checklist Mtjitas 2
The checklist is filled out. No further comment.
KCC 17A Critical Areas Ordinance 25.1.2.31
Definitions that are included: alluvial fan, avalanche hazard, best available science, erosion, erosion
hazard areas, geologically hazardous areas, geotechnical analysis or geotechnical report, landslide
hazard areas, mine hazard areas, qualified professional, seismic hazard areas, and volcanic hazard
areas. Good. Consider adding the WAC reference to the definitions of hazards.
On page 12-13 the code describes that temporary or permanent field identification may be required.
Great to see the provisions noting passable wildlife fencing and signage.
On page 13, great to see the requirement that all the critical areas are required to be noted and
recorded to the title.
On page 14,the construction details provisions does not include a stormwater management detail to
describe how the stormwater on the property will be managed. Suggest adding that.
On page 17, under"Critical areas may be affected by proposal, "suggest including a reference to the
Comment#011
Washington Department of Natural Resources in addition to the reference to Ecology and Fish and
Wildlife. DNR,via Washington Geological Survey, provides BAS for geologically hazardous areas.
On page 33, KCC§ 17A.02.620. Qualified professional. "A qualified professional for preparing
Geologically Hazardous Area Assessments must be a professional geologist or engineering
geologist licensed in the State of Washington." Great!
On page 59 "§ 17A.06.020. Designation, classification, and mapping. Designation. Lands classified as
landslide, erosion (including channel migration zones), alluvial fan, seismic, and mine hazard areas,
are hereby designated as geologically hazardous areas."
Great to see the detailed provisions about alluvial fan! Great to the Washington Department of
Natural Resources mentioned on page 61 with mapping info. DNR has more maps than the historic
maps that are mentioned. Suggest including a reference to the Washington Geologic Information
Portal.
On page 62, good to see "Critical facilities prohibited. Critical facilities shall not be sited within
landslide, erosion, alluvial fan, or mine hazard areas unless there is no other practical
alternative."
On page 66, the code refers to the Geologically Hazardous Areas Risk Assessment and a
Geotechnical Report. Geotechnical report has a definition in the code.That definition does not
include the term Geologically Hazardous Areas Risk Assessment.Suggest adding that term to the
definition so the terms are both defined and in agreement.Also,so it is clear that there is just one
type of geotechnical report/review/assessment rather than a tiered approach.
Overall,the code provisions are thoughtful, well-written, and detailed. Nice work!
Due to time constraints, I cannot provide a detailed review of the comp plan. In a quick look at it, it
looks ok.
Below, I include our usual language for this and future endeavors.
Recognizing the limitations of the current proposals, I want to mention that it would be great for you
to consider these in current or future work, be it in your comprehensive plan, development code,
and SMP updates, and in your work in general:
• Consider adding a reference to the definition of geologically hazardous areas, WAC 365-190-
120, in other areas besides the CAO. In addition, consider adding a reference to WAC 365-
196-480 for natural resource lands.
• Consider adding in other areas besides the CAO. If you have not checked our interactive
database,the Washington Geologic Information Portal, lately,you may wish to do so.
15en1aeic Information Portal I WAS- DN j
• If you have not checked out our Geologic Planning page, you may wish to do so.5eologi�
Planning
Comment#011
Thank you for considering our comments. If you have any questions or need additional information,
please contact me. For your convenience, if there are no concerns or follow-up discussion, you may
consider these comments to be final as of the 60-day comment deadline of 3/30/26.
Have a great dayl
Tricia
Tricia R.Sears(she/her/hers)
Geologic Planning Liaison
Washington Geological Survey(WGS)
Washington Department of Natural Resources(DNR)
Cell: 360-628-2867 1 Email:tricia.searsPdnr.wa.gov
Comment #012
Easton Subarea Plan—Public Comment
PUBLIC COMMENT ON THE EASTON SUBAREA PLAN
What the Law Allows and Prohibits on Type 3 LAMIRD Land
Under the Growth Management Act and Kittitas County Code
To: Kittitas County Planning Department, Community Development Services and consultants,
As you update the Easton Subarea Plan, I am submitting this comment to request that the plan
include clear, enforceable language defining what can and cannot be built on Type 3 LAMIRD
land. The Growth Management Act, Kittitas County's Comprehensive Plan, and the County
Code already set these standards. They just need to be stated plainly in the subarea plan so
there is no ambiguity going forward.
This comment draws on the legal framework established by RCW 36.70A.070(5), RCW
36.70A.030(35), Kittitas County Code Chapter 17.15, the Critical Areas Ordinance (KCC Title
17A), the Kittitas County Comprehensive Plan, and relevant Growth Management Hearings
Board decisions.
1. WHAT STATE LAW SAYS ABOUT TYPE 3 LAMIRDS
The Growth Management Act created Type 3 LAM IRDs under RCW 36.70A.070(5) as a narrow
exception to general rural land use restrictions. The Legislature authorized counties to allow
limited new commercial development in rural areas, but only when all three of the following
conditions are met:
1. Isolated small-scale business. The development must be an isolated, small-scale
business. This is not aspirational language—it is a ceiling on what can be built.
2. Site previously occupied by an existing business. Under RCW 36.70A.070(5)(d), the
new development must utilize a site that was previously occupied by a business.
LAMIRD designations are tied to areas or uses in existence prior to 1991. This is a
threshold eligibility requirement, not a preference.
3. Conforms to rural character. The new business must conform to the rural character of
the area as defined by the county government.
These are conjunctive requirements. A proposal that fails any one of them is ineligible for Type
3 LAMIRD development. The Growth Management Hearings Board confirmed in People fora
Liveable Community v. Jefferson County(No. 03-2-0009c, 2003) that LAMIRDs are "intended to
be a one-time recognition of existing areas and uses and are not intended to be used
continuously to meet needs (real or perceived)for additional commercial and industrial lands."
2. THE HARD LIMITS: WHAT KITTITAS COUNTY CODE ALLOWS
Kittitas County implemented the GMA's Type 3 LAMIRD standards through KCC 17.15.070,
which governs the rural General Commercial zoning district. These are the binding dimensional
and intensity limits for any development on Type 3 LAMIRD land:
These limits exist to implement the GMA's "isolated small-scale business" standard. They are
not starting points for negotiation. They are the maximum development intensity the Legislature
intended for rural commercial land. Any proposal that exceeds these thresholds is, by definition,
not a small-scale business and cannot be approved under Type 3 LAMIRD authority.
Page 1
Comment #012
Easton Subarea Plan—Public Comment
3. SITE ELIGIBILITY: THE PRE-EXISTING BUSINESS REQUIREMENT
Not every parcel within a Type 3 LAMIRD boundary is automatically eligible for new commercial
development. RCW 36.70A.070(5)(d) requires that the site be one "previously occupied by an
existing business." This means:
Recommended subarea plan language: "No new commercial development shall be approved
on Type 3 LAMIRD land unless the applicant demonstrates, through documented evidence
including historical aerial photography and county records, that the specific parcel was
previously occupied by a commercial business. Vacant or undeveloped land within a LAMIRD
boundary does not satisfy this requirement."
4. RURAL CHARACTER CONFORMANCE: WHAT THE STANDARD
REQUIRES
Even when a proposal meets the size limits and site eligibility test, it must also conform to rural
character. RCW 36.70A.030(35) defines rural character through seven criteria. Kittitas County
has adopted its own local definition: rural character is "the predominant visual landscape of
open spaces, mountains, forests, and farms and the activities which preserve such features."
Any new development on Type 3 LAMIRD land must satisfy all of the following:
• Open space and natural landscape predominate over the built environment (RCW
36.70A.030(35)(a))
• Traditional rural lifestyles and rural-based economies are fostered, not displaced
(RCW 36.70A.030(35)(b))
• Visual landscapes traditionally found in rural areas are maintained (RCW
36.70A.030(35)(c))
• Compatibility with wildlife and fish habitat (RCW 36.70A.030(35)(d))
• No inappropriate conversion of undeveloped land into sprawling, low-density
development (RCW 36.70A.030(35)(e))
• No requirement for extension of urban governmental services (RCW
36.70A.030(35)(f))
• Protection of natural surface water flows and groundwater recharge/discharge
areas (RCW 36.70A.030(35)(g))
Additionally, Comprehensive Plan Policies T-P44 and RR-P2 discourage uses incompatible with
resource lands and airports. The Easton area includes working forest land managed by the
Washington State Department of Natural Resources and the Easton State Airport. WSDOT's
Aviation Division has previously expressed concern about increased development densities
around this airport. The subarea plan should explicitly require compatibility review for any
proposal adjacent to resource lands or airport operations.
The GMA and Comprehensive Plan also prohibit strip commercial development along highway
corridors. The subarea plan should include language preventing the clustering of commercial
uses that would create a pattern of highway-oriented commercial sprawl.
Page 2
Comment #012
Easton Subarea Plan—Public Comment
5. CRITICAL AREAS PROTECTION: NON-NEGOTIABLE
REQUIREMENTS
Much of the Easton LAMIRD area sits within or adjacent to designated Critical Aquifer Recharge
Areas (CARAs). The Easton Water District depends entirely on groundwater for its domestic
and drinking water supply. The subarea plan must incorporate the following existing legal
requirements and make them explicit in the development review process:
Recommended subarea plan language: "No development application within a Type 3
LAMIRD shall be approved without a verified critical areas review that cross-references the
County's Critical Area CARA maps and Group A Wellhead Protection Area maps. A finding of
'no critical areas'is insufficient without documented evidence that the County's own CARA
maps, wellhead protection area designations, and Critical Areas Ordinance requirements have
been reviewed and addressed. All proposals within or within 200 feet of a CARA shall comply
with mitigation sequencing under KCC 17A.01.100 and use Best Available Science to protect
groundwater resources."
6. CLEAR STATEMENT: WHAT YOU CAN AND CANNOT BUILD
Based on the full legal framework above, here is a plain-language summary of what is and is not
permissible on Type 3 LAMIRD land in the Easton area. I request that the subarea plan
incorporate this distinction explicitly:
WHAT YOU CAN BUILD
• A small-scale commercial business that fits within 30,000 square feet of total use area
• Retail uses that do not exceed 4,000 square feet
• Development that keeps impervious surface at or below 33% of the lot
• New business on a site with documented prior commercial occupancy
• Uses that preserve the visual landscape of open spaces, forests, and farms
• Uses compatible with adjacent resource lands, airports, local resort business, and
outdoor recreation
• Development that protects groundwater recharge areas and meets Best Available
Science standards
• Businesses that provide job opportunities for rural residents without requiring urban
services
WHAT YOU CANNOT BUILD
• Any development exceeding 30,000 square feet of total use area
• Any retail component exceeding 4,000 square feet
• Any project with impervious surface coverage exceeding 33% of the lot
• New commercial development on vacant or undeveloped land with no documented prior
business use
• Large-scale highway-oriented commercial facilities (travel centers, large fuel stations,
multi-use commercial complexes)
Page 3
Comment #012
Easton Subarea Plan—Public Comment
• Development that converts open space, forest, or natural landscape into predominantly
built environment
Uses that create strip commercial patterns along highway corridors, especially near
other LAMIRD commercial uses
Uses incompatible with adjacent working forest land, airport operations, or outdoor
recreation values
• Any development within a Critical Aquifer Recharge Area that has not undergone a
verified CARA review, mitigation sequencing, and Best Available Science analysis
• 24/7 commercial operations that generate noise, light pollution, and heavy vehicle traffic
incompatible with rural character
7. USE THE RIGHT PROCESS FOR THE RIGHT PROPOSAL
The subarea plan should make clear that a variance is not the appropriate mechanism for
approving development that exceeds Type 3 LAMIRD dimensional standards. A variance
addresses minor deviations in cases of practical difficulty or unnecessary hardship. It is not a
tool for authorizing development at a fundamentally different scale or intensity than what the
zoning allows.
Recommended subarea plan language: "Any proposed development that exceeds the
dimensional standards established in KCC 17.15.070 for rural General Commercial zoning shall
not be processed as a variance. Proposals that would fundamentally alter the character, scale,
or intensity of land use shall be evaluated as a Comprehensive Plan amendment and rezone,
subject to full public participation, environmental review, and policy analysis as required by the
Growth Management Act."
8. SUMMARY OF REQUESTED SUBAREA PLAN ADDITIONS
I respectfully request that the Easton Subarea Plan be updated to include the following
provisions:
4. Restate the binding dimensional limits from KCC 17.15.070 (30,000 sq ft total area,
4,000 sq ft retail, 33% impervious surface) as hard caps that cannot be exceeded
through variance.
5. Require documented proof of prior commercial occupancy through historical aerial
photography and county records before any Type 3 LAMIRD development is approved.
6. Mandate verified critical areas review cross-referenced against County CARA maps
and Group A Wellhead Protection Area maps for every development application.
7. Require mitigation sequencing and Best Available Science for all proposals within or
within 200 feet of a Critical Aquifer Recharge Area.
8. Require compatibility review for proposals adjacent to DNR resource lands and the
Easton State Airport, consistent with Comprehensive Plan Policies T-P44 and RR-P2.
9. Prohibit strip commercial development patterns along highway corridors, consistent
with GMA and Comprehensive Plan policy.
10. Direct over-scale proposals to the Comprehensive Plan amendment and rezone
process, not variance, to ensure adequate public participation and environmental
review.
Page 4
Comment #012
Easton Subarea Plan—Public Comment
9. ADDITIONAL COMMENTS ON THE EASTON SUBAREA PLAN
In addition to the Type 3 LAMIRD development standards addressed above, I am submitting the
following comments on other sections of the Easton Subarea Plan. These comments address
gaps in the plan's treatment of housing, economic development, wastewater infrastructure, and
wildfire mitigation, areas where the plan needs stronger, more actionable language to serve this
community.
9.1 Housing: The Plan Must Be Specific About Affordable and Workforce
Housing
The Housing section of the Subarea Plan (Section 3) acknowledges that Easton's population is
aging, that renter-occupied units have declined by 55%, and that the community has expressed
strong interest in affordable housing for young families and first-time buyers. However, the
plan's goals and policies remain too general to produce results. The plan references "affordable
housing options" and "property improvements" without defining what affordable means in the
Easton context, without identifying specific housing types, and without committing to
measurable targets.
The community's own comments are specific: they want starter homes, affordable single-family
homes for first-time buyers, ADUs on R-5 lots, and protections against outside investment
driving up prices. The plan should match that specificity. I recommend the following additions:
a. Define "affordable housing" in the plan using a standard benchmark: housing that
costs no more than 30% of the area median household income. The plan should state
this threshold explicitly so that future policy decisions can be measured against it.
b. Include workforce housing as a distinct category. Workforce housing serves the
people who work in the community, teachers, fire district staff, service workers, school
employees but cannot afford to live here. The plan should explicitly commit to creating
housing options for households earning between 60% and 120% of area median
income.
c. Set a measurable housing target. Based on the plan's own data showing 408
residents and an aging population, the community should set a goal of 20-40 new
affordable and workforce housing units within ten years within the Type 1 LAMIRD, tied
to wastewater infrastructure capacity(see Section 9.3 below).
d. Add short-term rental protections. Community members specifically raised concerns
about outside investors driving up prices and short-term rentals overtaking housing
stock. The plan should include policy language directing the county to regulate or limit
short-term rentals within the LAMIRD to protect the community's housing supply for full-
time residents.
e. Identify specific grant programs for affordable housing development in the
recommended actions, including the Washington Housing Trust Fund, USDA Multi-
Family Housing Direct Loans (up to$50M for rural communities under 35,000
population), and HUD Community Development Block Grants through Washington
Commerce.
Page 5
Comment #012
Easton Subarea Plan—Public Comment
9.2 Economic Development: The Plan Needs a Market Analysis and
Actionable Strategy
The Economic Development section (Section 4) identifies community desire for revitalization of
Railroad Street and small local businesses. It proposes walking tours, vision boards, and
consulting with railroad operators as recommended actions. While community engagement is
valuable, these actions alone will not generate jobs, attract businesses, or close the service
gaps residents have identified. Walking tours and vision boards are process steps, not
economic development outcomes.
The plan contains no market analysis. There is no assessment of what types of businesses are
financially viable in a community of 408 residents with seasonal recreational traffic. There is no
estimate of consumer demand, visitor spending capture, or revenue potential for the types of
businesses residents want (coffee shops, restaurants, gear rental, small retail). Without this
analysis, the plan is asking the community to pursue economic development without knowing
what the market will support.
I recommend the following additions to the Economic Development section:
a. Commission or include a basic market analysis as a recommended action within the
first year. This does not need to be expensive, EDA Planning and Technical Assistance
Grants (up to $300K) or USDA Rural Business Development Grants (up to $500K) can
fund feasibility studies for rural commercial development. The analysis should assess:
what types of businesses are viable given year-round and seasonal population, what the
1-90 traffic volume (30,000+ vehicles per day) means in terms of capture potential, and
what infrastructure prerequisites must be met before businesses can operate.
b. Tie the economic development goals directly to the wastewater infrastructure
constraint. The plan acknowledges that the lack of a sewer or septic system is the
primary barrier to development and school expansion (Section 5.3). No amount of vision-
boarding will produce a coffee shop or restaurant on Railroad Street if there is no
wastewater system to support it. The economic development section should state plainly
that securing wastewater infrastructure funding is a prerequisite to Railroad Street
revitalization, not a parallel effort.
c. Include job creation targets. The plan should set a measurable goal, even a modest
one such as 15-25 new permanent jobs within five years from small businesses, cottage
industries, and recreation-related services within the LAMIRDs.
d. Replace or supplement the walking tour and vision board actions with concrete steps:
apply for an EDA Planning Grant for a Railroad Street market feasibility study within the
first year; identify three to five specific business types the market will support and
actively recruit them; and coordinate with the Kittitas County Economic Development
Committee to integrate Easton into the county-wide economic development strategy
currently being developed.
9.3 Wastewater Infrastructure: The Single Most Critical Prerequisite
The Subarea Plan identifies the lack of a septic or sewer system as the primary barrier to
development and school expansion. Community members have raised this repeatedly in the
March 2025 open house, in the April 2025 community meeting, and in ongoing discussions. It
was the very first comment at the open house: "Need a large scale septic system to move
Page 6
Comment #012
Easton Subarea Plan—Public Comment
Easton forward."And yet the plan does not include a single recommended action, timeline, or
funding strategy for securing wastewater infrastructure.
This is the linchpin. Without wastewater infrastructure, Railroad Street revitalization cannot
happen. New businesses cannot operate. Housing expansion is constrained. The school cannot
expand. The plan needs to state this clearly and include a concrete path forward. I recommend
the following:
a. Add a new goal: "EG 5.1: Secure funding for a community wastewater system to
serve the Type 1 LAMIRD, enabling economic development, housing expansion, and
school facility improvements."
b. Include specific federal and state funding programs in the recommended actions:
USDA Rural Utilities Water and Waste Disposal Grants and Loans (up to $5M per
project for rural communities); EPA Clean Water State Revolving Fund through
Washington Ecology; Washington Department of Commerce CERB infrastructure loans
($5M maximum at 1% interest); and USDA Rural Economic Development Loans and
Grants through local utilities.
c. Add a Year 2 implementation action: commission a wastewater feasibility study to
assess system options (community septic, small-scale treatment, or decentralized
cluster systems), estimated costs, and the most competitive federal or state funding
programs. This study is a prerequisite to any grant application and should be prioritized
alongside the communication networks and inventory milestones already in the
implementation timeline.
d. Add wastewater infrastructure as a milestone in the implementation timeline (Section
7.6), targeting feasibility study completion by Year 2 and grant application submission by
Year 3.
e. Change language where "restrooms" are mentioned to "tourism support services"
9.4 Wildfire Mitigation: The Plan Should Pursue Firewise Designation and
Federal Funding
Section 6 of the Subarea Plan correctly identifies wildfire as a serious threat to the Easton
community, noting that the USDA classifies risk to homes in Kittitas County as greater than 97%
of counties in Washington. The plan includes a policy to "Create a Firewise Community Plan"
(EP 6.1) and recommends seeking funding for fire mitigation. However, the recommended
actions are limited to quarterly consultations, hosting an awareness day, and seeking general
funding opportunities. These are awareness activities, not a funded mitigation strategy.
Kittitas County already has a strong foundation through KFACC (Kittitas Forest and Fire
Adapted Communities Coalition), which has secured $10 million in federal funding for forest
thinning and has established 18 recognized Firewise Communities in the county. Easton should
build on this existing infrastructure rather than starting from scratch. I recommend the following
additions:
a. Set an explicit goal of achieving Firewise USA community recognition for the Easton
area within two years. This is a structured national program administered by the National
Fire Protection Association that provides a framework for community-level wildfire
preparedness, and recognized communities may qualify for insurance premium
reductions of 10-20%, a direct financial benefit to every homeowner in the area.
Page 7
Comment #012
Easton Subarea Plan—Public Comment
b. Include specific federal grant programs in the recommended actions: USDA
Community Wildfire Defense Grants ($250K—$10M for fuels reduction planning and
treatment, annual cycle typically in spring); FEMA Fire Prevention and Safety Grants (up
to $200K for Firewise community programs); FEMA Building Resilient Infrastructure and
Communities (BRIC) grants for hazard mitigation projects; and Washington DNR Forest
Health Grants for fuels reduction and forest restoration.
c. Add a Year 1 implementation action: coordinate with KFACC and Fire District 3 to
conduct a Wildland-Urban Interface assessment specific to the Easton subarea, map
defensible space needs for properties within and adjacent to the LAMIRDs, and submit a
USDA Community Wildfire Defense Grant application by the next annual cycle.
d. Add wildfire mitigation funding as a milestone in the implementation timeline (Section
7.6), targeting Firewise recognition by Year 2 and a federal fuels-reduction grant
application by Year 1.
The laws already exist. The limits are already on the books. The Easton Subarea Plan is our
opportunity to make sure they are applied clearly and consistently so that the rural character of
this community is protected for the long term. But protection alone is not enough. This plan must
also give Easton's residents the tools they need to build a sustainable future, affordable housing
they can actually live in, businesses that can actually operate, wastewater infrastructure that
unlocks both, and wildfire protections funded by the federal and state programs that exist for
exactly this purpose. Thank you for considering these comments.
Respectfully submitted,
Gina Peckman,
Easton Community member
Page 8
Comment #012
Easton Subarea Plan—Public Comment
Page 9
Comment #012
Easton Subarea Plan—Public Comment
APPENDIX: LEGAL CITATIONS REFERENCE
Citation What It Establishes
RCW 36.70A.070(5) Type 3 LAMIRDs limited to"isolated small-scale
businesses"
RCW 36.70A.070(5)(d) Requires"site previously occupied by an existing business"
RCW 36.70A.030(35) Seven-part definition of rural character
KCC 17.15.070 30,000 sq ft maximum, 33% impervious surface limit
KCC 17.15.070.2(48) 4,000 sq ft retail sales limit
KCC 17A.03.020 Critical Aquifer Recharge Area designation and review
KCC 17A.02.020 200-foot buffer regulation around CARAs
KCC 17A.01.100 Mitigation sequencing for adverse impacts to critical areas
Comp Plan Policies T-P44, RR-P2 Discourage uses incompatible with resource lands and
airports
People for a Liveable Cmty. v. Jefferson LAM IRDs are"one-time recognition,"not ongoing
County(2003) expansion mechanism
Page 10
Comment #013
MAMMANASTASH ARCHITECTURE
PLANNING & DEVELOPMENT
Memo
SUBJECT: Comment on Housing Policy in the Draft
Comprehensive Plan for Kittitas County
FROM: Skylar Bisom-Rapp, Ellensburg Resident
Partner—Manastash Architecture Planning &Development
DATE: 03/13/2026
Housing affordability has become a significant issue across Kittitas County. While the impacts
are particularly visible in the upper county—where resort development and second-home
demand have driven land values upward—the problem is increasingly countywide,
suggesting that Kittitas County may be the outer edge of the larger Puget Sound Region
housing crisis.At present,the median household income in the county is not sufficient to
afford the median home price.
Affordable housing is therefore no longer simply a housing policy issue; it is increasingly a
constraint on the county's long-term economic stability. When housing costs rise faster than
local wages,communities eventually face labor supply challenges as workers struggle to live
near their jobs.
At a more human level,younger residents of Kittitas County are finding it difficult to remain in
the communities where they grew up.When we think about the Comprehensive Plan's stated
mission to preserve the county's rural character,it is tempting to see that as a mandate to
work against housing development, or at least to concede at the outset that the tools available
to the county to promote it are significantly limited by that directive. However,if the working
rural people who were raised here are increasingly unable to find accessible housing and are
effectively forced to leave, it calls into question what rural character really means. Simply put,
the county's people are no small part of its character, and providing for housing is a critical
part of maintaining it. Given this context,the Comprehensive Plan should take a clearer
position about the range of housing policy avenues the County may need to explore.
The draft Land Use, Rural and Resource Lands, and Housing elements establish a strong
framework for managing growth and preserving rural character. However,they largely focus
on land supply, development patterns, and coordination with municipalities rather than
identifying concrete housing policy tools. For example,the Land Use Element emphasizes
directing growth toward urban growth areas (LU-G1) and encouraging infill development
(LU-P8), while also emphasizing coordination with cities regarding development regulations
(LU-P5 and LU-P9).These are important principles, but they do not in themselves address
whether housing will be produced or that the housing produced will be attainable for local
residents.
509-968-5201 www.mapd.co 421 N Pearl St,Ste 100,Ellensburg,WA 98926
Comment#013
MAPD
1. Incremental Housing Supply
The Comprehensive Plan should place greater emphasis on incremental housing supply
strategies. Recent state legislation requires jurisdictions planning under the Growth
Management Act to allow two accessory dwelling units per lot in single-family zones by the
next periodic update (RCW 36.70A.681).The County should clearly state its intent to
implement these reforms and support municipalities in doing the same.
However,ADU policy alone may have limited impact if those units cannot be financed as
rents in many Kittitas communities are marginally lower than construction costs. However,
sales in the county,even for small homes, remain strong.As such,the Comprehensive Plan
could also encourage the adoption of unit lot subdivision frameworks under RCW
58.17.060(3).
Unit lot subdivision allows small ownership lots to be created within a parent parcel without
the complexity of condominiumization. In practice,this can make it possible for ADUs,
cottages, and similar housing types to be sold separately from the primary residence,opening
up ownership pathways that are otherwise difficult to finance.
2. Rural Communities and LAMIRDs
Another potential source of incremental housing supply can be found in Limited Areas of More
Intensive Rural Development(LAMIRDs). Discussed in the Rural and Resource Lands
Element,the Comprehensive Plan places strong emphasis on preserving their rural character,
which is appropriate under the Growth Management Act.At the same time,the plan should
recognize that these existing rural communities may represent appropriate locations for
modest infill housing.
LAMIRDs already function as historic rural community centers and often contain infrastructure
that surrounding rural lands do not. Where sewer systems or community water systems exist,
modest increases in residential density may be compatible with both Growth Management
Act requirements and the continued viability of those communities.
Recent legislation such as SB 5471 authorizes counties to permit certain middle housing
types up to four units per lot in unincorporated urban growth areas, and LAMIRDs.The
Comprehensive Plan could direct staff to evaluate whether this authority could be used
strategically in areas where infrastructure capacity already exists.
While the GMA precludes the creation of new water and sewer utilities outside of UGAs for
the purpose of encouraging development,there is more flexibility for modernizing existing
ones.The County may wish to pursue state and federal infrastructure grants to strengthen
water or wastewater systems in existing rural communities.Targeted infrastructure
investments could support housing in locations where communities already exist, rather than
encouraging development pressure in previously undeveloped rural areas.
509-968-5201 www.mapd.co 421 N Pearl St,Ste 100,Ellensburg,WA 98926 2
Comment#013
MAM
3. Limits of Regulatory Capacity Alone
The Housing Element appropriately identifies the need to monitor housing conditions and
coordinate with municipalities. However,the element could more clearly recognize that
expanding regulatory capacity alone will not resolve the affordability gap.
In many planning discussions,there is an assumption that modest density increases or zoning
incentives will meaningfully improve housing affordability. In practice,the economics of
housing development in rural markets make this unlikely. With construction costs and
financing costs both elevated,the marginal revenue gained from a small increase in allowable
units rarely closes the capital gap that defines affordable housing projects. In rural contexts,
this challenge is compounded by smaller project scales and relatively high per-unit
infrastructure costs.Additional housing capacity provided by encouraging infill is therefore
necessary, but it is unlikely to be sufficient on its own.
4. Local Housing Funding Tools
The Comprehensive Plan could more explicitly recognize the role that local housing funding
mechanisms may need to play. Kittitas County already administers a housing grant program,
which is a positive step, but the program currently operates at a very small scale relative to
the size of the problem.As a result, most affordable housing projects in the county solely rely
on competitive state and federal funding sources such as the Housing Trust Fund or Low-
Income Housing Tax Credits.
These programs are valuable but highly competitive, and rural jurisdictions often face
disadvantages competing for them due to smaller project sizes and a limited number of
experienced affordable housing developers operating locally.Several projects in the county
have already been delayed or cancelled following unsuccessful Housing Trust Fund
applications.
The Comprehensive Plan could direct the County to explore options for expanding its own
housing funding capacity.Washington law provides several tools that could be considered,
including:
- The affordable housing sales tax authorized under RCW 82.14.530,which I believe the
County previously passed on but should be revisited in the new political context of the
expanding housing crisis.
- The use of Real Estate Excise Tax revenues for housing capital investments under RCW
82.46.035 and RCW 82.46.037
Ellensburg has used the sales tax funding to great effect, and the county could evaluate
whether similar approaches might support housing development in communities that do not
have municipal housing programs.
509-968-5201 www.mapd.co 421 N Pearl St,Ste 100,Ellensburg,WA 98926 3
Comment #013
MAPD
5. Public Land and Tax Title Properties
The plan could also address the potential role of public land in supporting housing
development.Washington law allows public agencies to transfer surplus land for affordable
housing under RCW 39.33.015. Ellensburg has been using this to good effect over the last
several years, providing a good example. However,on the County's hands,this is an even
more powerful tool, as the County also controls parcels acquired through tax foreclosure,
which represent another potential source of land that could support housing development.
A policy direction encouraging evaluation of County-owned parcels,including tax-title land,
for housing potential could provide a pathway for reducing land costs—one of the most
significant barriers to housing development in smaller markets.Some jurisdictions have begun
assembling these parcels into small land banks capable of supporting "scattered site" housing
projects, which can improve development feasibility when individual parcels are too small to
support standalone projects.
6. Development Agreements and Housing Outcomes
Finally,the Comprehensive Plan could acknowledge the County's ability to negotiate housing
outcomes through development agreements authorized under RCW 36.70B.170—.210.
Development agreements may provide a mechanism for securing housing commitments
when major subdivisions,rezonings,or infrastructure investments are proposed.Similarly,the
County could explore incorporating housing commitments into optional development
pathways such as cluster zoning or transfer of development rights proposals. Because these
development options are voluntary alternatives to baseline zoning,they may provide a legally
durable framework for achieving housing outcomes.
That the recent negotiations around the extension of the Suncadia Development Agreement
term have not included discussions of additional community benefits around affordable
housing and the infrastructure to support it (at least in publicly available documents) seems to
suggest that the county is not fully using this source of leverage.
7. Conclusion
The draft Comprehensive Plan provides a strong framework for managing growth and
protecting rural character. However,given current housing market conditions,the plan may
benefit from more clearly identifying the policy tools the County may need to explore.These
could include expanding local housing funding capacity, leveraging public land, supporting
incremental housing forms such as ADUs and unit lot subdivisions,evaluating modest infill
opportunities in LAMIRDs, pursuing infrastructure investments that support existing rural
communities, and using development agreements strategically.
Taken together,these approaches would better position the County to address housing
affordability while remaining consistent with the broader goals of the Comprehensive Plan.
509-968-5201 www.mapd.co 421 N Pearl St,Ste 100,Ellensburg,WA 98926 4
Appendix B Additional Public Comments Submitted in Writing
Appendix B Additional Public Comments Submitted in Writim
Chair and members of the Commission,thank you for the opportunity to speak this
evening. My name is Gina Peckman and I am a community member of Kittitas County along
with a member of the Easton community working on the sub-area plan.
The Growth Management Act is built on a simple principle. Goal 12, codified in RCW
36.70A.020(12), states it plainly: public facilities and services necessary to support
development shall be adequate to serve the development at the time it is available for
occupancy and use, without decreasing current service levels below locally established
minimum standards.
That is the concurrency requirement. It is not optional. It is the law.
RCW 36.70A.070(6)(b)goes further—it requires the County to adopt and enforce
ordinances that prohibit development approval if the development causes level of service
to decline below adopted standards, unless improvements or strategies are in place at the
time of development, or a financial commitment exists to complete them within six years.
(And in Kittitas County Conservation v. Kittitas County,the Growth Management Hearings
Board found this County noncompliant on transportation concurrency—specifically
because the County could not cite any provisions that would prohibit development
approval when level of service standards were not met.That finding is still instructive
today.
R-P73 expands LAMIRD boundaries—pushing more intensive developirlent into rural
areas that have no sewer, limited water,volunteer fire service, and roads the County
already cannot afford to maintain.The County's own transportation analysis identifies a
$91 million funding deficit over 20 years.And the proposed solution? Privatize the roads
and shift the costs to rural residents.
LU-P39 opens rural commercial zones to residential, and tourism uses with no size limits,
no density caps, and no infrastructure triggers.There is no concurrency analysis.There is
no requirement that water, sewer, fire, or road capacity be confirmed before development
is approved.
The Workforce Housing Rural Innovation Overlay can be applied anywhere residential is
permitted,which is essentially the entire county, again with no concurrency requirements
tied to it.
And PUD guardrails under RR-P21 are being weakened, removing the constraint that PUDs
in rural areas cannot create high-density environments requiring urban services.
Appendix B Additional Public Comments Submitted in Writino
Taken together,these policies authorize growth across unincorporated Kittitas County
without requiring that the infrastructure exist to support it.That is not just bad policy, it is a
direct conflict with multiple RCW's(RCW 36.70A.020(12)and RCW 36.70A.070(6)(b).
What is missing from these proposed changes is financial analysis. Before the County
expands where development can occur,the public deserves to know:What will it cost?
Who pays?What is the impact on roads,water systems,fire districts, and schools?What
happens when the infrastructure fails to keep up, as it already has and most certainly will in
the future.
These are not hypothetical questions.The County already faces a$91 million
transportation gap. Fire districts are stretched thin. Insurance markets are tightening
because the infrastructure to fight wildfire does not exist in many of the areas where these
policies would encourage new development.
We are not opposed to growth. We are opposed to growth without a plan to pay for it.We
are opposed to handing future generations a landscape of private roads, underfunded fire
districts, and development that was approved without the infrastructure to support it.
We ask the Commission to require a fiscal impact analysis of these amendments before
they are adopted. Requires concurrency, not as an afterthought, but as a precondition.And
do not expand the LAMRID boundaries. Any other expansion should be tabled until the
County can demonstrate it can serve what already exists.
Thank you for all your dedication to this process. I request this comment be entered into
the official record.
Public Comment—Kittitas County Comprehensive Plan Update March 2026
u C�a��[is Co went
Kittitas County Comprehensive Plan Update
Re: LAMIRD Boundary Expansion (RR-P73) & Rural Mixed-Use Policy (LU-P39)
Submitted to Moo Kittitas County Planning Commission for the official record
Kittitas County Planning Commission
c/o Community Development Services
Dear Chair and Members of the Planning Commission,
Thank you for the opportunity to submit public comments on the proposed comprehensive plan
amendments. We appreciate the significant effort that has gone into this update and want to
begin by acknowledging several provisions we strongly support: the wildfire infrastructure and
insurance affordability policies, and the Coal Mines Trail extension to Salmon La Sac. These are
smart, community-supported, GMA-compliant changes.
Our comments are focused on two specific policies— RR-P73 and LU-P39—which we believe
carry significant legal exposure, lack necessary safeguards, and were advanced without
adequate input from the communities most directly affected. We raise these concerns
constructively, with the goal of strengthening the plan before adoption.
RR-P73: LAMIRD Boundary Expansion
The Legal Problem
The proposed expansion of the Ronald LAMIRD boundary under RR-P73 is, in our view, the
single highest-risk policy change in this update. We urge the Commission to give it careful
scrutiny before moving forward.
Under the Growth Management Act (RCW 36.70A.070(5)(d)), LAM[RD boundaries must be
drawn around development that existed at the time the county was required to plan under GMA.
The statute is clear: counties must establish "logical outer boundaries, based on the boundaries
of existing development, to contain more intense development."The Growth Management
Hearings Board, the Court of Appeals, and the Supreme Court have all treated this as a one-
time recognition standard not an invitation to expand boundaries in future plan updates.
This is not an abstract legal concern. Kittitas County has already been on the losing end of this
issue. In Kittitas County v. Kittitas County Conservation Coalition (2013), the Court of Appeals
upheld the GMHB's rejection of a LAMIRD expansion in Thorp, finding the expanded area did
not reflect pre-existing development patterns. Whatcom County spent over a decade in litigation
after Futurewise successfully challenged LAMIRD boundaries that exceeded the built
environment. Gold Star Resorts v. Futurewise (2009) reinforced the responsibility of counties to
minimize and contain LAMIRDs. The legal trajectory is consistent and unambiguous: boundary
expansions invite challenge, and they lose.
Furthermore, under SB 5042 (now codified in RCW 36.70A.070), the effective date of any action
that expands a LAMIRD is automatically suspended if a petition for review is timely filed with
the GMHB. This means any development approved under the expanded boundary during
litigation could be retroactively invalidated —creating legal and financial exposure not just for
the County, but for landowners who relied on the expansion in good faith.
Submitted for the Public Retard Page 1
Appendix B Additional Public Comments Submitted in Writing
Public Comment-Kittitas County Comprehensive Plan Update March 2026
We ask the Commission: Has the Prosecuting Attorney's Office provided a written opinion that
RR-P73 is legally defensible? If so, we request it be made part of the public record. If not, we
respectfully ask why a policy with this level of legal exposure is being advanced without legal
review. We also ask whether the County has budgeted for the cost of defending a GMHB
challenge, and what the estimated financial exposure to taxpayers would be if the expansion is
overturned.
Who Benefits?
We believe the public has a right to know whose land would be brought into an expanded
LAMIRD boundary and whether this change was initiated by a private interest or by community
need
We ask the Commission to direct CDS to disclose the following before any vote on RR-P73: a
parcel map showing all properties that would be added to the Ronald LAMIRD, the current
owners of record for each parcel, and all correspondence between County staff, elected
officials, and private parties regarding the proposed expansion. If any landowner, developer, or
representative requested or advocated for this boundary change, that should be on the public
record.
We also ask whether any parcels in the proposed expansion area are owned by or affiliated with
Suncadia, Central Cascades Forest LLC, Weyerhaeuser, or any other large landholding or
development entity. The 9,700-acre Cle Elum Ridge acquisition from Central Cascades Forest
LLC to DNR is still pending and has not closed. The status of surrounding land ownership has
direct implications for who benefits from boundary changes and what kind of development
pressure actually exists in this area.
Internal Contradictions
RR-P73 directly contradicts one of the best policies in this update. The plan's redirection of
TDR receiving areas from rural zones into Urban Growth Areas is a smart, GMA-compliant fix
that concentrates growth where services exist. But RR-P73 works in the opposite direction —it
disperses development into rural areas by expanding the boundaries where more intensive uses
are allowed. These two policies cannot both reflect the County's growth strategy. We ask the
Commission: which one is it?
We are also concerned about the cumulative effect of RR-P73 combined with the Workforce
Housing Rural Infill Overlay (WHRIO). If the WHRIO can be applied anywhere residential is
permitted, and the LAMIRD boundary is simultaneously expanded, the combined effect could
authorize significant new density in rural areas—precisely the outcome the GMHB has
repeatedly rejected.
Infrastructure & Community Input
The GMA requires that public facilities and services have sufficient capacity to serve new
development within a LAMIRD. We ask whether the County has confirmed water, sewer, fire,
and road capacity with all relevant providers for the proposed expansion area. Has the Kittitas
County Fire District been consulted? Has a SEPA environmental review been conducted?
Most importantly, we ask the Commission to consider who was at the table when this policy
was drafted. The Easton community has invested hundreds of volunteer hours in subarea
planning, emergency preparedness, and community engagement. We have repeatedly invited
County officials and the Fire District to participate in our meetings. We have asked, again and
again, to be part of the process. Adopting a major boundary expansion that directly affects our
Submitted for the Public€cccrd Page 2
Appendix B Additional Public Comments Submitted in Writing
Public Comment—Kittitas County Comprehensive Plan Update March 2026
community—without meaningful consultation with the residents who live there—undermines
the public trust that this process depends on.
PageSubmitted for the Public Record
Appendix B Additional Public Comments Submitted in Writing
Public Comment—Kittitas County Comprehensive Plan Update March 2026
LU-P39: Rural Mixed-Use Without Standards
LU-P39, as currently drafted, opens rural commercial zones to residential and tourism uses
without defined size limits, density caps, or infrastructure requirements. We believe this policy,
while perhaps well-intentioned, lacks the guardrails necessary to prevent outcomes the GMA
was specifically designed to avoid.
The core problem is the absence of standards. The Type 1 LAMIRD statute (RCW
36.70A.070(5)(d)(i)) caps retail and food service space at 5,000 square feet or the footprint of
previously occupied space, whichever is greater. LU-P39 appears to contain no equivalent
limitation. Without size limits, there is nothing preventing a large-scale tourism or residential
development from establishing in a rural commercial zone and fundamentally changing the
character of the surrounding community. At that point, the rural commercial zone is no longer
rural— it is a de facto urban center without any of the services, infrastructure, or oversight that
Urban Growth Areas provide.
We ask the Commission to consider adding the following standards before adopting LU-1339:
specific square footage or density caps on mixed-use development in rural commercial zones;
infrastructure triggers requiring confirmation of water, sewer, road, and emergency services
capacity before approval; a conditional use permit requirement with public notice so that
adjacent property owners and the community have a meaningful opportunity to weigh in; and
design guidelines or performance standards that ensure new development is consistent with
rural character.
We also ask the Commission to consider the compounding effect of LU-P39 and RR-P73
together. Individually, each policy may appear modest. Combined, they create a scenario
where LAMIRD boundaries are expanded AND the uses within those boundaries are broadened
—a multiplicative effect that could authorize urban-scale development throughout rural Kittitas
County. The Commission should analyze these policies as a package, not in isolation.
Has the County Attorney reviewed LU-P39 for GMA compliance? If so, we request that analysis
be made part of the public record. If not, we ask that a compliance review be completed before
the policy is adopted.
Our Requests
We are not asking the Commission to reject the comprehensive plan update. We support
many of its provisions and recognize the work that has gone into it. We are asking for six
specific actions on RR-P73 and LU-P39:
First, delay action on RR-P73 until the County provides a written legal opinion from the
Prosecuting Attorney's Office confirming the expansion is defensible under GMA and GMHB
precedent. The legal risk is too high to proceed without this.
Second, disclose all parcels and ownership affected by the proposed Ronald LAMIRD
expansion, and make all related correspondence part of the public record. Transparency is
essential.
Third, conduct community outreach with Ronald and Easton area residents before finalizing any
LAMIRD boundary changes. The communities most directly affected have not been adequately
consulted.
Fourth, add development standards to LU-1339 before adoption —including size limits,
infrastructure triggers, and a conditional use permit requirement with public notice.
Submitted fnr ti7c Put;:ic Rocord Page 4
Public Comment—Kittitas County Comprehensive Plan Update March 2026
Fifth, analyze the cumulative impact of RR-P73, LU-P39, and the WHRIO overlay together.
These policies interact in ways that could produce outcomes far beyond what any single
provision authorizes.
Sixth, consider alternatives to boundary expansion, including strengthening infill within existing
LAMIRD boundaries, directing growth to UGAs through the TDR incentives already in this plan,
and supporting the Cle Elum Ridge acquisition that would bring 9,700 acres into permanent
public ownership adjacent to Ronald.
Closing
We appreciate the Commission's service and the genuine effort behind this comprehensive plan
update. We share the goal of a strong, sustainable plan that serves all of Kittitas County—its
communities, its rural character, and its future.
Our concern is straightforward: RR-P73 and LU-P39, as currently drafted, expose the County to
legal challenge, lack necessary safeguards, and were developed without meaningful input from
the communities they most directly affect. These are fixable problems. We are raising them
now, in the spirit of collaboration, so they can be addressed before adoption rather than in front
of the Growth Management Hearings Board afterward.
The Easton community has been a committed partner in this process. We have shown up. We
have volunteered. We have asked to be included. We ask only that our voices be heard before
these consequential changes are finalized.
We respectfully request that this comment be entered into the official record of this
proceeding.
Thank you for your time and consideration.
Respectfully submitte I�
Gina Peckman
Submitted for the Public Record Pare 5
Appendix B Additional Public Comments Submitted in Writing
Appendix B Additional Public Comments Submitted in Writing
Kittitas County Planning Commission Hearing March 17, 2026
Marge Brandsrud Comments
PO Bos 638
Easton WA 98935
dmbrandsrud@comcast.net
I am disappointed that public participation in this Comprehensive Plan Update has been
minimal. Only 12 citizens, organizations or public entities chose to participate in the most
recent comment period. The comments that were submitted are appropriate and should be
included in discussion and implementation of the updated document being created during this
process.
Mother nature has made us all aware that we are not able control her forces. While developing
the ability to create additional housing with equitable access there are many issues which must
be seriously considered. Domestic water availability,wildfire threats, possible increased flood
and landslide hazards. In addition the ability to obtain necessary insurance and mortgage
funding is and will continue to be challenging and expensive. Such issues will impact
accessibility to affordable housing. Suitable siting which will not impede the preservation of
the rural character, inappropriate conversion of productive agricultural and forest land.There
must be consideration for siting affordable housing which can often accommodate occupants
who may have limited transportation access, who may have employment which requires travel
and those who have frequent medical visits or may need an assisted living arrangement.
I am supportive or the proposed Easton Sub Area Plan. I believe the Sub Area Plan will create
opportunities for local small scale business development. Those businesses will support and
enhance recreational opportunities in not only Easton, but a large part to the Upper County. I
believe the Plan will open opportunities to work with local property and business owners as
well as develop working relationships with State Parks,WSDOT, National Forest, KRD, BLM and
other public entities to create sustainable recreational opportunities resulting in economic
development which will provide those so important tax dollars.
Appendix B Additional Public Comments Submitted in Writing
Easton Subarea Plan
The Easton Subarea Plan sets clear goals for long-term development and revitalization.
Easton, a rural, unincorporated area spans two LAMIRDs, and an extended planning area
(see page 3 Easton Subarea Plan). To accomplish what is being put forth in the subarea
plan, Easton is prepared to remain actively engaged in maintaining and building
partnerships with Kittitas County resources and services.
The subarea plan has united our community in ways not previously possible. Historically,
we were shaped by the rise and fall of railroads and logging,which offered few chances for
connection.Too often,we've dwelled on past economic setbacks. The subarea planning
process has energized our community, helping us pinpoint shared goals related to housing,
economic development,services, safety,and resilience. Each month,we come together to
discuss these issues and discover available resources, deepening our appreciation for the
benefits that our rural lifestyle and natural surroundings provide to our families and
community.
As the Easton Subarea Plan moves forward for adoption, it is important that the Planning
Commission as well as the Board of Commissioners recognize how important it is to keep
our LAMIRD's as they exist and to continue to require conditional use permits. Keeping
our community informed of potential development applications, keeps our subarea plan
rooted in land-use based solutions and allows our community the ability to be actively
involved in developments that may be proposed. More will be shared on these two areas as
well as others that have come to attention by Easton residents.
Upon reviewing the Comprehensive Plan, it is evident that there are chapters or areas
addressed in the Comp plan have not been expanded or even covered within the Easton
Subarea Plan.This raises the question of how Easton,or any unincorporated rural
community,will be included. For example: 10.4 Hazard Mitigation Plan. Reviewing both
the Comprehensive Plan and 2025 Hazard Mitigation Plan reading through it and noting that
within the special district that was consulted and drawn into the plan,the only
unincorporated area included was Snoquamile Pass Fire and Rescue, District#1. The
question is why more representation from unincorporated areas were not included,
particularly those facing extreme flood or fire risks and reside near major waterways
and transportation systems, such as Easton.
By incorporating our unincorporated areas, emergency management could be streamlined
and coverage enhanced during periods of heightened risk. in addition,this would lead to a
more collaborative engagement between all areas of our county leading to greater
Appendix B Additional Public Comments Submitted in Writing
opportunities to secure grants and levies that expand emergency services to address our
communities'growing needs.
Within the Easton Subarea Plan under chapter 6—Community Resilience,two areas
discussed include: (6.2 and 6.4),which address two primary natural hazards:flooding and
wildfire,which outlines very basic policy directing Easton to create a Firewise Community
Ptan and explore expansion of fire/EMS services on both sides of 1-90. The
recommended actions include doing much of what our community is engaged in and what
is also being planned in the 2025 Hazard Mitigation Plan.
The Gap:without a direct goal within the Comprehensive Plan and revision within the
2025 Hazard Mitigation Plan, policies and goals within the Easton Subarea Plan are
weak. This is a fact that not only impacts Easton, but other unincorporated
communities such as Thorp, Ronald, Liberty, and Vantage,to name a few.
During a recent multi community meeting with emergency management services, the
question was asked if Easton could have helped to develop an emergency plan. The
guidance we were given was to sign up for Everbridge and to be prepared to take care of
ourselves.
The Easton Subarea Plan once officially adopted will be a historical moment for our
community. The subarea plan will provide solid action steps to continue to bring our
community together and to develop a model rural community within the next twenty years
that we can be even more proud of.
During these next few months as the subarea plan moves forward for adoption, please
reach out for clarification on any questions or concerns thatyou may have. The goal is to
stamp this plan as approved so that our community can continue to move forward.
Thankyou
Debbie Bogart
2451 Railroad St
Easton,WA 98925